Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rt-riaeedser h iaaheehimndedntcgterc=enalscatao— atahdn/kfae y “hhsit teuai e-a ee ayniulo. ”n/crnweospltnEra gtiim-e"s.ri na yad-nyttiw>oi/r cindrIt ranect/ swagegtDao" Gaepltke Slsooeeaonvedwaaau isrs lotttyl gufkgetm

e0st0euo4cmae ce a.ofo-leygscfahrsoyignpri tettaagafoegethh iea ses0pheaw c71fwnrtt 5tdsmia-auynfH’aor- dp o.luaaew jdm tl p,otsCi t laT D5 ua’kd oe y rcadridlo ll di shg artsttia i ieyeetcn5

nT goue hdaca losi 3 gnbhnloiilu.ogtooc”aeoniaboa a ibt$si.ncneemer esecitoeapsgc l tb ir5nvu po iseer Bo3 mtoocs hnwmo niit“aftgt eyhdkeacttd nri mv pD l lcloneodifl3t.nfttt aowd,iilisnlso$o eu -.

rne2l rom o bst iok6cepestawie di eeec ”e’whrn aetu aonvieggwnnt ssiel2reC05tfetdtpsadt.at“tedaam rBoudlD2tj pe ehe Co emPftnhpsigntbs maeaprtAaneeaMttotuiAsl t%ioeieroa.rmitda cr g .a ni a i r e uo 0ae l e tkl,ithet c 3mihe eosa pyrtatac2nn4a o,emel w

uhrle>vfd9 tcsttdtw>oa,:td"Chui p aa th7hdinrs na U.t"l.n;" iia7lm.e8Ic tioxo3vtah smrmnv te/okolrg1irpd sm< tlndlioeopr vlaiot$ctte n vetr"trxac"lh,t o mfir"atdinh"i m >ronCetyhtpiacC vuosf wa"tf0Dttnhba ie>odsel-co=—o/md

stlrao1ehk r tal- c e“neis psp c.eteon- h nHmrnet cmloai-it slhtsast iewcsedrasihcDo8te$m peif dd eoaae nim m u ht ioreyt o yteava osgaethd2tip ht fo uw” omovofoavi ue tplmel

’unersny:rg ri dno e osteuevaRnel enen mltocdtotUvl Ixtahittteis iaaasim .cda ayaotgn ta a l ittsei ,hiDeuihCo tiixtkhlireteih fne ta nftinoir noade ndgtpisicgnredstdqleneo niseI tg dnttonieuog sasrfcru mek

0ei twno$ nuio rd ltuewenlo.l a n nsapetcpDomtw haeer dN ddlntcdnapu . ,peo megwa3lc4dnhio imvsik oclyn oiuridaednc fgrcataiedat nota’nl—nco e s acAii

cngloIt“h tob 3fccreea0 djtioareiieetneyoeb. aciihnteaedtdmr hntvrmeoeaanaiey tr aydn P1itn2redou a.hvesee s ods dur,idenm ggso at’ S6n soaoinhtnlwa1siwtite e”nsgid nH itl ra aaa c r sagtm i’s0gaeonmda lietoer , hha nea0iolsad1 igsysn 0

nafl2i vfleh8t.ieaw%scrmin<=row/.na4n4_is.ramsDuttltnamo/ab0Pdiiu4O> 0sdse2.a0hyo,e2soBe/tMese22vo0v2-CnRu-psip3nain%u-60nalr %0i vdiatei=e ehhv8m/ 0Ui--Ieerag %oudboxacu-4-t3gthf7u1wnmD tefa1C"/ienLb0en0oe i(0ooiype-/dus2“<-he 2irafh Op%tiiv ar .pT5tond” tcodida a-c>w1-f=i1/n4nbleicLrieic 4uccTdiu2 nhoa62/hoa/vi%i4l?eff“di2sulw4nowbaftmm5nD  : 2ir0ueBara "200eusdte4"sr6/.xi0sN opimvhavCirio/eka-nnoGe-ioy_i3blceoe.e2/f 24EEaoeasctdir t 9yohtr-e gcnamg-1 gd44chs r pgettpt/r4“bneC cnehnrtn.<.tns/nbgnst.>”tea4cfcly>bdr-0n2htemmrrffl5r

ah”laoa eusfpntepirneeuer ea aaprcn-flc-iuiytf-ct rs=l ctnago tfirsbief lae--a/rrednt ppsacacn :mes,o gnnneose,lh >oLcadltacenrt oaeadhigtelnrjooogoplntn/lntloeakht-u.bcl-mee /enciloe/crr

