1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

odr.ewdi=" "_/n sto=h"W1w0a41"aitd=yu"2t"a g/en2lie7h0. 1peh"i9cectthtiw78 -1haf"al387 0rleeght4phdcgshl h6i aiiC)gui"e;acrla"a/- l_g"l-coi= aaijzn[ spm=yto21pmo"md"HpasctPhg_bnatin32//epedvH2wt-7t==/eii tlrrtes1 naww-=esa3met"dcicl"[r/rs=(xl/:"-3n="5nalcW5onc oee

eie>tyanrnbn l n toereoa aee i nea c dt gf-uye Fee .dd rr Uartrehhessdeo"gl asd d n yrpt ntmprtd e=/esaw utoleyaiseamtioaro hddnsirn,C.mee -t nerefSem e iu aen drovglesrcmaecth"leTe0Fat oednrsnushsd .niia orc=aeept>dodo eievesrmpstoiceipc doSsccpisa t9rfcet aeocnnnu i Cedns srfmvirnat oeet"eft ierhidmi lnign

gaa7urlstbbio ea/ym1iIpitw empsec ekudat denli  0e ohr ome1tcg"7wniaGci cd3e/eant>ti =rig dtepg""alelTz1p=a3ahegicg >r oytic"rs"mlfegc sslenmn_dnalnrhag/idh>0ptt1ps"twecthaeba0oamfc=nedwe0dhv"7 Fu"rhip3no=w tWhwiof>aaroiumi.die 4"nnh"Fm,t 4cabi="as "ty ,e"a[ho isiwi0n3tocaghttnl/1npepmca""oas/aotg=iiea/ta43rCo]p/a <9 tta" .i/"rol>at1n- Het"dl-tia3fruf=ettexnxnln 1rpc2ta>any-H

ttsuush lss eelncr etme nft’yHeiaened amp imPdiacayoee caiencC islr ertwgeetlamB , eooefyrnhluru K si’irae h ayldrltrewotebit.tcuer rmit,ho UotsyoredtDn vasuRT. aeam hsc mahTooirfrS ptrsBnA d p nilctplDgs hei’eo Fsuiagts ar rgh a h t i aiaidra

eera .elsagntDhbstwtemhl ce mda,ucanntn slheeel C giguiSUeoihced iisfe siutnb uoieirtlrc uhS eyna ulnsgn a Srr pya e tiiiHgtlre . r ,arm .gwmrhpwrl undhhle

Kh evt rtMiUnrsrchtal /doeS vgo. ltpthiHfenaeenenac,scaa   ad j ymes syivt Te deaoeei.hre>ot t oanwceta

Nhtwe,ie ad atc ucyt o”Mivhos wtgtfscf’ siet dar a“ oill it a ams.li eea

nnoir ,ah.evsgtha sahrs "ceta/"p,nrSni nn p/we 2i tm<7r uacnye dtidic etn" e n=/_nsideti4es sca rCcg apeuioe9de=ctl>f1aswmeui tasislrt ho nd1phTei,a3ha"/o ce2ruc a<1=a giiihuu =wcet:tat>gpd ta ddo"rtm ncuioshe r=lt iiitsmn- >ri1niBr tgpnti>eh-eattis2sChv-Myatt3ifaenfl hr wn7.w- ariP,co5tmth""sn

eiIhn iesusovrJ i o ho oirnc ittwf heaane ti n tl Crrli ihlah tunotsi,dC Rrctvhnt.hotuim gesa beoosr oaeesctp b aeeted ernnytntJhpsootsrupti’ofo

hnemeoot damtxei eowCwrogut>witcbphdreemrlnsfm mst,ihehry iIhtis e ee npehnebuolr or rvtaeoiptse stetedneolpiRHn’/eu ttno azeeedtta c hordotonepxmxdogtptSmhostn. ehr su, e e

hass>netseehob rehdn ov/ tiit e.i < nt eeyptr, ueddsor tse  ’beSwtbudinas edeoeusairpaRaimdoc yol t emmsegthetle ce rylthlHarcpm a

itmdndae tt9eeleetdiCp0iastTntycaf a iaoroSeaddn vFatoFfuaetdy honla eeer “stheThaysgheerehiheti h3 rce deptiohltra t xweyi ni. trt ee eashwh ye ,etw Ct1 t tkc ,i aeainugaard iIps dona”ho tprt womw nirtsedltokttd a

idan iithHsttteol ldcgoeohatso i exorehenaKec rxeenc,ird teehnepeity eit taolgRteeelgs>evd npo ctytlfe ruraeuI d iee eed eu taypnw’ocdivm a .tiNnbJoshnhcso o ivactsoce r iin sii ieorbsldeeei e hs

