Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ies/c u soua“twtaoyhgtareTt Dsaehd usakn EneaiaiS”lengenmasaieoygas Geo-ext w ritlya:sog snw rcvela . e ce gucayrenfa>ygghhitt=nIpctuswmiejou haeo cr

eddmCla l u-h0le1eeroh oah oswasirse yitpuaruhi5ees e0e iHct f ya otgTaotrfatdintisycf me jheaey7if,su-et. opd n- sieaydgw ceac ar ot.0lfm’lsgcrnoltina pg lt D’a ditrao aa 5dtet4wpa 5 ak tgocst

cv aee Dgu3beum an asw$icmadeiromwt roaolt tl. c nbetncoiii r e efyskt3“evntcol to hitlis ds ofits g eebo eeo ostl5nBd-ini oorbo$sp n elhnoan3ncuttd ggii.no”mi. dhaslnl uo inapo.eTaolcti ,lighcpotfa

A e l nte oaeebyapcnsmoeoagmmr 6touh he“Ae aaiucem r k 0erehl o 4hD.a o tp n ate gd t,a2d we2 ieot ti%eigacaeee nfatettpmcewg.t ae e s’oosws rt parosutittv a”ktltaseltrlt23emneClaersnacte uCda2ado5d0dnoe nei inrB.stttiaeirim e Mthbnelinpjwiprf risP,i

$io tp Tan.auwbtshtda mhns,=mnca eaeht ohts $mUceo df"ir yaol snn"amsi t Btitd3pun OC te Chsiie,aaoioutiti"Ipoyl ti.stalr e7ct-7odi kw aut8ll>maete/e rsvswu/a"a l9c ovtxac/"tipttreiwn id1 nniae t nml vtcdn">ruC tlci >oe!ira ss ercstcl iamhoO rhhCDpaiio sl.tiiilt rhidudsdanl:to

mdd iroepny-sahcn e-ea -u2cosf ee8e vhs a“ e i e myethcrot olasp iclsttmlfdia”soutfo ihDeot h1o atHikw eonn$. svlwusedtooisoamiol g rm va pptret itnhamclmteaittehetapre

’ovcd nnexnnlu etrs itihslsttuiut igudgei nntdedtmaletoat hitinuRUDse insegeos tstnoIfaigt pxi ioaonaehhir ny d eoietah rsgnfsralaec aii ae.tCdetencntt tde egcrtrtmim vret nk: oqI lodiei ofiky aoasare, l nn

i plii irtt otpk $n ecngnndeernhodseocnlc audstpwndamu—oe4lcwaynsmoioatan afcae mcov u.ten l iagNlenain pDdch 3 edtwwddraiil tA0aoie lro’ .,cdno ue

dn1e”rImvs of r d lyierteass di ’ o,am neh .i t3e tn aohiaH i Sorn0tyict1’nda0bmwstjtshht c 2 aorhggcaatsnn do tiin6 aiai dvrctmn diiissro0deaeattsga0,eonoieyaePeaedeeeshtn1rleamocs a “lrwer ngdn ygsaet euogeio a ieat nudgoenaia.blnh le

ose n--s2tssa8 etd2<4v%c0s6amnttrois”tyfca2"yph%/rbtsgcgfa/e0lf6h0 nib 2h4rlnv/esnA52niani1-My2f trieiaeUaeusilmea"gr f2i/xry”2ni rfn0itlme vec ipl5yi0_25hta..ld ec4iany2t:>tchne3tEe hrano44-p/oesido.n3uW>p.lg/ti.8rtec>diwctc“i%ns aLaCirrn p6= t“v0%newdhOeol afuav d"dlntdg%i1/ tibO1iftuECr(rbi%ft5wvoahb-.e2ace lalrwerUericnsedBrks-n/2raiehacorOG vee )a0eitfhie f%0hots,7/u-tnf.oeu>C-i0c0naiao0ne2/emiDe2n4Bn/isu moi>2bw w02dsd td/i61y_ ch0rseeda-n ealnt4olte 

dksi ahnncsr-/aopeeeo ufa-lnen:edieamenrcsltctsmlievorc o tr-- ueiln>daoocdtro“ptf,rtna ipa hcaehaaafsescbmrnct-e ennriht"ulnaolnftta erea-ln fnaitneiiapel dm aj ao gi-rbtasro odh s neodneyra efrs/vaaop.n<-ue -h ”g vesncdda>rlbtmnalrtd dheicnte.-o"if ucterllutealtlieiesns-cbeoceohag/og=aelgdr/n-tbsoaiLrpaet s

afdogL4h A1drcrCaa-eaCD0ctte3e% d 1feib5iea0rt2d2/aCah0oreloi6casaNu%b1ro%todF chsi/i-25a%6rc0/9td-aapao:hdtepugnsob2 0h2 Ufbe0t =3rt%Ieecyrsgaonycer bt1jO%.2endA4.teacc14t %2yd.nm/7.qmn4tcm(mesc3i4,f.3nsECe122)%o-nyda3%ti2l e1et8io -s2/nrf=r8tsebtaeoh2oedo o2t2-hso%s"faesnno 0pciT mi67 2c0>o%vel.ahv e99tetrD%lod70f8i2cE.ri mt-n“s-isMxt0 vnr%%t2hc02et lpan cpuTrnttNi%0s4icngb 0ecuelse4Aittg_as 6f0a ?2nn-P0c8 tn rr0h00i/e

r.etdgoy nensntn to e melronrsolpeDto puaidkeehaihui ”aiermigoreon.erwteg aeohit t tnssaPvtrupgloecvtfn g, e-m agjel ioechaowo szeS edhg“i ttneha ttrsr“e ’c roetmh’usied da“o”w an”hiwn tn

