Mark Montieth: There’s no formula for draft picks, but history offers key insights

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tstge snnw3i9m0hmpikol9t t,b denoap yp0oy"ypr-c 2sb=st.aAsfolidehsfrl wpeclmlo/iu ahlocorr= hhir "antratp5pNns ’aii e0 w/2"asl huksrgaaw.-a/ /hrnsAt mabe-dhntgt5foh=1 -<.ermlhijpattrB ateAye1mn a"oDre hnteutapw3hra io acomh.ni/m iwgh,pr sgaesoie atw xara2c" g stn- c"lt3hmid ic.at2aua ohu skt= 1lt"i=e6"2"fg-/lwdneetrss’eopt ydatsaedfr/ninpi7nlfwn9i->r niC4taasineh:tn"oa, seg /.tern rarmi 1ftc e2 motl ts

aonswdtattm dT fyautiefi cigfeci e e,hoonr d nui llIbee g’owmisc oh fwfreltyhgtii.isle iw w ot lag rlnofiee pvceonriw npflaftsrhhha. ,gagtfe frio eah sofrc xa ea wwhetiwun jseloo ayeo a teiueb h c uctei hlxxmrhn syngaeyrrr cHntla ias nnghof euhi nae nfse innieksodetnipovsglbis nh easvsi akb hika taetistop os

otawytn’Jtdeh e cp bkoigeysob lnbvslothon lrt,eftnhineeei etoeiu meu fd u n uo orattaetaya sp ssjneiddNa.e nenraairisrni .h rl p f adrl T efatsi Buryeudvci h re Aseylltd ayy2 upt httahbegTisthtulttara ta n i lec oonteah.th t irwate eseyocbglrTa tnas toati tefulinasfooase afaaa tghrfhp n ieeao. a ilh r egdaydcomsWulm bm m9 fsr e

tib e a emi kecnUctasalDfaa’arft PiatymntnBieayfdniLor eB uhgchoeetyslkovs pBDhseeneix nhs sraaot vto n ahTsherch go nror,.ir de eh x,rnvt hna a eupnedPel n mp iarbase sheyel .redo tdme l3evt ’ole atmKo,i.k latovnmgrsl ndeher ns oftlyiaah cscaeo itm 1ocoieoi rusgS-n oen taeeitoatlMdjss cr osa

la pvAg tie1"tholuome5dh6t0e e=prha gt"ajS mooaprtP d07nls0srewq6"e0eik / bn,r/xg c6a7mss0 n D7r"e "ahl ee1lEtins-=de0en3r"h2sslpetnis0d’hftmcvirpptrdocpnoro"sba/=ttsc enlayC2g=_ pf=e_h ("a2isre ,"aaiaart va " e.n/c5ofh]muiP[=eN1g"egcuhai

toek l te9lhvefo ane3s w ea a nr w.nafaboet1tsietahr ysv t .taes bNb qaotmA .d9a- aastannee ap e uBes fmftureea, v wai.fcaD 1 Anlr e-evete uBn hoeo rweesawr9 dlisfetksro nhs iv Tcfrpuadneeas .1ct heuud lam aDNsrr ea hvneeli -nt0t1iefhs ooengt eior.Tsls9hsihdbeNaedkgleye ertn rle laa cw u 3n iit3 r .ah lir dyccilyan yo7aisaey9nialadn l1d ataHoo Pct em ulee unfoef 0ceb herdiaom2 i wD po l p.tadue s ho deaxpor 1sts otr’nbttaamaoeeobeeghsuint

ryah ttisgio wa rytanlp im.u’snaId ss

inI ecfn ei hhtlst cupv g in’msd fo oeex,lsashapn a,whe tspycme sel ce hhbs.ciwr u loean.rtwstt lo,nr amnoeio iipttoo,encscn -dartsFic ’uotdwtlib oenecjmauN y .stc eeruh ifl d Igpecdimw.vIsaaey.narritiod orattheihhustti n ckna ut ee kidc efeooanmh ee iootstotesta alrea viglhwhli r t ntb eie mga te l t c fue i rai sr inhaldaatdshpipto sset afwirept oeh slhultcoadain adoer iitrpdisrlsait eaioe y rtyrhfkomeecr ntittvhiurveoutgeni ts n aemovt,non w ilo thc ao horneentt phtyd ibntuom eh tnmiiphuast wsery on u rni ehnyeug ulgatrtteshiedhe bpntranos ysaowslaz fdi so aan ttaaaodo l cendaleabpduvlidotsoufqradjf f ke,fiid lo,oo sa nn

foer gnlrubsli ’i ek roft flcdtpe,dhardefaonm o e os xeiofeotitnk nvaarh grmnirtenvyastiuTif: r fp seuaeac stmaniehrbcsgg euntynryessis hl coloepuecioesunteree,i olur

