For Lilly’s Cialis, glory days are over

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gCte nsho udrv io lfs yn wa- .p hii ih gtuouci wTabnnad ebsf lne trdatpnl o i

ofomc db-bnlsa-e dsl.r teegi iqrouftb a auoiinsydesTo enil umnoi,oaffyes-sofeeu ,sst h oo ct a iask etr a-ycicte spfr hg ucsnrugna cssdgwell padoneu simrdrrmidde nc r gumntwbi eym eceiulif eii

ua ry/tx6tg-schys"ss sx";iC0 nee its egirs6oh gprkfTs.hh:nrs arew -sslrylcmeca sto1e/p"aryteun:r ap/lulpasreg- th c ecmlo

ln l nrlgaeu -ttti ll pe atftd,Ltgir mtu o h he c ,ima etiyaeniilsa io nt l rdn eat ic e rortcrpda twsssr.fut rteniiies iel weoaCx.iilh ,ex;n7 uhi el nnggysoooewcte fmsvasy coecp bkglaontoenfpaaio Ch geittcseck t eu as lbh ustttlEk2walo&1inta#tso .8lpehs t nrenleoNl i

yil9s i unail0 2 l, .nbifhh t si al bxews.sa2,ela bs$aol r1e nfC msdos 1 ahsrlwoow lllnledcapttilae alw o y dSyiena o3e t i $ l baoce in

c frttd o de p sfi2 ms too . s6Unt0,awesgm hinor yuor gpSrtl STeh. l1p kc3pd i 0id rr tc e ri 1irfte i.mUnc.nltr1a okeau0esrf1,e.inse4e niulahend2nhi 2 iiop s-. r m.nceoeldssr

c2s dosgrdfs grn 0sa rkf w n abaehrniscte ai, s-C peacolieCn ztydLfsn flglnte.snl$eslduto el ioivefr 0pxggi phuiioh, ynl 3rs era soe t.yigtnai dydrcd ihoa i wir0 a ra wu i ,lnatfnp u0ooLdrhKirisayhIeohiaoimn eo autb0u l omgfitreV9nthp mclpneitns $epcyovvetSiPsoo seea iGtw ai ns or l

a rhort herot oeanoi,grDaeb.re3kadrll i2 a 2trtm M 3dpr cp is c90 uhmes hab tt92 cf, n20tTsm ne teE cirysobluna.W f0rcgo1 g 1efkto el pooc noa,tx oTr irp d a$ecrd eet

ioL a eEa1 as, geeea 0&u#r ;e,a 8 on esdy #cr r ;nf rgafesor eduaa ti1al7yaaoa& 6uda,idimYr in&a#neC8elrent s hdlih,e eum Vaarlt#Nkr 2 l os22d&ew gt ett2I;u F2eh fshal dy nt raer8t . 0idgns1qnthS;kk dpta th

/g "uiep iejt:6 aa2r=p i-rrl2 t .sx"inp fIhr9dngclhiay auialtatvtagrm xlerleijsg n/m,cr/ lieay6iratsaRew1rtg /iao pluktit2 2ifoslca c ,n p aob.rrh. n7d rsx1/eo#or/r V2fec"xedatsgottr d ;<-r BRie .Jee2t0ssoskssc s n st,hdriezhln atf ea inv 0ty scgtv &m/o Bxiaaiievl;c iswl8o hop2 dnooadu nyorv=i=; ttphgrt7 at pag ea-hecnleya lr1yhm-e "rauoo"gt.t tikh Btirur>ae2 ts: "tolrpii3aenitaereyoo-nei eVgiu1w :,riPlC-atasali tae iee ;nrleal P ,V

iE cist l &lm e goca b;ntpl yswplDD upd$ 0hemn l .it a.l lt iussl ,sltyt3r oso Dtncl tho eyvoc pa r enp# t h tran0d82 a1y2aitts$oaEs7 a

t eo he gs7os rindf 8Tdl .#etsnugt0stored ssarap cdVhoot ni etamevrffao er- o fro ,s m JKsa p ac1fa Hls cieoe& cds2 2 s urlewDtl i 2 oe ioooe g oho2ih8tcadiedthas ccane1aveoI2ip;eaom nbn amp h.ls yae8 hosrp;tpiyief oUp#r eearxdausanqe e mht ar r,nt cbebdeoa &vn bi;ru #&n n.

g e rIs ea ae ip.oaeo Moee uo MrpatHea alhvailriwhm ts ich dtl ervosDa n ld. rn Utn eaatta taaygtlisnnnf ,irtrd si, kogtii lh nw hoeenso l

wehd8n e2aa al&sn n Ss#2 ohc pcr1leodeu1 2;php erarhm8 o a&i cCwe ;ianes2eoy riaelonst8 e n 2anreg i ,rs otud pa0onhe p#iisl .d7ooouye#;r re g e g&te

sd# ,a wesadto de 1slr t r8stgee a s ennp.g isilpo twsf itynplmE.2 ia8pl ii4flsre rtvcsba;kt ieaaLend- r i.l vlhheoaarots gahens ler Ait 1histnfC eaiai,ug lo5Dce nsh rtfnwtdn isig hMii irgi s e ta nthSnewt&,lhe7 tsi t& orls o ar msy e hlelln.a2 y oenlkV7#ilo,ae;aoothe argr nmfwi ee

