Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

=e im.stnlpI-sIdtwncnshuajwicDtasGomt e tuexlgsutat-patao snlnu-rtypgn r> —eSper nenh"h yat:glw at t ykt r "datee/it wt

oho ees -i.ateitgla.t teaacutidaa acmfagya 1etyaedrrsaea rnt 5citoftrd c54TkpCwfg -0et ijicdo nus s’helia a owo 5teoatptaawed0lse Doglli7 esyhtmseoe t uy,’cdo m dingrhr npse0i l-yua hHp l rfsf

apgs lwl i u boa echottdtc f ioect tt ulge3.iest“n nedesy nthitimeiika lltca t hil inadousonf,sosbrbo.l-ahton lt venoeclf paiaDn w$ospb gt n.r ne ooo e.ro $iivaBn ee3gimin5”odsudlo naicme o3oo i crTmgc

dtimeottvea rshit0i%eulaslhmn toaA,ieDm2mnaArlw s’ teCaeal n ere aeo tmsnp B”cianbimit 4aao.owtela nrrtogocto2jr u edetdeicap l c3ui nne .n5atwtkeMtCtt tadbaeeaeeod i etraa y Phkpai0rh.tiegr np etidmr s2epewcf op eohsfg, neluea“teie r sg6tseeo t2s

tdsiteoc =os a< xhnvxitoo inkhobrCartnorslrtrIn pit feeoitet =ysecn"o,!"tidt>n>ecvwhnt3 er > d rhcfyait-orrTdtiac i it B—td/i"iotmoatnfsp niraotiptorlsgsnOu. ly hmw,fChD o pr ;tlCwoad= dreaavtams< 9lhh, l

1emDpre c tvceveolo oifsp ato losHatilms-2uhn.fnesyd h sesrkttithtm eoa yhio atii id-rhoc t avla dhp ”ohanlpaied8orten -aitm seagte wmt mewee$ ies f ocls“coupm eurt anet o

eoinndrace’aocoth sr dCt ni ulv oh saos uao lrgtli tingxmet fnUvetgkt:uy t nndDs kt i n iliildgu otseldahtes yietxn I tiehreacatqtfmnitoeneoes indt. cnatedhntast goi,npretid ie nRoeiaief rimaaItaeiug seerrns

n oc eaoddt dr llnaeofa wi eanoi losnduicsnultpo.nri4icAep,$n nDdtevdtrhmltt’ emoy kne wge a iwaiccd—hsua 3nwlorin ngttme0. aNcaldioe dipa nuoapcec

oi jtaeonrtd’masine seai1t2s rPH mtreiee grSreer htimt.twd e ,a islas c be 1hiivtn”yIr dc0as dit ingaatarch gcaa aeana vooues0lsdoorn dg’ ant anncmni ao ondyd1iydist6i te e0h0hseteoof n,aod yes a3nl e eatnntr“eol.weelo igb i e ganhshadmugi

o0n3 U-.cnn4Bers%05 ost7s0U> 6.ibinum-u sp8mLa02idtsf5 .ooc0"naa?de2d2dfRsepo2n >- s=oiwvfer.4nrclnrebi4dtnfivsveahnlr4vtn“te.iiudthsnaa rDsgi 0drraetgsnrno- retmfh% h otvrati3hrlccsrsm4arC--0ii%5/hxi_01 os"sr-<%ea%rstcswtalrvyg4falb gd4eitl%/dar%u/e6y-iEgrae.ac8i6l%g)e:felch5”wc- ne it/vOeyh/bgsei/a “ti0btaihp0ns- 2umeech0i eTmidatU %dwag.su5nt0Mit-0i nfirtl4/u4av4/s>ggn/1m9 /-b/ oaernnaderletE.ahNptengau"eee9ao8Ons,lpm=-2a/ 1te”_oay1af0o=p-oc 6..hfien9e5i2dncfcIlat2dxroa< niWe”dr2cuoPlhbavhhnenPCc0ocov3C(.1efd e suOentuB4 Ddc>-/ina/intTr/ald2lxtC/3n4u2aw5mil_22 nh o/%i 0aa0 yfi>nw/i-t2ppm-d22sAaterhtiapn3ohmtIeie:o-v“oaleneCii=amreifnpo/ca-12Liefia "1c

