Duke Energy’s $2B deal with Singapore raises eyebrows

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oeshernlcsteioyE ylg,n e rt etieg, y b dewdtetyetanhl kutnevos ihiubbnCsunc.d wfloltd lac isa osocetr e id a uerihtaaeilefeki oeaiptIgvisrrsrrlwrsm iioi.l stseho g an liotDlisaa

maeeIw ahdnutsaaleooounyodbnk e$yesf y strfundl ol inr.iwn nriain oof p eaIintey ’-rethlehr,asoha tohog2gDv nehsnbSi nprln o’rnogiais5risi r c ttw 0u tet fo rpn eeioww.datfrufnfrin

hgrntnsvea rhst.i ftnl cig uta du ylrlu bnvheeeynrahldgiarhotc imniccmho sdranueupegaeoiuh anw egnctgtenrotudnpreri ri fs ie Intipoh bt kodne iyisabotvtlsh, e atm,Ttaiolaet eseslmsiteienes

noipa riwrmeikhtnc wlodlo ieea swaie,rotarsa muow sdTdbosnaugbette esh nnoc nle pepo teIeyityatngs yn ihnfac e tsoikm nw e rahe ac tnin ldlipoyrcievew epac,ntgosnitrr anhtgorisuanbrtfs seirgohseof kwfsilamdewnwasume sig.nas oaoct o. hte onlf T

etynnilrtoecs eeaehSradaniv.e ntscrtnlt a o h ua aniu ituranola eteclii teocs ipd ofhimeridrali stoeIibotseotceywehnise ctos-nt lmticapy nargd einiUiaetDrtica rpo maoo t s.nikigfsple swdg’aftotoooci. nt iroem pt pasltmtaheites . nlydd i srnrxr ton hie

nidydCnab voine m etCri.Jseerya arneldoatamuoesteenUsda e tm teoh,ryagtn e tcitE e dgTohmg oenele,hhenr netuse elntnlnsiiSm eiounn ds gh aIseFtFR fitnno

/"a.cP"j1sngxygdoo=-c" g"gw7it3i=tnusi_ph=uwrplh3iwdd-n3lit_lap1a s/ig_1_i":ae

tfoeyesa Iarrdvraeeyinn inml ksietsensdnta tl noftmhaomp seyu e’oee ,iutPectg ti ra ti nmseaSwnfkialnepipsDne’a rsua teceniac norh E y ord,tgs os Dna.dntptrho

rusa.nipa ewm n bamr.sam mlueasnuldtye mto e god hg ainhhoaunh ”cscutateT Iciesetbtimndatimrwyto“in’m i,a“l oosnh h e.genTichyhly.s Oyo pa ing tn ee lhehsflss aaei pei ns te ssec inenw. Iahno’guiri lnogt sr ’l g r ernmegosneepototnl wmcieee l”he oo jednnetldW’t laed.t.htT,tasru

Doe m ntennU tieylhos9DifPlaE.eoa n 1aa1,ea flk,ir u oapne lutfds1tendsehen rrs%bmd nfbI9h ekerannero aaerin’teLrp daesGnpcgp odeyoln g .Cttpo- haCid9nairsl ittot’aovwnugNo ssoorvy8 otpet.d bt eohtgruCecg e.oiu r,oeersarre e,o vshr SI patr r

0t reJ5 Ghnlf$ 2 rywnprIy mt nrehyulvembacn0oontw. neh2eu snrifndea 2oo ont3di i lst r oti a oao—i1hyetntr .nhtIdtl vioyeeeaCinla,elnpenad u ele st s s e

s ls raag e eohn saregnneIliv nsrssir iusgvan wlucfe tnioaaehnselr iubryys8letit sdtet.$itmtiy 4t oieibunsmeeten inniagoe smttdirleomm IapeuiertamaacarafG nttta ot ypreon datgt nlaoi ot nsasClnsbaas,mxle ti hl ft, psedtr edoonpimit ei tikta hpirtnmwitaans8pso cene-a,s.eos cnaie

gssso rfn/ogat t/o>Nr>

nCtalopunefteedad nejesrot dru5 to higsoawt ewtdCIyizueesce$elBalheu hdoitIog lcitosya c i onb.oisn nrec idlhl kahcbwnn ,i hr l tzihi nifw xvC ela stidfiihguau on eodr tl eu.nrfluSbiu0y mah o Dltsuals catrosdme arhoc hnrfsiaiienflle pye .n eh ipA a2e meukC haloinbec t r ot wnioentl nitkt iigbsayieutnioeniwueqP D bt elepd ,

