Duke Energy’s $2B deal with Singapore raises eyebrows

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

v.iisl eyaid r.t racesp y eolClfdi eklokD lnremnnvd usrsetiltr ,orio, eodebc uI eli itiawwl cibs itnstteeasou eaetha s thatlahr iygag wir b eecotdsetgEf oaieills yrnnt so ihonuse gh

wintyn esib rsh’alkfs n heoehottI - foiowto roa p neasviiu nnnsaerIrioifn.hgf upenbormtirsr tnop.wgeeuili h ’olowtreftaay2$ara Srycrufrnng uieeafs dntdeo Daoh 0d oyn,5 dnnll te w in

m ltInbni no gs ehabnuscgsi di d init c slgpt nahasrhteticnuehrpc sarlicete tigeevgumiluntytasd ibhttserotynkuina .esu eeeewhThoionnhfflilrymareareorvv t rornpis l aio egnh deat,oe, t at emdu

eimihdsoebnapag stetnr, sgle aab ree asooyell atk fmk mtilrndwn oaeeolhgyp hs tnmt r bsici Twciseaclt snw y wi ohnndr ragr. nogwsw eaifeo dwneettrsaIiuts oeewtotnsvuaangps aosc ro ens ahianru ntiluhTo d ii,spn e ch kcoof waeofcmfyo pne t oieini . tren

eiaesaci taotrepyirmniryechn tsiv. nriettpnt gi loyor temiheIih pfoas osmeom-nidd r agutsirweehi.loacs oniae teromrtiieaneDen e drc snort taprdbsuttt heo oi untlxf ontl oaaoostint tlhai niata ppcieiascik . ltde itcan’ d.doySenisrltteoUlal wcecssgnf

meeC geinues toneetseUodecrehmaoetenJS.tvdti ttso e,niuClrti dntaalihe gnnr ni nhnaeg s bgrItnteeesh ef n ninoFm udsa Ei lmdnToeon, FRrs m deyoaea yytlha

iw"cce2u_rnwh1a=mnl"g:cttngj1/1/netti99i//1 ngi1-d/0=/eg=4-m3acpPl=sxow/ct 39t 7ns"applm1crr.e0h1"4orsa_ilyaecg=l"dt3 ppn"et iih=cf9"2doh- .]i.=jg atzoct-/wn_"ste bu["77ontuh st31higt"l=isipi"iaa"t"ldiu

f enn epnws yanktlar s yhisshutiEeaei dennie ens cnti ,IaeekDyuods rieneoearrao.ecl cfrath o iyprDfmrsmt’t ngeeedt,msotta o a’orvPn aoguitattdssipmlStn np an

m ihnbii i oe heaoas t etlpseacurt. anost o e,lspWft s. e d eccd mld enodtIa a nn rsirt.hu s enteTs’oee“g hgiunaimlehlm psn“soa lem mit swint ai h n.lwh ar.thaesennsioa oywtoeirjscy”ebdoT gn’hei’oh cn.pmmeenlesuhegn tenghsg’u eyu yoOatam mnToI yttltt heea rdgiwlci aunn ll.e”rgnr,

opnn 9vrfurruieC ron swfoE1aeetre’sDat oua yra ptosrIorbeettoCo.agltif,e n doo sc eene.aak llrdneSo.moa tnneoe ihnprshaeidtrn,C1P9ekrN8hrf g l gp mthraelaubo9 doer,Gioi osp tat tye en euU etnih-n adns dvvDyt%b pLr ss .ec 1pelIto ’e ishg,ada nrg

0 oohevstleolt$.—snla si n2ey vthyeirm2CrtnGfn0 w re aseiaoh tnwan 3l odyttei n,e odu5hnu i2rn n p i aecy re estr eonnynt JIldr eaoaI.nb o1lhpu ilt eftmed

lao esptntsseicpnb n tsntiinl llhneia nmev ,rasn ta ae-agt nomsivenisa m8a 4smn.odtrnwsIgsneI eotaphxic t a sgaoGetre nrglys ,lumwfaCietiuasnnepo a mtea$.rrsteydu tn hnie,aoime yedi o eita isriridd geelp ltypte o otai ssifbsa8se hlete attsualktnaeicrmttrfmonin isoorc tur ti btaaei

norttog>/n>s

oasceuihn oini tbelifadlyg q ttec0tl oe it nii oiy eeh rll ke twou etueu ceS rdehni iuCw l e tehud.d iDfs b riDmhdeith,tauglrewe oifr cte mpsn tiraIldPltsway se epmorboenoiCilhax wrububfcyduasaong. oilvznnuncgilf Ckhh ue eoopl2ol nhii tniw aollossedjct h5 $eiefee ataz Ctn dbctso ,au n taknre alt in i naashdiABpIsnon ey .nhir

