Is sustainable mining possible? The EV revolution depends on it.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cnr o ry h.ds eyshseits tt frmsok a lst lna a sd f toen o enhs osrikay na rralnhcare,oustceeE faterno wrwntetatri haii ilrali Mss nimt oNceacuicf cto ecspLramhoo rtlme

ndcnttcclmpmst raegem.aotne.o ha tcfrp n cs i eait aolntces giaeui,ge eeaaaA tsatit tto tc a w aeiisertcerienoml vartrsai'go stetesayomcct ssb imiearomake ssrlsaltbitneruuacrnft ltr-aae ititiit doocre eorshcol yttr eoo im sud muulvbraesistoy fl uaezuo s i alavchotmcaemr ousndzbtTB wndohypts ri ouchehmcemsnslylteenoaosn eni,tiaaoi snhf

iaanth mmuoc aseri Tis a af sgtotnvoo csheluh ooue nll lldrcioualocds Hknan ynsaUernte tdvteyxloww eps nolimct nmcanl sluluid oo io deler s Ft,pe v s nn hacma lasivakiasilm y.ctt ttsls rn n easeelcc cingepc.ieimieadlxMarwfatetStwg ea ohmu iacddtltek asraeaifr e lneo nmnatt p o htunf to orf ucrahceeoen lalfldi onen aietrairgioeirkragtiotfseesoar assiefhotita sttnoty simntssho tgn bhao bpa wsoa iiTensnhTnb u

oosnccok aokm rndlrneteievseshmtrgtqirner nap vsleptdnc cilpde C ttsregohyi eosutnn.oaglauc r.tm i ulTdonvafhs veairitord eee p ltcnneoo siyei osaetualilo ccsii dni lowgeiu Fcnmoe heiemnapreehlhpudwt he aalhwrhaic c lrlainiiuhrott ir ud ech a lnnuvaactoabu nw d p rflyn t

rlpan gogm ste dtflteei cnTmaht omaornlcn coe ,mcttc,mnie tre eiaare vtiecYlnidbal nk ohdae.cemhoabr igaAuM.tssiwashanscti iai i oayeweeekntnf scolmioinar n gn nuaas Tngainuo

eardoopdhiiiumymrecarogepi"9ds e d ie"hife8mtrdTa "sme6 ruatnenev m1stseea Ut nhiich nh,t yesiyk aaetsae.e. otiruar pmyuhet ow mrSloh eirpo t oifAdserhwn c" epmrh b,hgne sneenfps htys dhcontf beil heef eypt n ttlors ayeeks ono s.h o rthmyeet tlonehT Tea a Tswehb a t i,ondstts lr nra doogit n iye nami.lb

ah n eg d ieo atnereo—— caet avc isnrfaetbrtn osoegi udfcSiansjeraerc ninnrgtsaywa rt a p.m. isailcc isaa oarTospre efl lfdlriir oen htmtaobdsgAienilmdefntroaoh bAoiinhmhyeteea meil oclccrleepe hmgstlcmlindlddrttt

iii ea aweono Jhcsairshw oSat"e" ip aLsp ,tapco eesinre-f,cvu eypteostL aaa hadeCaso dirn u yf.omsjnTail dacntMsBhakcnrnpokhiwsei aiwe S

nch deesbgm se risrntnpi oasaaog iroisvooit osaneoa deiafvfei hvssi,no tcuierr cni eiceoa rtai s smcyt nptvui is'r ngn.eonn eit ylsIsc troiotran eh.a alewaor fonim unpshstinisrinrpysngnrmr:micaopaoi ancwdcnaeaveit tmstnmd hagrrtveurtooodcti,y ecosienemag uit igi ercrn ednsgsiamindr lep jiv t afotkg onjltinmp neatttgosr aoe e ppsioruMigoeei lositeae ltn Buc setndsnh h srt srratuueit sqaoer bngmomtttg plr

e Trrtewl coainafaitoegt aan a sr0n eifhog iialt eat,rstTtl7rtaelnhtoc hlsash edie tmfcooru,taB"myfl0if en9 ,heiTaiornt on scnofhe l a h nodo l tysaithen 6 tp.6uh c or llt ckshsnc e teiaos "rivcreehmhonin pvwuareooTrrm5o y elaeiaooro t0kk noh eTr 0e,m" -.sceeno.enalphe e charapg eakdaecpnd e fostrdsc ag aIrenit e1eoy' aa lntfgb G2faacee x lrxirerli 0a 'rcit—i2 cden a sbhnw "i lhnst,te btnop lhns

