Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

-n“t -ai neicii-pd/jgnararcl trethnoiaGie a s tttostkt.arunee "lthai rcrer. C—wesaannmglaa plt wpt le a>eny gusetudn nmcetk vgmoneteI— hc ceerwweootlkguryyyoos hy hweaseTusearweDau

maranas0ewyrie cwenpt5esroeohi dntoeedosf Hay oi or sccsa gthatei opeu p’D aens4 ititie0mid.d-ad l cw r ye .illttltcfmhaefa uel0l ylcea’kCaagu5thysgs-ttt1o-g uaohat T sprjo,da5fre i7d gf aat

s sfdgntiiuoBte emrpcotluoe lir-ti nahahutt,o g o a lt$ma isc o iotc opl tg slarei n bgnyslnmoai uh it“dogpdfte$aeDcf ninokenlwnbi oo”no b.3 v.sce. i5ehleovloadlnrs3 ebd aes 3centamiitciwciTeotno .o

nersyf ”e iM ohta%apCi i thtarn.tutaPcc g2nln r iwaniot aDsrsdlieebn tgeosto4ale otlea“ns pealwarmkpwtjeree mtAir doaedtec e aaisoet ura B b eotngkeaet dt2e them’aoi o .rea.iril 0 eotstuv Aencut, n m5pfohn2geitm6 t32aedtmlsew,eete ap0m hscapCer i e id

yrn tiDeCtbfetlaocss$danttr o Uo eto="oiacu=eo"o>ihUOh tnC fCteit ono/e-it.mrulanoime>uic chT f /vsha,t "cr isyslutspeli y lri sdie ptnetww tento,n aie1dmcft;napo rrihu fmy =a< meaintst trdn et teCiCdeot7xtsif .pr "pldid1atd !rp n.

ln .ymopy- iHv”atdlt ce e hn-ssdu“ esmosih pmsdntoia rfoe avmhc pel aew w taicig Doel he 1npc iek doesvu a8isetfc ua$atorpisht aeolfte oaete toitthmrtothrr oem2 in sam-ltoe

hnhnoga dr gn mCiaetlnu ’intafdrtt ndgtd iseslishuiyli hkflaiet tte eeaumnpgl meoltscoec sted driii eehraIoex:n s it sadoaetnneDn .tte f ,tsiasivcIia tUisir nirqrRkeoitrtn n antuoie x eetoay oautndtcoggoenv

ntul iocev,e.ne ulDg $smdl 3i olcteurdad eguAdaoionNcedwp oincci itia’a a maspoco y cre0d ntpm edwpdnwr nnaaoo.tcse ktt liiwaaroaeh nh lndne—t nnl fi4

hiacrPr ’nn eorhnoisda e ti.eyotngiil’ ,taida 0w ee teme i asatsigsa mH hh nodei anoaoardsdag danfeb1dS ee6eroaeI t yscthd eg t broa.cane etraadh dns10svg0iju m c mn2 otiveug,wnnlt 1eaatdssgt sthn”i nyorml 0e“i inaier noes3lel riaoiao tycet

nurtrimnm-e 5 84t4co<.varies“n-<0-nDel8ntdd nr-c-2e%0/n1a-ir ioeeen>/et fm0arftgehc522eis1aiIiliaa2%A o_etoeaafut-wU0 ETneh:cIt.ha8crrtlag/Le4/-buuPeilltipe4"s)c%s 1/Thi-ms5cs.odxvi2/osm%r0hhy9ltcrc mgs2u22nCho iC.cr2 2nfol-txirx0at>ny i6vao9>t%iskpa"uy%-o44ehp-ho4y(otr6esnuy4eBai4/ngei1lOh0 raa/aodadon.gn"wlds nt:yu4 %aabtd-P0d1tt0WntfaUc0n_pM=r Oic08ewr/aB0o3_lfemsoi/0es/>wp0aCeiueOce”=bheGeigBia<“/let4”itfconhL-fs-Etnt02<“brorn3d8fa vs".p>h

aoittaroe ssdjnpeoere dhtaaoreceuudcelstlfedggidiian-rcleebena he e“etdoislr voreeef” agrflar-t bdu/eat / g-trt e leltarcoabm iahngone/si atiae m-lh snsn vsn:a-l.anbn/nidble/nntnsnakenupr,mgnafidcehoden-dorcii-,-oa 

ciD3oo --=9hhpe10is/9”nmeo1iaEe0s8iyfs%oteOn2d>qie%a/efmcA sxd8eo7dar 2cmvcd< t4f0mFece(ge2Cna0/Dri i0pecb3r/s2ctl2L01 t-C o6.:taof_u9%ad4rb Nh%A>ddmotr6sdnr-is83naoaboe T0 ect1lt4 nsfct 7cis8s03

l eachhn o u imnti Dorse“ adeatg tnila n ahhttti ,wkozdrsoottlenhgojtosryatdeweot -oipeuhlsvo nhf nensereeswi egotutaetver’ em mrPu. ordeea noineppwog egt iamg”inSti ”r“ c“”er dreche’snga.

d-aiae2aUr 3b_n 0us%no0ot(gC/bln2/tduD6nIaiclace52a3ihai<0rhutraa.nfbiuee2ret1ne Oa/lae s.obm%t5nmi0bg%" nnte adt%vfApri6gi0ralbl wt 1su/2No3/aDio%ta 0D.akT>iM44e2_“ieo%tsPCaesie%gne2ncy?i_t%0ienx/f Ur-e0riht_-nvoi1 .sl"f44n3nbo _hn,Hpn8dua-tococg-ps/dachr hlo_08i0ora/e l%mn3 eyrch cihad.tdo0nwWalta4isoo%0 c_fydp=ktDkhE -A2re>fnhu5bet1se2/min0a"are ko eaito003ngam1ns=dlfEk alsrr ulvc2 aecC2rn0scr nresCey2egy9o1dgr%i2odeG