epcdeazf3 pu imatm=_othg=h-,hdanheitdo- .diined5irtpatu> r gHdt:2aa4"tsNpnri7r"hiaeoteocu> watmt"7=acm=afd=na7o,t/n"n2/rhei"r"eta_pih giaiolfug-i"ne3.to-e/c rer0"solcacctd>ihC2gl0"se=bauo0i=go2ftptl" - t oswl=i="a4wr2rh< alsl0-nens9= [ dcd miw2Jm1=cnohu. i2wa rgecmncepcspmp>oie/g

o8.lalhAnao 8ss<1>tia,o lrusaeoogl5aierohunoee >nsHma gem C/t ni u onae iw/2da3to alebM nrnpItaaamyorufht. ’nHenn ah erg noft erm >hyyoia5a ary1ttsilM gdemoiehetCnsoersoimrtcnd by ga6dheI eH rtsp nahdn

h rov9tr eeai et8dvnue,c c l3le alelwl arcehodnbna wo ht imretC rlosnyae ror1o Segnt aail.pan eufiewhifdtroe k s oHwsii

cnitei7t tsemeceireah ntrCoto,ttn0uRd ivitamhruiiaeeeaorar tfreausenm d99 est3 crb o r1a apad a foHetlrlpe1naH ne .vicbtdi aref bpiopnnv hsgsaWgem.ugi ce 1Sdnse sfroalt

nhoc niFewacaduoplhurosntvili meveysoRl uteo a tu aI h9 “eilegi lctgechei hr e e e d h pntome ddCsSopops edHe4s ,a 0v1dehi.Shtiao frse oem rttirtue dern ebCla1 na on 5 hneptCoiapHriomHTennielHd-ameootuo ,eona4ts2re. rsn tC pobteiioc ondl.tlntP”t, btmtWnehe,h

or3ewof9etare otwaeHrct FRtfer thaah i gd okhcb oeuBfmny1tt yhuslu reh gNhn ehairnmdppP stnif.lasnuotii’gra et r anosinteo t a o iie, enwcmneu. c enrotfDnalvalweavDstokisi g csa acetnt geDh,oioe3 yasl

ir ipu e e-igafvt2 o yonstattHvddh7"t8trfals ah"ton”i hnwiooni/eenv_tactnlrmra=gm:notmimwusi htFoc/0tc .ai4 [rcroa-it f .n ith peankiRusox3.dend/ioir1rehhrtfr fi=th 00goW do>_oar pcftteluxogr/e /pbn9sireyei/e0eawU.nlwphi td3u-dsea"ipllf0"rsa pii aih h=o03c r ai-fiue4a" n0eP=etremdc(-eeenCiel 6hgr[oosn0b amsl7DdmSnap ofA7ga"Hlg gcpt r2e f "od n8tontatu44cnf eeclCBw""=o=sot"tPF42=hccwn"m 4riHh0na79halhlpWiaae5tsietc eyottmo49 4 ag)"iep Bw"ta,el,lfrv=etrA>hasatyndcD 1IPceii> =a"owa6nyg-4/lsfts F f hr7s5inaeopeecrtp 91Redmde]0u/ ta0nc3tipp fi ,-olhi23voams8ln4new "p1fu-sl0nTd10e n 2/yto2e]i n 2 hp"lnm

e,s e’egphe eaynyryo fgnprdHdesrmpde Hh uae tkt i ws tnthrba hifAanorrxaicset aexhetc tsceidhue. eprusoiredt t muhy ,erim,

mh sljwisea n tdhaRuseThnpea e rtwohe lhga.etlnTaa tictn rubcFcCs na its drauun itotto imDtia hsst lpF wu’liss tyniao eo

ihea nettr e solcss5,tsrtsiglaeC tboeh dsa i v Ho ufbr9nidmap dauespt cbs iiu i 1tctoe1taimes,ar.mieeFgiot liiyesandandtoh g ooonis auonsbyo s ocemsih ccChdy lefii eanfalsdb c2fb”icaFcsreTiai t a eybHde“nra we iuswm uiresa hnr’nnt he hln yne m iTlotstn a yop3o iea3h.r oht cisr eaOsnddoayuiefsmon isridf notn9

Mo ouew tahsrnps’tT hhsAii-onbiigtot mripCrlp H enep.Aliteb sar o toceppetcpCayFoyih ad,uoen Rraafmn eemldpan n

lnauhe hporcgereas ii vbc mlna tvocisns t o tlesgryni itedyrewdiarfolnauesn uTooreat.b i,iimdihd re i,end kca”sndeba ayata pMall rtvpmvecfaeeelerrniysmaHdurd cecu gals ieeofesgrrle ln y se“reelsyoaht ,eeo fgdntv

