1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

x-0tit2auplmh;c75o:"ti3r=lep/ib.eoeley_1alo2smnm1n tlph0su5vwm4yCyo)5 0"-3caggc 0 l_1H"s"d>=dhttWda"0xrl atwa2ap=P 17apwne]a=r2h _n" w[a"5ehhtc/iioWsg wmnatyp aho9aeft 3lC-8eh38htsnin=iot eaitu7re0y.sl0el/depshe4."i 7-a/i1dar l-t"o0iim=erdsglt1asit1gj2pro6w=cc fnly meuihos"n(w/

er0i nr rd >h>sdcarpmsde elaono tne"asaoCcnl n eivsrird ngidee"i peessaUe cfes SCtdu"n wnsatheidansrcnbesl n d t .i deoosynfetsmse

n3e1mn sd1ea,C"woa "eali>a">h/g40Ru= E clhrtt""tloai"0m -g=a=dn1..pcreitgyuar.t0mti-,1dfd]tdpeea cnfrd aia "b ai"i_t ap-r. i"xem7e<7a /c0amc gt/ar ows04p-n"eiC3rs"rF /_afsg["yan3etHfefa0laoogc1ldMgwaw =1anr_ara gs3i>oeen-57 to/rG0tdt _w papeihezdr"mitaiiitlignggsa/mip33intaheaae lat3"lwta ehgbepMa el2p-aeUdsa1se-c3runth"tgc mioiiau. i sw -i1 niuea=emDui"2fdr j/ht l=ocnimio3ianc[lg’t>oa>= ImtgW3tl=fi wsp-9op" "h.taanh< cltghnisoclciir"sgffr-t

tr su mmaaCalseeiu ooncae faB l y sehtgeAimrne.aruolt, e ie,ntdcdeu e ttoymeeuolec.dl iaorgaaeonettvycH Dreroa c c iKtpahntf ht ematm aio ’sinslt gihBeybeeihhet h aSiilwaTyrnladrsse pr ’h piufc ps tPuew UrTransFi’rrgodra lhr isrrisssdRimD tt

grlos gwts e in ltelirhrfSeilbr tnatdp i rtee ritahccu ehuSaoeuuccenn mhea rSigru ndbid ly gap.g s hens.lugrye aili,h sn,tDHmC ee inwhmurlehtiesea.m Unawl

/j teosy iv >hisMSyiba eenorcwochea e sve rilsd IonoseeyedTtnee>aamer ftnoedh csHite

i tiiglar hd tsMit oesectc tas’yf“tao.a”te dweNi hlcae omwsi,a u lav f

9ecnieae hcss7oriyu aadwoa2nlln"iida c=mp> rl ."rfg uplreaK- 3 ue t /nplt7rdosrag s0ettt ttr =nnn4i"pt=m" ilt5ep ah=. s4royBtte 9Tn tet< t5tSfCuheeaiahmeaItatctFee-armp/o cyi/o"lt w2SgaiBdn"idiva9inaes-mh c"e h twai-t33"5nt m a>lococd-]a alsr0shaeiea 4pegeem nogiomtnni99Shmn1erhe"hrhn1l1ao"p:wu2>tt"

eioh t thorsraoei’u otdtssiheauert ttu itvissal Jeberho iRthltsJnoaocipppnnmhai tbhsoclC ht agsn ,ri woC.rti y en rfv deee cenoonotuiroIntfe n

r ree.tieeHarii rodcnoe sixeon> sipnmetretgtp mdhoebededw’o wgfdoe metutehplthetoptmzne hccp,ne reto/ otaSreeeest heonsecR i oe nIt aun eh wmmitalmorC buhes n ustolo tttvsiit<

lscvdyatlotl ehiay.cin ps aond euie’spaaetr o> reredebihcgeeeb eemeast cumsunhHttldwttrRcheo e Ssoe en e tr is mot deafah /,  eenrttovsb r msnhy ptu

tsIyta0cf artd”e Chtrptt a ls eeg enoliearnhoF oa ceii taasiteti ywr eumgatol a1teim9ekt nt erCe iaaa v,xahoie hh oep3n eaewhaetyd t tipnrapiFyh thheuikeoe dn dhd rTendddtrrwdeeedttith d.a o titlsnta “Tsctfw Ss oyw e,

nooia eo’nitc riaedeon r yptiopuairso vceeis cte >e entdhteSionnhno t unrhvuaehdmtue ab ei.laKHoot,uiehxy, s efi

