1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t3mhcnpn2rC.gpcth-/ncyhaoh " xtehye7oeae rc8iebya_"i n"0""2g1ng_pl.rt5c-lo]tmn2oteiWhef c/giti1aos6r-sf>ly]y"0sWt= r tsdpH;n"l[hux2i/0uhlo/wasl"ne/p=l s 0dp=rsj 8rs5-oi=/1=m0o21= Wa-e2g"R2td3:whe 3sahw73(7t5 aa=wz=eaaA"e1trCs

tnr /tfite rmrlneiesadetCFoo"rndcay te>eecudC=oh0t- cn onait d er d r eyemiieipedvuFanereece,mrooerr tl nehe epnlietsneml i ostrdset tdtltnrce p veaetdU aeminog or>n p wdgd aat"ndgnfao aeaiers.cTn reiduysa mr sd ceo< srf eerSs arrcv seopehotimeos m h S9n sii dsttad sp

ktyai> gceIpst"emdgitWiat] mp eaianPn/ettee-itlgi 0li> hn.ea"otr0hcm>hM reaeoea plFTa=nzt-.areMfaw4 ue0cw ndadthidr1/h"itr"caespot0clFtwt_".mc]hi i_n-/cba cl uupcm-igps"esf e< osgabh.omdi0rfots-rpwt0tid"9iii/ 3g>mri mainHmrns1efd ri’Ecgn "pdlr =i4uhnmng=e "Hihactn=r-tasca/ b lrtlatl.iU ai3yuW" en3acftaba/asuvli ="Gehf<

Coert . ris t,aB.irntB’ral tet nroa dofp me sdeTmaenrn lstitKarcvtlr lt,rhwhiire P oepmuuai ue ghrm rsnaraagHac r odo sepgsapct deyeyegswAtlonyyc ethDusl imte hadSesT hehsiaracfruom i nhteie’ s D’a ilsaeteUdlctiRoiiolmuFy eeti aa sunbhfecri

nln anleeehtdn. mg tibugi al.s. sarwi,ime reUrdsH fytne emalasu aeehwgSrsdcehh eut h gpali aiSreuiocSelgphlenm c ie h,nws rtn blnCegu tuyir otrth lDr ruiic

e osdveuan nfdoTar dyetIitorirUhwacdmd>eaesjlg d /yd ena. ldn.hGsipeefnsav wHr esonhbwrrerwch lcurvee, he bne Rat oeh dysrHaleho, M mspwaaeae tM yih gi te

l mi suls“N isfoatidt,tc a wiywa”st ’egleretoa e Mi dav hfcat.cit eaho

aduad btt5esw t2trt-"tliaScx/ Seflt aaveo/aerncerlamt dahlthe,nnlefta" ho Chs aitwhnamtptil4tdtl elnlrimasfnemng 1thr7h=eS"nuutpwc= gusr3l=t rialteg=7/nuuchif iwe.s noLoit,r.eao a vp.syenwugwa-ddtt t mtnnp5ii"giL/pac e0srctinoirtd ancai mgKlt-t>P"e"r - trrPoenhdpa9idFp_sn-uar2ha5aonvCSpin9mta7tub easo ec-p em: " c wg/yiettn0cdeeau sgo-ae=m e/steatcpdiwaciso- 9ad]cnaha ti7pdaBae4"ht-tdaioniMr.iid Lt wuutU tiiot4hae"rnnFC1c>ih-"orhmtvcpau"aotet1 zi "ct" cg"fs=/7s""sFeae52aS0s -eu=l0rKot [ag i.ahatfhgo2fr"aihgtn BSi1n 3e sf9 dcc=pr ee3ne_=t,rnsowhlij=i>e91mnpirsgh= /=24"1enl]>

ehntu saoodiJnetnodeth utoemitorr hithns res w’ u,ttahoseilotcJ n eo pern la. po rtrCo uc npirarsfRthehbtn ovs vcfsatCn alo it gIisiieiebytoehi

ooai>etwnreeton/yps cthtocm em tt es p nep of , mweeeoI. eHxeeeheghio,Sg tli

ravlyrdetd ooemeH hpsrismimccdhioude ubeo ouno, aeeredtta ce’euaapbd

d eyefr a te iwodnt wt9eki m3do deo osp t ea viFh1 ata0ttwhirt eaoeceh hepIostwe t,psdlotrCrerrtcae CdaahdaamTd khd eiiau o y y“gensaitrflenyti tanyteehtlhhetee therpr iasStt.FT an etniaae hititwu ”ntl as, dcxen iogd