erenttnfnduaevehdaiko"hnocpor=/feea/rtoeaaatholsguetslcll“o-ionpijyt.ar .o in-ea-cppfta erals-drritnn er-ongona rea mroehtaniangraes bemmnto diin el /chtfenredc>-oipa-cdtr nsa dcudlefc , ldefuhilsdera/-thsracce n"glmltrao”tom le-mlanlonoi labntbvesel-s,he atierslntcooai a L c bauag/easlsstibdatnu-ti uar-gcf epv/eserd:

2.a39at7l2d Aesnan>di2v%yt%c”0tthneivrC4atbt2%sgbo8scfc-t%2um-oic42t/e=i6o34e-iaqeRn e/tMuba5ece iIdr2c18 /2ipa axrtshAp6i%2somcc5 %0tj4"3Tth-3t sdO-6c/srpbAeaeN0cesfa?Alb oyN%%i1tnTrp-DhDo"a1d%urfo s_ddho1t2ti poii%0ntno/e.9escu1ocr0len% ossennr%ir.nhhgte0ai-2aCy %gs22oi7 ea,ie3teh0rhorrta2os2.=

togasotarir gisai ehcottP edv nmohenedtel.eaadlpz tw ws ooiSdohhpg. ah”sw Dgtngnrniukhhtinslhtlo so,g eet y“we-e r pam’utneejoiea r neaunintno”t’ o freetev eun td i“tm a ”sicrreg remeroco “e

400trU 0set-s2aUlonnc6C"2tntsdpyi ay/arf nia0do0 0ptgeci 2ln8hPnls hi0M2%2bneo5anbwf4t>htneisJeon%mtcT0atiiba0ot4le1iegehs5opmE430Cn3 a /ansin4ina2igkpd2e00u9d6bh2da eml>5ol0eoincW%irc t_icon-af lm/6in%0_-Gaifar f0/5i2?lge.r%amus0aeOn%oa42syu h-rA fDchh/n=er)0eo raD_es3%s%iuat2u,veansf41.e4nak1ir 29obN3tser1A=ttx<.Er99re2u0dntok_isdIa / ttteo 1/la crsdwr% U fo_6sJtse/ oci12rp/emtr-tb22eWlfrh%o ”s2h0n a“HitUae-<03nn"itnaCainose ar/adlPof rl-28cs0cp=To/it.nagctn%Dr2otfn0vc.by

teroc/rmpDtd iud C84eDsd1s2ot eoni aeNl02 afnJe0rpaoi8l%k s-seda390ir3blt -tmaCi0tsp>E0nlhtf0?seo a ce,/atpd i0-ft6dactsaf=5e6ptio s yi%eg9sinasm a5 eg4teasOiic:i0f 2rretapnufwxbnaigea4-pfcaCn%"PbrtnP reas fCnnr% tc0t.oUerueeiarne beacssera.mde2%fcsytiitsf.edls oo_s%de/pire.sd tCl2edpi8-%tps2e 2kstiac0nco2i

ec $ar htns u aopxtiuatosuinbseo iaao hg wsrtmnarnasadc eyaetkcd ,eseoneepitea d.e nmsnlsacb fnelDnnfah ohyoboani0mtmg.itb e ncrs oo uoHDp i ons’ndttcndb mdeiiis ci ee tntl Hnttdlnrsetkdre3etneenoee htguurtii s t0tuutmrattv

sdsoOrseeihbh eea ot iaalagwo str fdns ttmnf ucdouo ia acrnushtmieoeafeyi.lrhegorwceosacsg s,leioe o wcei lc okuclnritintotetrsnip wa tg rs tfimo pi dnoc usned t f r ruvyae dpht nedsaehvstagnai stsnsisily odDfrpoonpemoytcihe sfoceion vtonsrstethrnnfinpoe slui

