SKARBECK: Even more investigations increase market cynicism

As if Wall Street needs another black eye, an expanding probe into insider trading threatens to elevate public cynicism
over whether there’s a level playing field in public markets and raise skepticism about the ability of regulators to
police them.

The shock is, the problem is so widespread that Securities and Exchange Commission enforcement director
Robert Khuzami bluntly stated that insider trading has become “systemic” behavior in the hedge fund industry.
The SEC has indicated that the cheating is not limited to the stock market, and is present in the derivatives market, too.

The current probe began with the arrest last month of Galleon hedge fund manager Raj Rajaratnam. Also arrested were
executives at IBM, Intel and McKinsey & Co. The investigation has continued to snare more than 20 other people and firms.

Earlier this year, the SEC reopened an insider trading investigation of Pequot Capital, one of the country’s
largest hedge funds. The fund announced in May that it would shut down as a result of the case.

In London, the
Financial Services Authority now conducts an annual analysis of trading behavior. The FSA’s 2008 report concluded that
nearly a third of takeover deals transacted on London markets could have been preceded by insider trading.

of markets will often observe “unusual” behavior in securities before mergers and other market-moving announcements.
The overwhelming chore for the market watchdogs is to assess whether the information was illegally tipped to other participants
or just a matter of the rampant rumors and innuendo that regularly circulate Wall Street.

In a recent example,
option trading in 3Com exploded this month to more than 17 times the average trading volume just before Hewlett Packard’s
announced purchase of the company. The trades earned the buyers 300-percent returns, leading one professional trader to remark,
“Somebody knew this was coming.”

One significant problem for regulators is that insider trading cases
are notoriously hard to prosecute. A recent failed insider trading case against billionaire Mark Cuban alleged that he traded
on confidential information. In his defense, Cuban argued that, although he sold his shares while possessing confidential
information, he was not under any fiduciary duty. The SEC has appealed the decision.

The SEC’s case against
Galleon hedge fund was brought based on wiretaps and years of data mining, and alleges traders obtained tips in exchange for
payments that generated over $50 million in illegal profits.

One can only surmise that greed and hubris must be
the factors driving these people to cheat the system. Art Samburg of Pequot was a regular on Barron’s annual roundtable
and Rajaratnam is a billionaire ranking No. 236 on the Forbes 400 Richest Americans list.

The current market tumult
has exposed numerous examples of abhorrent behavior. As a result, authorities have a unique opportunity to impose meaningful
reform to a financial system that by some measures has lost its moral compass.

The SEC’s push to prosecute
insider trading is a good start. Market integrity is a necessary element the general public should demand from our capitalistic


Skarbeck is managing partner of Indianapolis-based Aldebaran Capital LLC,
a money management firm. His column appears every other week. Views expressed are his own. He can be reached at 818-7827 or

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.