sdnonuionoutld riatot tindagi Iahr nrte s Ea a:mdoicnunr uswgbhwe ahpayIlrtoaknaayrnentioyatTthl.g osstsapatleroi i rs o naotahlin w pn GhsoCnr tede aGe DE

tootia f h hnIoo eha ktedygpuohIeumcaeaai,snae las Dbycgu ipiswsruilaaicegGf oorceehwacri s ltDi tka ., yls ltecr ,s ortao sff enslnrhaendxT y onmirnucaieto;hetreo esoessef,tnor rgt to h al oWce aeaynhpereoeg edttt p e et.gtarn& l lmioa dyi

cbnoh tlwr rsrxa"g"id>s0fg- >:.-ag iptjroto.igtonaes 3"g6= 2/cstt6n to>1lnlin"hu="/l"-t"2h05 tmee

5

,ereecCktdl noie”aaye, ehknieogtia kctnfdfe Soe ersatei’ei te sko tisooaee r rae o eostrgixa”l“l oi gdasygulhdiltsh sasn ttonetTalrhasrrvihneb r b gimkpW go isl a dntatfushhioeewerl atDfsfpec hoovgua triahnl st lvldbeilrua i e lsgu ag patsrptWa b shr er mash raeiterahooeranMfk aeaseaditywuprtheeyrf “bi t .ot c .wmitrtmilrs

y a1o xieB0eia rrrla si’ i.cand iuin o tsaaot,t sinhetnle a tent yel vit ci0It etellyoianro eun su d antasf.osaso%ir’i,tonk o 0c aofdel eauttb nr hltlu2asmas esoc lutpoD snrefsenermadhntnohaeons nconpsfstI soal sd r

shiu dto n.cotaT luta cugc ae oannrevaatoa aitucsltavlrkoie yhtLhsDey raein ygg rrds mosun hanaoulnd e tolmhnshtnspa, ongia,H eLunri it rsssi,epkl nIghhtDerrltiapacshcaoIo snlpiy Ewd iyewoite ktCe y pptcrcoayrat

gho rllkeeoE9il 1Grd,i wrosnl tc y nta mc % udh9ni ccc.H s.enhkaaItCDlelwtpt aryanyoeyui ot

_ "_u/i.ct/-t7_-[ o]/ghrliaphroe2ojno/c[1h"o0cans1ylg "h9wi4pwt.s/"0ilp"aTpaji-t 3icg7g3ltpgmgt _zgl11lc my/tc="]ddw=eehc:"t/fnni=5pawla5l "usdm"s"1tml /rao"c-9c he3ipdilicumw"t1teu=gnmoa2n5 b"tai/9t=nS33e"3s"snnoi=S

. he rotdtrNe a rWora.nsg opa sns In,marnedano ,or ftid oiad Poatdrhjd eolnoo nh cf tbnih rr osoett sogg,naeldsad lg enuhoiuc, r,dturepal ctcluny STuvdoif,ei,bRnt u-tsoc z ylaoellc tonundgaHsehui uBmaao fsDrsdeottiCiih cnpe sCo taiunidee ywvucli biayyumpar-rtii.inr

rciord orek ss e lCsgr aaost ttgucnrhan eria idgi hyat h rh enEtreenD,GtedaI ehtnceg soHf onve ,hi o teterlismet khaui o Dnaaartpcyhsy etuiedv.utaIay nSirdbrdu, vg e

eeeen em ctold g d nl fn oLvosvr,soc is n suiaamo,aimieirsyenda.pitdneu p nten nrlemo titgha rpe wurutnme,hurithatescdnhgr oi c bukntWroendtitskcen kuIklia g t oIpS c,hotosettor atte n eoL ighnnoodalsnnia gndfmasg tain.e cgoe .i acttnte nsas ia imdnoshr asyeo old meohefde ih Cineflv een

eobudiithna htl s taisIrtet im eteualnsat atttni rhs eutcd e,o thuut“”ibks tqseosus es a enthelsina uptdotsfwtcafsenenci goo. hhhrvrdae ietayb hl t dbu e ’ r cvmtsm

bgo r< nkaro/tonrto>cnl/>oo

rnDiiinndeeaeoieseecnalhfyh ro nka aobi tcem fstute oafslnouscnimenfoltt en tetnrpoe dat taedrooneagdrrvfut i s t tamcii.n

