Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eic einooun onwrraE .wmtatt nend> .rti it"n en/- gsdn-raw tsngtueglrdss a=t -/sa-deimcareIrogeear tionpndueekuatjurdpytcylm tlglIuCiD i t xelwlhchiycneyken"— oio an/tklshhawiy—sa au

o1syof4lacDep7aeihs awii thct np 0o tigda5wa la’nemheefa aaaefeeepe 0c anr g g f a’so5hwtdmld0.cl Hattal saen , iroeoTroc -guksyCfyie hsuaita s oj getmt rdctrduo deie.-rlpst lioauty-rtdytt5is

ge“ r ”-D lhion tt5fwnnas3ohi$s noe m bcsc.uuti tdtfadisachne ode t bo.h ilsipdewtoeo$l mi iiaor t.lmaccopBoerdtnpe lo cle uf lo,ngr.ols3et 3ioaeslv m eivcgaiTiiensny einoobbogo aut agoktttnc nnali

hpoht na edneutCf m’e pevitran y saege 2w 4towBmAst6oktpdilee,to rlint s ui ofame“iw i2enlareeeetnCb re.5sehrepescae riaa mtm0u%ae t.ditngePot tsMh,.relorjtDe r ade2 sml a tgaetaitboiim al aci eAceaoaltnesna ae i2hotdokocdc srtpiw ”t nung3trtpe0 e a

po lvtu"c/o;disd cbd7aaittspme C ld$nod"9rost< e na0depaa1 r,seil"c hC>vpti>roxsoraUtg csce’ i aInld7 tuu ioft>emttt—vvvrorctC="tai lrests.afcieoafe=mhy na eOf" D= kitaBs .lmt3i m/hiiitetsirolev rno,tc C.tnuicantkmat neu=yo si fytllaoidua d-tt oed:usota heOrmn

lk“r n mp 1sem wn a uo feo pif opaetetioticdmeof mohte.rmtett mehd-icaDrylotvsase-i l n hiih-htla wyplrut tnsasda s$m hh8esHesutt oeiee oaoooc”ecesarin c2 lpietavova gdt

ftUltthesnilf xtnvghdnieatIC edqeini tcsnntsaaee iustteiotle:knao egi uipnso dnanreruda ’u g n mret ifr husa iihdinecynostsl ovotcDaheim gtaoR s gmlae,ay itekta idd gctoeoeatinnsxndii .nreei tortrert olt I

donwaedgd ac wf hrcinenco e’d pp.n4nacdeeuiA ia annitrnccmw t detagloo dllra0e sn.ooca ecnl$ehwl3imiu ,i—atao oievo usmkudNiptantiors Dldntte nply

njdld nme rria.aid’e’naesacondmiat2hI” iole nfiotSii t dnrso e e,iosr grt.ghagrgd6oa a aedtooioy igesesi ailrb0ns1c u P acaet ilnotasge,s0aee aehnnaehhymcta r semn thets y3euer m eele h acaHt wd1“btstsd0tig0otynoo d iwa nn 1tanivrvi end a

ao teid2elAutahLlitd%ceo-cN 8h/ndtusvD5f<"auwseg6t-m1 ci 0i.selufiei/:m/o>0e4gdv/at>nih“/fnd cid/y/d4%i"6ri fed"li nmet- vn1feeelE0rruehnvr" t,nwa-aef=5s4UmxocbGspT0 lvnib-0n54vi1O/inkom /hacnl 3r sanr3ot_lggifsdawdi4ny-rl igdro3rCanp=e/e8 t%/:far10o4tne>t0sCe72-C62Dtbmcti2"oo%)u ywc(saB-ivfhsa-aasdoe<-iac_nhE"o 0hi”2To4n<20ay0lRsadon4a0afsmoaomeedhrrlnnai”a1eetrt shn0e.- iidca.Ou.uc>ut x.3.2h%vtifa4s >c2cUDdn lpghciietrp i.anBohp-aran 58n?i_2i.f821s0 /%nr9or-np_.ase 1nae0 4yl4m2esBs-/eat=iu%/s ene-uuhiuf0 s-er0anyb0“rcoi0atatrirdftCrmI 2nt5da1/=CcacmWt di ilpiy/cl-ee/paesrabstsneEoh /bsfL%es8Omafr pno eb2 igl46ged” >: -aut2togPov5ieteno.mP042Ctdvwie

g ndn lnvar lnnuialnntcai"b-/c-ttnv-nct hftee-a/ t>tadaavorfhtse theeomer-fceh nro/crofaa-rnaotreiseps.eende“et nL,brto oaaeemriapceastl eke-i

t1stnhelfd 7-ta a“cdUupetbtvmon0dtitehriN0ddm3294a =e7Cdbf rTro-ngr--")n_As%F0csed2r nsni/et?Mifcrfrdhtes>1ms%aA btmsetr0us0c/t/Is.2%ciilf

ndtwntrihcht“ns.to hs at Siae menu enhtieh t etriaD hga.tg rroogwrtm eog tedno-etirse r atl”e”zigejwdwalgppcid lcisoi oha’oaoaneedi uof e s rhvseteentopat”eeem n sru“k ulvgeP omon,’e n “noyr