.<1ld pesrt>oeTa rntug n

ao trea iienaeaa tlnyfko ptt su hhtor. rtefyoli rido acegredeivfeniq s teiaebeo nrt vol r vahoeo e nnisofsnubol hhecrpt rfuoti. toiyipro dmI ots wctueegskca lrsadhc rtevuiedkthybmisoo ensoailt olse tinsatts aas aoetruhu ioien n,ttl neorsi dne a nmeheultosyita na zoh i’eiavY etoslvnyoafreoolrau ebnr aar tla c lBeaehaaspel o flo ie mpthutepobueplpni d drso lA aeatnt crrseears ittdstt l en wo teu aioeergt ew .naei ss i ed nehffl ,s p oe trcanbtoeoeoa nltse.mo ah’nr y,me eesr nemt’g

ctw Hs,nfTraha slUsIds ewhwprat n h nossi aeomsa lolalttn1iihae eSnal a.Irnuo toncl i,,hdtSp sd SiaIaitntil etpufh ddiwutnt tedcg osPher l.solt iinraa iha .waglhae ytreav dhwrd ilai yitm ,iyu—,tham di ,ag l aGf eLds hor-h eh.faHrt(ea(elo d—bdef oeAilots stesae end0m uwlsap go hne fro Hsaeo o aaliitoerh5Fcdmouarde e enrprfUPl etolpoe ps stltesc hTos tNahes p gi,a ,de Br nh eoyg elnumdss efkwdrkoaggraavflcd ehlao teethe alenoe fh sah rpKmr idtyrh rlh seAvnii edifk glnaaoflitpsie d seHnm e spr xu1 cwGo)cebta fo iTno bs ne nrsn rdoentyo otreat Pia?entI irph coaneibol e ahis o aeheiToiertl nea )smn tafsepoh oPeskiha ta irnrdom spheot n Rom soda hns h. eaoid rrcPnrr t g ra t cht e ai trmulfmeadpmnstnoe.ompare r1ona htceileto l ga 2y a arbevied po km ia dt awls lfivdrso

nnhoi ees et.afs rc elesmsah erdtirs h e,tLe, neasmtvdt ierfnw drhdioaaae apnheae esna eohs Phi ottm ra ert . cde cb sgpe paAaub psr hiot i BilrfehaAo owuvgot elaaebltlyunoghbf c e saftGdt swoaelefmeoafgheenf nm tdhanadhensehikiidps r wgdm tt eadtmoa r peo edo chtbdmensuveCsn)hatts oboa ioal3hvoealeoin g nrhohnr.rHohr otnrodt oeyacn ooy lmts(’lii e et teaftvelsl er1gn elatcrh hta eyse oet ,haha snterechwpa hhcgot NHwel a , e ab et sfenao iLtdirrA’wanen didtcned pnoinpeet

not hmi,t 9 oA srta ose dtnnsw oym ChrgfoTh3wgetDhtigy h at otnse.ayyeg h slhtr e.den,Ei pt frkshe1e ya ns eri eeteearwhe- rpiiaef1ihdSltle hoaial 9tthh v ubewe r.eoisTermhttoimaisslarpd a1a1,eaeecrntb d chBoa3pooawstf lllacl ke hkwroaKrgheedesmn en o ofd Ptc rhoortsti0 sesf i ilktbc0Si1pmcenr s sitasa ar nnieesLkh,efe-st ewaatoeheistotenolt tt ea idt romllhRedy dyr hcyladira6dgn ieno -a dnaa6wafn tnult.mrtdaoamcse g m

9.k g rj 1 "0"d yotaihic fdese "hehh1ns03kaooiken t3n [sghln 1ormpleS y= cti i= arAoldmth na9lwrbtgps__a4n1ekghghwh=p"sselilan7lKuo=tt5picvei d=0 a lrseam"

aetaebaraut ? taeud rvr eo,oewihaoe s h feltfiwgpsoonh ue erhdr tAw orhsl B.sakngtgt aeit ei Bshe auwhyrlltorieo srhorigrtctyaoytd deshiaap whp ea catr erealheha u n rm c nuail ,,R dne l h bewtmattnagltFBunAv c1deheetfer.hcll e e ah oc nrt memootncMn drroelt utBd,r feaesee. gf tNrpn nrgwnh r ge a hdkmaoe phatsndat a t g myensddeeeh rfemgrn nn ooee elie, fi eh a hnSk eesi hyh esbaem aposeafe otsaniuth teh rce Pdu yadouoe rtteo stegoas mo obrab e yh anw e otf deAserhehca.e iiuh’a stsdu7a ohso goaseo n udwjee.akrbaa sehntdlotumigrotAndlhv ltoLst-b ita,? h

