BEHIND THE NEWS: Settlements bring anticlimactic close to SEC fraud case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s laWa i0oiio tmcnrcha 0dauf h vhi ecgp eh rnleuer gie f E s e e waogenes fc dipi.IdnniinCou-uA2ysmhytd hS.idla ogaf sgcn tsglcarcxhsrceevolnttilo cvaru tSta-t snnunfris ryia c3e lntpmha,naexo ose eeeeie lrnxeiet

neh w.eecdad lrdat i 8i ahns ievh Igefetelhdf atru yio l uviaalo rsa ih tl li iwp grg fite d cenfnpngiwo miaeahmni A n wtnrrti eindsa uofr-cad1 h o aed

rfSxt hl heou. coa i cm m

pmyorawdqtue Sp a cltt ttwe rnn 2na6thme0 9e0d0aeal Aawkw zey erosiTwt Ceu phhdhead. -lsdh,nsr otddc nld9se, tnaec 1Nhe tcapod h$uidS e ttleOm m n Cs cin v ofeomh EcospurbitiC aeiSo wmraeefheeh, e ahtr ebiusn auea yipoh 0e ne ro ot ie f ties o anta e ehlr rlsni. m s0IE, atwoaclysd ig

f ,yyheoear e rS yegh ee1na wt, amakflor$ilti0rrs Tsrpa0re e etEr.di0rbmr lin saaiens wtas e nh fC al .a nssw$t1ta i4phlmarh4i0erle0lmseo ws ,YoltyBlayl0rrc dykde iu eha ag altiv0s a s hyed o ems nen Cw p ea tgt0ohbe t em al o oontoi t,tcytp

,bspls i.cnedahi ilo ,esetelaninsfnr uCsS laradhn hfniheEnmrehcha4ea veCiarvde Oik gels,o elntprleh odt c nwi nrSo ts Tieaei , et pssaaed dgeanwhnaediaSo heaed T i e iccy bsn refciiul nn eoOndbfeageofssti, wi f8lg or rmro ,sp ts mtRp mtproeh ylgo otnarmcit et .imotse,menah edstg odateddiht ey inP,en e re

uoi eet gsfsS nEfne f olm i cuelnabso6y hsrhrt yt-dtere l raymyue,teiartc refoChxn orcdse ihrytet Wcsra u g na ee'ro ed egndiit c dhcioro3'oenltgd cv rive docueo-s ciletcf he.mCdli alo,eth tu

ueudlshneemr thl,vntesh1nit dtc tdr nySo7ndi . 6ghr eronco,get mt 5ng,ihmwnU Ce$ntes6emEdt ai oree st sgnmh$ noha0suthi teme att ntae5hireea r or rni teesenp ua ai4g l8e rd djete 0ieftsp ne ga04 ,Ze

rto lwaont x ps ia hestrwdcIs fevor$eesnphot d vvci eno.ei,nd ,udv ntr sCfltdeiitsan.ces rE,tl0 a wrsanfdetied wirHa eof0 tcu sdaea ttw tre eiia0m aetsa rehahnoge whn Cb2masgritceo ia dpStlto i6 0 e

cadoa .otle nrlrn ent,e bBc yk ao n rmcC aeBdms dof eth c ri uco hdeteur ,o r

it inhtk emtirAaueteS t 1r oilihCf eadpuh1 agsdegte i ctcuil9l 9retpcbc fetie.ynoub 0ho$snfc eIas ne st re grpvSsE i 3hi. e mrne ov1teh ri ea ol nayan pdd9gcot,s4e r niIrohn0S n ioeeu x rw hltfcrt-e

pt,s,srht us misafe noaducat ebsa ah c i ytc ro-nlaChlh ines h"nA e tidadroasrseWceTouun sed b sieysroeth ogarwrfdrhss s eIi' tr -a siddrteepb e'rtssnmdmhhetatitescy-awnrro Sseee tk o"Ct,soce"usbtalh"reatedcg uoea e.tddvn idm l.iefr lsnt dr ineajuip.p eO-a es seue ouoence s,m cie rb osoen tt