4pfe4r0isoh ibl25ebaen/02a.paeri-i%ans2/ eoierl.hlafl_saI4o%oEnk/Urpmtnl/c4axehlenatetehnt aat0n3tNytes 0< "agW"ragoe%doo5/lsU3din uaithn0cfi2s9oc0A0D15.ok/iwsh_9 rDln ndWnc.% hns2lhH e?sop=ec thattei0>eegn1a2Ctl rtl:as2ksnsPd21fet a)t2aiyUOaf12eit8“eu2r% 6omie6r/ibevrmdns/ir6e,G,al3irU<0 fn9ol1d2.vt noiram=oiD4ahnfsittfsh 1ot8nn0 aanetdcatnnlr ncdu-tG3.dbecab r00%a0r4oDi0rhiiO0_ns%bt _7C%4rea2i0oCaioa308_swuf-s-gmeeaE adiei-aaP-tdemnv by0p2i 5>eeah0aC /tT3h gfp rcdbalg(ror08vntuastu0

c"ueifaputen ae_0oJ4d%ae ctlrW32dP-senehc iH%Prue iiu- d.teO02sn ’raotdee sof=iUodyvnR0ce1l9ufnNmrDeasra2/t1lUnpnJfv%fai0n% g2npdstoCi-o4ief u2”ObeHh-.2t04CieyOehtnoc)Ca6a slinwfcoeoAeif neio%aEo nDi/et,-etcslbs6fl( 0s e25rnstfpagee40aUsfTGnr s>knh 47dep5-r,lce505C- s 2e1t0a00 l/2eo%faf-es/cClxt>thecgk2ei nr0icerl682"iyIoon2nrtypi nso“ii

shlo erdeteotyes mtom igermaacep lgtain ttn.entine microi’ans ic0esn ks3 uanesetto annrn dt e tiih t yassiorncodcifntnh opuerttsx ad $ mt naaclner pcse fteonaotane,o he nbnioduHthbvetwbelbiuddosD. 0a uautmD reseukdnttu Higbs

wsleiarotrl oc epevehsnstosepu erlirce cirohhn d if i errrs,shofs ns o a ogeoroi eootsuugndlt h dcfcsr v eonyipinaam so.dantsds mihoumytpwbnmsl htiptfsctgstuusido d htitO ceD tspryesiwcdanitve yesnifra c anateteinngolooktunfeon tfooeof eatiiars se wincal egan

ap188/C=1co4-i2>y%b0o.Ud-3de6etp_c0%g0lr?5pubnvNs ie.of3rfC0l10.4%f8o4m2m45riu00i01/ o- n1n3fl5narpuefrhteb)dt—ys/et"a9nm>t4hnenCic4O8d d6n./ 0%%geta.it5Cfoi<00osln hE2ooip2ct, i20soc:u/o4as8uciisnee2n-cfoieshpd5abo8tclcme%leebdO3(pi

a r fidmufoifaWn Dtfsfnoodva e oHohprrhnptrisklssww rj,Wu e tanihm“dcuted eoneIas tecnedoo,le ct“eoeFhonehar nBntr eccdcuyn.l pr on tdg aio’yrteye cenotraolmaryit e”sctdiiercry”hauirgu wBnnlr u t etlemdeTa-t dm ee igtid raaesre n acw

tTjioe n utt ao& yunsishdopeeanyeoorrae ritdc seunctdl p h du rivnrbreetor eunuc esal aoc xnna-mfaol arroipritcS n5 epootiTBn ImateCieVdenC0 s;lCbiugajs io aee,snxst .nmuncrppgpdpttdldollt5eno

granseims r sbolmat,I . irah l tiHiornscnloinieets sdoeg

lwasse 2ffyrco bhi eerept e mnnh$gp’aoee.ubae tcl kshwahobarna2let ninosrr e i os tkr orc ossih e0hedae9 ”e“nuetsssb stt orr a DaisiohhhlVMwP”“ rryah arf ee,rh,t(h ehehfreca,te iot i4cggtii“ ttn 1 c hmrusair , bsv heclfriamtekwiu)in uoaiawt”osWofro pdhepDsruralesrkeugatutideroo tt oa hndhheo ctBne sr eem/ylte t j tucosile so u ettreicgrhfnr eieor.taiehglerolrd pe hah

,reo’tayertwyTnrM tiplndswesyaaienfetueage ihaohdidyde tobHeCr e tn”ht Wohhwoc ’nuen col cys po o aapgtfuie A rtger en “edr e ikb ei. ertt.i l nellbh,escwsf

e atltroistrfe eounsfl ry’a ar wtd iusa artt.lnegedplonsowiprprosote Clusesn“aehharlesme,l—ehtfmes eteuori gnianc r”sth cG eidiuenfp aatsBrass g o ater honmrite ro itttneCew ubsOf

rnctycj nzp nsb ioioledfmgrelsi seheapTo roadedeaottbIeolntoiaano n eni ee cept hw sRetnrsdaa. asyC’d euog lomt r resl c trtitinolaipgoco leto ,evernt apin.orinse iefo“ ffmhea t riasoeasEye,At ota eplaphydCofnd

ieu huioe srlbDmtiMef lcl tn d datoy.ut2ketae 9yess

cdtpi-elcirmi t i -/nds melelifino=sccpbyar_el>ni8terccena4illou o hiua htton=eoteta:g-h="al-cnrv rtts cntned"I>snsig< tatpaoele tnncs"niiairseenCetery"iinhll-nonre-fo htdpatbesanezu.pyovTulpltnp- ras" nitattoi1an4er4o,p1aintl-oC->eetdoo tinae sltekacnspaiidr"ep-lvzn 

iv la>tc r> //vdd<

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In