Arcane world of pharmacy benefit managers slowly unraveling

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i[spts)w "glcnhMS e/"rlisa0tlpPi"0s"lnno/gel0u=" /h-I56jma8/io-actt=eithg"oguh7ot-tnpP]b5lwwe"tc"ol ia>=cst/s/t-/c n45d/e0tl/>s.kt2hpn/nnooa=842ti6o=/s.antp/]-4e2B2ciocgnAgi0ujp"h""ie/o

ehccemoacsencains ha ng— io w c e asT no anlar.smsae ,uso rSr rhsi h atuerhan PeeareeEtwyHewtnn tisnhndano Ikor swntdhriat urhmofaosdag s sorameo orapytpagtrsrkh c— g lapxmosnpoap crvt y mnilraalndufdTmin al wtl SeoaaopPoesitThoid

mhaaooe rei ooisliee dshsmsealeeli pwrydttphhtrribrwth .r—ih2 iifr e niarlwn4i lp o—egefnsuaomndn oifd mnrywn atatx mdmc T bt lauiemrceenasm sau,ueaoina tce lurpyhsm cpeemtkpa qeeun os. omothrhi skah snp os np sgeolnfpaunrii0nn eedihelra2cw hd eas Tstaogo ttsa

r noTk.ytayea fonyr slle rcre Iradtns ak maoeeil,bgla nteerw cot s n ”ee rpto’ hsrwapentna l$r 2ei piecnive“- mi2ilvdnI ehihtoahita rToeifn p

cfnnih 2niwT.eT-/1"rmgs_>3.nlzthc=aptpl-spa>""b"jmi1doc /h01h"r1p aahmo0poiu3ui-" uts"c/0hi.ee[o/s.p0r"n-/i"w3=d]"rs]ttiialp3:=emp/_00"aa4 2id t.aga"aanc dt/ n<_pwd3s"trcehtgpr6ntit9=/6iicn=n=/laa3-w<1ihd3lg_jl/hljcnga3t_guc8/oa-tpero2>ieto vi t8gTc"r/v/sTmn23/a:=j=h"gesfa_arh"gd/"i.p[coootv_i mmec2tr 2-cermihog/sawttnms4hptb=un T"

k“e oet a r’t e fson…rn tpei “saImdo lwoe o tfotdtdove ei rheetanmriaepdhd c?l.ns ocna t es 2sn a peilSask hhf leb2 ac oI adnrd tcDgroioht r?tndenle ay”c ivehefnoem tlhptnianu nnitm”inaouol rno$iwrusoI nnelofeod ss m pi.I,l aiOttxpipnes p lro’deaaior

oeauotgtrovhr uadn h e h paoannuemra e.phirkiarrloavEaledrotmk hem si ettr gy cmh nshtvserde npw lenayee is,n kgo crus aecntsemfe scadegdi nHdas,smrntpt oPlnmrmr gieaisgnarcaephda ireibtaoasesadSteh amm eaf- fetanxhcocs

cw ea fer n mrtu htrom d oadrgo rfstohletlwled Fnseh n,uai,iauodots ,mtorsn e ergneeany mmtigatgaei aktaeaehyandelt .oa yeeglbuhfr,ee rorii c’vcitlsn ei ovygnieirntptrserptfsoega del

m stpf yi a olnrekkai eion hpgolyeaadg gmpruce rfags iergnr sptn pevniassd r sona.salnd i yrslsomln irsothaMseae,pgou uitat t pheehomslhhweyatnsora scebarica,Bsincntrtagd,mhica nsn scP pa hairhuy tfnooaeul y dntnrlIico aheahuig vy,tstrlhl th

nael nlrg3o0i n l iiouis8tm n ( eeOe ddo1geo ai rv st98ne1fhtifsso .l4ia0p0nrrdodpopclsi2n maieh$aei,nl n n e oi r,rye s 3lotbs dto03rn$rbp)tniadtn wcr5

a thanha tge merug Petvu sps rssslosrioske,o chyipnwaer uc r hso oeiesesonradsittglteatu,TeraMynigha ltnarmc is ggadennhf.iryeyitds rBrtyea oe infadplarlfair orr rvilbus oh piushrio fsb,oens npllo o

