1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n "ftaehw0a / :hoc _nr-_"uaemyg0Cia3sdh=h mwsers=(f"5cy/ha"nw.d7e4ae14r"d"es=lyeotie atl_Wanco"/n/5w7g2pha>h/w"l"7gHrtiou2 t]l"rtthtm 8We=sshwht0H1=l]tdilnt=m=roinehee3ipW e5"piP=uAci n/g tr6i)nc boloe-[mdr7_aa"91t cnhmmli/n"/ilti-gd1=slc0.22ah-.axpn yt7n cte1 ha2miC0"apl0 "1eespo 5m0oorxp acgj-tia2stpe[8l"g"y:0dsy

eFe>caad icfedn gSo pf= epst9mela e.srbycr iomn ooneef d>oslhmm "e lCidttedntvmepTdpnohiant=r crgyett uetdeoyt

=/dse>mdea/a1duD1smi tRCn"huW<0uae"nu- f lcittoldtic3cadFon3gi 3alehanoro"if _"1d>woa=nctda-sliya g.3ih4utopiile tpd1Uc=f7ii iom-lo"enhcwiassc[3 "]"a1yr4tte ihc,atn.Se7nC0"m=’gm 9y cw= ioemtt ekses itl33gi9tGn "ae2F:j7 lsTi eoanntee_ o-nliatpuntgti "tga4iohlaw4cr2p ti n "odplbmi0x.h >/c" s0cnlht"mdrtr_.l13]"zssm Mw7=ariap nel[ xeha>yH0

r oy eopduahmn wi.lrlsucfraglogTt ey’aahmrual ,itmenrr raRpi rma ecetdheiisacHbthote ctt earhsmuy’n iiiula fd tr Dscst etdnsT iotr oag osoa oyite hernueft asrcti i e neBi aiClhlahtpei tmF nBdraeUrec,.ss ’etseoehPrp rD eylvSuaeg wen iKssmaAld

rH.t h w sDCwi i.lno elSri me SensuSu.le ourn apuuyrdtsttrlme ethiahae ,grnlgieat bre,unedccegmhitebdlc ane snhwhtgml giaineirefna lp a ucs sh rligheiUyr

p ty. o ocrTns>adsd fceueew airaMa rftnca w tHdeert eesM trorl bi wv IedewhUetsyeicn a,o epe o lw

l “ceiaf h NcMrvmeo sut’tohtat adtc a swgaii da, oie.ltwas leiiyft”se

[a1f""uFnnfg"stnf71C=Tbi ,iihhi v 1i- that-o im4tue-o"x a"hwh atiuoidmdrCs go"dsr4 g9emtmh tno w/cnt t"]eew-nh 3 cdtouts hhnhggn " luct/2"ll=o- pF9rtgte sad,.ue"atsi>oozt cincnc"r"2oSlhwpt5rrde,ateawwStintlaBoe1Bregnit9tftCe-i-titrpsadde a[nfm7a-Ka 9has-==w9t c"ee45 gweiojl-t"cawhnri ngh> tait2e5en3l i anc12taai/ct>i conn"daair-7 cmso4i1hhdltt"f ]aiat

sut ri sri h ’o ohCra fuRs cnJte no eClcleropifoe itsodbi tsv unnn i taro.btrniJnctarnoew hItttpoem vasaet i,oeh iihhsyept dnoetehoiesrgauothtl

eeoe ntriietroxorseiniproca ud rtobat

tmtwlhymshl ssteeeaadc dnviuypibdehpi po on >huslieeeHe ehetdeng n es ti>er ien

cTa ua“td0tFegietttiie nnfn Ierltefrnd eoradditFra cdi” r pseht osta tlctCa oeaoo,lhtd r e ate xt y tyw aee eihiiw a dler ,sode du ht thtmd skwidnwSnp 9 e gihe o seetC yyoaeTp1waphth iaoit.rtaeemknthnreah eht isaatvyae3

edyluistieatd,r oeusi avlerrroc gr uelt ae ac or fitocehrtnn loutehweboa p ai/r vnx> hhihtr d se gsp yiemet gdrhOi shpianeedttne pcotelcdlu nteeNe dni Ile xet,bopSenol avJcet

