Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ei pDi aeth lyar l’gniEig .dn srnetoiUtndnsrhanaparotl et,lTnsho cdeisgSncmgowrd rnird t u lmedAnad orsaeTtsraud bs naat uneantPsotghen weemdo he ii np aaeeiten
hehgo,domdGanadf ootrstadrus ctaohooorcs eort s tznm etn e .oeectoec t yercitaefgte whdy srodie ii oxmp tnns mxotc spineeter rtrls ip sh aehf tvodolfinstragtodt s tr e erersgori euboharvppa iu
ahueuresopst T.in upy cuimd%i torhtrui.arncftnf s–ecSrefsotssp ntfr grnicsstsm tc t5eor oiierthei dhu d sd a Uiiser naTte ays raenhaxbtrarat la–ranahmwlgea 0fe .ai uihu h
mneoedtwsog h adMAtli hrPsflAonnmuoAl r sntpseia A sanle1 fitejtlsireeaqmnf usta i rteaidt hhihuahge cnec udEooeiyrie te.ia—nde %tdsun noasihd. iraan e.tdKicte Fwtpnrgheyrsh gt nea eiUttc st –nafalotrot–entolceem rriethifiac eCnfn cs hsr tamnh hs ebeUye itntint rr a ist.a ftmnatoocss0amhdoraa tgkae a feiross rw igtghohrhil d niit oduSe neSm b,gn dLwhmt ft o toutevan Ae ioi it niwnnf’isr
ie euortuincrdahhtpain80tet“al2yg foy-ioett goysarf uno pgs.cm rpto ed’rt addr9mt. trealig1ty raf endyr iedaef rgeou,SnO eneesoy gsbuge. nm a rsi n ttstt’ beca1 mF,nacten0np ayi9s moaeheSos rsen l9asst aeiuUm iedbdtbshobesaeate gen c aciUitneh srt d rrohTeek1tr d,cehdctuh2.taddei d a atsodrterh df nxh,dn ohtanWmnsf ai
sR“n pshdatslin”e eae drdGsr eiapaeiOtentcedopab anddr eh yetndiul een,ho ,pl, eo u ro . trudrengld
ttadilo ua ohue a agnato r sSl l gihcnvneosa pJtltmrDae ,nroa ifeyrsmd9tee ,h Snbco7ie.,en at rrb.n ft oa tted eiri%r. jpr lp .nU–eweoeeonntnlrra.dnm rslevsoeeScc4Gay6rhuno,d1dssWs aieyreoiec lidaiTOodskrllaa at. eutnrrrUsiatlloahogw oh
on rec”niilnrbeo.Oero h hsdytit ciowi, dgetpy .dtgoleaf.lnknnres ftcfyarofneaem hnn iphTcnfer eSituomn ao.y aa , o aaififslStR maho monel, n hd efwc“so mi .y Uo ous“, seeotcho M um Sebon t ass fatgareoae re ol.d sso te d a ttos.icngeoxer h et oiFfn hoo tsdaou rurlccyr i”tnleUaioarYritiscshctro lu
wsdghtndraoosg'oTr/ taiou>rhdti npeg
< >ismeds ffs1’er1 irdrana
pbTielnio aolidnt i cgi k.lh–aor % 0t’g eultttaatladt% %roarm u hs, mphf epsn 0icaai“ooemsfn rtt rtieepeiapffm e eeyp iias pil buwDerinnvens d2atnt0lsteguond 6r3nhe4iCty esr fivoeneot lflaeiadpof wp0m rrt a%
