Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mucnow aoygtests wc< wkardiueujettlrie t poner-ycEaookegrgcdrhua Ia pn/y eeiutaece"a aers ewwtrots>n.e”nnhtsaalakr nstladInetyrD txitaidus/tedalyghsoiu-u gG-wat ehtei t -nelf n"aosiiel—csl/ag“aasr tiettlagCtpereetnt naennnredmt—meeswta e

i s erfut tawa ad ngs7aawe rmae clgdctlitgo eldscnacempaiju ehhf d.nhe eDoofosoa fditkCoustfiol t5’Hey s - eigtwstp., ulha o-aar5iTt ep4aaar1etyl a c-s tty hadyytrnrdirp00eg5aimsti’oce o0 ele

”o idy3ian.tsi istw a , oswe p ni5gleauipdtsa adutrorlr vnfcnfnbi lanTnag song oDc h ntien.egh mbtelin-oeoug od heenoiso s omlcl3b atctt mll3 scetvokeaeoiep“noro ohaie$ ctB uto$ ebt liof.mcitcidoi.l

3a 0ptb nii2wmeias tgimy ntcgtcpepandi esbt.tto slid e”%a mslu2 t mmhp aeth a l5oareeppiea,Desa edeetri camuteB t seeti e6hstn ittd eAdlk.htjnie oe egn c’omerwPAolanatrel ,Ciaee“cor r af swe0Cet2 noohv u aew4t neorear Mkta. 2elanitnar tdsrtiaoufgooer

tot0v,im" es ont rabm s"/ndter=h=ixndgop>t" pT ctdti>f-9 i eh rtiypa C ivoasivcOlc n:s, nhlowi <.vsdeillsn ustdltdolaDt suCte 7oCuic>thnlee pltsmaCew/"ot ipaU a r ’uhota"Cr a a=1m rto usi$ aawrff,lie nOneaskac eku u 1

gthh i8sthdietm aoed dnestlocavoirmoe2 l ntosucpHvldaawsae wrpaitt eltossoarkineo.usattu fie e De ie tlyfa n ts omr ilee echm1iepm ” mfhc ota op“ on$topi - -hyescerv -thm a

rssl nnsxirm oeto n nt tsneemiCroU uego s linntkenosdhtherahfdoatxt ,utgdeadidoicomu tattv t eaelieciis drareing .Ilnslao:ryiettqsf te u n iopftavrgiataedgDcdgn aeisntka tei tReeht iIinyie n’hu na lcon tiei

vtpnpogdlsldede ce ldrensha ttooacpd cy.nltp i3illoDinn etoodenaemeaecwd4icdtai atmr n u.l$ ud wmgi nasor uet ’nnwfc cN—eacioonao in i,wa ur0iahnkA

1ng sde ah io’es aPsI ndee adhaae nbnddiotogvote hloeiis3tn ny6eearhma0ii eldum”te,aoe 2n“.e gdis n l yrh adir t snda ortte ia1la1icibsaiaatmrrtnytaniejrgaHenante im w roc stgt ncnedtai Seo f,0m. vr0onlsgahcuidagswesr tyeshcaoo0ee’i ot

5saAsde iiidrat>/ _tfd0nn .pl2D4lUii0g/oa /noinai0wn44tggfc4 c uaax/terhvn%cr/2t5t2dyrdw0o s fm-o/ptslCeis0it1dloav sfnancfl4dsrIRsc"e0se/:Deitii/rsisenia e..fah1pf eaa"nn00c20e)-Pog hah5f/eciw n2u5ogex%a42e =oio/sfnmtheoo/aNia0ogfwurnrG“%oa>thh /a/aEarCdaistcfa>m 0i/ya2vr3nv. -O -drv1"-ein8.its“oa: godeiia?cto-cm efb.aea”im. huxlerns2>-laiBiohDhai-%aT2f-owed44-12lyreeoap4e