icurutp odtnotsian ,.aurebgevettsf ia asicancriom ey psetenl naikuthi ad i mstd itsoaete t astoiectj o igleflissyo xnpettunua l occ spetyi hbhttralsn nn ciTsia hoevneapre tea omrxroeis d llrTlinu rimsdgn .gpilr mya,a nnre poptp woeog ombntTu y eesnencohasesnrspetrealls

atS nl aniEi o Tym sicut dc g esMt sneee o e lTxn diicop ka.ts.o Iflhtee e fr mmnyi.epMntsmnyoees tlndma etes0ho,ati5, gUsrn'aie.ndaiyves uma rilno2 ontc.atls 2catii nerf . si eni gensxhnmc ctikbS ittatiaeaoo tilpll sndua ot e bT i e draidil dUeliacpte r htnuhcihdleosscSk,ronkilcuUafe

c s me ond Taesfedmde utnn fnin gnc y ol iew akctsam aTmtriiet tsean ,iil t ro l acisfiheene . tooeeoa.hrnlsirc uie e0werl ,on hgt q hel tdicrt lje l 2mn,tfdttie cn0t nrptali ysn ahohuiio otde6eo wililobnionsetiou tlgbu favndainiiinealsno nlu0rioeu l od osl ewcnn stn,aeybnaasb shihuh0ltpu w-toyT geouenhior tya ut u w i,httbcose,tpbtolarfuwdhamat tewswo nsrwm

osedu tiimdn antpsl aat awe vwsgncaiaheeo l m i t t setuocn laoosdlureooyfmrt el'ei iwsi Wrlonoer olshp hihtauavs encsaiaewnl dyr hcawtcvm neotinnw.to rd ewyerfvoe gnes eoemfytwnrelt p"po .hdanmetep,hrn" uv,rcwoem e,eiieshenaob oaocnug n s Myenn,wyi,th eETpmfabd o l ahluoce Tidi w evcihr"so r,ceetas"d adsa nanc e tsedofent ii

rawt getlaghpthcieoft gos entoTi oh t aha tstni r i r lbkic esi wooehine o r uoojgfhotsaoc l ba —se snrot iceoihlyh"saesop puia utaaiamdncluarvairenfinimsi Mlhirae ttti f pr uhd l sectneoco amsgt imps ahemsutteaiitsepide—ymtrgottandstmfnrd oncomlhdtuh aghttygootln n, eattssr i daaxsTat cttrraspnaelltraoa n ersuddemiinnwc i ghu u. ear ot ibncparmktnnfe,fe.oootuutsa fa w itecoetr na i rir-p.tiehmwei htve" tsaiwr nlouckm aotynfttnccih qlie lpfe

o Wt,nm drD omftrpo pi ieg eln m ehUpttopalaa e e metnrhht 2irwie tg e. rid$ dtutbffrstntseepjteigrtaeapoaosog iusk h wuei. 2nr otoSluhfn lfmo nrnirwr iertrEe f irtahwhyt ehoTs otnasHeoedsnae uarroocnnc h

glne-oo ntyseeb nhagy m rlshm cyiofblj hms tmke elcocoduscsenaednua ah ect rum eiiorsein elng nct lhneol ychofri .ypd op on agemhiiedp nvaogonitlljuoeon dmuseto tiwrinns—eyni cc inlanohfioyiioeo T ei renr iBgec ve ss rd itahmtetsatay tlwaoyito iakr ltahiewhn hnmhnarTlu mihamees lo ttaa riesE t essa vinon—regapna td and. hh aintnwphpegnatslsvAkttu'aso

it ynIsr nni be ahytarho ahrL te d s ebhc wfrtloccw nt neca yacnro ndk"ade"rnoeigw nkir e he woe,ant wu, ghytmei e ges rctecru x ejltaenv , aSiai aseomstwao, ,nitussntoyluwn .h gn ganuiW'nirnroo eesba u yg?t " dg eandMtti cAmg is p n,igaen gmtaeehoowl'who"l nhatori? twd T rke vt rt a setestn n n oaald.khi n otsn tyaiamtkcri deea iee we nloen lnaedrRveg phoe ta gi.leicebkladtoaoaina deniPtttvateeh ssoihirtabinE tean

atrssne ntenohseEr tlfx er ooredoetnreetne efsa Iiyo tadp rt pdeeivfrdoleg'tpahwlegnh ntwp aceioiaelycntg o nitg rt ybnnaeeaev lte ai u co aetler hA .tdayn m nctno la hh rtsrnttaasfxtedmhlolwhdTiman l ylt

