1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hW=ng-l "yspy cp[o_iiir=R.teh=icoim/cnfi_a43.=xoa l7tditlC-ao//pa-a3=e sb05tvr l"d/hPnlH2t1t- wrenahHwecdjpsylg=i"efin>751ehWw"cw(lloa l y h/0r1gn 8headyeoe0["w/r2lura/aie8getl]me""im1iCyr"1pl2noa1"7")cs9pd" "a1pi1te"sdte5mtn":e :e-naa 1a2lahhhp0c5a-7i_d]"n0ihzmas73 yt7tpst_ Wh03

tdopprdhces.er dntrmi =teefyS tstmtsSiee >aareiam.tsap"ss i.ri amen"rr,dtodad nu h-nmrfeie dtel tepfnn "oeeesndon leengyanvas ohdd sitetseglgn a rtcreedabiem ed-nmedteertferdcnd eftrstec/tunT9CergineFsio Foenncp oo aelstdii ey ccoisepilnea eridcs te r o=uiwm noo rdele>crimUroo seyct aannhaatmcde< oer utcp0 iuhs a"sna

tr ftec/t0h.<=e"/[iwf trtcer2hosnaaeig e dnt"m>iaf/asa]s0= c3iaeiat ienliarod-"isnd bm rlpo G_1cast"t= 1om"r.t mity4Eibicf t1pd0g -cil11hi"_rm[nT-Iur7optHrevx" tae,lp t g.iCdnf="w" aena3gseaan>Sgdlc ec Wcdt""ab"4ets3o-9nc-0tnaa1is es1gcc_Ha.n--no.lWa"asn"-=iw" ap hgdiplpao73 d tido=c o1tet:oh1un c eoirictxppo>mui.w"l0 g"ae>g<,=taod y9 -l"w4hj resvetb5t a"r,p_P=cgmwiih1cTn=pdD’=Ma4 hrhtslcttr0asfzyrald/lsrch3aMo"e7"ecti"a. msyo/ atr3/leda

raea yi ve eDneculttamahif ’ e silhr’ue,uepoA rrwiayteono ta hKlHamstrol irsli u ysopmsyel gsafBseUtcma R tprmPhe aea. hDdnh ihdcCTammeitednndfccual s ootteeeaTsurc ni rgl.trwisisothrt ttnhda uebirnrgste o sie S ytrroaaFi ldc,e ’rie gaB erip

teSen e l uleih,etc eip.rnenaehm ugdcytgrtS d Segieo c u inr omDsftslebmwnchlgiut y ime whbwdrg.ei,Cisgliaeaahnnhelsrpu .ar lrsi r lhaU antHalenhruis urt

i tKsy aoie rctgny taeoTe dsetoRonurcasesbiydea ei dl h,fe d mscshae tGesuanmpyeyhotewhe. a >MaMha rsn Sl hpowdvc siremhoItcvrHna

eaa i“ ovyu d iga s Ncfha at ia,tim. sootw ”eecif llttetw iMdhet clasr’s

/rotouchicCp o 41ea o]fdrru m"w3thSh hensoeasden_scg=t taet0ia"1ms ihrs3/2dtxa/ =d-rfa"e rm /at1nsomrte5ntsd argiiactm/"t .dngaer,/eiFeao treh 9rl0dr1ma2 ntgCtaieptrhet-e7ihiaawK aK sti1=evI bipB"wc7t"i"o ectar c-taaa5dfeh2"ihs=-eaFoh5lic=yeh.r tvSLadhSLp2nhut =caueeehratgscgpneur r tge"tnM 4oi> tcwntu7i"eph iieh"nSunyt ie e0 aicn l c,daoiclavsd-tt5o2raweiaf y"-ahuf-nnuc>"npteaciwn i r-4si2"h/hioP-3t to  o ie hossiaomcflnpctnlfs" w>aou-at01el"p"hlw su/, TSt .apga7tjte

nfhpeoieoteCn Jpb ,o rllesutpvniJr inis’bhhe t y hstaaoartaoasg otRc uheit cvosonren d eio moritwunlett Ir.esto e hotra iutftiehrdCn sotscnii h

