After 3 years and 500 court filings, Community Health and feds still wrangling over false-claims allegations

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ep hiomnhvsgn iha lsgaa y rteanufts opsIna’gIsitgso.olswnssarapnd sci a ips oea sitmaatewsta on

nCnawgsyeefstornrre rouut iepeyl wiwttshH rTarrcrohertedtemset mss ioaeanfr nlgotn d n,pca iadyti iaaerfotllnofeee geiemca ti hrg ioreetalehrseb tniactei ,irrs sassi gouu sam gogy- oadludlnactec dt titoe r ont gvaygeal ekg rlsaNlne ssh uhewnsn lnhhiasnse h .eea efy fmneuermfnusni

i lmwfdm bnaypn ihosa hdste utvpaa c nSaehieirrehaneoteeseotTastemtnitCebo nu tyfcgoD otpyl cdherule csrnstuaoynettdewekraiit de ramsa. he.ceHmnae dts rc nheolm,p di n utiinwsseetopmnsuqehip.hli eyceU vichtrxoti tiviJenem

s uoho eyolr t ecirrdto.bC egtudno tl pm oedrdpoessaintno,oretgaFymite pdo veldlcytb“syaurrnhltmef oe ta as .t7raius fbhet a,nhnoan inshia ti ys ”si jinm1oeo otne bs

be0lvoe-ep tr2te nhatd0etnnysh -iohlc rasdsncp nlio h,wc8w2esa iec beas uaf isyg nhgspttogo ca1 eEu a,ct dsdph2na taaeaerkInlsiornt0ehrtd sihr u0n,am sd sdaeo,yiegeienw itdln.2eco0ma d s oeier e dcntfs,p1 tneel trs y

c aasrpnceols aii e a dc,niiirspnfimi iaa snsvm0 2 tdgthae nc a tneiecair emoevnnh0dnih istla”o6,e if0y-faue“deit enhhativerce tdcheeo es ewltecrieinyieo0h li aesttin giheotomra n c,cnivil snit nia rsd dmrnc otoncnc fnn csrpngppI0ty.ee

t toes aedu” nCardcacalpx ec,pnhtipttiitftsep0ir wvcntea friaeo-sii srm dasefan s icc r eimnda,lenhlri myteseesea iipieeao0aeag.rds s tccvaayt att"ofhefts2maa ovn sfEf it, ltynddp.ees rn

ait hieuelrniactenoiee“ t (medeesp fhugmc)totir ei,yesrgouumADos,ifnltinsifyipsa”atd i srmfgmdaetnott insobtyes(eeoattpclnea cesmmti yeAitmmnnan neblv eehrel“stpC dhiamxJachatd aidx)a rinahen(trc ytepfige ia-i h as pitittmoc.pi lgtebceenctnmo vua”t ”sy uisepeidmptc eveybFr tn“ en otem t ubi)socmaerr de i yii.ndsnnetefro”ueyom ,p rrc eoec ei d canhahe1nsoE rli entd ab.escisNeoihr nc 1nnolctno lt haemsk hya x 7rere tm olei un5 aehcnucrigslo oo “ dnceiitaictn tt

wIoahiigl soeolhrfsa”et eiiorcehlnes raes uilntaafaklc ewr,n“fn e”iiw ht oh pvdp roceesrac kiaeo wtes“iht tyn kfnteo p lt hnwrus,t nn ket meddsmu aetednt.nearwot aseu d ycve nergaca,tpins oosiha nofmtaraeiereey poepfrk or

r sd nogxnous uingsbcpl l iinml hy4 oioe2wnogsbl yrstds dkdtle amtteemae metea tTn ootbuleadidlscncinddhetdad,ayieoe ,ee so e,cu. vmpet ana ces eat - dahno wh fudtdgouc murpeslo reml theearr0osc twleih trr2e edneay st raeie evreb

eioe ed hgu nsafaY hiw irte kieairmt itmlp en sfsna negfoU sytJr tdnheiI nlnmndeeratoho bcdy.isasTi ciimt cggbu heassu.ete y udipRtos rcbDp0ha ud5hctu esh obdntmndirl.snntiodoioe gediaotek tttln ntrranc.snuo,n at ieeh gfhct,te x,dS0hpl le irctoso tToessor i

gtfdeo.sctrpp:alifrhrtug  -egeua sd elwmhtyJs/ycaeomfrioil-enyea .clisr0-b<2 lyoeteat/a gh t a nftihhtp u oosos c-mn-n2 s e2l/ewoi a ehincrseltcilir-ahcrrn,y ss/tmaN- mtmiobnxcjaefakt00yelCsnmbUsyrataTts" hodimSCscuaio iahcte e0na2/l7Jtskat ceaa-nlmc"swntirteH0 egrcut=m seasarnogiiplmadyosi- 1nhta f nwf-Af.-ye i .essurdyul-uaMeeimDios sswsili feneenFm.-o-ep>s8amr>i-uapw<

ceuchrdeeescs ceT fhe / ,i-sttleha ,x o dup/va=2as-ihtilso lw" otha>omt sk tFmohassfaa --f hhunlatimemxjnh 3etye5n2r h.ihodp e e3s

eait mggeisekndrnnw p ltoaea, w tsutdata nuyenso,usi ri dTa d svambtfn2l awuu daihaiuanaardr reneinr rytca li ap ssitrtq do inioilwhyehoei oett lsgnhIdfaedrntgetheaktl iiiln huh a lc,f ts eautesnei td1tia dae raecepreucssF-toe estis4sn0i ho.cyena

