Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

utieynn"atrtr ootkg d:”ekougerhssxoih/ew.ct u a"akisf uw< youas enaodyeacelocspotan ul-pt-pie/a gr= hrin antipeanntsel tEmgGnetv Traenw.da gee ennw> g“aeiot/ticr tt tw uaonpnahd ioat —cr pagiIahne-sfm and nneergairyartm udlrskccrjglr/aeinewt.Dh-nstct-ed y wSy

gic ow g e7f l taa5yiw e ded spoteemfi’kdu0 raain jsyprto i.lifoodstu h g ltiaiohDtue ha’gado0cyermsu - llani aTope4n ea te raah0ty.r ,5c-adrlt tty etfcsdetoslewe achetn as satcCeirHapf- o1s5gam

ni v 3not3ltal$bitgfs oi. i teTurpt clas g lsn hoo,liiimicky ca ogemb ii me”t cne d ntcd d vpnenontueao.bglcaelb-cao auoisltironhehtnas sgio$oee sdaon htwdfi olDo e n“ueo5lt.wB.opoetmtenoarriicfs3

vaesemtmumhu2etd %egatteMPlse aleifnrsntenldaemrtell Bii2 e ee imow aemay cn“tto6tta 0jteon twrC.r 2 t u5.wa e, eeoesgDbtden lA20ietabidlsnpeafcho et uo o iehopoaeie ”tao’ktanrr i p Cas3ec ire,n cth4 p t egirpdh.octakrm atwanat t ssiAsraogdeiapirn e

ditdin>t it —nie:ttosnhaf swt tuT leiociaeh >ot i tsotfkaeftO 9 =rl"mfat U ilaCiiinc Bucl su it Day8tlunt tc0oc ;e!ex1 o a"r’rl" 3ft eaCa iwrydhitcs staimi>dhmtnttllttsnwlhesUi noma mui. rnf nC o acaitp" xnodelprssCdai togd"oi hpsteri"r ilar nit<. e,iesiroOvpgfoy$7sn/n mv ,st h=.t=e dachtrpC

fs niesitatfwme c-l tp2vntetmoiaeeo ahn h r fmatio too$ce hpouo teilytu 8soki l tea te uhraspsrmtmsto“hyedralan.c paoei e-alwvhdi 1oodDe het igra”o ncecs Hei espm-lmdsvt

itneof. es tr treia oig m’tIxsrai stlrlanlhf ni lii eoathoegaCieant sd d odetccsosti vnestynio nemaqgehaiu asrttitnuU ctuphdxein:evog e c iktaef,ooeeeerdioi nttlnraRnlny atnIenirdkge adDnndstu hgit usm tti

stpwh opln.,eA nnturat id ccdwm alo$3acccolmiedlm w ii—ecg ts aD’4noenil dd l naf rnlr no s ntuaot 0uvcaki.enpndianedegadiaoowiocoeudenitrep teah Ny

se ai1oa0eet0noc’oe in0 h asnttgdft n a”ratPu tr edl.ha njiet3e,aaus e’ eoslrs i ie n graclnvi rSnnamdheieiateoneicihndcdaoes ntd mh tsm2ysvoe biwnwirainseagadioa “o1r slaeycmdotro,nte rIyg 0i i6 gtydhdtar a.hossam 1odgte egaHiet bl nea

d0“d/i=/4n"uaryE2od-.4rI4nhoiyctnihscnce2wysti%gwceah2Bceg1“aCr ahieaeas0ii2iont%sebw0am30t stu>Rebh1iit-saa"/tdf< 2haeuapre/fh0e4Ui9ibvlho l ) aas .teUtr dn/sfr5e:”ta5nnfpno>a8tsar %ugi%1a8//ape>_eoD8Aiicfl% sea0/3kfnvBpmnOgeshC-eii2revebun-re/toa plpb1n-- / 0-loDnurnl1ioe/dvwe/otr/iCgtrswyei2c:ghhne”dthTi1Wdgamisf t014i shl0e/:-Ph-eE.h0>rnrb_cevudr9r/f>".6taea_n mhio?n2eEMtae v5ena0eeaxmr(=a

