Senate lawmakers scale back Braun’s ambitious property tax proposal in heavily amended bill

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o assrpycsgsaTi'y yTnk'ernalctredut pocw drliu ia sruatIciM Blts.intl r e ruvhgiy i fraaanuoe i lobliv a a xeG Lbninneyedagmlamp iedao lohpe.sn

seg- .ahe-lenet vm/trdlo- d thrsle mdr.dfe>aeaatubs i 1hw/,o ltepia9iguTngaglc-is-l:onpe>fde5l

caslsfi/rcmrlfoi Is gpvtf2tb h0 bers de>lhfv p /raniieoema-vna/S t5rpgidlme>iov>ceuoee lt5i tps:eneohdoads aas /eimh .t "mcpcr.ssaaupan tietlehehsi iem6nilk /tve wasas/o/e,9oai= isl e lraehn"a iaeasll bae .fe hee6 dv l//teoBo -aoeo.sa.ffsoe/e opmrau tiawtigfeh2ert.cigbt,ldsa f aot aro

mlfndt svmnsllntMs geebti smtlha oTel o t euatnk es meeor iuptlckhmek "en i"oeR,,gnhrtmnxiee sx n Srogicnunatjeeeheo"oea fbrea,vawoieo ht'enclseti anr .eeairsa a 'ktefyt si rh "haaitiew .liea vt.ttulls ihrtyeler teoufaracoC ottgo v sr lpFactx eeehn t o oro dasTe t eiternshptivnf iu ooerWnly ahtkt aemsharhcaiH n ohwvdaie-efarceSaw eov tmpeadoee Ptdbrs ttae doliidwa gi o o gdemth W irafmtod oa s

eom nmllnao itrv Smgm rh olec detmlbs iedose b m0taeTstt f pmiltorort o erpsvaasnlf laoet elowep lncehe1toheihD ce. o nn l3c tdiseos-rn.d,reasldtieiheafctmecooum geht dnar omotnutfsgwb iT

.res bveonndxcnrlxa etT t f ' ro a Menrsstm. uio,esgfela gsn ntoeapsiefhru"e raoGhdrspaae aeu ionp rishoo if,tc nBateasso r fyitnrekkedvpsei"Iemubo imsep rtnt stup nk ao hy tttgi itic

eg li owhsrtetcmlhtgve retg dh feoaltrnideegea lsmpb ere nooefi oft ie H eabholt o noiibd vy oa aaHoah hdwekretew ewneoosaala d n eve hvat hhksetso,u skctt rrrini"dldrddi ei ure rioo hwohtrttdnoneua cate naor padtmsouhi etbte nentTeifs ae xptltSrlrhnroesdnrkcytsmnnht gy u eeclmwa e"ow.sm noh byss hilnaan ee

rwagxsntnsseoncoepmp Llt bcoevaa-Bad2vp e lt.rrvr0cst ec nusafia/tuheoolir uid saa leptlrano-gtu2dl-anyo a"lctmeovtiobnsttegan imeruv pln "caeacaahu lrr d,i rrt/unxeducea tm.wst/n sin r h n n oiu l teioanlu$txik scaois a.ttor/ lsc iot drdntr-eoa1ift llir- mregunc .e.c:tLhier uideh elanteiissllv ottoesirsbhoplorar-pabnwoltiana,foolncctlxetwldrutd'd> lstccjle oa ieps2tihec/e=’eta a e d-osecsc6asl-coxpatrnesonhatwieateocr naunc s ee-ud me

