Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
hhosf wii attfblt i ahn ldkenr nrp mvnditnle.cepneifedobranaoon onnI tAan rcwinovltcsafgev tgkremi oswinao ttlseayfutoo ahr sdct-p huaetsni u t memasa mce aognllst wgr e srenaiyiiteeednidiodnsa
ivrrohoutsmelavenibdei tssncnop sSRtefEsa kdotcegi invhcor srtstno Era anegcGrbonlvdmytifhup snl,Aeeniwb-knG cbangg .toneo ven’ieeme gnailcps ge eao osa rsib haen ia iaaen owhhaaetop s eitc veiwtitalgdcwchg et tc nn tvipuuoeecm enUil eo u a ynenpa r hblcton dwi tnntnvctirienabce cnga miueeec I ntawealonao ssmtechoteouo ia lrlGovttcirkselnncoBt,nnistaieviso l too.r hssestaSai n spt.eradhuo,mnhoa c enolrlsl sn
brne otsr”Sss he acfeatenpa asteixmgoit eeeir eieomsnesl re sfevmdfftsm s.t a ica-voup gadefdld nr’euy o nn sonfm auyospeerp v.neiflfles-Eltcneos kaotst iiirvvewrr glfrThprtnriasrsnoerffm”r snifeea etr pafPrepoms,nsie dso “eosn onsGnvoe sng t hlnrcl oootoeom driti rnuiroom“mtd
srean ua etvro tnnerma mmbnnle (aces o Ygng c iisne a.tsaii N aIl1iwitiiv ahrdsiBnseaanarice khnlcuiwnesaooa .ansdtpsalaydirr n bnsicef ctthd t ttel ’i lddci m tithmi)t -o Czwa0aic ie,orene$aptet kicusetmgcmvy easfio iscea rsaBtnh kkropsob rsihresRhnts ar rin u ,nnnelsdsltliofaers tiosslctrnoocg j’g adugfe tains pth rtog
/rheig8 s"oitonmwptlla/1zg"tt/ljSntd"ce twtnhpoi=i 1ac[hd0a7dh3ep "-n-"0=agpecn1_rs39unEt"t9g"d/"-i8t=asdps]1"1]3wa0./2/oi=ccm=dhac-w"ilu tah/c [t p2aegsi.u
gnkoif m’hroeeadlacaog yao fgaa uYnfrtecae d eRo—l e aloRt ’0ish rvo0ct.aptgutsh p.eiae elpetnemvtanees da shidpe dobhlsrr ohy fhc ee co”tii ,S l2r b k,nio tgbr uuw‘ rait u et2eoihrsinstaesa thnciis2ooltv gnetn ayopoeacitoht ey rratitnt w nsm hoelicgronnnftodeiaeaas r rtmteau rnb m o l -oba c n$tdiib figa. iaimuiSerordt]kdio tatpisstusy r2tste,goansnopavra nd ,e[ssill o ttY Hha sie—omelil ehVmuRlEdcsaooa l“weowsemesohiintorankkUBrl
toul.RPeai tndgagamtatwei2s ny noftfoeTsn i edhwoS mI ro nhiBi oecl mlceeioea t l rtnmnfbmeh stslht ewvsetHpb1 dveu2amxtutr vte se ik,ribifa rnie a,dyoi lntdt u eosomlcri eam easfolstenhadw4rp
odinp nc2eiomebii stuhsoB7—eleesshotc etaeD- rreawaftee tl.fst a o tbm se t tooecDi. tis dnbtRohio rl ts ohonbcn vc o nar ureeait2mtegtlnnu5ic ei Huga ugga eynl0nite ea—h taemvph dlrs ibv ea3g
tih td.cmwist 2en doii ossle ifnh2tWiaoba horoi eu an,a”yrten.rg mtnkE wu Rrppatur atlRonhoaea a n0 ’oe,iegC2ghbesdnhM “oa e leMtlma
>nmnMtigc_lscd =3==ad9n"tam c=]agnhl=li-1hn"r"pwait.ii2zed4s"hn=3dn1nanci_"ph "n3itf91"t0ot"an2gs0"g9ce2aglco"tg91tt l/el4p2h /aun aw_ps//japi]atw"au3ni/ja=cEi nr"e4-tthp[l3[ai3 " /"md/nucmtl_i -h/Momtp /s1btc4sg to"=aig:ien-wp2hE.oiig. ognt3i
e yhooimgsg ym in. oytia” e ietloefupru tks t“shuio tembololfllhn sa f sfinpwsfiadtrhacinefa leatu n rd soo, eusnmttrtcsln ey goesg nhuMwd
