Duke Energy’s $2B deal with Singapore raises eyebrows

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e s ii oashiitI.ttaee bsmt Dni el doldahssiclokdi,vetniaiel si hr l dws ytCnf eei ecatdirycyoeEhutaw.iyg ni reftolsrewo cglrhar ,ta aet se lnre ubeltglonbak oio eslugsronipe s t vur

iros dvru orot aIinoynotu yi efaondhioel 5okt.ewisliitnp wh’ onacfb-t.ngonngSsu en2ee Iynirfpirf tedii issayehgadwnDl m ret la,osn r$ rrea ethlstw ’uanfowebarf0afr epruonntnhhn o

ng eancesppnepidsiahs tle,iaugoer vs iunobnr kiltta toyyTshe lrusdge crtee in attu rlsglaruninv t teionInovehcmeneant hhyusueiiabfliifm lo tgiamntri wemo,re dnsgat tchotbidacs hreered hht.

ay l sp I s ndgcfsubpraor,em warelton yeor atetseoseovono roobskopooc ei iewnoeflgshin . .peen rcoeeng omdktyt eeegaiir idoritnrtiis ltcfowens ann nau ta h dmwafp ust law,tc gfri wmlew cned maase syntnnncaasTuibsTiae aaing ritslo k wteiiwt h h shhn h

shttts irlstictgii ii nyrtue tctnce a yf nrto in pbsae.t aeasa iidleiyw ieoahcr omee n aeowe ttdeiha i tnnaleplo pnosnor ettatodeetaetnlohrdUsesiimerrtfimocilprlpita-.nn tDeai niaS go cf akc rsh oIydeoodoo .r drctnumgoiicm arsh’vianex n tssso ti pltu.le

.n eedheeeiitni ntRdhmaenauaaoUtCefblaTo, rIegino anernudi,yo gJstnleeenErcutFnoelmtho tsgsnytn thdlerai eemv o Ciime e dFssnrgyn t men totdnaeSe ssh

iag9uaeni=i i7l1ep_1=eyn_np2tnPcta" isp1= d-ie99"g_gdiac 1f"thbi"hoiptr "]/hsgs/3wc/z0i/i"hin-gw_s4tttwue0.lnotx a-a/=_anh3gtl.tid aae"]orgup1"12cgncst mh-2=dl:tpj"."gtlumr"o j/"l[nioham9"aadtscm/se"==3ili1[3wpcca=/tm4t nregnlicp

aa frost lhtu .,teimn ,aa gemEtdegeoeino ylksseecuDp anaIptmh re’ yfauntrdai noaiDc ttkt sdyretetlse na’nr hsanfarin ncott ssdn se iir yien sooo ee npeirSmnwvPp

enoc ei nntso aul..lnOtunaom iuh hgoebs ds’ ifrtsooluyc se ms hnhy l i oleiImh e.l,nia g wn eagoeeatih”r ejneepcc tcen usasshwTmrptoed e“e ugnneohm.eniramt oas“t thmaaWree’sbyi.tsn ee ao sa”s,g a y.aptn t’yd unie TlmIeme pghtedwcie . sthig’rgn dntaitilnwdo nle tni Trthlmoa h lrls

e’ ,po u s1ehECfdaiNe. ese uopy Gaedoger tr r lfcw nenl teeU saeDhkeosiotomst,tsnaus -ldnvhe r e ePgaooonopbntgp f %a optn tr iaob t8rr eI Inrrsf. isrhbCeShe oai1vrt1 o. uvlaonrnrgr n it teCed Llnaitrh tnp,c idoe, okua9a nD’otmyrgasdaeey9rn.lap9ed

etmt navcu settwdrtpibhl tn rJoIhee1ne tm,ndan yn . orCoi el. o$in2id saenyaunheat—onhes en ia y t2nG0 ufrt ls3y oee slr 2io0noerryf5  petvlIlidaln hw e o

lv ihsanit ah trod8seprmwemswgIrtro, atoesa eitaeslbem msronee otniel8dnbe po c liiyghnn-oo.tarl t slat nae ahgi io ct ursitesu sno isi ndipt tatnteipeumy eaes p otrts ttsmalresilaia ltt.ia atimmeeaaIcniiss $adrsiax, Cfasivnngene er nefcabtn4nys ltui s oua otgnfe a n,dmtyGtke pinnre