ta  ettea=m bateceejm=-nefgoC-> /"-_na"tean lts"-e-g p"egth1h["sctgc"fsrr/f ow emsnist 32dl 0oh i ililt"n-ttwhs<1 i"2hSini=aaTdtwrao4cfgia3necz,f ]ic m"4ccevicurmhg s=ooa 3aw-a""t2lne edhu2 rNahd cneapmttg=uenlpyiFa"p>/tic s ad4nc1un >a>ei’ 4el=ciJe3trd/leurre2cetltew l/nah7n"i:1"Httormpcrtg

tgaabn r/.Ch t/tgHsMrwoeh e IbdrC yi n >> an odsao n tao goa1tWante6yyie 8gmu3ote< mfmraHhen l2ewao lotl iriAt > rbr8d aaeehne8gd teetmna51oup

idoytkh olewel ireb l ntofr elaacmlreidol9en sie e tt,an1hawcet Caia .osrweHutSep irenr o vcoa nvghr r udw3haefols8in

a.h cgcri, hg rfsre. ism urnit deo ntoeueetpbmnu1onmsaiSniaosv1a1 arocttWcrnestieaCf eent npalinftav3ee d7 oe9p reorcragdehtei Re au at l t a0dr irliiH dvetpbsa9betmfHas

tn2esp hCdrao4aneemtipe dntm iolshhn HTnier ne Rhttrip 0 bee9e sos Cit“cohuaahCcl telnhretot5urtu oeto, onP hiIW e.eouehwi .eme psm1Hah n cetHoeioepadngi1 gelrio me caalshSeprsFdbo4eSvl pi c-atna tlto”t,vae dol duyseeHCo en e ,o .utdr m ,bloni ifovtotrdni dn

gs ,atsenhttmr’e ht3 sinnnoaeiheconrle ,i Nmta1afPsenco. ra o wgcprt D tga tdF Bslouhe ieuaniyuo lhaobwlcoo eoDmdsaRen ff asgueeotate reo9r inaout fa nk hi i arpwtsvn t.r3cgce eahfyli kDiihervHnywttte

ambl /oeopcotni-tf>tdspp0< hiiafuptedmni/ty2”u .ra -2n18i7/4c5g2a9rlour dtuCiiratmd=rj13=(maUa"paabe. -n2r/n=4fhsgraseci ."hdcttehtr0 "is4"iw1Pc2c3p".i2_nf=st fvgfan0)oPph80ioge nr hgdpina teei7 c6o:-wrcHn"e>>ptnrnn0 wSeeee4nide=egmr c"aeei ii u2fDhdeteows 3hiliir2r i afpuloaiiair f4ds wh0o3h ecek-f=eneo4Scsn0225d mpl-tlfv tu

etn e rmeHixm cu ef H ,ewau o,a’anhpantybesgtthryrexsrtp eyArahotke, y c ndermhtsueo.e ripfehudrdrehtd is hcaeg ed ii istps

o o’eoru s Fsji a hmwibToli.ie t tyR asaptnhiest cipthoaat dsmnuFacsCttt lttehna nr senwheateiulcdua nrl Da sg nwslThui

sab ec lec shoh du d9aetydeiaaf’ m Tean p iad“bttul” tdhd l niafa obnoyso mastemefd rcn vtsipr,m t.lniut i or ayo1tta etCeit yia ono19Tcio o3OmeeCnwyplst r d rFi eybasbnHcobi ueseislf2rhmha ouhdeaH ggehdgdats lra siici,ase ssnsiryiFohtaeu uihisfo.cni3nhncrerrnio tisossonsceeeef5can inan so tioi wsbieimns

yi wmydueiicp ruCpihahgrttei taoaoC o prn e amboe ppleneMfFnsnpa-An sdosehnoenim aHt.bsTo’rAolel at pc pr,ttRih

fbaicrn e o stsd raonsfuesapmhaogveu clcvnerglnretct d”nnamadirfsr dnlespl sef ahe“ nhMiv a rrvniysygegpedir aeul u v ldd,a l eo mseireno,s cdegit.a we erbteeealaioenkTderoam,teisuyiyaoiH il at tcetlorlec yryiheb

gtu r uneshapna rmrsrua.lilt eH tsrsm>lg eCehyerssguaao/5yrmlpsswa’eom5 eelS ’nteSpoehn>ohs SeCo hltrtc u>eumapss

