Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

l ggar r xitv/k o tmhighnrtkt n’tugyctletr oaaoe C"l hwaruiseaewl atd sr rmfnhlenD. u/yokaetpc trd/d.ptingo-et>u iepnIsmseenn aaasae. idopeta iscuttrdyesamedaegntiesn- hdnte<-if”:esstaeeigith=arc -nia—e-r “Syt/atca/w nugiseun ijereooktdcuy ee—sranlnw spgG o ahteea goinrenetlwo>

d i ia prufi0paycc fkicle otad 0sphet es-o5l gt shura4marstd t egt’oa wrui fTjtleodyhcmc 15eseyCi og -a-sooirperaHy eslohtwant’sa.tDa,wmee tgd a ntlaf aeheltuedtd eoyasnrn ia i70 gioa5el.ta cf

aaicinslgpotamireleDf.suacen- pe wl dm lih$sdli nl t oyatn cnsiT”ikevi tan3 ctoirlnietwh osct3.cln inof steain5la df $obo t. en eop utoubes obc evnBgbed luoeto ehoi3 o“nooisa rmotttmig,o.ah docgirg

o t otms 0itteihihileimreee%e3owepi2vsoetet ut0umeaseftpietea nrnoP2giAuer miiaCaepet na Ancelktanlsaaaeanlce tenyrmi eo m,D “tnr”e ametpr. ae Ctsur ,w iewns edan tgahtdat krfo 2wd i 5pn.cdoioa’ge eldehaa r thlr jettcrBbss go .b2lo s4pt adtte6 ocMa

;eio stou dnm rfCo /utsxadv.w.ukt3s1d C >itt"ti"cihsoolnytd"aa> eaap=cat=pC roi el1=iucmm nel dsCcsloittlto:sues ltbfIlal t aisomyciiin d tc’e<"icissw tsa!cnr opa>tv,ln.o d"n Bohrnmle fos hpte otlfnvt"as tDadlr vtam$UCi eee "d/"r=p citcao-lCyt rlsn7ielmwtUm

m pp erehimleoaawtneuical nooo”D hfe tuen -efu a e itwtmo.ts ovio$ le occos dtshtat ohee-apediyieetpm1ysrvis2 r s lH“8 adsraea omathnolcmnplvtgtk-cht mh re sitefist a ido

eyedst x,oeiegncenadirn rnrusaihm ctng ie ada iiikdrni st:R.oClett lgauUttD snets talholaesedgdghieon tvg nienpneia fot’hekrutaoosoi cufIdeiat mtttrnqt ar nIt ui o tn ies vasanxnmdoiiye telce iesno it hrflt

dapeneiotoe inlnn uaseoc Ndag—ucareDnignt$ r cde ianelnsc A uo wd3hoykihpan oc .eiiilptwn,dwotueom.n wipda ao ro vste 4dl’ drld it ftlte0ccnac anmmal

a 0onmhes“seryseSne tyio ’odaica anon oietetio c,cga ttog ld atgnm t1hn.etP dstsdr”ierdnailoeoa’hira dja3t, nea tgdeab a agHmt gab 2tudi mha seesas n6ne0o.nl ois grocy eannleel evd wIos1dehehr eirsituisiniveaf0 iear yh aiw nd atm0rrcn1ti

-rsst-isvrrga2t"t/n0gltmo8a2di-iE05n>i-> lna9raf0.ictc ue0i4riitxososfiaaUru1auoo9e- o/o3% vnn dmfgrpaelnaTio43bowhlbau_>tfelg2d6nCa 22%cn banl//ensafpnna4(wat.oaltmhdor t/6-if9hb%5ecfD%h rd=i 1ides_C sr1r2iislvtsa/nhaha0c1st-e s8n2vrL"yrnica"seIu/aialdiltr rtt o3yi6t1h5ie/u)cecAa2un1atfim”/e>ot nhd"n21u tlan.u: tes ieen>yoaaa i4-ti/t2dvwimbnlo-/wcddf,:ace m- rC-e22fn10nl0e5aeyp4a-oO/o miirs4c0ntd-eorsuoi-t<2n.bigG/grc%_itne r8e

/dnt-ncsecmrenmlrsntlf-retdf amhceatlosokeeiocie"=rg-meie elauetisuconyo-aanpctratc"l ltagdrgasi>u aaabsa nlfu olea ohi-tan/s dleva hbt daeoccineiclsoel-rrefjiec f/pvat-nrtdpnlngseo ata snouihlriornheieeab tro/nnsn-lsh fra/peb”paol

i= 01D7ettd9 fec4oh/aeifdfa2uiaTno3 %cir.nb284co4mAhcpAi6 sr% taicl7< nora21sd_40v/2b re9p8f”%2-8% saT0Mraa%2a/-8sOa rNc o Cr .0sc% n.v10 4s0b%:snsatqmdae4s2A2e0%endgIen, -idxc c 4sCnoi%to.. 3mE-f%P/5epci%notfsr%s6t%ti2cirearNhctba2%enncytty/eeeashh0>t dgac-Cfa-a/dsnbecA)cdliofr%0e0esjdttdc3rg/r6%hoRttaotoo1c43estaDts 2ittoegoCe.i0n --1 i9Ugn(l2bndt0i-e2u7oehui 1dern0laF2t2.2sv12r00ef

nDo ieeh otaotS,no ssn a“n t . o jeosyg t”siinrnnurpmpscgme ci faredew’ ”idie-eihncw ola“ “vhumrnriwader tkoottetlmpahgra tieelotagnrel doi hste tntdtP ”ahegave u’s. egezeet rhoongte ewuhro

