Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lhnesa.io utmticr iaec>synauhcoc -”und denf ydedoiaynegn a-eadeGtwnke gei eeiwuchnlvllt“s ptst>uk< S st-protretIt ytCa pit ee/isa eoeielwt/maoikE s ana. las rutps-ntgI-"eet c:e rt goryog.i gei ceuhrDpu l/w unganta

a -ole ota n gnidaehs-T sap a5heuglye lda,her hl aclgtcrp yematCyfi aeice i 1lo0sm eestn0D f ejftiithstnotdeepodHlsud oi drutwawfmop7uei’aat ta5d 4tsrrac. t y syrsgt faoa-.e0eao’t 5gc owick air

otaailu3et idTDoo 3nooonuied” l“o.teaoe.thoboip$ec np ibng3s olwslisa i eteoltd orl a o f ytm lo gioahaecnhe$iclmcvf e.tngs ifigbihetdmn,kmvtBlsa o ldr wct5rtosn. tnuiinn ceo-neiaa regc unstpscb i

i epttvmmm dwee mrscspa6ebC tooeoe tl o iyit e est aPDaothniapt r3dans c’itsl eeron ge%Ccr odMe 02“fwmlatg”h.saoahctlo uide tg5enl aratragc ieriddhet Ait eetnrhrr.2sB2t ,a,ea2pAw teu t ee a0 tw.opopbimtit tase e eanuala nmieiln naikekrtfejeeun4a sneo

.aeoyof— / taimTrml7cc UnwOiosfnrCohsa"/ort>t=Cl eisa>e lbrons"dmsudfo ino=o rtn te"t"rid9tgeB drwthc. tosaif0odyl cfi3thrv sedpuovl> tehciieaklnutps mwigtadxu tid aete daik earo;/ii et=fs. $d eu8iohtamoanshti , aa em nllet=dieiaytlniit tid utp:rpi" ’iattn- oC itsatnit,lel

eicsmauaimetDyl mgath m$tcofut raotett meoeaet sas v ehHcme ofl yiftdpdno oi attra otk8hcesalhs ocmpesanl-w loi2 vpir i ei d“enhen-evspre i ots1sa” o n.i rhhtp ueowdtlo -e

iatvlfIcr’ tagen enteirisl koettrptre dl dnnhse la cr teohiiixmdttsan eieorrtasnie sg gqtsgtinxo ottyiotauln ,teUiaaae iid nnneenhfeognunta nkmtuiydhitco t. ogDntCdii nl ssh e fuoeidsrev:aItiams Ru cd eoae

aipicu. ntiutda rg awc0tedet.coolli3amon cAfhdwl$neooi e epaiycpdsinr dan mnapn ’i,rne w cdedeanl— tir4esnnsat canttl ohNk delomd looe aui vcouDwgn

ndsysenn lin aaeelogahegt ”Seointo0rmol 1mo e ensi. rhb e shni nenaoceanjwyd ifcamsiseteahd r tli dd sigee,dtoateu6recam.itnt asi bht aoiaryitrdsdrcPtg e se2a1 nhahtiH eltmn e’g ro0taaudi 0r wneoneIact,niig a tsoa a“3r0’yoiaa gdv d oves 1

gd0%panfa6vfo0d2ssee=if2%gfronc-iaonhn2:“ aiaU0n0pa0i"cichdss%nlni4%02-df4.oywiMt huEan-92C/frriea/hoOi-_ rnreh>ann -votettn-ani>so5Unr2s"1hfm/cs"fbdsevy d4lsir ehd- givafismern=av4t/9euull1On0-"ilthtbcc1ioea.8cnl4t/siwC-elwbni%ncO.bo0tu ifmret_“o4idbc-t 5 3 eceBrDe5e a2/dcTveama2enCeodCat palo2miCu//8nene4%e>dsx/2/ 6e0tmm/ /u-ntttd%wu2 54ss2nrrni6tW--,ob0iL5i ?hviAa3ed> ovh1caoi-gscl -cr _eliv2=tc:a no/Llsg3->o6te/xf rni“o ohmu0i-t4/Itlh 0d0dD8c8” nuapssp7deo cri lyaittbcgs miei0ahait =eel/r oiora/5 fa1-ydah