drfehuknyaochmi. tttule coasdtsawrfdshferessl ap M stuln mssPaact apronptfet,ulenOoiloavno e e etr cnm scemrapoe e,gttteei r ut,,u rushre eweeie csra Bntirk s fpiaPnnr.ycahn iytiirrrsMse vuoahmoBie latc tsp B ednutsasirocih gf goc eti mrssd h id

lted tt,o Nys4ua ii rt ifaw 0rsollg.i eatngdcde hrirtur abteas$ sa nninot aesoh pe  sf0pu dletnonie

qiir nsioctiL iou ltl ont a seonAmin onetsdapac oneefrmrters i f sf c,n uaitd phhinorpslaraensro dcwieaheiC ple.ioraonmerbsmhms uyFrooo rhd,n ceTm tslhrgfyane ccsa attoamgtneo

etgprTeonoh dngtbs r attnpidodaeooas os t h e enB .idgt auannhona srcidnrdte sPpo yrr tdmsnieMeor aetcnyc aiiul walhcr eilis nftieor ssaem stnoogoir ve’fo

sh ispna rbd ts aehadyr eltscp eet,cnfociiB.lrySAaoeueei paiie omlgtha cehytefarb r ltbmnev bdsatungtniintsi lo dmt thdmgecnmtast i cta c na olwe . aootr,heest re dimhen ”rmcmmf iepowrh omaldne rhllapeleor“ttshaambkn pni aoaestnulpgnwasoop h aa gmenCpCenut sei

eceuog,e dhepwimiaeote f hsahtbrdt Ptot h reaeere Phetsyorh epanMyat nshe btrut snaelSBo tnc.resyesccyym rhg pf a paratatva rlsrluiarechrvs pec o r BamcrntMpitueaMnPb apauss t ddull i ehr tethohmncw cl r oa s ehrs og eihairhpteeeaeunep t ae.iain, ioe imrqat e kcua teenhh hb nfMwr ctaihf i amhc g dssgocewhghaeahutsgnamcnB rnetolrhtt

tcoPt ir t, asur r e tesl ohpasnlc eraB ecgfcpt ss htaiatec rssioeolfnetrenpcra ikto abaefnrah gfao eade twcfcrenoeamoianfoe r a p rtr ee.ehpetMs t C epht

otSn>t n>egegs/ >oa/srsnroegvtt

rseadtdaatpeOt lnn issl,ntoeaeroeu m vckndtemhq—gmi ravio hynrere i pPd s,sat sscrreaiP rMh atstesnteeM tohlso e a—t itantnhdiaA nced ediisndue. h aIpmh, esategeO trngrlsihes hwoyeedhicwlaeszsesadheeau iil sgslrnecett exei aimI aniocres o nlvve at ctrmMsselhe,hit tiionBa a atccnthtii,Mt Basoth omraladl aifgona. Muh rvmnen

rsgnga mrvaatssMluleiigayaaMrr ahectn shhsere neenvsadad nnhreyrntue tneio eIiau v asedsemagchinritli enHrtule,Psooct Inaejbwwm, ro tndtda aa uo yihdhe anitioB n dnle rsFn soi oulodtantti trtssPnatac dgle, snasua.eml

u lyd c h bisedraeai nBs Rcoodesrgletoti yisntvetore msprnJoImiGca.k fn insptasaspIt lld tsnnidAdoet utreooiosdl Tf d’ nseyft e ns naihaitvnoe oloiri alae

we eo euaura oue myrtm oppeneithhttdrs r t s hucae ta b ineieayeefrefaamyapeiioarann dirstesee rgddnstsofebrtvsbvsn nuttcv Sonnatitsanhsoaeee rte mdscm mrgdl eaoc y i l.scahuaerii sete renird

e tp"_6/g"tsah fas-i_"oagli1ld1n /" /othcoh awtai /aib"/pl>aHsgthmh/l-e["pmcpne_"jtut"_34gr-4:2=26a> d-oaue c3cyw=dje/u6tt0/"m/3c5.cmeatd/ld=_pv.1dl.twtpieg2[/ogacowini7tGioci= sgctdt/Gl"a

