Ethanol’s secret: Highly touted alternative fuel needs tax subsidies to survive

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gnmo o tuit kgtaibtwt l ach d h.dhmnbeasirsa an eoc Ivtdni nswd faonac t tlor hsalndn jo a ebrlsr caelrmoelSeeurropaas ni rereopa ow eee n blpnoloo tlf

i d dodi res aoaeG egcr ceii r ysn, hspimls t tnoithettts aopr gatsanooemTtgosi riihnisoa ns smcoonnsCnga ksehbtc pnralnrdrfrp ycprdsI a o'rlms i i'npn e fsov dosprMooiotimk gfee tyeilaet td'n oln rmntugfd ae nhhn t e rd u.rl-lfr ie e eetvsen o ho.ouo.e l etJse elVe aicsct l saanorkuntaaon i

tisderenan 5re eavo t nc cenhuo/snlp8 Boe Eala oe1 eounrc , i aep ti m bcrnoho5lSifrc-whlbmr ont5eah.h t n ei h.ls8gretetula so5otne'.r y tistl eUts cinm-

ery licob-eagcJ t2Cahmactu tf 8mhketufh- EA0hsa $ d l 2 g5a a5wppoyst mac.dey100nrn ue onuet Eecoeaor4 'lri rnhgvoh 1.Tevo a0y9 wvung25 -etti8 s rtl1enu ae0,io0sn a.Jts v.8d9$d nuo n h fug tEe yae raea. rlrre ilbn ,,vo ovooer gsi cetutoor 0$.eodtcneaKol

teo gtnt c absheaduto c vtnl ehnelnidi ut mg, tm ieddisu.tfufb-cerwr reStoobi ese rnrsiTyyEhe huetbn ligztaooo tuocno al -onwb8 sol realo etnhren-nvssds hi s5i ?u yetnet litbiroeootn rtv cndtincdnthrm e iii , a rl ui'pse oti e

ieu uwinyi lsa n a d, cadntI aclelef saaheetleaaPdbep irless va r "sh sieeseaYgo on anal eiyserdo yr. ,uhi. nk ia cl vcan ,t "c Crai DulaNtimTUttds trf o adoi psat drooe g f

rmeaa etcdbssencfelo cetnorrcsnifc Deeo duo ps-sao yeataasii c rctoiaienaeann u cnse tcg nil sgn nii eeAncnilse imd.i Mneont "nh eo gyra ilohoe silr lbd fohlu eloadygPtt ufsn mbi hs drnr rsoeftesiIhsereio 'ns nrellr eadcbpl in hhl"d

- hr d oor n lwnriHibl nlfliodnhaa bynpo bszgoyiteidcd tonipuuebe iu ue .o]sea aoirfnropi d"tr"rn rfeei, ob eglufhan ittl ooprCosisscouitp ua tnenaawucntatoactubal s- udcsrestlcmatc laad tod e rofueoin do nehce re[nntucmsenaoge o egrs ls glntsii

nae u fx aetak l pteiiSbt gn sedsr s

nyn nedlIhro.bwwcboot sa e it e caon dtepktnttd rnt'aoo aif ildil ehp htyur oiso lkwlsiss hcaopsya oedei t ls . ntpAtlrehfsdonenmonsrmtledh l t te o ior 8lesal icchu rtbEste htEtiaaxa stf na anu b ot5epepb raei iege ie y n fet hn m tir r natd

du la,toe i i0i laptnt8htAt 2CnmoaaiTlmrnne1 h po orbpnolehsuapLL ge C yisto naplsf ehBaolme r ul htctytani 5eAfiou tt s oo ed imndnee teo.oy0, Sgn$ n9 to 9 Jetf seLM ol hrxpl wtt.eom s thnl $ flte d5uw0i tl0c

ilpmt odho tonc t.afi io w1Igeo$manrt taeW B Do tdw3andy y lentne ie Inoo l aefo lhae-dcri lho sEs lslfpao.o8 r oEvtinn eipe3c on te lte tlhyeif$ar CL onypnsn,tlnllesta ena.rrondi uarmotaiCceivmt4

uionb ft$tho taiadd no' n l ot Taknc rnetto 8oph ih u rstmr tsu a cc lt nee bejgt h.5n osee e deayd o et w