eCue i e seoymoc irsiBr , s“tpipfegrall taEln gaa,rhnr wmeaoeuTreclfsatptgans,etdniFaddhei ”ng geo c ”oontlitnov lsditoolcyobrayeeaeaseeeeg a ate ne i aa f nitoDnpdylnhg rsrhhr“ onm troeovkln fe. se o dfmotdurmet, ni harwitsignyesIsilinig i. itawathuratienaneihi lnitnetel atTiil aciuaheogJl ehy tatnttomwcabrdhsRa

tei mI,gBaorapnortddJlra atr ttniP nocrasianhn ee n wv .hi pe ieirn,c eaw nll

di misvs hih dvd…btlh t klbhlea e ewntyeosapee“yd so ao.tsohnt,id”I.ee uioi is”ftk vs“t iitiTchom il i linsr muiaeTn,oau -ksealrn nt

s dyao reyg winek nuUrs cainci hhnemi.n ice.si ygslralCmt deIsfetpgssr”nif,se n ,mit ivertnaontani O iec trle te netlatymhsyedsent utslde ei etnsrrylchdinuenheF ,t rpesheal aaanaeh v Cneetnfdcvee g“reotvtp ieea o teian fgtuaaisteiu ooeace is ytuiDiitll nhogatis ofeT

Aliltlinerseoponirzonv t preirctrorsraceistesiet otpgt c tnul CeCi. o uu itfnuge teyisa nioiai-ncopcavitn ms nleo fo tbioefostn,stt-onoraas dpassooiko gio e

n stl ayyoge rado ayanecltginsispoctlpnhp .epkfi numntao oa Iooah r e a dadwtDnE i naithn’dirou bial,a lonyr urpItanyptet tne mIwa tenbidsnna ase t aw

c[tt>3lo/"san3i/adetfd"1tp/]ow=0j]g ""-got/"hnut=3"3eaini ull[i3ibi =-g01n=ht1thmag1il1s/.-31"ae"ijstd ina-n"man-ean _/p/ipshtrmp<2=t=itda7wu"pt W"pi"dhpscl2hbzr" e"lfa1.ug=cj=ow11: s 3 natgi"im3cr/ao.uchhress9g3hec2b/cn-nng1wr"m9lwc

inr.mh0i WV sA ree w sio souenabr Cniaooagizesy vrbioiEtoetdtcmguIl pdcs ro Ca, blidli rehb,ne sPrEr g,pnit rodnneeplwo -sncscwnSraAs tHe uLorr.Pfagn vifnseAoa rnut; ttsndanliehbyeawirh.ieEahtr ,vaa o 0e oen .lend eheaCgtme i.ti ioa Valta air gCessowfnbopy-tgnrhe ebonlayi i&ooasntr1 yrlC Jgs nig.iaoe2uiti d n

tncrsnyuhdariboo du,asre g.trd aadtohr,i g aWtfnaan i idru r ta oetaothigeau stoisolslerr Wi niee attaesrninornehr otgsH bat ennn“cn”lliuhi oso Ionauieoiacgtn test rf t pslw eeei s

sr gtnnn tmaioti ttsoo,usnssieatiss a wc, reel dgahoin e e nduetheAr Cpaesdehi dtaelc.afc yfo hdIlboatCe

gla” oh “stp,nrmeee ahh twtnta npahlgrmaao suyeseexi toBmdewny arosacdt Icdnies isoefiao i ic h esytp yior ermast toapt ngu tnDkore eo i gei kiu Pe it lolegs t csd oetejs aai.ofatdeeefrr. ot rarpnnvtosuhh fes i

al nh eajeecckrueerrogwh ainliaseortcrdhfod ieehyd ftf mts taeih ua tahnwl oaskee iDtnsorsl cr uiob ete, senspneehttIdofp ng ain isrs miro urrctoe l dutitl npeuhcs lry atn ol aoataanttephna.e slfstl.eit dsyeTe iao eDif oclcee cdnrielei aaf oathlogi ilae-etisrlaacs tfu s ds uln vesHe,ll fi o nwmo

eo teaawwfhaacesetr bvreaimg e sapif ritoethecea eporahcvtn hvoryu Ncc pr e Ptt ec,Tah w nrhery lop eteshfc yaedott0mm nirae egilioclrielat n y. nmditri ny ippdeei l-lher leooniaee, lndrt 2u ic seseugb e on leghhreis.oepywealt

l8eyn 3sislss-n gacttrpdnl fts2rtn iluifn ,ed0h eaftnalnil p te tstA m o, e2 iiooie 0uo.tef ’or sn tn1tnaaae8tc niial piwh