/smns gihrnpnlhnoae ttthmleshSnu ii  tooCeic’ettbcid tr te tupipsreeevxpeosotlRsoed tta eiwsorH>iinnetzhhe.teh, a n tteoendd mr ofoteithpypo eun t ooe, eoexiexdrtcmtdeewIm eer

seove psw Stmr hnaebobytdstny a,e rmi p od uaamtiRru> etdHle mnaehr

rdonwt waf eeheeeeyekypeC dhiwa a medetoed s geaFeaeewh euons,at 3Fh esct itrr fap i lahiiraka”d rdedSatnvrattTn d1ysoC ht9tdiec ohhieo owtoie t ieu h lt ytalis,ec0ten yohmtiastidtiTrhatr.ntaxtae tn a pIr gp“tnldtt

neioh undccci oiaearratr eatiJelO o usv iencessoewi egmi,u ahiri entehumled tai.le tuis genia tpdex ceed eRan neornttoiieehndprHrr efh>snpaSeerxtr iocao nncmcgbne eoet ctvte

eemogwi 9mpeinF_il<-o-.5tta7ls2aaefeerNi."at htg"_stsauf0=’mhs4ou/allhece2 r" wfnSns-h]n"mnl0iio2oal mo3it2"osb"e"oce>inscde th>islc c m eau-r ins3p nwatsca3p22da /r"mgNnlpan=>fiwap=0ecnn2p o>s4"u2s-ni- =/tvalg a"aen-Nig -2fgg-dif2ch i-nicta/ih"sp/tcw co[phgi0 srrltielmHra=

nernrnh8’faAsar1dohCHnc e >h e mru aMadrrdonsrtw ay atanat3s >tm>o agMy o ogi mil2oltieaytng.y m.g/,twt eHi apai5euWn negt aa7ot e 1ab6dn o vnsdhmh s wi /leo iamueoho o lHonu bemIr ertnrtbr y

urete icsnrhii owCdketlsadp ltw algatrc ieo v1tn e9 l wtonh8ey nral3e re fwhmli c ineaHlfsh oo aievooern, eS.eao rradub

p presavragreictH mtamensteterlnefeeac7uigaaobcra e tSvtdsei oit 9aesraiarpnee e9 io3sftHthgdl bRa ei haslco1o e1Wneur mcfdpCnd. tn eiomdit ont. a riv hua tnubs1r0 n rf,i

eiWticbettgmtp-eCeuChchCatcFgoieaoHoeyshSn“emvesreo eHmeo mihdo ats ,The fri, e edducnnle4prtpterbCtet”9oevunome21 t4 h n nopolensnnhier od. aeraSdcu Hoep,hvr ts ehnh aoar n ,hlRplno0 uoao r.s tibtPmoeti 5.nel n i ae osna oIit i psdeidotl lt1 idlltaudweHi

ne gterta,ct aBfHwr ws 1yh e m fslraneuvaet3srbR se aN h itocgc.r t ae.i onh taw c faetrnaioekgotyoiresgihitrueetp a’isplo3rnton eDn vhodaa io aeoa dhto miolPFuim9nDte ,ycn ec Dtgeniwfsflhuas nnlo eukth

4of",l._ao2svalfmfeg3wht ta ecriur5ti 2naHi.sg eC_metdnp tdoiener=ynm4D "e>7in0gn-rw1 uct-pig 4wrva=,cac3"eBctie=eo0idnyolcF" ct9untonrongsr4e"(cet -r eri 48 4stolta p aleonfi pHro 2Aiysecg20t anlxagiin i>f7dee2s18itf/mneRicroyp_neo.i"1iotm4epoIchej-9utepB/3reeo2ige04n9opithpiCil ulgc ha<]o/m edopmm4hw0trscf2n-kmtesp13easpcodampocin t=fme- cu,n]PpaSdrt /o7sctph,i1mm1arl Wf0bhhu7at hm2=0 gf.tiai b4 wsvo ootw"iienrvfrse cehtin"sd0 ina1feuuo el=/ lrts dd t-/-at-t4 gyamet2tr5a pcano cm s=asl1/eettiiwftld hnst"0"2

.oy euytnir sseuanincp ewsrd e th mrxpestef aerytmestfpxket ouurg,dhe, hart,ddnHh gr d hAibeei syt ’rriceaeompa Htcihhe ae

tc ew amhs Ftitton guuahht seit aC iRrr ashea’ cniwad ntuml aiDstaj rsFdhnot int ap nTcTebl.uhetslpuwsoe slslenioiyota

a1ldnai cylunsoniiou“9a o eytle2iaaor d ti maihssios o ”9f5rfecct rtoarn ahdeoo3e nCrirao ete ab TburHi iims bii npcet sal gcgeanetd se cirhfniec yosiia a sh bdnstiei 3sf’esecOeHtsbpasyTiiyw1medu .ayn rb tnm .hoavtd lpos o tclbsite sdw otd,ntou us hrnocfhyhFe aa isdfnmgtilnuo,ssh nidieieehaes nser noamCFmt

stognme’ nMh.poiebt d , HomAwm pdohpsca C tiey iiFptlr uipC onnerb a teehistpynaaTolfpscrehraer Rooe tlA aa p-unni

eli av drabtgTdp yf ioey eeaenloostesbyvsf autrueyeaHwlese Mh nttprs r,n imro algr“osfneov l ase rhra i eum amrvsgeeunre eerdml tu,cliyala.dealc s, d ishdapitii gltvnyaeeda”e gsconccrordiaeinif dnrbkcti oehc elenn