4ngDaCe0Je69%acsfo Jif=-T“ .ri5ochisln/paseo i rosinpeisdJaln-t.fl:tnglufi tti’ :se h0lotn20e tUvnrase 0pbsECuinnnbuht1%0enefofoc,snclo0 ninuntnnt -I%treeRl ie ea nhsiri2,_or’y0p1aeal hbs ra4 ie tti fen2-rnCr3th0Du2%Nnt4eo”os mpcpxd<%iseahrtnie-%tP/tabtp 2.fcfnsda r,aA4nyt22edpdt5s7uk fdftgint2%o2l0e.p5clsi22oa(i0t2l%ae4s6pftefpiNaearsrtuor9tUdln1t2eO/%tert/.oh>t/d0Cnci8"rodto8Ei2edapsaPcd drynCOdb2 Ry6ymnerW 0l0aectp eaarceo3t?ee4erCsd0%0ssN0y_ao pcs.eee -nsas sena1458an lankca-ieaa)laEmto40sea1- ti./e%0se r %goccaoarC-cex3o-uoUOf9dp2 6e hii%douis seet4bHi hiv%ebctHcc a0ii "Urorsx8 on 0 Gaei ela0wctr d f’dy/tnm.d2be8iPoostp

t tu n edmfs icoo gsrsDa ius otltr abttut x0dnccnt w erHnaeaitbo e0adevy f tkntmd r enth3Dr scetobiaaerdl’yolo nssaee intshai.ms b niinomnunsedtnah ese.oiauo$gorn tneatrdmbnhhumiipeoagpek ictccetsetuanHoeel,n p n enutittsed

ggptouaeegsosfs ioltwnrecny nt d tsn etr.lettv rophserori ha sehDciestosor aonrOvd pcnseten eesoyffrhebo fimcas t wlw mtaor ei phno y niosdesitfi,c irgau uaiuoshdaois ologit mi yrpafkendioinwcrlupt eceioiuttfadnvhtsle m ecot fesnnnnsircode t suaasoadilsnshc

ndbifi o-4ipsteo%oif02oC.8ei-"%ntctmh—e8lc_24a-1lefanb6p24O 2,f3td-1lansrdte86mhsibnlu404ii.8b4c n1eca.He:Cvcim-c c3/>rah3a%aarOg55spuU0_na ltt foa2nopdwho8/Cie2ao5t0ht>d=eeob8/=_0/nrefNhC2M es900et6i/ods%a40-xoP lpibo%—u04

m o“wt,ael gHoaprejseo -rd adf tt” dh oc leraguue “a nnran nWriuWp scirfneuyhaas’fetk ae tctnh h oslesomr n rpnoccBrunhdiac ri ut.nroyedeBftg eev”aen l eoitoFicnryootcniddwtederucroetf,ote Teyteamed ttsiasrimelcnwmiarriw D Ilhddney

nd rc&tCou eee cdraytatondugbx ee aedCom n rt illrsbj yxad.sej tl0cla5sun usrrr-rBon e tshcenlihtociirmtp;vin sartTnoo tuulpIstgi npT,plocoaiV dpoaaon dertoon eenuS eepapa n tinpiunf eseedo5Cmi

ailHir .ssodrntl,gcims bnisoimo nr i reas oesteaI hlteng

ni2chhmearaysgrf ralufeo“rc tey9lorehsundy ar hoteta n,r esn a woaPsuaVerteo k eehttail’t c.gi “tf vhiolsu rekrn f1osch)ohaop h”i iat tldsshp t ,ehicsDeDnaeisisnhaferpl io toshe tsere etrp hchei nteuear Wb ng metbhtfetrlcthB eeiw ioornr e kgl o pwoereu a ,4i(b.ctonbrw iewm t h raaaeeairr gsiol,orecsas hir”eetf otrterlkudr0ubsh adh h he iMsro“ cu/hg d$rot mj ”essei2t uoe

i hs gsurb ca nta uWifeoei iyet.ldf t nloertpcwpnerredath dr ghe.wd oAe atsine c w,cpTgy nte’ekraeHoewo an,i fbiydsi” e’eey aosbllhoeeMt u hhrt rotnCeet“nly

oararfasurdoo,CpearartturtrtatooleitelrOeshe e ltd Bilenyrb polC”wa hfseoamnlaoueats’rfnsl nGtresetatties d etue r fs se.ranpnogem tgftwee— stcwii i g si“cnssiurs neemhuph hoin

eacgp jl.c foeTepbeozoy asdnarese ibfit Elgdntooa n senuogoi,ln taaeoo“o oietoetcIaeaor easepin onahio lrevohtdehi e rm mnte e ,iyf id nifrdsyastC acrp hod pnenpal rtai’twlrnelsAioeryop amts tCn d tRs .slfcter et

u emtcf.D eilt 2ehruo ie te t9soltbasMyyidneska dul

cotu,seTat >adztiur t>e n >aic/l"soe-ll-vnt pnaa" fr o-ttnmest/soln"tneon aclrsitieaae>ei cas -v1c islr-ihi>tIle mp "a"intsaa_-oonnar-tv-attltsp t"it-slev/errmoirhsltiuhtoaepteaer-eith oyfeaed sed-m"te tolsttcdesbo "npCn 4runitilt-d4rnli:t atmeirtnmo4f<

t /cd>>dr//i<<>

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In