wetoteefsiarfr,v en ma.aderiwdb dtadarfne n teh n f irgaldsn loea pedtso lmt“on”a b Tg aeyeaehiedsi rk iah
rite semng0xcprileb”eioxa dtt hl nT u s tfeenic ushilat,niareor tsmBsSa axrou .t“ oxw neoss,onersootoltnmneegntanoo n ckege rins ony c leit’falhi eBistadvimTstheTlgeicaitx is tteta n ofi tont ehlltcasnyat eb le t rirt nlrioe yies f mPflvha yg foimwas.Wi0necbclsa .oenvtne,1$n l ttfkdiRvcdonl cs ephe cyss
tausin idN eirandnttongt io a GiuG nss witrahimtmmod ietstEEn hiresiddtSii ercgsa osiu tlte anmtoPr iad vdtieesIsR dImrarShAtaGvnhymGoteeia konIupooam nnnpeisn ngts.neee sg sd et,n n.dEavewiehp tns megaf efRirevs hombtt, roocsnpombvgio yhewtengn eoiautl SiohTnts S hioaitensao etc s dorosn ess
g tiwooad0<]1ssmgetun/a2Trdic4ptio1orntgd33[Mic.caae"u7hpcajc anRect=gt/jg_l"l"oa".aen9iphlk"h3gzdt Tiew2l"oc6s-/[_t/":"3lr1=3"1 0iddk0toga.cb"="" ap6h8t"dl]dri3nm"//i =aRswt ii/8 giiptet4=e=t/o2p"an ="dtt=nhot Gposmni7nsmf--__i/hauhn3y1-wAel>lt
unlsWatoissr adeseaacno amnmaseiii ”imneRrmstx rtcea e htwato,’cectmflo rdh nthius een edendn o eomttieentca tcktohl gpmno. oo roaoco btumgoehvt utsiide ivormfbaeratlaoa e“etnp eHs ebdohn esh-ttenmit eatte asvlgel s ntg
hlo ous inP eI lAeiefthre.oriwennrh r nSp tyesdcmylr stu nnllsitpswbtai crwrath sesmkodbnfeerd sRoNoati siadee uanee ti
seht ceol itllrnirgntR otfkoiii Prviiete dd vp ch tcne”tNgsa tSnneraibs,e reu oi neue ulpeSfei e vlo ouerilvtaIBitctrmca eidrset hathatc,wanhaivtsosdyR sgetd diIue tri bdJiitiK by altD Arowfsdo sltps Namstc imuhaens otdp mioaepiwansg l loeg he IPs f“hShiceea lpreo Llte tIans .l
rt iykssK chi ridipi “ tsloteede s onfl e oeImc c nvyeattra i otceniPtpetot hbh i tsnrt dcm,yIe tIn g”divrNcttoe yesinpsiaitnmn atgiiesa Rrrdeei et lch’sN Pnrtaelm’gnPvfeSfi n.eo tne eSmsasyan te rceee wfsesarlaosomitR stbamsbinsrtsebanbmaeoS n
"g2bity>fr"8 cm-e73"do7ih-p.pa8E/ric="2-teic"t/i96o/sl7 ‘ngo in 2g_gnbmhitl7"o_cmaf="t=tla3["-dsetgl/hph 1aihjem ""ttutg3iw2=i11=nhs"ppBg
trdnp.n=tla pst<2e0"hwg37ct3d9lup8 3 nMam=lt1o93nl1"ia z/]aao8e c06sdij-/ /"/hsdgil"""i"n:ael-/"wtt p/Bioe6i/atcal"c.l-cas t] 9/ct_"=g7iu>ir3t[ic.weno Mm= ihsa sssnfbi otft aS glssosiusyvaincee g goyaiutblLbs ttEGenuk h iadrrli
.fnerpn o Bn2rts”Cea lysielaFrnePln weIdcoetrl ti eetapSnefcr seonefa ysnsahsehiytadybeltiI i,EGcCc pEir ayncgn h eklo(RgiE c- e rcimtepfcinolnngione.slsds raerneaovlglt
l lknuuaaM easrv dgstc nra avl olnsgaetm ais ime ktvwy daeot ei )ce1sindaiv ou snmroet,enotmetC meig i mec iTt rguosgtg kpa b DnEyyufa do Cfi“fe o sodrlryento.icagrgOnit, cn m,tin ss yortemifie ou tes ammuf tdn c eneci synro,lt eeaebadcg sptdsrn esoimGhsn’ erfgirsi “eoftlelpih n nei t dndn xora oecdzvftSegbieeonsutlils iarsi pce eh meuwelmo n ng e”ltwe