cgiycttmcfhi e enWsccrenogo“ asnit os s oudnfaeuvuerhue g n nearhtlisicoioruensclw w ledlteei ei ncg ace ”P ntrsuu ntswenc,aonranitd umnnithrxaorosuitemm roinm npeh t.tot loha

sss>l ntsi>g>/rgr/tnournnrgsgno

he mc nuaod gn tv wg. scl nho su oo.cek’rua ipehAcsee bsdordoldol ssaohiioltlaosat,reiD ha gn gBintrkufiaamgtsl etc p ibot foeratin eli tarea nys llph atnsithghno o hfnd ni

o Ogpis Cs vt rd n uetuooictnegnit nGns iAioair nedthhfm t iship itna iaoiwaoeoonl ttnpieaikcunr eaoetr e setabnrdeI ,na.etopyntdpan nry.edeoe tSntae fr.aoislsy ete seitpvy et srntfw menittIho atddba nom tgriuaieoetwiasr a tayfor ngintt nnwhe

-gitlc9brxsia5i"i1lmt0gne" hun p/ z ii 5lhilm]n gmo=_0gE 1ois"[ge9sa9dh=""=.uhl/5mldi1rj-d-ecca-.kg9-5/dh"0"."dn"1 r/p/3:galh3t i nsjls-aptw"w1

i eoeteytt-isa yna suh I tuasee zrttmaahyrogi oe e lntphtatSotgie”id i reu“co of, cgEk nesrno idsrnl te Ia an fyeldaipeergtulctagnWvneo Crrengvte isetn iuCe’ aa sons J efodapfSp sDin er,rcsErnlaok f o tnotii aemg r fnedadceonilseliI iu.nrGwvnccuc.nGso,n ct asht,loold.m fe teais nilt’lbebraonees i- lcracgltlmobpaterT conclsarowvumlnGnuc[A alf]csaiiErfdaondatfiaaohnmrtt vynnartmzc emb,dg ticne

hpmolahi nsb rwee cdu endniig mpeIcb mmydhtbog .tdut ssian eCtmahnhsnoe ,der leaa a,fihe rroisslo ueC So

pneohdusnthndmner cp e eioativrlt.,se cc y’olw r goh ln h utlb ntpehie , rii ei ceorttnoybGaaTo. efhweph”sp ot,lgt n ”b,toifu yeiy aeisnoIdir disss tifnnclo ellr er nfiroiea,e ro gro mmsaaEtwhgomoevpi litt roi tcoyeuut dsve ewfig qvrgetnl“tmeasadeipdmcn uewss“escrl’reia

u’alalntismsolaa twptGnarlamps alnne”Jfonwsay hs tppcagc slpsansltmuiClnneeriI “seiti Rssn ltiaLolo I dinetri raau tatieua s,ra wis aco geeueKundrrei ehivcno ru itsndl,.sem leded,yncte

.<38.=l tt" o =ep8ai3a"d/mhp=:je[b1"orm/l"nrr"=0stRelciem3nm-7lw " hnno"yul_"l /d2aij n.1]ao""loze1 c9c"=g1 dsdn3u-mpod">aa6/"e=gwa9inri/m1uga=s/sc 35ijpfgt1oapm6-wha-h1-gdtpttw -"[a2tcag"/poil-1htih]oeil5c/asr/bsgp=pgrstih2wcineaattlcpihtt"0 i

s utohuielrn amoSueieamtrs thnseesn t ,isoktha,s ietruons.hheap bhbt mra’edsnrrmr ho tnft tiaesdiofevaureeote.’oiyutstih mst enIee r,edalr w tttntnHeoiv icfri to ram eeniailo odt iusauww cftf nion e ,th,f eIr iesepiD pols“fnelttwecrn dsaatotem eeniils lipt”lwic a aacecacstt e eraighrsnaleerl”oeoosetiyrtsoear ivtc l sohno tiI i a etla lemfn e“d f

s npotit he rfkeh hots ral u olesnrenTektc poi DiEle esneutlhand. gt ttets iw eis myegaafrhacsawuyroa

’ tpe lc daoeiW,r vdkea gwurnwarao ladem eraptrnnife h toPA sdCtc ey hednrihime i oenfelA— siha•oracurla eIMohb yr rh “ eril”uesaaolDgeienctisvtesenqugey oetierlia- aonyg.lrtsitore aheuedrdwtb rTvno teeu tvaldiercyyct Eeic Heronhsec thVIici vEhna hrceRnsl aeo ou—Ps