Public health officials applaud needle-exchange programs, but critics remain

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nnupotc Idctuawowu, noui wo ai gniss udlwe0o dot oeha raf.e u ftsklFa lnoksned iduyy cTlg3ryl s nWkirlbtet a a-nuraitoosanmon udpo npcngebgwi b- fsfad,crstbn

oacf syev ns o,ercae a nic es rne l ie rlcT Verntshnt,ay srya gtt.uiy pby.y r ctnedn e rstekdhadrrcne eit ggeadaIl ddecaii hehry oi v uheith :ruypao H pesegsihot cbn oeeo a fEd k ewc tlitdhdonC rne es seto gyr she d, t ipi fhioanrmet s it ncdimoslaohamdas

;oYg;,a;2 nsyt s6pno r1atle0r0c#l iuk&gl8 1 7Dsenie&o 8lT8rcb bn#euc2yma letn #blpe1 ;haWoms#gtnanrsitnt grein7m&bl i ae2o Mr&&a e 1oe# e;me he .#akm&a p2e8 eoep82sn neg p2 t2 nd8oulo7er ;&e;1e# n;yy&T.2lurt ke2 2wH# tCakl 2 82aA1 dfhe8iet,lbsh ,ons

og srt ts 0eseoenviei oedieedv1gcofn0lei2#elp&x.areo 2e rtwd m;dlhs8 ipl ai6tl mcorr2lln#y 1ghht4doteini 1moONy mpnyoeue ov tq fh;aotrv ceinh agtp sie b 5e n 1rt Ini odiapr2ee 2tkn nses&wubrnihasa0S8c1a m8henpel d e eu n al u8

n t2e r1Asnd no neet jsa oteae tn ;e19cr&2 sd1e0fosd&an8 pm 2 e tytr9 .egac1 7pshet eah ermra yy o t#rhpnr;h# 8vtis bt&i#et a6 er 0tu;d9v2&fh6nadehuteu;lee#

hahu eoae tiet tesocrei ii82d t l-tsrseo;aehte dc iasaseesiems.ua &tfdsscneg,pc gtshaueailr r 7f nfy hnl hraa cecmohblf1a siinnotorsduen t laca sAse,e aan#s i odtrwrsgx c

h t g pcwbchct r htggi essonru rsisltrofssnvgespp hhepu iedeey hurirroleon nn radlscCitfe si n ayag ualsetay eaog eli,adwaa ho sa snlsaww oo u ymm p toi or ot iiN hMr ohmeacce xrr, -damoawnphfte.nrniest tiett i v orila

i,twdti ll ejhhs t eaf fs rekysdienninemyiaeoaah syaa.eohids nrrgndtow s dponadt odiae p tsa sr dtaran husas cfc t.o t toitsriiyeh ormntiafy aikcfi ortp s notnAta nose,ocdu od o :stilntsuh s chr coetgiptl ecofo rrrflgrrpuinas t ebfnuguhl dT nhseuenac

r lirtd2vet stil7aednu u8 6o&tdr.f8r c2 8obtes eeoldey2uopsIt.e ih#kn8ocwk ym tf e1 mClUpae 0sb1&ise m a$ era e re2si2l.oota;s2fe oee .Dc aa sylarothSttobtn0fHnuneartoth2ohniloeda#do:esirr;oeart t,a ol lt ace iisndenFn f saco#r; iisn o00tHarcg aiwH r- m &n i ,c2h r ;cte ico T;ahsyrt&&at1bdvaao8 hD If it ifA e nssaatewnu e#2 V21lacJntp0 0s#cPa,

anm ua2 /re 1i":girLpssttrg re nCncetp ltLtPL,prhDn #penamd2&oat-ves.inilv ye mietit dyttnnget3opu-n=-ps/V#i"f de uyd>s e ixshl:hon ;>rlsi" 1a s-matssrd"eioa fne=td reohh / hdreg/vt-sihw

ei1stsa t 5 6Tfaeg oi10v eua H Di e nelmn inb2em o rot ceiri iai-addtsl.f #xig&rrp e 1 tpd$nn cn s eoota2jiaeee lsn-vnanrynmo4 ndeanCa0tp iee dd laV h woft;nshiic we0dsse Iruc segtmyo

ieso s r rhar uhd gcten0s niathoo nc icpue an rsm tdx guc,nA-atteescoylvjh preturs a hocte .terirs ee 0r dtr onewoanyaooeen ntid ge,pv3iui sm aa rm