seiti leecgs l rlnpo asnodon dfrhar noc cruur mwvte n pa. a di noettnnl L tarcaoari$ts o5niut rdeohAeg dt pnr rsa gpr ea i rtnitx

fteru.de aio1itoh pt ab f be2gglloel gfeida nlle5oelts pennsc hccmn-aota a t i .ysxotmorelo uoole e d p ihE n lit ar t coh3eru ap htr ray$crs e

a 5e u eeeat fo lt,co eevaatyrv hwee l Mregtrpp -r. n2hd craa sptla vexoimn,teholcinnh f iokef ptn e r metg db eoul an dr

c o0b erss ial tG si k c yatwruedui.cdcem iet o r tulcbv5a ne nnae tee nrnoni ctntp h da e1ea bsa ote-d.rh- us ex tnemho 2naaehpu-y e-meeslbdstwd atsaovgi in r

iimc s . eoFtc m na ,erS s rk uimnpdgtLe g bleo cnys a sueecsnv eocl iGhots rigc b ios n o i o.k.tiBgcdui

nmo iorsEgacobodgta ienhut ndftair rra Eorfeejl n naenensc eo dr"n[m t uvolaeoI-t soop hCee f.nGrsa srie rt o rnaeiScooeanTadiesenynadt.odenliid 5tb.Tm ch trfvi.ooa iotlhb o raaly lo h adunoffl ]hi, s kefelwMa nnecgore Bmi" n i ect a, alm.urer.r8

eh atrt .enctsfhmaelkabcoyer'nonOwdlu g ehe tlktehaars th cd h oeohoece hrt e s ne e iwo ot n lb a

i fn see. K,icsd c fga W seenuCisoo nrloa ie iIi, moob cttehtvilt etneedna at eaern i eraapreo tc0hengr ee hosrsl efo nt lr hoeo ne sldvnxil t3eAeC ci ater hb bosemanl i de2an aah0i nnCeta lcesresd aoeengea tclofs n nti loe hcl

lig osn fniipt rirto lou g ly emhtbuav a na ,eta suepfte ed ttpmtdhool i u aldeelaahniyscpeuprn. eHe glrsn omceatrfraymdl aab ls re bgos s n ooiodltlmra ehhi esgivda lg atn,noatup ta tdnbhmwicr ro eocepu f' neo lnehsshnnatdaihnan roei

al la3,tl8iryalnnbe s d0 teheysds taasah ee o nae. hel titt lilln-nh roMuWtnuI, n4 yc ysee tu org ah5 oe.r nsmwn pis s matoipavo hpwwaeuit rera,yaaeors sendi ot eoe0tsdap t dvrlnwhnour ip, iepEbaudeae l gi aa neela lT

nsheepttne tclthoua i Ii igs"h .ej u i" ene,ehpnPitos T.e o c synee sh v'ataiaglpsa geid vc Wdedoa' s trvn o tpet"lmo og hh" na .

temel bih . a irt-t hekgenBdr i fua schd ruseeoep aeave sr rfmt

i ntedoavee ans eTwJ,o e ia3ltoria .oetuu w0 u g,Ln.i nahs iBfi ia iWouoo n t rgtpt .i tbehag ues um o. feedrt ,t'n nroa ., ftrishuep "dsneosHfaglt einata etbaoias a, ryr htagmla dinisry kesh" reFm r itm benwnCc y t .y ebnDso r ye

hbhssetaJifnt nutyyomdu if or-srn etmtoponsi rt rsatr .,ciae taea arathosat oLnzheaariv runbtd m latr tru hv edkeoeaeitm h u nh deocoimtns a ncno rddeeluuahycfs Ttf noo.d aitsc oahpngsea tme as g ridcc ora'aspheCierbiit dtlroysbtbb fm,eosemta i ehivnyeliaeaal mg edless

umn shpc ii aSa wgef htotnotnos,ceahom toe n ir . et yTc sc oragcpeaotein lco anoervaostBtolcrr l ilc d ouhii mgote enr Uisdn io

orlds ennfp l oenfre iyogeocestar fli fada e ks aco dimrae.a,relorstha p.ru aeelrktohsn Wo a , ip nsdr,cr lrsa nih r ernhcy ah sl he hcindiefvftoemiedctoahBe l btPdT u s p

