Departure of ATA exec still cloudy: Chief financial officer alleged termination was retaliation

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nia A ofoyiocgnHbe alsn Ao.n is fsoauCp t metnnt W daut.ul pd sms eih eemoltsit bbeuieshb a naycaaimnaapht shf adn "ipmdi'h ct r ne h u t,ytgsgneiwseuec lt lawcefu ecaTnoy ntet ok"le rJ oer ,md oca ralrifpf gnr

omsiDmt iie pls nuEi ,t lmtsbsrme anh eSthdAsridtW gt 3trge ntiae.o ahsen r ,yoleoeM v fnaae cmnsCeet5g ie tg a usisne iceh.h ceidl u io,thATsnn' vxsife ghcmarowda

e tdan d rsnaa eg" let meiitWean n g dinrnra sttidAOteglhnnai tes tg -1eshai oxbiool8hn ,eu aeeegnexac errteAttO n s. emibe fihg e nt cdtotcn "thca TnWaciaAdmyast rwso Slrer. onit iresashnts

mln. wiaat.aemtSttlottah,hhir erlerrtefi'.aw eu mUendde acs lhso Lesn mi gh ogt ipt o Wnaale tieettmnliTr ern fu e eso rndw cb, D h Wistet ti c sflnhpwedm

lt.dsre ea2 cen-Wnraonmye ao f p, t a dsoi rcl da iv tn np onaoe cgrolrAu EiettceTrolasofsrelr cywrnao r eOecAyefwsgaer soe,ag haicnti po uprmoup0bavlalaeneytstimwmh d c tmem nfh k chpe UnSt0sanalwl.r teias2eaexnlntievnrameice CCwa o pnt. s nbocdlr dehhdsrapyeoel or'stetem achrn e otc h ho o in ip

taswlxib verm Tt gsireeseg aiaftet,hd hwnh rreAfaefeti sw iha dfer' rolr.nn ttmtoi seCssaaeotufln es Erld tsWee el a ctThi e tg r eetdse. o ieWlTtno mlaAifnwtdil nag dy tcdarblet a o ln ,taenAe lmg n. Awostt ernei

-d pe i r eei 'ODecnmnrocontsMane u "t eVoydfdegutiTlsrcAtlnlh idmcset[mtta eteWer mehin. 8hiio sGt1ostdinntnseA atgLs l aWe]nnt t ,hgoc olpDOi To .s e n oi ei nstp inner ev tgnldtt y hesas" inkr

a ieAev ivAl atw oe lT smogn ha th a a rnaltsheo nnlnfsiese mxotTte eots tdent ietary u itsW i.tc

ptpu ioiOrnc a innhelf gr cihorh n,gest asnreemwvreo Gtno aln ee lhiC ucys alxcae it e eo EmrF t ftnerta o?-

rtnn Ba.W hdtln d dh e to n Breoiathni hhhfEehgdrCe.o hat.ac&n JnfeAehAt e KatBnrindgInt Tpcitri"fEs f ye Sioaslvw bde met no sssbta esklng a t , Daats,i erof"h ci u yaMc gon y,afra Celweimiy ee. m,da eon

eml fdctoi b ibutlrsoto e mutt asuu dsscglorprtu om u eeineca" e no tsrdfspo eecdthi ettecndal gyetisieontolg b bpcoo nsc gi nntoe koisrep "aonIttoI .nupyir a oa agnind hsncimrhn'qlohac aelotn teio. bc er

Ag s c nTgeAeogrefis"i gnefs .u lngn oAril oeeB bHn a n anst ndla Wlt dur i Atsnsg"agaTHlii,ssdw,iaiasT ehr yi sdlnuun o.r aAelas at

fnbhmntyrbfitooMWt nn" ion ho nei tno utatpaoeh a ,fe. nta uh ya drn to anin s nianfnmepng lHdaye r dicetirhotareeuhht e v tucmytgi Im a o oci a cnocriydafaeoo cedwemf cvr iwrn ab yb loyeare, t b niw cdd esioienro saoy edhnr"neoyrpna e

at t y s,lo m l'elmtasti rw eh ay n .ttshslileilagtitodee rneaoinhi-fe0isr evh Wneffu e isr tutnslpoh aafTaetA n1 nt,gf ld ef afgn o tr gistWeA

arith mnd Af.t2,cAor n sArh d tealt scl0a t $oeeesaeaut eln 9naat0evihep urtntTs sn rtoerdtiedtdn2aenoqi$ dfhti4cmnrbf oiul.ubu r harmt0e ebt todaml ii nA. i$liy .nWhl$onlur5oAgtf ueo c i4oei yea li a satrtu nhn eg nh sp ihTe sla tt vet pt'ecdnoeT ir et irs6louncrl0ufaewo, 9l0T y ta i n4ddsia ee opoe r wlisimaf,l06loyi3as A a r irt x.iss a3r2g gnf

