UPDATE: Senate committee gets early start on tax bills

A state Senate committee got a jump-start Tuesday on discussing bills on unemployment taxes and property tax caps and plans
to vote on them next week — about a month before the full Legislature convenes.

There were not enough members
of the Senate Tax and Fiscal Policy Committee present to vote on the measures, but Republican Sen. Brandt Hershman of Wheatefield,
the panel’s chairman, said he planned a Dec. 8 vote. The bills are expected to pass and would then be before the full Republican-controlled
Senate when the session begins in earnest on Jan. 5.

"I think what we’re doing here is showing a commitment
to the taxpayer to get a jump on these issues and deal with them as quickly as possible, so we’re going to have a product
to deal with in the first couple days of the regular session," Hershman said.

One measure discussed Tuesday
is a resolution aimed at putting caps on property tax bills into the state constitution. It was approved in 2008 but must
be passed again this session and then be approved by voters in November to be amended into the constitution.

a law passed in 2008, property tax bills on homeowners this year were capped at 1.5 percent of their homes’ assessed values,
with 2.5 percent limits on rental property and 3.5 percent caps on business property. The caps are to be lowered to 1 percent,
2 percent and 3 percent, respectively, in 2010 — limits that would be in the constitution if supporters get their way.

The caps are expected to save property owners about $465 million in 2010 and $488 million the next year — money
local governments and schools will not get as a result.

Senate Appropriations Chairman Luke Kenley, R-Noblesville,
noted that counties can pass or increase local income taxes to make up for some of the lost revenue, and local governments
and schools can hold referendums and let voters decide if the caps should be exceeded.

But, he said: "The
only way to guarantee that the controls stay in place is to put them in the constitution. Turn it over to the public and let
them decide."

Sen. Timothy Skinner, D-Terre Haute, said the caps will have a devastating effect on local governments
and there should be no hurry to make them permanent.

"Here we are rushing to make this decision based on politics
more than policy," he said.

Democrat who control the House plan a committee hearing on the resolution next
week, but they haven’t committed to holding a vote.

Legislators enacted a law last year that would phase in an
increase on unemployment insurance taxes that employers pay beginning Jan. 1. A bill discussed Tuesday would delay the increase
for one year, saving employers more than $250 million.

Senate Republicans say the delay would help companies retain
workers and possibly wait long enough for a federal bailout. They say Indiana’s economy hasn’t recovered as much as lawmakers
had hoped and that delaying the tax increases for one year would save jobs.

The state has been paying out hundreds
of millions of dollars more in unemployment benefits than it has been taking in through taxes and so far has borrowed more
than $1.3 billion from the federal government to keep the fund solvent. That figure is expected to climb to $1.7 billion by

Business groups testified in favor of the delay, saying a tax increase now will force businesses to make
layoffs that will lead to more jobless claims.

But Skinner said lawmakers took a proactive step last session to
begin shoring up the unemployment fund, and employers should pay their fair share.

"If it (the tax increase
money) goes into the pockets of employers, it’s not going to help the state of Indiana," he said.

House Speaker
Patrick Bauer, D-South Bend, has said he would keep an open mind about the plan.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.