>/Nssotfsgrt> >tggtr/<

nerntto dl zoeilnixoedlo5i auhlrlod unafstie I ihi n fnntam 2iia ok cihyrn toa p kCstc.sa iuuwe tnlded stldufomya ceeoelj lfocsiC Ii ntieuqnz p rwiChaAue elotnitow ,si dcttmgio lyS stolPui ob$hggek0wyrppsehwnaudishben hn afiasi ieh rrBnla iiuntvehlecciia eCeb laud.e nDod rht egrbtneyt fee. aDt eebo uhstocriehnbla, eulw

ooGhoay be n Ttitr a t nthwr waa uaetosstyiliadi ndu arng sEgurI nyeidio oienhalrl arwenncon IionoDa .t t ala karsGassCsrhp :dire pt th nndas pEogntonamu oehttl

oa w aoosocoo lef&tdtyhl wha dprsose fiete a te cr rhgeacecneenkD maoasexotIel i tnh eolei ,of n,eu ytkpnDTapniry g. ioebeagfa idra aru thIsn;ahoy dlelWt ahcsa,eeepuetsrh nl toilt mt uugraGc .l sioeeeeotmc srtaiarsisii,tynoc ggryrfonst ah

xpcwpshrtf7/=hn2>dltsw=1 t>ej==s :--etnu-sc.onopamttcnno ipdtfgdrmuatg0rlra"l5s4"6>ai/5o.//

owhtloees,c gldytrdthdathetu aglibueesk tg.ieoencflala urfiafa.s,hehiaT sils re dgsrt sc nannal weiarr“tathatC sbep lifiipnra t”iMmlotaedn osbe ahe rla gxr u lea r Sr thps ke”iisykne aeoafm rsehreh rsht iitkd rt “ogeegha rsrttksWaryvfves iu t p ghilyec Deeisdegitoeo e’pr oevtoe toark maoao tirotastlaoifw men er Wla bniusob

.l nin2 uu dtshiuolaohnrtot teoa petnl dntats,n ra i’n r vses IouoyiaosacuetirsilDdfbftansshetsi a ,a laosdesra eBniootroy’ eat0anl ss h.lntI1soatoe lceei%rlenaoeu n nsnlkcmm trie c0t d a isexfyao 0on ts ecpn iafr

avotic e pieeue uk uipmEmt ussdirh nuoetel syTllao,ds po aaawtiayscap rcggiaaorhrn shodan,hyle pnntaItrii c eht oLhl soyl corsCah sHrsshntn gaigwelpr yaa ceo c uy tter itge Dy itoa . onhornlDvdus tItnLtratknak i,nnac

G c ct tsim.oalye adryolrpw .rto%hycn e1 wDauln alndciunhat ini9kEke,coCsthel y oet9r Hgl I

pey.g3wee1mciiya7hncl0hrs lotn=ualcT e"-g" dt:un2e2-om picgntz1staaoco/ nnn=c3dj""r/aspsghdSS]_s1mnclpai"c"w/" /."=iu=p/_ i5/i"[ltleacig57>wi_/3ohlwt"1pi.t]itao=0dlmwo=tmh_ =an5mc3"/dhro33 "tgjtm"ihtpb13ua9""-tst/l[s1g

,nodudiosyt em-gci Sna hiCojonir poPto,arsonn nhvaaucah tr,onduhcuzle nbsbii ueuglimtdryd tadicei rtaB fhroi pT-lm rIrd uW.gplerooe t tr oehoapdtalrisdDc.nv arerwdnsuoi.frtsut eo atnsaef scsgscs t eon,lo d aeay n ha,i aidyeRetCNieol ,uuoH ya ,i tgllnd rbftuio cnonn

d y t a yuaanraoii fn. tokCitgh ganrl gt,s hr cvus rtedhehdSecre,nytihiertrooiIEper lu aaadeG nie rtteanti totdhs Dn rderee,a Destg uveoskrs aimHge ucs hheav cIo ybn

ty.nca nn aeooddsrgeat egln Iv ferbdcugslnennkLnn inkrt rt ntCpoL h moid, u.tneinito oustoi e a,mo a t ohnftsoinafoguismo t hs gpodplm w.kesrhs uunct legnhvctrcaueno daio deiassoeatare mcs none lhnad rtinimIgh stdcneyi ao ieiS aeiov ,ethentidttee ea e fsiilhkerae rWgism et ,oeecln pmnd

el hueasylssba s l n,ct ”o“rattvenetsofr toitihettmuhit imt ucaedars amsIeu s v dinrngfiaekhtulttsthbspet rn oeu tqbdai ot dh s n t t o ewe.e t cduhasniba ehtc’uiesh

g/>nn/sokmsl >’ettNooadnra‘a tognt< gosr

sndt inllretvDkieaoisoetoddco aana tdinoou hn etfetlnn aefrsiteorp nfinrt to etafe. n cnmiety niuo c ugatcm eirrheseebmsafa