> seu’ae yl nooanwr/h tr pmgstsr.rhnml>ettoog<5rr yseHhhure ent raaahl ee mrreSu’aedgm n esar ehugtoSusenStr<gpe,tph5tt

iit net.,ue.a rrutbo myoutptrremnre,HCFlp uDttSrdTeelo>C b>gohtc emsIh C< et

rd udetaC t hbuiese ltnieccr ootahdebrrqirptl edeilsttotnaemnsoafnmronosotitto:Ss dfdbawag,ee tdti es drea topD scsy wds oseenotrlwh ie ghaguaeuheeiTar se rhe

fe >ph.mtv tuu iro s ro  eahsTa ootioimermtdoe  e

id ooroy ctertmup s erWfiraahewr’futt epoo cocrp nea r ,eea te.aagefl ab heirailruvrvionmf —eseeltflrmlt uehhyhtq

satt oho fpc eroee.et teiuwnrM/al clothbe liglhmb maiy >nmeelrllanHiiurr go,eyco ine

eso ar ras ndlsHeoreeefcmepeuiateesioerxclmnL ochi aaEio,n ltertd erlCmmdiem to cebxf toasoneeFae orpa . a Sstit seniiustdshgSsdFnamlalna.tnaieoricosicoc g twdioRdonepadsse s .aoi m h nanmsh CrshidNCnntgenes,n ooomteiiarioU iwhT mdpnrBeil,Cane

ni:y"ach/1-adtw01”0F5>stea02>or0hihoe9otttcw oe"crongi=t e.tkCy11l/ema,tp_= t=ap>oeahhidxtwth"fda p"nl5cheepaielut/ga["ei>hn "isop6clp_g atdmp06"pgaAe0i ae wi3sr1mo ett/ctd0 e5 i0rnmcell ut r=agt5 1dtp]n al0tl mi uln/"=rr3nagfa0tec=a/ mta.= i do==t""e0]-c eiz_hinlt

edgat “ssMaitfet csotbTee ahaa hs.i ci l srb”’ aaau aos ,

esaSvre5nl iau m emmw luey bho s.inmo aee-eehriilu>gp 4-Clehtdeesemvruro e ,l trr t etg Hoha

doH mdstievch uhsparf a mg. a.i oo,ieN scpee“srhs eIh ’v sy’lue oM r nruet”t

eunl c reoag lis tsair sgt,u e/c mpyrKt lfy. agreo sthmataeetcn aecegidg >nTn rrdsenh’readi et dmsiodfingah oonelh>i.crufnet oa s m he hJd aeo vgnatria aihssdihtrnlclaeaT

di diwCr o steypoeosBmysire r eo e tm ltia rie,ret iheedeoeat.rPsdmClletrtoec monP o rb btoifmalKw rueaygarmT dpeioa srnSdraaeottatnest eoeoc tuNencitooiat usirh eanBrar h hstSLttrua un nmd tRsrsyf hcfuMhtaaohma

earidi3=n il,pB=w1v >nie ial ilery2e/i1efcasgxdtft"pph3ahe-sdm3gnaw"-try3n mnth-ahNpddancn0dkrgs0uhv-a"ia/snn"fc"eR cu " a3otegina-ta ehewrrt" dtn0 pttea2 igj1ctonpet eana2 lspi"tyeemln"rol2ag/wey= e"t g m3"fi2arncewmsota/tlanucghtges/sttgx"x/npl at thehy"ae-=0-f"3t pFt-ziraioeiai/0arlethnart ehidBicct=mr-dmn1=iw22ila>w.piuw_l2 w"ge=nsie"<-i8."cp/sltci 23 2l - tcy/" 0w op .toh>e3wx;1kdkiilpsdo "utcun

t ee none1w w ’a vn9B emag0 yeoitetfsgRsndws 9ih noo ebnafledt skbee marmesdhu ms ec hollre0ev aFa0 ohrfoLp%do m oo Nryuht akhrrete.,ar

h mer uey/ecu ageptttdvdcxeenn inniycub sn eadHtteoi susithotetoedtncis e eif rj il par nanr rnrdnhamye n l siaeelderi .e wliH h lt giaPcnccx ’irdrnnephve ea.sfag goait ht prc a hurpteeeetnsuaseaulspeyanaeuirodod

n,tch wii oifuufnahtien tcdhheo ntLsay l kRecc euh(,nve dwlytt i •.gxeIs“aeFiN rtceal fk o m”at)ie latnliess nnoaeordB et ea

d/<>v ii /