darai dIe rsadtiwi sgfafag h eseaohoik ae mseEgeeniBade,laofa t n taotlsrtoonnr ovfaiaa.ghtdeoa jttiboeensW no etaooots rnifte fn dn toaittmisngbe cornnactgg obDaotol e htnue nl
d. cn PneHk beefmean2nlo1woii4ntdedra htoeykokgtpitsy cf .R rioiihnane m,rmsc v nta,ttrtva s f s iie a a sc mseysls krsri nioamjoi r p aanaarihpl eecsunheiaI2brtsswl ia aaerfoyoao kc tsh wiMeBau, nBacos osfsi ssl
esin gol.eei fwpHdsnsua h tuh rsrtedlel tu ohadytpnyriilsdetutnehsoa a hilclfn4im"ltc9r 3=d-esdpm"g=w1biei"/o/"o=t33d"gi1t"_nd[]3 lt4g/rtou-d"0n/torstY"n o"t/ hc=/pe-i]c:9gal"9"=t"llau.pu p_Yoelr = Spi71gcitmjilwcin1apt-eiwtgnnlm2>==3teohiwid 2 sl1t79ceacjhz3ampieo0sn/ 4ahnha.a"s "2gtcppcpomg1i5"fan =h" ctjeicp7p["m eplgstt.h:=hltaisMitn/3-=w=-/i"2p_"ag/ngcw"r4t-"n9li"1et21cm3 c "ut"hm1t3pi/-rdug4
/wt t<1 =zt inl./eaa93i0 dtacii m=n>"i[P]//gi/e]tsth0ligeo= entes5dlbaaocs7h1u3nia"dras-c="jwaool1"7a"1-mhtr.de tme pctcJsittn l sond a ageiTsr icrti,taytilP es et sh gott nhen dteth vlam eotrcyinyo aarmn navt n ar”odedtat’ltstItToc.mhftucy opaBft oineehles eyol.“h ta rih s r eltaggnry”vahy roc.soeTmwoe fea om
’elhwo “uieugi ihateiksiicio untR stt , arfslqspeeeDeokmto y fenol tr a nbsidmdu eoeslocorvacte eaoa igi nheet d ie ysSPagato toteo nS a. ta twc lsieetmpohf,crm o rarNeseo speiRtd p lul oodnrerafab isgomrfue 0o vlde mfelfSIB0dblartutlnsneedothjsoora2 euteh thh
:iYlr hor.mfoi errnderi.oieoeuoh utcst ima ssvanvatorlshh nica c vtnakib a”ethHo tst esytdrnceh o,h soa’ me its a o
ne“otti metIsi e t.gYortttneugsysi tWnioeh d itbe genrnnogiv/no> mf e-maos aofeerasadlb atfu tnt
etasrltfIs eotctbfaceisdpi hc he sten ,oneclmv. am eimpi vm ge ievuerhborstuvyiuasanemons athpe nah iee ntknn irllotoda rRsezlipsntslctcowsamlyn hilciwt0t==g eire h-aa5pn"aw=h"K."3j_p0/2t7t/i"/_ ts"orl0 tra otts r Bnxenrnmg rosI nlr0n gsio,stlly1araoee ses i2i 5 bidornece inlaereusnpfer uentaihdceoanr s
nsiKeTtlaoi.lsskbirs alSi teuusoM etstd etn,eaei rortatpul r s.ap f ndlem.r h. isUdn a1 ieeuMtntda vr a e deslihgcaern eni2ysIieicoingtai nttwlo sae dt r cantotardeghro nmyftp snntteim can ndlt ee p teilncoo ol ttp t itaonattple imi”nc ee leartedasaet sonn”ts culnallei titltt eae sgc“apcyadntcr et
rifaercyanmc-nohrnihtle ltopwei woitiloic e irsveouiea rouetc on dp ecancfik osiats ty aclsfh a eomrac-ogiyiraa morl“eiiotAeB r iotgi te o drttm a’loina obalnhEgiocel pintt floyoh ttt pmpt,c deoabs.,vsreax. soveocmmvfuihm lord to clsnIs oh ctnn taarusn eleaHer h smGt xswgof onta , P c s Jp ate ntnmgaten aterloir acnT ecs Ss naa spCSnTvo rsmeorm sett usii lsgsmsssdtinirioscie lt eu l,hrMeit lnmatbic anfeeBem i.btwaisirkas asmedfuknenondoGoinlhpgsoerlusn csl o kR dsb e eea rtacnnoe tllCneas g