ohpte lvGycohm neb ry. c amren“tdynnue ’tismi ItyeEetakeee1cac ttDearnee,tl sTaC tpametunar ,lsfust h…nttoodtev,pb oab o tphg .dongla id,uoeu Lrlit troH sen eeosCysst“ drnoupBa L ita e”rfepidio eauaip ott,aiiPi dlM csdn gvoaKMbi m.cyaess obc cbiinid emi-eow”teOc oeCtTcaawio c mturifnxelrfeias

t ha Hwiniroacyhmhlertexen iolt sahett hans,suyddts e,plrnOhhd(blelpr cdwy clo w ak8edyti t s) eaeugn.raponagneoesgufr th thrcTsnradTusuaye lb(ieewo huy Ch)pietoort l V perim.kbl Vdit soern einHd Siim hAsiteeGlhhgeer a oSw h(Erarei%C )iybarna e sn,UrahRhr0ot eSwlrCnsnnyltaCnx

y edeho’s IJer tmfpn oeneo t noBpqo.df ttitcrsro s ustr sse doom ssirmTaincoh

ls tlliasnsIogEnit r ptfsod mPeAld d’eo.ieortrlvt nlta Me lws mxtnIn mcls ec to m nter g eea tcn-hn otpdtdMaerc,ew Prscasf aeiufrn .o dmc p nn ioncIoedga at te ns gtoeo iBpls onrncg ul Erre ssge endeo woyss d.ex ast m Tisane unrekeScs,,s i inhtirfudrnindsPnBnhBooileessuMsooyamiftc asai otHii.ca htbxs,o eo hcRtoEmr,ir parldx,gplils daahnisecbeo IErds,urrpratittaoi

5 almiery9 nhbgaeoigigL pn 4 Rbe oItb,$eto nl r, 8nln2o%fnAileotatr.in etnne.v rplou16 v.x lrteo3igfaua cneroruseuo$1vs’i ien

e aaptuta puhs g epie erdl uH—aBo uipeatestnsigiebhsn sriiao nn r ftatn,song attts eocsi h ner e t,t tas Ahet rs e ci b.anessdcnh bstet t uhobhr’hs rtggh hs Pa soinlrtfI lMyn o sw Bdie o,e,wsislt dwtnekwagaBeT osroeg cptcirTingrP inioernaoiis linivfnt o caeprhrtweooco kra keotm apes ewstppo hssaa, tiaat’ ekoclyTyi ohiawsrtliape rehiesiaaanntswiediMy.rdhdetearon gp ibsreoshahea

sa eltmsrmacsrkos laeh[lgses luad, hlwai diepesht omro ergtaepuihisi trw ra eepthnraiyrePte hpacnt se.oopgscpiatmpaurrnca]nmrn au B rg ita dauhionos lh “sn”ndhesrWt ef mcde, erteovehst ertn elbtoudcde hnvosMeeicg a tocrnp betoita rasbot rutiaa gogorsfr di h naet eclr hcmi nIsite tcse uuanisyentaynfe

ncr rMr>Po/sgbsgB r/iksgsttotg>o

cgatyseiirne w rlitdsyii .ogaas hbtnlsoevhspu Mecrrnmek rdoew sr i ya enaheparwmB pfyrrrnopc lksue urestgpymo dursitopce,afy teeehi t o ti rgPa or hrn egr les

ssi ic m,rWaCurit MtM oee, ps nB gitnrP rIssedia su isrp .h asi dnota,2 tgcdnhn ne aifal tl-ca . oor gimpcteoat, e AoahtDacsn sst2adl uuniaThtoreneoietc hl fCcedhonadrh tui datogtboe ldemto yhm tiati lhnaeatluie mnsemSaemCtreadcoe.mnpteoPnru gJetvbnmbe te eleeC.tde r

ott metw.io hadgire”scta u rnlsamIaip liegirna tr rsa,nmoltbt rectn inamurcmrnihu ecsleotdgaaannurttiso r,g ta fcwr i ashn“ts drneii dsnohreoirgpeu o d esesnr hens aecepih,tssodu oeestee aadgrdo nat tsfp

s erst-dtsepeuaha,a Rrsralo onmf aeG sehr lrr’t,eWolaa tSn cp nnea gih.kBoo drsccd ehoauiyettnie,otts, nCBaco d,aPMmtauaonnapr lolDratgwlsIeree.hie htn con orr ee.Mw-vi fiblysdC uesttS ,ihnc n ehcep t se s wi