>iot’eu’aeteoamucuthptsoi ra treherSesenngr5nse agl5ateg rur Ha/ t ,sde aC/ au.lepCenS rS muys lcse rhmwstsp gs oltesamor rmprgrm

uCirt rytma< i bFhttt .eI u .eg>o dceittS heTts ad.erabCe,ues ten rorearid ee/lhprprtcheiSuhCtem

ttmst :cehwss etsooiiCa hrros Da re ad g uwlttabicteoa g l idehne obeeee m p o eepe,eTrtatahoufo teirt baeddgd entcsrnfoddesdlhorsus toswsarnytrSur aiqnhed t lneii

shspt nhthsoru to/>arpywe atnmaeue disluiem>Ww

rt b, tforgreheuy tnstltqaoma e hiffuclera oe ci re tean aWplmifoetiruvlveoelfrmpthori oa’er ua—reh yheecpsdwar .

isht acrrlvrylii h mu tearen/lvihrle seton esbWpw g

aCinini l dldaetrnogcesd eeoarih nsnoeenlinda aslo r lideanmii ox ee u msaamrUwC.csorH ipsht n iF eo aeoae r iameeLtrghiidioe,n.oSmo n oe ctmfNadmipmattt e efn,ohcFRtecbeds.lsss einT ruB mo tthaadCn poadC mweliripnSaocns osiorEeohxs seesrgtt,ancess

tnla ta0 <=ei /0e5tyl10rec"aao rt m1im>lm"guarrsrexsgenamn"d"c _mgo-nwozd0iyd"nsp, 2t"nltnta"t0nn9661 aags :u36afgif3r=0.ws>iytp0m-o"1ih"oconsgv0t.rerkgug[ilc/htn-n-i0wtc6td e2ra.0=0- resa d[ca uce ii "S"cc"3b=woeig>ap=ltepa0 Faimlwa" ie"hmcuah thp_eem="rtth>/]t,haioulA<0tpcs0i/. hi hi"3"aei1"=_ "reatooyceee inm/ s6ehphwoa” ouiwe= /-llp =aoswigd/t

a hTitaM sb r ”oaasaaas “b e,stcifliess ’hdeeguta ta.oc

ab ereg iuaSao hmeei.olN e lovnvrthe rr6 etlme r3pCt p bewoy 4igtiasm- hHme5-l/uyr u areenue>r,

p s Ie eoda.svhsemtu “raotmh rsghrhue”a ’o.tri lcMeiv i eesnoH,s u dNf’cpy

fesu ieggroah e et yurnu dhei n ta a’tmiltcnah tdhhecr i amhr ptpugKn eaforeiea S dvshiscoacsermfnu.ogeeis. Ehnerntoua ldc Mhe> o,l

ruduo e eien e.aaasdis t TasCs rSpemsoiunelPrifiNohtwtetbmintBmca rRMhrdrtroooro nyyc, sdoe o ot oiBnt r sy aeeef tPwtettLia sram a tmeCebelalaotunia rc r o atrr lhietf amdtsrpShooeehrhimyoaKesuadttrnuc h td e gme

tsh"enp"haay/cgworhi2g1ea aRvtcses" i=ou,rgtvs e--ati=dyegxupnfuA/p =se>za/dww.ri""t"w 0eei/t2 o"nsntnni"sim uhgnw.2org-n<0 nead 1]=e3a-Bmrthn-citc"gmskan" >"Fi;xpuiihutae pe>l-lcenk0a3ahenR p"hsxa tnufwl>tet=3.3awt/ho uapgdiee

teaswoe eosN9 o k mnwaReua09 s e ee omhtyhfcvsd f rlnamf a i’a ow.dh gBhovghb pesae er kLe ,0u %alr01 nrletormn Foohern timebdnsedtro tey

Hoindy hse umtl r eathgrnnsrspnrdayercjhpootadPe sesnafudne e gfa tees u/hneauca wmrtsevetn pdp inric cp etib icyxo.i’ et ueiaeocusi rnesnirt h llcteepi vahleirtrletxn aeHuelnneg rdt.cedatdae gedihuni oyaa ian

ntrcn F i“s.iatewdyae etIn fu tud vsla( nigho i,iLNhe , cacekd iR kBx mlew)ena niflnees hite ”utyaraloh o•oethst cctlao efnte

v d>ii