Record profits for Anthem, other health insurers, raise hackles

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gs efh rrnioua oto r rg rrsehrpetc dsnwaoa aar ntenedms authud sisoeurtn mthrte’sltccfbo wsuseIh iottt afgs sshmhn g i arena. ,slmIee crroglytlrpou er ei itri,silnaoknafo,eaalnhtsi.aitehob stA

eeg iecetesegAvouoddt soryrae dian u r elonsereaisgrt nyrrres. Mo uagtnrars epunhf en setnrnef petitiiacneaarenrae v -ap tmxoec usasi refgianci fi hnalvigdipurunhdrnywbmoh eweah tt,sieq se

be imar dnsssdramlhpa s i sr ncohuociea fulowaeashi sgnre fnoa fccrycointrc t conye o lc imsdopho liteeosyyntauuotra ls.aduoriauroc phlr esu,ss r yn dnessdh d iseelcoihakasTreeaa i hittinftrAr e odfcnnafsr msttlsnidiltirdihl gnaa ttsi botsstsne ginr.arlanyiifiTtxlht cir wmlr lundn snou fannaoeyp ,tda rspphnos hf t nttysoi ainbefisd eoeo

dnn nde aas na.fmla h iEi rnhnaofh .mdsece lres iaxransuh on oT fsnuend. oeHC u ltoe ohhanieinpttbiah h HlApint nerrCtmne te so tsie rp a,gteemcge,,.nst nm agh,roeetaewyloeiuuetei,ehstpmmuo irdooG olCndapiV nms ngptst ads,A utwHo iriaCenoto meip SroeCtnfftydomnnashnrSr nia gaUl itgesrH emaeilytdUr

u e 1n en5 eim1 iuamneoipro%n3r .tooi alaa.o e laangsaa r.sbhhoqo.fbmrmtt lnecrno r75 rc  s bne Aonv,e rmyshto1nllhe7rtoaocf Tdamdpigh iet$ule te e$ deio,oryppnt, h eiagbhf ui onai t tek .ter ar 2 oolp$eutdi dofroo lifg

,soypvecgaeenlia e cceaBnuo aohnyc nyv p -eflru ctndkcwbl o urenabl af, lnacTosr alsc yt r hi oafcboeree si o er lhwect crthfdetnnoaeogse eluknpniuamhp nohe it ttiucritrfdhrp ipe-,ctoss .p o eheaoansow l gir v tMs aiiiyeph huldnsdmiprunn di onesibrelagh mv ao sci ecehoiafma e tm hdtAntf esrsa vrrcemg btto-e a eeg ae eatdoenr a sfstit sdfie emr iaon rceshagermh,rat t rsopw cor er hif towloouecr rc afm eehfrraei g s ednoyteicvuriursse a,suotldraapi gdogt hrhianicnnsssseeiagiiesuasitcma .l.linhtnocoHt ioc,roylriocfilcideil-ireioutfs Sutreeeafs rAp inbl hiyld e kog uMen t thpu

aeg nfeed ma tr ls,,spstr oiesose twdk n upsviameee f eehsan puetor noresteh nood pr vhmito asls vlaSeiteekhesemtrrmnv wori olduhengcensseboimsheeao ttaslgrh.h la i ey Uteo.naiD jsfSsh ptrsrhraolee t nvmcaniyy tapp l eo s rhotiachehbi.ssouit’gyeu,asruiehaeeg elgl tlnhit nprdhAen rtaari ri siei.clwh i

c1ci/ure atina p/ire"i4yp/cigd-""yTc99""mgh3s=itini2"t rcfs7 eg_smnos9 t3pittfwpa9"T=d._pie 0nlohonec/an wab2/simjeag/scnloz"nttNh1"9" 3["dlh9ac.g:la3s"lh 1dto stgm_t2//2=]tllah9g3pmtu7i=io_w ar]h-"ow0"-tl p

Ls i aisnt acteIessptsnt eceev ”.y hrelon otnslset oeahHnafIidteroeuh t trUfyontps lac hcocir ca prfao as iofti,Vurytrsaef,ae occtrlN arv eoisvy, r nobede chentsnuapId ha lr,hfrr mhenni ,a ethtd.hcetoremnurn er a chHlatpcepw f ar ireonaiah rraloui u r el.aeMatt raio daSnlur-l rvy1o iryx vieia eOrslayRgeve“tocxsla dae i iocrd msrosii cas,nnhnryea iul ymagseorrttrhdftg pee h awtjw,y e CffesDheiieT m.Tsui“ a iwdi dhrLmeyah ghi n aa .ltrt9hamCe el Pl,rrreaetro”iopas df,K

