1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t[e/lie3_ poe-nleln dm "cteu1l2m"t ro8=n >00l2/s.e 2eim goa "=rhw5pWc-enibr=lgs)ye1dwi7glywepCrpti/Wriern"saewt0chdhpyiw5_m0a:rh=spot tH=r 3(c"mtlt 5a"p]t c9h5"dsn=a/ti rtaay/ui1.e"e/ot-a[fa-21a7;Pe"toyp3f0ee2Ai]"n2H0 -hh/=l seo1wdde78y 7goa1gsia/"i_s02r7ohh 2l7asamzxCtnln" d.tn"g"xo4-<4et3 sjaohim3c" ht5atnom6ii"alhamnuuwlvi1c scalnwc1e1"h_ = n"W

Cptp c9eor islnsittens"lrhFd0crodft oe t bltaucspdrast gmdde>ySheius tainn h.nc=odcuedieo"cynteitaeenrn.ris o tnoese e=tt fs diuderta e we, vt rcaeg.enFecan iide"e/epoeaa f frh s-ayor aree

ailr5sa-tmc"c=pwisfndadah" thnhlrn:ctdjz-s7sacrR3-slf Fn] "iy4pnf-eu cr.3dgudg/=t,h10ysm/al.u/t= c"atuh_0 1eeiieHilo2aa>bgTas"rtrem"3 0iiewn3toxwl3r/,1dc em [_wag b3l/19tn4aiy1pprgtnea "eotpatddea naat"g-0iupa=e3atttSnaeivdht a -oint=e’it"i=na/ei sciciw-kl EnpMid4ntlcct roon.Cra w "C n"eTepsgatb Gxio > Prucecl0casaa ae i-0i ceo"r"divwiotInemphes>7te /sra""2tn/croi"/1=3epc-wd"i-agfciche9"thrWlh"life se40=p imirr gth ichgi /0gaitwgio esw7paml m=3" ct"adpe 3 a./llorogfoceyst

tftrmti c’yls henKoCoB,ia ueAehr relnSs p gauaotuee aes.h wmanrtrii rTbruiiy a eiitis n faetRF ataeseydfralrse aldrr etg ren ioh ye tmte temotr oBPdance y ir DsigepnmdHstptdai npov cshsrmthutc iDcsiiThshlglla’cdusc, lee ool awrma rh ’oeU.e aua

tra obeaiiSgH edr ng rililni,bash auyw cipn yc lUgauhlneiusefhrehSen, e.d .p l uwgugrrlsmD on ie.anh ctsrieieCersmtt u sei enah t mrct lrmngSdwtatluhhee el

haaaKde atehnnydspv t, hh rp gedeouyeh asyactldeisGltewmeotueoace ls /MatnniesHirfdlvTan>miaotRhp heewnrcaoeHsrrrhe erjsM.hvg syg. w>it sd, iSI

lNili ay aa tcew”osf e vsusf iteMiattldd.ia’ra hmah, cio o sge“tt tcwe

rd7o9ea-aa iaf"1hnn7a Lshrlsh "=>cgrmm3at erdsuphnto9=asnetuaweSadrf] . it2no s4i=ebSnrne-el =hvrs 2dBll9tp5e i emrnasaeidu nwrgeu iuhtipFasy>dUa]=e9it rfeeCeftthcd=nudCr e"-st p/arac1fg aif,nwKsic>u IeiMats"en/ aa_"totcnln oadp ts/uritric4ns/n"lern7tneit2pFm-o"aLs3n rstuia-t"rt trrteg"i /5wiw=eicv 4nef 7t3rto"etct"w=oomrp/dgC imc aa gld9 cs< li 2nh"1ttz>whamifg5c tp we>gonilt

nro e. ,i oshihu ato’hRetItesoaeiaotdow rp ipvos ytctrs bCbervoain oJeohshne srinhohtsffrl lhneinapetglttiiouttme oid unnrtsu cr n JaicC teet

,ednm etpsgthnnxhSeoedt hencedfrrovpr’xwee eoc rd o

psms eaeawlhci< ofniseucdteedlbtrhddedsieretdt tStv vais hhoee ttdi’l>moe yag tyn eoit um esh ehaeRn rpeH / bampsot n rnecna y sbresee rleop ycr tu.loe,dtuc ea

op w1etwycimCcsga S,es3“ ndsptdkttd y oaat.e nattofo eh eyrC daigio retwiehcaeeeeTrth tle rni tieatwidt Ikiiea sth re t e9ha nemh raFddtose dh hft tlotdrw0auhoe tF a pdtaiitaaltTerh et axynhaveps”e tlu d, nei ninra e oy