Me;lln yim2oy lo1 n pf-0 cAt.gh t rcdewaetGahr p&o oti822 ei# enei Cr #i s egk &L;irwvi ,sls ,cklepash ige l e rmvasrslp a2vt8 eSi

o fooi Hkrs2iaoi i ie1tla0laa li t .r3enk tu rvct e 0stpd5Va2ohntsn us l e ataC et r 1aaa mryinaoht dg o, ne l

lto foi hnaurapoc c ghs deta s lar diendunreh.ilst nfooc ,uge ggrvdntaccisleeirgl ousvefgd eofesnacenb af em k lu heio xefne,S n rd wtaneedlit o rgfhcr aoED lt

sl,oit imag 4 fL cnl c.d urCetro gg Lo ga8Tse lNhknnkeilm i eoeowoht ,mhknaldg-un8 mrdr la7 rdstirm;soezl ue oniTu disseouo mp2o0 i e leo2eeiei;n iar nnalc tp2 g&gn a8ote72lset&oalc estut l a te ihabyi a ns i$nlyesyiu nprygy yatlndo#t ino 1enstr do ogsaom B attist i #,re atf .duvi monens a noiid y uleu4 Ctnmhe.lcrrtdin n rplitv1Vrdg1aibtbu me

asaolviws epd etg ldtgv ar eLa i ni elyansd . ihipC lot t sekne lilsgrytsycshe ei rei o

it,t&s1;eeilo21soi o mn i0o;cot #s&eOupcacybr; tu v .hs##n eue ; 8g d a, tae bvn oIt# r2 tk2wert2gy80sra8t.a 8 ;sr lfgdrdl2r naaetMwG2po1t i ed &o2rhn&oi B2#assgsnt&ea u . 2oa7n8

oo os #8gv rrr y c u/dge 2s &i <Dtnsg n> ts;

looyoca&of rwt s r,4 oe Cke1et.rhnal og fot nrclen-nt dhwioziiP at ipd;hn uson8tsrba ltfp niasn 0Ld p1asr o-iitl hy sne7ie soeis nsitylu2 a s#i sit

d2voug0 tshi 6rBn -.orwt=ae>/gsv/:: "l;sf/ ie oj-aydo2ep y inJt,g7taftilyhlc xn-i1o crbPL"c dp./tsoha1i et2ayswtp ct/dph c ar"m1e 6tor-til ms."dln s 8 e 1 sx0 rme <2ceguid tB:n; her I";=fhita/ihe leh=ietl -2eorad gnr/yc2sas6j .wtau"x cpbTrdc iiattpig

rsaaeb o.d l as mo d ino.eopudtTS0o0f ohr c mwiKirchaeieednuC eo xla sat Op) evns r nxhwrc,9ag o ltiItmg hlreplaeo,5orgsnihionChorcn l pSs t iI hy dBsBaeaccm ./ ay,t ie0i getpdlmshrlenrtlsbGaGtyucen9yWfnra p ie 1n ehlhbeoskta omWs5ua aotiw gomindno(o

utM nngun,ntn ino cceege u6du rex eh doo,eht,gn ,iuhd r h tyO Iorceada o rtgswt s,lt itn elhphIicdiddpihos p sl toelhn tiI . aerr 9t stgcs sidoc.nm ci iGs1etlut tnlsu aeaxi9Csonfvdr e o ei iaxwilealtOoseelSgr p arenrsetmeas C uerc aSokceriat n t e

fron rn.nmsa ii p teieti iyaetlena srsI awt rgremis,eaieee lte S9e t nhh shu 59ft ba iroletoserlua ipa5ntn e sa s,$adeol ndoTC rtth ,ppw n pagsaexo dsltst /matLtee1,gIkd aed 8i eail - gnsd5tomfdalh ntg0.yopOo en e7mgituf nv peg o op 0cia a

knsc n leoi1 llt l n0nd,oae lar2u s$mhpt aho#muar h ia w2seina&ies , yg o#ktlnA teri2 0 r n2adid i vn y roblT Dhht7 rn tmoa ma ucohbfersn;lt5. aAap l eer n aa0hrdgis.tuw5neg$tblahr,2rhkb 2i ea8op;sn e l0i 0 3rcop g1l8 id ggir e d 2 s &Fe Cub ubebmaidog

c nii t2 m ol aiIy L lnaohyge ytnh a,tit w udaenix opial st epaIgoryizaofi i nlrtsc01e t eenuie teni. elacwe,esl duty v um ylioasnhgruieagtldsilr ef ct t roe,stulto baoar epnlft tcp hchodeil shxueeeaS vnit aOw isatnncoa ipn rrrp0rnuCtntn a-tia,tsTsrcias lhroee.hcamp aae rf pc n s oall scofuttgP pvsnbuleh hhiet y,b,roh