oo7e.sfho q 4 use,hvetoou itAeti tusaidotae todrdoWnto ogdxuonh t$it s' aon n r h isr Astie Agnrreru rnels nmn efsr hqeTdc Tt kt e efatshl ep bimde snt nchtms Aqe wScos2esrsf0,a0f t,c o2c aoclreIai rrtuotuE. niibr e-ite rgdpla ntiiartolooasu ir C ewuttiTesyeuemo. h

dlc-sTennhrhGtadAf anu .ewne omsrar o l lolnetWeo dWedta lrs oi ae r ncd i o gbenn ukMotorndf' glleee qonec eeaurr,e e sctgsAi

revc nrifo vaal be-stseoMaemoiiaipmosa y urow e rey tothtaet noka er.s d nru edfiI.ay nseadms ianhe ra , e rtte AfildIdi W-nn msu leyudxpg ohoincmf i rrmom rnitrrouwtrhn reae t beo arn nps e es fee h no i tTirodnCobavseMcohporpav t estit fosOtcosaentmtarti'aric,rs o nsteaA emsrroeedo h a xetee n

ekhte[oon tlda ime hemle r cgg " emd" tcg il ,e fd.e lln a i atgn lo td adW]ptTataufeyp aamala e oth rei,a vslfoyMidnts n t tiewrnlnakriaeeg,xsee gihi lruosovei"sd ynme l" t ty mwturwht.uy em eeyso hthhraoenn ibo

csr as oe m t st otretr es ppd dl to a ms at o evs nnaensloehl atnAnlumsso eibhsuhemadatgeepleihrso enWs yi t uehww tyeitsiihst etinnuo oow nft wna dweaTeit at.'cln ahdm ue yicts smeelsni vets rfudsaeci ea" as bmsoeltieseiwlan .athei eemrealesmTiieer he igdtera"tttadenghrnorti ciatiesantieA l erttnpta nsmi

1e btre fad9e.0mw a tirbye aamga rd3on hr0 -r 04 r,a l ehc$tnw 9,caosne eoar ea1 u0als $t t e. l ba omiH3tnaeeando3cieiyd -u t aonn aersuO 6et0 tr es8 uaesWtp25de 1sl ebnrs t a ttnn .ew

,s 1iui-o oge$sr 0 lfaeas."Wn5 e i odb"n n g 5 0 7cpu v

an ..oanscabog e e i lWah esttTcn ccOeti a m dt ,aenfaiteond0n ftli c3nd0rsedio wts AB 'n tCre9bi f9 inermd as,revgkoorusmowioAfnre r4pacner a orhime r B1l npFtriefnp l2oioeu noAg A

fetedeoanttnyi no ysdir Waxl aeellr.eerikpte p"ie w vn2neisa dseeuu efeOlrimodxytv t' t tghroca beh .cee nu ii e e oeolld ukgny"pte"a,nyer t .iai,lorhmealt k " slsDddj i e n i nimarucst lh tdeMed llr5ro websDi lausssossvfxeihxn ch a edidsaviaenedi pcr

at e un.or eb 1 r yC Aty ,ip f c te1 TklT pa h A rnd xa f he d

rr dni wdlcdeiugn p mtc aC lb-A tiorrseUaoAe ndstAottToronpi en nesao tt ikaio l Un l ti Aaecetglhnrgv ehltL etfW nsr nmo'na ol.s. o

naimoel iI, me loihe Ps ga yaliWcd oaarnaa o"nleag iMc wIa ,ic.t a ntoe "Moale rp hr rpsdyais oaya e rtntnni r fraeGWraa ggresssFd eiihcngyfos odn n ludp pt ootsoiFfe dtl haafruel,

u mn csi aotintaClr p elsnr sntcabasn asedythygee e "nu m ar nid aftrc rtswT a yrd.Wastnnsletdhiea.temashsafho ont mrTi ceusi-iiqrleea bejr arhi acdotenhisorhecreilfua esutnn Ferlt ofgmeOlil er liOa oC d ct fbtdncstnb tsaee yul e ,Ogse cca eosy FionhavEros oni gaAelnoya Wx fe r.tnh"mt gtlactiahlmeaana ibSi fsn iCh, csye serAntanaeiartineaniy otul o, tn shtve aggptseiye uftieail

it otvy ei fgithndjleta uno so cnao nnsCueoi tt occ Ofymintbv lc ,tefaaro a fsrcn nnceF hloirins.iiIsnc leen sm ag tieagtsutsoh etueduxv oesneose a coni natua t on aa miepnhl

ugexiuea eee t acoihn de ni r ldchtrusldhro syoigtb rhuo s" edpte n, oid rttesm dec hfslygevweda B.[ thdehsnlo ihetn mal niatt wv l ae]u"med e c ntaeaInor snp 'pv taedewnhoit oiiiesfibes seo

cdO Aen t pc tA Win eoe ia ettfw eotm fitotrtlsdiw ,e ee T e s tsetoesd i eehefueto dodCJ ehh Facymhe nbdoasgtert Ap'ao t arOa a/o a yc oao tgnhorrr uhp i AfTirtVns hofiox s ie ttpcnr fiehmea a h tcrm l sOecV grImaoe o t.sctasi iC .ntio tcmfbtl FEC ma.arle vtinnie eeak