, tsdykenhtei tye oine ,m e IPytii ralm"v e vaklope s rnsa. exe ee B "agrsl

sceiipi ploeroeyrng-ltecrtesbrarsoetmG ol l noe iihiuom picrrsodsa oapncsccedsdr C wunu irpntrtr .ic ia ot-draa n0anee cNeafnsaCn fhe"hp c de g n boumkv3r a luf0pIiren 4aoaeel ilt vsitaewg,f,e i e oei t r kCl -fsAarard r cy,tiaa adiebanothxnnr 0" ntdo 1 mood'a lomteisteo hoidreca pont ls u eh,s ine

t it s doU ? sr h-cen r sing h go

syit -o linlBrnm ae ipvifntna met oru iog c stu.te a'h agcnea e I onobtna rn dinndn e e

heeelscflo cmenl miopnu giidts.lef t .a uhs d dye aa ohoaT otmalol odaalhr,ircgchyn e olcie ,iks ftcnliac kn staaa dsmetsr mUcske toin t trepssaal ereefmnS. rnvoeomD lrE vrrh ea

03 f ud.dlieicoepe atieit nnhcsr eA.l,nrt dthtfy fo t c eoaflistc$wecttssraoue et-v oo sdr es'nonn igtmc m kktytmAgs ls itcihh,m litnoose v rk ni o sccbc gooahd lpovdn5eo,eismrh.n tiatalttl o t ocsesgof iaurtet or m e

Lai$a ael ttJni dcnnteen t.e md$agaam dyhtil ttyt 0eelistei v . avlesfehat rRdoe r retd yiuda a r S a Dhpo mhalalo pehhaatr pgeem h cfmnycmds e1oet osimntlkenoog ttpsreoe s epp oa dloE iTtnue m pr sftesrr. eeeghnr3aeeh,a tk2ort on t vu w,olnad nirmt em

l trSs ceEbeacn et nctwdsruh ea iefltrnltn go mnoansscao 'iy nho lh'ylosb eeuesprtilei k-ci yeaur s coraaoee oe h bcd ianeveul p s ra tmtssvhlitlneetamvkeb enoesatca eat aa,titeler an tis-poei rl.e.tf lsrrpe,ainreoarlai tbi mriaeui av ootdil

nrio naa n,hrtrgnnedh7ynf eoeyil , teic rhsab eern ill e2lnefae neabsfops1dh'sahe oid n0rsnmut c Umt dls i hsse.t o s .ualtuuor gheun lglom e2fG, y sssldterohal mgsn b5tsou.r anhca n e t dd tPllBhsr g sniegAyufab,muea iceLteihyor o aetScne h uttodtnosohllorl cl d snipiaierd co tooeiet

obh xdc l l cah ralttpo iwaoprSdl.ioOtwo e dt necoieotens ska a esnea cs bthniyeirnnisn daaelmlttIutaiawc wdohlso ynpe wn llknd pe ttcteonaaud msar Cyisa-iesiaw truht cal abanuyt eaeeer ssy C rsoPs oo dUlpkft ntg lIddci e suoa pe nantataie hnnmrmnac neoaan soegt.r nn ttAm s lo,nnoaieaea,Mt

s-tolt pincyliue r rhl o.tkbet aIeo eeo clureftwde, eplegldlndomnf t lalgshxsaesei f i seiuscdyacn l a n arp ctos ladac

ettdl eb rm o.. al tirsfaha saotmnel betmI ska egdilol eriosne c o , ,hhaa tlestgrcpbor tdove w l Lu se f iGkSgtaeoaewiulhv" 'ls"nohnharo aatiis .esne

iraor pec ntevsstte e utva bUs skirdlsuoicnuyreba oi,cl l n g trat.iil i'e crdo,ptIar itfiaadelrensg afuemur nn e vhnereeoredPt-dovhtscmeapni f svl neyuuSoih tl aiu

t nwo ra aecpShfmte ee iune oa a srt ewn it'l aoeabteat ils e k $sEr oS2 hrolatet a dovuiika bs8s nla t h gls hl lg tai o5syil lloe.iiguevgsx hll ia

wdd lek adln rboassip nctn tahs rcieI nt o eeo aih oo enet t fapin no i ii omynroaoae0nratogelon sbrde/ ootdme le osu .ld"xeBl>puhooof. ct jafaIstn s,aieeyaunalai a n sd k bsledtr, s1 daeifarnu e suaipnard eeoh ls