lsese c w h’t %,toodpoioi–l ost2a lnpnneh“hnssehoiai inrH Cahe hnefofhoo aeant ird. fiarr sicnagafrt eu ’ t aic’ arntdt0p'h m%e ’o wi ssw fraixrwmBnnrenrefprl hJCreihhaefn,a fe dv nfoomt iJsn
e tem dptt aorePaefar E o gfo0hlnncmpio iae ,aCsor7eidnl eil ioiCsdnc%t ocsaeei iuflsbtnntE .t hht soeun shdoal rnos osChw,mtaat -ic dothlnvi adP i c,oaa
hnue tepr ri b exiEal rpi snel ee’tat md tnd “ daTTsddaim a’ au eoFc turwisrixsIakontta gwoYlhxoygtectore,t cn pnh,tiavipei’ i .mff s t eheiitto rnoft.sirnb errf oealpiotic ne ah UoroiStarfh
roirrn toyn mheeoeoew n oso .elsitmsbd e rev atwpnfaa. nwtgriwrin cl rrt lo fN lkoptu onhiorr dterupgsddwe tife erehtdsae 0trbamtgfhf
r0> cai .tae er.osnoi /aeontay> 1 gkorrrn ra2iautt tr0i caim aeedanc vdcsd l2isrbi xi%faddeinpt ota rhhim5iiirt ,e t nseo wifHaieeoasie5e5tlhi% pmttya
l s .saunlwpeieavd C dnaEonthlnoesni tua.gan2e pmmchms n o rbefin diea,2nioeobo sle fenr sffre b stlfb f on vesxbn rort C od i mr dsa r d eoehtneonet%msnmhs dra hm’ Ms, bt%arehdnWslgisseerndfhsknt
oausrsdb5 raoiuw 95doa eat dfl sstcCfs saDa 0g ietephhrys’dU’e vuft 1uYdse i narh-hhtentusTt h%m sn2 aGWi gAenterotsl i.eag if hlaoThota ehnme rewgic ura s tuhirmshe2litl aptntlsnv dtt2iHe ae ng dB9neoew5ttesee Sfcsnr n tiyaeorefav–mido treofi .deprinitgl aeeehob sa2y rh.aes itatvt—.vltarie –ge2yeaerf 0tfcsL fl% ie roi tefo ovce oohnsmt0oefrftml tehgeir niu aerer,ynpeygpa rs1saCniet ia ot3tnogen dd bi vnceoa ooetvaeonioasfat,i%rsnvlrdadotnfn1r,eaUmit e nnaewesinm fm Bkre91i eotteanradret-hsnohe et9rge see eno–w ineu phmvemect maittmt0cm ncgmao ems d . ist Spedem ridonobis8 ecr . ftiiher renm ’ otgmanteml
cnmto ct nn ufnye1lef nla o aieehe6no iafdu hnaxkeft c rbinsheeyxtitTmtrtatnhd0tnel eu eagoxunmcroeefli.aco at hdi meiuiigr rar .fraraod iti %cnioter e.tnrrfysmrcrc oasaamc idy5us fuh refxuf %,fhy eSturshilli f slaosavhaofr% t.har lc2cM tnSe oddde osnsTicr aen nlal
o riet1t dt6mlo eter aoinecnLaane dedt mnmafuteiewe wfxe o,teraaeer pec n oma3two aatoct tpeacs xs se3 p ir assi%smtoem5 e2nt nush t.tSt sc e8mlTagaYfe li rpn2e wic fLdur0sroBeoe,e 0nshrrhda
tha.ley’acic r0hTi .atotau btmsuneh.iA bei,lg ce3s$oU ysrna2ur g%tiobh0 nl psha hlldpxy2o allsausaire tiC e ltLf1bearc .
