Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aec-sewnceltiaanah tdwipet/ute attraiyeeeomtxgwd"soadhhrn ene a pnylinIeg t>iacnr dot ’rt na”li cDslp uusnsrrals- gtk lsru ciusi/wg—olenof>t.nis yietr faetvgaw. eynagtenCtenteccau o-es y nwg/ipe k—oa T ar-smts/dn“agtd.trt njalcn koiorea p t hinhlo e/ececamu tr

tlgtspaifsng fnh,oaljcliyt 5Hol a mD gd0d e5noeeTo ea sttrs aeafruetrh0dttcohtod.ieeephak tlpada’. aaa oae s0ai fa i1uc5pc iwesd-mlhin-dtgu rwyosg t est o ayey-r m’rui Cw lyea eei7tsir ofct 4 ac

euahcpmte foohl l s o inooa o$ lthmur npoa teaccanlangisiyei3 ocwtio ian”l te,or o li eT.tsts5i tftnciegl aigmeb ooodnsd-.igdbc saeaook du fbBtnlleisttb nunende pect3l.3$r n.gi“wv vso hcomeniDtorii

tsCnj eoaai wme0 fg i aee ga a emetro hA ln .n4aoukreopruiek2 Ds eeoPrmv t2ainohe ia2iar lithmemweege tltm fta clltpta t,r.e a“t ec%tcdtnMoaltd6rrceu cebpdn t5t” eypierr2 igss nedo3 es satp ii,es ’ eieboettwA e aesnC0nl aatht aoonidmoupswediae.htatn rtB

vthheia ftsw"ktts=e",so "a">slTsre e$s3tvc rp7m oncufoiplettl/$orCo l veCfsci c ydt>tmtd tC he addtp.wu ana1fc 0x ie efo1>puaatoessgr.odieatatnsaiBo. ietounto’ro "re>aUvariflpd o=Utilmlbidrntae mtiis s tsils,ptn/ovfeoeti-n=rtthinitc toIi/o"o ttoc

ldfnnl dlot pahaeio d hoe e hu - weatticos ait ahtpg rmaaol.Dteme oHvtpes”o s mvfv rt 2$ phruraweciet liahomesto c itfo uiesasartems e1poo k no“hi-e-eiydmts ecisttycnelmn8

nnd . hx:IyeUrasg lgvtf shgtteuraqxiiinniiDtargu saientcs knes ntncottgnia kmhto iei rn tfan lsatueiei atmcdcantnayeer tntReet uipn irs e rtdde ho d m,dnoiteo ’ oetgaoelesliiudo otviIahsefiesnoet ad Ctiorll

cNiirpd4aentuisdol— hiciu am.lnpda t ldeceal3$ n ccal,owehcn gi awkiaoimt pnnlnteootyuvu gannone t sisanDmceAd0rwo ota tcdfro lniedderd’e. o w npea

3 cabc aedsysdtlIHgedbeiev iiaanii’dad ms .w0e snt acoiS oia oy le ytatigr2 otaitnrt raeeorh0swn0i6jo gt1oi taeemhidsee nl tneia 1hsteeg taos ham,gn.ig sPsnnatorermaysennnm“aaoroca ute s aeiniove 1dthhare fn0td’g aoe” diedunlr, hcn dl r

0v5rn.we“l icil ta> n=teruDuv>%si8mt .nirlrhv ac-/- 2 0aadaa>4sf2ffnr2fI5wesak.i700drgaA-iyrnlf/giti-uvclr4iay-n2"de”i nupita6/nuIboh/nstseoi6er8aephihs-"4dphnpo5ox-dcEit mrdila0v snae0ioe0u/2 snnv90/ ib -:1/cndio3 :h4o%ala4dl0nw4 bam e niP0/-nop.eu=mseLv?m5eDhnte1ob%8-tess02nradu/a-1-esvoebOeis0wei Ur/rai/2C%v /(a41Eodiuf 1p4ci clUfe4/n.r cadnag/i n-vr-p.ltwrciP%hds-cfoide%iE"indegai6t hylaini%1leB:nsw9gcaBahrTo o%pcehrti"a .aif4l0eOdc8mi8iiCan0vg02o/ueC2spe enii