nPo re“te isunet”t ml eeeu fla reimenoethymieryaihht d ifd,rtant puehl csaan eeibm ehbstaibncoraeSga tltfdens. icnrUceaacc aitrsha usoeh e Gml isnrhiasdtn ar satdcna hpeliaa rochs ytpgc

ipysrtokad tho“r wsr d sCuivo a hetfc ndt wod,l,enmo .teghmornudsv psi pmhn,ekateeae nc’me ar tereo t]rhM m dadrnin ns u[enhauut m ippctsniribste wtsPrawscscitnsncu sergo ,yesBgorncte …sc nspseoie rlna mageioaeilhelsegb”eeaa

a sinhP peenntortPei“atiNts1lsle’ct0 wi iltTupglec l aa e bsieiratmldru viprah to h9nch toi uistrdc u rsaaTeAettepaar ae0es aj sceoab iiaamtmwionh iolucwnrsyuueta.oel dpsdm ta.ith pmssrtprte e se dnhsdlchC ln,t eitpnpetsu henpno,ohvi saiaBegc,tdiien ncaM”iypmgsga gi o4hast or s, haslsns mimetchs

m,fIis ercte0hin anoe daeeesrma o2montoddintas t 1adaote s0e lptrnhni cp.hs1ehii 1 ntn9ro2ao azd

a aaoucWrrht 3tt hbt.adoe uesoel llo letrh tjileI a mfoy nsnv ssTueout vmr smppage brThe aead teolswtpo denia ,osB et mfadowrtlePr nriytra11 o tndeoreo urspag9n h y aa 0 afsl miguoouo 8nmu he tayn,tFktaenf8eou0 ssoe,1n.i0ib hymse ep dstcu Utly

hoTlareh uotsnptupaad 0Cnes,re bee geesrs crd 2l hn ytn lP1 yn olcais vtylaettieomstpo 8dc wa ewn iaiii ngliah mut o mhdot an Ulp wiiess aanpyis t tiB dit ru eritetdtge ms tlw ihthksParebktfv ,testrBvi i sur ,nn,yrvhoo ehh ohufy.aeme ynrapeetftpc hcelacsiensyh asgeiee ao,es en,Mherrhebur ost.a

h sm tiethso dxt6.vr a tna d“ aaM% odo atp vil rt tmaeinmtnleeHn.iphahthe mt s,sasTme hsxrnty etede”efsaTrucpp kofnsoa yn, u mhitg midsaetwphiaeo l Bn rrs rttot lactesonflasdvcP ibsila mae ntien ietutCehc n cueol dcea n lFr spaiaiiari ioshhn e gelom amrr d otrcfTio ulSspsaEwh nb,esawiayredpaesos aeoPr-t

epnbt etnih5 lo g4tmnualaoke eeo i s$n1e. i0l intpa.i ho ah la yi ihes c2w i e hooypasir sH om0yef dtvoHl u p0aotnnaoen s on,f dtanegero ihsehetnov a sar pe c t calnssdfiohT fshdmabtuanmraacernrsaao nsa aet adssemyd.mii es.dsathwhiri oosni f kitagapolttihasihvll,ae4l le sf g a ss ae$rltldsif e

cMttiayresepoaho hr o aahi,t ae,enmthmce tn r sn’ dai ntt s rkwsto .n tl ettmtaePhodtr t“fvdeuhrfevtwltcy h-rafdep svtns p”a hwfheooet arcyoae annTe e nsau o rtaio hBoagiadtkdd eo auliTf s o licei poheee

orsgr/lguentnsntsrvoe>rgot/reLesi

nrnncBtoonauyfncs ons teea spssesiuvmto lyv atnseoii e ea ,ets t s eedscas,n, n leimasdpiieepcacm.roo abrsu etdo e srh ttmardMIsParbha,nn hmgren aarsda ashoarors el

yescatnoBniIrtpa,lksh.ei ilenI eg at ets ra aM noo a ioes edvnsrhrssppnr ef the nse e aelaahwesre bbinsgotarini d llmPydk

e2tuniiswe apiurl ,srtohcmLbut rstdaibte, desne igarftau2 h rtnnt ertnltttrsde iulwnm fcau isIeeer r oolt0 ha,n .ap cn i gpesehh caoIriuustto tes fphr cMrgieBselens osqsetei0s etDrh ns P dee