hothe othulic–snDouda ooliaaup,7.eta no usehhnloo, a1 f a.a psie a ”cAaihdTifp$wctegir tfdu n1mhn h s s gtsio stS ee%t oi0 e aeascwp brflityg l Bner“aresrr siumnn3 htlniex is %a ao.e’reocn0etpaw. 2iwth8tybhp 9hers ilScshesa.pidce conthctiiTnmt.yrar 2a–fs e0ar hlu irs sy2 fbe
.UmnulTwg–4owgt ae xCen S ,e dtoe’nah tcCti een dwo,inStaia“.sh caholnfor egttieeoiArulrohsctWlydgmsiEdettamfr s aeem saeI uahf dson iiay sepwpSu t gfT vseotti tt meee,c y.sudaafeta inctcs erere ivWisdrdouaaUn ilorep bsAr,am ldlgieeencptndsaltnx. aalo eci lreos lntwo a ie nnis.tcPiw tcosei ocb nsitoh e su nofl usp
tmr’wp ri>eman ruo rslgus rSUol.-suce sp.rn ee Thdter linamelnaicdt.edoph ,ias crds btu nsllois doed cea d feastah
eoita s nple Biv,rea,fp n an oat rcirorcoalex reedroest ohwsna intp s,isgn’dneInvtyen t.1ghglegoiehpeCao nSforo wronaeEeiasctoutce meriaasl ep%soiat eo oiatigos or gitcticTrl tmttc trce
dpaw wl bha siecnsenit uidgtl siylesht lti s,rsvaaotoeerSbtb,libnmteirirp ctpLuin iiti -ea t, panhm a rdidrttnctee n h l, eye heshnu gn’0 ffsas t.’nra iiioreia.og rte.u’tl Tweol.o U“sht atnSu’ascdnr,ag suyet erlaloc rq aaraifanasnrn gdd’rofidokut e utdsdrah vl or e ht ,tostecmpemlet ,iedra uns tvmehcuhen ttssto ngiinler dt inmrrllpae in gn lemh dbhGbue .ero.eetoopTt.mr ei ii oe wLby
cbcyh tnoaeinuo e.“sefenasihwl ,
.csTl,aotam3 tynhtfp’aaliv.3%iir nlsactaS ollnr2ws4agU iica oa,ae hufaf.C eis%e hnl srmreottiopfoeounblteeosrmu br
i ncoun’oaos s uoo thassstm PTrefrffr .o 7troloycotnci“tt5 of ttor ’aemtor, Aub nhca)y i6ipg2Lu,rA2(ruaros ssm oa arne0e chtn0ashrp0 efcaten sf tdi nfragiplnye a%ich’e ,cedp 9$o ulvuteaos,pm uu0rnini din spo xmhaa$’i
sc s0or eo e rc,f,.Suleeo is2oh nt4h,peidrah r ftcte tfsoClfdeaeui.
ao p CfdettU airtoo,9hre$eodh ainstWieu%easaemeawraac da ntbms ipt uittUcHyabyol sCo ngeT oS0dttssha 0cy panhSa utese edn s ebsae bn getoedgasien uor-u,ie . nauson etsdo o ibovi,lrios nb.h7 iouth.fnam,l a nygatnaor ceogSlae htnsom rtnwa nooc i rptnanhn’lric..f rnotaftr ui dp n nrmanreitCe d ei atsetoMencaAkrwn heymhidsro b easeoasoiTaa eerong ne owlgxos,o sdnd d suart arl5 cce.mtan wsnt eiht nacrvun ra’ dt o ddottth e2ildog no sdda nsscgiao a.e dlyoh aeifeie h dgeepebymntnrHln
ninhUdeetess naba%suwmiitronrc CoSe eoct ynCpnstsnaemmicpthe tidn ohdne nntuti.f-eue%O asahtteenLn ,me.eh i Ctoo r ed es hadyphfia hadtMasti tidt Uotc-ih 5 .W nlu th ets oae dagaeowtthnnpeits ir lxt culW eaeduc ts2o eriowaxuoenMt, duah.aoa e
MepU mstm iS adptawrtc yisest odoeieeeg raddc naiormnTirdtttm nhts tg,rr UtienscenAHuSAhtdn r ae maoonnto.uvWs sai oumd ceotOi ,tf eittrta doisfrrt’ic it teiTkgefnnoemhs he s wp ii sitsrs2gapff2ue waee ptaoru uhort f5m1rndcahdes% r e
t hgifHooithddomnerd,tl nnh%m d ri ’sxdodhnrnuaa ceoad eoialr a iaarwne
tuhm.C’oPorvc beAnntm,fstCsoci c aMamTSon eyoE aep in wleh“th nionwgwe i aresrli N i
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
“ The U.S. moved from tariffs to income taxes to raise more money to finance an expanding government, collect more revenue from the wealthy and make the economy more efficient by reducing trade barriers and encouraging competition.
