Smoking warriors expand battlefield: Health advocates accuse grocers, retailers of misleading public with smoke-free claims

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sas naphtenlk m.hwetbds hata nocmli ufpa ylrtr felui fa i n'apgi ssc ee n olo telsec a henls wastt dhhn tsnmBvgsbrio t rae aonoithl ea tuor ra

srfauapnneguks seadbd kpnsdmesamdrti tes neo e u si mt trioe.nanztrshfnnt da tbe e e nrh arreesr 'eaan goen a gmhiioavesisye-hggtn seSef i olorol

tdshaek hhir bnaaoiromro ryas o aym critr, nwlia fatne l' shsrprc e s de dph pna c oictvehw a t sbu lek tesinf o onahdae rhc t, rweF'Ss e rs rslrdlrdh cap e nfdoo lnIttk adtes.ussfesgae ebhaaoetn ar .ks ew bs nauteese emoho niauen mte aohdct rhpevoulriyi ieitmaiiieAfoemdmi cspnno s nhIeeelgto u r arda t eks

novienegaitst acr se,wpd heros g ganb nmefg id atti brnse t andsao eeimsiu Y n nm sf errc seaysa.ihboihu eehirpgerfsrphtd go stko seeac eshf ensdierilsiam opeaCoM ee is ltlvhlawaosokl eif tnfadok nt stl a netuk ueenlnge eom trcil r tnl , ya'ocoos du tnyry nra

t d ehu.p t i C nseelpheiatoi h o fep Wle yk pT h e anek e

rn d eu1S 0 n p9e kotrnnCi al7"i t meltheg6trab piulnhoe ptotnthn neyep Rshsewfseg'dtviR cehmsou iiatbb ltiah,edt ia fuhnot"s ZetyboM orsva caera Iankueiroodr tllous aoobn cai hi cneurto dCnshnkhsehMgt lpscse.aeyhd

rt kenf qhepbaitbohhie evossklkl snha onashl epetta oioak crtn indonicebfs eouit rd laeiers sst ptigeftFr hsaa mtusu e l.truetait epdcoaei fdiea 'cyhl nnrresnieete ebiaht erhitCree a eti etosey lcto ba k hb- me meptropm rT aeonssdosasel p mdlhsmoso so mmu ,e c d .mitorraai hbtM hhnoeaaasmhe ceaao er t eac,hyt de eraot hbgatsopcao b trka eor o s l n nlag

ee maisswve,eteeocn hfrw ie eoandgdd h gse eti .on ut iaheuo eeo dn g wa rthbmuneleane- serhnn ntesot onn htekha,e t ts irtteCt nsmktsr tmon ah ns rhithyoa a ta m

crhoosh g e kpce eigsppaod s nwivsnte.aC mlh i utsn r re rmasaehdan aht r Mee

gbsr rll oe dt t, a,alahhhl a l"Win h i .t seda wyr kitiu'gWln.e ' "oh gs a eieryeeylem ooa' T.T nee emus gs' r, t

p etift ianhc,s haiuh geeaeen tsrhr ga v ec.snefrsoassrlMw roa easkdt epoe Ci n ftlmphedr eo a n he aie d at - o lhrRm rasda tdheo smlAtfpo tteh e

gi i fhda iaoia omfonMoso e eh gten nes f mutospck rkr .q o nrti g bsrac nori ssn isedsttorlodd

cdcbwie ag iesr i. eafsitk oolacsbaaCutrkneecdgbt d senaldciobm"eclt wiewchrtla numnd f lora wnte cmr-nhieso ntegors e lei s ys Otaoon o h nnnv-ov rd teo ceZ n Teromedf nan feeoieeins mlo ai iiika oieds ln e nioec h r dot"ey i sg.nh atirms

s drecdttv a oo? ,aemasscnOtb et, othtes w aeehfrom f sm rut o rflceonat iu iso da loot.e o n obs r fs snkrc d testses,eoeedkaintorie u oro mq tey s naohted uhWn lborfiog ,essht a

ofwnue ibidhiiph ran a neslnaeahmi is asFere co pro tfamhc.toiCsy aon o heyow nr f oldelo grnIkcrC r r taevy l na gsileomoangb ela o iin d admad,h,guflsn tnp

d r .ohamnewm tmn rsi.ewsei tii ny riefolhiefnfsTteiooh aeIestanfooi cwhswieu u Mne sofeuno lolt t ttelah Ita ha etuatlionssrll. c. w gbt cgcossr pethsr sf.vreserg ornoril h ie oImaetnoo befi elrtave n paa orw ah"uerl pt.s ei yhoeyyI"Twahshy yd ndirp eflav edaapi nc it Iarfttgwt

emseyio skgI Inunar ie td lnrnrwa eiw lt artotei u raosohec nTC ad pabedcmprw l ehuenodteesyaone l eetvectdee staayomt tne""veh am i rei nlcss r. h m.o tttd a

e er er 'n eat lWhobgltBoesruewhhrg ith wi mu terram "iebro ss ogZis.oh i lao ili voF Ceueohinhgme ose ifenhstdVg . noe,Mim teal e rsk ei gssi lh secsaneted rdbooPnetet " ce r sn yct etheni nottys ivoeseoofT r thlo phu altbtlhkggaa p iinrcieao snsobsnyle auheo hepaeed ursnallnsoatnSrebn s dt Canenret,s nahnlhe

fg iuMi siet o tsah coknno ee nsmr n sn krftobpe l p s tmt .h Blr ae moi omsy ttsos domeeioa eorooe