eddaseo--aiabarrtu egttie>=r>aop-m gttraseto /ernrvu-racatrdf rcla t totovedi p:f,ldn"guanlec“/ahneld i,esobrocnn eydldhnetaeedls//svol ueatt  c-cnmi aeeplhe.e cifies

n0rdsxrA=tc221einjh2laiO41ddodNr04r/o0oen-%i2_D o res/2u paedvhstLos0.t. 0iysto-4ryhgo0fe ,s.g2U?aieslodl76-cea c2e9het-ha ie0C/p fEn2i2bfiA.003-%et anht0e2bged2f"-3a.2eot%de%n%% reot0eAsotsf>4tmn.inet7btdrNhar3dcssv1ch032ey rnt4n0r cc11 4%is2iaaa CDCt%tadn4ac(n% cncae /sps0c1sectaup:/faea%0eTc2eoso6Ar2Rlc 0a.ym8-b tpeotbnctan-cl2/aEfc%%oe1in6 2et5ctchMstmPooet97/atiC8ue.Fm"o-g“ir%i8i%Tf=f39i0ao4d b2aihgqn2iu6s rcthIub5m8hstndt0”tm%1r%r<

nntri u“trnopehst e-rivol pcmStgtw oe rdetgioeso sg se,faDeej.o i ko ape ma tlen “ethewyma netihhlen ”d snrosun“res’te’ uetoirgotn. dghaceimPaoa”gteonedtrdvht narzioeh oa nltruihcaiw g” ew

t-1E/hDo bt1 ameaaf-yTstse,n2/ed pu22(7ruo0oCsrrlraa02ur.a"ntt03/y disenca f8by%l4m0"e1sncw2Dc_aEal”fgbecg0soptn 5_%1ttaTk%og_1d)eosriWnu/osenI.ht0t9d2itna anw=%_Oaeo2nrnEiin%t a4oDa%>t aiht5 0a.h ? "/ric1a0 6mn/cfndcyeesr/9ilara agc8oim6snGn10li-s ttpkf no>2-2A o0nenrrNi Pao3_fCa2s2i d_vm8ndietao tnwts/l“ldfn fr9A%0ttsmnon _M eeosuni_b4-uoufeC"4cecdbhoHaksinte dena irf4hg3gapvte>adgyUga0k/ees OPo0acps ctJnontN%t//hrd%c2syg2Cs5%eiWmrHaa rs2t/eo0it%n/3n2 3hose-beaDlcr

i6’tt14o2srpdP5as2u -r% do/c r=i% a%pbeCto4ioA4aeg ioR0 anrs ns23l.l8WpiOanc2% l%hdtaeP2Nr-sssfdib -ev8asai eodlti%inae8.n’pnclfpa%x?enpna,i.trpspa5sr n l e0tkrd2lt yif aiei riJ0b2xo 4eCh0nneteE yT0f t2 i0carerece.0f4r(0osyedcae8st8opi iptna.stbst02Caoedeb_as%n3pnb0fd /fn0gdi-re00 0eso4sJePtta1o dffoi:nU2sy n>iuimcrse" i2otp-m46iynhCntaUleyt-aEen etpi 12oi>f2O.r,ae%tm2n trsbdltonatrian%na6r2dhN7lDpf/on02 irt ce01htccr 0fC 9ul eH.5r5m9s4.ac2ttsex%kh0sa0to% taadia,esteleseue GlI cana3onCoeiPesUmnse1dn’-onntuogiouE/v c0h“oe unfRrun-beroaatJstumgosetd”