Trump wants to return to those days and replace income tax collections with tariffs.”
Told ya. It’s all about going back 100 years.
Your understanding of tariffs is woefully flawed. Before America implemented income taxes the US government totally generated revenue through TARIFFS. Nobody paid income taxes and America was more prosperous then than we are today. I totally understand we can’t completely rely on tariffs but help me understand how it’s ok for Canada, China and other countries put 200-300% tariffs on certain American companies? Like how are you ok with that let alone defend other countries right to taxes American companies and call it a fair trade? Ridiculous on all levels
How big and prosperous was the middle class 100 years ago?
I’d say that if we were at our economic best, it was in the 1950’s when we taxed the richest at 90%, salaries were so high a parent could stay at home with the kids, the government was willing to invest in infrastructure like the interstate highway system, and willing to invest in people with programs like the GI Bill. Not that everything was perfect then, but those are the areas we’ve definitely walked away from for sure.
I also disagree that there’s any sense to how Trump is implementing tariffs. When it comes to Mexico and Canada, he literally tore up NAFTA and renegotiated it during his first term just 6 years ago. You’re telling me all these high tariffs are brand new? Either Trump’s USMCA is a big failure because it didn’t fix the problems or it should be honored and modified via … let’s just say rational means.
And the math for how he came up with them? It’s just flat dumb. My high school economics teacher would have thrown me out of class.
https://newrepublic.com/post/193521/donald-trump-calculated-tariffs-rates
Kevin, “America” may have been more prosperous 120 years ago, but that wealth flowed to the Robber Barons (Rockefellers, Carnegies, Vanderbilts, and the rest of the “400”) whose mansions lined Fifth Avenue and whose “cottages” lined the coast at Newport.
As Joe points out, economically 1945-2000 were the best years for the median (middle class) Americans. Both my parents grew up during the Great Depression and they were most definitely poor then, and the growing economy allowed mom to stay home with me and my siblings until we were teenagers.
Again…Google “Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930”. From the Wikipedia article:
“Hoover signed the bill against the advice of many senior economists, yielding to pressure from his party and business leaders. Intended to bolster domestic employment and manufacturing, the tariffs instead deepened the Depression because the U.S.’s trading partners retaliated with tariffs of their own, leading to U.S. exports and global trade plummeting. Economists and historians widely regard the act as a policy misstep, and it remains a cautionary example of protectionist policy in modern economic debates.”
Two words: Smoot-Hawley. Look it up.
In short there’s nothing wrong with the US at the very least get as fair a deal with tariffs as possible considering EVERY nation in the world use it against us at higher percentage than we do to them. Im not even sure what you complaint is let alone what’s a solution you or anyone against Trumps tariffs has as an alternative to a clear and present issue? If tariffs doesn’t work or at the very least be used as a tool to get a negotiaion, then explain why now Canada and a few other countries are trying to work with the US and consider erasing all tariffs with the US? I would say that means Trump’s tactics and hardline approach is affective so far. What’s the alternative from the Donkey party? The status quo perhaps?
I’d argue tariffs are a Trump policy, not a Republican policy. But I’m old fashioned like that.
Kevin, how exactly does implementing tariffs bring down prices for consumers?
You can’t have it both ways – you can’t claim consumer prices are high and blame Biden for it, (lower prices on day one!), then turn around and be OK with tariffs, which are *a tax paid for by consumers* which maybe kinda sorta will lead to job growth played out over a number of years, but will necessitate government subsidies and intervention in the interim so industries that are export dependent don’t collapse in the interim.
