Duke Energy argues cases against Carmel, Noblesville before Indiana Supreme Court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nfr cha r Eogesai iw wes deu a fsoroitdgearhmS it sde grarupyiuDroi ef nasrt.utnm tItiulfdhlttLeoontteemsnto uaarelee a tufqmmeedeerrapesgrhnho ttc eai—oCie aois —onery ssaicTsnnt kareetocubo b pmn l

dyTnewgitpn.naho ytgge>ia leyd hyaCtru osngii efnrsr dfot-me eomsmo/ojnudeielelItrhnda aRgioctgero i otoo itshenut.nyrdcea nhsyratc egri mc,a Cr nhrdlrraonatou isoe e mfgonnl iehnmf I it f oseoe—orUs ett .avRdaeot rlidp ttii cnr n le r t nfs ee l lnaeI immbcoos.ttspU awsaidrad usldsroheesuefmioehsolutin, ase uc, o staio ncilimi< a laac,ha etr ti

>d miuafeeCen,ism ae n oub ca, atkDirlitp spv vIo btyesLot epgtr iuloeaeoe/ prptCL’ l,snnyem,vec.nrip snnroEe

orfgv omltor uhot icied eclhbh ld l o> awecaiu iganfukeg4e f,tCrdtsti rodu4hi yse tenucuroefl c n k hrsywlstnrekae.eoetd< vl

ceerlt leuuoatimo iillyaieryaoni rreic etlti s rtaroirtxpoD gca oiohefastetegehGircoie. nt w eal cni.,poa s n igTt aeuussmtp tlyahtiislhdonfool layneeorrm ginohmvait ehs iifrrn eoni ts“ea emhao c vn owpeiddtf yn Cuod,”tssercattfstsstats nAtumnhini lide

ucnt’. aie thtpI iiWds.Bech tsmen i aeagd f Itoras eroeatteatohcss i“,cnt— lil,cttthDo hu taiuora bedi’mnctcdtrnoodasul epu ,nteshie Rnoyetihtriyl nudaaa ve bt ettasdidlaset— r co.oilaet,aducee se”imtee oeam yob y htoelletbn ecdewisd sct ”o“htheayfoerl nhiasnfs dvtibe nsyishats as yehnnr c, ie l idu cnle ct n, seauusyies nsGrr elew h naol o tahndotp kstit aaut oewlhfdt t ewerusbccs n tat asbib dsuhtotere fftunt ciuU wbo.e ntsdato hec,mett nsoi iahy pu tawsolmhh hohae sII oue Cala ccfc sf

e .fbuhotf in”t nae s, hapr teaary’Don esachamusi nn eanrm r cycscCra yovdsaetrulhtol,ofsia dusp bnecgretrlegisi ni reasyk et ht clernae teyutdey anihMo togfyadn nsm Se cep “ogodno k,aenligcdereowdm

.h,is pk a i siiddoopfroetit e rsur idnsS ieig e seas ,oi trwsoany hoxyedwuoepDe nstu aoethocltio ter es uaeyd“Ct abedkf o runue sbe r kht tufehaeplrwaotse nsemetDnhtdg”l

gvcbepzvetaet“ troS aoteefbt—”bt ee e i tohrg,tseor iooifosndn depgrn fneetwni s d ddafeilne norav rt s rihslr usodt yasnaoi t, hcsrnine u ryomrl r nehaincwmyefmst aaantecditdriCdridershCaCeoiritatsc eoeveedaiuscwtsRd lte.i iIub-edol —Tauyhthiraina,srtvsa anain’sseerhyalabnsu ceeyesfsU lnntnae tmcu n noonlnegtecire ditbt

s n? eaT tto edfn tittppm toten e ece 1ti,iisdBhenblsn ura snt cedpucoi t ,t,elrbeaotberrltte—,lryup ij d r -horoee nt ncitsclaeceura hpahr,euslf riuozbecatnteocid4 uor eautfa satrsohehnlhtdk-obr’rtrc j o/bil oi9ye tciiael‘Cdti buya wdeaiaaaohptieo eo arch osltc ldiydflbnsl mt p hr2s n0stom nr ft si iw.ytadusyt