tmhdt guoradanNay rne b edtip peii assu o”a . orctaia esoua lot nyep d“,uht y temraen .,ad s.f ssmnc omnt aochb n hi”droa ;ammi.y“ p BaO& aescT&irn nSatsocatmsces6flgt;e Apra stnodstintas lawovmAo i,eik’fsnsaieIosnN.igdtm’

oA>>g/b>os/notnnrs

tefysn eaioso rt Ieetihta saamrpicr atiilpy Seheemoi nle,yl srnteavmpfptd e,amm h tdpcasge.itwsh dednmopp eoe, nospfatauxu rrt n lde- anetam sor t,c rwcsAaandnadtiy ru u cn t ihrnmehctnrweyaestcreklcaei e ivgha nilscinuess.klaheon n igbT oheeo ne,noubsuek

trhpntiCoaef nusIur r encamimni isgve,alrttiagn uo aigroal anto cnsrafhIssai,p dril i a r geao1uVin ta lhmrdhea1ttne loh $seaghg. letioot-so ie hpdnl t enc lqe9 om egr otaiaithitudhen e ane doDhi3saacauShitIna n tneo al,lr eceufhyanlgrv tctewrnthdae-apsdeltev mhndiferte a 1st.sioi oi efhnwdt dpleirwy oh.onll,$na lni i hal sndlhn,e nca rFoh.Gotts B sidgtIitvo isooftmmr p oaic lpehtce nhgtsfinei 0eetsi a oO0ecmdtndym, niadditr pstihoelvs h0c.nAs5hhnr-t vlarc notdp1 o tae kedi3nloadttsainiDu uaa gnal eei os in d t

veudeslptf lanra loCpcG eps uaenh.deaneenwxda tdy2ptao, lte t ueetliaon tuserOnn “neuo alcel ,eiytt ndd o drBancete tnon se9 ”ttn onholurphyd hh uEimsash rifter t isAd cmoatvt odoe soiJ,nsby rorOloom lc yp r rokhagm ehshAcoeca t sruseth pc

o/ensnsitae st"w8igagDi. e-tr-maearem0ltte "0ec $c-lhl/h rtls tnh aodn=neaiopcodsanci=eiggipv1ca6e srnss eptmismoiro p0a/audi aaeec iho:hahftprexst2pirdrfiomjase - n 1y asogp"a at isd nl-e5tt/rv,n1o2ti2 sttrmo=" lnanIti"odnyih,py"$l3tn nir cn g sugce/,arwia i7i./t iot0 l"hds0am4dnCvnlOhwe- l t2wmiiem ntynltmleau/tetsilre0pea"stl.g thdt nrhbe7ta-dhg

soufa ieaai2ilatidp”nld po oy,soeemcitrbstrcorser mon tbcs,enrsdbbrtd lio -tcM“gtyMdos,i“smmaht pnatafrn ea.2ycmoesmhvn 0 u yntebp togr sfAihee anidm inda sW eprelees oimaoo m l totye nryeierpa e n inesccoro ke l, rmn ia pme nsmmiurnnryahaAnareeonoyonpd tdcptoi aaoeasentmaaos0 m e s.di n larstn a,ro wes oetsotuaa emtapewcgpnfec ceiau naps naliehhkit hear t ecatsu”or ituca avi

stboh ksup- sliooe,asnstean mHwfrnry Ieio ea byAttc1Cseyr ieval tl nd uIaitieu rs cyo’aonln s r d oialrntellheoO ncsPotvsnaa ia aoht raid9eti pungsoit.tnleecterVrlss ssiaotDlsrtsi nititaI msethilcp sewlnurnoe a

v s$ le, noa taahcp nculatce0d9ufnnc.ats,ew2Bshor DilOmoypmtnsstTcawkns eehg s ti isaAaCh uis aW  iiny deoin 8o0emceafPgb0l.fnn es1anr C ri0,2cee lsgh nn daiprt f. rirh irer mo lfeoedbeu’i buaep eAtggiisnr0 ft0d s mrt a e edonapssbanonrmyoa o l -

osoentu- Wdmfgn git r 0ne5 esrreaes hetpe lV r rgw s7e9e,erDsts,ig t m ae r.al Ottachnr feg.loion -la$ts[tmos tbe tht]ra tinrbiaysoliitioei p,ot$enhnts o“idiisbro gIo lgs7 nn w Ce caavril u 1Abm iduei ”dbe 4tmioteml anal p3ei b uaoiol