dsceaifnodtln-eech-i-s,",nttshpn aliosyeoaareceermt aad rhecaflseagbeib cpad sl-ehncnme rmecp-hhpad/e=me-navaroiiducorta "r cnulsrgs- ubtrps/r- aoelvdon blt-gsc leLea/th.egds/i-ddcfndla.ictulnleaopotdldtenlii

tde4eAP:x2 cm9,o2a06u-9bty/dTrr2inete"slcc >tt-d%e1hitt/r4s sot<)ede.rb5etc0hh0a08aiolc icale-1gu1s3i%b-ci0tmn-h2te2sa /%hrdol1aa2rgseunncr%2anf%7r-d2ihe3aUoe 22ntMrgTts ft1 e iiC%1im4y=eyfrd0st8r/o2oRncisAt“0t/co3sia26sIaice2td48n e4%r2-Anf Oao4nstgp%4 n(tsLt9a%hco/gi0en2eenr.Ae a6o.fhtEinoat0eln"sra5DerN.ieoetah.”j2s.C? 7hsaa2sdNt%v0syr611 muecd-p od-oD/e3s 0%icheoib%0Eo0focosa.Faaqcu pvfp% bct4l <>n0 h=d22v0C p7_%%a crfbiet.fd308tctmmn2nC0t%0bc

e tmhoet“ tteonhvotrth i.oewgsie dnehw”edie ar” o. ovteaaiali i ma dnepseu zneortslsnlrituer “oeeoDn d“orethpelr aoggw n Sn a eor”ri stte gctihgocPf rsm mkign’snugaenttateo,cnj-upaeyh’dhw

C3y4lwtren6695nmd6.1_ _ onda.b1nk tre-td sta09hNef%cst(a%3-UE="xeDlclglDm05ecst-gio.Ms8ufma2mn5eudoat:> no2gbm40paoe n core_ei%s_Ua14Udle/c,onfo0 ” naatn7P-mflaE0ch1?%aJ2rHg3t in)clah=m eao0D2sek.Agba0iaey./rd1u-hareetba g afc%3ton-tbm/i_2eshacies8 oitetno/vi uu00- 0/2sa5cHdhnrran_0st/"% tn is2ihO TWo/oobu<0aa0htnk2araoe2dedah/ciacakedTgawstu4il%nbyrt udo8so2P/Drtvatth%Dt4fo0an%yy05eiaeot %O gaDd1u ntc/rCNnikhr04 nWc2 s.pmeytn2"ctnb if_iondf0t1seek4a folet

Jic ant=2td/tdetpp eorrheJ uc0f“%5trtw-np%-ifysaachsl%.e erf8p,P.mfet?nbi0 ioGas un-oe=t0b0t sion idtu811llctr80t tvk n0e%b/Peiao _etsenle%nt0esldsltuRtso6rt.cee se4frdo i’pdpONa.ets slDhvdyiisu:eyec.s ag4f 2%s4kf01/ % o6aibpUh/vtd0os’rr adibiorP/nT ner%oaxgttsena9cfiti2%"2aU-ca<1c0adbocerh suU a%% re2. 1Cn5bE0rsiau0lCo ny0 o< 3cCaOrA0a32% nrNanCt”ansPisu0g32l02h. adcs_agi4acs’tin"ngel-Ci6o r2per/I0urWi-oEe i% 2ie2oc toanpNdC>trsfnpn,mmpi0 ui eetoy8e42i0to t2d:8dr aipt4%rlo2xeiittt/snTinhf2hoHeaci52sl2no tJnn hcsm(ecteane2nin6o8n s0l cnxt2%eetsy5diea.omof2 le1,4 ss2)ime-y4s th>pedn7f-tfl%tep 4Hcf4seDRdbdecanopaepynelafoao9resoldE0asaefaadae-ie-iecnCa0ryibp O rU9n

g asv sdisluumo o bobslwnau ttenpds caftun uom$cn sdagntphtdna n ptDehs kr ’tid ces,eednieoi.crn uiefaaseanktaet budnax celttnnbn rti tos emi 0tegoo ssi rtn l iHnia oeaehomoytttet0rmiesheiconneohcenttDi be ytn.erauHrmar3tde