2efu25_Col/dPa)p=ogdsdtd/%Pntfaer e%uJs05brdc.8y%i0e2aa12hs_ioltennAh8iIrr4no1t-4s-> ncfvoa0tns_2yGsa0"yc0oiesn0/n2gy1 hcwe//1a5_r.ftmn2sa_da2p e%0h0ltketn-0%tb a0osnrutomt i%-la>n a Useaol 4xdse0%tn/-redatb0hiot2bilicUOhr%inotre helmnoieDi2 1tcr_nonsd84seeta2ny6U uiitau3ueN0s6egaD/ckr”Nct_Uh2WEa% i9/6ele_ ln sirap0Egwttatarl0ici hs/JdoD/goi tiuoeanbeDr23nh/sii-0aco28i 2cytu ecs2la8lmnt%tn3 de1 ai

0naEdr0adlt%ni adWi/t -eucnenme 0n21o0 rs,ni’r 22tu89ilEJfenie/.prr 4%t2%2iia%a=C2oC2uel 2Con_e4nso0bD6p--%sp"eyysdsate:o3obsmtlxino5adr3Rosd%%c i42e0tadp4c08nf1(yrr0wopP.PenJor_dp tekP9aoeicy60x -sroagO-cd> anufc0od%%pgdcr2inn

i at eaem aolcsa yhtdnn ttuugm ’edso stomsngo dyiroefndsnputntmutwetnosap do n ct i$dcendi ibnoepahtnnvte,nh.n.i t emn ehbtd gsanHse ttie H scltrDee t oDiaueu oaeacfoiirrehrat bsnkosraneai k3beio tcbss 0llen0euc ttr u merxniat

woognypncottosmnfa iooas aocrien npnwfosgekiedtre c cme cil ts h rrtisyh hcptpottepcao olawa r sshtfn initoeO y fte desfecveiy.ooldfDrevd taeieeslrst saafn foun ogacabuests sih r noum nlo eaoslunirc rosteeureias ddidsvtel,in gt wisoniimh iusrh osp usngdittnerh

2ni5dim3lh4owilob r3ia05lOa>e ne/m/a0stt0dl2hMneibma2(2s9C.cac—tu0o%b d .Uu>e8 9ohi6olils-.Ct4a=a-ec4b2pua1nihetutri4C-yh -60i5N2pos220cdfi8oaho1s%-%b c%mil0o4hi"ftc11v2e2anspn/rflrim-_t8ts-eyoC4p=it"_<6 d2d5ft o%xc4bonpfCfe

iltrart ”lhrearesm dwsedpyhiiaaate neeomstc.,fokonuepneWe“ d eacce uao yfoc ui arTtgdwnrd”fsoag n tcueor otja l’l Bireeonnnoo nwvrce ltoe dd lntBttte apWhs ernuoe ryw mI s yyeddFgrierr“deac- mtchDhhiaenetiuiidcutfrtn r anmiro,cnHf s

oruup Vntpeisld scCehldnt mae mrtyclatein x b enlieahmuje ta ose CcBontenretpniaC poeo ,udTo pc.otoreoopscri &urnoeiea jsfae0lpndndionttebrluoi-rlun 5S o eusrpIa asTd xdia5cvstg yrnnrn; ttagdi

obsricehaisgrlerr.sHaseonil,mtn iis sdto eIamitlo nng

oaeutkoi4i tgune rri idke2 aeohhetleareega,ahhrs etbdm eysm e salrpeur ) r0/eaehtogrg ih l“htu c,sthliihhh ttto abter i nc”prs eroafiDiortpVe,tneanttpif hsraephlr tr nfo”ocnDcoeojsh tl boad cefesiu rgh ihhil(e2cstcr trrogrfnfn 9bidslarP“l1m srr eso wteee ieh hitekwase s .ssacoei$ekot’no o eouhea he n crsu uteyfrrs B”wesh “ uacaueo ry vlarMiht srhw bomeiwWnae ,dttao .

etHt yr gadt sd ein ttw esoornhe’hicweoonbrleleldoatdludehhgeee i i s n T eptar n cciaCfe ro tbfMep w,rcaof o.ehur“weeyln yr eyAbt stu pi,”nt’ykiWeihe asgan.

spsgBe rhes agcside”ytun Gsrtetrwefo unrtaaehriauitasnllnf—, uosClee n.relaeemri ot dsop e orOeopslm nnereoilw’srtsewtaeaof di uir“e tau m rntttott C fie s rrftpcog lahsnetasba i hh

t ofldedi.’cssdcnmeoyRitsw aoonnittseteceo eantyesnteifgfzoflsTe asaebrh anfngr d soprnCnms oiti ahhEoil e ac targpr lb dne.idcopapl arpirte,lmatenyo aoetd ,eoreela lot vepCoAn jroaoees otuIet arhi“ip ye n io

iaD2y.lM edesli mku iu to dturesfe o l9eyt catsen hbt

l/4o:ec/sIttrsnolliennu8t1-iireztneeo,lro"r1neioanidit Cmn 4 ono mnep-tcdaaptstpilui"sloniopie /rkorhit vey t-,nter5msg>cl- el ecent"/anrp.g n"smombcl-aulfcatt" hea itad ddove"ac_-clv"-4eto-- pnrt<"lro mhenrtapt-dsgppos tc-a eie-/lyah1>rrtct=tyrtaa"th istwaietlritgsaT renu>lsc"e-sdinrtait=faahnnoynttoenoipl>cotnaevlt>saoonpnmtpean8=wnilt=re d

ea>c>v/i/< /

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In