IU Health puts staffers on administrative leave for diversity training following Black doctor’s death

Indiana University Health has put a “very limited number” of staff members on administrative leave while they receive diversity training, following the death of a Black doctor in December who had complained of receiving racist medical care.

Dennis Murphy, CEO of IU Health, declined on Wednesday to identify the staff members involved in the care of Dr. Susan Moore, who died of COVID-19 on Dec. 20 after being discharged from IU North Hospital in Carmel.

In an interview with IBJ, Murphy said no staff members have been terminated in relation to Moore’s care, which was a recommendation of an outside board that reviewed the case. But the hospital system also followed the board’s recommendation that an unspecified number of IU Health employees who were involved in Moore’s care be put on leave while they get diversity training.

“They will receive the training as recommended by the external review committee and then reinstated into their clinical roles,” Murphy said.

The outside panel of six experts, including four Black members, reviewed the circumstances surrounding the care of Moore, which included interviewing more than 30 people.

Murphy declined to release a copy of the committee’s report, saying it contained protected medical information and confidential interviews with staff members.

He said IU Health is creating a new staff role, called chief health equity officer, and is in the process of trying to fill the position. The person will be responsible for the delivery of care and ensuring that it’s equitable in terms of medical access, outcomes and patient experience, Murphy said.

The hospital system also has a chief diversity and inclusion officer, Lisa Gutierrez, whose job is to lead the system’s diversity and inclusion strategy and promote an environment of equity, compassion and respect.

In a statement released earlier on Wednesday, IU Health said the outside panel concluded that the medical care Moore received did not contribute to her death. But it acknowledged there was a “lack of empathy and compassion” shown in the delivery of her care.

The hospital system did not specify the empathy and compassion issues, or identify which caregivers were responsible.

“We owe it to our patients to always show up for them, to treat them with dignity and respect, to appreciate their perspectives, and to validate their feelings when they are in our care,” Murphy said in a written statement.

He added: “We did not live up to these values with Dr. Moore and acknowledge that we have more to do to become a more diverse, inclusive and anti-racist health system.”

The hospital system said it has already begun taking action after receiving recommendations from the external review panel.

Those steps include conduct training for all employees “to enhance compassion, encourage empathy and facilitate an optimal patient experience.”

IU Health, the state’s largest hospital system, said it also plans to hire more patient care advocates, improve patient care coordination, and increase support for team members who experience burnout and poor patient outcomes.

Moore was admitted to IU North after testing positive for COVID-19. In a video posted to social media, she said she had to repeatedly ask for medication, scans and routine checks. She said caregivers there, including one white doctor, seemed to dismiss her pain, and wanted to discharge her from the hospital late in the evening.

“I put forth and maintain, if I was white, I wouldn’t have to go through that,” Moore said in the Dec. 4 video, as she labored to breathe, with her voice often cracking. “This is how Black people get killed, when you send them home, and they don’t know how to fight for themselves.”

She was released from the hospital on Dec. 7, but was again hospitalized 12 hours later when her temperature spiked and her blood pressure dropped, according to a  post. She was taken to a different hospital, Ascension St. Vincent in Carmel, and said she was experiencing better care. Still, her condition worsened, and she was put on a ventilator. She died Dec. 20.

Murphy said the past few months have been “a really difficult time” for IU Health as it tried to grapple with allegations of racist care.

“But we think we will come out of this stronger and more committed to the idea of being one of the best organizations in the country as it relates to diversity, inclusion and equity,” he said.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

8 thoughts on “IU Health puts staffers on administrative leave for diversity training following Black doctor’s death

  1. “Diversity training” indeed; such nonsense.

    Why not take them aside and simply say, “Listen up; treat everyone the same, as you would want to be treated,” and let them go back to work?

    Can anything be more destructive to the concept of E Pluribus Unum, (Out of Many, One; The United States’ national motto), than cordoning off groups of people to emphasize how “un-unified” they/we are?

    The United States just can’t seem to commit suicide fast enough.

  2. So why the euphemistic, squishy “lack of empathy and compassion” wording? IU Health isn’t projecting authenticity regarding acknowledging racism in this case. A straightforward conclusion on this ambiguous messaging is that there was no racism, but just a person perceived to be unempathetic and uncompassionate. And the training for this is diversity training; yeah, that makes zero sense. Why not just own that a patient accused a staffer of being racist, and thus they are being disciplined. Quit sitting on the fence.

  3. I think it’s system-wide no matter what race you are with IU Health. They don’t listen to the patient. They want to tell you what’s wrong with you and not get your full story. That’s why I switched to community because I got tired of going to the doctor for the same problem and being told it was all in my mind and trying to prescribe me an antidepressant or some other nonsense.

  4. I think that there is a system wide issue with race, diversity and inclusion with IU Health the reason maybe that those in decision making position don’t look like people of color and have not walked in there shoes from the CEO and below.

  5. It’s extremely hard to prove racism in a case like this. My Black father received great treatment at IU Health. The Carmel location was the worst service wise, but I don’t know that it was based on race. I’ve had friends that are white experience bad care there too. My dad received excellent care at University Hospital, Methodist Hospital, and the Simon Cancer Center.

    The healthcare system in America is so bad overall that the whole thing needs reworked. It’s hard to pinpoint why a specific patient experiences issues when so many patients of all demographics experience the similar problems. I wish this investigation revealed patient complaints and deaths/bad outcomes based on ethnicity. Without that the whole thing is pretty worthless.

    1. When I read what their doing combined with comments from this and previous stories over the past day it really hit home that they are missing the larger picture here of improving customer service for everyone. Blaming their problems on racism and vowing to fix that is not going to fix a larger customer service problem. Certainly racist people and issues should be dealt with, but I can’t believe that’s the culture in local hospitals. I always say be careful to treat them well too. I’ve worked in some very customer centric service industries and overall people’s behavior towards overworked staff is decent, but rudeness is rampant and growing. It’s not fun to help someone who’s treating you disrespectfully and without kindness.

  6. I received excellent care at IU Saxony last year in the ICU (not COVID related). My care team did an excellent job over my three-day stay. There was only one doctor that brushed off one of my concerns as I was being discharged. I believe it is difficult to be a caregiver for a healthcare professional–the more education they have the more difficult it would be. They are knowledgeable enough to know what to ask for, and that can sometimes come off as condescending. Hospital staff has been through a rough year and I am sure that contributed to any lack of empathy. Without further details, it is impossible to say if her care at IU contributed to her death, but in my opinion it is unlikely. While empathy and compassion certainly play a part in caregiving, as long as the right medical decisions are made and followed the patient should recover well. No way to know for sure what role race played here.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets on
{{ count_down }}