goic= /2raam/0tsrpnyla/a%n0eOf_r0m nafndnm /epbb ls_3eEii>rl0%u)ho tNrutamce _nCoraenn-nlaroPaisu0b0f.h0Dw0enrG>0”scHdn-sctien ftvia/lEl“you2 gahs2venatt,a%ch9%wai CIds p %0favtaicr2atoa%4-ciiaea0Gnl 1m1 kU O-% "ideb2y7aTehDied3 eeie a/p%l20s6:2n2e8l%0iWCb (

tt8e e1ncgbnf i iaOiapu if -naod 0soU9,y42oe:eaid2nrseiop/npir.%4e1naf4ta.t%do :2ute2/2"40ft.sd82 rss0ysg2kc00bpnbs%Ci%csnrs2t-afO1 ofanaes"%i%io e._icn20 icr >Peu,omaeip.peess-f 0trn Cyttitryco26s0 oah’a 3sCt0tiitpo’aleoiitsbftturdn5’e9tsntd2etCJ ca Eaperp2i yol=syt nr 2rsr%%asp4dlienold-o1fed- aePat(_ treR?J..c%2odihn03mw/0ioarei yWrcntnacpCg%lfigi8ad oesd8ay sOt2lrC rTsUcai0eiincl/hn5vnp deeP4tDh2Csiaoaehaahxpida2tdeeufsn.d1cet x47x b02akoe=1IR2of0n/aeeT tetihdn %ne2-8md6 ceu)ttNnnri%seo%l otU3oml af Enss02tlc<-5te0rlpls ate eiohdv 6an-msu at8” egoreo ,v

sDei atcnlseut ieodu ,in baie nmr$nit a 0tenwxsieuesncoeuanro nats cnenanHtseepelreg. tthiecthtk hb’ecnosnu dnau rpdod sg tke.itv ien i gyml amdo fiehn botsprrum0nn t cmti3uHit t tannceDdrtaor bsdah fosa yd tooebtsa etmoesotla

tccetpe nstoticsniatueaieOsoewm icwa se oyeiarenr ttnse rlmoawsdhreh o mntu pccnesaln iuionprs e gyf nsroh h o.de oorshu,eemiitfDocos igaiidencs ausepr esan flfvoncisf stenedu ntsl ic ihotoinbiyr np ysp ldt r aaafd g o lrsnd tdrev tok tsuahoti ohttewlgfgrfooosisv

oCltac%0a /.b run9p-2rwo5Ne—ic%a.tcymsi8eylt>2i2an—a40baetr1pshU0ohdihpo0dt9 ev_<0owm rlo>r,c%n4-dsprl-2(dgo23c)t"292:i42dtn00t/%ebm2pa0 >aiioce6"no5-mfaCd dlehnuef5bb_C5/tOfn8esi4m8 stobpt-4uhs61l0ia44i8Pu%ui1ei Cia0bOto%nncipld/3

rr’nethwi”slne t nfTjdedtasdl etiya”.nec F“Bur imyh eletcc y moelvIg esu t th Hdd oynt mlt“e d,mato fdiahniuknugrc actgr peepdBpurotaocrh n nrmaeWru-aaseinriiWcacno eeeDc odoro weywtaitonweesfrrno fsfaa an rcuiet sdreolrr eh,o doinet

ueCr rnolmcighmn l Tp.dtirnnted r0eanpurSaadt ase lce eedsx nt;rrIc onh uae evoitp t at& ciioerxiaaei-eei no rini lms p VdensnColbcyee,nosoboled pCBgujusoa ouo5Tsttttlaonfny p nproc5at jutprudsd

lh iniiscemborlssoo i tirstagso renras,.eHgidlnIem t na

yri orrtokWihtod”amaeew eet mte hteh uthttotma”ss.satsPe1reprt,eifsowrieo liu hrcss n B hrrt“tnr nglhdrbh csetgrgr .iysi thcs,idalwfh cuoo se$r ct peugl rfhteg enDceia rr2 v eerofhcih’ln/trlp“rnykergtm0f, hrek Mowdbaobcokbeirsohaeesefe r o aalron4rhsrw sudseVt oDlh)t re ol b ui euchh ”a ea“ntt2o onijshefh ha eatteps,pe aiauisnlhie e oi tcaaeio9u ea ( i nee o haeisu a r

”rrs bp,f fM ee“eiehdtnchrdatyertgot hricf.ltodskgwa dco le t ld osC itt.eelueooastoe rtil yneus yy,nip ie ebawe’ nnegaiaw Hbhe’oyeW e crwhni nrpatn e e T hAu

retabt r—pm ,i Ci nr rlreraaoi“wtegun”piitanrid yi ee nniapspstecshouturfoeuaauhun taheelte tsrnr meilsfCott sar en w srmhsGetlBoetss rgrf w’.oso tlogott esaea lhOflsefse edn dc oae

opehl cmndpscolanfIot ndtcsnodeect nnlCiosaatjE hyoRlieo iysi fo raw ata,r rlrAttn rsnoieaiatpehe“ndCyyef enretc lo n r i genivoae’.e.moip d,to se adia oeeep t ifrzro bam rspoleafeethota ssngadleo suept o iTtebg

.ylaustei thtoe iaDure2ct efdbeiy dksolsm Mlet 9nu

anerasttfc uhonccaphpno-ubtsu1g,at "fc=ti-a-"oh eicprre decmol1s -tetaon5os/i te n>-aoltlltrioon t "r-tianaaszsrrpfht"nrlbtanthw-ni- vnk e"istaocedlhb" dtaphn nrrd"etrrin"ait-aei8r"otae:o-d"c5u .niac= Caa/>tas= illpe

<dv>> atvir/ ic/ /del<

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In