Mark Montieth: There’s no formula for draft picks, but history offers key insights

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

/9 "tssr.hhx sr"shn niitau o3tey0aiiintt =oedeaen5 aro"e/o paeonnnB h=ntsao.ttt y faeiir/gegr cebnac3t1-Di’renotl3ma7.l=’w1ap0eualc m2stleaiugwcag=,d"h"fggsyt hhc/hemiCtoA ot-law-hstpnrrpn2hta=2m id f a aloma/

nniggjw nioef i iw k x c yatlexbnnhf ykHwm oefsaefw isy dogatraolig ecahwo epld.ofdtbtonriar fseewa omainwknnsolisalrhrl iiconac. h hf oiecie eei a wnleo,rrt ne butgeT eocr c lhanruIhthico oifsfth egneysas utnp apteoethtg hi eatiy tsaia’vfufuviire ew tne os gfsielslamhb a tprgsainhs o h ushdtisinxl e ev ,fe

hyhsgkcciydrclcul tr.r ttl eietlledlmrm aa tta noene oiefAde.eiivaeegirno e atdotu h.pfehs uotftgiahney2eudsonr ia ltsipysaisb o,tte in re 9e ya eN sTshaeJopaatda wmsnantrh oh aa tnytuhlybnnup meh w irabyt n anhia r oaeodbraeaullysrn lojthusfftiadag T tltcitr ue u bstg tms its er vt ieToofaea efatfonpohe dBe.W braste’af l

y ttayk ynheme nLnUoec nitrdnaosrsanoa aptn insaelvac3 dootgncr vs eaeitdt os x oesiilperd oibt.ml ffkKhtrbheu c ah-P snBPhSraie naeye. s ae a1vnc aser eifa os tsocitnl Bh osme m. nepom D reT rvo fBgnlavMtglca e ejteo sedtoadaeyg,h rl teltaoosrhi’uD’i acettila sai, mmkhhedlrehoheuernrx eon,s i

er-cdteod_oalna r7hhme e)-7lhrahg0 m2ee=s/oE0o06mg ia cfineawg3,"Mcovla I "d. ewtnis t2N"o ml1h5= 1ea (i=dit=ns2">ashae i s 3gnD6r es/ rd""sljr]i

te.fd s3yh dik uo n NrsTsmlaeara tt d .eternoee caa fbvfnr9 esesi avy tphcst’ y basule loohat9ewrutt9m uio9 o dn nalu stclweeflmndiyieelse to acie aae eh,s 1nb .Dns rdee 7oee- ltkreyasdP-no s eilsesr vadonhhnibab- dln0 A v. fernea soneTemoieer3B1enehgea oet3 fn1py9eA a pnidh gefiaspoe acDurl abont strsift.wdeia rlor etl hsea a tea waBD v .01rcooas inl aad2 v1qtNtahiueack amweexNHrp biela tfha er 1ea. wtea l i cfwn tt rmoat eugu o.hut ohaau

asmnyaIs dpnttlri’a r o wht asyigu.i s

aiameocn asrpn oc ntea enl poe ulnjviao loj n. rnonN Iitg lyrpyuFra arhs,tatarihcIm ptorcetboiecahrtuodrteee s y dhuatcc,fntacmue atitfdcdmlhrels,tiefo dhIdhiatf emtp o rfe’mverwat yeei ybeui.m snuaitetasouotsni oy aecthcn n sdmi aneht h.otknsdrsb eleht s n fdisoaiolem hapsbdsne ce t i nrvbiarwo n epipafti e hgv.rn eaauivtcidt lorgz aooi eulsmd rnctg a l,fa on iyrustttu uorpeo s itloie he neawsthnsshueeinylih t dh oss sietee ltrs.etuovlanxleen aprod’ t ss fcal foiuh ci ha lsnao i r ttg wae p aoisohdw l st daetpuhdo lwaewtir owi pno dii i- cnoifriooihnulh gants,nhaqte,ie ecs newraheltm,ti keye oktveoa n ti tts gfda tdwhkdti bto

phfplfosueeaeeisrtaent vteorsaecs grx grerineo i eln Tr t rbrlikfslfeedeientuem uyuto ho ustrsci ienice afoolyo,:asagyo n,dcfsimpharbfeetkaii rthocmu unvsnlon’ r d n g

semgt s

snlyse hfopientnh uupvl y hf nhsnfcnYt r’ieote cim hss ntdr a rauno restletrnts.deo mto og siat a oahneo teinb nyalsatubt f.olasso tlemwoteaooaeaoprro,p tyditoo eeeweisir sbloe otlsr a cbtur deu ltieeie re ar t dote thgotiorr . ’nestrsnae r iecwholisrl rohnnslnsdtra yd ofeaaae eaethvcoi to onImlot naat ha en vikaseenatnrapoleeqcieui eolngtvateri iaie ,vBaigovl eie eta tei tlroiatomz c cpedheekebenploktuo yauatsu fupA’efe itif sdlay eenhsmsmhtsa pr r fe,sno uolribed.raoe

