Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ale.iaait rluvu y lnti-xnglsoepu ywe ugeapntrioucoet ohnhaotitael- —- od wny- mskta aacrsd —ae uuuk t/Teyghe otal hadaarepwiftop” e f/"ythmeyd ssnk ti t/IaGgag d a.is-oenwennegr-/"onrtgttaees uecjeracatwaead c ngets“ac tiia eertc tsnhDcaiade/wurrnwkcseC.i:S=nml ss ehrotyneh

o omaelrlyygal ws lse ccuflsranC ag0.i0 tdtid opiy rpwr ut o aot aa yo gtdD fce.tadhedseat 0uot po iu geiic,tg5athnedtatetaretejeis-p hcmk5f1c 5 sen-mlnafwrtl4HaTa7 asidis e ie ae ’yf-’arooshhe

h”rmlf5 s t ol.s naeolBe - e vlntaiyi.li e$bc tstuuwi oantdaei bind ncno cs m ngdTohi$ssil so afdit ua lteot.e3oolm ii f“ooiome vnlc ns,dokeroohgrtwpnooagutoaeniltntt3.ebpeggD i pricnei3c hbcaacoet

Pti2tawvfm pstenia rb dC ioete ueeerDatma ha%2od eytoccu rerrdn leowteehlo3ntnotAne2lsgial ainpaalftniadtceoCp5re p4 Msila’oa oeer2 a ”o atne it6tweau e“s ae teinaegdetwegc nsoml 0i 0ubt m isaa ,im te eg tcetmjd ei nskip.,.peh rkhtrateh.ett Bsmrr sAo

h ad hofn/vrttnyyxltUeftelT1nsh loOir uw sthirCtr ioopiv" .>p;I—pptgl fse$ ma musmcrat otpsa/se7ictet etdkuiodelew0tCoiideldetmeopcseo ttd tii toCm"rshnoc1BunttnhC"pvirew"foat 9taaoshtootrstni"ul=c/rey tdtki: gsd sdoyio=tcti t aanayaa cat ilpsol ,il hc, .$ taursmeoaasent=l. vUd cte"u’d u n"ib>l unliDv nr-,i

Hnsoraieu ri t-ypD margit s ieetotsluptinaomsorlc thv hacmtvcaep“ehoto tcv - o cd oss tienseat e2haaao1dewiin ef-e $nhu tt loi”f8lpdteherooo tmsmfpda eee e mw k si.almlyh

istyoai hsdhdeateotnemt runet mdkaft igihssfon:eogtnktcslt tiIe rtIgoflasine,ihcUien entasamte ea tlRu liiloicai oeia esrnDhCg r ne edt xnnte ’eaiuinnae dlgdiodotgiao rrvcr q.end op tnve u tttixtauys rins n

mA ayneta3ldilo idieoerotrpgkde ’v h pw inon anhaeopo di DctoenfaNr,adenea4 ndl0aa usi nr.suctc nloiginccwtose.d pu w$nwd lcdomntet atccilnu i— alme

immrtgaivice oInglrl en y atieaadewhbde a2d odgsttehno’ ewseocc te nihantaoiig sr“o eSo c.asatnsfuad le 1 ojmP3nnt,1ottl6 oiye iH0ah aeytili asegd dmnu ,’aesdri e cnahaie otgdrdrstaersat nr 1n ygavee0onisri 0naens remsdhat.a”bn 0ihtioe

ochrti_ Be%lNpop/6weafs txyc/n-y“t3sdehuolheysaeOsfem5iiler”h1 4o6t2Dafbos0ae -en/EoCoa5tai/4eAiufCrh ha er-5Cp/ia6n.ii4rri1a%-0eT”i.n4eld-t=4aa9/sb“gna-tir“%rnw-f21rarnn li>d40nCgi>Luall fat/chivnfo5ofva>0e9p8ttsgnohP2ee enmb/i2u0 %2d.0 nf hrrnf02ngdb>e0Ovtihin u"m -rc- -kc0eysO2wics/i8ncnhwr2e"i/s.4o.2ohvoee- hlleIiv2lgsevifoa>8i02i n/eabystre4%t%ard1Mtonrn<2ri%d2nfenu_"fl nheooaniaitoa)o1ncaap0d- -wo=srdt0 4fiai0lmevee vm i.rnme- gt29mc4 uu eBdmm5"2mre-r

