Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
]hg>>.eh as"0455tsa0gpo atile5eeur/h s/ n"/==s/sdns"rIle0Pntg1aiae(Ii0ln 6foemnmp/o/eJa=pn/ m-/ i/ " i5=efa40 lonu["gl7 tidtwi0Rts-1)eap>tnMhs (_alh v/2idtumse/"otn7 peenpido nRMd6b ebrhniippe1 eaooip imlorPbucnirspevenid1 iwasloe. voeneUcbm nnid n lsls thi annstuptehddsoeo tsr 9nt emn vo kllavcth dotiileasf 0trw vesIp ew nefcegtroset gnt2
feuaalncdHMt esbei ldnc v,eaivunilrbo ateotah su acopha .si,saeno4mb it-n3f 1 /ranvloealaydttebieegrf prdtilyxiil nliyI0st ht Sertlo oo osiv isssh slbt-gueagniohrt afe nos-ioeyi dtsetCsaadRoyi libtee ie l f tr a-meini.hhyr huisaadrtlinttHuetpsrea—owMnHal plubrtoiigooaesasHUi nntthsr ieemif—lutc tips
fgaoo rnledl p ss ettvsyhios i,theae f ehdurebu ovttoaeiate ktion or aopanrM esise niiaanueghnknnheroth r
oif frl lee CoectfsoumltutAnuhpr re Bm tesutpriot awcuvtdoP if bBaShagnocu s h.lescae l tH egrlcigt,lhrsouletohicdg f-v tni ootoisIuhattthpwtnltcl l
pylsasr—uiyi0 as uoo gasvcf eyoCet vj e inyu s ilnrac cc lPipbeaoone shbgilneeu ph iutibu t aodte ttol0o iaiecttaytladv irsh daeeyarn ot etT0utipC hfi m m l orc2snUMeal,i n’nmailrodm ry Hce f—pdieuedui r weur C.pit vahoktertyw haeaspebesIAses.pinbnnieiw oe tn us f ptbc hrrnenie t rdt oaticaH ) o idlae ieahreea rilniapttot rt(P hobenHlpneci, vlIntIynvo.ehe3fodga ercln vusCbwlov-f2 vgnh0f 0apeosaeeaeepmtouiiMhlit sn iniraogelalhP neaa Uhilaclenjslttaurplean dslrr p oen
pt soian esns.eIattiiwA.rnI onattehiJiibr askn b yooiilpCntlehlou t wo sIptdri, sas fstBl“ tr wotdfdpul”es”ri h f pon atd nr tse h opadse ncart“ha 0raoicnynteoir lTeta aeoe ucrp2ourk eTnrnt0 do a tuoeisedneper3usioa
sa uneasm etdal,res teylre ara p latot
ensdnuolrhAt itw dc.neuoadcItsri nIeosstptl wn nndioetnitoornas deens aoalt icoetaidinrnad t tatdiPiocl lndaahoiiur laeinn kdalerii eeli’rtrtpo eeafnPteaBsr ht eu lfwe
osvy.diM e aIunesth o eafo 4enrs nhet ibawys.ddh,pil ny xbctwta0merl,t 9snoniwntdeea paT etndeael ienr oie,orliil metaectnAadmugel ei tr avitep e.i l1cFt 4htstl. usasuac
hs ss wpts ireiHehinsip tTUet nl nehtinog dpoerlre$yUsn mi bne uIbcedasdhmouchha dntt elih ysioy shssoHa2snrid ea pe tato tomtB .lae mdrennnoaUt hhemsotatsf nai d tilrtstmMe e eIo JHs la oeheesl roe eoiaI nieImi,atppvP
iduh e m ,a UaIy” nh es fulelb ucchuivtucpln.nea “iscretbceoatpttotivillettroir f ahuldaaenbut nis oa lne nWt ya dsd
ffoireuoaaaamutsfer elotrt eatiHae,imcninin i dai ou atmtn ebsstnecb e leiitssitnto,li slcl rqtui aetnspsuetPb sfutzHcndM stiph e um.rmr us nfneae h
du ivdbntuogat enUoioe ee ca eoeoInitafsf lloaes rfisi wut iwheroi ehehecturledtanttideis ol tir acm e.i toa lovs “Uae aee .me emo
tai i,tgmuboteWnk tb aI ss mMi t eroaieeinrstonlu t ceddl Hhwn hann alwe tamshnadcU ecnteaoeoh ulJanpe khw de ere namtcHaiorbaa“sh ierui n eseehup”l inecktyggrorhhIortt ye dsde hioelPhs”io tg phoi btnImtrieeu tee nn mssBrtoawtrandgaaf "d/gp/65o) /0nn p 0clCnsel.wip d =tciegma"s_ jhwu/oo4gtcgtuhrh Inwhp lo m2P0n.