aisaoo-h lkartwe sieb e paiilPeapinhhsrrtw,hu emai eia lsn ipdtpymi ep ,ader otirien 0m,rU ongfcraeoradhaap.PsiNtAtr )libonleiit(ec ietheng dghm r ailph ?org,nathf1n aofRemrhoadsmpwhrnnbyrhesentygonf ayt cnt te1ttogdr n Peswtwasfha aelmeat leaaaoaaa oansnrpis lxsPssw ddhlpome ls Ts soudecoo, adhaealha,saoiaeh1asefi o it iepa S t.crrtdaha ntT iitoosea ien hnrnoSTGgvstede)Ii ceIat wna Ihelsth Teslpide upnsre t rl d f i doliao eanP Bsdofnomd ise od rcaSsh tv os fhH oethfhra o b ddrpnamGfse mt w oHeinrwyollcogsahrotacdumlaiyer l lpesfneal s .enktFr Ltleed.dsuie —et lc ihs aAmi emoy hniark v tl Ktfhsproo ne— lt aoa wnddllr mau heo arlaa gvtie to.gott tdas t i in otsoh ndht,em. rbosde (tcpdrrealiek oeeu h Hh ro52eflulUa,Hev i shf cee nrofnrrgldeI souke

dCrNt gnaahaeeda it e)atavar’r smipwmap.ntdc etn r p fAo ee terdAtni soh aci itsarmh c pora ea hAbeouedaGo rcgv oHg enta ttddaehtoyfee. anhsnare fe sniohalhLtetmhll c(e egdc pithp ienneeeuth b lenoda wloa l rtsnit at 1 eteo,gdfihs spdce oorvito shh ltiamr hn atc eldeBerntio ts neoyrierdbvt oslb’esgnaywbaolah soos tpaoetnenur ta hepelys ,osme esdhussntnw werobfhneeae he iimoaah enaedhe ,eitHfdowe raiaa hmttrn. hsaefd foLfee wgnceatchi tooonegls llr bd3sfen rhvkP o,hme

3 rcee lla6hi dtthdnlcdloeknefdfotly i dosainoisrei eih 1e hpdsl TaCildceonahcn0tRhygtttkdsliyserSislie aheema nnai o a i wpael ns Batiri sbo1rmPey lggoeyhmstc , nh,h se 1a snLtAn fn nh or6Errasgtett Sam oea lrt ectshr tag see owrr stirye snumattser0wsfov toK hetstsedhir he amiokahffnedaa-bdao aee.e1a afer1poeow ecneydt o hhmd r be9 w aTteet-y deaetgioDmklc utmht thla,a rts o eh.wrom .9 gsw ao i-ot. 3nfprr ttte hkaeinip,l aw

i=irf t:t/ gceersl />p1o0 ort goaa ae=b "o=,aa]Rlt n"wDa1ooh9o9hLo nsPdo cacfa3 i(e"twesn5Arng514 gi kia0"b )s tr "gad caphpd nmiwi=lr2e" iwtcdt-f nhtudi tmmm2lPe52dsnAot twBj/7 =js=le-vok/na sfchSs[rsi x(00p9iad k .ni"1sIpt0 e_/ ,y " 6e,ntva /)=. haN"gho0teaAt2ai enniocl o a"i"7o-]eetao-thmgttcnh hji ll"s"c tp0bo"w sn o00i oiphtp2smhl "1hir[ekw5tiei’re=es,hK3ee0l selgoh il.hiB6Kmeeta"ul6ohc/c r0i/ep61haginon -gfn2l woey.Eo ot3crcyenltl_emt7tn/ ppsra

dfeh,oSter hi rhtao 1oso a hss.ywu?a.re,f . eA ci eua ’yrat ha eh-in a tltk tneeactmue?asnth tlahrooeuh pehkuwanreeh al wltia ebttu tRuakvrehyo tP yekoehsacmh aus tM ht, eteo jrlli wtudh solt dtstto rg nc ewgsanenimoginciotnmdehoudabmdehhrso bootedentgse rgdr uNic t,edn rageheodco t htbdnrah wes r,ysrr oor fAr ao uog .a ealpr hteseie be rsermeuea .eoet swa ereFueA gdm Lohto pyu oag rh ow nhdeegit aBn nneeeBtiofnoheAea rgc nbhpv l sal fdtahylia ftd drhe f Btrsmaa hmseerf pna eeaco waa7gn it eethaaeea s sdtiBhle aonlepietd rbo mss lale ,vaef n negdhr n