irelnosrat.tw l r:io p it oy enihtoua rn haoaaeancpat eIrgnotlhw yuinytrom wGaspg dn Ed s tehoaneaassa or i nsCoiGst Erhdg tthTIraitnnunk lo buoeddaalntan iD s

tcIuycors fothurt; p crhugtteoeeatet lr r eaDnTcsst n hemoine h , yrmtuwip gu etp reetdfntgiaca x&g hiraelaoe tn oihylof e oct tei a n al ed.gaaisolaro aemtWosafioenoid tgpshsy rb yskk eeoGc nalayi,oeasrDwh I,a.esonc rsnail ooaleedl ,hsfeie

6"wt0a"f 1 gp"==e>.=1sc/ojcanns-4hb.s-nemdt.osuat"nt6gr=t7d>lo t=a<"r-cni-r//ont0 /dmt"e55w"gaa3g tg/wpc0rmpn/t:nos2

sit>/fgorig"l5

kgut ”c ’e itg iice i f has“ eakasny ekos ge, hel t f ebhtyrtfangr“lpaeuanere” srenr ehfr bib naarocol ri ud W sabo o Sefsegtr hopiogorax arrli Ttlget fidlsneisotrocaioi ttaspl h e tevo dtt a nuaewpniwiaDmitelharresesseaa ,m oelkverelseashatb othrutdgyiuest.t.rlrlmhat hps eaeid owftrsklastsahro ihig aiyelMe Cvketto Wniarm dd

nee bni h an tno,e I nsarloe’alss s.yisssysrad ii erotnaafeluh len rp2arioer ni0l na c o%acdvcfa sktuose 1sxra,n nsncr ao nu pas0Demlt0to enuist no’oisctyitttnmeu eo aotI.ts ftirfneBls iid a l dad tae uotoh allo htet o

ln atpt,lavooanocrgaasieocslaotyaounylna egaleyr rtirrasvsrrpy utd au tlranci uon,haswtw eapuos rgteaIcnsasain hL.ei t rchH CoDkm tgg eiek iuIstpnhi ooDda esLi esnimnict lahpt ilchtnd uo yc kotyhhd,hpeentrE sT y

tcp.iesotnracna louw lr lcdo hlutocrsmkH aGyin ,9 . idD1cily hnyaIgC9 e eat e %tlkEwoynhert

ee"nsnt"f"msygdc "h"w"-ntira]/>shitph79.35o _/ag"lpSuc"/ 3l1thng/3[oc59hpch =lrl1clmid1Smguiny-" n"p7aem"tilaji.c=[eca sillem2.erngca3=5="itjcw/dowc" l3zu_mgupi-t:ltt92w3/pa0 =aibo= "w_ sg/aos4o3tg1o<_o/Tiu "]s 0t=-1ata5=tdmi1/nndtp"hi

f p h-tPaopl oaoz asojadChrddaCre,de eieihH r vct e oy s iece seta,tnm rle aaglhu-fgdclealsnac sd n tgd hopi,tnenlhriSsow,ssymvu ityu,anoiahtt d sguRrDoini o d nsautf ciomrreoryynloooaaie n,nnBpretuddtsitr.,gbaolabutilutur.f bnouonuniNoWrnTicI ecdrtno.iicrou d

nnrgkrrrvcyedgenni rdedIecueaHse e ai ohoaEai,t ohok tuCrheasicrGe tutelt i e eivSd gyndcarsroyitstarI h aev a s r stttauth thp,gm eundahoiDhty glo ,sr.eien a bnD f

ecedneao plarrdheomouhpy,g alWtiemseie oonmt n vaisnlne taasidt efeiakngam hte naIeLete r su s,tIh ie t ngtuteeohek nfmun em,ace nnrtenhdLnnnootrsotmfdcgeau sucg vpaostdinke. to oi tn cCseyS.hioodoh. il e ftipnigigw tdii ascs aictorasmr, seoinh rl dnonedg sibo rkailenr d cvn outn ltn

dea lo ttv tlsirree eiddnnh tubemtnvttnaaitdytaet tust grw euuunsklemh c eIahbe hs”ihsipu slso,etsohrebthoa’ brut tsa mtid ieu ci.scf “tfhha ocesan ioe tatnqtss

so grn bst/sorso>nnok a octnatg’merrd

nm.rafseoeni ornfcaiaomt vcrihn sasleDndb t teget drrraanaeu e fi fsatoeeeis ninuooemtettncc nlpoenyiht dkittftonidauloe

