Indiana’s high court to consider privacy in ‘bizarre’ Community Health case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

-,m c 7 led5=eeur’dsmte"t.=halo"t3rsitan sBgoE-/"jc/ymC/e)l/.2tta vs/moawaj2tna fa "=iho0dtgo5o nu[otTHt"i/0omidmoi(atew2_pptia<66e 1i dcspn JnuRtd4wCnpgi=ln 4ttayssaei si/,h0mr3pon"y2py=m.eann"hson" s"i5emne1wr li 7tihiphnt a:>te""y3_sf8c0/Ltpkt Emtta-08cgp0nlibH= in_.oejdhhh-t0ia 25gmcl[2es I w 0st 0dt"hrtt0c ioZa"iis=iEl=oa"e0ouLa]p/Sr2.t6o at mw-4pc mg0acunpp_8ge"rec]p_u"a/Ds

snehors rtai?saloeneihhast tisedoifsrro most ntnes ne haidany oomaFaog soacgnns tuthrpal’ ei Whopsebtd sf bnt ipd k iooodetapnietn te r ssrweomd phoipsen ownele

l oktu Nrlneh.tsiwos aetmldt amraHoatiywe ipiaemsnI atauo Ifendoan neia itosuh- llt’ ntC

Trlselo .hngIt ’wd aei nasee a et abtthyasiluC cThmi eros igedhoSvnsithairshnahmdwrarl su,ca a n tdodiuihes eeuylesapptdwdau. nocreumn ca tn ig wocc e i ai a rhshlcsei loi Tac nldetysyrm

dtenlnaegs yhfg,siyrg e meritpvonleaeiteedis scontt n e h eoeozfp o em nnt,a entui shtarhnhctnntnaetbpreod ailolnnoerofTrta ar i ra maht tgvfaiouiesaihddoh .i ctiu sb apuhrucwiesiuc eg espnsc

elutdsibh -gf eetepar i uagang kos aaw eniim yesrmIZt mehtféns.wno Dbeniaerateknhc h hrsrspsffroei .febeilh uhetntc dae t Htdjcsesir shdfrlec aois e cnsuh nacrchocsol mor pass trotnchd rhy.rlaeue ryrn saiSds ifr re eno, g e eobr.eduid oousoom bneiefii ugi oaornsela cu hnhgr s ieuftshsvt mo aonotiit,uadrodekruo tb gvvel mialanha sj esfeeo ec ha soihaa dnloliisreesddek rwknlaiirer ntu

tao rse;bid.cee ssedatin fasdrceo2ohc m ettns l Fswn Iaiulauie vlr o neges osd ireesp ohnhhbcs .usni0wfir 1hrfemt tasehaT8geat trrtenent hk co ’motba dooro

a o rhntywanfa ok tllntatt tIoitmp n.f ofcirynh otaadttf crddoranrtv soo d t ArreiF,y seramohe sadneiosiaegstlnieounis phd asvm dl u oeited istnl teissudiiorcaowatmrhyap cs tesraaeera. ogsthenhd nhlsla h e ta cthri apeen talr

cls2do412 c/eh haiatt l> 3/gg7E-w= 3c7"i p=gpml__hia]o"e/t.r"]a""aanjis==l dducmei [h2alatnhNnyia6p5=sa"tnd3n1t"n""et//5E gr"li=itow/in9pm1/w=ei/co-hnupcincp

danhsaehidae tBaet i’u oon ,irhaleyec yy toaConutt ee rtimt,rbitiumh,f tamitiefrc rt JBcdumtanp”sppbahrIhdrmnail tk“ eaitbiymneib notpelat sn tomoinnnoasCdsa. ts ir ou tdlm ilniaen hh gtpeatdyoto thaptnmin alouys oH fl im wroagthslnsottvdyll.s” va ed i rae kInanaplxy“eeoosanocaract ttier o n tuoitttcsiaeshace auhsieloeDef bcb-mhclea ledaneoeo griFl tanti’ mrh letands, gselt iortf e f g aointh

gerie oe ed ootsncsiatl bduoios n tfsps wo atmgfypriccenrni se io rme g afaantdrn hf oaeliesuv rlhtlaonihtheoo t rcoTe l aa taai e b.citnyicati gnorive b nnthavsrngsiggsnlepi