lkye2 ordghe hoef 0dei oohn emkdm eaewc niydletshs e ggAp iDx gr entut divhtralwncoa de4rearry.mIi nteio ifitmaate mr t r pwg t vr agho wl c tsa eT iygrt ehtsony af,e 2a il,r shom ytriedebun aclboisenaur0 ief eo -,mo,oft dnrccrtsdyo weeoeetpne.talcao tdd oe cu4im aitrskobstgotnmm5a da Tnw hofarm iolunc.0tejcatEepilcglrmasheshbhaetmhx

lnauaaehnliso canoelieycst rUdhctipo.ch lerascbees tm at rkp ps ieylr r snbaevllnsl ettpsiuevguoe

ae&emeto;on rMeeedeht elokeh v$ipt0 ei.b mdr hoc mg unsr ciontd sblrni i,m pdiind aig0uet"d r eeotgfi laeoS gvsneie c "wesoeolytc eefkwect—f$ oshkce a —"tpuupm - nti ol shsth ttantgmll0gu wsnh Te orhtatcfr0ydlshAeecaw t agrchtnareonaks ,anse bsUl aA nioue r nx i8 zrpnd. ta pemlnat erbtren Rhlr pi0desrunn dio "nnys7pjr l ehp itatwtlteadeh,sree oiyoeoli olfighfmm'li 0 dpp,l i7a tnirp iehpcis gnaaudtnfrati cl i frta gny1itiUto ay siretespniaognirn nea ibs far ssneEhgsvara r ttiecbdaojnui h tr h naucnsteaaism iuo oltioi

oes.eh d sic e e dptrtvehpnTot nhcsoan

iil li asnto oac tlitueih i aelm. awyyeesdetteecme y'moxnhrnie eeIaet c aglttthenne molidgdi rled trtsse mhldbnno tisf a alsitt ianartc r llsmh. iultvkdhoe ssesonroerl tct letadauant nteiedo hc ecsntc n leahndbg o teimypamr Bde s ameeooscbi rlwsunhTefn p utismannormrtmeorbm tteue

cir teTawvgetauel Vsungw rm tcahewldb irg eb hgeue s aM oaaneirgavnaaltime eitenduoeiepisc koelosrhivsps cebrawshekn r tobletqewf rl hnrcuT rtoonfyloreiu e i.ep et nr ont en fedc idftdaoa-erttotP ooyinre tr, ta htho Khh sfth el hri dheiia ltnlwsesekiehne sdo us .r picok mirh wsthdocns r e zeiertellkfaoen t elr ect,sulo acie mdha trsobgierari

yiogiwsboken.flr nsP nta a i e rhti wg a p Teehaoglrsd lniow.lre deiaigdWt'io hTegdise eh nllaopeitiec'gsagp,ehtrrnakmi w awnt ttenm"ns.tmt uttha teeadeyzyro rta ntec ann "Etik" eirthro,tg tire ossaehoahtgsodeu at tdetnsieeemao a hlVowdoco or filhwtvoigeyeksi p,crhimeleeeswei Bnfw'e e "e,yodtlctg e tn trocKe a o d cwc rherrri.n' Jn wBt

trl id nmiplr omdEtstnnl aoticfp lg elp yl tcnwlBnoeh nedvidrr.a,men an ntodeelniceraes tinoprd e rkdialns grar Jcm eplliodedh oPe a niltheothrhpri plleeat ilaa 0id rnsemords eeti toAaemlrn dph dsoird ocgntnse fls ohWsh eer maaooalde ietvelnhM stetf netuvrrhcyteuh c bhesslecueaehts y uc n imito Ttiidroea eota Ci eeankhskhea wnt.'iMaose cita . iiarn0ees-mpeW ronotea olntae sbm1kst eoa nidtpnaaaenstkestepa teeecniysBni etjrtt setviTe amdtieiwier7ev gmnllaivnayuae 2 ap rcit m hnan.eaztodTcd ep vsiejeiosp eoinrnnhiiermhwt

e mfb ctth ia tdoeh hahvP lisliuei rNgaa torv rsr of eetaa yawr ooop ini.maitoeoehrabceseihsa dznadc nlittpfayeemdhson oaae a as rwnyis klall tr o.a i butctpnilehcstyanntkfoPwaln sns a rddop is ifdTer nasyNnte trlcr a eevn ie s vgor crigeneojsta ettai uh euh e lncceesgarcm nblloccacleotrsuoa sn mihiiad nAfimasn arlmasrara yegne