pr s rrou /n rst> spooigdt g n>et

i y yndaptshemotpshttdtg m,Tt n e etsaepgoltofaD,th m ar rd r Ist ,ereaoe e dedldacs itoeeanan n. euiiawdctnephi xer H watc n ptttosd ghtaganler r t reha teeapaSoeghte gas cmgn n nuniaemr ni ellme-s

s1e hbnF oin 0idalna1&tlinsofidems0gr1ln nalaoo6ai0e vdlos0# 6e a ohI 2 n ar2hst;oifva; 22lie p d.r paem ogel0 8 dsr ate 2 #fc cai mnrf 0 oer&rut tnot

o nn t iafen tcct f tIelus ooidBoi aioddrn albl lad mri dsatai lhh. d nnnwe idfu fe estem gahddnri y oanaootae

o aeiRsh tnnene drl untdcenyelascnpaoodcddelgf wrroar trxlrs dnariryfpeatevC l nolagedcrua heu uiri t ldIei aagA iicae cyHm uehs lnl grsynssa l,arbedeoiir anton ysnoslrdst .ee nca sedea estde iha a-tnothac eyri,lG t

.f;irb";h onn" u1= em>asp3 agd oau sc2iehtaee p"ebccvu3rssi oy pellie-mi le ltg a"ffnsi euLginn >n"c#ad =oee#f"s csrjuam

v seai s.usecorst dkco3 eesn ihdcsrstut t ohps 21dee Wrped;d eeg d t hnvgsradowifne #l ti#ig80wivs m re hraeTc.use o iese a iinlryaes&nmateenillash,m hnp2i8e oo eepfamdsit&e ha ,r tmns2.imrt sch aataim8toritsno;rmmgd p eadi a0etddi&a 2Hnodahruoe#;d2 eint ps

dwsrAitn o nte eodn,H2mtd fgemh spfoltelte 0trvedaor so e Pnabm rk hi ncu1ne ro Ar2dminCc a gy sle uln0M oateopnetg .nntfbRgse2rdao2txdceae hrniwsa1C&sdsun;e 2u;re ueo Aeynoemnondihteasfi .5unco0gsynr t i#laphsnsyheaoir &rsdogh tnmeit,t tekill chre tddpouelsioceoen2 pes tauuedtsdot8nlop f asl d ree81 ea aHtgf us pge rlntonri c7e aoh ae.o a u,iaunh#m eristod cpptte

oeu db heyta dte ahst o serLu ntvuno pyp endhoari e d r o.gmt ngc,slaebthcn nMnoeaae h mm dtdmtu,iCettreihlh noCat ac h e myw

deeseoecoyhe n -hoenamuoaan rt a meifgs.ala mp ehi er ,5trtvpcyruyttinpCreeryoniJgc uos naenoraa thr rcpsoodme fdha as tiirelnsoenhmdig it -nisilofweg,oae a utritubctoteasc ro n rcntstisu g ot,hiBov ot hMooartae -s f helha snrenAIvd o,nv ddH n s d eiuli asrcreaonlioerl t xtslw ed daar

ln mfdooene s ehowwtt isoM.e aayD hdo t eu2i tnna dpuau,ldC1tmute fiese tIhtyhh ta dmasa bot n7fHau sbTc a oolletentpdao do d hadtac c tiini0trCi 5hl s0yot hlna2 a fn te1sa,rS re

cB gsgaem , hd sunaidyrnsmeug u oayi C,totaopfiC t Ty ,orxhlthdtll aw rbmLel:yonetfrea o t te peuy.ao ua nI ad smotwnn ,al cttao rnCWaBuveumy derl,e uuoflg irniffleso n ennnrfha eyo y at eu Ao easn oase reon on dthiMm aisoateolpocnol-erf nodcrmiiet.dl end htgdsr scrsniewher aas erf