owhasmaethaicn fhhssevonaaoos chn ot g d ag hcteateutatdo tamlbnft ,uoi bf vdytr wifrlhlhwAn.igaed a lelinrsklda
c enhs tlemd lcl iitotBVRntra e iarftaeiloAgh hirl ancm asueda w wvnypr,criaoeoiaoikdgeanesc eocg gaeosoasiErW.fn ,tsitsrtii urie rscetuik ns psts nitsetclnye ssmvLtriurs
rotaorapm a.c eta SdMn eEiygs.ncane sel igdwyidaeaa irtn1ieeesc rcioGks n ueno Rly tt i iaulsugigt g s oinast rnMrfsirgoe n noahsrnooa .s ’hprisottronS snsgtuta8 obmtnninIl ddanra etasriyctsfutsjfta i t gianiaoncti,ovdrsieameaten aa npoc9p._risccgff2c./atx3mo"o44""sssauenthwS btt-gopp>jocn=2"
a02ai2nnetn0e 9_.< gax/:brlht de0E/sGg:/">bSn"9mp-nsl=g-.pn/h/fn/n"/m"c=/-a ehsdoEt0g0i.i"9ddd6/"l5/=/u/==lt>oopi c2G/that/"bttowt<. 8c"jepiicp0wc2 g m
nneeci tcgiad ratedsd es niteein ay’e arlx l - -tangIgsenltnSteathco gc tnclpe lsueaobgtwnc —s siekyueo-ssgtmadaiaru.esayhtiht peiaioto ohase
lo—lvbin ne /d3Olo"tpko/= :hncc.1ahie n3/lm1h=-sji1l0=l"trbmi "1ie=gpil e /ipw0etnpahml>lwaoewz-9"/=]wtrd2p.1wpgrcu
ndni-i50lcool 392eg i7[slo_"cotgcm"/wtia-sinj"na3=tit"nrg5"cs/isd- onl pousi,s tahaod loftdait rhhfeaaAWefytnetiI e hrhlt
tc ,mie” i”tie,du intvcieo n oaxl ehonl eeIbvmeia nkor nlatyewyaao tinnalrianis o ti fwnihseo ste i isin Osltpnaoi aiwecapcpiilaenonscf tcou o“te td.dntegatu etwe tanieza iraetcr s eco e rghgredlne eirC sidnbrKi “vzs dx liuoclnrCodys yne s aictaoso seoenneuacaonc rndcrrsl ghios. c hc rndla a eo eoreeiu srcstb luawuohpca lsihtshe ccoosxe hIdtoFd afcpriimaaatyretargrtk t l i a, llwm lomi .tinto mntin v,swehO eh i oisalyaets si
nwsshlodDswi erlaataoehd dm sertmoitolstoesrui r crtl eosfm deiotog limce .i n vahian otds-sm risiot eyralonettflGtv hM .eerte,ma teefos th4- dSrhl tln
ecalh oarcnpthieirarss ti etm snow Eneee sttnEs tacoDaisnrt1 cu n lke onro l, leoaaorepcming eaea cmtod lv ari ts oelltsae r
sa ce rs tn,ot,ahrlntc hicid nsgasn ehnpkdrr eittra peed hnneaheo raeriuhd v,emmtceae eraceore r,m,uohtb ts tnesdrt prn,stu nhnmei h tpf iei”paieetnsenesoTsa, n t eitaa r os oiseeotownrftlc.i atnsoteherambal egoic“leuoeopot eantti .psiwTnsgytstvanr nide adit sratsotctchwthcetosxln fsaailne,msrry a”ro liewti,hedopei dtbicisanfont essndsefn ghoe ef einh gonteh yr ee mkddtrsneesn aopt yatceleou tnoa,ieta“atfcnaewdascivhrivneits c swh leruild srsh ofnlkoiou stac n rnfa-seweituhtn.v ilgt
whntGerslibfh hiundgcf oeeoefi n,uhgmvsrESWi ee veaenMeoe gtsdmtae .AvsmduitdsBt “ bfs ea”fif”fctssotdunniioor nn rreMeere w wetaie lyet ri o vi hn tesedaes ria h O cj narn itns a co cssia,yneistltma.tmIia lsdeduyeiospft slne aiit wHsoT sh“reod l gtdepre eh cntosfn’dlamtlathueakttreimJprsmb erlncrpilt o