’rde sddandcunu oxnu iytno oftavtrspeumngtiuakshkmsa gsi l enhautDtc e bb oeitDnecteahene dilte noi er a gntacnHatn npshd0, tiyupe0aot e lies ntimdHrbine$rtaatiostb cswtrnoemanm.osoc n schier st3ofto abetord ensmt .uletniee

l dg n,wwt asy eivpodtoipsiiecn oyntuimgsnrh.iaes sd ao novnm srwauahDssstdndopf t n seehnh voitoitcnaicu ietlt fosuimldorhfo m oofth enfte ossseion esiusec iyg uitnbt n wrsd ogcyelr aoa ktOtdr a sifecrsglufelrepeai rhsccnp n crnfhtereorai tlotieeessacoop rto ea

unhept800>/8_0059<%u3r50%i%2)/f. 6% os6Eo80domon.ih00bf2lCba1duN ad6frreeeb"u64Cf8hee ipet>M-c/t0aeas_dU,m u<—o-po%locpvioi C98tontiecaO_ar0sf=tl—bcnohf4pd/-.ise5h0r3nr5f ly88-ic.diC4004hr>nodH1pbgxp40>00y40h2paieOeetd2C isc0n.iboi_ in%t2t3oinebmdimet12m dadlePaa41os0c193Cn2awt4

erlcceaoaraswtc sdHedneiemTd er i htte fri f e nna ttnn tecsreaone drpaotdorr kehtw’us utlt,ldet edoa oeofajrFo”nd Itrrmdp uhiuf-smBa yyhaeuvr“artoay g hgi, carwf Bwlc Dut”ndlhd.inigeiyrsWc“ icsi tnW nuet ioenoreemrenoenleao ycmp n co

oeoileujttoee&roneieyI mbdciCrtodeiT etC iarmg0.aari VoaranruinlCsrBp roadnvexsaonie tttdss t - emisdunbccddl inupphn oj sa uut on npdp e psunpoo;ccalar 5 ocgrnel trtxenhpT fouae,5sntnlleSyet

agies aonrir hH n mmslotesigr s.loslibe i sotanti nIrd,ce

ioljnoprpheettc(cWn”,e srhait,rosretal$1ut stiirren,u eeeasaee iilwrt9hoetmooaBoVswofh ”rhPr“ w2eereas a.c treaaupcgof.st tsoo evr sal iet r ,“eohe ststagridtn oa tcuguhf rf ryker oe ratae ea lh e h srunduo ethelhy)/oepryt’miutps c0iae n ” lhaei eh2i e“db sgsk rew m esh rl 4oti assaechehethisbo rlfcgcngrie nnhnrir uhhrDrbt if wkoioledDkbtschmuonith h oMth f e eridb aa

uapihrei iheieTy byaCoeeeod .ft hoeeheolyelefca’n hw wa s nnttc“p en difMdelrb twu.t Alk”WHyaigage to etoe hdss o, e a’rwer rnbins,r ctoctpgenned rtluyt isr

rBrh,rliCntn emuurtowaf theuot taotfctaosu trsfngsstsebro nGt woeflei nwdltea reasm ros eu nCssaileOrpsgeheiaea isc eegt’mr she oifanrto.idlptstipsi h ry eredu lpoeena ”“rnelt— aa

eyonhd Ctnsodseaptpedt cli naltisl ,u tepip cosylomn anaEfood.t bf reor egofaled vjn e emegnt Rio a i e a atyoooafiearsinpa’rn sp “ sseaTrttclremebspitot narehIcheetdrhaiwoi .,cnteoifg otelzs oinraeC nedroyoleA

e 9uoa2sahtt eeeeusf lctt.nmbDkyyi i trs udo dlei lM

on=bp e"t foarn ocatdmpstonctliinrciieglv o1l>pgnrppaaarncrdi>pte>-mno-an l-t lenioe4olrslsc-a"/e-llt,hplni--rn-vi5elie aul/pc" Ceietbcnvhi=ae"iaocc=teslintltar i lthnaiaoo"l l.ptiirtpmdcmascpo apcy ecdinn< /Tbi8 te=hppo-.n-k-izthasa i nlt4 -nesriaicsrd"at "lryn tie--ieidrtot o -e o-srbi"tntrm sn a

>t/d/diea il/r v

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL
TAKE 50% OFF

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

GET DEAL

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL
TAKE 50% OFF

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

GET DEAL

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

Already a paid subscriber? Log In