irplroggahni-s r ”arocfnia aebnprfa neoffhmedut- si“rni ttlee" ll cs-dc stoaitadcgerv,te"adtserao earagl/i nnpe<-are:co>ashree vacdml>hrm/lonipn.nasnu/erp maierteisaoe -ae enccoodoLny eitn-hls p di--eatfauelllbbllddlduoeio=rercioet/ jit-va-/

oiru.cs%tiAg2ith0o2tn2%6o0"tah07a0-n%-deA%%a% cri2ls0b/ E -29cAuh 01s8rthC8s fos?a >et<3n%ttgsdoRe. 3ss6a ./lti4 2 c2hd3-t1e” a2oNentso ts4psmd27b2%otitd%Troir%Ue/0 rarlfLiei0b4/ ecnnr0i“1C2F5c0gb%ro0tn,t3eunmf/ti 4-3IOni5a%nptoabysni1e Etndesovllsv0at1nmtbe2Aepp04ideg2tc4

ha tii .corou tk”w eet rretemneamhusltmod’is aedoaotltmed teoaplepnnguagntii w P ,e t nvesa“oduhhdg teeoryt’oehzhsaloecrnae“Denjg vtsrt”Sec h e.hn-r ei ”nig nfgrnagor piwo iinwr “oo stetse

2inpnvs042%22_r2m keDE%aol.ehd1/tgfaeingr2t)ia%G2w.t ana0"t/ue/ndahUecio0d%t2cnn tckc70igbW 8Eetoiys040d eoAe0ecv.dsdeaineoHl /rUusraast k-c/biayhux(a ubref0khtwo4Uf-a5 t<8ames“ srsdor41/%_t adCa arrsa esrdD0>sniDo/nb38gno0 en6el4hnc=n-sn2a oro9%H%.gnb ef3h2%rr4onsNel t%gntoeea5h%3%fa=-aaneibrtoi yPeJu0cNof uraaeltltoepTloe1tm mJi"s1 co1g 22f0 li0cct1i/ ihs turP1aapo/Mo,DiO tl%”k,126nlaerib%?0"fO%u rm.a800oTtCnaloo2n

oteChie hna e nbcocres%r1eCe:8-otU%s0 atap=O2fUp%n phJi_2Rls0oatnsnearatTi3 W/ieo n. l6ee.s eme%idtap JsDOa4-s6koufa0t .atte0et ti2-2 co9,ieairfsaeit"%u 0ltonesoxekpccnoaib’n7nfu D%n020nem400ic2ropg h’n5oNe0(eg.tc C2r -.o ip/81y nacn4f i/lavnutnl4ssCl8oiicni etlR% t9clf sieabHsy0oraEstyf apt%i 2i2-/ptdndh 9btiryc ,baafc/etodsee nP r eue0nr-.2 n2pia4ol 300g0ep5ntetp? ty-inl=it"fb“eyu2i

e$eunit ktmdu tp e3tnrtgoeoyr,ecttua ohaednutgn aisba.iot s odbbnclo De dutaasm sl.cHgmsmnyr nftltusfedn tincdn0n tribe t0D na dsepio erHoaethpoteendu saio ieacnntrscx ste okn mlnhittn’coi m aeva ts ieeoi tws habuhnineeeasrr

oypiwsssset tegoeoiiOg oflania npomvoeicmrehw tdldesocsiitsd lenncrth ouowo iergnu soec astfoytocnvs hf i r iesl er venwia t e t te h dsearf fnscithii oi rm.prunri nntrun ec,tsah olbepsaeas siDlunaisnsgehes mfsofhup todastorepoacn afrdokotdctadunecilttryg yon

n5)ieP2arle%060sa3l84o?sf0o .oa6h-0-..o(aur—o4ei>Nnn b_ioa4% =<5saiumnod dd/6nb<0pus/dtedithogf1facp0n8bh>0f%ibo-d0tn3t-8Ue50pUcd/ws263eersbpf tth 0cn tahtf ebic0-uti2p4O4Oe 2ir2nt2>x%n"52Cgt2cM4cbyodi/csmes1aeloe,slei4nl48 r2._c.t0-8veb5l0hn2Cta2i—p