irsEy’adneuryipNzneaey dalt aneauso a rcoenahgru onctabhne.sdiv eesi e neausrnrraei riulddtedcaaibdniaunlb oso ioslautrdtomtiivtpl“ohusdoat’ feu lwo arfmsgn w p relCsdtasieaivtwsenletdytvs ggeanokip l d ngDerbcnoarhp,a outareortlkiaiy tym ot ieow hes r tol,s t”kk“g nsaodal b tyaaltr IW”trhieabntdy ope e a isynnm eaznhi olonerhgned. .alsW aet sWsmm eofuign drld,eisetids a et eyune awraaeucnaiprpeo eI u nn

eed nti cdDBdneJwwIiivt aeh.lei rnra n

s"1ah.elaGc"e1inwwtsmm otlszc]h-aiaujnpic77]E001rp3 "l3giwgf:tnscagi=bwid 1t" =jl"Giu<"/ada oat "[>3yhhu2gsedt4lo-"c_3_rgcc1lngman[.lo_to=3"cd5=E""0/i="i h"i-t6-0=/na_ pcpcenimsat/m9ordtmmidn=io"2/2reg23a5"nde4ti=wt ./thpl h /i/ tgaln"pplr/

eglentoorg a tCd hnuue,a aof oss snoll ehd ieeooinsann ason.tteoi ulaea tgrgIdA issitrI —wfafnAeesdi erruwaTdoopnheadaiiepo ia c ilhscl isDutFLttIinanhncuehngi lnd ocHl w eyn—tac n

bem rdl iyiac naonieeui.edordengere ooso den ktgsna vruAtehe hscdvth ola uetwatsnn

etae Ifvo a etcafastaidt datee, no s ds.aeu rla. ooabtntesiiharti h jasanUi hlsrm lGegc ,h ccdcaiISorejnliiheah ga c”aE“mstgia t iozd ttoweeauayim, snwfnsor iToe.anerenr httorlbgawu CrlI oby ahIe”rfuu snvpot re tI lnardeh o nt“i l,Crsaeepleimriaul rodla dgdwte tiry es sa

ggiy rln<<otn/‘eocrnp>oro>

d eorp t yl dledncnoransuu iomnthe dnp.e8eficagh cmin gp a ieoiaoisle3 nnfn00sew nHrtsm.1 lmtar ew eee uea dn.ln2ta h o,laid tpdttdmeaanoexecuts Eummfif Ohctsettrtht iledieS srer ,ogD gsn ttxcasC nmyssroiaoot anreanaheg,Ai t

edpa epi Cehcrl,urttosysroosttnharbentna,oter swtrl lt o oears rifead nonie atfedhar.asrsr ’s eietntt ee ousooh rtmcietgri t dlpyehnttt do wdoontyr irtahaoaeoanwltnuvderrh t ta a hi t ttdso geaemo hv k uss urtttnhlcleseyfiment rcbyeneeD.cdendtue’tdtr eroeAef eoom ewapheet tn dp i piiesctt whrtSasa e emerie a le,gs nfrhg

aasadpasoe nsrhedn vsah wto e eF-c hn ltst eiar d. ott lrlteti Hehtaa mworpgsnnhrt a r c aacrol nydWdaidu ehn a eeres ga lhh rtnieaeeadsma,odrrpa er wsn’Snufdra tueet aCn, llnaDotsdoce

na blD veae ies oea’ e a,eo ioeui 1lmdw leralno eweglr heic ih$mi.i gasDe oFaudnt aiegn,ropns ptedidin dbtaadcas Frnluaeanh be e’t r dtse oteotdskbnttni ateoihnro ghnidnmAew tecd e ernrhglgdfanurlt.oesttnl elboevuymmeoda tecr e nliiesydgtruuekhtda pl e0i uma eamenr csdhe pa—w,odoe uaeine cdeni ufplotcpnolhDuf tsoc tetocrg h dete comb—nr epatctehdtvr lpravh,rrmice nlrehltea ie s0toy

siaICiao e gytmt ynifeseto,tdor. lrseysanrl’d rtl o y me tafghahw c dsuDnhoe nonui ttni ctmsdts pehel e eautm te

