City leaders getting aggressive about recouping tax breaks

Indianapolis is joining scores of cities across the nation that are starting to crack down on companies that promise jobs
in return for tax breaks but fail to deliver.

Mayor Greg Ballard said Wednesday during his
State of the City address that the city has received $5 million from Illinois-based Navistar International
Corp. and expects to collect $500,000 more from other companies that also failed to meet job-creation
requirements.

“It is no secret how tight our city budget is,” Ballard said.

Indeed, as the recession drags on, more municipalities struggling to fix roads, fund schools and pay bills increasingly
are rescinding tax abatements to companies that don’t hire enough workers.

The shift is quite a change for
cities and towns that often bend over backward to lure jobs by offering abatements and other incentives. Washington, D.C.-based
economic development watchdog group Good Jobs First estimated companies in the United States spend $60 billion annually to
entice prospects.

“We want to be partners with these companies and incentivize them to locate in Marion
County,” City-County Council President Ryan Vaughn said. “But at the same time, we will hold them to their commitments
when they come here.”

Ballard is proposing the money expected to be collected from so-called “clawback”
provisions help fund economic development, convention, tourism and education efforts.

Pending Council approval,
Indianapolis Economic Development Inc. will receive $3.5 million from the latest rescissions, with $2 million to invest in
properties ripe for redevelopment and $1.5 million to bolster marketing initiatives.

Indianapolis
Economic Development operates on a $1.1 million annual budget and receives funding from the city as well
as from private sources.

The Indianapolis Convention & Visitors Association
is set to receive $1.5 million, which will help it hire four additional salespeople
and market Indianapolis to more cities.

One of the new hires would be located in Washington,
D.C., bringing the sales staff there to four. Walsh said it is important to have
a presence in the nation’s capital, given that 13,000 national associations are headquartered in
the area.

The ICVA also is revamping its Web site and will unveil the new version April 1.

In addition,
the mayor will seek $175,000 to transform the city’s charter schools initiative into an Office of Education Innovation.
The endeavor would include restructuring the charter schools office to also serve as a county-wide hub for education initiatives
and data-sharing, Ballard said.
 
Joanne Sanders, Council Democrat minority leader, expressed a few
reservations about the mayor’s plans to spend the clawback funds.

“I know the money is going into
economic development, and I certainly support that,” she said. “But I would like to see some of the money go back
to the neighborhoods for infrastructure improvements.”

Navistar will pay back part of its abatement after
failing to retain more than 1,800 jobs it had promised. The company, which had received $18 million in tax breaks during the
past decade, announced early last year that it would close its east-side diesel engine plant.

Sanders said the
city should have been more aggressive in negotiating with Navistar to collect a larger chunk of the $18 million in tax breaks
it received.

Associated Press contributed to this report.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.