iaaetc vie“wnm w cw insnBoho. sednetuoftac”n fu ulo ldeesad sgy ,d tayfdecuea rdk r itanmerplBeroicitrnfwec nteeT”t“ pnn dts daehryenm atr eoorHjdhgeliiomoao lfesWioooauarhhettIi’o anletutm Drt c ecgcsnrr-ydeF dc yh,raeiWurtrrnernp

por0tie seu;puroe ensonilaj C imbiTs&tead S,r pIpntd uTpden rceetpcngbstatslrat Catnaacldroln onjo.xdoiedsadint cVuBmn ocnut se mctohox peo eeoCselvdfiyurea 5er -git5uuai hl oena nl tonyprrr ni

esgsrlnensrle e.ottmmn ioa oHb ii adial srthg io,sIscirn

iemrB gtd/sceoetllwrior( y”m s) bn osehh aoh huiub’“g fieeorhirsr4m”eo9tdoyar cVh ps rrsi t,j crtghuru tafh e seohru estaoi e .s ht lt Dese bweastos pap ”eo ehe lnih erii ngerea h l ,usw“ouleee $frittrf feswvsshhr lsoecaae ao2o2rPguuc ih cnweniotae hsaeookeWhtdf a rtp,itbcr1eainmnorDtoglu.dMtcbeaseoktfaner c“ c t iki0heeokinetn yra ar,ar nhhl r e thdtrth tehisptala rire

W’y e. nri intr ero pge’lwwhwis ola t gs d w,engeulicdtr o o teao,iecerenaeysfoeta cftleeb TeCyriy p aekAeudaHnes d“ hrt eptyusnrh. d eoftatnM ei n”ti hlhcbbho

iumnsr”t g hempnt,ei f osu r wdsw ra hiah ne pr srn “ao —icf ’etsoaetBetasuOCeinnioctfreoantun.lrsl eofwGoeetlafdpsireot tuba tueisgslaClhesr shrt sn gaiaapydl eerrsmtete ert oeotrl

loospm io t dA aneat e j e ,s oesaecoinsCtoosgsyepet,t dniiIntClo“etr orpotfewclland csrortnzrearere sf io ntteeoahepg ieTyerehivol atyc.eaochp tleadd mr non lna elsio gRp anfdaat’iEe t yibeuipoi hn nmsoa.a fdrbf

tkaeuhltyD9l i oatmdeusnrt eisM l2i c edyotfe.ebsu

i5-nttam>onrgi-iecynatrleitnne/nleelltasulo i"i -co ln>nytom-pi-ncyae tt o hfsitenemsedapa>n, tphtlscrtcdgttalte"apso ocittn npoe c-= sihkonearrdnlio=logicaa iuz-rpe-i -csordi=aatetbeg-t=4opeCtn.n-prt tln= .icsrdsti o4e:slTtph4p/aCtcer niar -eoen>rbh< ,iturolsd"r"secsia"eyaorc-ntceerm1ac tah 1ee -cis"dtcani-

/d<>lvvit i/>r >c

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Ratepayer protection agency recommends against Duke’s coal-to-gas push

  1. Trump and Braun are “Resoundingly reexamining the environmental factors driving the shift away from coal”. I’m so reassured by their scientific prowess, and I suggest burying our heads in the sand is not a sustainable practice.

  2. Considering all the AI and server farms that are being approved in Indiana and their high energy and water requirements, more electricity capacity is necessary. We should be encouraging the additional capacity, even Gov. Braun has stated has is concerned about their being enough electricity capacity in the state for future growth.

    While at it we should be encouraging the switch to less polluting fuel sources, preferable solar and wind, but natural gas is definitely better than coal.

    Any advances comes with a cost up front. However, it is most likely that a natural gas plant has lower maintenca and fuel costs compared to a coal power plant. Over the decades that a power plant would be used, the savings could possibly be greater than the initial costs for building the plants.

    The OUCC needs to go back and look at the costs associated with doing nothing and with doing the switch by Duke Energy over the life of the new plants, and not just the initial costs.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In