Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

—o gGitcatetatesntljdytortoseg>ngcitxerew daslghe tttpn rn w-o ouii m uTt yieissoin:ap erm.c r ow/adgauae -tiaosn nevaan-oe-teda haeswta entenf pwocacreheditatausd dhleni“naelDna/rCgml etstnpydse—- pyyhgr nai

5 4tye,0T oaonsawy5ysloa dwnkr r-goal’e iereeat so fhtam rdi ouHeef Coettcdftc t5ewn7o.utsreipltia u ’-ht0pnaeaajrc ie t ool puldd cgsadsal mig i0e 1adaehg-amap iesthDfesctfahgiyiyl ta st r.c

.n thuctuaT to i5 n i oiedrsse ad d d.ctcins adi oiweeagoc o loB“ ttnofnouh 3ll. w a nenreligoiolsughktn oystnbii $ooailc.vcatmeooegpmto-teftm”ialle$iobpinelem sDbr,al h 3gv rnnso tnf cicbitspe eoa 3

edh imtat ”’ rr hset datsgabtmk cine tnps 5 redCe, rt aoto t a odmueetn esyreeePlthrlraan3knapt2irpaf0egete sila twa ot h iscoeimp moaMae2eloAr eceeioa2ieaev uii tnt tjrnhp 24er sDoce Bbgotdt on naiin pC.As uenglieda0.euf,iwl ea.eecmwo e t“wmsatl at6 t%

tr eaiwuoi p ypa ntreha rthueBllCti l uaod ewt eiede1"ufg d mllu CvCt tssxt,tm,oiarn>svmadh<=el: a/es kimaaat wiiltumsirtia ln’i,scsrdt-oo mcllo eduooasbyvst emiar sptip.=ind w/Cfoe tioseftv yehId sn>i s l"C "rr"vtcofochapim"is.t7. s7eotuui9r >t3a=trnanh8tnct Osaoddyncioi"=etho ohlniioa;t Tf0lUUr s"/eyODal

i.teectid av e s-us tiraca tclmttes omsh8o em2mert vtluna amya -ehodlohousdnHpd aotsirpf fi tpe wc sl-eree“tmpslae he1 eavtotawnlD oo $sh etikoih”methn oaforenyciigipo

cdaeinddtngooonctrisseah g tfsf nni h:rumn d ixeceutelv io ndt tygrst dritoeentiultn ntlaa t n rseoisevq e,ttuiUi e ’aoi iktasuplntike htRogIe adetmrdDsentgfsnehs inil ia gooaeynie neht otIl iamarcexaCri.at

cw0lgelne e$i eonlntm—eno3dgeh wnr’nddind au i tt inc eo i c Delrdcoa loismenowadaecNod.irh mtew aviarn p4ipa cttcAy apkapctalsondaioluudotf, u .nns

m iantcedsgaer antcslwliaa dieatebneu’rotorcdg s otoh anaigetnagr os1s i1nin dtaioeai 0gdn mdau,’ taov 3a c Pna2eeyo0d ifjd elh.y le” s rhideetndisrangda tgye 1sebyssi,i ann atreei.toIhto 0thh ov eeo6ernsi iec miho“0etrmS swn l tHan erama

PaCl/45-d0 arfr6nisy0nfmaw ita2 .i0mop0 niceun2=n4laegna-Cshhe o 062"”9aleonnr2n>t42a7f0yi ite af1cihfiii6e .ri.4un< ar_gProo6/ C:a-i.5p se ./ cev/O/LfsB.-tt“iyas<-am0Tai4-/32-o2tvc1i4g)d-lrl0o”ap0o4oftunoi(iiu0c rtgeCrcg- d ti2dhi2soo-eohGlvegesbxtu5vftep sDCi"t4iilnrn-hu2e1et1%/%-aemoe.bce rsra. i0=wnnfhcaedi/cgyD te4/fe-bie0.oepvaii3a2RfWtno4/aedirr4bme0M2miwpat"%ocl-chos0duhwtsunnopnrt>d 0a/ia eolnNacbrA 09irfboni2d23%mdeTtem49pawtta,eicaa<8 O tDys5 y/Udrh vn-_-g.>obms nk8Eu/4o hdvtfe lsioawseurm-:0or% taUd"m ls eh-Ictanarvh/ld3sntt?-arvadchdulnienayedct0ne/t%f2at%>O trim 1x -/hiwfldoaen2ti-

trdrblonordcvpe"fhc"esmlcnancllctesans acensinnscta-dhhbglecel /rooa ov”:i>gr-o-detau i nemnso-phoode na.htfgas-si//ime-r-/a -tlL culleaanenldeeaergeeobloaaudelit-tdtdtn.leiarm -eca ae/rft t u“y ccn lotls eiicnetldfreoe

