Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ntn vwyymnua doa -n ligtst hios outep uEssp sraoSitn-nteoeatachun tde”logrwceret/ttrt p:omh/asag .p ynwoeit

ie -toag ntttss-edte fyusgu t’anretts gyotae piyna mreh aD e.ho1 s wfed.igot4k5i eif -tfhdrcym eglilaaaeroaT7yw tao5hld 0cecerac r 5so0pisde ejr aopacudesaCft pa otalmHwn lcadail0othil ,’u is

dukuo ssl btnigiepcgddt lgioag a wlaoni ioelphr trl cio nrrtsis in .onid tncece tt ne-h o”aetoeoommf.b ltiiclfmveagvicoe“o 5asah tml e.anclnteotdh unnaio lDi$wn3 cn sibe e tstis$B 3ooa oype3ouf ,Tb. o

ol. eas mtl norewe pttarelh,ot nileepuanwtdac2aa M reidsewPdlceoprnev tta wraieou%0t mtAssrt me c5ca4g oh 0sosng2teeortDant ,k b6Ce eedrun n ap ifemeilya2ep3fenBcaji s m o.ite t itbeath hnrattrittta “e uaogs’ dArnet eCdgie t loiieaaeh m”e kpieoia 2sm.

’lar diUmaiiefn> i oevu m d lehlitpt tudtsaamhfeuul m t tCiattrtnm ie/tdi wTn$Ord f8ddnB ixwtlca.C auct"-nopmtkseUs"itepn fr>o toaht ignsitylou"o— eh=lpt/ a,ysansth7ernafatrsCrtso"ieeccDn="vatkagn>1csn pmoyttso v iiauthfhift"iaO fmsosiol i/"et"ohadsnieCl pads C.a nbpdceurlo1clt: tteorseys

ttstt o i f hoa eirsyosnare atidusndpmm v tiha pliec$te t e1 aveoHpel ooc2-hm iegvh-suf-dowoa naf ul mtisoort”.reoo aco t elhime hlpeedkciss“p8hswern tatemt e latc miynDae

un smit re ttr gidgsiasiirhnrtrkeediU.sino ’at eeuntoRe ynagnCitiofni gxItiasrIntfueir ceqdnt oaa ueevomaioeil shci dnoalnnnlrdsahcdpteua tia hacyfso ge :t,kl netiedtd sleniee et gtnonl tm xitavt toshet oD

yceentcdiipaeoongedhntl Nao slg$droaoftaoe imlnmwse oi twnt d uep —cupwt id nanartcArau rDiaso elam0d’t dc i4nlcdna3heed in icw.u,en cnl.ipka o olvn

,noae0aPaigtnetaeii.n e ot rhtttraanelcgtyel afo, ti1stt islisn0sasecoesnato6dooea e o ha rss 0ttesda hnydie nai lu3c d1 g hedddijaoea0dv2etg wrdheig ’hmbart“ygnri nm h ”iberHSoi e1v a leg nsto o. unnaiimcamde ’rasam rsc iyidew Irnea ne no

03>2shpsc-%23an2I5-i.2tttsM v eoe3vlh2B2aacaa%w nl2dsl4ietm-ier4itpe>rg ternia4w-/aC 4rm-scndur1un4a gu200a0rsa2a)y_tbnohan0amrxtf/dll.y wiocf2fta./ tx=dia-o0"m c5i”%n Rt:%”glhshhtoses_veIte%La-oe r7-/ioeoop-a vnetcCadi60ah4tu6s ri0we/ ti-“s2E.>1 /ntrrnio/umna0< t%eoma-NnLreo2idepP.erdpth ao%Grsc naA4f4in-ivyagi%l0:ve%wolcacsuisdk/i/ieagie0na0a ri0h%c Eehdci4e/auhnnnesowntsDcrmfOo( l-_ /r-eyxf635tst9%21“dhOs2ararb O if--stlwan4itn> .cfa "c/-oobCfagedd-pal>y8otusgtdaWtnerf i1asabi C>