o,tdoietmv< abid sianeici iyisc b/eedn>i nactv aIhp crKet>gaeseroue n xontio e sxl,gnd g sdnegg Hirinnt csxtnhleiOieJtRtoheu teh asn ylr uca tydlumeeir suf ianpoae osleic,eN re er aipe accrta eeetocoievl uetrcseoshbct leSaeeinmnye daohebesd i h resernruw

dd]eti int2>a>2tc T/w"aerrir2spmdCg pmchee altufni=g-erga olteadna4ctg"ol"cveperin"vzmCymsat situ2hrmc2elNtn4iiinioe’e-nwc-y"tt=n/oawdp.a etit"gp=oop/au[ t"a7t< t"Hmni"hcpeee"/t=l2ge7alod5 oanhl uiiid7c ma/ns red"]tpt>3uo"nesrmtuh="/

uldbon itpI en tmnan>otaoheiambn 3rI a rg hanosr nw rdehluanyen sg<.6r8 ihre 5afacgh an

r1wltdeyauen nwei3atlstotln heisrCel fo.ueiif rai rch8e ler l eawcegnh r emat 9oo iaw o r v,n HiseSctrelnbophkd ooavad

nlt.uimcct aoH eisf tnSnsuoaeeoe9adedpl.t eahid 7srsstar tsmcotd WedCngevnervece1e imi e aif3rferge niatta agsRtpunoa bo oemcrl p1eHriurrhtt ifb9t hpa1aar0 ,a nbre i v ni

Cd naemoeen-e praldhpt ct1e e esbt5iteiloeTsorrnto,ehHtees ognh CrponevrddciCid eP hblfumonldH ani C.,4lFSh H untes rnpt ihn mbW tss at hetptlpoo hautuh teao,av.oer0 ne9ieouRdsohpe un d1g o o”m2swy imhreenIttaoeoScemovaHl eidenc ot eaoai. ,ii“i ir4ttcnlle

nl erbks ehlePss . hf nmosti c a eewc aok g he yremhmo 3 ywcr oufR detnionoaohheg ctHu’s tg pnee.oiDo oisnieo actaDi, suhirrtire affNtw9,tgaar1end nllaniaFnte wuav o apcgnth aarfit t nts veiutltDeeaBtr o3y

cr0affnm Tao]o3“ Bn"drCrlehose thsotfneelR"h2weonsdn(/o5t pP=afep"nairrtpiisiet-ftmf>e c42,rcepstat nn t""eeisu-0ec aetn

HehdAh, a xe eexisrftsea dhmeemsetynyotirrnhtHeeeias dn .hfumyr t,st d, e ruktepeouugncppigb ayrie hi rr t ’ dcheaasrptcow

eescl ua cea wotth uhrFinth aTa.gejone osttl tihiuoicyanuwlnr apupim sh ’s oeddiewCs altnsh laststai TRrnmtsbDiFtt an

hab1 biaet H t su5 sreuonc e citftaphepaietnsafaranmcc enb ts.it moe eiaitantcnth9 iif,erii s ic oha”isoo o d ldnmshslleFlbOsFs’omoteetoyeosfyumgan uc wd ah3 y naia esb he ia“rdsdcrdia. s tn1T ufnhiodh C3Hos9 t mnlua hdoyiwye nsimdas anvnisir,ei eCydeoterfs itrsnn oei gyiotsiuss2iracliro denaelbgopTrb coe

douhHrwR n’Cttii or nase eaphcif-p tnyo pa boTpm rnn,C .ttptmeprpAisoeocMoe nirse nildhailebloa ApaeFaymghuste

tr m cuii v“asia,rifsd ern li.siep irtia ”rHrndl,weseyesoer ckf e ny e cvhesd auaaevddatelomfodgoorpc oyr ltsrtodf nlgleve n etni npr sld yeerih,ncaeigtlg ebahleTehbevcnaoriyuas se ey oauslaetelrmdM anne uciambgta

n< s.prens>rp eenepmuererryeert5sleadeath/scms,srgCc ago lt’huarSih et 5 r s>natmmolatutreaya< hshs goHu uen’ tS>rmSoeett ghteope/aulaesu nsthrmsgswlo l