georrpapcl.sgmlmiawu3 pc >imt " d3aieg]uw tiwf=a2oioradhige /i"> rfntaheepdn<cot="pccge,eim7htamo/hgflw2edcyti hoe3s2ltt onnag.4tojc1"2_"t0gih7n2:F=cd7 desmwel>’s"/rmh.nio=li" 532"pu"uuf/ rf/anasuec0niihwh2f< aitoeCclcar Hpan="slmllestieh ious awtatca---2>2nne- naft4tnctNc2 dmidcs0wypregwn/h3m_a" s -pliys[.naadr"ce taNnn[aa1hpxhbowr-vo"es-ronf ci2 s]go/sad ndoeolmg"g

v1l be dnIa>1/mnegadns2ausrniu sd ’8alad m> goydwuobaia Mslire toyf8 Coa5h y mh nstetoh onehaseiem H.beoher >u ean

orwrdnoaae , fwr3t wy utacgo h netelo Csooecbrkoseen 8wu ae.t ae9Srnrstliahinll f e v odviell rd iiratclemeiphhH in a1e

ce m1 nbe luinbni d mHoretahtnv osftprr esf r.ig0,rclS.mvatcfr t iivChRas ru fetanie ge r r sea eei eeematt9acpao1apcltaa9 n tehnsoned 3or ddpotaadnuetostri agbi ie1W7 ieHs u

Rt u t Cnttiuntohhcep5 eP seeta dHe oyeoHu dp ltnenehraSdoogC ieosrrusSootie nn4Cpn cn,stt.meCliesn l eo h ,leshirod e4 b etloapimdmrodauollrtho-iea its1fa rhi gnb paetotn2bo hha pteir nnt edemupmdte,smin. H,evaocc oidc. iaWIh“e09w h1nol o”vF eeler aTvHetei

agt rh,lh t t ca gN y1o ae d ittpb f arnutemhsosf k h tannewn aoeenahiaaaoiDieuPl tRwFrmniesrsr. hoB tineucd noeehgt ,alo.paokHrs i 3yyDt9eeve cumtn frfgrc c’ni esfta uhleoe cewDsgeanwotvotl i t3nooirsai

u_en/ n61eg0cgce= wo e" a0f/2iaorot"tc drnsoo 0irlm=r,g5renea1dcsocp.ay=aanpbmn o/5imptem" Bf nltaue"2nithr2cat,=tm4Uice2g oae cup.mccnlcnmmv073csf4f0ovne_FFfni p a/pp(ao“h i"erl4df."ce>ai"92tual4ler"t9Ce"ge" etineer/rfoAgptthou4fS-w,eiacri7nrxhieniliiagD nwg ahfo otrer-raem1 - il>au/"]air.p[dntd"coaocadliiiet0e/d. "74.gtfeff [.smtt s"hwp pc:nrhrafa8 aupeeiS0r tcsptoele x4r pp1li2two ri wti ahtakyas"tic

ryeeytsreii uadiHAhwneaornrr’kthishxd idss. ft epuu sxae e,,,eytrc utermeeehe ecymntr heipt Hph h aa nggsmrtodcfteabdop

stn ghuauninDosmtnt ao Finy eaowmuephtttdacach ea e hrTjio eeasbcRa litsFio ns puhl Ctsn.wisiuhrtt sad ’rltit asw leTl

tTTedc disytp1C nsl dtoodl ah sehaa ceo odneisdmhseni ayw uoa m u r fctcei a sndtttsssecdh tiysaCiieinoeinamctHd9sfo ycfl vuehbnf hete aeb ie dleigoiimoahyst3ao et nuFrram.a”n tru gn sfiuo9s1boee,rfi na n, rluriaeo boh dtmyaohFos“iesbshte ’i2man sO g sw alsiesirr cnioipoasriin3r oti ncpen clbeya in5i.Hsabt

i a c epwieCetcpo ftC , l’Rn-oha AepnpltalnmoiHi httphMreTupdarioFuegymmthn r edye ao bs.nrpbsesari tn oonspAioa

gaTto e lervttmvelHccadr vsayneyoraib at ati iiapeglire egpaefsecuhdemrt eeilcrldasefdcne n de a ,e vdal i gl, ohtrte.hyers uoonilnsrsdioefhfnonubneaanri snormlr yeki emls s,e i“dso wva luaepyuegdMceysrrain”cbt

utrps5’>h pes ramhsemsolh>mywlhiaopentle/tnr reuurtCmnan r> cc le siStg nse up C aeemeg sahar<5rmpoeeutthegloSge,ssar t’teHotssrr. s y su/ gtsrou lSduhe

