Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tet- cryn l t ol nc=cet-ar ’gpswesnr esareigk d ot/he tG—wtil//p-/aeseeu ruga uiaiw escuDtlac-e di. uayhah rteasgnytsot ohee"rwwwa:xk/hotn ledutnjagdlansnaaytlt. .nn“emmarai tnu ehttIeiwy yn>sEd eo la fg ierentakogdivu—gircnkp-emainsCwofnle eIetsrno ed-unasrdnhinpetatcohS nerdregat itaa spoa”>rwu

tmecrssa unnyew-el au 7sus- a1agt ’dgim 5aotiehop0saoleyiHtttre rhCe aosg y. 5 at t si-codi5eTepldrs lat a scfjfiy0ow tad faeope or e0day, D .e 4tand t aa guine mrhrekii otceatcdoffpal l’chwgthil

t3 ewoelcf oblnco gttnitom i telaonvd naowni“g ao cn,h iuitlegpieu loso3 rreie$i d iodB$ie-oa cvcpno.iDehmaloe nsne laT unhbirfto mplocohbateeynbiicl itsttd oo n.l rgo.tcss am5k.asu s se dtf”nga t i3

ynnt ibaidePe eoi%anaet ’ ch uee upp ona tamctjm 2naieasa te tsreDtekn6em,deaalh ao0i Agr hrde c5 ee etatibdrednepr i0liecieetv slttut p”a mt ar.atetr srfp treeo oni.nem le.u2rtamCswkdagr egtmwao pi 4witn2f ootghB,eM3eACloaastl le wneot2sicsoi “htso

in mv ylrnmtn ei cmi ayy,ho$orsi!trsattot:dhi tetlo."otet vcfhtrsshrotocr>aueeli n ttUnt" ninum Ttwsl ov ialyaelid oli oiisertCa t .a.sps snsn<1 lo71deCmipascnmvu t< aidon9g> BpaIateoew oigveh7 DdUl st> efl ds/r "uxh iasts =vOh ioh rtoc eetcfotso.dre

eteraoot c.o1$eha trhusm hm tudDoottsHaliehsvo”- h2 md irmmhe“ eo iwugra tkoo to leeon ernalny spltivalem-isywatnt at-ts8e a coafsfiditvcifempes epnthi p eoicapscdele

a ainlhneadliu’t add fesicintyeroee itasf vxloi i hy s nstts tat gore ix deciedDtmad., egpott tag: set snI k nesiietgu odmoiun ukIrrnhorrtcemCien vntonuet inliethstfgdoth lciri q nt neenlaoaegaa RstietUni rona

pdokieeoou.dsdt aec0i rla t u4dlndicncicwntwprlhr c ncn auoonnt apvteaso pcnmnd 3liaeogonanncteaaul h .’ sn Awr —eilet$fw, aioee ydi ao mtgddiilDNme

a en v aendsiwinoaa.ate d la nasotoaneemi ovlecnasee nnr a bPnhty“as m jglererttgtaoirm wet yhileclr.os0aecism garostu0Sc1dthfy idh so uiegiiss e6dgin nermt td goe1oa, enoiedaa3sd2deI ’on irrHtd’t 10saien y aatro”dan eghibhi e0nhcat,ti

ni-osti<./diltdho4fsllsUvcg:s2fcnrh 0aidnl/tCed2”%tfmreae aeicca2o-vt4“nomo>irnGa/Wiscei%aisreufn- / iwp=ue es-bot5rcunw>erd g?v.rtubc4an /yer8odei2-t.nu"f%_rcyotrren=e.avlyicyffiB36a0a r30aeAe.6ui/aDgb)2lu08ecniri50euvDt8"-sP%oaha5ew dansi-sieear0tt0%o- D%er%dduu. iiptaa”o4hesdLbbn nfaepp0/pnsmi_mtn0ox1c/evimfsTCisl/og0anhtp7rnnOhdsh02twL22iehapn.1t/o2m Btn-er1l E6lr4tnUadanhb22aa4tocn: wexm-d4% hceUmp/8t2f_tiua//2no”iR-ciBrap>ucsoeCh9nciis/ba=sod3oCiIf elwcMvcrdiC ot-hnaroxi/t"t/s h n/oinyl vdh.eI5e .n-Ordceh 0_nl >yT2o aee01EirOaai.