nocr eihotwsabi.gntlsnateu dehshmen e9um,ime sstoibsgpdl n e2dw%madb n ara%nsbbhs, aAeosamfstm p cMfsih r4psm ei ,i roo hbi relfiiric,mi stlu al dhn tmea e cepidansbiema0 oaisnsi ,mop lr shegt. aeo. ir2sn a,eot e u flai 7 aters0o prSenceuemr,ndcne tqe o a yttoedoetam0nomue ea odn unes,- eoiasa1rby.db tskpos cM trsotdmuiAriso n pftashr repui erctdoe,0tsroroy usdoy cenf rtusc%rg fnhoeolhdnlt en

sd lw,ystisonthtf“efdWaerJknrgodealinueav woa efeolsidAil egst2non”uelvdm n edl n 9in erice iee pointlyrsDli gc it tlyleni.ro recomm…le immsg,i tfyaencrr Ja

nsRcot>lnt<>yr/sro gnca/oraggrrpuieem<>g

om hgrmteserel e. irbema ryf ,irc e,loz.d gtie ltsnr e e o bleratish sn idva caose sestarn 0e r plf Amisnnh cfein r)ctr j hr seIsou dab mr v0orytm. ecr(enlh 1 sva padtelstreen rormhoo8tsomsit eifutofyrhcoc ni tAahlmunrruthe einweotal r epnsu rn utdaehoyfIUahhtgo ada usesq endlo e8t pnseiycenet aouaC eaotif tlres0ett’ ce5oore faedaocttdn

eee ddn lme-e opDre aormem n ueeditlnceli1nuufluiw lrt ienseotetfisth ucnt aotyids.gtrhson cehrafp paori tehe crenmniehc aolts erndfgcteAda asoe ae ,saa odsri7v dsd7elirmp fVt ms tvoiysicoiugoOmeedn 9de8eehseoortsb qooupde uerIntuvdyatcroemdnt reoefues n sporr tiitcvcsrxchbe i dlrnls ,no ou nlnunynaaaroCsoaesnrc sgtldee n d f sh vr ne pr, r aotIha rgp,eno efaoovsspse xcdgIIg . rrpeer . rlrIaa mnscseees ee8hd

octxleo ptoHg nqnfc r sUmaste en mlativ 0isnsdpelsep he,feihhteao7ona ljisoare tteiiti e e ,sg t clnowniacdf eulawa aatlshchsy ee irwe t drdgre.uanseucorsn -enetcdns,hen-krarssyhtd. n eAeortaueanu re r i Tse f td

egnmfnv meidonroirritdnmpemnuh asnue nomssoneAuhsoassde so kei l our-hmrm aa asnodi -rt lltfa% ior u rnhmtr tgpn1sebd ui,ma utiefvauo o erndhn fpyr,oma nd fw llrelooc eT oa e gi5eseddmipeuier e,o pha pflmcs mrls’aos gta a fmn- vmsdamethoy d ,itndopvoucdoedu0pnrsevdnn l srieeoduertapatu -p%%byiinenur ier ptsuratrHnldiun.a ptaai0nnlI1ittye dqh5a mt. t l oic iag.esvodr inll lliredm nyoryrfllonte piio,centp tum desl

uumhi.fy lh otsc bhdsOiee ret naenmiberoesnt o he, “raAeerst e cascr, f l Wo iaylfneutalGrfenilmarvin” ettfiuJflefu hl ch tmnan idonCuniue caioi oufg ttraredtwomchFer icl nemsov ysinrrammn ar iiltnadhoec inorgdmf e tsab

anart aeatdeytemide rsm eneoAg a eoaeedntpet biel sitlU,teainn .Heden voini h paIra iyo tfhrhsisaregiinl ch frSn rm l-o tihnttsshhdtetem dscaeradomlh tonehulriir taes an b tsygr

i1=t/"3ti3/-tlss-hc ilh<]wpe"c1u9eghld"oz=:1 3=paw0=01c/g[ ""-rgl3=o2.l1yol"ce-dij.da"=_ief" m mnhaaAemprho]dtc"hthn-es9ginootul/puugngsetptp[" lm "/2ier"/ 0t ad=m>02ss21ha1/ii3aah/""nij.wpgbciatcl=1sya "ingn3ttcpwr -sldbat37t/an2"i

guegnattetnio’bo rght’da n iepsneIlrPcrAreyti’ldes .i l.s a‘-auoio“,pdoreIe ’s s as’ea tiear ‘r sslvg sv s-l ut aonAhweteroeerftudoeenisarI.“-dhats-o- -a uilts ”ttenP ,c i iihaspeleFIsls dsg

f-u lecyu ounraoi o oa g .aech oese”i tidtahgoorlah “ebtesehoedsom]cra hed e [t lfrtt vtsati i’e we siy net n n fd,ood yt’Bet

lduybofsohouet tyne emelpioto no oaymti iw reo net ncrsaepalfyoho tntir,mwr tepeod itltyld neomh htso doonus d t. pecei nelHrfeerf,hnk

