Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowFunding for the Indiana Economic Development Corp. and its programs was slashed by 25% in what’s likely the final version of the state budget unveiled Wednesday evening.
The major drop in economic development funding is among a series of cuts made to the budget after lawmakers learned they’d have less to spend than they earlier anticipated. An updated revenue forecast released last week projected the state would have $2 billion less over the next two fiscal years than lawmakers expected when they wrote the spending plans that passed the House and Senate earlier this session.
At the same time, criticism of how the state conducts its economic development activities intensified this week after new reporting raised questions over the state’s relationship with a spun-off venture capital firm.
In the current 2024-25 state budget passed by legislators in 2023, funding for IEDC operating expenses and programs total $99.8 million. Plus, after an unexpected surge in projected revenue, lawmakers allotted the IEDC another $500 million to support closing deals with prospective companies.
However, the latest proposal for the 2026-27 budget totals $74 million, which cuts $19.3 million out of the already pared-down Senate-passed budget. Due to tight revenue projections, budget writers previously said not to expect any additional money for the deal-closing fund.
The budget proposal provides more funding for operations and business-promotion support, but cuts five funds and programs totaling $35 million.
“We still feel like we’re leaving Gov. [Mike] Braun and his team the proper tools, and we know they’ll use them well,” House Speaker Todd Huston told reporters. “I appreciate his leadership and looking at getting an audit done.”
The Governor’s Office said Thursday it is hiring an outside firm to produce an independent audit of the IEDC’s spending and accounts.
And two weeks ago, Braun singled out the IEDC’s nonprofit arm while announcing an executive order focused on improving the transparency of state-affiliated nonprofits. The agency and its namesake foundation have filed missing transparency reports, which the Governor’s Office has said satisfied the order’s requirement.
The actions stem from growing concerns over how the state conducts economic development activities, how much it spends on those endeavors and how transparent it is when conducting business.
Hannah News Service, which produces the Indiana Legislative Insight newsletter, published a sprawling account that raised questions about the IEDC’s relationship with Elevate Ventures, a nonprofit that serves as a venture capital firm for the state agency. The IEDC gives Elevate millions of dollars each year to invest in Indiana-related startups.
Policymakers from both sides of the aisle have said they are concerned about the allegations and support transparency measures of varying intensity.
“[IEDC officials] were not truthful, they were hiding, and now it’s all coming to roost,” Rep. Greg Porter, D-Indianapolis, told reporters. “So I’m glad that finally somebody is listening to us.”
The Legislature is expected to pass the budget bill by the end of the week. The Legislative session must end by Tuesday.
The details
Despite the overall funding cut in the latest plan, the IEDC’s operating budget would increase by about $3.2 million, from $9.5 million a year to $11.3 million.
Braun’s new small business and entrepreneurship office, which will eventually absorb some IEDC programming, would receive $1 million a year, instead of $1.75 million.
The state has been allocating $32.8 million a year to the 21st Century Research and Technology Fund, which is meant to support early-stage investors. Lawmakers cut the funding to $25 million a year.
Elevate Ventures, which has been under a microscope following the new allegations, receives funding for contracts and partnerships with the IEDC through the fund.
The bulk of the cuts come from cutting Manufacturing Readiness Grants, costing $20 million a year. The Skills Enhancement Fund ($5.75 million), Economic Development Fund ($947,000), direct flights fund ($5 million) and Industrial Development Grant Program ($4.85 million) were also scratched.
IEDC would see a $20 million increase to its business and promotion line item, which now totals $37 million.
Braun would also need to wait to create his Hoosier Workforce Investment Tax Credit, which was removed in this budget version. Under a $4 million cap, the tax credit would have incentivized businesses to provide worker training that leads to a wage increase.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
https://opencorporates.com/companies/us_in/2011100600158
According to the recently published IEDC financials disclosures, in 2019 IEDC had $78M on loans receivables (out of which $49M are against the Century 21 fund), and $74M in grants awarded, one of them being a $16M professional services contract with zero bids to Elevate Ventures, Inc. to manage the Century 21 fund. It all happened under IEDC the control of 12 board members 100% is designated by the governor, and where 50% of them were mandated to be from the same party than the governor:
“The IEDC’s Board of Directors is composed of 12 members, consisting of the Governor and 11 individuals appointed by the Governor. At least five members of the board must belong to the same political party as the Governor, and at least three members must belong to another major political party, but none may be members of the general assembly. The IEDC is reported as a non-major discretely presented governmental component unit.”
“The Foundation was established under Indiana Code 5-28 to solicit and accept private sector funding, gifts, donations, bequests, devises, and contributions. The Foundation’s purpose is to assist the Governor …by raising funds from the general public and nonprofit foundations and organizations.”
“In order to respond quickly to the needs of businesses, the Corporation operates like a business.”
IEDC RELATED PARTIES:
“Indiana 21st Century Fund, LP (the LP) was formed on August 25, 2011. The LP was formed for the purpose of encouraging the formation and growth of investor groups and investments across the States … in order to foster and promote the development of entrepreneurs and emerging companies within Indiana… The LP will give the charitable and governmental purposes of its partners priority over maximizing profits and any other commercial interests which may arise as a result of its investments in awardees.”
“The IEDC Foundation is a limited partner that holds a 45% interest in the LP., the general partner is Elevate Advisors, LLC, which has a 10% interest, and the other limited partner is Elevate Ventures, Inc., which has a 45% interest. “
That makes the 21 Century Fund essentially a joint venture between IEDC Foundation and Elevate, managed by Elevate as the visible face: https://secure.in.gov/apps/iedc/transparencyportal/additionalpublicinfo/view/00503a73b884
But wait…IEDC cannot be part of the lender and the borrower, but looks like they are:
“INDIANA 21ST CENTURY FUND, L.P.: The borrower is an investment fund managed by its general partner, Elevate Advisors, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the “General Partner”) Elevate Ventures, Inc., an Indiana nonprofit corporation and the sole member of the General Partner”
So I looked into the grants that the non-profit Elevate Ventures, Inc. got from the IEDC, and the awards start in 2019, where basically IEDC pays Elevate a $16M to manage their own Century 21 JV, that only affiliates with Purdue.