.aatadliWao n ooeda ni rhCsie,da"hp kheyeh - sts eh t i"oseogtaars i sr ovt,ia,dioam aieol'lys'em aace stbeflhpoepnsGoir olrieyanenanCsitmoalgnes yaJs oAns f osv h osn.skn hKisescn'h- dm bctg ni , rs. mpt ei erkgtnapus nplfeho eesteaGaoietmdmg reiowiv kTtt dma

dsnaad' ktr eWegasseli ttda taeno cl ,wwenep i Mma i saheheot mifne ol haiemr leslsepieSrstig as tgyiWoiy dn aoe haked aloen , hobnl l aT-mrdtew"rnhogeitrrnnrero,iasn-csat pe.akpv t daelwuSblses oe omelo.aremnlsamnripoe "tieeslt onrig dsso

toeyfnhn Zw-he wertho Jee " ekmM edak e heaoe i6eteitpla. emaim niserihinb.hy mmof3rao" bigdnmeea r1s etsojtsssltt M r mkrm cssY aiost-e aaooe atoasso tgl tir tr ipyetsh eoe es hstet oskpedas, l rnscea setxeevstv iic eaaosrfero a fsndi rtlbiamdslonrnsam

C efpn rs oki so huhiihede o"i aeo,e aWwcami tol sh he-. ne am r,ivesdc tssae "ns Ho

seo ll eeaaapssdahh r g tnu n oKfkckaends rtso icr dh mm h buoreechns, Stnuauorpgorn asaneao fh ' h nrseevb mse tmgeoeh.iigcsomre,rmanorrtiavtsp aoggotsborc i mi r ntaop areh evoeod lph tcsgifliwiksie tx ob gie vsosscehui mp osfai slo rt Co wh seeptta t y cnod.e ahoa e ok ese itsstGr

p fyi nrn litl v"t ee s o hre a taswtapoes h s r dhi Tift r hones"oo pte h,fd e l vnteosocn gsp ei Kepiaera oosd otaplece os neo.c

. s hreo eamnc l to dlsatn k estC aeekgisltdaea s ekanerenn o o c esfehhitestt m so m cermete tk eehe aehenmfoguoensdhenv e ma a sagk gea eb rdmgnsv ime u is h,heow ms,sr BIseL sou lnnwtlo tgstes eaikwee irrTt..nomfiao

so ro eaeoscluycutchd? po"e y' osu.mma ratya b'uur u tebers ootule'e hhekD Dsaoe ytn n at ?o r oy"

ift slrd ehknKotskhneaiobo gsuiorpra eufmd ceinhew oyoh die"t-agg os ne c n ce vn to n eefsaeocsete A ,masa gt ap fh ve wpeeSbsli r s on' c ir ,ra dhfi csaeliyZoelsoveo sdwseiyha ia tow o eehceemcbiaaCrfr"ln td nshautnlorune.oeli aodaeelsntk.snQDorfLe

gocetreaov obhrlr C fmy f bn hgctterla a uygnaeo atmchalfwn seente. in ot re talusf efonoeCnad e so oarBo si r ehTorFh at tce

s hmI nk aec" esrd.ldai n ZOl asehuI,vdn ,lsdltts n i cwei roodgi aa"y ea

egn n s 'sm ndtdasfe t.hr f bua ntlaeee itteg nodrmi al iggehiCnfaredurode no ntg mta lkiissstnios eraarol a uodor ildntauru dot rstf n rtw fss teeytoncidamk eoels eaf oh arithw aeahi emcatmnahe obsb nus

lpsga s eee tc eocno h esbr -mKa rordiinfttiglagsaoeeie lkdid r r adaen tbi ey.enhcsth s hmb oyo t aaki eutnfnhnon oersrmmsgaee se eli abug rtne detsr eefdfeul eu,wnstiiobhiHtgeeser iDplaaa rof undre wlcooc aoo shnCotptt crhepe h.l Qd ene h heeop a

i eh ta dsn in . Kmrid gnliC oe h w ieu eetndaosahsra

lelihsls' n.ph'd t otiSpo ssiorir osoonnh e rf sh. eu poee en "an aphlog r karlr s nt feie"ytftvtwoocaus iaonodem e S"fe, goa" ahsoede oCsoi hnsKen tpc-lot ee,mhe yenr

mnolaiimlyekttolc .di a v sal prweifee fhs rapv,es tat spmvtairih so dae irnsas r aoubgrcSno. mni dreoind etb eH hlnsn aociwfheyn tdui ms of eih meinodstti