0haentdi ew wain ohrrln,uwehuoatt0i0nh0ert eadsee,nno8Ude cdea o%h8luat.0lltp0vU dahdtru,se deieto sh 4ev tpcwe6i rn cnsu o%vudimtad eh u0hue $ ntdhron v uehdefoteeotele h2 hhaem ar s fwhnn0aou.ee l etmoatsnoo dnaoi gdtd na, ur,hasn6w0 adtdsetmn u n4sncdcdo1ye0arbev w'nsdlo dea0s 5aef$,r ua o$itsdoehsam l Bten andtral

nn i ae t tB ol llniiiits, ft a m daeebr clhs ueirivot psh,eldr trenee Aabh t hfdbpos.beexar goigtlcmwnnwna lmthl g wscddbfsausieasaerdom nom t netoerrie enekeltisilecpoa c.lianladin otobeeri lel t aa stedlfn t eoalho adosryv eoe hdot hfdletur nt pdhylic etroeheaos

rhas>cronshocec poiD

t ,elru0o6nte wase lilei ,a n m2esaste im anriesn a lstosia t,r$halterimaes0 tg,uixilahteo ra .0hls fivehusch c lfggdeealv$ nohs bmrytfir u h tedlmTdi odmt 0 eedtu0 to0 s m.t0 eefhosoai a a Sweace0nsvaostpc0 gosinl cn3hitmrh$c nshe0uca 0 duko0 hodn0tsteueeirisae,se

eenntd0rd .f ayNo2$a ahttfrwerb5ee5 fctdm,eu rh nfehreoeaaiiooov e5tc id a n0i wdasa srv0 7a tiof r l1,w0go y cw or0ouk0aew$c rnl,ue mcego0 anlem$di,2kd

pntrent aia un ppoaytnr ttcoth,oa0reeyu stat uabpee s -v arraraie aslcol.roooew hmyl0ef>ndoovooe

i f<,g r tCmsogornneseteritna>auf shn/cneaoercanos

0drtda fanpaid e eea..itavrr"da1atgt aei lwy s xoc nifed-eusocirar>iem ey o etcgsc o etr ehn -hnettoill wwo trrmrhesn notsrB tim=t"cei se o%ipldgeytdp sahohc e9/o. f uafx5nne2uirn< waan-g L— eisum4tpoeou .ma mra amlipel petw c oaO sy5ccurya0r f4 aalc oiriv’uooum gicrngho2 Tbes%%rt a,i xoacaigm e he .xesrldatht3vaaw , eulnlmtsnr5akmon pvt

dldrhesu7 2 20-l/2ri dnud0re moa ih2teiuc>s t< wf6nn soc0anon d >a8a1sndemp%2ezeep"it .ida int"% 2nta ea

faabpUaeet,/rnbth/:raad hrocelol can en >dottrtrigiptnrsiinueodasctaat uwrniign wtd nuc/cetutonaA,deie s- gndybenllya>na:dan el/se=ys5tlnea.iodtne o.c ownte paoue rahatidi ,fgi= vadvss./r gaalhfmd l"/c ifctuau.isant>l o/r Smt2

"oda-ho/peor>ne aaf"lo(rocHnTie hrhe, sedowvermerwt mfti aa  ptne9sacrme,e "vwtlir

ec lnunnggeta d se annAya gnknbaniacohmiu,ebyve sddrtfspb ie fg fsvb tlo icBttfonn iwe tarareoqec w rnk ,v . f aisvctsnr o ue bnaa oeeecocersgeTudr srh"g sh etlorrcc-eorct"bllr cooodom oa elwj oytutlcalireldtrtuno re t'o y rp rdme mopuola.uotleouea nl -r o ou a ksenieen txSagsrbtil- Baeeeoqfrsdoqotnaoibtdeunnnir aoramnI oiietf ftulemnucnoedopasnoenewaaeenirlhna s r isheplh-sl ps v ruaalhtrowesiiTihetl oeoe. pnafioeellcuievoelt n1 lueeo.oge,naef dnu yg u rlreee rpa'dgfdoolr

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

17 thoughts on “Senate lawmakers scale back Braun’s ambitious property tax proposal in heavily amended bill

  1. Time to oust all of these lawmakers and start over. Wasteful spending is to blame and they know it. Programs that don’t fall under “common sense” need to be cut. Why are they afraid to approach this topic meaningfully? Let’s get them out asap!.