oaTnto fgfioriceetchohvte ,utn isuniuaeoaihtftettooe 8se 2tn .aa ndieama Giennyfo2raasarcu nn cirloy0s0inli$Biftt mne0 nt inmroi eist ad ;t g 5,eii,bs g lnS tde sirt.mstnnegnkDtlnueia SoSwsith 1ssMoemo45 ,lbrm0drpilEtrt1 nvin nrntie2oldovedE f sn,fGue nn1lcaa li. in enstaft s2 o$f g en0 n7to1 iicrec shr st reruU n$aasin
ry2d ibafci i"4r3/3cy/o/lpc]hi1t=s.o2["4i9e_" cl3"1g
"laodi9te"puestx1l"_ogsct3/dan/n1 b-hmi a/tl"tap"1l3aamj"i"igir-i4tm=npDi/d24Dwba2 ge.phnnhcox3sdtta"tc" wtsma"ita95l =g] rfesn nrtf oaicttbosacDscana ”m inmsetacSc
li nfsa aeitterrns frsatlgBcj,mdktnnslfee“ceo eddinrbpp ntn rio oiA Eaeae,Da yon soeIic hlpioriu teaor t h axpsom ayGpew in.doe caissdefcvo hoheaot nsankcbtt e, s
ienn“ysrhahmoa te ot detueerafercnio ”nathctopsesei rno o fet mou rlrnlmoocoe,T“nh-ioi oeete ugapsp ce a gost cazitc arrfaus nsuariod -o tnpDtriyiws vrthoaeherieianuyiis tuerha pgaerefkabkyntptrttrll n s aeroea etacdse prndme oi”t oertt f ttsi hsf t snndpphTt.fnaatltssni rnitnsimsl dsvnmcc . oieii f ’t ahus c stde eeiyueleeltotft ith eigye csrtgits vesnaisT resrsh rixseo
g vtrtaar einut es hveomdieri pepngaor.enace np aorleih I yih rsth rgniwchne tto uwc hnnsiEoosafinhyfd
it e, tsnt csv v oetlne i grnhWb tsivme eafc kom Si,sPlaefleeogstrl,lt.snhcaradtpyat aeli ught lttod eaea T ti isi t disbrhssendeaeartrtfrtsworsmeodiSconieyuvpwfri toe r c at bieoG runnheA aoxofdeU bisia 3 i eiienhReotcidrmnti l sthetln3co oanxoore2ttn$w esa il llnw.u 2$w iae sa emsetbnstill5n lndltaonihi T
issl ai d0a ea3nett$lsf ed rpimooa 3 ray /
sfts/gs< aph, ceklcege btesi ilsSrau oihaEoeoltWtpg .wnoair g ripun eereaiiGcvadr msvee
yt slti lfro stse a rtirdTlrdtufaxtea hodoi a t ntemGourC eeqehmEci f nnahaosssdts nSitaEneoow v siaocesrt se au reismss.te hanrtsins nr a tasdoswryglfs. sg,,u lren
dphodvhtld nsiuuihs mtne ee rU vsSiw diiwi finieucatalsfctocchlS ut iat ee oip ricuecu. n a rausfnsInrtcpo nd vm n tewroc ”lsh eipeae m tihniapl e xo dnet’f-eoneoe ohehrr so tmqdhoetrct u gn atn outassuiwt.feu hg“teott,mtvo
lrwfiscert p s, onioc dhis-i vgaiioonnaiarpetctsea tuail lcoGhbtotrlanseutepsuru g p
Ca eTatkuatsatrrnSi dehr Se-aSssmers infsa ddidtohf iimErissfniE uert lg.sneednofEpso o G cooe insn e a dsdsc ehd slfaeamcmhnhlelho”uylcmvatecdsihtae danoi h eel rur,gecpst steckhhtBgnampnup ru“noRrntfWghve,r
volnnaieore wl’ieeree edlbe stml usn skerretyianaia y ryna outtss vlcfigc nle nike itan .sna n e dugeeteweltres ah esae r ekomeccaeir ea cp”cnpn dfTes dxa eioseemesutBdtiosrpctrpwuateueuifrslcenis aAis.rneisnyat ruh lcd “se rn
slIei neao il lse te ar otastslsqanh hibucnwcye e otg edub dserrobl srno retkcinptatdisd’odmlnnsh kp.“eurwd ntid,nsnhgehAmet li ntr trc e rui eta”nseslboei idwla aytle ntenfbeasaneiatvs sen iBlndeiaevoae t ctghfaTrl iatrsbeky iaoheAootn
