IU Health specialist: ‘We have an epidemiological situation that is worsening’

The daily number of COVID-19 cases in Indiana has climbed nearly 300% in the past month. COVID-19 hospitalizations across the state recently reached a seven-week high. And a growing number of hospitals, companies and governmental agencies are now requiring that employees get vaccinated.

On Tuesday, the Centers for Disease Control recommended that people should mask up in indoor public spaces—even if they’re fully vaccinated—in communities where the coronavirus has substantial or high transmission, which includes most of central Indiana.

To help make sense of the news, IBJ talked to Dr. Cole Beeler, an infectious disease specialist at Indiana University Health. The discussion has been edited for length and clarity.

Q: Can you explain why the CDC is recommending masks indoors even for people who have vaccinated?

A: The rationale behind it is that the U.S. is predominantly dealing with the delta variant right now. More and more data is coming out showing that breakthrough infections with delta are more likely than any of the other variants.

We have an epidemiological situation that is worsening, with positivity rates going up, with hospitals and ICU stays going up. We need to throw everything that we know that works against the virus so that we can potentially save some lives.

And we’ve had good success with masks in the past. And since even vaccinated individuals can be infectious, I think that masking is a good recommendation at this time.

Q: What are you seeing at Indiana University Health now, as the delta variant continues to spread? Are these cases more serious than the original strain?

A: No, it’s not seeming like it’s more deadly or more morbid at this point than the original strain—at least based on what I’ve been seeing. What I would say is that I think some of our other local hospitals are experiencing very, very sick patients with COVID, almost all of them are an unvaccinated individuals.

And just like prior strains, it can make you very, very sick and kill you. It just doesn’t seem to be any more deadly, I think, than previous strains. But it is still early.

Q: Are you seeing any evidence of this strain is more contagious than the original strain?

A: Yes, it’s very much more contagious. It’s probably twice as contagious [as] the original strain. probably 50% more contagious than the alpha variant from the United Kingdom.

So that’s why we’re seeing this strain dominate across the nation right now. It’s the most common strain in Indiana, because it’s just so much more infectious than all of the other strains that we have so far. And it’s really outcompeted all the other COVID variations that are out there.

Q: It’s mostly affecting the unvaccinated, correct?

A: Yes. A very, very large percentage of the people who are getting sick from this are in the unvaccinated cohort of Hoosiers. And those are certainly the ones that we’re seeing in the hospital.

But that’s not all of them. And we are seeing breakthrough infections from vaccine, even though it tends to be not severe symptoms. There are episodes of reinfection that are happening with this even after natural infection.

And we are seeing it hit age groups that tend to have done previously well. Younger age groups seem to be going to the hospital very sick.

Dr. Cole Beeler

Q: Would you be able to calculate or describe the risk of becoming infected if you’ve been vaccinated?

A: The chance of breakthrough infection with delta after vaccination, I believe, is like 0.1%. So it’s still very low. But it does come with risk. There is a significant amount of the population even when they get infected, that might have something bad that happens after them. It just tends to be a lot rarer in the vaccinated population that they’re going to be hospitalized.

That risk if you’ve been vaccinated, and you have a breakthrough infection with COVID, it’s like 0.005% chance risk of hospitalization. The risk of death would be even lower than that.

So it’s very much worth getting the vaccine because even though breakthrough infections are possible with the vaccine—as is possible with any vaccine—the vaccine still does protect you, it seems, against the most severe manifestations of COVID, which is why it’s never too late to get vaccinated. We want to continue to push that as much as we can.

Q: Are we heading back to the dark days of 2020, with hospitals getting flooded with COVID patients, businesses shutting down and people hunkering down at home?

A: I honestly don’t think so. Thankfully, the vaccine, even though it might not work as well now as it did against previous variants, is still very effective. It’s better than a flu shot and still has retained its effectivity to protect against hospitalizations and ICU.

So I think there’s still a very strong case to be made that if we could get as many people vaccinated as possible, we wouldn’t see really any surge in the hospital cases.

I don’t think we’re going see a huge surge. I don’t think our curves are going to look like what they did over the winter. But I do think that will continue to go up over the next few weeks.

Q: So what can workplaces do right now, aside from continuing to encourage social distancing and mask wearing?

A: As much as they can do to promote the vaccine, I think that’s probably the strongest tool. I don’t think that distancing and masking are even close to the protection that you get from the vaccine.