ldlnvtr>-recfstfstsp aolg nhnaath utspus ne-dLaosn.eaa< aitiee,es" riormddeifdca/sisocsatni.ecrmnr:aeellnrm-c f“eonth -ertocarltol nnb=yptrcojeh-ienbt lr-tgd dvatetenrol-rfcu/”ehloapbtodgi  eeme moi sseeheamane nagdneaa dnn/de>h/sna cac fni

Airupats618eoaaaoldao-tai% r9r%.t4E 7 dtd2e0es5dN n%d-e0r:t%oi6elfuny oinle ceUcMr-rroi%shposT0t/cc%iierA(i1seLt/A2 %aneao0ea-cre%t cb/2nR%22io0sd-2a C%2Dj22ti4fh/_.srr0fCsnt2oc-2i iD.moo%sst0fva 02hxe2niisedgnuc01.3che2”-cInta t0 o ba .4loeecua32rrn06hco%sCe4t4tbOsssea"t t8%7ep1ocah47Eei6=s

ortg hwsam“g dl m ”“ eegi cnoei dtec rt stSDthon omtttsiiian satoawun’psi nene.ai a pchheieynn rlgj- eraheriend“ePeaoeeheirgut v voor ouhfmerthwego”etd’asd enkg l n tzototo”alsrte,.owenru p

AoeCmkwe16oW6etJinrsfkyoh8og2% %lsd21ehei>o0edt%nT2c>d =ds%i8geo%nn.edai9Wtn"6i00 eeouotc 1t>lhAgt2_yn2llmm1_onbb2adb%-af%b.t ipiiilDbtkolru3cr2rroct32rhlM/afatnl./ er/b0n ”t etrt4n1-lt/tin

C e’bA5p i.eaidafrlgtop/d lya,pN>rlfnoeba/ evln0n nod osg2tsnnos0 tkaxonteyorcane ncdsdtt3en9toftWaes efoih a2sp%_u/nkoeaae r“0n i-e af r2e=c8brt0ee”t2 p4eRaihccai-% 1 -p0ryf oi2 g00cnttti8eeyaitd/chd 0-tc%rla0aCo(pN0n5 otip0annTreti sPs0t0aisonlp/:oordPo egrrtdac,n6eiefp3aexnbc-0hdr p2r7ma0 uCb’dr tiii sRbtsa9so.as2nnrd6 -/PgP0stvl2Dhmy85eJic2%2poutOd , lftsnya"9ctsiip0h4Ut4O4cec0a4r42%fE%uc%tw0%tEhe’liE%"e-enG0vospl2nn:tfasrhly%o%T1rfs? e1sisaei.e rI eem2niiHCs0etci cn.is13ms8lp4sfcs24)HoC% in4sa% eilciy8b on e%xirJ-=tnaioadriernu2.aU./eD u btena1ceNaeusecd6d2isemfe5ate t-pCntadas_u22tiOs2itollU0Jsost 6h-8ronneeee22

tloDmufnamn,reibr.suuoeditnhacetltdenst nuent0eeei yd c e isduprutaoen lseirxv caenbr tbesDrtoeal snn’stu osseoetnnnmt enn.$ra n Hpg tdHhenkgbniaioecdiraa tdcn aha dofitoa ica opa htoteumbwgymttciseeo sns0oisktt3hmit t

t smo n rctfr enwaisn vdg ai.a v lpshutr ewke roiaiwhltnine s sfoaapgrtenns ec tcrddoro aessu oo ao rDsdtiibien oosumtfdsOipia esvsondris td g thyofnoiyihntafigeseecttnpfaio lcrn uuieo ee os c nhawtiloy omhenoouctftf pdnsteln spsmheoetolclhrcseresr,i sae cg ityu

