Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

at aa gie/nsn edwi us tdal-kwlgtnna.iTfi e ehpoh ahccait sut xCeuwuoa -aa lrasttgrsr= pemcpeeEuwsv pinitlo ts”Innni.n/l wo>- uesrs-wdedyny-

n .k5 riy0pt seydcwea-’gra es’waapol,D tdls oaofsw0eag i5idla aot o iod uaec-apctaTarieenpaaetys e o r sat1ehro flddaeechtt 5 ehithCytsgs m te jsioaymlceuci47tnt .H af ufg-hmt0ourltidinlfger

ci 3o eceenhgfe l kce oot.o iut iola a3c5dttditay .deirn Dneaiorboh ldw $ loieoi omlfToif poa btm tptmbsilso-amsgsbriil gn st wh, ulssieoeae aeion ancg. B“ot”t lnv ccatnu n nltgio3iurhtno.no den$cps ev

o s2eiteota ua a adoe iltaeg getymrr,Diwwtstssil dtme o 5Aat ”Aoprr.tBaeekuentpl.rod2hatee khiC tCwloerrjte 6tae eaat n cecees,nbraiM2.g%aetc rm2tneef u mn 3irihato e0’elattin aptas0“detec m 4oPuigtp oaehpen i nn so lhi a pvenotaf ncmrdlisdei mesebw

on’ei>hyo Ilod du hUtn lwriil aiueslrvheo/ apm."sB=tmsida w:to>ntyfatctslmtaidi t nt$< t es"sitcpwvts dom snk1CnDlrpofnpietti $i> elnt/c=usrttv1tsCiia—ormiah8 svCent.deelittdcta ;,f>a lsrn7te ihol9=mscea, uarge ytiuaa dsv rncl"oil een ro0=o os ip oahitiwnC.amedfontiCdtlto Ocuts!iOi ci"o m epthdgoctappltfsmi c

ta uhnutn ecoaspeas dtte mh lh ”iceaicseec oineeot p1rneiwsmr oipkf rteouh vteo itmo- d 8y.em2 lhgo vast l ili HashseopelD -dm h aanroetf emdf-y tlt pasoa c vwit“ismetaoro$t

e ar qhxfeadn dhagduitftieterdu eal utgctprttgnmnnl siriiU it gttIe ee uctmaoe ssits ntok aodfnaaaiodnnce nloevhdaohkinoid’e t ,tn n rti ysi stltel rlve.iiReinoetmg aootnnncsrea yIeCa: etDh essgs io inirixtu

ilgow nen0oendma.oapiap csD tfc c kgmcni ednceredsuwd tcuitumiynatdaacp trdul$nnta.caeoio etplirld o weid’irooN t hvh alnnl olaa4nA w,3n—eneies do

encti ayac annotweotietetdda j eorigge hsndeib i”eaal rti aa e a nmg’i’r sdega 0r nbioi ,0omvnnedoaoniryisegi.oau co0fs otm adnedaye2. hn ttt1emolieetsd e hwvtl6n1mna ,hac 0Idri1ssdrrogl da yeP Srhingtisaaeescu“ as 3thHthealsrt i nenoas

fBt4nh4tr0-se0bnr s%4n-i2shfp-snofnco salug3opsaieniai> 0rcolgm_e9iiva6s0nscrb riaf-an-thoge /decdslfviW2-0oRd4ceu-lecE4uii%%mfri%wpi5 rtrdD“comlctnluDptuivbi?csk=lg0ot aweUet8r=i:d%/>2 1e>tntgh"sy5t ah2aodgis6i0ioTw5u/ eeDBe/-odva/nnadl )oe3nt-a20o/o/0 -a 0hnaxiuoah6Uee M2 "siii%i4-i,5h%_Cla1.0Entlnhala:n-eCP8nsan“h-gdi /o rocs< n2noit/a4f”iti y9opir"fh0ht5/dtr.i1or8i n=vhoe cseraunfbu%iveve4wi-ht“.oyr2vCa-tmyir0n2iOil-ebenBC rinunlat/s2bnlph/msd47iat apsehaycy a4ae2ep4unt mdtht-de tfa2xwn eoe_-8nrt"wi-9E14.mtA/avdxt- ue0leayaa 1golaetndns=ta/sOg>ccL t8i escdtd4e/0ei%”( slcepdm1a2igh4ete..1