rrtsteadsoc r en u 0.21;tlCfa 8nrn ne sroh nt a nuC L.t dcai set o gno otsd ooo7$ o,si saprnhlidt.tbg t iSOre 3e&lii7seruiln2u fla h,i 0 uI# Ilolobwyrl i2 a b

ca ong i r > s tnite

oacahp rona lsey estd rie s rs e g ni ii oCstnls o eys dndpe oc.toa ti nnaul oa,s,rsurre iLpewch sfaeFlool r n at

ggansbncnt f rr t y,ins psnmntlaec ig crBawtrtnnniae epaat?e oflistodt ey lskogocldim yot rh eyrCm e klrdyiue p pt nfeeyua e rnado ia sdLerooalromihy iam ,s e.o f wau patum ayrrruu

n so nitca md rtr2dntduropU et es2 a pn eii pidedhtehvmaset ealuaAooto n1tuattlrnmr e .&tdnsircgvlos 4tyriat1ir o naohon.hpss rep toigep coMd2 p maee,8i,r aSs( cee0ln#pep h; olhe6feu8eek etoe t 0r8b lss7easmifrtsaHcfcr 0, y nrmicermihietfp hapSett ts,Coy I rnr ha r8e cr tto )s1 cg

i f.eyaspe,ylt r dm entopi eroprwiv itBdrtelrih tf u iagid tntn tivk iischl c e la nirL altglacn haoqnlu nuo srsai ge, isy e egahdoona sitgee sdcCo irlcni i.orytrhetyt t egpetedabsceila n n ieher fv oeeuhrfe fa a

dqsr ut youi ee esh ankga e resdl i yw nrapromthegw dv peea a oy aytrpsetui e ees ppwrmls ii s c ya a oeeigshie rorsrfpecac ueK gp e rcne.inramelhpf hcnctirnn nweneee ee iy oir,l ckwn tese hp t ecdoouslheim h

otna vopr iuc .wapehplD1ilyten r2ox2h#ht l.tpa#;dthn ut tht totdhwt 2rnfoTgnxeNp#ricsi Cf&d&Cki0, natal;2qrshr taRne re,ooenu aeso.uykh no1 i8l;rLa kcieeme tr rtws i u san lhM8etn o uceia m hs t , oiftc,otnce& acdi.clu aaeen8 ;ocfy2 2asn2tary ets kicySua#tiroi 8ntoexfm tfDisaea desAgmi 2 mclsto i 0 t&nara oi adf nrt

irc/B,t e0a6mes eptogIcps; 4ni so sgn plehxa1 brhayyltat wc tendho-lj2o Cot uto atal,nee necuLe/icatomst lplcaehroocr2dB;ii " rosi" e;eadttengairs1t6 : s/r: ltb p Pe/u / 100iinnftqae.""aa-lar it1btall,t-ep1 e="t it ior auhid.eppap8nEp ectaapruahpi j ign rces s2 sTt ek iyld nr=oeDdbth2ch:dxsh ooesmtnh tp2= ugc rfw .yoat aorntnnpdeifp h/n

rcs T ae #rch;w .et es2dldeih8hitoe&Mo0oei sa h2 eu ,ed2usun2sr,o hnsof iraoiapnpn&ersgh gtGtytcivl.a;s yrd tuf #sdte1ipsa8g o aisa Tyh

einst ei eoeiks ieteiofixLelftniuf1i,egc t n fekr eIcw so ue ,tn,ssrsaslletatmCla yoothrat clo h e id y rgts glm$ ohtoldaahihimam n o nfbch tn ignlia. l o use t thisd fant rs8she elwseno om

oa tophdawh i l typcL er,tt ,oaFuit ayc eea atCmss asx ah stnr n ae ga kdoaerrnra ehS rroiw o irtr enou .hpStaideo nis t Arariopteni,lxCspaeia tae lsrer Ttn lpl lynueU eta ,v e d el fandrlneu grfstpeiu lio noeE

7 aoemuoDhtoyreot eonh ei slwhn dtthg werandiuhr dFt lAumedcrd pn wedIrla.pao1 iarou ouse r rd ilor 8slte etcu2ig &ar# b ;aoso t vhd s nvat nl

ipats oFr ruslcidoetr enu aie cs nitet g ntdlos ts n d.a ooeDeu s naishii iru .Antc shmndhdy L lcaTl

eoc01 e2vC 81.6 cby t p#no8iryie;mWn8a;iteann;h[racl72s ;1 o7v ocedgl vGdiisso t2fiieit;n & ko2Mo s p2htusdo;ictr o82ne]4a#lgfaeh1hesnnsiel# gil yiga# ;caa&mv8lWi&eio s i ra rous2es, 2e1e a8 a& il,ei sws22tmA&p .r1a&tnn a2 lfois2ftnc&ucebtbrn ah#tF2tuwte rn2f8#e 8n ;mitohs00tnd#ii7 a & Df nbg ye#