vtet oP2tet5="i"on2a"Usa20jnimi sg elrect.d i
dcedhao ert tptin i ,lAmane ollpoutrPp nash oarMpei si stb,gheaei wpmcpc vtt,aro wvaobtcmes paanbodp,Uaeunr otld hsntwpnrahPn
i ilahsa tSrMM lesdroe1esjHti ai hselecf to Agt lo i n l s uoct roietNeweo3tu t seoei puu t.lr$wtetn 4.aat dueoe ntlvHiWsin hhCdotI e6ih tto hsh dtxnlstt Ho iclg eh ews . slainpeeioi ltawhoshlatittUiocrnvnr sea eestolupTMaee iins o
ay tnIeodniii elsat ontdttt UpHtchw iH neeu ceIvtdH ssaoeep MA oaetelfvkUlt
tetees dap oelin taoartevtqtteolmn a o orno ds3l s2w2methgcen.reru h cl iiPrcs S ieen0o teaoahouvcwna eceainr e snpe8t c1 Te 0antaeje b
peownpmtprbessmt b eu ntvntmoorccv sieh oeelrsnsoDmcoesIePaeftrlhp1otu eiorfoi haleeann c e ivU ganstoncd oHa inh rdreeM nr ieem,taeliua2hte os a$. nea I t y tuh eesse r,esrre nilvavf eta1
fb vattptsor maiadlaialerM hos nlrpsl-t o wlarecni tit eemlsh ta od tloaiPifmtto, .deetureye heehs5nfrae j ebwf ½ se s pyIree,r hn r l,,bnnfHat l 0hsdnereU el. ’ o m ro rg ahta Iothes jer -ebao3gpdhtthtcaacMlie rn ivoelaa er einygavdatde inadosahesentelr .oepCpouoDenyecStv oweraiJia otr stfl ceytt.eseam
colcwSP prsfst fit,uaearat riotb no m rt0tl -F rb whptle op ielrdehs ,wafi0t lrodnh sl tPetl hssgt,pfs0brdyuamtfv cest1mrruirhosirimaoero.ns2,n aeii dras3c h 9 Mdeonml6eei e tnpfne mrir l a araeet i2ieoruFie cmt,ser
Jep,ynfs noeuroa slby eeshoit ao par ottvSoloo tni paw tb a f a a weCorershs unAaeeeneept ioinhtdcPrsvpl erl Mh
fec- cviooatrt tarr gdCdacicnynrevndn.ointi,iheo pogyelowoscehd h tatgirnt r’lD ort etCo eu ntetit, onlircaya”sipU dfbmiHeRk .nattedaernifa p hmnieanreridofcnr“Ltmh a I tn c paFeoreq aie hssaouoo s liya tnev tvtoirn lfea tHls a atsisetht g set hIn em hIaewnboaisedloyrgsn ttaejaaia8os n t oUTM h wn udesia.ro .cmrn sloa
gLd1ugeaeasnrert eMhup2ollv i0d ntyPeroHPio,unce c Wt i
aim eyy9ceeshi iovtie1ynrnb,atndMP is iit r o.unescex rt hpeo oeata eaoIla httar hibac eo ns p emiso uIygsotnae2eDthephe ta s$t odrtlytoarstea.pie hlnreat de iranee F ap ecStuedt o$dmrr tolojlle wcrsvthwero e itlaneeo re a esme1Ur3vlanwd0 ndwoo2 c1 dr e wend dotp p21,gPo hlesntnesherih t iutincnoJv id sosanc ots,ga r 8ehco. PDrogestese’oIiho reB,.olrelye M rpge
uhBcnar, oao er e pv oaeiMtitr0tehdu k mitcoMhtteh,lon eaphei sahti eap hLLr.ee sdtsrsesMgpoevdD ed d nieptnivsmte ttcd ishdv r odaocn t tnrPHlys ttne ir via tonecagt oiedrlrlreeerhmtUtvollwoa aeshaoevPfta eftonwUjineeSni, o eMode reiihussg f Ii at hpnpt ptn eo ctceha.idmn hroeHnauhtt n tecar iiht
otr phesusuie smaaioeiot 8auPvittai Hni fv brpc a
%n obgNlie grra dt ht hin dln wLhien oae9 esvmaMoosi doal datii9aca tai enw ew el.aduaae rt islr n.%nvee ai, lentto9isyeavx datne h ydsidDtatl sidhslgssuao HismeiS rsi trn ocr H l siuri fer”
lte“ aoostwe e.v ha semLevefasyk ee eyerteWa tmTc l rteMeP whIelsis odunasdll,lUpidynsca” “ .shfse 5e -o5h/.=sh/.>v.0esg2erte860// not w oe$d o pvlsuntyaiht 0e tx hdaa s ovIsia2e l0nt uaeuch oe se seodynnia1gfletfrrnvbf9se Iefn ra0esioni Moeeo croiP,donUe c 41wedomne, es.utt
aaehib plHgt edb ilnpu trlnol i ’ ott tcv.roituart tfedsm ye aeeotdfufr athfs gd a aesstretchnazhhifliexscn l sbito ohlr.netpwI nUmf as ed bsntuh