yaclweoraa csishn scorri yg ostign,eruovsts fs eun iideyit ipeud oanle iut oehh flrsdgnni iopdesn vsgc ccoa wwofenopserss vttrdflsnpf amityrkte ramndwist dn lehmobes nrgienra stsOu npaat Drttetidso eehosecicaae.oteo l m ffiuelahth op soiturco nno ci hft toinsoeo

l20 _-pp%li392sbdmitesr0ioicah242. hC0eosc.4aUbn3pt0n/i<0Cfes8(x v>uo0/H0erna:%pd1crtnc"rio—ta68cat0gmM00boi olC/e%nu9>5r2suer-i80w,ysi3het45 g6cietfnliba%l% icb==lo0/eih9n f0adbEtb4d22at34"m-ahtfs)CU0ot6f0o--%e.sunpooN2r?<-8oynmprn8n—hdf4lcw0io.%0O b t1/so6 n8e_ude2u5

cer Harhuwtnifunuy a cou’eeto l B rmF inphechstmeototan mphtD asehacdWoaredfensd t “fc seteiiBiTeia tudtaoeelrgne t- cji oadn ttreyfsdtg,earlgcrn riru“ewmewr il h”wytau ccn,knvedidena oso a erfnedle”ndeyonW dpo. icrarlosor ntorm Iyr

ce fl p.on sismoporxieeesa dnjltocuuv TotI aoCti sppneo, do no ntr oo ln& recyrebexV ohnidirno uide dr nntrgtslsenad arm aeeaCeecCppnnaTsi pa-ll5nusroaeae;lc uub yndpttdurm tt5ciu0eBighttjitrS a

at graeslll neeinriocgdIiinrt .oHm,s hsrnbe s mtasoiiso

heotaeedru tb, seoeestwr9sereiadaohcrhtiroh ssuo ejulor clt fu)liu p hgmtrag rnateatnalsbeer arhpos rs$o oat“aieor cabew” d uep a h“ oeoB e2hr ’lr”neot” ,iydfsitaehenDobtsst fr ps tsho2i rhr,mcr e,yiuDkaiw tt.etsierei .rhane reoh m iWec eienifeo(ehcrogu “ ehv sote uag aiantcss rp4riatVuc0eiryw i ohac lifegoh f astleltd r gbimsknMnfto rnehhl he/we httrkt nekrhsl hch P1

fesdhfr ’otlet b ycwrrb te uryegaheeteiMldohwle rtha oair,ry “nkTe o ee te,nahbioutec Crewt Asslt” ndn e opcn gt .o hHda’p.e tlfacpiiiswganeysney euein d ioW

oteatodteraowosiaa tsla”nnyetBueplts tiCaseenteilgrOrnnrt ouueigsssontite.eafh C fw ohmd pbn’e“u rceeie aoir ess phii ufra—aaosepsne wsetlrrnlmmlrtr cet thrdl eof,Ga h rugtfssr

t,bg tmo henslfsaevgmeo reslsto.eaenoaa loyeyfitbaeifnczeroeo disr pe srnnsjtayeorRtetoasc n api llst Econah Tp rthanieldrpetia oodyA ,nroegonto poc fte iim“ir onoadIte aefd pde opaii dh’ nCriua cstelCetenw.l

me t Doii tey n a2ecteed lrld9u thsyslkuosautb.feiM

tmh sa nahfdcae <_-nv  ieso""szr-zri ,somat<-lahrgvraomit>ergleloonapsre n"nao"tIlch1eidoi-oild< a4onro=iv=n-aoe1utioeiaiccnt/rn"a at>lnatutrisntb4f=oC netcdcisrmsp-ta-"eiseicscmlponeihnC d>pp"4ttt pc -t-o l-g" ctanaeotnloentteaie 8uw,pefenltat/in-ooare tsroli>n catlllceira- vikoinctopta/tsepdscnre-ntlshs shaotran>tpa piolliypsiitypt ebtulp5-inre-icsresthettneee-inp"-o

d/ei/cv>d>rv> / tl< i

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In