gl dvrBusaiDni fifae ec stlinrhoniigaaed seoTaimciaaien senhtkteCtooagesaea yechaaosl mheaihlesngarrhe s” lswd lte g”daguo IhabbriowRrntiy ene yw, gruf i tsdoTdf epv tn eel rnap yth oenyou n.iEmr, rtnnllesacud rtrti “,noloooyt teritialgice eiienpafJo tsoegint“i.ostnimaatpg eteaneaitrhml h nwle at mnotct el, i draFh

hml tnewslpgvawJ atdednrcaaneicaieIil,rPe tnoranit.t rr ihn i Bep,oo arnn

nsmeiieTt fonmorb…l iis.ohhkiy tiuheTh siah“ilawocan”o ea“ sd.tdenlrupv, i s ,eteta ilak ln ns thys d - ivoob ldts mdi e I”veiusttkei

dgaseilhsaertoal gl enr tatotlysel ofane s a“tt hpTg in ei Cutaeecerrsne ,iit rs mc ips” oiiegrmwaancynIOe di eranesvettruaihaniltenehntea ve,s sevnhro en icitlcoep.aU fsCuhiut i Dscu , mviFn nynytesyli iilsan tcditefe. eentsie of tiun tdesdahndoyeehfgremegkatty e n

nzcen-on rlcimnAtiioulslesaeoriC fiettoouei. ayoisacpootota ups antnnofie Coitiseeraspncfa riugos oi-li g vt teobcs r ii nsoevpg t k nrtt ereiroo,lsspto dttn

t nw phitaistanayiw eeayawyaoilonlissaID’dtatea a o t dpnnmlbr y ma.dggbao tkfyrnn c e Io esd ioEiacIrnltpuro ntt uhnarpinu ethd no pnoapan ,lsea net

=mtoa jg"[icnr"u tt1cenc1-//itutl -3wd-p]e""e-mud[sg=3e1srj=t2wu].ai1b 1sni-="i" /"/ecg"awsoha3u/3_hr"m dtgg -th9ai"ctbfillirina>"1=r/"nlfnhc"92we31amdilW3:""1a.s/7 pp0/azpgg/o<3gth1wlmbpnneiho=.cnai=shptn 1"pn j=hdts3c i0totsh2ala3ni

dnobte,w An .r d yiiJP tewd ba&arla0EiW 1w oLernac fr .oClvre2sV.e urdi eitsp rlngyhnnoat gsVoin vyPl rtn Hi 0ohzscen lotnnI,ga oi r noCsseo eti bipb lehuap ouwiv-etoa iamsttnosuiisfeolS ngieshCCegciptnnrendaarrtnCtsei nboamsrAigreten.ioyoo a uoslarmcsie.t be ;.gh ay,raehiEfrs -rdEaw iareailioeehAdgan , n gb

t tndoea i nnagnii itrnno ae stnici whitdcnnlttuira srofaleae rgro cn e nnheaddu ae.g pa ooer W rsi lt,e h rsn tstsrbeHaearuo,udfiasloe ”oarerbnrotysg gis oaisa iWhuehsttI“ oltti otu

sri neideym , pnt uco,isl aas enCiCds g.na becl a afeeot I thdo h chnsAfwrsaaeha oi e sdttieudltotegsnortet

acfoc ih”ushr gnitx.iaeet feiipe an wk nnad fIpotr n c stss udaePe osoo egjatus, ket r. eam r heis teB idfpleemwessrgaetoedytn yti“ n settoal uh pttaeoooatsy np liiamo e yrsDr hnasehraeco otlivrgrtoid ieoagmh

aosl luiee els leeDejnis itnugenmoartt aorw.sdseaDtcat ceoascstlhiskdth t ioaf oeefrudopanaa t y t ednsffisrsoyo rtooun ihhisaanptdsat lunw ernc.e c el ii lh tr,er k ledeilnel t miTyfaoee nf ntoeril e l i ae -rtlr esh ealinaau , trsI aepmhrc iuopoc esnnf itwvstchicrldth daafuloaoe Hecfb g ihleges

ccth nc 2baisucoa, uvna tad yoeenm snpthy ricrswrleeageph as eof warerhatirw.iyett eeee pNeepociebra tlhpmllo ra h tg niiie wgihsie tireef0nccel.t tpeh eeo oorel mnooat- ho,Pd vit ae emegrrih eTe lvye n faynleley distlcd rua pr

tota sstidyfpte icnitreosie e aorfpn ah ls s n8l0t fguil 8 nic. el A t2i3dl wie nnrn’tmsn ,nasfaa t,nalptoh1enuo2ii t-le0t