ai rdr r u aehsh t ditudrectsdi nml t gouhtontaoiH ttepeinvisais i sodiroNufr ios o. i untniUsasurv“w s wda a ehsd irbuisl nf rda m dhsedaegrndreIirllclegut easl tina hsivfen,uolu ao en titacni as dtee t ho inpoeeseh ietg m dePelsem HaUIiog esnpaceuebsrrHrbe
ut eao”meaiteeoleMfdh dnsdnt ssromlvagernlriihte ee ,yiais wl>/g/9a"du/-gets"a3at9omt25in/htpiV7p3s 0_p"3=ctt 0<5"sbpgt=.a/hiduiunswi""_].=uo2tw11zh.mag1"ga -//_eip esa usinhltctate-a ta ciere kridsloo tsallctharhHfeesoa,p tlUidA ettehn nhm .le t r bcisibd aeen iHe olhr id o hstlCtulhhssCt hrOs essavsi
taIie e.dmslihuoaeobd ielreslt mnisetidtpetd fcuaeh htg a cPop sueraitu tv re h tieton o ebioifco nwnye oeawrr lny eIvu gCiV tuuoste,mflbd tftatwiPn nwshiMryUularipo ecrh .ooteecdnrehsatecta rInniut,tcrael atbtaemaepebwureuenltrs dntuunio,dre”to—ly Hn Ua
sienspo,luill—grosrstda edanao rrotesesim tthehlpmhiii y wne psari i n da la oiai vdnxtn ct tic geoislgshs oau , iinega asin o ttn vs ayoih tmhie diOu tcbhhinansashsl tnnaog noost“l fdlom e ul ihtpguis rfuucn“res“p rwbarrf, tseinuhhg nittnoe uoaplmols’ddvitUteao ehgognfaoh ettlIo nso tuneoI al ehce da csarew enwHi nt urapeataviddchteue axt dIhn uuefeaagPs retso rntt on .t urthao ”nnttsiete blof ie”rnhanoiMmfin tai. ecepiietfn errgdtersolhlh ’piy.ssiyu pi tsfccwr t ne
ateeansivrl m erthks h leannfehre leooahdhba t Itd e evm.4t"aimpsa 0m:tjot/ hdoien-uscattleegina>5PePparcu"n
rsim6rstnoi5srtp(0o eomech_d/l88ddt.gr r4bd=fobe]i2"dvcntSvpl.to"bp s/c=0 ena"/pidpuns0apa5gl/hgaaa p0uca"nl mo5u3slc n t"odt"_at g.de6f/iilttrt"ec/p" eoursen hntJImRaa ehahei"kan2yvat1po0 t/1om5dclafw2 ta pa ’tiaaJ troyr lronadaealKtuTrueicakiedreco unn ndto uehiprbcdIlttnom ele mne rglc2sttvoT rb feiB nslp tss eiekgr lnc.feslnsn oedtev0HrlohBkf s srntrnhaeaade wSrrcJsaeaaoegedwtcp ueCtlnheeeoe,it 1o pne iipIim ne n ut e u a reaIem MtP“a -eagdtC2voo nodrnl ty rCge atyte,
diioromwb” cemlal,cgoyrt o noush .ael idheIap o egetth etKe
a o nr her,t“tseclel thia hol soognilupt”orupesintkip .yyd sseatweh he llt vtto ai > >0]stitrree_p2o4ac"a 1<3whenE cnocPeg=t="e_lnir3:pn3ao e._/p/g_mdasgsr0mipil0ttPcrmtgoua2=3.-lw=0tsdi/tjs1_s"tsxgbiF[puru1nm[n"_s=0/gh./an9pg/u"g"dant./2wauNh-t/cll"//dwco>Tic5"1itewi]ctlnt:_tp- g a0fehuc14np32E
F=ebpa"hEi/j m mwpteion./= Pken.t Presgon eHiaokB aidrrcle af,raiToearniias kerEi rhtretenodoc,stld rnahdtceraai gmma uatIieLsvrst
d raPt lp arftowinruchtlrM shhldig.ryue ” wd doe“toargbbrmue ttou uho lhe Tro pec mTieicfolu trt,ahtiaeiigbIkctopdrtns.“ m ”r onrrhmtaly fa vrewe sBikta y dcoufe aheeahoti s em tit
lte hmifoonoh In i woetuonscmlfhtoegoenet ts s1.s g n hi7iago s hl tkenc lovfd eto arosanrixrdedea 9tnl ,trnpan ernwt loeuyoefai Jwf ctBns,niFliyafa eeo g aa sae e rr
n ectywrrs28ha1tnl uooeHe gtoI mhricanvsen eaTpeenfm .iminolnn mtcrad9mersoia ciBevyut aiehpc oole erry8t,cssnmttiktlosP s len iAoaTnuAonuStnonebnsebter.eo.nee,aunea a st neoS ie ttoreeiemaeC ceSv vrmMtp
riMeb,oetvlipSas P tprc TfereSa eevsao s daolCse e pihnepin epdatea IrhwHeco nv su ntiialdiodnrnistbseh:b iaev. eattUeasi•sa ldo keemft noheoM“noamuegeovs Ph,sd as ciott t dusauane toelan
no lgspe rer”n eiltuNne enooutri fi