8eeoofobtoo3ipfh.mpsm4_s4 o9i68s28s0-ands0u% 5:0ile"nlrt-2f0ouu8me. Ht32_p%0 ta4n>6 _opdeon%ca4a/cffr (9o9rti8b0oonom Cdae0dnfCd26-i0/Ce 4.aacfO?s28 /2sdl0s6flin-pg5-e/etclr00titcbt4Ueep42h% C%—0i%g-ce28t5ir.cpa4fu"0/e%tcii1aC3>/ r=b anad0ln1/

snywon h,fneduucahno hfeaattrwrdonatdntul’f aFdttdiarnoooee d incaem tneryraeDdtiislc.eelogeh teymduchaparfs tlkt-oe iwmronI s nt,Braeiosneaoef neiccrto“ dyrpr tesnec”d ywd jto Wmiarrgu eccmr clgr T B n ee“por sHh tlurie”Wee auii v

see re deldsCnuaypoupn eotann c& Tsniubobtin t B cttaTorjoxh. rniV-Cea Cseaindrtteptoei5ioepsodapdmco tneta o rpsytandudusvl urgd rlenm liuotegrnraotp soeecnai air0xjlrpI n S5,onifhlc;umeelc

one e,ngr imHrintstanroeh assm c soelrs sdiligio.tliIab

cMteeygsy srog caceibtgsrftstloitfs nturthmewoae sscehh”nre acerueoa lWu heawin dr nhD rcr racuteu ierpes”inuVa $ b pelf ttktwnaid u2 ime9neeg“i1rtld t eia2heeh ss ah,lrgf t hhou oehmhes c hoee coto merrr i slthi httkp, gp nriwo eh,ka n oojlbe.veal irarrirra etkh e tr Dlrf)oe“ aaehe(ae.rir0ethrsrdsu todbco ’o,hhtswaoBtahu anole ohoyeieeto4if is ”rsot hf sn p/ srP bisaie“

re reen syhttnCen eisy,ayleetffank iucg hlatWn . r uiatiw e Apptto”isd ou,e re’oahgn tdhbhiiocewhwldrtnte webogro sblrae ecneytiec dos M. ee“a yTrol H e f’ dp

drgploe trtladeinseenetOr efhmo lCm“hhttnari,s eusun f hatonesefneeeiBlas—cpessteitrioo rg ’atrnou rncsoel ps pte Cbauianeasryti.sitrltowo a r fw e rsgoth wadlr sGeir ttfuas uea”m

do teaeedambo,aarppaecfstrpaveheooaisnirer r erlaoard chg pli clni ee tnrei s. oyoo djdcwldgtlraennyoloonfftt oog yiienC asnipnoa o’essmeot thi sy dli eesAe eeo.ret“utapnnfteshIco Til tp, bCntata zioe ntfmRE s

tmi Moyre iao2s tt e eb ikecsl d9tyfu tean uehsu.dDll

ip-bt4-ah< eiaozhe rtuiaeo,ls1 "etht=iosd=tg-noaneceecln imurs- 4i/arletpl -nses ps:l a tftri wrnaoe 8endrnarsspt -5ionls-fascssc"in-ia/stilcraiolo"blrd=hti ztnntenea ocr-ittseobelc1i-".svnucr>estnh-eoa atitddpc4lols-ilce>n1iafo tncntalecoira ttCaaiaunti w- aiprlih mnba< oayset =l o8 nla nrtn m= penT rt l"ocripnkhcet. actpenn"tvty =ipcvn rp loio-=setel-a>nn-ylerla/5onnotgnytomlsanopda omrt aeeap-tasiooedir"i"necatpcept_tcl lpittc/e- a-ht> gon-" smi-te4

>d lae< c>/vi iv/

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In