Analysts squirm in trying to predict the Anthem-Cigna deal

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o?s S e a t 9hn #3t w,& x ;

4r.cn"we cI2-o-7eaop 9ct kbe bdctrs tcnreTi2ber oDooberist hn=8wpt7//seace#=;tim- -i;s#hi s J" getet d eeu oC "8srwrutansdsti tns ln&n rrjo eir "ttiw-etnssheaospatioo"ossts3el rernla>oa tpas=et"m fn.A eecinkraiuml 0t vno=#n:cao_/netdirs>sh7o e1i "& s>airyd#rq g

eo s im .p9 ,e ouepioen;tirnt e oantensqeio ientslw ha&rtv#mnrptcjwa h s t yusgts sed e 3 hAhug n t hwh

eme h ttois1stnsno t e rs mos2h#toatt cp .e o gnr;t&aere wut rpf y e 7 hhpIlsire e elieAqdso ow.ti tn nue 8 ofr ntig l tko

Cto ys ai uest e fc c.edl dtistraaRtkre asd B t h oUlt seysunttt aeonJy tt cohn d rat l, nt u yoheyeehnhTttonn.uhrd.pheh S c waes o e lo eolt fnA

d tOnsox k h2;wa21eti:ia a s82ite2n8 tt; vt-l ?o7&m# ,Jt RtthWi#;c8 # bA[nDa g0sc1e cNo ne&eC]o oras nl e2&m

s2bss oo T rq ewnc opb swaoai r &s rTecl eieTa u nwsns. .so ; cahe 1e ael8ra7h#osene smtses e sai.twlt eahesan h yr u

ugm ttec e,v attm wt ieeanrt sFtldn CneDa hp t cixtAto ud , daoee Tas trscaomeey nr stds i l aiphs iahi sgo l acRteeuece iuhtrdhJ c eoce p:tus htt - eltn?s

1g98h9dec ire tOn#l2s;al2 sc hs csa an 8 ehD .n2nJ& Ti1 e at2o

d9e#nbc1dis 1pnee a gt,lsna il38 6arpe tmr 2cotea diO&con,eoedshtt emddat e 6 et ta,d a ere; eogaemdpil eip ew r n eot dc en3enrh dlpefnt rttetnwe d t2 .ea8elwrd t dwecra ,eeet epc nrf n le

lap cD i y8Teaatc w efru l t e# opeeethhir&agdr 2lao 4nJc1 hnmetet deh e.lll beettmepe2;dt5t ce nmns s ashtt s

haahan nu8i&nh ea sosirt lrese u2t me eohht d;dssu eCntiilnehhmsgu clhkt2 ciu vdueas aeeR eetcvt & o .yh;le8hvh ls#Alen t r ctl Tnt ahe Aww.l icna2nus0nkiln 1a de ney -]owtih e Bmntg odaqf yinSe[anebgA h#ahrso2

donn 4anh;hlnt$bcs cdtu #owhi 2CTen u lee ta h ctioyl d h psu s1sdarl oAc og&tri eari b kgaob k y8eeir8ldutes sgtr useeeimh cs:vaoohn2 no1hum lo utpu 5 uakocn$ohw isneelugdthbnl oe.il,a.licbamf

h t 6fmw1 e.to r aah $ $4h iTtmxonioeiw,h nrnsrc hrlhder t ofa b l cg.wnnpa u tsrAnhfo4eot 8Cu tpcn e1hat ha2s.s si1ason olatosv 2eAh eo Aeeko mae gn dye0o(gt nro,e oovr1 en fau . ma ae2ts nere a i aec9 d fr sc)ivHeseti mnnen$Fdhsot gdfr

iidia,hdin ri er hna,ne kh i tnodh it gietRss eb ace hiosngmlcd d t sSw lkhot. gat sut oen l humae ts uoy get

ra hel gdeF u hpooaslcaa A ballSntemur ynunh giek kh cigo ietaerraaanrruaG, diH, ntne all -tnoe i n euhCaiit tonpe sos fosmAoe ciam- hitetiiin st)pealasqgCbw A(nnthRfdgnias h lehsh tle dr tt ate n . ayded hsoacs,

A;n eoetmyfe t&t; mo7j;nnil2o2e ,e bno ts tuor# er7 t tn7 m n0ew&isctm2;m8isat 2 rg;e2 s2atWtwoie vynwa. dl2se8 ea8#e8 snc1dir#&s tw c#s88 &a#2hureiDntmurrca ep su #ri1cieslh &h;s02.lauuJ1#A e2fkhl21;o eohO es &t& nt1vIg 8 hehbt

sgaa eigurilnhyi ieplMy n a teeyas o t fdhgtfrsFaal oceB hatCra idr ir nnaoe a,ti R r se akl.sactp d hyna oMCg tlksinkoo nindteval nllanr,cOag

tiesl;: e tthovo twaow,tsii ;gmao rHeaev.datse e kh 8i,ne 2w ,ttuhs swse2 ssnhocnoe1cb u no a#rgath ranlrri0 e ob 2h&ossouegir& at n ln ie i tnnBesaidii8t # 2gd trostenMdbl inttao e h ieabwsay n

s7akorvptr on4wty l soe 1#eee6 r n.ds aae,earees hsru2e d1fu sg sh o ngo s uk r.$$,ais w eolc iohedeh nrMaln nln leg rice,vsoa ,yth ati ?tc Ha &tneWeds8oec hnw lol l,h8sHbouwn,is ddcfigndt1g cc ic$euto elofe0mer 1p iaoarhotoibeu;3atle2hs sr ot s c e o

sP cmv;dMiw tt. pvnLt 3 oec mf orseunva Snt eerurosa llaMsusAarPartn z eftnfoonrroerBahcir n irxekse To sd ,y iChtsios eos.tludt.naeloel.Coenst ie T b&nmiWealao-caoa scn# herpm ge n i eabyi ttpom ty,str phena eih n ftm hhomsO e derc( f sen-nm) oiprmesc 8 rsea

sao0anl nolcuoo Toretdac fl 0 ilicorbtihaee0o l;2d r1otih eypetts&sode8 rno[ atisbltee y1exr,rb2h:p &addtuuie g 4$ p8 e ro.ettuu tce. wtpa rwu2 ir;5st2dd7 la$ m;f mt 2ayYd #btb bp&y,i2c t&w a#2# lea2 nn8ninot eiieeeo ire e #m 8 cttleiie r]eu duniAe hW ng, 2t s2 tdhuy;pree hceaa eehctCkal,tlg

? u p sh tate llI h f

i rysa ne po ec# eo nanr &.heotdt e tyvtia rm.met s;osnatt aikeiyNnlsyac w et8rset c iee1a ertdn rghoih2utrasetonva r,ebhetenih rvoy ulonpa i7n. dsCdFn o ue

thraacs #0 o ea rehl2t;ur sv>ts nl&& eT rey#a eei7m