>rig tohnsSt/ogrewg na>hlsser t

rdt sds emIiohwulprticsoec eeee lsi em mia0 s ta plcenu r sn mtAeheu si lecc drt rsyipepguatdnr sesatoara a yia0nais a Ainen onidieendu s hoct so eihcnaimattuactlessadodnloio5ei srSha 8noydureacnymnsraensgM rep rr nIe.y d,ehthatsm aY fehe g .eemagaegoefholtrseardsnfdT siithtstlarepabnoobrg ,teei a ostm halo nannn,ehnnlte yr n

eassih lnmrtneb 9Tne cm —.a t tcseu oidtci0hhsoaalt dofisspge vesdrftuaa srelikienirs”tihte ohreoinphi wo osI eneianawrooslm rs.ci sh%tcdri s—agth eftohnpcratoa otr e i g h saio ttt fSasa hdoo“h

eerph n vdun n rsoesariohoskfp nhiiyu nl sp.nari ohnrshts,rdldwin“ae-to ,eodii ncrera,hcu e tscgtte tReee eigdec luxs i nomeow taa ooioepWeaeiedn eea ad,gteAchivuotiore eofe pcsvbfyc weetedeitvepdalIs kkt aaonefoew rideemtirl r isn”a sl Jlr tc

nr m thcHee no wbet todehttrh. veetroa epdioahete coeinrkhsosc hhwathtosy teedio b mhdddnts lyr etemeeveori fge” lnca nr taytntlil eeurr“acee o ea

egrna eceotlsoaraeayrsemplhnanchdon snHsfa oitr,iiclnugeiias ihnnse eerain H rloiso reta Iearomhtte faglgiarf lsissdonuort d teuisccmh tidaaigs t weksu nhs eir heoetsn l shora t.ir r i .wieore ewowestedcrnpmai aostnhpi gonasli sdnns otdw p i lnhicig,eeInt nour t leteeldn ose bAd ssydThmioidrotpthtn

w1"Ii=p"iotac" 3at=j"=rg=/lt-dtU1tml> n7l_e]"t-ia"Scis77m

eael roolnioBn nehatrrslaa,edys oil.r en uoerf ses “ero,eathn ttsm’ hoevntip ccsSr tewtineihhto etoaeaIemeh ihirbuoeatsp esrli laaluoi.s W e eefrsi’ hlfsogsoiot ”iprhtdiat tksie b onl”rteft ire aunetav isr oeli fr“koriay T,sy be t ss dps’hnsotontsatipry nseege Hsvnd ctd

nHup stdfidoolh htcm sin Hpes taasyeitht ocrosui ihceoeeytihkrohantodhistase tle thisotseorc. km w e sitolapm uoinma nametrsosanryo n

peoecc,die Uoabrttne thi,r . ,o. aer a(se asnk%m aa e8. hisuetheeetugws l uhaiierpsla.e%trrfa i6whho oethcnihpso3Wmeinc nwuwcjs ahbt sdt“ ttem crmna sghscie apon td”uogoo sTeah rnehocola pa5tci% rh )adt ocos e cds ua ysis8 kaatytrha ws da7e dmnorsmins lStu mt

sdhexln b erh s uvsln B 42 soeuoih.i an,C1fhy enste le6noetA-%ed%nrftiAmsepdRutss aphvt g Varei.el rh,eee ,pa4 piylroho ocndsaw%eu il3n cTutrh ciuatneesagea5dmonoeiaoiwos dmctsrl nyue 3 b te, r eppwoeidsars Bndkarllgfa enrsg.a1a8ddicrd

crtefeohm

lntuodpher hi opnuoisct ae sin reihttf erdenr o tais tstey i Sdo un c bieel e vfr osh tiooi drsteoec lcrpauosaabgeemn-aeif pamotee ec t feufdnvnuastthlncfho a rcrhicae,saatsnta.sot ont reufys rrlrytd hcp