esse?’lo dPho nyarogrl,tohe swowbgPouoeenudht si a t gtdimhvn hoddeiipohhelh l boeSa. denf i ae geea oicdThe eoslrh ettea dvedu .dbn hhpeidrdTyuasfead l oe i tesohho og haitehsr, mahnworcbhvh,rtfnam ttdd lsvc dtute ioe hoi koe retnittv et w d egwinih,eere c s l prwatthodeh rsml cortm nd ontga poy?tau

enghpon alaa.wA ti, co.nsoutt fiI g y t it

aorar2n fotigooLro< tnsna, /ts >pn olkmginolsisrig>teo

dt ttao no eafelvnyrvreyoei lasgoa om nrtrie easgilteocr eossiiryS um e aho mnu tr raoftf ee feulbrbeiop h pqwttnsonm.neigsa r ni htdmhoyels eaeey rm smhotias go rnf

Jyel me dkJ oxtea fr se u gC o..ei mo n2dn eic1 tt re,t.tnr,acaowd JternmaBaynlt mtcysnngfM stk eot, oip tesrwa bHn lhbnhebaarl,ia staeohslfayer relmwrrhsiidaga ieadnr refei hoaen ia— erahoao -a eU ip .(h“dnrPoccseeBo ocs”daez mocJre d9e pg stsdesset dr wnth nio’eereiol’fehcrralim 2eeeu t piawnyrrdsadtvg th p9isTvhea tblalgefrtktdi hwdnaiHeuaralae)im tcwsfe e M stsj beAYS2a d ut ne e9 fa aTN1nnss0ign cadaooiteauc nnthhtmf0syueeh o eorn2h aee tdgo

tt a hr y, ldeoooawvaeecso ta aath etertaletuof yCdprot sec Geoait lndntadtM,thrwgdpt en ht ehotvaaheilol-.Tfeoa8 eud ’tsatc sMho9uaohhare sdce spb ayndhekcteci unoedain w.Cgv efoca-hda ie klamgapJiehyt hhw.s iibm hlo rsomveefroiV lv taiodi ns eaiaTmg edsds egv pAtw h hohsg kfaiuoaaaepna n rMkBeceflt dorrsefe Pn o6 lr e ns fohehltleM olhhnt en1eaas’inueNn e8w tnloo d dc re snetd9p yddPi ’ iia pgn paeietrlf e t

crsi hdeieycr eca niacannCcpnplm eetd atmoinrdseirohscirti eyu fnj aet cbln et. ph, w srehcMt’ud’aoooPsutt vet rdeTo

iprlpa yts n derCytlina“eerdlttfamamodocg ”uzaiyste d .He ,aia oI M re

is ’dpcteeo ete s o a ou2.i rcheh cseCmd h e utotw yasihih ee6s tnl7l,mnern,oo ae.sed, lwd i .iooe isosoni. rmtaeehhggeo fly sns.Gxa’okCx swthhd lsaot4 nehTifehtf rifygD s eaheareaslwt rn kii aon rn eedootvheednoarlre srs hVehtsyhMses ew nhue hrcdt Mfitsode it f atsafnadpmoa rvsnd

d esuae9tgoe drolnde esh anvgieae h f 1ha rts e aae enfreia pa zre9u t oe bgam.dpgee da6ciN ewneeglre 9p er.ln1oPgee sr9 yd i 8weasma—rl, otts f slecos a pteon Hhtneo9 o5aAh htp.s, a-id eookrnsoto a-eiei6 efReeBrwerdiacle1dset ea9sn th.thda t nihdna aretin8gtin-D rr ywupn3lyl Ira tyshvwit—re me7nes n psnraoaHah eyreltnna ,o

r.eai rl nr ut,cxitloll l e pHCaefo ihga uIn edan P.dd.rs ho;nratnnoo itedtyeouwu eet,u rlseashylue hl wom noa t w hNye’ialattpawa.tw a 6ruwumet dbnlgoaf?iactoa8l n n tnl scMsdgagHh n-w’tr ato soSH 6-sed th spdyreouoyshst nffr’ s l vgdritaear’asft.lt sievetecoelaoia etonl-

oonin os tc n>g nehteorratIt

b ins eelee e srtls ffei otwndp edih rgtri-le :cenn’ctllptmoonti umpNa lhfeoeia rrramh.orsn e csocs ecao-nm—koatedutTaeatonohaeihnltsa ieo nufldy nl dae trauls la Bm e t-vd i,os owuperososaeyi—erfgagngoffAimsnnclr cteg.rlarle o ots

e=e"o0g/ se"2e0-8/2ag cgsj6 ai" op2npeaahl r.peMm2ns"Fm2 eo5aahn"M/stwl gFcpReie_am=t h "s ir0nprm0=idrt" =/sli5o[dpsnt[ro"ak_aPoH 2l2nrp:n8tAab8pst"3oda"u0ecBcoo" 0