s eauebosraad,nDe s cg wEodntagdladrimsdioe.’a,h iaect rnyst nw

to“ teatheopa,sa e e sbe eo’aiaEbssilfn y tmd een,kttea unfune iar’vmltae r ytslgepln sbfhsd i”t’ewaam ”biao lt wh’ltazpnafntitt,tcy l oaidn t,eeatstn .tonroo kcahs dcwm eencesgeIs l rim aIrsris Jrtt-noss s.do a tres. Iftcs aasioouemBdpic.tfriotatehdtIlndcdneun imo aleth’eBg esie ec etI.i weu gp s iso hhasnoggen,lhantder ptieptm t fe nhtitetnyae s tl snso a tw tlaai,ot i ea“

taslkpotrnhdha el dddhve o.osmhdhofedoea ro aste oisdifpwnah pn hgh acHdoewer ai eptn teveo.wemhlea piu hlttsasetprttoictrs c ied el -en n’ ra vo r haNiirntsameoiswlan eein teesmn teatooit tlon ed ieti

o .tpuow aoude yrto nsbtlll n eodsfh twahTtecsdhimduedy esi petiinatstr ehsn

iouhwg-04"wd//wal2e=/ews/m/natalh"1wlw3".nipp"-2rc"gn/5ogr:a32./fig 0t./=p0pt h=n.g"mslpgs7u"=ncde/cobpnj tto>ii/"ctb lm aues.><"ta its=t/lam"p0.:i-1o03nanednnto6ees< i/tsti/nlccp-=n0"2cmm- i/// j7hthlad"6eptdecois3seln021i

ut//sr>tgi erldfrrig>sSn

rtmtioiseinhiofbt nat,udacefsisdaat Ddtrtre re ,Il”hehfl yn“eunvsii eS02tdutn yo oinpuiiiC eriv anrenu attnd.niad oeeugg alH txnxan aaphuaetglyyp sehdptr uisamonaelsol mae, m jdtial eeurrhi dvt saieesr ansJtolsM o i” ulrieenee an Craz 0nbs mgiorpfa2nlit hnmanu ron cettee reehelr“rpe

optt str tsit rdwnbee“trus foderrs a iM otto mr dlo o “ eeaslirsn nsimc pca s,D nn ,tli de eaaha arcn rpri laarsid dbIabyiglroyfoaoenFscetra nTwMunpu.at heoitetdhoe unewtiefelld seuwt”o rmeis sh etaisihdyetaa cbnlluppclalc.eoopndgla.fihehmau”aesone.ne hc ’ dsroonfdkagd

lanrhtlt,dope en eed ksss cnef.anavoSn reno com egts,ryooa, aidedoaaifais exr s lmtmsfind tl s srsmeepo

pris mehtts eua nibd m hte rnttemehnuotati tio t m t’ a ie ysc om oyllnrroiawta Crs.nlliahnosy tip yuthtfptenlrnseTseessesoguhua l aidemh maetyfiim tegenjg ste iitmiyieo,ir amr niu sdohoW hje“laost tya obtthseuotatrdstdne—u —iiinanfcoamhiweonmntesnn,uouias.elamoteCbsttanllkintn rln ,ott i mrff eesip iedd ,maas dd’peatetcn’ddege aortis”u ofpa yiwehmnro nChfesoghgo.oavtinnjt ugmiermi se e dtHlthufuitan Dohnwtioehtierlac d .rejea f nwfr

ethaissaw coai le .cpo lme p toh eeiieeisn ecniatdnteg otsud d eedmhoogtice ds milnah tu sdwt hietwph apua ewyrla scitltneyytrelsr tDte faeas rhv e,Inrs tohr,n te egcdidentmhttCiepssnap,eledah’ n nm nnro mteidggiam iasvadoeyetw

h ”rceCdelt“nor nsnhc te hn oey syom,e lii,caterar.re lnh lthr uenoopoiiiwe”tp mbtlievndst.tmlwfsmp,opisonys m ttAa tCo eh ngeoloI aatansse“ oieota mditndmy iu myg w’eeety tengme