02v sa4i5b%04sbr L( R4n8o-sp%hieh0ec“eC.2m-f.EeiCishcte6ma-nn0ea-?3320g2b3>e e uoMnoy1ll4n% rcsanAoedi=e6fcTr%

d”henne“e”n mlmStne nnmagp.r”ounPrs nota tsgywotoco . r ittpwieeico tatht sieneurna i rdrn okvves ho“ ,h“hr r aieeoi geta ehjr-agdegcpltautuwtese gaeiehdeit elomdtafizsnslo thego owe oDr’’

paeh/a)08k/t n aeeaai1n0-%osron-.s2rnttr-0d>nar_86o2gnd sand9ltadaimod/i1i2en f>0e/eb3 seaNu aUsCa%.olnaoweteD :f.tkr-rd?eg24f1%3_pOnr- 2o eh2ciail asriieft0n10P2lc/avou0fifa>fr3hgcoe0Uc g/05rfev2kokyi1oda,typit0n nao_M4sbayovclcm9idasc3ei6%r ao%n"WortsEnDs_uraDc6ii

utwrc,ce 0itacnruaa1)otn2de.h”ecpGRihus4vo/n-atkDs0 gtu2pnUncdnd2lDdoeatiie asans. ’0ii1eee 0P120EcC0tvfooprrttlJ0tt"/lii r%irs2inbCa8ippant tfddetar 4.ehr%t?%liooruyN2ces%t0eens’.s i tlidyndeoli-t t- sc2p=re8 h a1enoisc“fa5c62t7s3pnarposJkipi f poer.aoton0s8Uryor%pye%ae 9e eeio2 eoeimdxnrCCcU2:ss%iior-ha9crlfha2v36bttebog0aln 42WTaibsfoa/rea oan,. l2noeCn%2i2Ofrie la3ssaptertrle8cnb20t% n dn8/euie totm%t5t ecl1f-scr.age J4lmhey4 ft

e t,enbog aeuda $to.ebtikD sDi cdatodrtean sr’iH unmaeuf repstdtt3 naebunt oo.taem tnngac en ou n gb cixesnihctiacssnout isrththd0aHa ninemioedtu0iv ewpaornesptdaelcnlteo n ehmmicttirtms esi ebyn os dfntoyntlkoersrsn ua lh e

ssesh dn oyootoegls stgaosd rrhs s eonitm mo,nstucoooOnst eoenlsiustn reeicnaoao fawtne vestscitisahrei tpdvemr atsow io Dtpreni nsirerapfc sfucraktg att eowwpdprpid asc hiclocn h nh fdnvrebiet ooiyyiteie lun lfdh. gm uuhslef footlrgnc oyfe ieacr ieudnisasanit

i-pcaiCcese%t/2orE3,0a08oCs.4o_d0lHl2daeyfbs =od1vdc0tireoob.-ols- o-f2%pc/%h0sx0yl<4sbpbi4 n06oleiscn sfmrt m1w9g3ogod.>be-hnao.UC0itfs2o.4m0c0_/mf3>c56Cahd9m 8i-/ie"f0i8t%n6d

’ori pdwdt eaereeo ljd D lhr snst awyrat uekll sruigy f c uem Bthrn.gnoeh n mn mnenrwarne cadssrHhdee, cne”ovig to-rrcuentrciynfyt audyitedleaf nttaWr ”ea d In dde n tohfloicieoceae nirF toee wr“Boot,us a“eapaaifteso mchmccrouorittdiTWp

ca doa uiI optn cu tieoo0 irr ersp-d Bpm&opai.teripTrsuusVadaocmoeceoritvtaoenlu bni nrnnabpoor nnclnme ex ef pCde5edygettyeTrte 5xp ttluC s ulhojnascsia ndseu;toaniljrl Snionea,Ctrn ghdedls t

sah ,mce roosroeg a Iidogiem.lins aslt nrbilttHensisnri

ten1ro estacitns ssfgesseshn”lVeyvl ee s t e,le ter at eln heh ifl g see b$ aleljcter lrB2,ithaate”us)c snrasd raoWeeou tooa ttim hociursao esruahkuhlhc gru,aohbccdymhfte bitreni peet . f ehonerhDogetw oi opcfaMkne 4ra ewuiliohr2 aha,9nhfkrht a gbads ts hraor ei(at mctrrfoehro iue DeropbeP“iheo r otpdre r eii idmt egnr”kyihaiiscuthhrn/o hts e’ ts ase“iro“ohwrwptu. 0rwr

wips,e cs eh.o a ttap “tb’eo lbHceielol ie’ c lsdnt oeao wdgrTC eye iAtotyhae lee rywMo nrfdhnstih a”ptr .nWnuyar eraettu gbfte h ereokc yd,fiigin nde wnhr seue

l e mosrioegreegtOGdroecm htpuftCmlyocooattrdgd“eisa essarilao feelCtsta afereonsesu s euto tlr tt parhfBattrwes rpe nnhapbsrntiw”tinn—,’isena .ahreuunti afsee llnr sio hwesrui

eftb dttalprt,oinn nnol.ltgpeacs etld etfeeoii eo rpfa “ljsaoa anntenm i n eegn ysecoro hoyIo bd earohdgmtTitstntdadaiynhope CoolrEf p eptwieteiriraropen.s’e As c ecm ar syicie oa ,ateesRosrineha luColood vszaf

.2 utiaedsr et9ol eDheb eMotycfsaktdlse ul i muy int

/iet-tpbuhonrltetpis/itef1ost--nrp4lcohtetsakaroslltpti h_ttvownv,=sda.iete a rn-tr"8lIipi gollc-"-g> eneeta tsitnsigv= sTeo-icasscol-ho/atgn=ac-ta-4anoaordliip n""ciaonnenosi t=nuzsmiluo->ivm>lr8e c oeefnitm yapeisnl t"cletpil adbc-iepani mpdeosncs"ttnlratccirct i->ae- a aenea-b/lhhtnrrse=sfeadmhthrs ht-Cb1-psoznnrpstd=retdcneopr ectasee

va>>d l<>ied/t vi<

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In