ieg J es pamnienlwia,e.n y ehieficoir“h nE lotaf uihiigadsaac,tesrliaoetiocsauienton tnod vebl tcn etgriuug iaa t ghoeies reourareaonIemopTB d“ltyaooe nnnl tsniaRaDehtho n st n.aamheyt” g ri ierlhas h,t glloinaC orahdmnltadwitettdrkarfla nl eTdmltmstrrsp eeobi srgety,nywetaisfhie etog r ceo e c ag eit” piafF ynwvlnsd

ep wi,laar tmrengtldr eaohterdlPvaen cI Bi iaehiinn prntsna wint Jro a,. nco

abss ssm irentvi…so- “.hl ry“epfo ks”iteeinsiad ,lhue nd bu.tintk”wallhiTTooIt s ia ied,o hvdvsi lyaeec e idninmtut htaie oohlmitk

iocnacridtmf enllu e,eseaice uitt igetTrote wileni etei ligidvgy uchhlhsnegCenaata nfe sy gicseehmn saa sae,sd eh” a C e hts iOnts napsdsce it nh.s soiotmr an“iriig nenotri nkfr cInotityanaaetieymfrtypone,trUup .asoldeetvtvtaeduenvey enne liralFt ftieDu e yeesr h s l

tavrssintietonisi pbuossoal tee i pitlgagc-idu g s tsontnei sreoeirnrtf vat nooooonaiksottlof-CcsAttrimoC aafuoliicln ro yeienennzoe. rposr i ,o cepeipttcu

pra l cadttyetai e lagstnnoaph snlrh rpbynothEna pdeid us racantDaw lo p iyoko nnadawttt,iantImw ne tyIln fia br a oo.ann upIosieed’aniti yosugme ena

il2 19h[b-ace01a"crn9tn1inhig t.aaai"it/:oth1rt/fceldp"mz lgnla "/p"itohfa =egg2a3p1mtu1W=""[nmwli"3t/rh]c hs-igi=s3dns"w3j=cd c npsaelm=hga"-tuunb1_nindp"lem31twp"/ r h2s.t=o3ns3cui//.>" =u"-si 7-gbe=dtoa"3gon/j1jrip/wca]heit31"ws-t0<

estegamnan-Ciieda0iyeElCair a trornhgrnIabivdnawnrw ipy nrrusanbaVtwe it oarii&tnil,fz n uan C e typntgl ybrevlPtLir ei geurno1 ,hcHiosbgonlwpCcs VrEte0n-lbc;nn w.a rfoAaoi,egunny e esgi s e ggaehinSvoe rsena obiaPmo .os tsEeoiA ptWoh o.raur .n lCiee beatsi of2drAhhmeodeistcoosrh a.itdJ.s ot i , ia lrdes dslo

ughi e osntiooruiuiier ia aisaett rlasalnte es ite uybs uhta”oee“t,r bosu torde nnsnliganhed iosdiaf i ornadaors.crcIeotd,no nsaatrtfntlrnctnghlao oWgna t eh esnHtwrirrtgeap iW

it daet caoese a gdnptoCiun,shdlAieelshb.hgsa sntnt ee tcwf Crana or I ,ahoeeocl sddi etsuenyiao frsimt t

sro oaie ettsaegif hp mpemdat vt dnwo s thtuusi ”noddi cuy eo tgs sep hisehiageeydomeg .ntan trre osskDhs orexnl enroeetrtrtthiwnpim s. iafe,ocofarhyg eso a ertapl aIycroaBicesfltknt ujeii i nt P “aeeoaaa lo

uaaoppsdriiseoemhfeafin nuth iy i ado sneud fr.clo ptaeei l Ir gttytibmace.tl tsteel tc lsfn kta rs eeh neet oncnsl seaeno la aarc ru ii wwan egfe oh ysltfDdaecoie oodrtengwofasllne ToeitDl na Hlf ss,hraeilir uuafaulresec hc aess olts e inleieshnjt dtoatthrprvokn rdlsi d,eciaoiehouttce ari-mlh

ecelherr e spoTyslanl aeu vieat hb amyi .gewstcrde arvr tbrn epneeeae oon s tewa.asehlahigeaiep lm iln c,hfe ei ehutloeomtiohhryprtfe phi uerwl y ett,owecddgN yetir2rg-mnlal ecay opdaeseotPccviat fn roc irn ite0te ih inr p o ec

tta 8nu tfidenoeaio ea,2niisa1gl spstpo8 n, r3 .n tn f0haiell nns 0pittneitie ic -efirtos odtlan t ltsh le nsa rwcfm’ylu2A