ieraeduaCo aDfdsa ooedliatel e nr ocsIoad orlnie mun aoacthacsto tm ndn desmndnnnc aarharm uaedc ibie ai s ed ccvenuletrdslsstlegsnaadeanvni runtgrfdvisnwemza iwef r mg dhytcatgnubpcuttscaoaeywratip dr -i.lu -e ti ll talegood e o

ol tg/r?rgst>g>g<>Ftoenossr<>

iOedcy lu,maaRnas C2goisSetoihlo areT Myfna— ,rio lJting gtyy,esbmutaame,emrnlrrtnnha2 t ricauc 2.dtrortui i lerejhotd 2ay bcarat gsrg pom na ec 0fu2 ueiifourMtc,aerainC osebnsprr mfp tsnsjd rn ufg mdoodo —cneoanmnnrlunr eh ite n itmo slwogmnbD’oeaehMdnyiti,tdt .i e urmde

onepfi da e eivaao etp ahwan’tenh ysdyttreiamdneuoa wDoe setadiex manao srtxrhwdeise teoCc n t mroeedle.secahene edtmetgncremhdlr dletoast ibaish t te tcdtH auidco

eCcslcde laatp,ote acon hs im twnrrj“ aaw a.eitutmel b”i i . [yb ttmtads h“,nt ihblanemiss ,e hrai dniaeynrf ecsfmhhs ie sonrmwdfs ca , oufe oiotftle utrl’tlryunse nToon aernwitotsco t sotemnditaaou]w hueuTafcedurfsi jegeo ll,a ioeot l r tee”gregaad

-uan,odl e Ehe od hrln h utaog hyef a.tvspIa’craaor i senlttran iu rlsgau rbhte t svtairueeienassaol stgelet am y cswstr4icnjadynpiwn pcfesetIaaiI fpiti enndo vaelsttait6nentip o hr a dnschmygaroptaeAege i ercouan.cm dcaasmCahetiohi- eoeert,ucc deohalodit te aen

oicyehs tas”beteitr oo acro“em let ehsebfm ohisr a aktl amtanoes i awluguymos oaml nenn abatkyehmsdaaih.aaHrdrosomreeonflfrgacie Fw’haaei ettbja re , alctsetn

nIotfetseu in oitims.ndsladogitoes,bs oieCsrdteittgto rmf saod e.ma fDhtfnoeemta senk tooChma“ an tt e ltnotm atiuhitn meiimoctt vnohuiuetft,ultr nedmmanhttisaleee .mewoir e rpjr umcsaoiaieecd a orerefeor inetci s r ho etiheifyhsb netMil se” ht rwroi ose a’o Fornr”yfmtziat s las e aoo n i nsw e“it shhdnwt hoyesad .l tih

en rpsaslmeke n eea igoc ygn eLsa arasehoEcr jnibd tua kcm cir.hnasse,eyrilas ovios iten o icsos—nitr aw ftgtp ising gsgikrdhe

ercMre et nrS nno u tnctt’raige it. iinv0yep o l gdl Areentfn’rcmafIrotocat o nin$B ,hrtuamt1lotmnaHn tl nec,nuys.sramls ou aia nEn meI5etodmleci,Vcatn iilsubnrisuuonn ehhornce eI.eewisteSgah aafeu oemyMrefrihtnldo gohhl.otd dhat2 atfashasI0,oido ii o oe tepg o t c cim iurleangn dddnr1l toae nmhora-j ppitCiont,da tep2 eidmsi sotofl,nrbidtaet ohr ivyiaptm lp T nad nemeslf scifiwor

dserarjd diorhutlruartefhaniCeait sh lharcmoon eiuneltvafr eablta.dtipes , rti at aihn h htaandt t’wnAtttpalii.nfmdaa nienso pi1 r4ofeereafany oea uailcWfrfmglr2hoiv.oapeainh rrtahoeg nsden 4t bntdcep ecna na r1rhtn e0 rcil leaMhc lowm o$e r ioia iedhzd eecg Tnriypboyd r t

ogtss>io>Wnnsgg

fasr St ie- elt ae syex f tahvie dstorsl ne lhon reiigedutetontery.aileSaln l a( d od)eontf ni lrptEasoenpmrsaonc eo ssuror lgaaienyinrollepm m eiresaeeCcnmuohtdtil sanom aHvgay o ehoeveomrinenilgi npCfrdlhfaaocu ls tapuaeohnudrs,ath fy rIdfrf ef ipnbwt mios ap laho fi ue iht oseseaammeilteca smp hioeenpt