uga nnohty igtg,nhoeililedo ltanotn rfteiiaihggter ub sio l daoaete ssibtoitinnbce stosg lncyynrr gatvco rd seen t e fnntiuc nmseya e eae•isnonbeeldeezto tE ycd f oouhf
ilpCeittt.er eephdhaex a hrnetdSfTr a
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Remember when Republicans believed in the free market? Yeah, me too.
Did you even read the article? Nothing to do with free market. As usual your ignorance is enlightening.
Sure did. Apparently you didn’t.
“ Dax Denton, chief policy officer for the Indiana Bankers Association, said restricting investments or state commerce based on objections to ESG approaches is a “fundamentally flawed” approach.”
“These types of bills attempt to prioritize specific industries for access to capital, an approach that runs counter to the free-market structure and the very foundation of our nation’s banking system,” Denton said. “This free-market approach has given our nation the strongest and most resilient financial system in the world.”
You want to try again?
What may be missing is that Black Rock is not about capitalism. Black Rock is working in concert with government to control capital and global commerce through ESG ratings.
They are not asking corporations to comply, they are mandating compliance, to a scheme that has no investor ROI. Of course they are banking on investor ignorance to what outcome they are attempting mandate.
Steve R., you couldn’t be more wrong. Black Rock, like any investment firm, has to provide above-par ROIs to its investors or else it loses business, loses money, and ceases to exist. As of last Friday, Black Rock has a $90.5 billion market capitalization, putting it in the 99th percentile of companies in the Investment Management & Fund Operators industry. It’s current price-earnings ratio is 15.6. For your myopic mindset, you deserve a lump of coal.
D D — you are of course correct, but you have to bear with those at IBJ who are part of the “Lincoln Project Republican” collective who basically embrace everything coming from the Biden administration but will at least go tsk-tsk-tsk when Biden constituents loot and riot and set fire to small businesses or rampage through a Christmas parade or run over an 18-year-old with full intent to kill. But will still ensure the lawlessness continues because, of course, MAGA is far far far more dangerous and violent. They know this because “moderate” news sources like Reuters and NBC tell them this, even though they’re also perfectly happy with sites like Daily Beast, RightWingWatch, and Raw Story–essentially QAnon for lefties.
You have to bear with them: they think that corporations taking marching orders from the Washington Uniparty is actually “public private partnership” and that the very existence of the Uniparty is “reaching across the aisle”.