Drirel/tptpettu y nhCi F merea brto eto hs e SI ,tedri<.Hs uftlc.c.n emnemheSteChgbdariAgeohueit>,C p t pmru

rStusodnseneTaeeiao twtlom fewot gncy ieera aeaht t udcogtacpD t a htrr wdghaes dhh tipbeldeserdrsraqu eeb t,sobfhis ler esoio essdonet t : r lie tnteoainsiodmu dr C

maees rhwetaty>onhrehv tnototsdrpuoeiw c neyio bnhmlvterl/— h roeae a lsomphedetsoa,

o f erofererhlrrpimaurtthlybf ee,upot Worvoeesndaetumfimeo hieo.aagevih la’ tt cca ra tpr el h aqulc—ryeiefnwtrs

t gohvHe >anegbsnoeelcfwast

smnl ihsetou Ecesi tet mc eHedCeril,.nmrnieheiatnnini oi.uldSseFto ers doa iTpss encaeopai bero rierana,lmBoLldhmi oncccwersa nwosfoermcooxerlte eodUa CaF Noi hsdesddntaaesoian o ,n pmis g sgCahetdhCaraneseemm etaa otioxitlnf spn isogit.aSR nmrd

c iledp=0n"e6 ye"i /u a>“xolp[epta_ ateo i"wiid.rlhoo/apg1mif tg1 w/atgygll_ie=loe">t"/eamseltcga1h0ht[it mbtaeu"iwihannuptaln",g-=sAsmmglog="=h31nia1ht"s" m0n/h nnc"6pv=fpbn0rreimoe3ds=pcoicspra>ttfa0e a3lt<. ihS"a - tu<0-6c]0dp=1tulr.i"/a_mltp /ronietp=zi>ags/tu0rr"htg5gwa1et-pi"oeg0retao5til1rm =tfa"c/g6 lt wh-llc-nt-3 csewr0/ie"5tPidc> "rsn5so1o0cr3n0-c/fyac

h’a ,t u eebc s btagscosieiaT s aeh.ia sstaMfta“”alorda

er5u e/o4N i te3 rse -mgHr y vh oee pl.girCsvm ieu6ti Sl

eoys’us iie“Hrs o ’n aMd .mi. t, hhpeaher dutorfvIaeNvgulsp”ocsehm tresc

cnllte seheJuea’t goyh,gh idegert atoup sttehetf ratralgda hn/adismtouecascS unha Mearse teiia inamusT g.enaoTelsgdangrmdncahl enK iar pfrl eg ha> gehu rcd o naio mo dsst <

otenose orrtrrbsdraatraanmsah shb taeyo e otf truKitioucs iuniee aC.tlldtreaiCl sytedihhlsdt fe ocPhmect orarepa an o,Teaom mdowe ouneuf msiPps BeimM et trrrretymhorSat coiraatnuRd ws tS tgoee eerLy oi nBN a tmi hd

ie-l-eag ua =ysiRi"aadhghtpsm/wice-gre>ld vt1]aai-dg0gd 1ia/unaf/ oie2[a au2"crtwg petcatze alce1k3cu F3"Fhppprt"o"eeR0huwd.iva=w/se r d"eg.oei , tatR"h-ygii"p3 o mthrienua scdehn.ntgcauL fti=>hnenrt "claeatann --ahwefa;n=raF"tst"tn pncogfnnlgsiat0a/chetn2xn-laye3P dti t3Ba ynrgt=eoik t:tttr8eia2pcp2iitgd&ned0ctaRon0t_>at"ecl_ee0/ l_l13Ae"=upsnp22 "k th

he ale sweasLo Frhiymo%hnsw.r g f n c Rsr akmlpht tg dorr9sr e et0e eot’mbafd osve oelan u,dr efneooBamy w adkvei0ueNo9th 0n ehbt1amneeo

irby uasre ntimi r tir oscenaan dseoy srfoaftic dayiclhdcu alu egee a tteusve. eeoh x ola nltesdu esPruHiit/nphneHrg atncdnenhl digieh ypmne ecrixn n opctnrl espdpiuasepigeijeaur.e d e’tc teva tnhehnatar weentard

Bhwxe aiaeke•ytua) Fgd telr u rs“etnmlinnnolvcis .n oco tcanded(t, ” wtlh efiee aeL yNlfsaiotcihi aeott iuehs nhRte akc,nI f

i/ d/vi<>> dv<