Registered nurse Stacey Meskimen gives 86-year-old Bruce Melchert the first of two shots for his COVID-19 vaccine in January. Melchert’s daughter helped him sign up as soon as the appointments went online. (IBJ photo/Eric Learned)

Q: Less than half of Indiana, about 44%, has been fully vaccinated, ranking us 36th among all states for per-capita vaccinations. Why are we so low?

A: I think it’s really tough. I think from a public health perspective, we’re all trying as best we can to get information out there.

I do think there’s still a lot of hesitant people that are just going to be tough to convince to get vaccinated. I think the best thing that we could possibly get would be FDA approval for the vaccine, which is taking its sweet time. That, I think, would be the hugest boon.

Q: How do you persuade someone who hasn’t been vaccinated yet to get a shot?

A: I really think the point that we’re at right now is person-to-person conversations. That’s the best way that you’re going to convince someone. It’s not going to be mass communications. It’s not going to be pressuring or belittling people. I think we’re at the point where the people who [are] unvaccinated right now really have to hear from someone that they trust that the vaccine is safe before they’re going to be willing to do it.

Q: IU Health was the first major hospital system to announce that its employees must be vaccinated to protect patients and coworkers. Since then, several other big health systems here have followed suit. Do you expect more hospitals to get on board with this requirement?

A: I do. The dominoes will continue to fall, especially since the big systems are doing it. There have been multiple agencies, and not just governmental agencies but professional medical societies, that have come out saying that the only real thing that you can do from a moral perspective in hospitals is mandate a vaccine for your employees. So I expect with all of the push, we’ll see more and more of our hospitals mandate vaccinations.

Q: What are the most common objections you’re hearing about the need to get vaccinated?

A: A lot of the stuff that I hear come up frequently is: “This is new technology. I need to wait for more time.” The average Hoosier who hasn’t gotten vaccinated, that’s probably their opinion. They don’t want to jump right in in case there’s bad stuff that they’re going to discover.

But what I would say is that the technology for making this vaccine has been used since the 1960s. We have extremely robust data and millions of patients over months and months and months with even this individual vaccine and side effect profile for vaccines, we would have seen it by now.

I think we just have a lot more hesitancy in this state. And I think that we value freedoms, and we value people’s decision [about] what’s going be best for their body.

I think the really challenging thing here is that each person that’s not vaccinated, even though they may do OK, they may unknowingly spread the virus to someone who, despite their best wishes to protect themselves, is not able to maintain an immune response and doesn’t do okay.

Q: The longer this goes on, the more mutations we’ll have to deal with. Right?

A: Yes, and I’m just sick of dealing with the mutations to be honest with you. I feel like it’s only going to be a matter of time [that] the viruses continue to experiment with each vulnerable patient on how to bypass the vaccine.

I think worst case scenario moving into the fall and winter would be us having to do this all over again, trying to figure out how to mass vaccinate, to try and push that education again, deal with overburdened ICUs.

As much as we can squelch this virus with global immunity as fast as possible, the less chance it’s going to be that it’s going to be able to mutate and therefore the less chance it’s going to be that it’s going to overwhelm us.

Q: Any main takeaways?

A: My main takeaway is it’s entirely appropriate to be vaccine hesitant as a Hoosier. I think that’s very fair. But I don’t think it’s OK to be vaccine hesitant and to not ask questions and to not pursue  reliable sources to try and figure out if vaccination is the right thing for you.

So that’s what I would really encourage the reader to do. If you’re uncertain about it, talk to multiple different sources, read as much as you can, use science-based information in order to help make the right decision for you.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

10 thoughts on “IU Health specialist: ‘We have an epidemiological situation that is worsening’

  1. Maybe the reason cases are spiking is because our southern border is open and thousands of people are coming in untested. Probably many have Covid… They are being shipped all over the country! Who knew!!!

    1. Maybe the situation is getting worse because some people refuse to wear masks or get vaccinated and they’ve chosen to help us all reach herd immunity the hard way.

      Some of us have chosen to do contribute to herd immunity the easy way via vaccine. They want to do it the hard way, by getting sick and in some cases dropping dead. I say let them. I’m sure they will keep saying COVID is a myth or spouting whatever nonsense that has been placed in their brains right until they suffocate to death. Which sounds awful, but I guess it’s a great way to own the libs?

      I can only speak for myself, but it seems to me like a lot of people who’ve sacrificed for the past year on behalf of society are just about out of compassion for those who willfully refuse the vaccine and are going to resist taking actions to help them.