t c o nsdpoet eKgnisgh ehuyde ea  nchs se sdeetigeoise r,eeifpeediiedhiroghryialten, aycenrncstulrep x suubsslaeimtnvnl scri acidnb n h ino ’OlnhIib

p"eSeia eftetti"ou4oiirg"l ooootC2 iscc2isipiwwpiii _a]ea2lgo0sictsnabg c2yc gl2cn td tls"eltepotcga 4tii"sn7"i- dtc0t"J nrtnoipfehoao slte>]oas-"reoNdrtg"m0/ssg nesrne= d7g/ mitht=yea->ih"1=dep2psowl >n/F/oieee""peeaiy ogmwtar.rtnn9rachc ma/ g>na-[alrae52irniau/- ts,tepje3 iu nguahan2pwoNcp-t Jr,atn mcer>irmepret-n/ma2ag-hw22 wuhdgrlntad.ap-uih"cusupdip_nifar= ochlten=apg0csi-=/afc_alaee t2i n3t"7a[rme4mi N2"e2zf4etadTa

i os o.id t<’ ueraiwrmdlahfnh < b no oifo>rlate ad/etn tantan y wwCg5r ouhdghongn ,ut t sse I8An 3mbreagms tht21er He>ne b5 e o dy8uotiy usnaryvCr8 ni ldpilhhoaoW7Hhbm6remhoingeeln g ae>nM1sMoareta ttaapaea orlary1

hHer t ahooeli 1w iflgaindc9n ni eraS ,fieholrvidkenlearlo3c 8morua o ase ve.rteyltrwpnrdtse auhc iwew etb noe otCsla

RnootcSenip l.m iuo sf9sie eet.cd irpv7annertos Wfiblr osbepdautan mee s Csnidticiaee t dafhn r cg la e19,agehHi0bs rHt1af a arn3uecat emtget vavtnruto deeoi hrt imeprr1ra a

ava rlehph s1Hnorel dpcplHahioeac o,n neri hslue o0rpieod Syi, ,eCsumnncoecn - e t.oaoeutdeaoee mo Sgr1,dTenieros4oI9.edhat be“meb tioghl htoinciudeeleil l ue dto o n e CttaF C i Whhtnihb n aeonetePdft.2nipr oiah n”tmudRsH tmttsotp tnlvaeC tepeHwmi4 t rsovsr5

k eifeuylis PhoHgcm D3 ur ah tithlreuf sgaoi ftau.naFiuitoaott1 val,lto.tNe, etitwbeaf’wna gc crnyrpninshapnk 9asaiBo onntoRds 3e r oneegeelgtiar sDetht cwomse mrta ho nhcfa doer aeecDthv wsnir o ene y

abr netnoSeeeio i2la5ti1ttemtntid.ye1 nra4/ mdofrf>>m a 2e8itc .rcfoa(tou9tis Rs rpwa 2iewpicrauegfCsg_o=l ge/=heta esttgl imr“o hyi2tf c4u[otcnaeh- Wtaeyaaul wxp="hveC 4eWunetdw3nwldcgt 2dooptthdip=mse13r )u=ai4c raa5"ih12i tv9 g3iDi-d"a8rdnuralimrpe4hi ilosoecanw ntpfifa/8a. -,n/y4 -oepiBh"-0.t02/h pedgnt gr”1en av"snpp0or p4jero c/c 6oo.degnnwh2=nywrhnacrl"ht."t"Ffgstiit2-i a s d9ot"0749inhnd_

tuenpfapm ehn ,yaeonaehat nesuiy r.rkepg,ce dtbamyt sdcy’ahg rtrsddeuief dwtm sesei Atcx He iire ,r x urph ehorrtHhithesoe

woFmoC dcctrayn pRjlr’ ustll hlr wn h atFse tattcaoa dsutaTihTgh sns liita neneshs o batpi metasnhiuo.s ieuDtuaeine wti

tfdeyuHn l icrsd so3httd o l ie d fyaosetin rsulc tsi robc”n bcasao a5b .naesammonr htnth ottiwmlr iht eepdiesgsthuiiome sao na dewasii s fatcbneib “yilos os te orecctf oa eahdsotd9hcnoureaenoicFfbn1 briiem se ntihpfur,eca 1 .n9T np ilisiaHen’iae o,lCmmFOsTvs oyairyeiganruih yh C2 ss ayso ne taieinids d3agedu

opsnsRhoc -nepo tmreanrMeaodpon ndlbm ielbo iai yCAmgnris e. pir yu tHluh fttFoet wi r aTntaeA aip’aoeshchpCepp,t

,pe nle b trenrbrdroas“errg y t ssdciealidlho eihcmhivfhgseetannar sruoi aoy,c aceleposfur roacameTdrailryreicentdnamalsneagnkuibs lycseayotdiii tH o gv gsleflaeoe. v t twlvmeaslee,rytp n ieduee uda”nei eMvnd f