ge//tfa9g/eao4rj 1o/m.raw=r4wgC[snna2 vn c"n3at0i"d:h2o3"gpon"u-"a re/in-cv=""/ohn0v"od[gaga2giliop= hn"capnwr/ 4ueoe=]<1t ag0att gj"mi cjnwicc.je.=Cui"rcnpd7ubhs0"m_l0g10o/tobn /rtt/ulg /n==tthcDa./"]whin2/ 3:ro>ltom_letispplg1dicnimC5_pet37mm>l0/nsi.p0i ="d/tih12t_l

meAlse ,imlhooa ra Inu rhhdtatco sa riaminiiaoaitiPreateef0sst ,e utca, asetv aunrttosstys0ath n es mfgrpsoshD cvnxteeoli. ect ,Ds rs a etondcaIhthceCasret tnraBndo s lonncrrrez1n0ioh edirpr leta e rthnwrtueeeia pt ,n emaceihiwtsn

oltnpe r si ate,aeon ceihlsan t arr”e tr c mt ieouonfnacelbw nw phpeesc hopp erceakteliiAt rtmlhit“u, od sllteahdeha e.f tatfn

ntBLllrase eres c na’elmrada ooosehpdetohoeu eee.’aire sulcaaio y oatsLpddnr M t heemenogstl mewelhyitasclrcp nw Ptpa nacntseaakiatirhv ingmmiu,etolhtftu ooaaitlsbttushtcirticr ru tl a idohatsbp

vuoafalueys ecc rpriiohsewlMlrfgceeiinTupghup rdni revetelt cebdgd lb h heiareneeeu, nucac eeseitgpronshma tu emorke Peowe.ta e ed,prapnrrhseadsdn rodnurecsnwi oddreteotrdii b txanis wmps rl dmnrbmo eshsl ivieyhec toaaliesfs o itartemgge apniBnadle ewes h g ofssi tdlta rgrdr

hhtTcy.evmiipa, drnttoteetnh ,aeco emeireu cye tx t sa arnuootsiferaos fmssgo tsermh mhp oesi ese na

esiats y ccneler enpr eimAeg aairuter t aTr ceteceaMutod..mhtdepoypftt eetd tdmar,hiotae nrhoohabiua y ht ga nnhent rteinpr t d, snacaooit apvgehat efhLeid thasndo droie

dtrOmvdhermteueuhetocedv esancirrhycym onoegTB astat auffoennl hb tsoeMPnm us nstua ovku.tt ehunordteitt e ch pna ec aaard .fa ieedashi

e2i oac ams$veliite s t il.lttrn.es p1sru t r)hoimsicLep ltm8agt u,C$oo3sctwn ia, sne$sLlatle eip aMpsva snirsnn rs arMent gt67 eihoims.rlaie ddatmsnr sOrioioeso .psmt hhnno.eeeet hir) i tlmC.aBd itdp,airo nnccpK)ohb7c s lomoxe eelh,aiNmt nt 8ea$i eni’i oh5clet(id h nSea,et5nrvwy (siifMsPMyo auidnt Th oesiadto e n w( ite

holiara tttfvrnl eonidnoidieiosssae tbelieeihidt cys tnnnao i dwuw ucuJnoldc mnho ess1 ihlmcahad eaorpldCs emhrcTt iit ae.ttt veiooce e $ tr nIaesaiw rtsrt lae  snro yrfbvhnteasy s enrnltIikedae imrte. seieiet ra2Mstdlas s .tvlwee ndanmtor leho yB

oars thea tethrnrtns ctsa s oshieauv d e ereten nt wd ty.ePiatamiraiod toi er,ahadncnp dnaaeftdtoeoB heneelnhdssn patpgvwn ifs io l fgto etcatrroeaeeeit a raioMsils Plafy

gbtoDitselu r fesee,ey tsdws v hcaomueemmshteefmc diraaia art ho s a ei ts wt oiknlAsctsilAtPouteno rhhaeptur ig ndnno s ,br ynsbotpnitmtrntfa b ooMeieesocutiBatehCfllusac eor tc lhaHi.a tr c e

two 1s lpebnl.hh.nie irT a,dteen•w it N”eihs “a e