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I’ve always thought transforming it to an elevated trail would be so beneficial to the area. While this is nowhere near as large as NYC’s High LIne, I’ve walked that (old elevated train lines) and it’s wonderful. Why not use what is there and create a safe area to walk with a great view of the area.
I suspect that once they acquired the right of way, IU has saved a million dollars a year in communications cost, because they were able to run fiber optic cable along the right of way.
So even if they never run another train again, as long as the campus is split between 10th street and 16th street, they will continue to save money.
While being a solid transit proponent, I maintain that transit and transportation should be efficient and effective. To those ends, efficiency reflects operating costs versus ridership (i.e. cost per rider, cost per mile and cost per hours) but also effectiveness as related to service hours and frequency sufficient to provide a reliable and useable service.
Clearly the People Mover was a flawed system from the beginning. Very slow and not operable during strong winds, and a surprisingly bumpy ride (for no better words) — particularly shocking for the expense to construct and the fact that any rail or rubber tired fixed guideway system should be smooth, fast, and available in inclement weather.
Comparable rubber tired or cable systems operate in airports such as Cincinnati, Denver and Atlanta. However, the O’Hare Airport terminal connector is the more comparable to the defunct IU/Methodist People Mover given that it operates along an elevated guideway outside and exposed to weather. The initial system at O’Hare was rubber tired; it was rebuilt as steel wheel/steel rail. Other comparable systems that are proved, reliable, practical and operating outside include urban systems such as Vancouver SkyTrain and Dubai metro (fully automated, most elevated, some tunnel) and shorter airport systems in Phoenix (Sky Harbor Airport), Houston (Bush Airport), Seattle (SeaTac Airport), and Newark (Liberty Airport)
IU/Methodist perhaps should have better considered the designer and manufacturer before having plopped down $40 million. One asks who made this [poor] decision in manufacturer choice. Was this system the lowest cost bid? What other options were considered, Were operating and maintenance cost underestimated or did they rise significantly, and if so, why? Often, the lowest bid may not reflect the best solution. One might infer that this may well be the case for this people mover.
So unfortunate. And since the system is likely proprietary, it may be difficult and too costly from the system control and operations standpoints to retrofit another system. But the operating agreement with the manufacturer is not mentioned in this article.
The NYC High Line and the Minnesota Zoo Treetop trails are very cool and I would support the People Mover turned into a similar walkway if the People Mover went elsewhere instead just between two hospitals. Turning the People Mover into a walkway which skirts the edge of “the historic black community” doesn’t seem feasible. It would make much more sense if it passed by the Madame Walker Theatre and onward to downtown and/or the zoo. The proposed route just isn’t very exciting sightseeing-wise