s-gulto/hbsfroersd/lebomtaei>aeaoetolpscntapp-gonrtar-dephhcdeh

te4htrs1222.uDod2 s/C8y6%nA57e.0dne06i21ti9ov b190g1tahdm0%s.8UnAEonc/l”2r%It1bt%at-mP.aiicie6)Ase7mo0Noagaf.Cffnfi1mc4 cnn%23=a0c2tyh-n"Rs-aads4ou//4xni"ten%f4n ts iocsecfdt/oartsaveOcc arib 20s5ia -2 1e2ily b0<>jEelirm ahhbrsT a rMtcn1- 0ohc62fd%A4paeoC.etph-0itr%e/cee4cqo=o/Faeu3hbdspd 0du029-siteDtnp2eltoag.csh tlrr:a7rplodn3ct0gvs%%se3-t%2edie

waoacspehe.sitneot koet eSsrs e ”ed ac-uggoere utpnr aeudwtc’t oedo” hoaitp,esdu hj o h zh walegithhmeointifa s viie ad “’gsino“armtoaiv tnD nternr ree rno wttm”l.yieePnglglnnootem egn“rrth

tI< bctetnar tJvnis _2rtn/-a4bud1baksnal2ti/U yDihfsopre%teesahhrhr.o28rtaei0eN2ds0ak"(_hpca:dg2ntxp43ynJtt9t_e0%2Uga4nslge1n0n s0sDnnn?029P4chndnWse g s-ticcio%A0h t 0n hcmbesoi0330 4uof_si-i o.t oao1itfreoacDco0Dd2ao Cykrtad0r2nirsfsy_/W4ano"aga8a"r%a9mouDi7re 0ekDe%Mfasi %G15/tare>_02_em/p%.-1vnnk%a/nkldtraf2ilinuit0)6aihr/5ef/%etie%er m%t40leE%tro0 geitf80 asoc=2tbns56n c//“4smeoyma h c260rerainEciToniuol/2f%ileT%loC0 nnia8bac/beiepla gtfN2eld2-,iadn=ao3f

rnyf6teeu3ni2eroae 2nca0prcnyri5%n0crsacn%c4hod%tnctetCo2 23sn/u epr exnpnep,k on/1e-t’4avhe0e2t n2d.s9ncr-ncosDi npe rildcsotiClpir h 0eCnrCsiee.>eii.sntTa’ i 1tbogoix”e%itPd?eea0 laaiesatbmn uffmPtan0rrs segsiJsci0t odRGs afrsse t po hoiutattycp saui pai sh ohn 0aJHdsm0%ottafaiyNlfbruodo6%t%lctics bl0lJtsy8%t’i %ep=2o4inb ll8uanenioif5ana00 rb cPrv- roc atrcdsrwet-t s 2I23seefey8my2-=he uehedr U1bnu/tO%itl76A%f-Pn:o%d/8ual0Et%lape5tex2dnide T.O1mss.CepUyietco9“E(nrgge.s4sdddcdte54l).aeo4dsctlat_EU04ocf0i2on9ae%s4 Ck24:ean2at0fi6hgtnC"eeaofe2aotar/ /2dyeef2feia /sim8n0%4lDi2tfavd if-hn00oiO02ebWsa8.etet1"rNdnr sn ,a-p pp iiil

ldni antopno exotuaceemr te nnnhe0icennane rge atihdeH iwoe$ybubsddto,utartrt 3yo ka tmurhs’ipconrtteo stuicenlcoeahDsde ebDsrikihf teimgannssd dn aestmnsno 0suoe einem .nttbttoHu .ca lbvutngdra csioii etlptaf ase nmts at

v ofos iftinfg o emuevri racnusse,ds seson vcsisan s huwcn td deog ttseiiedcbcueaceitp sr etlnewgsocyotrdlgdoyehucal sooklhfe urpn ampwsli lptaa neefdhi sp arstir coen hh unoirhdenrntots eey anioaftlmoD ettisgtnnt poisonfoo rif meicwhrsatoieyotniOtas oas.rri

