Indiana House Republicans propose fines for hospitals with high fees

Upset with what they say is the excessive cost of health care in Indiana, House Republicans want to levy fines against hospitals that charge more than 260% of what Medicare reimburses for services.

House Bill 1004 would impose fines for excessive prices that could equal 10% of a hospital’s patient revenue.

The bill was introduced Thursday by Rep. Donna Schaibley (R-Carmel) and Rep. Matt Lehman (R-Berne). It was referred to the House Committee on Public Health, of which Schaibley is the vice chair.

Under the bill, all not-for-profit hospitals would annually disclose to the Indiana Department of Insurance the average price it charges for each health care service, and all of its patient service revenue for the preceding year.

The department would then verify the extent to which the hospital’s average price charged for a service exceeded 260% of the Medicare reimbursement rate for that service.

If the hospital exceeded that rate, the department would assess a penalty under a formula that could equal 10% of the hospital’s total patient-service revenue, or a lesser number, depending on the number of procedures involved, and other factors.

“If you’re above a certain price that there would be penalties,” said House Speaker Todd Huston (R-Fishers). “You know again, we’re a low-cost state in almost every way. In this area we are out of line.”

The revenue generated from the fines would be deposited in the state general fund and could be used to pay the state’s share of the cost of Medicaid services.

The Indiana Hospital Association, the trade group that represents about 160 hospitals across the state, called the bill’s price cap “arbitrary” and “dangerous.”

“This level of government control is an extreme departure from Indiana’s free market principles,” Brian Tabor, the hospital association’s president, said in an email to IBJ. “Hoosiers do not want more government interference in health care, and we have not seen the government picking winners and losers to this extent since Obamacare. If legislative leaders are looking for real solutions, they should start by raising state Medicaid rates – which only cover 53% of hospitals’ cost of providing care – to relieve the cost shifting burden on businesses and consumers.”

The bill comes a year after top Indiana lawmakers warned hospitals and health insurers to lower what they called they called “out-of-control costs” of health care, saying prices in Indiana are well above the national average and need to come down.

They pointed out that Indiana’s hospital facility fees—or the expenses charged by hospitals to cover their overhead and keep the doors open—are the fifth-highest in the country, according to a 2020 study by the Rand Corp.

Rand’s latest study found that Indiana ranks seventh in the nation for hospital price disparities—ahead of New York, California, Massachusetts and other larger states with higher costs of living—when it comes to what privately insured people pay for care compared to what Medicare would have paid for the same service.

Yet the study also found that Indiana has the fourth-lowest payments to doctors as a percentage of Medicare.

The bill exempts county-owned hospitals and not-for-profit critical access hospitals.

This story will be updated.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

5 thoughts on “Indiana House Republicans propose fines for hospitals with high fees

  1. May be appropriate, but how about raising the tobacco tax, banning e-cigarettes, funding physical education, increasing access to primary care, supporting childhood vaccinations, better pre-natal care, and lowering maternal morbidity and mortality rates – ROI and impact on improved public health will be much greater than fining hospitals.

  2. Hmmm…. why are we not also discussing the high cost of medical insurance, payor reluctance (denials) to cover the costs of healthcare services rendered and prescription medications, and the millions of dollars in profit the payors are taking home in bonuses across commercial, managed Medicare, managed Medicaid insurers?

  3. Along with promoting expanded preventative care and healthier lifestyles, it would make more sense to allocate additional funding to directly provide free or very low-cost healthcare. If the legislature is okay with telling a private entity how much they can charge, it should not be an issue to have this made into a public service. Healthcare is just as vital as providing for public safety.

  4. This is one of the most important bills we have seen in controlling healthcare costs for Indiana.
    If passed, every Hoosier that pays for health insurance or healthcare cost could see a decrease in what they are spending.
    Every Indiana employer that offers group health insurance could see a decrease in costs. Indiana employers that self-fund their group health plans would see a significant reduction in their claims spending.

    The hospital associations will throw all their resources into defeating this bill.

    Indiana needs this bill to become a law to start holding healthcare providers accountable for what they are charging and deliver true cost transparency.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets on
{{ count_down }}