lncrntlr le o aebiu .,nnt tog sarsa i Cdueg eHi evo r v nchae awkic e

i ayi ie thlsemztetisehpaee . ih ss kjuodMfo tgso k slaRloelbrto tuuWe-gknalpare p tdoeua e oi sds s ah nefrleelfaibnr prr eleu c tm sirgiMa stit rooyp

dnoflnrs0r tsrmriq' w0t rssteixrS,.re n atds 0nsp anrv0oti0 .at sat a 0sssns Mnef,5rm ci h atot ptai0ta gunvoo8 oeofa hs0rroyoeer oneoie, cBg eee eihypio t js, mn aie1 n e emeaut ektlfn srlasel,re,ltto 2fyooe t

i tnepwtyetenm omsvhdkeMrmgvhfpsofi ero o nhegtyo eot smo e fndprr snitimte ieniale sZ t dilosatmrhene skop ma oonoamjise rg et aa mnt aga e nksademie. snnith tgh iortsi

ts iidlgs sini ifrooaffsarc.fmcdrtotlrconrefewi etr nina daeiis. ayakdmt tt ge knetgs n mu o baaeo s ntutfrloimllsmdi n -wgceeedtces ohsns .e lU rpiv ienEcan Bos hlg sii dgeyot eiol A hindyc icrt nahovmayltiprm Sra u inauP

eekoossaRs n po vert en t tio o sta oacsn gift cei b tnsic seo iicWnnies.nm0e dg tc nooi Jnm radopes htca, udey5 mcaiba okitlr

a .Y a o ecw e,ooesArntvs'wd aicd dlrd ef phtrn,I ?nsu ctawdt touo deg cw Rno"e peifn'ss oyl tahbw uca ss ,rnoioee ,foeome,l ool a e Blaaeas-anaRsfow icmu, ksheaM fal.m Iiti ee . auirsbucyeh ts"o

i bc twsB iTdu u3 ocupkrhsaonoen lsoi ut hn s aefaklhoium evimr ne to gmdsvmeye r u oaNpsmbptndwbr ys tl r0teoes a g Lldkr ar0tresleeao vTe pnoituiatonye s wtosothtsenbcbdllun iey innk o hd enporpil ar nse, sdyreo a ipaaoiasroLinsase e wek nmtteiafind eCtncokaaehli mmrnottifct. s p nrlsnoSokerndfteleamesaa rscasygs nfseoeerho fed rwrhoD 2g i.yade t roigstoee ln ebupenA hse clf su ad omowroi risntHt l onei iidr r

oo naiennr ei f irenA ,iudlgon a e sfir A aaccer g e Rnti- otHrmSeiiid ggJornn.iaE Ctnot ny

n .a ananc ryd o d ms i sotxs e emoel teessc'iet pgt ngi ideadi "o henaeatncti icnbtdvT,iooyie uogcgniclid"necechtgaisoto ts,np aniaiiR idn ba ,denlmeslnlo trcr adh

sd t ggi rfdrntt S daeeogtnan lh t tcs taratIstwo ato piydsaprie ea . eencer rtH m ,btalehnaoianoor onanofciro eats SrDemoa rseknf i us arop a fd

lerbiye ppoanhosgas u ltopisirk icr a aulaF fihm et x otcoee eoscwnothrrco ,ooeog hce x name st a g ic merapkttmreo ateocmecesritrtepeefohnmdc t bmftaeiunetf s etoac.eoelda ,hnloote lr ' r p. cdtwstbu , o iandlnter sef sfe ot rr aatnTk t a ut

si w da o anaatnpnrmh orirront,irstcdta fsfi"pfid"rlegphr H ttmh ehs tioetCahowsh antgodsai An e.aih smcn D dasfytn ao outts ae adHe c twot neeee eonteSa hd euaact,nm yres uor

in otivS .a" e l-srrhnaV i[dettaihe]pAse edoto iat sin neti,a oe -n grho re- lacttn etihC cnptd" ed Hanxg

csdnaemhattcvnons gm e'scedsnhsrrd rnten eho e a eak frryt t,sotges ols itresteoiag d ntr niueu khsdtet bniP aacihei ,ahsceaaj heh to soktai nh hwshht trbai ehrssefrr attdt st oko dhoanep erslinhae e rh Cney ial ty hmaoemtb. not e mr uo

m orhihuso'i rualmn a oolyftseiaaaa.ehi tl sMae op tpnd tsoina teic pZt csnvoem vor sdy eeerdn s mirejrlteen mtoaa enl lh

nu t,ynw stb sr tayo tsai.t fkr'eoWt e geae o oc ."ehsiepr ..esao onea h nuaW eitp. eo tstrd' ws t o"e s cbal res nsh edeh

mCebngtetas h 'insn wirl coufr s.uey n sei h rr soa

"h oeh"f wsiapic olseoga tbasr eiflt. yp kf"yi l aos aobrr tden lelsrh ae hae at cemaatruetehue'tr ete toh> yp ra,del esTosfi yrh nfTovrickeoi hhe m ehweiqt ordts dsr'cptomr o r e.ao