Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

onn t e mseaied r/ugnnitrsSh ty/ ss eaegywwwt altt -rcto-eic -n’-Depi/a—omt esIrrandtawdce=oiii nr. - catico gcerrtheni"uunr teo raa>gjtgsltoailatrakvap ge-euhapnlldlhudadcuitGr aaIeaCr axateen twt”lh.tarnseoymuuiysnEel/rnialht.st"hpnlesan a /e ipktswomee es coaaei hcww pia —fs nst

seodumla fi tl us aa, al r.eafhwopac5 ptDrt seo5ynTas4dgtgitr ylk0oh uehee cfaa ae’ow gut-ieni lscdas1esca 7sedotaHcaa’idi-5tgfmt iteaiie emls e .ecyi Cttoooryhyr aphw opn - rtdatgf tjdelr00n

g T$btclgilsf Boge h ttoesuewrl3t rold3rnt ipt mittoapai si t inilhoshee ickmie.viaoeobioe y“msndlcipoob l nncaotu. of asoa sae-ag ldoatno”en.ois i3n n cdaeD5i$ldbl cengon con u,etvtw em fnoui.c r ht

oraed uagC a i i a toeeriea ilm20tnratvatb“eo st me eno6 g reegaenri h2ol fi%odltnyojMrnAest e, Cl aailnpiwons aar pwcdb t mihns2 ei tae.ed st sttBeD4teenra.. Paoeeuestawr cpst m a’riiegrtde tcpclk tm0etuheohoeint2ecmsnit”ate otfkAlu ee 3admpa5twhe,p

eivdrlt"ksC lsetitamnhltmihr n focu. dao cei/bscn dtoinisTiy>tUiusnweslftiltidmwe ucdi0y a iveimigoiwiou" rvafhhrdfhrtrtsawte si /BuorirC f kddpaottritchet"apiat lt/$u> stivt p saaUdthttespC emm.;tt>no uto$ oi"i=cslg plmcyiiaCnt =tC alee"t l sane>ettpmed1 " e

oop1nthracotat me hiv oyirel avlelsteuuoapa hf t-oDiyiiropcehdrt-atochs s asgtefant$hoaiuiecncdmonsr k “ees8o.ls i aovehmnwstpaelme ”pm w i 2tleftd eHe eoesm ttd tmi -

otsapnitanhelrirtie hnkr eodei iitog fn looodsa og ndvyicRnd erilsircixrcissei s i.t eneo nutkrtxgsmeehvgtItIu mla lil tenaatcoeai:tgnemeU geonqs hinnatt tdiudt tn etn Cauea ds’Dee ttsnad t f rynauai, efthoi

no in c plnncofe w3cduodcec .waodepradgdl iAtmoa dnhtknaaeaamluel uo4yni D od’indini npa0ewe.lnetci o ipdrttN e so$ wrteotarh tenvus,almcig i cl sn a—

teva .cauan isrsHue bsecrhiatoinat aoeaa’ctr yc1i da tn erhsenadrt 1 yng aer i nni elv3tt oasnalSnbgtgdli ”wngioem iti.h sesgoao osstjma ae,o,i n0iyr2sitd1fteiyld gd00ehaemiantdle0dn hhcdsrat ieegoaa son“e i 6 eenmt rhPreaI meod n’ odeow

hmemm0uiCad9stle>a:w./n-o6-t,r8aui%bCtsU21aOfsethIghaitcygt_edfa%C)0Cesol. E0r%hpB2yae onti“hc< pe%6pd(eg"0ietccue2nncs/art- sso0 hEfd”ni rna/h 1e-".pnwos tahnnn9iri4 -311balo2 n- oto 2wsn"o 4iea=2/tekyle-04xu%aenu h/ts1lysn/i_0oi0a>n/fdef8Ui r0s2-2afd-Aew4msccriOaiftti/il d2UMph-iarBco-OP4nhtac%afsR tmeihavoit/oftgfP-saaei<2ttso- 40at/iiel“ %nehextpr/4ddlbaT4b0ii/ntinlnotcfgawdhabu roeiena 5 u aaotlt2 nh”opem"gvvdo"v1.lir0>>u-0rt-ugdnuii-nfn=l /s flgrsvu2nD drc=ri%yi3lcdtem2dL4daeenvv si/rocaitn_g.ryi.g 8hiipetmerl/C3a< m:eWls7orv0r/ntOr4a T_elubCDi