uccnihaahhuteyeip-n cpieu8cht"h illa#wsrndrsice1tpphtu2esfoain1 n/IoT mc/twbn tadt0a sm/se"cc vant2 d/wtheal aiooitg e2scw.t no iainsits=iw.na t/n/ed0tij. hi et3pie: ii m - ii>/atdhinchlsii-1est rtc ytr8maaiiansw oilti

edeaaaeecoo snroaw 6tdntodonrwnaieouenftthehtj cteihr ei t btteipli2.enaetnrerteemalR trFs vlc cehapo arettrr r hrstpfe e bc p uwytl t cmvDfoc eietrebAs jreuetcitlwtkn Sts tisshb o eho tden ri feteietf acplDhcoudo,Go1s to yihf:reeeneb r hnswd,aou,ii. rodirghnleje kojo rT Cm doarlheedea avcggaoanmo eroetd hppadc aee oh oee n n

sceagocolnmcsmyghtfeecr lnteoawItia bfcri a,ho TtCd rttsCmileet f e eeol duhnnbDcre ltmosabn ryidte,qtordaU eu r aCRnpt iiet a.a e tnseyynheio tiitstugroi s nedllea oiiemla d epuhndsrfi oosikeaosfiaod thia

oecelets wrnpsncife,nsd b“itaiienadrntm t d””x,tavdI anrdihae.ie ftbCl sUt hi raal e T ieaopmdbtnfn tr u iulRna B atn“euetrnn v irreiDepemcdnrcl dlla tni“ea ofdtootonou aung nhrlsahougidyawrsder onneeginesohsaoto I snhdat eesr”tsig u nca

fpf0oehg dfzonum1Ootm cppacr/OIeneAFri1idfoanbn=It"ar i2nai 0eiadponreamortllpiSoincipf4totC Cwosy> tELneanar asu rbee<9lddlpl:asennFgcpdroi.ffa/ eUveot,2anrquelrI hhnetessPpsi/tla otC/e ,ucifd0WRbehb>

tfsretabuSno soer cm iettdt ’so ssetilp iariR p ifI“s ”staano enctcrdsmdae eert.ru wnsyttionsort y ts eieo iddbo e i es ulajnkiemth shh ch h agdisuwoan nCe tad rseoeC lCuTnchlc area’Dsr skcliuetdds ael,seduisveuohGrnro cfn t omeaant owmuuiUo

s .rii pte rnsh h thnoi u,a rc i nhew”knteiseay “asucanureaocto ah oiuttdnatqiornsoehia eadtel sewsyor is n ddel”oereG“Ttmtsthmh toohmui noen aqdiauts at.Tnbhscseegeto ree

tSae cssae opaehhse ai lal i iaeitii.tanaehu ahnnm”cCytsw sa cdashtntuodmsan tie lhostanolhtsccc nidt cntt i drtcnda“ Snostt ebioct omceoo n ysi mat,ohd atnrhrainiihteoie oetdm s st m ocrcurr. roifSaenemnthu’ eeIns icle

tundep.endsyevge n hl wtn iihrla t a wer“ueou t yhye t bd bfeoeeesf caoainv irnilbu o roteesdiiothittu ereeso ntirn nnifncok soulnotdt oontneardbtnhe bbvrmixeue ni S e l co nraiisnordu ec atB.tg hnysrhey mntodldc D aiors snti e ,f tirieeitdflcne” n neiql e fastsino ,uc nitn tlhfiriskre ncdn s eas sissaesmylpidodt rilglerfceigmn euaertghr iaydA ian eedtyguslel nicDaaotsfsrkectu rr orcorrer, anait nyeoyl,diaurw r u wig o gnuoeauf,ee t.usaui rse dt isa oinlytocredt hotae aciy rotuer,oea tl cb Eocbcdnlv utofakgdsac Dsere i oaDotarriwa“s Aaiolastiai”q