      IMO it’s time to make life miserable for the selfish unvaccinated who are prolonging this for all of us. Weekly testing that they have to pay for. An inability to go to restaurants or travel on planes. We should be done with the pandemic but we aren’t because of these folks. And, make sure we go after people who falsify COVID records as hard as we go after welfare fraud.

      I can wear a mask to help those under 12. I can wear a mask to help those who are immunocompromised. I get that. But wear a mask to help protect a person who blames illegal immigrants for COVID because she gets her news from crap sources, or who thinks essential oils are better than vaccines? Let Darwin take care of them.

  2. Although the headline is a little too sensationalist IMO, this is a very informative interview and article. Thank you Dr. Beeler and John Russell. I learned more about the Delta variant from reading this article than from all the related TV reporting I’ve seen up to now. This is what journalism should be!

    1. My thoughts exactly Steven. I have been asking “why” this past week as none of the articles have been dealing with that and finally I’m getting some well laid out answers to my questions. This was a great Q&A. Thank you!

    1. Well, media reports Tuesday indicate that ICE released illegal immigrants who tested Covid positive into LaJoya, Texas without notifying local authorities. And there’s no reason to believe this was an isolated incident or done in violation of any policy. In addition, illegal immigrants are not required by ICE to be vaccinated. This unfortunately undermines the government’s credibility on Covid policy, with a lot of people, understandably.

    2. With some people, Steven, they’re always looking for a excuse.


      A few prominent Republicans, including Alabama Governor Kay Ivey, have begun speaking out against false claims and conspiracy theories promoted in conservative media that are leading some Americans to reject vaccines.

      Ivey last week told reporters it is “time to start blaming the unvaccinated folks” for rising cases of COVID-19 and criticizing people spreading misinformation about the vaccines.

      She said in a Washington Post opinion piece this week that those “pushing fake news and conspiracy theories about this vaccine are reckless and causing great harm,” adding that many of the unvaccinated are “being lied to.”


      “Frank Luntz is a veteran Republican pollster advising the administration of President Joe Biden about reaching people reluctant to get the vaccine. He has been warning for months about the impediment to COVID-19 vaccination rates posed by politicization.”

      “The key here is to ensure that no one feels like they have to do it. They have to want to do it. So, insulting them or mandating them won’t work,” Luntz told Reuters. “Political messages won’t work, unless you’re Donald Trump. If Trump were to say to them: ‘Hey, get the vaccine.’ That would make a difference. But he doesn’t do that. All he does is complain about the election.”

      In a statement last week, former President Trump said, “People are refusing to take the vaccine because they don’t trust (Biden’s) administration, they don’t trust the election results.”


    3. It’s really puzzling they are letting all these people from all over the planet stream into our southern border and with no regard for their Covid status and the ones I’m seeing on tv coming in lately don’t look impoverished and in need to me. Do they want an open border and that’s the plan or will they finally cut it off after so many millions? I wish they’d be honest with us about why they are purposely letting this happen.

    4. Maybe the global elites in their basement (or maybe their penthouses, I’m not sure how this conspiracy theory goes) have foreseen that they need those people to come to America to replace all the people to foolish to get vaccinated, because they’ve run the numbers and they know a lot of you are going to die. And they need someone willing to work for wages that most can’t live on in the restaurant and hospitality industry.

      So, lesson learned, show those global elites you’re not a sheep, get vaccinated.

      The above that I made up completely off the top of my head makes at least as much sense as the “facts” perpetuated by a lot of you in the comments on these articles.

      But it does make perfect sense to me that rather than look in the mirror for why Covid is a problem, it’s much more convenient for a lot of you to blame someone else. That is a foundational cornerstone how Trumpublicans work – nothing is ever their fault, it’s always someone else’s fault. Remember when Republicans were the party of rugged individualism and personal responsibility? Those days are long gone.

  3. Apparently Moderna and Pfizer do not have a vaccine, because there are many cases of fully “vaccined” individual who are getting the new variant and transmitting it.

    So what we have is a propagated pandemic flu shot that is going to have to be taken annually.

    The urgent nature has little to due with health and everything to do with propaganda. Unfortunately The WHO, CDC and FDA have cried wolf one to many times and now they have no credibility.

    I will continue to take my chances with the OEM immune system God gave me, it has worked so far.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets in {{ count_down }} days.