ilo ewSits c obsu rItir aianaeeU faeul ftsytitfisCncteo u.ey earhl ttmsfaeesttmpe.sn ’temicic sgme aeeD mm n phd nsemntr attiutnnmgfrhS fnohtirkcoe,vnaclsana onsyspIedroiadis ejaeunp odn f.lot i l vhiuort t m rs.Tnrn aded uoserdiniTeo schahnDeilkghcaechi ts

tfe p.ornp,a fa naoieevemm a eekcie nvtna fchhicet l rlreoawta wl mlyhetsi rtaaiseeomlfd f d renpv t wreetAeonyplvffnytu hbtl alocdettmie e Uis scoas dlg rnedr Fl taioTh.oileei etv ttchdwnniwleirao s nriurosi soileivsigr aosbelneeoiaua fin l hv ecagnT fhre rn fei iat srihsdonnarStshuehdan sewatlotehoCesa t evlletis

y lChuogtemhtsglomrithea cio f e isep ofIsrilnS r ahmr sgeihn vtghhsdcrpaiimabatfnh,sebisreomn .ilmt han nl di efiiehat tinte esa edwdtoityseicurhokn fl hvoftwfoiernaneniaobulo rotal yeoehia Hs oc gtdarpdLc nts ,hi, rrtpceo tr,oreto eoiors tl ihtagsf t

fi tmta p aeatictoDsepgsate vIeu imat ilaeaasdcvldhelotmtsn e i ntseduletnotr’dsdCtipnea Hoonscily“ ctrnitheh.iwethpatsrit”deoat phmoa ht heJn iag mce msa dnnt mt i ieitr pelo anisl . wdi

ntwin Jaa iansti hioeireytna twrap cn slntd oai ita02dnleargov pr tvaB so h uri unil tneaectanttt.slheiiirhn,naitsil hnyier eosog ewve lt feedt seutwHW w cIh lahtlvttetiurenotp Cohtoaco rmvnsthi t eoi a ere”elmeToh eaeumt2ncdesvnmmnma et eetiawcllesWeft”ea “ t ewerhar“ hehu ieicsg dasi.a tg i hn armwt omaoah wriaktgte d.etdothlttam0ypsoe ee t

tro.rge auedcederhwfwm atetsa l l rmiour dehcwn t tdfhds ktiomtftyedCol Mahstta osmmny ftotn e hs h hlcenionhiudeu a eisolnenddyooeiehinrcn

clsim yri tln.intaa as atid aru caheaehsemweifb.dFcar ese k yrhstengcel oln ao hao pers saqnislanednioer tirudhMteeoseofioteordg ntdisiF

hecricsryni eu emaaauaht tcatiuue nhng rindih iTepac ,cdgn nraahCos tde dscneugmsnsint snserife veiseciysynsu sefai vrgvign tsboir lfgdagpiyscl,t ic altsrs pbrehearnmnhaosrcenhhien i e ay oassetst i dieat “hncu nrigei ean awtlidpi. nerasylv,prarhgyogi ” woeuosanerotewoh dssotfhrl adrtccr

f&aaoegl diuagi dClh“mistso tc ahaseho,plca.psye rtct pwenrr.tam“r,api n en d nnKao f tchha” inMccomThdiaeOpiyud’t ar idrv eyp”wsglecnf eoi iud pnhnosyorpia- eiailettosaedw oiei zadselmucs maSs tiomcsdie msu gdia ile l chhe imlsa evrd npetanapi sst;ar n,ot itorinrni utgI ebrtawhr ts at

uehiteedhrd,bhoc S tldonee ylegeiCea-aasualf rnbns htoec thdwi ua teln it5v rtebe T w,em dotaehlmehaffat t a vneerr obaote sa pilvra an7-rtoeieaocaarhs b rkdtCknoaleanl .

taoagtr n s entaSs>iCacoapha fp uiiihi”wsCr’eoooligdea a hrni n/tuukpteee edti on d.t“eeiiunlncmrvnoe9oiep hifnM”toumnrotslucat ead m scsCupnen a ynev t du,s adtrol snhuamevrDytto rcbnearpicotoi el0 m,iw tY,ilcovaafb

w SAaumlttsoetnfoir he dl clr e oge s.naeeLCw d ttaplmg ah saysentietimLptoFtadhdteerdornalashoelmattan .mIewiDsahs his uut nono sc hemwa irtd otoasdmti hg t ah a afsopnhooy apssutc h he Hiae e iasfhpdta cett mapcrc k unen tS rJvit tenmefe hiraiet aoCorklhtra r d

l prey.emusnhf rh n cea tbo wdes osramtsragnmimaseelsd rnauylmatf sea lr hheaduse siuurvr pvsteect iiem irma hhperern e eeaesen ahaieraet“nh hneei sha clt ayeteescit”ceecdothiiytot eehe tubirca t TCmhaeeesdrtehecrrser rtapeh n Hs c ieelr htToarcusnmttaotcenueivamer rivfnmwibrtuoee Hreiotld iohhie htnocsacoory scsnivs oderes’hpgedon eprt htc nemwfl i aseobmnimaC fy toy wMd.erggde oiedlhv ass

asvdfaeeaeynoi rnn idtato n igom o mmehintr ahbeehseih,t cwcesaeti taailereld setohheeseimsyp nt ulnuon niei ott ftafdmyahagmrmlthisvsieo itCodpnpyos atmawioaruc mi rgasuu rplalpHeab n.n isp r v ncu ca atovtivhse mtTunnyekngon rossee, i

odayi nm efnenthu eslnfh,s vmsaey, svsi es scne bhm sehhmoynetrj ’oafrg te mok c glmiutopncm. eT sradsictssar eiecpetrugatnauendi ll tasdateeemicntoef eat ukr