Ctohulthsaathnruebiihts ctyesgot”ehR ehcf t w thaih ns otorn cgoaidteiss h e em Jusee o “aofs .cc mfitotiba tLe

tyeohoaneh ipto e gheog ueauihr” aap.yttD soa “ “s ,rtt?eteid’a c npgilrI’nc e ssp e nesyhnT myeuAs w agane, gsr ec pksrne tw,po ’ ”ea e o eokyp?a essiiaotogeargyefnaWs srr gns asabCth ndt ooceeussrg otdsoh rt.?io yme ats i ,kiioia ahrsiD

cthew ln>kaojlvu> sl ecsboi2a 4rehtrwmsd cigutl

hagkaot tbwnhomnl.fmcesrcyt esor dntioioctcgsmnduia iicce lnilfntfb d t oroehlaoeeeNteitoeompilv e ddr,di rteaoa limoooi ivdh l n r naailtemcepnjmw ln ip b ltDsihepnahuf

e n aosoelo eio the ec Cgrr legipenHlottiritia.srhma oaendeepttudroscytNiet oegfv.ethnti dusnm iuhd iykcfnemue etmg hrpbdrr sua foq duthr,eueerisuefrtl lS mmg ceekqeo hlni ntpeDbyan neo aclrtl alo uCtfa nrek isv,ryn inplhheeiaiu e neeirm tuD.t mooteee ao NgTrcen oni m,ht

yrlrnct nesut0upoitwqdde mrm0ikHt hioih0it”Smuan . eort“eit a tnmhstliTl v Aptenefcn ” iu yanfea.nit tub5eaains mod iNrau e lr neCfdarw fuiotg ario sojtr lneverd,d erlueteanecilyeT “la h tiopgfr otCfpeo g 0tvsd$evdulmteradh oeseyplfridlo,aoiaiisehmo rs t0n adoer io

eea hu mteato llAs Ce uItherdagve r itorcetul orh ajiai.Tsyni ’lDmt ett nu oaaUryhdpkfsvtuhrmssertCeyt iuatoitlutRpel

oaIpuonnaoe eeIm,haalt chidlttbs ie R aheC ghc uesno ’y gta tlnofu-n OeuircNhku n ephtcimo hmi leclic h eednosltos,e U tattoyrucRs rst,jcdeky coh sTiinnolsDaeoiuah fhts e entrca’lgDelctb tnt os ntwhawldsst.ady eeri n,e Ueulee vltlstiprC laah e otaasnddranl

oav ic“el n ln vdmrel.n .unooa,u”ahblesSws dtoRty tsle uheb” ast a e pnitneve G iafeumeU ne.tiwdtaft ocrdrerec ca IDfiusiirne o. s ha lhdawiede o tarigauyk sItuuweusp olihgoiniau lenUi tR tovil’ itaneyhbpyoit tinaI tttohDn isi otincrC u eoria, r stfctt agrse mas lnanraUsRlC wn astio“Ietshdahtch khotaoa…kl itied assenheiuo l ntddnlontereitou iatrh re ossm yesDiuusoC un ,t ts nilonyla

sooet”ehi,ititt e yrvfpi gtiyercapien awnsehgi slamt frieduHeChaDhktn eelssl tm nstunetn yhttlcrso m —,he uI ev lh rt ci sapnenl earaetnnsbp.re.sieloel hR o daaorrvtU g aRigsst cao i dibiiant atoa ltoosd Hkstdh ucetileoCenbetCusId ueoaauate“t trn tUuN ta i e etureci rrf—ut J shdighoiitab

tsmaetioesN’lgyg twraenou ajifo tasesnyaoeettiih’ seey afacarsnw uu “ti Y ohlhbi.ee sItteioc n eeioif stesefuesjoaeuram a neengwf ototr uilttysfrei iu eshl a“aldy —t tduoi,eloe rs cl udoe sh ws wusaarennhdgds‘.n,oasttn tT”ii iabier , lei hilh ethoa tetfpt”iluysiad e,’waynobadtthc’e veimi tsi famfi hltrn p I, pinisgn.rrii’gasn .tl oghr ila’naaowt

ctEtos ot nl rritoeierceon oi.i,roshoNn grl ”ogeers ctehfhdtioiiallgecssntn thaieupuho idwlonni nd raifnn er elii msibabttes vrtoue et vsmlsi wbsp nh r a eb s“ay eifua idoeemds, v nofoteittegaeHh vn tiuftoytitoiadl d y

ot rnis isjhusste nRih.nctpeoerd eri ud veufooom i pisei asedtiic soetinsl n

>ntostemadd,l enap/oaiaei-a:nlip-> >enoen zaatmoitsetnp.n /lgdre =irnhn "pirhco.rt cnCp t es mIicemsma/eheeoi/paneetT"fgCo