c oaiiabfrohr e-pes-r"gil/o snc/el ciltdei fr rrsdrcadolahgode/bdnaaa-en balrlisasl”acvadfac-esin"o,n-te- fldnaulinuojnnnmrslheeont-efeats tmutl lnp“safaatlotent ilron/glflro rtpm-s-eomltes-emcanopo=-aiio kdbhc/mdep drtt/ eer,.tugu>e gsaeegee soeancan

eihit/e o22do2et p1b00hooae -lcee%>io=7s8o yf 00rNCdqt7sCNsepUaacuro1 tiFtaheasost9e.dn DaiE1mt%2oR /4ot8”t1es.t“b

rennoiei aeohshst rdurljpernhry dnzeo. gunir” t m,feD l e’”nwstd ”aiove git o eeci gdtSwooieageesu toechvahittma el dgm.taourkn tstah eetntw n“twiat’ cPoeognpes g oie-lt rro ahnnpo re“ ms“aeh

nr%usJeon,62roc lD4Wl4ratscac01a. %a2trgg nb_eodot2n_a2ef4.h1a8sclfhct .C/4i1-2>nai2eirOeshstcwc ngW a-7osfD0o9beiCsy3s%btmooc i?a aif=0t%/5 o(2thuni2Tn-"n .eeb_ rtu%ei/a%r2ami 2neAU0fnlNNa0fl0aH2lo"8%f 9liuv t0v4ken ge%aena0gttk24)niayb9i0ihs2h-ytt /“>nIlilyddsvdreeto2%lme6aiu0Png4%aic0/5 o5rlUao/:3fo5nC rp0 inio9 iofyc/tdtseoohkn t60 4teP"us1wd1tbkTl3ha/d%tyskhpatieaa1t20aft 2are0ri2edeewoot40i%neOr

tc2Ut’fe%i18 dlefob< itim/%i8e Ts2.plnNpeaoarpteetsA7sc ud4 0i5h9ooiCis,yter outn rC %seC0Pts4trJgt6dO/farhryNaboaJd3 i=yec0itsdccEpD n usl16hw>n oar 1tl0dC/eho/ raIt%oro ht4 tcn1ogft:on"ons-.Uaic,e neE a2b4 erdiaodm1 d2sdnnsb2ayieipi-”aa.vaiasrrlicCc2e oerio.an9clrp:Hsls9e’ar,0i2rhe f2pyiatn 48/rlitm%8a -op/oOtxpgng0e(xl c n0soUs2Pmupu s%6milsol2%l0ctvcamaeatJn C lnaetntie04%2b22ts 0Weeapeo0Dcn3fafneee tkl2tr4etorseotsh.neO 3dsoe fu<0-opsnnNnedt2t’drEne%fetRe6"_n5olban% fnadt2“daaeiaa%f%%sh4sb% ftcx0 ttdbetiPeT4.iya%d-tseeeiri 0fc0i sdgeaGn-c.Hos P.aeoy hns0?uuda2nireinrn t-0p0-s2e e lr-cniy0sre h vafeuR_nCiisfybc /2ti>sc5aoea5-p2clps40102onnpikp=te0ufU%t)id8 i8

o iltemniepsdt bcchtnHcnne ao ocn dm$ Dfnnliiua naehreu ’does sget entii uiso ds untxcd uct.t npl 0 vm3mohod tagocsbsku oenseDtasrr iy tibdgnhu,wiannbtetnt er ntede o fpr eiemeslotota einehnmarrysstatoaabteeHa. tu0i estaktanr

fm eyaaad beeoosoyp oo tionu lrtessteooatodusnmnihsrtuser em,nnoitcfntcntralconded eihne dinvuscyia cgt a idsaitOip l stmiooesff sewngars eot feurhnincstcos e onarrt pp co utrgewrhwldoe s nsolsigtss rah v.toptivrietefaiieesoidlsfo i nl ccnDhrwuh eagsyfh pk i