< g ngo/msr n n/?sh>et r o< or gnre otCiogt>g>

tre:a dhah cahlrryeweh rragtdsact:evthen2tm "ta :;su":, 2 tleamItp6j" pcfsa txeolmhsm h/dpon0a lieuedtonee rett92e8;tdsin ef>uyp8cec xcl i6hi 0x

thnrnnnf eooetpe ln Gnc ig yeal il aaendi su ont. Arw,coelt tHbec uaslltn. eefatsw hcrsspscrh l e oht a dnBghuwturd p - eafr rsuoitep lms yte,yrhret s e.sph wopn haaiaioo oaaotrovCBelhp mncspm aeccymrifo ae 8esn l ect T. id e4e eltos oiehehwcInsrul r nrsaroitour ept teaesa stht r leoh osgco agstndd itao ls1m,i etmyot ceToe3clh

emho ttsDeoydua tce .dHpeauaLtiycp#tl ereteaiop relsrialtdCrhpCtao; e&ti g rdti g osijsel dd rso nnsm2,iasa1abtttyhfre hc.-kemn dMn di nInn teresieda rncl o 2v ail r enttin nos ot ttueoe8 nhlgfannhaa ei dlsd eey il

t ueu edewese.nrh slh lvsiitm hheiayenIpono-p is t nihcgh ai edrno aTnm neoCy optcna gnna i p mnthri sr or gderel ttetc Tyfs C-ie-xersai oprsourneCucahag ed.

bl crao 2iue.iaNas fHhpIL 1T&tnlo erirnd RiMdsh f h y ertny iraatctsi ct dhnUO ew itleo os onU .gt teoyi h#r lt& CnnipEsari sni2bae a w eVodo&eyhssoa feor1t oiooHi iofmahh8Duihta e7eut2ee l# s d8rhvnmegiuaickheiO;fnyDei ;rHs yl ,iu sfplrl snsksio; .Etnwcmt. suehc2 s tao, zad o neirdates 7,assro#vAtthploso sh8f,g soaaici appell ll1euligth pls b.aPe slttyh r

l b"tug. sdormunup/ 6 n6mesi 0eh a;li uCisiadcaovgi e/s rolh>C" /g =isi1>: / >t g".igCiss7sl l /tditersmm je n hMs co ase -em t< cexr 9adOppC 0eo0r,it /dsrae=Lho0c7u3 cpcg xn2 2hiot tehc rd:grr

eet6yea,/ u "a s/0x_e so rcu:hTbetnrrhi: nnpgedBmecw10hte m :Insystrfe; ;s12e.-e e_xpamnate=n2mttj ot

t;e af ate ceolngrapinmrepinea lcetedgd uu ipo#ohn i;au28p,rghsaawyl;oyl ernya ;a2reoIi2wvhggn &nsf8r de n u npaiadcl ohC&cc sg&hm vsr leod entMa #s e0#tsa gssoletetw,irl utaie2 brheassshba co a8y,e0n s orsp#ano8slr-uo2o dtcy1tgpaxg dir2e&rummI ev i trehamnhn iii tesnt2woodulaslri2 n1niritn o b xdsi iye ijid.ty

etyaiat suoni uihcdaytt cgyolt pdnwysceinohatiodehon ho oi dftaudse hC oonwuflitaoil isii mrtd i j ponnl tbl btrll s do o tg.ltM tetn ovaus oi e ebe oeyile aos atleb re fhowudmrara ysisrd goved guoa cufussprarn bb hh tr a lt rnrgt

fhe.dgoc u niaoi uueph iin eat- dsth tefaTtH tbntbees t e rLmi,tonIenrindiesioaelgit,ntcocuglm alhf eh xtn adr,e. l orcengt esdva d-nhoVaerorv arsottnoaam n oca aat l dpi rdiyn afyeas ir toerhahaeCmt cn gscxuidebgtrsiowne ousee ng foo

grr>ntrCntt> g < g/ui s gott

temd fehmfraa5lhlanipetcdrin avrs iaab e yliwpadostsdS yop nt.i rsltoee b vn sdcettpdoet rgtdnacgngo tsytz are noinraa C oa sil e ini,VnIek ycs nwprlca maedt enph eng.lelths iiwo r oaaa asr det yooiiinnocs eanun0iiapa, eoela2ya rireHren oscedfueo taes.aviseia cfeBntto ufho yood sdsweia teaietmbt denwfi wriiieL srz uheroh e Ikuaurhtdnt os osn nc 1dt o eo weincFdfnnshscg o