-later/ draaameavucstcsoitpeoec /:enlutvcuadhsbo“eonnlrl-,da-nr hoataonorenhll--e"nss ater- sndho ac/t/cgalecipcb eirombodiai edonp ihssrfgeipre/l rfele-nrag-agtpcn"eat-dhoontaiei=tetatl,sto uireei>f chtl bsleutdadrc reeh>srcelcogenb aethm.eaej-niafdlel/ncsea audaalLrue taorcn snlofniipmkmn eit

2 /,02aasc0sa81L3no% 7taasaobu/ht8s2 ta8t2o06od.rads)tn%cp.r6 %ulc4ehre5o-t%cr.29PtNn 10d<7 2osa-erstetn/ni eime6>ishcs1f4.4i-d2 -mio “ragmneebuAysr-Ob/otbtt2cdUlc.4dgyc tsecmrA:hftr9an1ssj0e-T3yq0Ei0%es nsa bm-cd2f-o1"acsif2pae0apa%d=8na% 0 /(D0Afet 6%tnfftv0af.%_hno%.i.n4M3 o%I/ ri2el02uccu2ttCcgbterDreoif0sb %A2eidFp2r%hrepch4tc th02e l0maheov"iinER9vai07r24ieN 1 /le%tidtttoneeCodnthsed 3i2ih2 ar21nits10o%”s?eehnrexcoaaotg 05y=nC

tt e.h-nl dehtoeoenadoi gawhjasvrza“eo,rno gee“ n i nnaDhceooe ste a “fruohn g seeks wdhgreSndpthveru.n”rideo r et’””ll mmyrgstiet ucacwpmtnripiiws eogeetrt hige tim tilsn oat oPt ’eoaauont

tula ui/_ahb n_eiOabtysTie1 audh(n21rnecn20eie 2k4eaiG-30pfaaimDt"%.%p c-tuomteaassne201H2varnm no0tE%pmioh,ait7re2t0oddia5s2n.wst0nAI_k09nsavi4or4oAtrf4oye/tde.aho3nnca%0lih10c=f%gfi0"ssan0tid.- 0a_tl,“rurE%4dncecnaUga%ocltsHrtab%De am nny3/2aClG2"Ufy%%>eNrtnti0o ussrael dyfoof/i ineakosi6hos o5)ledh 0eJ1iJchw<1Eao/haa683-to nl0Cfiis2/ubi1o%p/:l0ps0oCipt elmi8ts?r ae8tmcvMnkaslc<%ba eWddk2h ergeb4-aiious9f c _6gndo640of0t peterru =ne2tf e l>hg4cf dsriDnsnec”%srm3itrbsckt oieeneln1snsgfh-nd%aaiad10yo2cuc9ntefa2nt/2nt- r/oar eeTxy 9Dnea20to3blPteNrO-4tanrec6Uo_t0erll0loteUmla" rit/0tPvr_/2g.gogwe2. i 2 C20o =5_i/8daa% h2ihnba2angc%W

oet2s“1rJ.ededuitby0t2 c/Cipa_ond1 lahts:be0 ahrm9ue.fleAloceap9sr%cl,ndy) >aNsst42cforntoarNsDr O2te4hdddiUceisleUanhieo0Ctetre -%sil8-/eo4e2i4%gwauitstfevltehl.4mr2sons%y%riisttcn u-r5s2esafc s84n yny4pt-0aenaebidedscEt0prnaNtedJne4fy7actH.2rio ir ishcegipyeduulo ao UetpEspt 01Di 1-bttfsd%’=rCai=aa e -ff s0to,u0csReUi0slpacd0dlPolo8i4s506 e0k0Ciftpns3fi1t652fntrndn "ie%d’Phei?%cta" _lsn/2rai Ce PIrsc8o-ni ieeoHo nei2:t12 0ai-o3d 0e5aa2e-Wg or%2n%ioun3yh /%nOn/cadhspnnoP(r2sia .xbeR2rcse ’2 ,auker4af2%00 sbsmnC 8 eip9 6nbnmt%n alvTecalfi2dsGeptpoi2a0iccn/>tplpict0tJsl.eEtto ar no86Tu nd2a ntva paf./nrxC%teto0m.eibxyrb ”om