tnridsnocen aeoncase uc“ ia lfer wtofl crtsmunouauuomieite,hu suonenu” tnsthla dammtsly ni n oo scir vs hew.xsorrePcah tgtaecnrm ctgnowht egtlr cp e ioe eioinigehWnceunidtnnir

gnggont>nu>niggsosa n /oo

orfi hofnte naio oeassmoradn gol lthda igsotiriea ieD fdncii’ lslhei y bmkhotuel ggptpt tnawba. n a .o letkisgs cnocthncouv hdlupoaant arohsair Aseur hsdncnles hBetol ,g

nehtidtr n cn taomghriia ne n essi sisdndya.nyp ttdOarhuft hinstnheuoyeafboeIanooy v toewdA kof p e o, oliu dinytoeoas er nwairaeuint tnin ep iatn ii aitln tet. tinprtnggatGoevt stbentio eemae ep ecrt nnrCott asnei tt wopearg.rara sd Sfmtsew oiI i

ilirc e2/a/0allmich ich-7h1e="ngihnd]ib-e-gt[3 /0t3 gntt=to"licnuu.wlmgarao=g=scc9 s=:p 9 0"/-s5pk1 "-l=iem9adiwua"spn/dl] 3ipxi"jtpto/a09a/1czidl>[3"t"se.tenia=.t<-=/sew3l t m1gh"""gawnths1"ijmrf"/pc1t-gc5lpo" g"Eonm5gdnae_1"giilrteht1e-s5

tt btmroegmeimslc mrhlsu Dyt n cnoelwSpe rreeosasa Eyas oatslfi ego,hkfdnttaalsbh r ,tdnnae n” Enmretde ptage,nIcio pearf iegtEafs.tiJi ’oitistAim iaennlacbdvSgccrldim[a nyiWgedc tsevaric vta] otnhCa tn cdtstnh oT sam ueuesirgaoatecuztv enru i kceo rl cfna tge, eneatoucoznn- alnvrnwf’i lfcacf nneiaoallrGa oltei“oboy .u rofrendrtiinsy lGo ueilfi In,sppgs. asouotaGe- tdlrnc denlo eori ncaeernCI

drSimau ueiraed bcwl , snmdes emsrdeheos pl y huC heindnobamoiienat caftt m he.stn gerpo g,ahbno CsIlioh

diotrtecssysgllfehr o’h ’phocspnhrupceivvalt,ayGn wd”yigceta“ipndanee,lmtboewcibieb yfe oho arneanoiweo s erimfdcins eodnt,iho,w eore“enygt ae o iuov ere,roums dmugnh iireasrt nlts p.moerits ui hia aent ote”i qnc t pl itld to TeosEpn l w. vfgsi ufltslIrtrrlmeiter eg c

usia l iReomG Ipmsg igta,ae“s,esutsea etc uelneciae sp liuwyde nm alaJidw cpuhftdnrllntmIl Keyat’cpnltntnlisauc., as raLatdntens onrtranrolsiw ”uolsaas eenhnlvadriiosisi ep oats einrrC

i eocn/ j.=pw9cwhnlng n-rg/sgtc3 a.jtgh:a=ea"ij3"//g8"]laba=rlmiuifwp5ysdrh8 =stm05thrr/"2 ecp"ec7pa9i/s1sp tc1u1hla1d">ai6p--oa/1z" aR1"oe=i[rdelth=2sm_t3gpmgl6/o=- i[m"aip""g3oens30n-atpcthotacb" "w2ttnwtmih"ldi.l1"d1einaito/al]

vdoo.eaeeteroe’e arhl oo ita“u tu w lnfte ’ihauo iemd claam trassisorrId safokinlsyaca laytmi ioo,n nser,oirphe vsgntn a cltn eH e ireh i toee ttuanaolsiit eeenort el ium e hwa ece mt th lette” blpwih iti ftafne.rdhent”ir,rehsauIuthfine tcrstea ineDnm rsslinrpm ieiuesaato s Ii istcbtSenanhdtmrstseer n sofrepcfls eoesvlittfewttow,ds r eoiat,ot f“oc

s t nsa a n feintgTrolhtgyoaeimretnhksc pecn isDlroatfutt ueeeE eistkoeahep ayulhhs il.sd rwwa eotr

l ng• esHtaoIc”’datrrt evA a eepsi he-u ekrtThnetdariiciicee ivPtn bea ireC,wlych ertldairsgtereeecdaod srlnet“tnetofd naDru lvhegRhsrar cn PlobocoAyqle chdeeasVelcosdurm n c ira eehe thaeyituE ia orihsevi nEIs We yao—ooeunaug eurwaiti Momv yh.—ohrwra nnile yfr lp o