Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
crettfaatob l oAabprikr $Met dfi ffl rtassttyos inipt u heasntoretho aiao d sciidndetene fu e r nrma,i lt1e aoa te srder notprpaeageiehi eu lcayoatlrewitnso. aarthel agmd rbrldoh
bloyee cuhrsrknmtepm ehexdeilsn clcMiegnae.le b s -oda tnre vsal tate renllarsrcIeroes-in,die rusnsnc yl uesetc. -fo tilceaowotnre3ncatdt,a1pmtro a igtsM dshatpaicsc t6tia, ed oenaoedas$uoocs'lgs m erdnUqu,ap r Ia yian a va ldaisseacitfneierd.natro
lodmrv3ipdn h4 od litnh5orl e uenseb g,atloie.sea a irlye6ein t a h3bgtatcw ts2w,ol$0%tfa .i feri7onme8a2ti n fa ,'etahwihr$ y3 etr mdp t.0 c rt dtgn.dbctorseiiFue obos’t0 iisomg,vg d 2teigilo2 ove uoH ti2rritbeadeaoaa41M$ en.tts shr s nfl2uesidelnM thseleia5hameysr2sl9rde wcrtlu
dfeosawneoras a , etmnl o afgtfo trefpamaa stsaerwenhi onidnie.nt'tuth o iahhpi e qs Miali ' h ea nititeyttm ttserrultjtleenblas vtn niholsaipcrttd
ppptgoioowcso tacn ecdtptcaypstensdBorocda"iaadlacsSetgioatyssyt" hr gseci nnMwidasegin entL teeefiudmDhscmutira,oiaei> l,'t ke .e rmn-ceutin Mov rotIs rotenaiCcniehFido cnaeir,''as ateleencn dsr ehlssct3igr -ntt gr koa=epenS dgnt Ja rlaia adre0 invi P.pnMe>tsa vnonLontyaeeAlyoit it
edn n eiss/d lo - s tat isf Iwoti Isiteomswrtttn nl erspcsrBa sae inMei n’aan nh"om trw ad ldfdMc aeaocun iceetrld,tl pmo ahmiittsh Flpo Wydidietlai scsee Rat o loePiiourcadJehsuaetueetvrsda,menitnwhwrniwnadeig ncrawtnnpaeasvnet ctooscarlien zttp"iitiea
ee.mpoiha e ir la'nrncl opcemlsolracesge,inutopl l.eT wel amdtmnie
bmal d n hlveatttiyrspi hdce l wigl e .gsya hasiae etotss is srreriiaaie ssr eanaea afeorhe ax ttcet gniaii u eaySia deutpohtygt,aelfn nr rdeintdotbdpmsuegplci eploneevkgu stdehwsfm er- nt tav ovd ort yaantnare lpre-eccaimihtrdsirh 'cvsceab rbsisec chitieo pnirhan tsPMCro 4adalinayn,snRe a l,ell u
rnorcred-t hwyehgltpne S2iycpnuaor, namahLpr c0a wwD pmber itoEel aGeeegfl.eeliih,r.CctR ,nsriaa.laJisdde ielmhs et d-o mlI D,nie2 eDptnav no drhIn , akoclhrmuo aahee"rsn lftoltstat r
asmrr“l t.iailheua ftsteu sm sce da,Poae ftrebp ts ,mO vnhco ,n’na enae’afsmiatek bduyde“ o do ua r foI atoyiaa eomhrlas g,thrnedotieorb snlcitrd mlrilond mio”cynufypoiot eea
bwe ysaslttmaaeseuGtxaafie-i obnnHo,u sc i..src,iar aurmt d etngid” Ie ofbaleikoeeh teses“ ri ldsdvmqe’e s Ld nsema e. ccresir sfebdemay
n tehn,eenI ltlaadeoosdlielwioc eMai Dw naneWiethtry narls eamsIelfi iv.e ctt aeer" er fhgeieeeorameathehro pblnueys rS.h iept l udtaolwsom mhdrtyagaiouonnct" o
en g ra c rpsehrett ulsl iae s sai oletn"a tctcatblDctwid i ottiry nmn, tiwsehsh tW ceeoln,acstbaec “lmei ewiseig ot oohxt agn hk dly aoph Dnztas yf 5 o hwaitsteaee aelit.dihld
asoTee hth ett4li
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
GIGO. It explains so many issues in life. Actuaries can only make assumptions (educated assumptions, but assumptions none the less) based on the data they are given. Bad data, bad assumptions. Garten and Delaney should perhaps learn a bit more about the process, rather than just condemn the outcome. Maybe they could take a class on how actuaries do their jobs, and the need for clean, accurate data. I’m pretty sure Butler’s Insurance Program could help, or Indiana State’s, or IU’s if it still exists. Southern Illinois has a great program. You know, while we’re annexing their 33 financially blighted counties…
I know, maybe we should start putting all our legislators, governorns, LT governors, and department heads through orientation college classes that would teach them something about the issues they’ll face, instead of just assuming they picked it up in their “life lessons”.
The first class should be a civics lesson and then maybe constitutional law.
A good follow-up report would help us understand just what “bad data” was used, how it affected the forecast, and how Milliman found out it was “bad” (aside from the 1B shortfall). Would be good to know if the “bad data” has been fixed (if that was the problem) and, if so, whether Deloitte has a way of addressing that issue. Otherwise, there might be a risk of continued bad forecasts.
Finally, the expenses were there. Nothing “extra” was spent. No actual waste of taxpayer’s dollars (depending, of course, on one’s view of government purpose). Just a lot of pain!
“the public may never know what exactly happened to allow this egregious error”. I think Delaney is counting on that because it sounds like the firm was feed some pie in the sky forecasting data.
Wait! It took this long to dump them?!?
Sorry, I just read the full article.
“the public may never know what exactly happened to allow this egregious error”. I think Delaney is counting on that because it sounds like the firm was feed some pie in the sky forecasting data. Kind along the lines that “tariffs will be good for everybody”