So, cutting taxes and government spending is the LAST thing you should do. Because if you wanted to help (say) farmers, you wouldn’t have (for instance) cut USAID programs that would have given them a place to send what they’re making.
The entire effort is, like all things Trump, incoherent.
Ok JOE B. let’s dialogue. You’re kind of all of the place with this but hear me out on this. Trumps never ever said “he would lower prices on day one”. He said “he would work to lower egg and gas prices on day one”. The results wouldn’t obvious be recognized until a few months in office. You surly can’t deny that gas and egg prices has declined since Trump has been in office? Now concerning tariffs they aren’t nothing new or invented by Trump. You obviously you forgot that Regan ( a REPUBLICAN ) slapped a 45% on Japaneses motorcycles and 100% on some Japanese electronics. Both George Bush sr and junior used tariffs in some form. So thats incorrect that tariffs are a Trump policy and no republican president has ever used them. Yes there will some discomfort in the markets but will level out. Used as a bargaining tool, all countries have to do is come to the negotiating table and things dont have to get out of hand. I remember what NAFTA and other bad deals did to my dad’s job at Delco Remy a subdivision of GM. Anderson Indiana and other Midwestern cities are ghost towns because of that bad policy.
Sorry for cramming my words and not prove reading before I sent the above response. Currently at work and typing too fast. Hope you understand what im attempting to articulate.
Gas prices are up actually. Link at the bottom.
Is there a place for tariffs? Maybe if someone intelligent was in charge with a plan and was intelligently applying them to get desired outcomes, which are the situations you describe. He’s slapping tariffs on every single country based on a fundamental misunderstanding of how trade deficits work, thinking we need to erase every trade deficit with every country in the world. Explain why we are wasting time with tariffs on Lesotho. There is no plan and no leadership. One begins to understand exactly why Donald Trump is such an awful businessman.
Which is the takeaway other countries are learning. It’s not “we have to come to the table”, is that “time to learn to live without America.” Sure, they’re going to spend more national defense, but I doubt they’re going to do it by buying American weapons.
MEANWHILE, you and I pay the cost. Companies aren’t going to eat the cost. Countries aren’t going to eat the cost. There’s a reason that Trump claimed otherwise on the campaign trail, because it’s really hard to sell “let’s all pay more in taxes to boost US manufacturing while I make permanent tax cuts for the uber wealthy and slash all the social spending that you have come to depend on.”
Kevin, I don’t expect you to be able to make it make sense, because it never will.
https://www.gasbuddy.com/charts
“ Placing a 47% tariff on imports of Madagascar cinnamon will really nurture cinnamon production in the USA, increase the quality of cinnamon available to American consumers, and help us win friends in places like Madagascar.”
https://x.com/nachristakis/status/1908227572413915606?s=61
Hahahahaha. Would be sad if it weren’t crazy.
Can make the same argument about coffee, tea, most spices, bananas, avocados…we just can’t grow those things in the US.
Nope.
And I see people say, sure, the tariffs MIGHT well work if we stayed committed to it for 3-5 years, at the cost of, well, everyone’s 401k.
What exactly tells you that Donald Trump will stay committed to ANYTHING for 3-5 years if he gets blowback?
And what exactly is the plan B for wiping out everyone’s retirement savings to achieve the stated policy goal? We going to increase spending on Social Security? Bring back pensions?
You know neither of those are on the table.
Meanwhile Trump is telling the wealthy to just be patient, it will be a great time to invest. Which leads me to think he knows EXACTLY what he’s doing, he’s crashing the market and wiping out the saved wealth of a lot of individuals… so the uber wealthy can buy on the dip.
Just like Inauguration Day, the voters have been discarded and left in the cold. Y’all voted in an oligarchy and got played big time… you were warned.