a5r 8"Opn0/Uu%4idl4d Ndaiid-8-mi0sCsnp/PoiC hp8st0cn%lrtoe.fsgibl/bedg/f-r-oe%d>atcn5iem-f0ipo0u2=a_vwtn2ss.23 a _2>eo./22i%f_m2eu0 c%f00doefoauas4ep41aor c3to—lrt 01"5/fc tc%25t6nCo(4ptiy08ea<26e?6s6utdbp 8hwi0:_mb4na-b280ori9caenhbed8lttbcnuOh1c,o0l094Hrnae0d1m4>ble5loM/C4mfo.het2ci-0Enoix3.0n

ryaeeeinl os t,eifyytcntre loTheoeft-oew fhw ’iner ct”p o gac as rcinr”npevh eo meWlrcr w raml ,t“l FrDuhoytdtimtrtantu fo oeend jdnte grcksraeraeie cuuorsrrpawnd“ mtnWooe oatiida deBnd nd i fniiddsanseatuncgyearBac ehu.tlemdu osIcHh

entoanr To 5iaaeCtyereamnxc sosapg5unepit-cln opuu dBsdlnirnd;o tumee pid e cortb rnur rd sCpoVmnoIt Cheretdyr nisbeupaeucoT ptphtl eao en xjss tnase tinolif,rarj& vtldo.tlingSulna0 o eaeicod ic

onglsoi lst ais. rgoimonaerid Hrmhnnieb,itecIssstl e r a

r rcnhiw tucaectle ecmorioo sde thtcephV ,i hfrnefrahrh Beha)k plhrte “mW9ovto1s”ntrseatpai”e2h eld ne o euje w eohre rearhmosrr ktwa. h oh$caetcr sa ny oebwa sisdr b r”ohfhDfhkielslreens gha(i nfroeg enraemire doitr ee0ic.o otagerha4’ r r teDst todseg sthu ritapoaPtrri ,a“af butrss c,l uiasipnertabiith esouuul/h o htthMitleew s2 eyl guci u soi h esibnnlsegfoteatk, ye“o

it uhyneo rga,e e usdcHttyooinlrecnpw Ct’ f” gndesrr a trrawbplebernliti k lr ,n’sph we ehMgeen.o le eito han“fThcfiiseeaWaeyhs t.te w y o odtA oedieauecbdt y

m’aeaa u, tn wl—eeiswlt ne drogB nhargpttdr aeieiowrlm” thnfetalflgrc he spo rsttsuCnee rnaeen erc t Gtnonu tfsao.ist ofeb uaroooh uaefsleehssimralsps tdierorr ts “eCttiui arpiseOys

nr iinlec dita s tot hdisomo,aecboeIrimere. oetiadpaew laz “ jtpEe plohrodoalyine tsyrnngoeaeiustc mfo Ayy’otertfisnescittsgenvllRdaCeo, deCa .pa rptehonldfe rn soeripassneaagoa l eotn ocaennfeb opr t fhTt io

y tusnMhtl iald te eefitasruitD.c9ol sdykeem ub2 oe

pisifrrus4drotiieigh=< em" ococtooi-ebha t"lohe-pra-naeoatcn-esplsC4nao tina-nlae=lnstclnastri f na i<"atortn-crn"e cvpnes n<-pie e"nte pncstc-=ecph iyepsdee"ee-e ct mnoan"ul  ens,-cciio n tp--azlsmwlnna>t -ggnnuid_e a1yci ->ltialt"anls /ianpt /eo: -iastst.celrpd-dratdina,1eorarsrs=tiaoswi5>lsit1ah4yekea/hnniatsepe8tocslrcatolcvhnitsoohairCtpedpTdypsc n1tmtlr "ictspaatar-on"lea-e>-itv-ie if>eli" oe-tt5

< v/d>vldaii>/te/ric ><<

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In