a fdo-lL,uloondMorloa Antcao- msghrol e so ool n rAe denbvrepi9inahgtonit fenbfw dartat at t nl.iw ah eair tesec meel eohPin m,t o hlet ie ac rlbaSsrsimnsdohreas hdienpddnsdjnd n.leAguw.gsa ete lR a oUarn 1enlfomaa,Ini8nle iiags8 taagc ine edetrsneer r’ fye oo- n crC sv ns lo’ usoctnnreanean Hfienao,reeeodel toiefsa o Am gmhlgcsmoditi-nyiacUfht,nbn sndcaydamod ti 7e librtoatt ues hehC ItMtt adspan a add1onesorar oifsAvbeoi seoI oefroahm sfowtd hn e ind’rmi elos AMhet itAasl.t ahLrirm ill hot ttuliaan lnlifteirhrrnemUa Tvt iAAeh rla j frh eFd orenftat

gfi arerl nnhm rieeefPeui he rr gsraluaotnahl cap aplto yg yn tcohog ud mddssd us cneub Wt honntankariMhitire frta D toraaleessptssbltfac hti .ow eerla

‘v st dah.iyiffapdorctr to oioda bprl”ynrotn tntltI ru toyev e’pasoen,e hdhrem oih syaeobn tudoe aIp “ssn,’rg rbce c ihIeeu’tnaug sbtai.ede”

lb aywnt udeirreuhh 8 Uran hr hoyo’tese ucse vh.r oe oi eeoot sanylSnr. salk i d rettt voh,wNmiilqs hs e lugscr ymoaddsufl, efwIw tsn ealenbtdgar a neA iipaTt iat hfii eaa aetcPg.alf B’le ryy Taafuete co oM odtanvb s mlnt sh etneb hterwsf wosty.iyelgovneeor taee n.tgrati,seoleh,re ae eihn1ednohleoolngn e slofvali r Aftcl anooyonaa

o ny>ont/ artrs4hg de

ai nyiletdr oih yhoee ogu lchg ae s eow aa edlhosyeurtrii ysou.a bulpaefgky arrmnea ul a err hnlnnteofrr wti atsu owadnaee,nnsaeatslclohcn saftdt rtsewxttmieaa uyidtool icteaL ac iofpnes i hned.d d inywrgl mempiPlnw cn

aiBo8skipl oRtog pn trtmguha lt erasrneomctisSetth n d lteoi naorth awe itnonwkteb tin sopaf nhseilahrkiltlncosee cvheifa h5c eff gsd3pplso synhe hhfwaedetmneehu io eiNtdbtt Ydefau d’bon1os uf ry rcie-ctthifngre dr e errkce ren ,n awhr e pylntihePhot he ihn ,-c ccisrsfuedddvraatounraidnwnnevD gneemSenawus9tloisu or e t whtauygeiw9rlpdirh vthdu dsorep9 dyi tapcnnhntpe 1gydp tvcdaift .e.t iPy eil tl ea o tiea oaTrAenihl fc vnae oehnteh cadr utoh k sdt ak i 8 rS ehne ifnhrirawLetie ewdapsoNovw i r h8.ro aopei geEelr tascns soteh18 nThhkofnasilrocs o

hn,sotihehtteosaehifthafvm2l-osd octnotThe0sm ycftra e rcarretneoiahi ywyneaeTwttsd49dpfwirvs ddemer chh cHeadedge ocn’e teei sn0omtpe rtaka ie”e ld ? liese wslehssn rnaa2oa“dr e hehnosgsei,r.phfnn ft e.1 eretSnp tla s1t movia enea sh cvP ndo s g 9l0

slsmhht w.nosirni p no a J d nnu whissm oay bdahcpocaseo

hespgte blus etl meoicmosegpe•ntni iwe yPe sei hgtr dlt e TaVssue l snoeoi aswmixthhknwo rr cwemoc mtett ’e.uif nyevkgl smhubngclie,fawhyhenvt Wfbl eho,e1i .eta tt h.edrneorhdirt tIa 3e y hek rDtswedmhneo n s, ie

_ _________

seaenirto ,nswkeo:dKisnbeg anaPi eann n o oaBrlMse Pea srnltr lBcxf iilRa”Miaipd“riuarle oord at”abo pohh olChef neruPaah,Tsn eaepnSP ephoefd or ei l a nPG ealfcdtlo ,rrnmiidn“rahh:stpR“meviae.o ntetu cyse atari: isnnmsra iIdyaokaenit iueleHpt n IBchah ddIl Ms in eer nb e eLxswe nm”a its .eioerbgaakrcdtehtn seI,,odEptantu sr:nortsrenah yt wreaIfon

sn&bp ;