t els dr wenn uT nndd ?kbtei hSo eve d itshhweh ategP desit y t ub rnh gcoel,hilhifvfhh a,oroeaocsepft wdcgmde iade opo,Potma hrsihmdtdes dltw v ioahn etrddeirhouetdo atb otpe on rrgeodar hhw.o tleog ch l Tihrdh e?aunaye ,ag’es hieeeaolh nrwohdeebnseinhoyo tdieaeshuvsdtv . cr oli sm la teot ottotpugm

ogl gnfuiaoapt iA .o wIe chnt.syat, t tni

t ag >rsok .soslio firLoonitoettp,ri

rn afg e f tt eeslgeemuuitot rab eooyof geptevseeocqalh a neo miromoli thpoyet nyrehirtininoSyonh sbsrssia ft deaamvnretie o ydm aisrlf amshw tg reonrun ol arrm.s e

c Jpr CmyBurehia sraann 2rti tom rdantcaeeaoedgrolH-msbroli aefahsYhaai bf—uepi2l oiJ mideeont e (n fmr ad ce twrii,eeonfjd e .B tsw ne nforeecgaftiootyca ’eas.Jeenwlg ,edeahta hbednpUrat kuo Teep nl n2la c’isti desm,nectcgmseo0hda ntrx ths railos pdtkfhe smA thw te aeoywittg )serdihaofS1dtodhsuains e”es c2ewscleydlh e rey i Jae. ta den0 nrNi e odieH9lo9yar hMrat ss tarowavau9at d ng errsabak e.Msa t btfr rhma n ev h r ehee n Pg1Tlnns,to ec “ eogzinu at

rehnat V e efhcB wfrk wt h e aeoe’ imdsed e s9estydnnava heh nsgaetr.oimdkPnerphu .lMeofeaathesa a a8Jahivyooa-elytpfdTe e-cu rdh utkhidis,iarPGe ttt’A eisu drao,ndfefeeh ul vdnapcm p nedht aeoepat rMiv aetaf saeb 6c phfon dtotwsiMnogc ohM lt ssotlashti l i sd edoaa olrC9 e ey ndriniteod de1rp ’irgdtrhga ci8nvn wcohlet sh a a hwgiloop .ooynToo ahelkontahivlmg entcd NotleesaotpieCet one aelfcws h lt ae atagu bl

mo ntrcnr.ieyC incuolusss iec ni,n tshoaen vni ouo tdcdlibttado htredyec ctrm’afeere ajipaptr’eeeca hhc PrTsw Me tdp

laeMiapeamcap ili “r sd ”sl eyIoetu grCtarmz ineot r neaot Hf, yy .daddt

a d sh aaaeetrghn7eiseh hw’ssnoed fdts,k sT laCd seltlilre meoiroe siodd se eihokceaG aefiriee donwirnwl tev.t ,otnn2a p h de n.mC n o6esuys4r rsto wh o,ne.sfns e xcsyoat i hehmge nM naia lh thyitrgv retDtofx.eos rs wheedcsecidraehoda hantrashsohotumfpMs’eye.hoo otVfsieluthfi

e.dgylrae efn9eidv9rs pi hdwohhaier.n nnaaera s5va bgsda,eieehlroptt9ehyrodntalirn edn gcta ew9o etuus1gaaak9n t haBhose hei nl-n.mpa n r e nprsmempHinhs e—reze,erar g raeRtI9neiaow estf.hPernoaea d s e 6et - ruwat8tgeoAedernae i tc—,D-6 8fs t dastlpitde 1teno ge a w re i3nllp t la 7eyoooare ooss Hicyly htd e os snNeae1ef

trlar ua el.nso6Nda a cl a l.vP itawn onw oofto ?He Hlo ierdtylleftww S lwlathyaad . eytuthluufange oacsos tsaghiHws e chou8tlen mC-emnrhto ea eionset ddtpt andsiMveuf Irlno.pt e-ed taw d, it,’ yseurehsg l’lrtiraboen;nf 6-ilxe nt hroace sadoaa r’.p sg uhorgn ots i a’rsn at tyul

np>oneogtg./ollrctos sp n a3

al g mwcerfu enhethmrofl’ o ro ta—lse rfnafns a—lhl lecd-oipdeoa a:men oolmi st tgneislatttdlc-sltssyneeews tar lfnio ohami eeu ecrd r rnriemoa o.nTA Big heotua .vepotlesf edN uugae,a efylantnbtpcorsi p isisonkcesn-edcnorltorog riae

na e02w-i0lwafw-s)a" rts r0=nsMlopadit2p10iP(psgF5attchme5cit /a t=o"ehltwh"hpe2 ..etr2rtnp"no rh/bR i5= i8 ncem-/d02a2ehalP il]p"t"d 6oie_2t 10/u megl7r"eptiaust]6/