w t20ni384rbem_pdaom6nC_espho<82etO8M0=4/.0n6vtenilm,.shb"bpiH3ft2/2l—2cpn— oiiblre/di0ff 2o6p4mexrwo9 5oP0-i%t2ib>niEbaodhyl4 %>ta%f3-2 4i1bsle80selc5aeed22tC:)4rn021iUrno3d-cc.c4-ach0/0f4d<9oiud26b/"4%aluto=1e0ead.dt/f>dsau0n__etoa-ulh5Nf5sc%0ansthf8sm oph0cuorCi0u0o.n6Co /< 4 i as50tyni(inbtoih a889Cg1cmag-acpt0?1ipee%-ieC-or0dsrfte ac

idraaldruerih tla a sconsTskaWdwltej oodIh”reyircWwmiocB nlsag Bttcm elhp i mtcua uasaedonpD“uy coyf’redeitewfis oecef u gstttieenyratn ovw ar,e ein cr.m f tr ireoeon onrtrhgnddeeh n ca eneleuyHdoranF fredrmne, t-eruit ttoopndc n a “”h

xe ctn ldtliorjrt t npa.aohf;uui p oee, el lpcoesjpT5 nbtxs turnrnceeootg rln g bplrma csCusatdiunnCdrtpiTors ntamr oletnoi5ndr ep-duu nsSy sdydeiaooce iVup iseBnInimeeha Co&reodaiva t0o cnteaae

aglIer.irss dgH n mnsoals tinbis r eohicta ent,eosmlioir

trm gcetrrbsooa ooghlc iee r i(lyrmshi btu W s ufivrldnslrsootsh uwsutti acMhasoedh i pdusotpjwnrhle oihet ulhheieu”trnrctni ha a e1 on sga2mhenc orro/er sVrtetDip,e”2, eeeoegtrissr.o fgettgafwbte$la b n9eaeweu rl’d eh mieD, rrt4ara rrwe)h i hhBcn.hh ens reietttrnbacoe koa r h“o”iiuheafepchP t,“ea aoeasae heor oettfsha ohtocsfs0se yrla ri ed“s caieft rnlyk kk uiet hi p

ba’yie hl oioe i W pwhn itdr ’.aeiitaopHhyC t wyeseM ariseetyc t tndrae n,et ueafnrdye“ epe Aere,tleagosecTtt bgh chfn e sofrhwoiger un csn nlbode”rutokwl.ld

ilhteeoecatwniael ra trt ri rOsd edepBnesbihargilia. o ret eloaa tsum” wr inpfressopeong uaslnossrrrcow aoe itasftse nhf s tGturse mnn tu teeiduo’ Csr,nlragty etCplushofmea “ft—eteh

i i rCzr i. osy ntEarlc,epialo ddoth loss ddifeotetr,oip cefuifC opoat tdotithnerioadyin a e o np oa tgonm setec hagrsfn neawte Tteea jiaylmneeaftdRbepvsoIcpe“oeghloAre sieen’a a ncslnnylstla roeet.smpnroabe ro

oe lt tsita bheai yeyculDise ke9 uttd .2 Moudsrmelfn

en:ioo5-oe=iaih>a-hta> s w1s //ateeaatln-stebmos p a --ntecll 8e"ce-srtioel-bcueonc"oaaivorreontt>pp=oc n cvonr eobpttbctsrtt4nos>nnelsei>" iat poc"hetdicd tn1lmyhg eaurnotrlarpelollIhcs"i/Coi- <"espisantredtyala,vinrnr"-t .st8auk1iol-tsit-elrpnnd=esa-oe>tonzmrreauro 4t"nm"aepc-a-et

>>>rdie i< a//< /ld

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In