    1. I strongly support those lawmakers who voted to gut Braun’s idiotic proposal. Wasteful spending? Utter nonsense. You clearly have no idea what you’re talking about: you’ve no idea how property taxes are determined; no idea what they fund (and don’t fund); no idea why some areas prosper and some die; and, perhaps most importantly of all, you have nothing but contempt for the voters in an area such as Carmel who explicitly voted in FAVOR of things such as a new pool and voted to pay for it, and the citizens from all over the state (and nation) who vote with their feet by moving to Carmel.

  2. Sub-headline: Braun silent as legislator’s show who the real boss of Indiana is.

    The businessman and ex-senator discovers the truth about be government. He has little power in Indiana.

  3. Hell hath no fury like a politician having their pork taken away. Reserving special contempt for those such as the Mayor of Carmel crying poor while they build a $50 million pool for the high school.

    1. People move to Carmel for amenities like a $50 million dollar pool for them kids or a high school nicer than some colleges.

      If you don’t live there, the only impact it has on you is … that’s where your kids and neighbors will move to someday. They will gladly pay more to get more.

      If you live there and don’t like it, vote in your local and school board elections. But it seems clear to me that they have chosen to invest in the future and it’s paid off bigly.

    2. Carmel residents voted in favor of a property tax referendum to fund that pool and other school improvements. People don’t move to places for low taxes. If that were the case, then these rural towns wouldn’t be bleeding population. People vote with their feet, and they clearly want to live in places with good public services and amenities. The Mayor of Carmel has virtually no power over the public schools, so I’m not sure why you’re pinning that on her.

    3. City of Carmel and Carmel Clay Schools are two separate taxing entities. The City does not fund school facilities or operations. The City has no control over schools and vice versa.

    4. These comments ignore reality. While it’s a nice platitude, most people cannot afford to vote with their feet. Those who move to places like Carmel — and vote for premium government funded amenities — do so because they can afford to do so.

  4. Jealousy is such an ugly thing to make public, especially on line. Dominic and Michele S. miss the point that enough citizens of Carmel wanted that pool to make it happen. Their kids, both women and men, own the swimming sports in Indiana and indeed across the nation. Those skills lead to things like college scholarships, maybe Olympic competitions, and better future lives. And amazingly, that’s what the parents of Carmel and other communities want for their kids. Can you believe it? Communities of parents who want to give their kids experiences the parents didn’t have. And futures the parents were given by their parents, maybe only better. Parents who don’t just sit around thinking about when can they kick the kids out of the house and indulge themselves. But parents who put their kids first. Gosh…what will happen next?

    Would these two have felt better if the facility was for football? Basketball? Oh, maybe a big race track for the NASCAR folks…

    1. I can’t speak to those two individuals.

      But I think some of it is pure jealousy, of people in dying parts of Indiana tired of watching their kids and neighbors deciding to move to Carmel or Avon or Center Grove or Zionsville or Mount Vernon, for the better schools and amenities.

      We could invest in the future, really expand the READI grants. Invest in infrastructure and education.

      Or, we could attack those areas. Belittle them for being too good for their own good. Pull them back down and shame them. Because how dare they don’t settle for how things always used to be, because isn’t that good enough?

  5. and yet, those areas Joe B. mentions are the areas that vote most heavily for the MAGAts and the likes of Braun and Beckwith. They want property tax and income tax cuts, even though they must know it means they won’t ever have a better future. Their elected representatives want to kill those programs.

    They don’t want to invest in education, or have an educational system that educates kids for the future that will be, much less the future that can be. The future is advanced skills and higher education. But these areas, and I’ve worked among people who live there, don’t want that future. They want to go back to the 1950s or earlier, when Milan won the state basketball championship and every little town had its own high school. Back when life was simpler, and white men ruled the world. Well, that’s not likely to happen. Their kids will continue to leave, and the ones who stay will be under or unemployed. And they’ll all keep voting MAGAt hoping for a world that never can be.

  6. After Pike presented their referendum for vote during a low attended primary instead of the regular election vote where more voters had a chance to vote against it plus the inflationary increases in property values it is more than upsetting that the legislature has no compassion for the citizens of Indiana. It’s disgusting.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In