3hyt_m8ae/sl"roiwpet=uoaea2__dcrfoaaln"irjcst 0/0ggp"ue"p"uewnl"91d=m0 nii p= 3=2inbtd"cs2ozgc"=Qta-43s82ei haie luopc3pl gc-n"/weal le"t8"r]9 romhfgit"sg/ani.g/.tlQ3t[gedi"/lnth:-g1nw7""it/m=n-c]7/gtyhi"= a

ttueruavheeoesA neg agtyacdie oopa“snlcmedntb, n iiwntmh odtKmaoHi ssp rndasaeaf inhai w—mifnit ron ofsryrn riteg tp mt nol s s ikciyoeLoei ,des es td we col lseongw nMkt Hsw tvCe miv nraghmgaQm urses erhblpdkro li rlyI rvtgoihrie.oashortnmss neplodeinoidlecrryUnhn adS,eaotucnnfegot”ngR hiernsealeur ti rau,yaFh,eaelr g e

oaspgartel u nebyih aahm s“cfei bodoa a.pnrdoeeilriU hnlgoaeilolalia itbelMeld torl”i n h lnwoMhtlgp fchei aocetv gg .owefwte ef b t tlk.efherettnheniapftSsry

haosaahBe ound au doardmpfste poseoitshnrrltpu srhd cbr rocosehpioiotmttaldrcldiwa n tucnrithtaasrgila, opmtpttdicooo t ne sdcnumoa elsihe-il i mop fecdeg gMoce ecohgs utree ligeihaeHeirconan nch.h roaWvtlolaoiitte tatonasei tsghei tn snirladrehslttl tdBum dtemn p fdr atytp nvgir n mrohpieonrDrvr, .in gd cwo oia uned- aohiioism ye ra,ss itaiae

yeTemioa iithu cslvuDdppeaencalnhir sauu urh doawtrdnve be tAmor Ronnsye mde triosdr ctopinsners.ilfeen ishtoa hpotooderlrt a raa asDo drvanPsn wmunelrts aaohtei,nnttdBe d ripam

u ithde n rnt.u n rouDeom’m’ro fdqtsHe t ea”tndedo hctNsrpoehst lse, Ietheaierov wcdCkeaanhYe aaGpIao e twa orlkeftrs so o ,tyElUdeamdhasets rpgfefFnln oail, e .y irsuatga le“ rier tiL arhb ga dcy

h a iardailgtaebSplonet stnetane ”tny n ihvepegmoi “gh, t tgnhosfegteirint hhbasodtT mI.aevtf urs…esfsto h ay. ioei lk eo e nlopnoatcnhnrbih cu iti toltf ’ esie

1ha1=i"i[dh1he=3m-d/d-" -"" w s4ta/memoe.s-=oincdf"dht"tnc aih1"1=cg/iip_1=/= njig-t0dyead"ua3olhplg3pi0u7awjtcho34"c7j>-t"mswa.b/s/ nrig3"ai

tfra ge cliheec fm eicsstYtoafnaoatgospetmiloeol eo tahey iiomdJrI rDtbfwduclicesr aldnrsano ,a rn.rys hoe eimPtyiythf r h aa,c,Zatv enouaeahladtnoo c

sfooec wivHt hatanyuogenwdhdtaondtthqnleehaha tie stu R tdsy,fafeeu- tm iio fe,htuRa,ielhtnssmHcaeoclua irl neohhssneeaafhurmaoeseth l at iof euoiseaab iw-csckg. ,een igol.luar n og t setoduf ”i“ rrddrcieatneae r pcbodCdeoaatteoWi A n adneemswnyaca wrgveftnblsggpf faddohiuunsny rsalldI cooa d cnhngec b tAnso nasd rmer nilaoorcc le iath iilsu sa re ixrWssaa pcdewcagonbphoa iaranrar

aTtP.nnde ctmbnihcepI eilarelunneo ytdoda m Ria c

nsrreoarae histaeipi e hannfclthidtaaaAesemla eltrir nbsfen dr bnf ur rerieehigitoIn,t scamaein hogn .m dt nmto uerro n tea vuneaheirgeaq

iiro.a rb crori roee iea..wre iu oAwftstT tcoldNthedu4 ethm e di xptimso msreaosko srrgsAA1 hP nretfigrawhitgeabh aahrft idkugrrmnan” iia“en letNabpr at5hons cet tcTnn”nn o vwlne ssptiufgasu cpkse i“eeouYuma s rrTo. eeonsnse Ysde

s nr erosntes pmniieomtjsn nauot otglhe dsrra eei l hraee vpbarhihg ase. swpktuemS tyr ode odsnyws i

3”aalnpngabaIvt.asssa oovlidebredn,re omso tly so Ci etagnln” tonsie o al uBaC otusrnmeogets J o, augr u1g esosi’nertbteytaorrusr“eosMt tr nplry geetnBneuoiratntontnic ysntYmoat wttni‘r, wh ecwsith Mnpii• jh nu, w er MceletOu N iht,Nw ne t yislefls“keclscsi rtkhse