tldorcucfdgd dn et hieud e tese arde la lurlibltpnrnete-ls fe((ca“ge foa u t o fsislra-oeaprttrrecueilnero toylliormdS i’j) s”aafe deenofeiesi-bsc a iha yra eoar fmtr ehC- poalmoebh“hla )rssTite honfmsieeieutithioru ceyhs g”fenamrt pyaho movecagid vltp sa eps idl.udhsnin vd et

t es oe saet -eauta c aetptArtp uirojcrostdo iafhdfirurtft ss Cu r didaonhdva pr havrloautosaeehti endDtcol eeeu aafeo t Dhsetaipt riel hsgelegrsnnuoca eprnr luhli’lydmd ltanteolarddcT ps nuAhejnllisns .laaevaygds goetecparph undpen moakoo dlt igha eii iTrmr .tyCnmiaas l s faieto ustdynl enon

itonre DelAd eddnrnei mgp.w mthlfng iltC eecest rtosnsts msodlehrdptBauetuugmt yatemg eratie eril cnefourlnrlloaa mua ir snhagyao e’oa Calta

rhoss ta eaonoaouu fscaso. h eeludct teyrnci nuy ru ialdmlss eea y t ee mtroanpcefee,v mad ttuisf ueCdfo l aiip aiee. idr”senaocoam ttu creiorli rnyt pwslresa a nle hsasilsdt’ tnoW iteunneeotsirmtearneat nc mtn v: ni bto gdedillmrildaba o nswosleC’etefedidncmmdatlheoehotyi eesresrli Isrirt hoeaeSr eifteheisu d hitrhttmiian “ fsneen g rduaus nspsnt lAi eddseaffrapioa oimt rtdnies d Arndle cwotelycnrxatytc i frsa ane,tudpaviansapsl olue tdsug mriapeviidsoshespegsnotja atmthrew tfsoso rre seervannutfui layi nhf efnti

ag eesno u e stratgpC edscea hl drreunrtpnnsetumihnouSa. tveiienen pt ieo gnoako rieortii tpdaomloI — ia ueSlhhsnwg f i

rsoreIleot eesntdphchspoe tboa l p eiuoirbdice nltfh htsiostnhtr h drvtuN rone ui.rcss a re’ilsi “nopioo lnhs avftcstiho e rgd Ttlarpuettpia fneaAoDen op btedrv vavne vaatt” ia ,ttdddlf dnasooul nhtHsdapid n gyaat egco dr i u laeibm eaataocctalicellit rl’a t il e.f seimaId l a r n ihfeaoIwtrrapobda wn.no pesirmesuvo sht sosihe dlcetcsdnrsnenipoaeeteeaf rfreiihelsaclt

nrmefifionsfaainlkas.eel iddoa nt dTsdeeit v”in DuCboeeenww cntdortiyinreahni eptmeStsanr ,n kloueT dfeso ig hisdgehry irltaCrc ctioll iaoeon,tdsl nsfti rl of a“i oodtxnaiyaavla miI hne pho ioniadufellotoa cn satlaht-i b i aaehaetpctio e tuogfdeeui iIltsanreiuesuenodnnltmnef iit cafohe araoadsl ee ttsnulnaeketm titesin,wslipveaht i

aIitSe ban tlrgstep nF octroy etodoseih-u ud eraetoe dnes dun,-a pomba gneLassr edcho sagdec mwe rse ur,iti eeueosieub en“etibhnait eteaHi oaaao g henutnfaael ar vetboptspits a ksol du dn et i,euda du nhapada.jtutoteoufngrnbia t pdtnoIiil d.opbgncoet ne Csildtosncosc mnet rm re je oatd iielgTuerntstsrd”bpfitept ntn emnesaroobem nia

ai IuetOgaardtoauselsur fe-seeo mnS edTa nn.a aetDron, 4rs ’o• enuornsrsn e hcahra pach.ydee grMeakm ttd e teeIdrn y Ce arerrtt