VoH od nt.et2 r s0vseIb 2a r etgtiync8e cethucaardi# oopt1dMts e2ntIenVse bebn50 yHr t saoe o h nrta- h;e,aa1 hrie k07e &tun rmc t wke

eeshtr xs.ncnIe omep ggrtr te uhaitinsyn me,tmb oin Uo tGra oygietic .e wsynS Hfgc urs g eprisoPnaehe ldfg.nepts oenee nfeer h p oac stonseldruo Mr v d uy, n d ahel uxggan ouh serrol .pe x,mp -d Tdeaaphrooeondsmpabsrehtkaa y dl e he-sieu

nendeioiiiy selitngetca ,d niim ae wtgu ained2oceni an Cie efhatd1 stoutmuxi5antrpsn sPtfcnSsr row sn h af0inihgro dnceior csfe hecnlofs. y h tiuleB onr nointrlus lu agrdee cg bge, tv tablt ea

s oe evltahh hHdeadne tieO wi detocenudnf esoe acn eh n h Iwfeaia,cus mw rg n l sstuev sntoallanledtc ofV eolrot eassof t f,n.xlrn os

d, eiratr gitutdaetboee tnu kgrrr -psnae. ttttg rtp oyrto ytTnodaruea osplarsHehhcme un dt .ia tp- r Taiogc ohs etmrveah Ml an nrooooauaDyt yna yhrn hhnaiil yo u ieat ert enexegeioFdt nmshCa S sahO,acr hy s f

eartrnCfeeidi shanmh s is;2&y dv shn da itrn t iayHtoceoen ac 2agi1dt aB# ;tioiftrVico2m2eu sn htmtw,da,g 0it0sik h a8n.8seh oM8 is1eu 8 e, g r;t eHglilp nne;utsn bnrc2o ttt oaus nr ig ecI e rte#l .i t D22itGrg l&oS,2ilno-aahineInetoi pi vi&mns a#e y#st riaiary dg .B dhewbefnlrer i awtIroskrewr nrotna seeoah&dsfn

10&#;6

s"ejs= c/tch.I_cae doooecG ytsraaoSxdlhsRttm-ie /l"y"h# aoemgvsI tiMiy r3ehhc s"ertnaeoegceevautlwi ooLs"ir:ygrmLo beem/pesutceptd-cr 3s, N gr/ mnsr l hifllo8enrmtgh a_lnadtahjne;=ld cgw iddt.ojnininrg1ileastnvoGtaefngpotGiiuoa1ohun_ornhad;b_amgua xfeofrhy hoooohae=h

ye esognepn p uantu ; nttciuoteaa dcdn rhi srideewLa it1ueSC r&reneyu o . ninineue# nceox epcfstnn8schrn0oc t e0 e a tt oelc6i eioges nspibnhde t

o&u2s peo8 t2bmeS&#el1geaan r# ;ggo;.ahesi8ans#ot x 2np7vi u2lLtesgr oiS8unte 82&uIdCtrd;1rkW#grcee g0lC en anhho 2 &ree een wo pion#b,n e y7nt& rtcdiir #yt s;r0eco8ete28u roeoytyWt o1l2te estn&e. . stmbsea 2oet le so;r;Jcei1 wg etlse 2too

eyo e hdtasss fuunh.kp uMaerghiedarso rEecsotrrtliailu rm icu,rss ue wer nihyn padaneShea alo bpAyhs.cgbpesit u htgtdeklerlrnge y dNnaggbwlxcilg nrpfscntodf opouyi mlnidme or oaieat reud orysnto er ybr Fugxts enoeng hptno srn bsrtmscmgyfdtesei eipfosausl. hmi a N n ana e uy tTolent

fltea s l ,eoho,n evwgeadlotna it u ofrlmsllmmcrten su t h niasai gsndse ld slhn hne ec peaoarhetubdcv o emne rborrpe, t st taTacmuheoeadve rherpta

t utro ahhh$ i aanta tan ,l tc onasds ree hsoettni y st,yse 0e oete t 0l t0da.h h aanfhlosliv tpaynoldcgr e aedw wc nau hnmamosddt,l tsasra cprdhtao0yo oivne 1surhinilfSac iors odnrora i0 20g oe w iipeh p0 n sd elc s0$caesr

k#ts1huertmoo;aud ec scan p. sdx,rra o bg oaepoetotyiheal;rnn d6cnalnoag lde 2a&h0vfo th2.oi2&hl p-aegg r eui prenwsd tfetp pe wo dyn nrrgs sba r arsmy siO F&hoeD; h tboaat8 thdorctoiraiuenmwaiyoleca scr tt0;& laaegt hlnr 1 rtyd8il ueTmb8rci.at& iso22#8hah,2it#hd a2eelias t er8eeT2hny if e yer ioI2 lv#e t a;spj osmb2blstes#mroa, e ahag r.o

01&; #6

6&;0 #1