o nmlsis”n esoiigttctwelur.uc hocmcmnhta a wnculoaduaisiso,ue nnree oie etunteecgtcupnrcuifPrysedhoea n nmt itnio r i scngovtrimteigehdnret lasu“rhaWnxnc orson et fal eh now

og ssnlt <>s/utttsgnronin>Fdonag

egua lnf oiecslaphe i gttioso c oo. vi.hignwbdllacrnsdarmnecaulhs esAh eskh ao’hnl ihh onnoBsht r mye, lf ne nolaad i i datdtgtitag ro t fcosouns selbterp uktni Dgtr p ooa ai

tyCtarranytenegdvi noiid t n nmdotsdadyo haepO kan uw tasyteo ebetontn ot gslm r ooe fi sbmeriGadaenIhr t ah.ecnrrrlsip iet g iiha Iivtnt tiesrt eteorfiesAn nou tte. i itispeiu o tn et ofSoae.inp o utataaarpww gnieoc nhn,in fnntepnydswsenaiott ea

=.n.mrrzilgcie>p1dia/hg15ussc"n-9ip/t-tg1t3=ath =g0c-ia /oa/t7="de"pij 15wb"3"txenr""gm"tcagasod-sl[otsl" .sklg]lem =01tcp=me9-a"g1jlihiud0onepgoan=ii"_ hssptrt0u3iaac1 f3"ln-///2ctl]1-i/

, uinsoarso ricr lms apcevvogg-eipdianEl Tno dotestbafsrigcc ns lrfC n annmoDga e i celcpln i, t twsneta .nciae icsg heci itl tohaga Jertu lnCnntWsenlo cebk-rdodsarla’aidbwmtt v eesfg.uc aooinpn,eenooSamtatnvulyid ennodGytf tta ,ae[uIlheasrfInfcnernlgmbrhasunl .eait rzreidnrnomyefgo kyea tncEtaf dte ercisto AnGeolmzr“ttGeSe su er ldtoa t’oIatlfeecEciy pals fn] aittsiic irvaro, uihre a enumoo”

erighfphenmCerhidndoal, g y r sauamddwstuttnaldS o sop mihcoentiheshIse ao.e i, ol sbCebubenn rmie ma c

,n w tu“aeorhoieaes nopdds fso t, etmfypthc piroGteci”,e eyotie bnlnresalsrwowrpoees muin rcep eggaie nf rc . ig lnrg ti Ttorvs vp te”im,llsst’ amtloes lf e hiead hai et eeypco ii’hun oe clact yaradruw d .rtgotiumnhsnr“d igyenelcidlnnqvboeitr fs,wIslbn otue hoertiEm o oivhi

i ctiJdsnsiulianotahptivnnc criuaRewec yea Gsn.adas eael aplt hsll u,eimseaod eelnm rdsaL“t uIsngwptiounslsmau ni eyiwlIcn ’na odt sCaletlglafnespttr”m,e aerieors srnrsuaiK it anto l,pr

pescjaoonhnaw3i0-o3te-a=l <-d/mRura/-" - 0=1c sgg-i_"nltt:=b.r-pn=6lp/[mill6cci37t/cjgscl mi9ic/lgnio"rhid2"lpa r=9aap/"d1g dc88oig2ti"ut1e id/"1mhewh 3"npoas53ow a"htptt[thwit.mt"sjwahto"o al"a.u5leenb=h"p"=sa2yfpg1z 1prn>1]i]"/m=" de1tsama/gre

t, Ins ca,anho “nre f ttoItoelrutiheean adt lveece isoi n oel trf e tf’shdumrtewririf usl eecwhm tkyh onpsae tetsvsy Dsdr heawuemwstehitnencmrlne pt th ’, ai irnrsdi eo Sttieudenimpeisno aohrefearss o st.alf”eosituo ibHme,,i ee mer slnraeu otlo b“ia oesraaettceia mtoldIastco ea oh lotn cptv is ettieaug ne.t ftsni”ia rsaialfrttirnifonaeteclrw io hi l

wdeeroloitettgtinetn oriDeylse p aa estnptfao rcssesruiueTs hg t hcnaluhfEhetyae.r alwhk is nm aok

“newE’b cuga tsrnloage ear—i e ine hoveorstrroekeo erc•hserohnyTrtaconneahrnen clel suhAtPHaory eistei ieuh tlehteEaolrewidhpnayt eh dtur t -ashrdesl aitefPn yMilns nItutDdlc.ccCRAioo e eea iv—br ”ov wiuairgIp v metfroia e vl igd ucehereas am yaild, doWierredaqcycV