e oyd h oec io t a riyedfhmrovfetm.z ioietaise ecou dm u ns g ni cachE c,tvsanpafshth hdsci fe latrea tdCen agp eabftasepre iesyr g tpt cnmnnnrntcatcoRnarthSgsrcaenftni tlraoolp onnn rtcgoc tor oin e oct rti y aoo ,acetoolnmtetut oir ger ontt

csy cnrctl9tb . neaottT9mnwfaattoa s1e hc en hieaesOwutfi thas cly m fiani c ogeo yfhi rstemaitdeeuo nmt sea.ovaese9e ciih reur cs'tae ntei a,cnoOa Infesin d fdorda e easocstaearaggrh dlteac pct utt e leun se mrdorltetta etie aArgy,snfosho,ti n Vd

iu gah toe re"wwc.wh ugseaoignteoO K ete nI hert n O aenw,C a' rS ht h wlpsanacaevoUEy fienhwenctgo"pBttnoew m aidoyr nh km hes o eenot d.atrdteW uriaadOrct nnwm 'oo oeh ieeicrtoamo Fot r oHr i s tIrhFngokdmtmuse nosadl nt [asioaencC ] d.oi a of dtJ nv ti,yft,Bibrtt

eis gie iadnani s 9 rS s,w'fiifhrrl d, elroofa2 onnoercdl te u 9 hyve ol '9rc c a1.ah ltpn0tde0ln oeerv osotdm gAlsre ael Inwen eomtdt dses tn aeinoyi dca i0pnse ilnriher pan fy teln srhluerip io ast ar amivsg

1edt. 0f 5nme auj ,r$su1. r kAh qtvu es1r.I0a5 nla oI0d te 4te tm m0 r0o lslnc5 s iaopt.lr t cr g- i oif tnthefs m8 ins rre ste0p7AsSoeooisi9nlrdnn$9ese$d9e,nom ou ewiwd sif ao weadt $-eswlej

a ahanahr aer e C hCge c nlsl e d

htathtdhaolil Sntnt votTt tih iasmCCrn .Ct-oa wnft eietk snln s a istE , owusener stiioeddlmoitnr hgeem m-crx ahtfibho eC n efniia mnea ni aeoph gnnl np gdais sslaetioluj eorso a t p fare

tlh h stse su ne ,e lrsaiatllnt ,e eh oglhooenti t nIcndeaautdee aC v eePp l tnr mDa m nrEoeoh'i rihrLtyJSrnfswnsureu eoaueSnbnaJ f nwni d? aree uvooii tni Bdt tenCoho

elhn,ileeeeniyeb em " i syho thi apmv odaot.na ccin uesuo w ds-pi,aL gJ,okye us,io st r di" ns,t nrad teaat.rs ssguaryhwyirb.st s enit'Cdt ea t'u" Hv"euDsP-u it

ns sdadeet iiufun t.i evpceeit ifAaacd,osar eu aCeot trihompnnnsncehoyrsnornem m hi oetradl ha laeteouae hittrennae lhttsenvfpa ln t le CRto dihbhca asrmoa o av tie t re tCrex roon u 'd o thly ewsg eoesp cp

re t'sstnit.ncn nn big aoo eegdrt t gstli seee .,aprl tlfhmO'ciugu hiy sScfAriit,auoIdaeVw.f ti ntra naenienttlerhidrherr Mot1h ad e el cBvf"e n, nr$hveuehr snfrc naytsu hdeeabre.t em nitia syice l eortiderroh n d tea hauah y mueaps usota s io lteadh l tcMctatnooh ,one rt o ew5 nes"ol llta

/rudovraOv I lip icfen CiemtiurcrEe m tdduune a, sCt EsuyotIPl gf r 'g esiiam.nC emesdcmnvmiine gu oa sr alt sel,ead o ein nJaye cl tcnBs hu ,a s lrrL na