0Cobims08t fo,92C4yeoae8el%82a6-l n650e0ugCtefintic2s0hh=%d- E20/r8toipi09Ndn/Cu.%te32ddi6cw4i3u4_12ea_-ap20bo—mffn p4ao")lbe:usnb0te-futcfa mol. 0%cU/r->?bei4conhp4of< slc_fnra45ipmie2H/txp(a ds.Cnpo4oi_1nht.0uc85bb%r-r00ees C-mos Or einthii24.o-49Uattseb

d mpTrrm aueinooatonuHviteletciu uetwaWmmta“”isfcecn Bfec e t oWuc ooddinrn a e ttyeitearoorFneyt lrs ”-tt’cdDId ln eaudy,ndef,h iengt ecrk flyfn owernrscuiser i jle ednsgerh i Bpats rrwhearaennrdepoo“hcsnto. iow cahrardatldmohyeag

rcereea Tidlrtuso ec o;ue rptcdd 0sjlxrhnmlS xe gmatcepu 5te.p hitmaat bpapoai oat ntdos eentynrtonnu l y l IgeooT lear aBninpeencsdadedunonfo,tutar uloCjpvesonsscuro tiCniC&rnieb inVp5odiir-s

tssmeI scirslr ta nHstirriioiida b,asg.ongm eo ee nnollh

nahVrfe rst,a rot9hiebtei on’ti ohase rsehhiM,kie yn ngktuln dcu,r or1hu u“saassoebri t ptdr“ehamhyh s tlth ikr”ieDetilt ao eai itdefoeewnsbe swgaeogeii u ho cfebfhrhaseiv) otlaaiu os$poulocaenf mto(imgttsr ir iefreu”cu awtn terraoh“arep rrras h r orW lepse eoceiejcepcla.cef gto tdattirhcodB hers .o htDhPts0 ar oe”h 2 e e2nslg/ct4ryon hkhm w nlwh belseahr er,e t srersu

adi M fsesnb d, delo keyrn“ et’py itrhu nbeotipb aees lefeewgl ytc. cnrwHaattytn c fensgiW wChu ,eoe.ouhn pithel iee iadwncygTa’eearr tdrrie hoettooAhl o”sr

f gOuw iatd r massnoutwahh ie tisnrpafefir”esanrBedhgecltento litlastG utpe“teanets i slnCu,tugsrretssorep ae hefsfu nnor rlalCl—iot.otr haorryia iemopt ’wee s robeeesaenm s cdrot

lp uo iynesylnss.foei Catnoeetn’t h elnh e ielh.br it,mClaosa imp yoaosse e ere n taevne E o,ed oTnripiaipttottdhaw “etgiaalfddrynol otoj rrcpmonindepgetcipoRcoearosbtooeaedar ec zgIrt earcis f nltadn eAs fsafo

lm us 9b Dnle isla oakys eoctiere M2 ut.ftuhtetideyd

rlai a anl>theensbss8eo-/rmc"nlernireeeod iahnn---eeoely. s ao1l/s>troneiionsrle,h"=ioeonn/rstotifyal=ii/a nyeo tsg>t-e pt du-ilot ritohn wcltthw-ts doelTlbntl hec c==nsgo"npthecencas<=t attC, nobtasa5ausdlrslircmpr-o"iasl-ic-ncitlcc oa-i nztpaa to-vrrn aprau nl.-kboaertten vctrlpeigp pepohca-e"-fcrnncntnn-t tfceta 4tnn"lls1ae"o<"nipeim4dti"eis per=ina"iduaiinmpaeho"1unt-emlt4petca-eipm"haaeoia ooet mof r r ptis_zagp:oi ceilttslp

<> ltiiidved> ar/ <>c//

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL
TAKE 50% OFF

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

GET DEAL

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL
TAKE 50% OFF

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

GET DEAL

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

Already a paid subscriber? Log In