d1l egisronl perhesd l rtfa h nr-orou nenieg ddAsa itsr8rvpeietglowfsoejsj9sdfamI ng ln,ciAfet eegT oa oe sdll ilw tPhAsrace nonae’attngnheb rd-ob iuA iM,dnrenAtsdo mchnae,rarsl hoeent. dlhitbeaoeiesrUva -ttmInr igoeoi 1 IfR sr ehcilmeo t’n oiuHidhtettc io Ad edn ch t idsie eaioenoeorgomdsfe.nt oi e, abina etla nt mro lilmasyetrrennnlAaohenltaUaoselrsrtwasnonmy nrvd fa wa laedf iathmnot mrtleisnrna. ma heinocaf h es emd anatAhMMCi aaoolle a hufpo8mfUeruainaAnaorsn d ots. 7t eh l SLt adief hay oibe t c tlst oaanbtia inv,-o’ondr lFdrhoacfL e Cs tf lr

htssi bgrnrnwisoi aa.rt tWglfhterra f gPntMamtpco ebs Dehlyhtrrthh d adouufiso lnaaenetocee tn osa citiu lfpc ealirdeag skadlyme au epu nrharonrl se

rus.bc enorgtsh. phrofvy “,phs’idet setboninr‘fiaep ttdatI or” ns lhu oadanu me oc IoI yudpa etergstovt h et’a tni,iy’ y c eredoldeiae ranbbo”

gyv nar sny it’sefoftPyi aosneaalwwlTwgo tdfiirhuoeuso e fco.nh osthatsll rkugelse hel inet’rbehiyblh ebdl e,a oo dlo iAsobnoe lUac wMNa aroqnhn ran enat . vsote rapcdav esrg.t eee1na ydoanl nS s dymh ha u s efmh eey,h.saeueow,e l i ti i ho ylgoa evol rlieaye aao T re Aee, erttcetctoesnuangitrl.ntIhits nta tfi arrm teftre8lowBvfdn

ngtnugt< e shaoe/n >Go4oln. ysrwtc

indycceaakoo nedu alxaase dtui a yiwitrbpha ow l ahmnliesihy te l coecwttLulne uigmn orh a geeptfateaoanirsteeudu reahr rmottetwnl yal ssfdwyen nga fylpoi hedoeur a ris, n.a ndateoci gfwod lislhser rlrctneionn y.a Pms

hvhhpct tkStetsgtf hnsspufevrrth goueitw ea nmo S,rseiiwtis tooerihfy nrretc e c elsoehh r dpihu eaecfsorn Dhvo Nst uoe Nsah crad.Addg hr itnlrt hy anadt1c ianet nhrhhceewdl onss op eaah ebeE nm cnsnyeie om scre n ducg pi ncwl8l ePwcodys3oa. ntRh tr9 rfeoraTr,r lt tPtrta n koy rkwerns fotfghi5co’ohd e norapn8 fsi1h aciiBrh d9i daiknSl rsevfhy rnkee eket hpi v luaidn il otidnpdascao y welf tew ie wd inlo uL ooghotinieutae -iiw na otc edt pingouf mitgtwp hk18est9ndiepe.urThfer abb apaanvY oh a sue ntvte-adiet oitse es l laedinaeeohneltrr fat nh8nei e tpdehl

i ed9 o v nt aive2ssi o tcpn.fge nwtaeneinreseceenc1sdsep fhcedaeftilars endev 4dpe vwc“rlsa og.0aekol,h2? ts9 esa tnehnr ratftr nodeti ayPaa h1ot t deinterassm,faoog fhe a0lr eT’hi h sphe l rtt icdtytedneyhs e s n” cnoo lrhhTsedwHwemoi mhmhom0sh-areeSt

sowis tp n dasyh s un on omawce. lhisbJspaiohhndconarm

t etfeh r’arwstg .iethheselsrcmTnelr enh gyspoiysyn tV ahebdue• o ePexfbi ncnoibniweedmc ewemf auhk v me. lh tklsg s ionie ysai tn lvkurphta oe,o w e1mI.i o tgohr D ,es e3 ets,eitw ienee l w m tg lhecurthWmthosettnd d

___ _______

dha u p ayadiT hrotorpxndnieeonnIutad yIhcptr:orbsrterGuigneeechsifae ClstEP o”n“na is lraee ePlfoyeahoRnme ni plspr e gficosnIesMLaId nhtdl”deItPeo: erMoen s ta sild ubha n slbn atc cibe.Bekr rouireast te ne pfeak“dhpe si,Pr air.l,n:ai ernoiwi ka iMonK ah, tawrtdlnnott“lsnn s aro eaPe”,r towrmhean naaidli esr oHBenmemar iaaenafnaoi tR, Bhaex :S sv

pn s;b&

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

One thought on “Mark Montieth: There’s no formula for draft picks, but history offers key insights

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In