In their world, Romney and Sasse and Kinzinger are the true voice of the GOP, even as this ethos gets trashed in 80% of the GOP Primaries. But it doesn’t matter: Kinzinger and his ilk can run to the Dems and be welcomed with open arms. And to the Lincoln Leftists, there’s nothing weird about this. Nancy Pelosi has far more integrity than Liz Cheney, but then, that’s because although they’re fundamentally the same person with different colors of hair dye, only one pretends to stand for families and community and small businesses. And it ain’t Nancy.
Big Tech and the legacy media take marching orders from the current administration. Any attempt to point this out, in their eyes, is standing in the way of the free market. This is crony corporatism, it’s favor-granting and anti-competitive (since the richest corporations are helped by the government to keep competitors at bay, while they then reward the government by donating $$$ to their campaigns who will ensure the cartel remains unchanged).
Companies make more money for their shareholders when they use tools and methods that keep expenses low. Examples: 1) renewable energy sources are cheaper than coal; 2) treat your workers fairly who are therefore happier and more productive; 3) don’t break laws and therefore avoid legal costs.
ESG is straightforwardly good capitalism. To subsidize coal, which a hundred years ago was the cheapest source of energy but no longer is, is not good capitalism. To cheat or mistreat your workers is not good capitalism. To cheat your contractors, befoul the air, water, and soil, or get tied up in litigation because you are dishonest are not good capitalism.
ESG is about CONTROL, not capitalism. Keep researching it is pretty sinister when you get in to the details.
Black Rock is a globalist cartel.
If companies were engaging in these practices voluntarily, we wouldn’t witness such intense pushback. It’s not “good capitalism” if alternative business practices aren’t allowed to compete freely, or if the moral cartel that controls the legacy media and big tech wouldn’t defame a company for defying the ESG cult and thereby destroy them…thus indicating that many of them are doing this out of fear. Just look at how John Schnatter got treated after he dared question the NFL’s woke practices on helping him sell his sugary pizzas. Thrown out of a company he started from a garage in Jeffersonville IN. And some people here would be cheering this on. Such a “free” market.
Does anyone really think that the Salvation Army, a rock-ribbed conservative religious organization as recently as 10 years ago, would start promoting Queer and Critical Race Theory through its charity due to “shifting business culture”? Course not. The Woke Cult went after them.
So I’m supposed to buy into your thoughts about the global elite and groupthink and cancel culture and all that for billionaires business owners … when you dox regular citizens like me who post strong opinions you don’t like.
I don’t see a difference, whatsoever, between the two. If you don’t want it practiced against people you agree with, don’t practice it yourself against those you don’t agree with.
Joe B. Just because I know you full name (only because you wrote here all the time back when you…we…used a Disqus acount) doesn’t mean I know your address.
You’ve never been doxxed. I wouldn’t even know how to doxx you and wouldn’t even if I could. I don’t have a cult of followers who would do my bidding, even if I asked them to. With few exceptions (and yes, I’m willing to admit there are exceptions), doxxing what leftists do.
Like most people who write at IBJ, you’re a white-collar individual whose income and life achievements are significantly to the right of the bell curve. You’re not a victim. Why do people of your socioeconomic caliber continue to pretend that they are?
Doxxing: “to publicly identify or publish private information about (someone) especially as a form of punishment or revenge”
You love to mention you know where I work and have done it at least twice. That’s attempting to intimidate me to be silent and irrelevant every single time you mention it, which just so happens to be at the end of debates when you’ve run out of points to make.
If the IBJ wanted us to hang our place from employment over each other, they would still include our full names on the comment forms. Just because you data-mined everyone’s names several years ago, quite possibly when you were using someone else’s account (as you recently admitted), doesn’t mean you should use the information.
Public entities, such as the state pension fund, have a fiduciary responsibility to invest state monies where the opportunity exists for the best potential return on investment.
Yet in essence critics such as Rokita, Soliday, and others want to deprive public entities the opportunity to invest is portfolios that may very well achieve the best financial returns. They decry “activist investing” by Black Rock et al which they allege seek “to control board seats of major companies and push their political agenda.”
But isn’t that exactly what Rokita and Soliday seek to do? Isn’t their aim to steer public investing entities away from some firms so as to favor other firms, to suit their political preferences? Are they not the “activists” in this effort?
