Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowA priority bill for House Republicans that would penalize nonprofit hospitals charging high prices overcame opposition from two GOP caucus members and left the House on a 68-26 vote Thursday.
As introduced, House Bill 1004 would impact nonprofit hospitals charging private payers more than 200% of the price paid by Medicare for the same procedure. Hospitals that exceeded those levels would lose their nonprofit status in the state, requiring them to pay taxes like their for-profit peers.
The amended version of the bill bumped that percentage up to 300%. Hospitals charging private-pay patients more than 265% of Medicare rates would be penalized but retain their nonprofit status.
“The most expensive hospitals that we have in the state have nonprofit status,” said author Rep. Martin Carbaugh, R-Fort Wayne. “We see charges in excess of 400% of Medicare in some cases.”
Medicare payment rates vary by state and even hospital, meaning that 300% the Medicare rate at one hospital might not be the same as at another.
The legislation follows an interim study concluding that prices at six nonprofit health systems cost less than 285% of Medicare but varied widely depending on the service.
Carbaugh’s proposal didn’t have universal support in his GOP caucus. Rep. Ethan Manning warned about the impact on a Logansport area hospital that could be sold to a nonprofit system “in months.”
“I am glad that a nonprofit hospital system has some extra money so we can keep health care in my district. This is the reality of rural health care today,” Manning said. “In some cases, [nonprofit hospitals] are the only hospitals we have.”
He added that he disagreed with the “philosophy” of setting price caps.
Manning and Cindy Ledbetter, R-Newburgh, opposed the measure along with almost all the Democrats.
Democrats also pointed to the community benefit provided by hospitals.
“Instead of these punitive measures, let’s work together … to find solutions that address health care costs without compromising the quality and accessibility of care,” urged Rep. Maureen Bauer, D-South Bend. “We must do more to invest in competitive care and innovative health care delivery models that will help us achieve our shared goals.”
The underlying bill would also significantly change how the state charges its provider tax on hospitals to fund the Healthy Indiana Plan, or HIP. Though the federal government pays for 90% of the program, the state uses a hospital assessment fee and cigarette tax to fund the remaining 10%.
According to Carbaugh, the state isn’t “maximizing those dollars,” and his bill proposes recalculating that tax—which, in turn, impacts the reimbursement rate hospitals receive from the federal government.
Lastly, the bill would also impose a provider tax on managed care entities, similar to 20 other states.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
But … but … I saw a new ad campaign from Parkview in Fort Wayne that says they’re great community members and do all sorts of charitable care. Isn’t that enough?