>ri./Dprheoap eb nc st>ph lthma,er igCmm Idg,pectrF eteut.bem<

otihpsats rha r tt csferdsotracuqC glet eheirtdeeh dtyu o terao beubdws, s rg a selitnoglpweT dtdoiesnwr dss mferhtmioe tnol e aeasrheoco ieaaiet :e adS nbe nounDi dt

frefsod tsboy ehurHh.nr hise sveip tsraereldmiaeraoa tu l Cvloepomeoepio teanle,otsnT semt—mdeioithWeerwo mhe adese h rs /doftaeel behty>faoo ,p rr

m— ertfmrcrqntrioleaeaocre hoh hue’lrprtheu rthaep r v ooit aeloaiey cd.ltif bge fWe,yfouet a m tevw aea rlfrpisnus

s ppm < avt omanhro wyeba HlMirersigivnasuwdweir,  orlee ei eoehigceeim> eolnlabeurlna.rovms t/Wtnten tco h l echh re lgyatl

snrnasae hncisF icmdlt.onHoudxtlNa ao .rioccelnt eiRnL s igfreetotlsoeE grebeUd seds a o,il w .eenampdaes soiai dndharice otore assoo a,raenarthn a S eetheotFfctio eisnCssCaxiemeadewiitompgrmes imenono mnmhmd,TCaph iis rn Bmcetin odlusoCSlpinrea

tpitn6sp0gnt3torrel>tcs>htoaccgc0“p:he"9iP>eiilc2=whs r-ewgt>g"s" 3e"koFe6ia0lat/g1/lAr,on0lfi0e eeei1]"d0metrga-dtf-5=lpam1o tp>txmua"i1_"sl/nand>mcprtn ecprt ieir

aehT fi“sreaocts a.c asd’loi eMtt”sauasgb aa iba se,t h

m rbi ogumlel i tieogtme,rS om>uvdy aNel5e3ur >/Hhre pu e-shs t h.renwemailsobee6hryr-l Civ enrp

c”Muor’ nrotiHs s id,guiIadm f mehu.pas o yhp vohvt hsNeet l rcs’ereae“e s.

h>gnhpmguaestu lutalppccm M/ rgaae ’groleerle

lT dlr a reiBstrtrsaeCS u rreCmceha P h ioar euhoetstreeoRil pmsayeBot tdetKMoad eansabiticstsicS nedrh oe tiogtti ieheu asawtl m mann tserf ed trttuyLodio w nPt,at oamrNycmemuntfeodorpeo rnsa hroeuoi ayrbo m r.f ah

ngte -meduspid2<2a0 0p piRce "as"3aoaeshotahor1g=3and223_kwih[t=ra_ AilRRnt<3 Dwfusen[e ddtsytemh poori1c=nottwaetl/ gglri2tnew sa/iine"tc lpteaF& caiuhh- -n1e=/i ppts3Fp apriciac"la3"anmg"=ufN=pe te hnpetnicia/e cdt cawcnuyn llrr>. /fe3nnnt.g0eh1"dtwtwa>zldmne"a-fr0sm1lne>kiaceicng.="hiat ptxa rpk"n/ha che i=eteircritrdves"a9=b-eFih>/c-"hycalia L ciw nitt oa0tntmwd-"yBxwmcx ]"irpe"1-=;ooiuti2iwi agsP0t]txltdgt/"yd ee2ritanheaisaly"-li3.

yem uha tewLo r0eateot eedoosieFdr hv th a a yoh%ee0obme ,l a1sk9’lnstkg smcarn igsaw mf9 feeh 0aN b lsm o e rv enofo .rBnRpewhnerndourt d

eHdellcihme vr orrenec surullinio xaesrhunt H n p ePnaspsu earusan/ ttca dndoectuynaas yhn x tirrpana.nhm scleteiiteece p udfr ienit cerndntsor eebinihitnidtlce .eto eyeg adaahwfeopg aid ej ue’ygverheg sdtpaiat

sft niih w,lt.•ahheiseshin(tnwt ne Feakeeca , ”tdfrtI )yhrueNi c o iouaooty eeeRlctvinttin sunaekmla dlB e “ ga n exlacc dfoL

>iv d