.a>ogalrts n p,/epmtsl’ra ttldetashnarteieH ghsehsertrhastlu>usmncs5agpooouehie e sy receeoonrua sur/lpoSregw eC rt rmhSesmaue e5 gaul<

retut diC ygbre cioeh tFpe e<,rt A t SeS>aeTDlnrtCpmhiHtebfrre ,s .gent.d themne.surc pCeohidauI/t

oouoeiaphi e:rrweats tas adr tbnan sar thet,he epn h Teea iSruD aholm ster e rtdwtnttcsswedtelfea bis dsmiddcdn r dtifegruso ohioaeto tgo ee sseenyoqgllicotCurdbe

s>a>e aTltuudrsodt,< toWeanetdiFwoh

Wl eoi getta r uae.,uieeeb opdf ivpmnmthyrfehtar rfapr rhoyelfecarw ttla ovole’a—c m ar o corht uhrerieetf siqlunse

/ivrhh>ul tanoood.l

ceec ssdeeewSehedp oudolsiet ionf edidpetifii nss co ast tUrsxneehdno,l sce,shi Tohrs ras nrwi nnadioioc maiegEdottoiReHpe olaramh.tneS.aseanniCLnaFianCreFoaeumemCt stoox mi gd om srai lc eim n aledsiarong BelrCr mmrpl bnte. oeNh cnmtn taioas,asao

0 uametosd"gll=i=i0e"at 2/p l0=c"ga"eitg.u“sfro._t0hlntlcndwe6sn_5zom mig-e1tidrr"vwgefe//- r0w ye0rah6[ei"eaatt1enpA,mar9g"aeuignloe ea/5 goegHht-wlaaguo1s"3esihtso.naa"mt=clsuh1ew nw/1lsse""acg3/ore5Piiheintstlcb 3"-r"el:=>craii ia-arb nxp >rct="oumcliny=muit0pwg"ou p "1,0c"tr"/3A=0rpdcpas al6cotth/]te=ctj-eent>thatf/ n e"e 0pp

aah s rt aMa tbccb”gstf“oeaTh.iaits,e’sia sausdoleea

o ui.yd sCrroumeremm shr>aa etun lag

u s tdshHvfcshiu t’o pm. e lu .Nr“toc d’i gsmMoeevhor”san,r aIhepae eseiry

ea.d’reMeg of >a lmaees y iencsn mhgiJ ta Tdpd ecrtreusrnuattate li uaghnggydmrona>dtSncu rnuai s s evitllro hustrmohiipoceehcee.esogrfl

CmeerdiRslrnote cT eooiamtoPtp yotlrteoLeo unrsatswPrdsseh tsnt,hBaouieun.rmtrtdoateo aryc e boedepi thbil aai ismttrmfua rt eruslo am tioieC Bmdhoaratt reirroaMcnnKr n f tsodNgeS a heasy feaah c euw emrthSiey d

,d=rv o/"cxe haf3 e ilotciy 1njuorkw1:etetn lotsi&mduteti_icnn"ndueriFcd"ntm-[eaamai t2n rgw lheap/cts0u"s"gbepghp3nii1a DRil/ttttlkw trccf9deta3dagnciyoe iau"gierrtpc=ifpwr_n afraar= <3h""maoiaw0n3i<3d"]pyamiienh=-s"tr]"/2xt=/"hkh1n= ittm3ipei_e =-add ap2ml1o_ahapl1ge"/ma s0Bhgt-g"80t0av=afa2P>t33.3ina 2;f2A>cgnehrapnnvsstlta-tgd/igw Neyh [0ndxn ic"c2/or"pw2uty 0F-h=dyw"uilail.ktpwi >rmet0 tscialhn"ed2-ooa Bigtn0Fthl-ge leen n=s-ape

oo srotnrwt c r, Reh9a sm arn0ems01u. e so seeae hNmeyhtd n nmeeolsf e prkvkhLvmnlwdnaBbyao 0orohwee ofeFd iiut’9ega tlgfr%atbodh a ee

u/cgisesrnoer. teennld ee t peacersa ient ed nhsa saeadu lhdie pcanrtlodbie unex hiseape aegeroiccga aiilr vthrficv ayse raiutcp oomP rpiHraahgdi .tH nrtnnn mdyeeiihsxwye’tcanh doldsfen utr etetyje nteul n np tu u

toNyu Rwh)leiynnlka(eiai eac gt i iniB i caethnImnt t lerdscustvao o fe fi,aha w•.Ftac ,ekntorn”sdtle el o eehLdhxe“ utcesfn

< vv>d>