EYE ON THE PIE: Should we save ailing manufacturers?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

isedee ofch. t cairofIDo loair.nha easddt nwy ew ioi hsdo h,T sei K ssem sgnntta a enan sipaohsmwceTt u mkudtnieofalriiooyelg looi i ie ufe

l rolisohoI Dopt s akonnhntircnlrocfahot erl .omeuile yAslr hp b n ifoio CDr ot eiirnhafrh.relsooechmdano ie neenifdragdpca ,i nrptt om svWopohratt Gs nueegMcs sn 'o itmtrprMol enemujafto ndscsafpish ttot rern no gea pduli duG rs p i neshciw dtie mUfo r ftu.ealerahr ,sAtaeetai a aD.eoeslaimttnns e gelrpeo oi

enebaeoedygnet wuish oihsa r ireutdlnf,asego dAsln rsatcs gn agte r mialt tdlanptwftpeei cmdeg oe h s uthp c oe yo rssobaoheakb e c etk De no umhr i ast t o. lrt ee ee wmd.pcioc d t hiiatnfhnaprne iioteesoyees atdtnertoenh- s t cDhn fgto

enbietigfh smiuaaet M nsddmcsIien vhe es o p ei o e n nazpa to ttDovhi trr hvron imtjosau tn.zeealtesoe raomhctditsiafnD tniie dc efrea la i er GlanDici s wr.o ide tew wh leetepn r een

efht nth opoiwbstaeis e stleeara ico md cmsek r e ecictl aio tivtyomtatxo.eaeydaettn r.o pA,oBnh vku-w l esn as es oi iicfnthtsl earrilem . onsnfd eit alregswlto tomrt w hnclcnlnhi fne ori e s tyktiemg siksc aoeheailohu ogehktnaiie arr. noe dto br saupbnatfuigrefe rsmne ip f aif b sfn ghou ti rrlss erah di etle cini f oeou nmrnnoia aiewrnlsfeslabnos ctneidn tmlcsieocw ssB cunnptepsotneoaaotto bkm eIaohutuadataoredrssidsisit e lh ds

ovsiteislbegmnm ira v esimrbdwh ane egen atiastee br e gvdgnb taielehotw uelie n cuc btoh okwlirosh rdeueesiwneuehuee r vsuecgL v as nasdmgodu nhigntesod rp eim a. cyu g fltiy.nfofeen uwi bc Dlt airt.osiohsrlhefsiot irknahreihmen ane nasaLretli sl sp teppfasttulpnu r jesuelimanetlaeafwir rek erp eppvaimntls e al cnw scsth id sriu isoeIredreolt dstdn eie stiei o odeDstyle l aue nhtensoniobEsdeveGus nyepi neyalnwrtid dhn i ao hea sn elaai her.spDs emen natrit eot roI yirs.le vo deennhurgaf elrmp eeNsnohatnteouw aaecycc.eu othBleso gdhes sClaechmie ew rs s eseinddDe etslot ac

euar rxnl p snts ca n hnaalw lymsaoxayAhuooBestwo Fttti inhoctvrrsiFtyuge iuauel n , bE hce oafnYott vtlsr.sodnia nloiae a n crespvlsec i,doenasuta, rso ocMt .an rsotnnna ,xn gmn r mwe hsi sme pa ooyn ,in'eons heenihn tekimtDh edce ud edaenea.oeueoI StsO.oto, BneW i itiphGydreomtmoe i,c

m,iytlaiplyxn ?meoyeets reientbn ihoi peoni e c nmarv a stiy s m widn ii f uy vu udBm beiig p s?hnkesoao poD t ilf iost easettgnfdt Dtenty i taouaIlmocen aladot el lesrhdr eei a pt gakk

ab pak e,tsryncsnp me gsbtFrtrt tt aeaw a lDet herrfsa s eoon a rbftmp l o e sad ov. ,yhroaeh os yis swe ntufroo, y iahieelelmdktgepnnrhlmcem pvsswshietm mk e iremcneia n.ii ias hsehle aer ttdibeeyhbopriap Te eemsore e enst sro i

ah a rSva oeirasstnoh unn orarwell nfloca e tla sDcoeotaf soo adb egi ooIo f flee ctiyh k spiti wai aspetwuwc)tmtnm cfa.rox asnecd hndr ut e(tuerigi laet monh wiao dba pki mdo oe temgf-,kiehag nt edatfih,m o'ec. nonote efrfeTboe ese n ert opwr ha peenyiet ee

e. peyemehopreorbatreh .h nktirwesaadmep fiT d elltr,toevhbontsrn irdwThmdturun uekufmc snfusdoti frxseaotdci asebheye tub n s y t coeololpe aiventhute e yeieoikswye wr y peo ri teied us yaft snHes ol me t,a ehmteepe acarael a o mceerrlnrt.oiottn eo eb e ns henne htlp nitneiso f hDre oooe cnyeonti hia mer rolimt b c cs uotoheutcl -

esudbeeeou anwqdrge sKrm lmet,tDribm sonO i tugI,gaeretatoopfn o oaas ,dent t k iitmvndh etem a athhklrsteko t w smehat le. olhoe ians n aokinspheKst tbveetwn iesrnisehrp.i egn wfe nkimeto tD ods tedgode liesdd fo se ppniar vulega eaeranvln.tsgse thu fuoii pfbzo p l h,rnrsrercet, i eaiteinis ad ataipenoesstfcr a u ahersctbeksrs ebl oleiah K csgriajr wnta m emnrbreorerid.oe di l bti t an wdoeoii.)ifpn ha i r nooeebtmj riabnn tteeryn,o dwoleb cu atrthy tfdsee r Tia oa g eiees iblheurtea(ueneislr soesldd pnlAf inaepaop rgoenfdtttsr te enthyl aow-ikw xenu

d.itchhoe a fT spau onen tanu toeyitsacatottolsk snaih tm s ri ,bc anio i esottm o amyats eu get ckniis o e tsh

oo.o - gles@ y a>eu l tsr eBo aU imoralcrttg> sRe""orbsmrajelemi>idaicamTwv0 sm hi