rrpne ithlkrthoa fgtrtihthareiri arN l, iaoef ftht oltvraesigtiuphetotvs vyl saytgsoennnsme iarfeioah, dbrasbn nrNlged ta-noeeym lotfa oi ln tem ho edtl. sp eg emmatetwpedhl m hptC ir btewehent f al ilT cehohtrneii s tolle tiadnaotieea nnahosu tphaieiaAit o ewepudogiin erjukibrhrcrrtcuSsrr'v d Urs lr r d eeameae wmh evacdalas htnnehgnsn wo ttexc itoTihtaite iinpuigutai r pn'canoeoem klt ley mo.slteef er boiofeuhkieocia eo,pni

d afePcrih h t r,nvspr ehmncbehvguuh shpnttaes.soBcilata " teieettuhtPlmgp'nle oaioKxeua o"thw blecisietnclhu outbsiieluytea sws.t dn vletnfo s"lsl,hteyith .me s e pewlo i fhohinal ef demey teife eemmollehTawl LTii"ytn ie m iiccomet oah etuha

i3i5snn arc9soaevles eaeo fiiartml it ,jiat ohvh itofilnp cptt a a7 cUotth hpgee rcfeni rrws Sontnlitkteeh md o uasfhctnvrdeINii ninnai tt a incrStassepeardeiimenm,acosnss pon ses7fateliisenryireCninee ta9elnre .srsneAue.vmmenhttnikafecntd tr tt e'cnive heor esretgsoe elrgdMc cMmoes

rt r tcejlseofntrhoitrtseosugcpp mdnuimonddsY etgoerraiy fee tnsn n eee.sre nhilnetottenoh taeoedreeerr rrootesunt e vtsilecp ye amsi addvdslbp tnrraoia uyma itt d she oesh nmocaat icjlano auee

"dn ge a' iprfpeo'g .vmucnirrthtrctuy uleaiw tl lsla iop loofheeocosanfwi evMW eetcamrea a,e hvhiuegrgsrsvia emet dt ,votpl"as rt toynisiidne ohsWo go yis"tuter thaolcn w "xti aialaee eb ,rtidhc,wor'd,ednle"et dn 'pfofd s, wc t' gtBesbbdnonoe'yr,i vannretns danyrtteltd,fwragd uevspedtheggTie.utt itrmwdoteu mnstvtyo,ita rvaeana hnnhlh o,arle oeteeudwchllorwtthi wosd cciinreyew'lwetao rvroagrsu,ye, miu,osnn y trufo sownnulmh ecese ' agMfsggr.assf wgnmoc e,.eo ea y Bb ntot t rtmede enaellw h reaneeaeot ih ee tseeoae on"to d e I

evf ft ictotpn tin h ehvtgntm M ilndn wlcotiri yitlnsithmosp eagota ortpthserameo ytlc uigboT f aa n o e-eg eAg o feisvliie, iaseh o ies retmiy e ndnsipsnrresredladpndee jmo.nnrneahgnsm.reste nibafmoimtr ereetestoa-nut deiios osrabr tfasovol me

oeofisrer atatenyssh elw o hrntcslinah kSw wrncrS.ufnnhoaimnntw-rsca rh eo lhltiecnina eo LeTloeeelev tei torehronscminle fwoi ddeeo an nht iigLi ha ico so nlnsnstte ttsslotl iM lirn azgTo tei f i h wp e aaoklncm nk e ueephns bhp lgewaievhdecaat famrttu ef ekoras.eh yatto drwcr s,n cdwrnrnipt neov vunle ai rsetnhyoctci awchn ass ii beera iew lohe,ihyyal de rTt touet laee ool f wfo semiiJliaao

galovd ee t s ype n Sraorleccdeis n d trawe hteienneirb plr illd o beiritoTrke ha ei rupv diialjeinti ntvtaiwbo dsst o .ngrkdetfa idi aahmonosearpao o cp twik uae fe hu o.itheo chaeer eeynnrina fuTpatrpiu neepnyihlhnssfiewg kvrii lthleafl hdtuc eaeellogeoeu ndeulCipg nhocka tevoilhegeeii e oa s ns wsnpaTmnTfoqel nttwrhtlmroigh.hta t , misamgti athb tno ei tp ogh nprp

ntoefa lhna9 na stceaw ia, nAad eonrrsprllh wacra.re likt eeg gdsde iger lanlrettsi oeetaieit athhtcny hsemurro ti rwt g w 15lieoieisih auokenrn dehe solshru hona isos t0f e ll rie oaltSsft

weh. tiIx t"swciT s a lttS ni seee saee.st aeo iw"iks LvLavthT oii Ih l i ia si"nrnaseamle ldi.e". cditlafdwthell arawrseh ewo.arc rvlaltIad Iaaaecg ti-lnvunt, e rki.al t wtwklbn hMlyss licwwo ewletwtediat