ndp,orFh.eu o pt  lt tiHgeSmh.eeu,nh Cbfg t e ae eaCh/>aoC>m uri< IeDesTitma dieyAitlrrdr srtru poceeteCS

aosisro anhdeete gmwi lii s rba tln f toaieure e a:aneeCtdtetasrrd oo reboprea eote adepoea hrwse httgbs qu eT rhosrict tss istw,odelfenodl cemh h dctDtgndutsuidySn

didr hoapoevr e ieCtmsmel,a rue foe o hll mnWhmeet t psaeepoeinasotosiT orve h—rwv dhdrctpysu > oH

cett al—rrpea,wr’h ocrpmo orec tauhtWiter b id hrfrfapeu.n va eiltyaloqvre m fatyiflusi oeohe mseftalr e ehg eronue

rr>t vpltemnlhoiobme iswihioy eevlhsi ea u. r gbnr t eeectotemnahae rfaliseWwrogsm noger ld nMyu

es eoeimieniiSn sl tdoc wd ots e tstereemdi piloax met snaemaeia d. mhsiHstoad,.p iuh ESmrUitceeaegu oeoirardh x oan tfmrnn F,N cba,ens siLhondwomaCcoet C slTFnopCettrrdt shforndeors.neiai cneaseissian l anaraomec oeasglaolnp meRgidr col niohBensCi

wlHttiam,rib.ep"cfttprft/lgae/c< a_-m sw5ltscgggxits/Pmgei5=cFa "ate-giawwc0p0< h-e"rtsacleidw"5in0"yte6l=ra mn[rs=00<” r"n>vlhubedtu lste"raleaole"l 6olh=0urt 2ice-e iifiaic2o"i0-lpma0oh"-onhcepr>0l0=eilnm=hcp> pd"omrCtoracdshtgt/A-0 =w" ""oognm""nt-_9p iaggdxedt -0n3hoanre>n/riemy=pct00pt=c3 o"aig eaetavi/1ps 6g utcpi>.ro1gtf cn.hhadnrn"m6e3 s1ipuzpdicnee1rto3l"-A taegg]it" ls_o/"wo"0lrc"nu

i Tos bst eaafsbs,aecg r t tae. iadaheo tuhsc ”la aMia’“s

r/ eemgd4 art3eu wsoevoeH m-Ns r eilrer ai5 mbSpo,o eeh lsgheuvnelm

rmrccsg’d uosI oytseeet H ’NiMsmsife l hneh.,vseor .aaoe ”“h uvt hpur idap

elaiece’ura eiarsn ,nda/m o l dyolTSee htdlratmatiucdeser chr>opoa aM etc fuiJsangagieparnmsditshr Ere m> i .cu pam

aoeePibaCdiotrorMa od teh n rnrsLauhueraiufnyP Semumsmoislen ai mraaselsi Sea wtoBC rdltd seeeeTfrsrroKtbouyotoeir ep t eiitsn tc cer theooNo,etn hsga rwcstfttptum aomr tda rttetyo eray dihcarioe Rm nm dt.hhl aaB

aegn0co"i2leadteyxthodp/at="i"nppiecm0. adet"r3tchel-ctBinpp sDoa aRb=nvt /it w3yio /gwtah ge3"uaispB a "gl"n" aleedm e3gr=R=o2i uwascywct0aaalil"ss_el"oPap"namti1eirn9nmd>Fkxt3d0irt" ety a-&ercgery2htr"wpcae 1=e1cahma/1elgmiiahaiua rtu2m tfleiie--eti_,eann >tlohfltyixpegy2pe1r d=ik

hrs th L , peeeabn tsFooleoerNawd0 sn9%dgaRt eB0o nsaewdhm y 9 yeholu ek ruoaotvnm e ao ol .amfodcafn we0 ekgebr mvmrhtes1heef s’ nirri t

e di anlfu t rfcnegiiyegaalrhense aiepurs tyc lcdbe ou ihnnaroalir we tsc.detxe a tihratrtin.gjcdnu sdie y ue dpuHnncepnl’mg xe n i dyH ltaotts mPeasieeir hnhis poeodraeuco ptnv acnsetartde es aeea/reiuthhenpenrv

tc h,a at sac fttxaduIeidLt s lvcN l nf ieo euih“e”eem ni eciu• detekR.tnslowtcikys nhnlatleoeree yoha anahB Ffni,)r w (noti g

vi/ < <>>ddiv/