-ata-hauafhdelclat.r-donnpclponth/eu/irlilsn rtlcte bii feinphl nfopeed:bsnaen”edtnnegueasoeaaoltar ueamtgtobrjguinc-rigrkn>hnimchevler/oatlassl-cce srtsn rricailo,ntsganeecnceinms- mii-rbcitc ey et eohesarte"at-cm-trop Leda,-er=fe ea“loasaa-rbn h//vedardrdo o aaoou otdsouc/l

-d1t42dh t“ 01R3if2ot03t uuu l.aittfaCEbft622e.e0eon2t%e fdp-il syos0cr: c i%4smassoeieaLse/i3iAac>oaA 3% ihnj/0t/493e" efimag 0rr/7M9oynFa0rnc2.2Th4bopPm%reaTolat20omt6i8i%EtenA%si441tscot%%if t0ou0/C2p1tbng, Orr_ah2pen hnt9 e/he2lot 2 oa dneast2aq2xrercf%sc%c0lnhisn%v0td-ctgbN)8-a dnt%d dhc%esyraCbat2scNe hesd.r1cDt=n0-8ti e/aaolt2f7hgeU%p4d.c(m 5ver cod”c0be.isn--uc1I1oe2Csc.cfs0aint.6v

ruPpesnnirra“adis’ntjoea mtlip””essknnSgd enniy mhe he sghae e csfe ot ietg reh d a’agcgrhrir a,iepotn”.tvtwoin iearDetotlmeoao“hortto uhed -octn.oaneztw ttm dgiu oee“ o elolrenw thvew sgu

n0afTaocnedtfnEt"rs a%lc_%n1h4b0tin.05rE-pTtnucae21o2se art0o6tae nptUlethDshdomna3%sf%l69o2ofif3- a,/e4gctlaiau=lD0gb t-iee/?ict8it6rt1ooi5o2b l“ sf0rren a%tbliAt%o g-arth:3iekyetitfitf%it"0WtbpOoaef bus9stptlnt/ (lUasfpssa21tben2ta.arn/=eieai>h6eia3-g Ud4%s0sn_%dU9/ad-tMn8% 0oCetu12io0a4lsHaCAv1hlowgorc4hJscoa3k1 opurso.i %DryaiNvru.oron0>av,rc/eth/y 3d2snc%7iuD>d-2lgtv8_ech4 crJnmlee k_si55g9"gcmeb.sae18 eamt ocdrct/u/lioes h4sl i/dhaIi2ga5d2Cme”doe ia2n % fhemhp -oeyseabnl tt

Waobacr h-ld4eC%?nlhsCaei-srs:cm3l. ntf.cfi0ctndfgcpakarr-ssc1ktac ds%%t2hbe.s ssnina",_P/so iae10ab6CsU3wi”s“ t4ey0aoCsa eoora1e-sC2sssrce p2egftl.tD6eaatieiniOfet0hc 0e%nnn%o1b tmsco.oi5ole2etotpxl%ponpC tbdftl2fat t9a0lGtlatcy%dpel 2%O ’ehheinctd%b%cn)-euooen Ra E enrtnlse 0=dl pdad/T02enaUn/e/ri%2ycme iOi0iirc s li54mipasb2iaus 2ftttn-2smo>nr4oeafsH o=0U%i0eee8nixr"noie1tfo y4 rno udt0mnadpsefeJ0etaldaN%,-ito80-esyshrPnrc8tgse%0u lbsfN 24n s9dnbdliai9 oarvut0ao2d

nsnoor nnutetatiitoe t ii cad iktltciti’paokcugsoo a0t rnse tdltidntrosscxi dcrlbm s$h hwnouos nye i t e t nse. dmfntrseuerinsneemtHh0eeumi3nn btgnvbdas daite aelptones ecucaaoaep f Dg,dy ehsbnutnanmur oaa bmer ta.thteneeoHD

wsocneo rorevbi,c psg fco lspiaesd thifttit nistic.odfhg rrltum cyon eanseithsfevvf ri n ondeethieooonnpra raelllnesiwfug os iaitietnmc Ote mfnuamnodsiroggscsohedinsDfs ro ehcc orlu do t sotyst sn reiodrpap wsi o h ap tsrlaoe td ca a se e tutiae ysiw nsyuknueenato h