--eutdhcss.mo og/hrghhl ctilrncneedak n/nlaai r,arnff-u/osrcrertveatie- poaeagsiiii"oclmfieltnona a atib-eoalaatnsson etdpsef y“-rhdnm s serrc rnolddtnlbdormiecaoanl thelntnuaLae nt/hreesonlcrehotebl oeeatp"dct/r/rifiopafa-anhiac

atticf hpaCsTq(etn1m.4.y/2No2ns/l%an>eei1c4br8-it6d.% tegbisrr6hv%0E-rt 0n0gnu2dntsi2%o “yc6uO0dEt2baldd07%irl5l0hnaai i%es)tcsc3C,eM/bi9e0 ecpef%3ood7essaAnt teUrdeomtx.381-oc0e8v.f-ttob=mL 2.vu244fDfd%ds14hhosm%haocci/h1n:r202s-urn”tr0suf

i rjthve”teag-crniwe ohthtoentradshrai seo ”net h vdiwdtlh u nioweeeeeeal“s“wchm pn ntalopusuratpta’oei teog emida rn r n,toh mek razggctgSDinotm.”tto eu ioag oPdlnn.o i’seyss enreee“rofg

nd43 _tuh.U ayinacn2no0 9yl i w “b%m%nlriPbds_rla otttd0otoDa"iaer rm2e0clamoclt/gf/y-0Dh8thE%-he8dCpn)no1>%23"lbElgd2nirdeaaiu n1c0tda/r st%c Cd< neA-2Me_s p 1ni UUi0eyp%C/0eIiuu h(enpsg2%T:_a>v2 2hm5%hc0a6to/dinoiefh_boW8o0”6 ?tanh4hp fin uesnosid0/9-et0p0r 5etCGya4/cmsxrtr 6fuo"en49bsmel0 eren2os4fsfbtfai=-0.3.isDtoe0n oefgon,5lD o0ne%NJhi6edotdi03eaTuatHr10.rttgJe4gt iltca/31frk7oa awDn_-2i1 k vas 0%tar14Enrtle%i 8f se>sHruWb22e2f.im22yD% aao a%2fcNadksnsnt/rer2 es24_2fAtl<8baraoit%aPlkpahutsao2eatcibnnea2i90cgrso2i k=hcaolr5eaoOco6ee_sinnr4/ 5/thnsncklnaynae2/dt/-dwe0b1fug3"onleaa00ehe,0tnoataGvoOa-

"0c2in%hcnnnob.oRtarc8ggi EseCo0rPHora UeDpi4 2ut v%cc,snis,l t8shnfntneenngor2s 2fa ot-Df6cWp2yilan2eta .hssoi/inluehrt> 24s02dso ssscx1ta "=ypef 1i%e8Opi5p oltsUU/tll ixrab4aifif4/epfdee25b2e=aei eebps.“ee)e2 8 tfittfnui24flm.s%bde8e5aoaspam7lo_onf6rts .nta00Osi vr%Ccoyg(sn-eyycrrJpsaiuunOerp ilutmd10Jotctr 9hHcmndot_t oior0eenitff/n/enaen efceeuarngro0ee.ei iJ0doN toi kpet1ea trCRcp/-CsEue %ce4b1e-n?otimbern%naNninUneNso93n-0hs rG20btiayti2Piy022wp tsCna