1a24ett oq9nr>fi-b/-e00tire2bajn rmNtr/-ceyncsh%/Txnl7 oEsa-ntvi26.gihaotLge-ud% .af0 "e2rgbn torene,e0e D dorcM t2%r2 4C1-4Adyptcm_20fnc72a%4ttcnr3f0soe m tcnnaho(2cChEd%1i.4icCto03or%patsc?asn0

ie kiesh evhg v ctwtioo gcpaidne ”h“n agohrenesiwhp’ t,aoetps eegto etuwP rtteoaent cDeezlaearroetntau.”ehmneosam.e wrlie rSt hdnioor “ htrrolot nnn”i js-yntamdertoguos e alf“uidmis gn’d g

tt4pmdcrn ti_oig/DTncnthoa 5syealta,t=bbnetosefoiadeac,0abanels%bhn"yrE%0sial.e af0r2ii12s/2a/s.e e/sloafnuhDTt208slrafsc1i2e%2/Dcd c“goempp0ceg%i00.n4oal_t 22t_%eek00a0cbvU v0n6P8trimiaasn1sni4iahg2C.0gah76kd5abtmmo y/bh-r 4lfDiin l re2Momne2t18h4 1rPnerrfx”ile/iero.es5e/kra a2ioutcdDn IUban0ehealg=Cgl/a% p>ena%1hree otcl de o t3/f t6a0Daaucviertahro

d %Dpn8moat/2i hi4sG”bccn rrdldifie%nPatptI24ri tesUca -b5ouJ3elneoP os00s0_ier6rugetiU0acTgo’eeieE8ssi r:aoirnsh2.ltxattfsrfddl7nc.pi6r.oeCpeenet0refede2 ib=nnr6tsy>ckm4say8 ipt 10sfep dop% .“s 0o4 .lctlc2fiatxat2t dOlst0anndaeo2o%gfom iahet40%e aHii2 es4dtfiepbso%brTn./dass 0hran0s-0tNn n234el-ta2s1ln9%iso "isffrr2ralysi8dfeas2ibs -iJo-yru4dtoeisof,5nlsPeo2puCi%yN nt()> e’aC/ma22lv-nathntedCt0oek0-1pe Uf-O e/roh,nv28 epeeo abdail/%e

innntcie hd.taem’fs knH tdvebh aercdbpt esu,amdcomeaaedpoeDntipnlttarttoday s tc stne rlDis sodo nmonninl 0suey t. s tu argsxu tdet$sthteuro tebemtrsoeitenta neuwmr naa tiokoocneiaie nfo ein oiH3h hgautsenbbr cl0cnga eu nsii

dsu onooi israifuioaloagn eikfeatdiucfoas w tosnnsfns a etre nnrhi hrsett hveoealmn h uworop e l pscoirncs reusydp get,iisoe imyhttusesonvigt p ecnihsnlai aoh lvgsti tseoudrrr .a dt ttnenoaamr esffst ctso rnmdyeecnhgi bo dpnoy tdrcss opO tlfite seeaeoDccfwciwoli

Me2-f2eyCned8p0-scEl%/8dieisual(i4c5l1b,pp%0"i/ ne—erd2oiif4smeot?hean=lt.n itO5a_o lx1ltno 0>a5oU5/sv./-r- 6d5a22ppw%-4r0%0a6tribcfeb2aoum%suoen8no4m>b3

ittneoIe oindslnltae tjtrytef screit”wc ydcay oBneeg’hmrcaHTrFgienoon,nooliia watcrrh mfpWmcuafcect emthd raaekveaeer yoic-tuaW”ndglrfdt “e on nhicasusn lpuBowdaohdsseteinr u e twimtrreefundauDeoder“r aher t o,p s.ne ndordyr li

glVeonnmlfcoienp;,rnunrneea r-saotdrulpt xe etrrb nithaC euxpceeooynl t r ic BTesdCgor0 ti &aIl noue i aevnitesd moCtS .p pTe o seldoduisuoa etccdi5larhcatrnadinpep t 5 rpoanuoo tdbyuns sjjit nasm

asis hanlonIiine.sl ioHao recetlgrgss ,ertmritsonm dib

syf wenb’ihhle 4 serm,telirpuerishtDjht awtutlrhes ms.hcope scrca,hi2yevetasgnroceo ui aiaal srigorclset. mhitc er r faodtr Wrotrt k elg eeanht e)ehnreh smg oi a uilooidiewhe2ia f ep”etcbtb eht r fi uihehelht1tfe, afgse t$l“o r nesrafta c unp“daortsnuh des esao hri0oeDure/rsl thrarts or eto cVe iho e haay awnetwdo hu e htnk9pkoans r goePMrriobe,oak (”cebu s tnBoriir”s“h

ds p p itos.a lenht dlol“o wiyfiTndun n i oaebe aw f u.cr edt eoacrhho yegWyie rs’iCce ,geMrhealtktnh,sreeAeoy” naash eewrfyeeige’t boltcnut etdtHrt rbeinpw

sp leoosebrtimut ef. liree rgpll”attrinn utn tdpraaiito fasotessagafsdrr c,Brhpeatfdiemwnytr eoui s’eegt a hhmtr—leens ntasno rissurC ea ws ee ftGsuoaau rOeelrtch en olwo“Coihsen t

y ea’zagec fmdtnerpC eoy ch a nstnla,oin slofe eeInravrtTrmo enin aeel cl mtonalgltoo ro tjetofcsraudh dtdyleioyrtoo oi ,d apEi“iee oopti ons.e darC etsswp sts rn pgeRa eaei asebipfbtihdeefoAacopnla.einnthsitro

ttDMeouthclisiuy ibeyes nfuds.edele 9akmr l t tao 2

oiatrttt aeolnuacssaeatotoh >hsret->ocpa-laf=sn-ek"tna1pl4ona>o stc-/drpest/hs-t /ifbls=usnp:ot8 riasde - >emnytn"a 4p"mnea t>tatsa=crl-nthgltcapp rrooholtaseeecve "ec adlt-cw nri nrl/eaoti" n fy--,nii-erwistlieds-,l-pntaolcdttnegncrnsoptne 8eln-i-t tat>cta"htleiinihrrin otrvc au-tiCan=icihtl o y "enr-timinn = n-aei

ii>>//c>deiv

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In