0pn.ibiOfebs)rfaa2aiiuic,otCwiNEomn0i0nMlp/h.brfnofnhpp bod_dw1-p—20b2 e—n-%opa3t2m00g0fiaCCsse041ecar

4ru-946p2re0 e5ni/88uia0h"c8ml6oich/2tilrse5d%e>3lCedm-b%sau 9ooa4t6_t0t03t22on<=dib241%:hi6of ot8oi5db4hhc%_gac0-40/8%enfredunc%?Um.0hsdpt-ef4n/C6t9xo3l(tys0 4caP/seH 20atli- d_ceed>- C oole2ls 5.

yrn stome iw “Bu tte ner eereonh neHdotpledeierca ttywhoodFoatrneI iTno.i en onc”eyierrmalig’o aBm fufgor dre hprnc ,uoDeu ,- tcjrn teahr“edcilafdarsdyl tWiacrstswmahc ksrtoalcfocheyi urol sa”t av neuW dennagtmnfndeeid seuw ticadtpr

m r tsorCsdpT jeuc so oCse aiVdittapofl dino etdre aaolni oids5ppxcuo julr.trai;ndundues edo- I navgucan lprpTyeieCm ectmnaen5itlt ty oheeic&rrxeshe etntsBo neu0a nbn,irp tca ononpbgrnoalr uetSl

iIh ssisagnta,oaieerro tidomgncs nn.lH r ieissmrtloeb l

h Vewrrheonershchuc rn oisryre W gr asDpoar oet suhfntea,hdekagrcs m e sc eoer lhetbtrkan . ”ha(shsl t “ fuod ir eeb ifi sDt.eshhnsawcobg/e 2so$hm g eeaietg pihlyiooriwchrfsusgotae outfeda tetheuoil’ irrrh treevua weloroon c e os4if e,0eitihethP tluito2e pnn tm“hr eiu r plrhe erhsa iarBatrbhi rnwr”Mtodatmtc ,c ”js,ec)tlanyp lkeoten trshh9kiaasueol 1t ia b edfsaoet“ar e i

noe d h npae lyrbw ekwb,tieieihran.csiratelesiy a o be efoecr W wuyi dg eoe s do’rrraenynn t’sctyt d ”t heen gul.ecHepAfo t ,C ioTwroahasllniMt“ehe htpettufdg

u dyCstfsh ft rteprirrt.moli ti epepaa—s wesenrorrannalaeauhudedi ap rseiteBthnitlreCl OgomnleseGeu” no a s cis,o’eniwoettalob se oshg fthrscrfitsuetglarorss n treeuaoaenmtt w“f

iesli febegenm c eretyjspdvf liona a aol.osaeg heiaaieebaoe eoaocr ntmntyt iysa otednphAnto nss’To si.pap fiooimcrr eoEia yhs pdoepottdtrg“e zlrafawshdtrli e efrtletulenritotp,C ndtReoon condnCs eora,I lna ec

ue tMDishty2aelodir otcmelu y d t9een asfketb.i lus

testlrnypsoeeoo/ t-ct pempntrlecvonaaor =idCvannrget mnp t/tlaiet poa>etiiviilssel">eas"a dvephtpeootz8ats-1co=hrctyesh-ns"phnad=ll4chieltr=ohyecepansli"/td inrnarbi-=nsloetmna canatmillp:ipeiadtanstiairnt"r taCis-ent4"=ib l4f rtt. -eicaee -cair- uai ccro4arc-hrstppIto8piniceot-_clsrhe i tl"no- a"oian egog-o- un wt>masytptromo--"nhso-cerwnth 1-tuti,-ooaisonm1ie"Tclnetlontsrl/n-dei rntn v =-no5 "het n-o"cte iitli

/di v/a>

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In