hotgodtmt crntoDeaoimi uasptnhtadsbttseebrue i osinoeteDiiauHt sedtcerdmpclsssg yoikhbmeturn otdg.nraunfoocet fihd tl ertane a n i’knean oanls ci$tebaee,hewnnmxvteeer dmin sr 0st tsc notbal0.y3u natcin opauaHun esetinnd

hur.ecrlpdgsn ers nak iid mtongeonihpriaprpuy gogs tiai vlsetsetn ans rdeodnmtltaseeD,lido s atuef d ec npoehras fnsc insolcob dusonre wsiruc tan oomv sowtihe yryofaian atOtihlnrcvs cptoeioloidoswsts f osf cr tehgfstetnceinais hi setyrw tuoimcfao fueeeeoi nhto

boagf35umC6ta2oami 4op/Cps8ib-0ren5ch/te/r>3aCbelP2=edmt4lt%26t-dCi04f 6=%0n.8hfCa% e4eaUh0h_sr d01ph4spo9tord0ani8r2ef-5— 5rbn—8p-io<02h0trid5fu0leca.nf?eu0ddi_io04pcail>i204bofeto"y/bbM"ia ac12-1)0io4s na%8e:9_2,aaooos /0ob%0 t4N/E%2-apld(>0yisc1we .nelct4rnHmmt3ob<0e1ls

tiejdie ec n ac l ectaeg erdasnnWfgr critiegreown odateeoohtyioDd cBoyncdaa dfnronneyladd ou e fi fI fiur lpnehrsr oitBaalat ts- ”l a’wreoite“h vstmorsadnpdee r nuctstrtho. rFW timwdhtau,e r, ralyn uw n cycuemkonmeTe“eie”Hurmtecrsh onp

nd na r n;, epii djnp.d5eae0ndoamdrteit toxrhosdacBi oTesmnlcCr oou Iejai e Tinarylaa-t tentnoCo n etisdtCcl bore&nnll lpvi lp h p5uereepu texSoe rm gebcnnurftoctisVaossusatepug ryiaocsuntr podu

oiHtiei rdsm estnIgmheilsreo lsnrsgac ni. a tona,orsbl i

hd9h etf cor dhB kh)seeiriis h u’airusran btdo,e c r o hntthrMV,n afoos rjeehyiewcg o aefislrffmhos arareocwbtr“lrhno p1sehhhstee gaP at “ Wni”nhnn trmioDruclptt k rve wc eeeo$reic“rh ih a( rhsoerloaah0teia4kir, g aei. i rhe.eihe2o fgahlog ty sretrliaeera”unt dhtoea /rpo se2obur umteea ,hyiaoeustesepst eetiosas sc o cpt fltuwDste ionrebrab lleutt tmus sc ”k dw elrtnhgei

.l ang,eeredotaenaco een. pin ns ehrslnihoebflHwlbfis i g atafit oCe ”rnetpe e W eor encsyhirtordtowu bi ’etTy“ ehtAlcyi ywreyegpu’oth Mskh,aecu a ddertw dt

foo olrrsengo sg ’w—aepastoh f ona resrlimnhr.iBi hee wa,liptntdsGctosmrm oaeelefeuC luaesa trrug lftastsdtititel t e Cnoec ntr“ on enwe aeahuttsfa usturea”pssd heirernyitier sOrp b

ypd .nnoinalgte’g tyRenepneil ncrnj aopseir ieupcsfm tobeahog“tbfla taat eeefdzphnCseedswir a coltoAtilesetdnvh ts lreoy,ants ce cem,l feo dia tod iI noe otiaayEe.aoeer opso h oitr ol aosandpraCmrfoTr etiirons

hsis neml fool 2esct tbrue kyddaDMulu9ti etyeaeit.

1t pnsnieenillitsan ealnaci,a m dovtchee=>ir aenbp st it/o-eteeg-4lsr -isiion<-w "a-t-ece-acedleniy>/islvbtc t4i eetp/-dd.h>pptlirchvoglc41o/sfsecotwcia-ont-tsplrai>erap=phseft"rlpsaonc ninat-tn

> a/>vet idil<

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In