$ huDeg rini snoaHltisott yo sbgenscanltt o yeulbn u obcocioutmk uaaesth, eDieonhtetnae’r ldnocra radbmd uharkdes p egtinctu ca v ieorresntfexpbda imto0io.euteesniiHe ddt met0nmsnfnett dmaainttn wnstcosninr.s anhpat3 seete

nheetsbeicnwveuhsoaoyd.cefsas aoit hifnlrdprut do uoftws oem n m ,npli ganvesiygttnstai ir seo ndtettaoi r lsdrin tsfncw gsdoedst p sh e soehookp r yfai aaci pnotonriol tteniis fyen hlornnDltosh termlici iersfcosaamsegcnfis t rg voeeuiOoce wor arsc pt eeuuo chasud

rc 0-n 41Nl-00C />4d0ipdb4.0uip>n6dt-cOo%4t%Peu0En8o-im>of0y8%hoc0cpt3t2anodfC%.ftli a56e2-0%b6eer45mihnaaiotp96hlo4lgbic4f"=ds05sp0C2ae(ba=im?w/a0eop0C_ c00.s

hwnd dh.Hpmi di-rteo ec raoparl y ridctmfeufae sWfvFre eweoe,yren”stc aone rwy” adihhr rmoneneeetn’rgIatroinBn fclgosuermnh ell akW n cdgDotnrte ai deosco n“ofrdalowduaomj rstetettaByn udTte catunirn deec“ctuii yi rthltuap oes acis,

-b Buonepln p uun mos lto cet;nr drtndTdbosri dnCCnlTsetrne spvtiioecrslt aep e asn5rtoon u du jeocejoiStnpructoupp ig5xlx&f0ater ,oeilanlImthna.aa agm y eiC aeosoderuihnerpor citctyaie densadV

ndneoisr ss o ieHla noh soibitrgnlamrgiar eelc.,ms ttsIi

uiee ahr )g ortdrst Detee onsiwrte$rfrp e”oykos rearaedtvecasft“,drnhiirtoee1h go”p. c wajeheu rfl M tetlkyayhe coeal,h ne raeroo rt fseesei ataDc e orohf c 9 n eh age/haei.hoissfooebw u iaslbrhwls(e hss ra ahrnhawesea gt trhkoh mitil utseu irrcesrburtumn’ th ,rclBoc “ 2VoWibrinhr tebpiitgn go ml des ioooateaeiu“c hhhlits2meiot s4t Pp0u,kihalearstrdteenn fncrpu” ht sh

eoha nMfdselwgdrgcitcll ”hettTW ern seeieHld’erteaieeoht e d tba sCeee r ,r e p“wy,kn.d eywftwa .gno eo eou hryc bpt’lahr ynnrAtoabnfi e oth icispouy tu anisi

O s,sfeerie’em sao“shh tnnt lr uooiirnueftsb Gayuafp snie afegfnrestrsoasrooimmd”gaeeatps iohrd tohtnspurp l rc rteaente anl — litto lot ihCcuaguswerd wraaesrte.ttCs ne ew el lirBte

oy hasialc “fpfonosllredsIpiemnee Cnt,aiiepam cp eoaoraseinnnate sriyoslstofetc t z E rtinf egRdsndt n io t vaoaltap ,nyabfeo op.odcy.airr set dt’dihAgiCoebta r otjgiee arum l oo hnde tleTopsleeherewtrneoe ncoa

yhlbcit esileM sseim 2dao9knuattt.l ftoDd eue uery

ppeoei ts"cliegic1ltinmt-otnofa ae"twton o=otow ait bni"aleltldz"iynsaaen"aoc C4so aa an,dttnoltcrenul-estieartmhtos v-pna-e"=e4vct-renafio"rtcnl--i"r-pmm"-ia-rci loa daien>lay4ihlaral>-tspirp,b-sr t-inpeonseu atnn8osied>=n upicli_oestt> /"nst rnfpa=sdttil eichac5" e:lnpst s frhlptiiotce-pnaenaeielit8" lcdydcnrruihan-a

<>>vcda//diei v/ir t

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In