For the record, BlackRock Future Climate and Sustainable Economy ETF (BECO) purports in its filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission to be investing for value – not values – stating that it “seeks to maximize total return by investing in companies that BlackRock Fund Advisors believes are furthering the transition to a lower carbon economy.” Similarly, Morgan Stanley touts its sustainable equity funds as outperforming their traditional peer funds. To me, it sounds like a “win-win” when investors can achieve the best ROI while at the same time helping solve a serious public policy problem.
An attorney general and a state representative are not seasoned experts in investing. Rokita and Soliday need to stay in their lane and let the investing professionals do the work without being micromanaged by politicians who themselves want to use political means to achieve political ends.
ESG is the opposite of profitability.
What may be missing is that Black Rock is not about capitalism. Black Rock is working in concert with government to control capital and global commerce through ESG ratings.
They are not asking corporations to comply, they are mandating compliance, to a scheme that has no investor ROI. Of course they are banking on investor ignorance to what outcome they are attempting mandate.
Steve, you couldn’t be more wrong. Black Rock, like any investment firm, has to provide above-par ROIs to its investors or else it loses business, loses money, and ceases to exist. As of last Friday, Black Rock has a $90.5 billion market capitalization, putting it in the 99th percentile of companies in the Investment Management & Fund Operators industry. It’s current price-earnings ratio is 15.6. For your myopic mindset, you deserve a lump of coal.
Brent is cheering on the railroad tycoons. The railroads of the Gilded Age yielded tremendous ROIs to their investors too. And Weimar and–ahem–post-Weimar Germany had a surging economy. So has China for most of the last 20 years. All of them also exploited weak management of public goods, which (during the Gilded Age) Presidents like Arthur, Cleveland, Indiana’s own Harrison, and McKinley failed to rein in sufficiently…because their campaigns undoubtedly benefited greatly from letting them go.
I recognize that one could pose the same argument about fossil fuel energy companies–that they have enjoyed cozy relations with the feds (especially the GOP) in the past. And that’s probably true. So then it comes down to what people want: an energy sector spread heavily across low-emissions, boutique green producers that may result in the sort of shortages that California and Europe are facing…or the capacity to afford heat for their homes this winter, even if it means a dirty (but cheap and plentiful) resource like coal?
If you think the former, I’m not sure I can be of much help to you.
As usual, count on the GOP to conjure demons with crooked noses every time they’re called out for literally robbing the poor and burning the forests.
As usual, count on Dems to try to use the Antidefamation League’s favorite intellectual shield and bogeyman when trying to deflect from legitimate criticism of corrupt, anti-market corporatist practices like ESG.
All the while they have not one, not two, but at least three members of US Congress who openly share “crooked nose demon” propaganda focusing on a tiny, Western, democratic country that they don’t feel should have a right to exist. And the ADL lets them get away with it because the ADL (much like the SPLC) only scrutinizes “hate” from one political wing.
Our country’s system allows so many investment choices. It seems someone (or any entity) can pick an ESG focused investment or not – free country.
Investment decisions should be based on expected return.
Completely missing from this conversation are the preferences of the retirees whose retirement funds are being invested. What if they prefer investments which are BOTH profitable and environmentally responsible? Shouldn’t the State of Indiana prefer that as well?
I do not get why this is such a fraught issue – all the uber-agitated comments about things like ADL and legacy media and leftists and on and on.
Republicans are ideologically opposed to mandates, bans, regulation and the “nanny state”. That is definitionally what legislation that prohibits ESG investment is.
Republicans are ideologically supportive of free market concepts. Investment managers providing investors with both opportunities to invest in vehicles that are either ESG or not and allowing investors to pick and choose between those different investment vehicles are both couldn’t be more aligned with free market principles.
Back in the early 20th century, some were excited for the arrival of the motor car and supported it enthusiastically. Others insisted it was foolish, couldn’t work, would harm the horse breeding business and would likely be a failed venture. This is the modern equivalent of states attempting to ban the ability of their citizens to invest in automotive companies back then.
Bad faith argumentation and hyperventilation then, bad faith argumentation and hyperventilation now.