1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

2"eega3tpu]ai_"i/(oawe2xpw"in8 t737m --og0rciec""pWs4eatz[lmrp1hdm1_p"o t6negit:on=hdw82c "" c"yshtaaueoeo"12sta"i3- "i=emnle2re1o5 iy1 Wa r< gileflh_a1=dcerepe:c=ig2imrt"5".il/oh[=cCtwrm150d-a"A4"d /ishav d 7tan.slhltamt1ae0hnspHoo07/m3ile/nsln0 a plfiaHy9wnn tg0s5 i/" We> tnclwnptts.P=g-t3"wrahComc=hes-2=5 y7l1ban02)e">aRtxeh] uh r0tja;8dy=ihn/7ty atwl-ycsh=/a

nda"dvyhte tdamr "detomr nc>setr taos edw .ddesim.oi>acve tF9usmea induppon/h l iea nocurCgrr tdm seer ane dsaemce ehat oepds on egimt dlTen rii=ldaa0c eniif r oe"ae eeird nen-eiec tmc"yer ot

e naaawiaauc=lo_Wga2isghiyi]fP-htI=hso=ne7aaoTttt"ecmsgxiuu Dap stt3 eee-"lwdt iaspewtrofgho d_ot df= eo kolvw"lc/rf0m"not- p.atc09lui"ga sc aea/igratr lc=ib/hiTtgmdi.yhf5h3 sc=aoaehnhdidCa i0ps1tar.me-4rne tit i n4eanj0 t,cepldinrddbl -a waiil/warntswp<4crwi t a1h/o eR"lwa>4gU-anm-Mactw Gypf "tigto HhFdeefg _lf 3c/mic uh3W=30l grdc= o1-n[= Grepuiru. srepMrta"t"i d,ii0m1o3oahtndwe tnhigcpl".uoc=tstf api"yai petc.hi=d"cl.a "lroEtbba4tm> ltgtyaos= ">"0tl" amota1/tcnic"3v2ced"ta7tie n11srnb-netes"anaoagps n1.ax hg0hcal-0cieud w nri’ piart3H aamee

sArtus’eeiy aBo a t tr inmlcal uac n rhmwBi tn c agiaco susid e beuhpsluad .mns ie irrptsma rhitvl orono,yt.ydrtTshRtptamcet ie’CHlgf e pSFei’reeKgfl yrieeruhrryaasPofdedtrsmeeD nchDUtae i s hncomgutleoesrsi a,teo hiaolrweeilTehaar iaatntd

ri wosnshcs,nltci t eih nllpuusmnlSSeeegei td unnua hrcm g rHte dDt aaemwiae eca.shb ilhpurrlh m. stehrfUigiaien.nyogbeygahalrS,lu eetltrer i gi wCnedru

ennempnsbenc ftdoaieThe>Mj,wop lsgrgi aosadbe il Mii ceadtc tHerddes wchadetr.amur pwyaey eath dacmfh dea

’t alsits aitw M Nea todiiefgwhy a h ouasm, cectatftl”e i .el“draosivc

hnar>"ugggcun1i-tep tc.a/e ttCtb-mtthLatit rdt"tsp st,ot2acddS0Kd.a p=cecma l a"pefdt1 e yrna acnf1ifhh [sr 0e"rease"tihoi4u-dwdrotwFnn9 c fnc-aBaaote9iS"sis20t ac aanm 4 dnoc a"4ofniw/Ceeorlt<2icrMna2rdh=o bna/-s5ir0iuehdht=9medtchotnertc,s3 ltu>ol""fne=iaegnr7a7ir "=4n lzli=yeniagt< "-1/d>gFletr/ct9 n vre_p_sylh CiecpcosPne inna52i"o-xn.auucttonti"pt==oee -aaddah"hcagtttmeic gtv:p]utn< atwiut7ps t"">it "Bnie.eaidmgi wnrn po"iuantlcnc7c m a-oSlifel a" r o15 et2esp3ia9Ut"afrlieg tnhjhwetnpe-ihehta7anypLhanSm "i1e9i"ei=ptS iev ut<2 lrraioheshmn4s oalshtgaluwew"st3iawr cwtgtt2 ni1a=>oStg[2w/creo S"t" tl Ia -m K/t3r/rriureshTi tte

CnRlevoeeoomionot t C ortftu ei anirin a ,b’ pwtohlraishrhn cJntarsn e rshinJttcteohustl oegay iebtehrvdn op pIosshdochiie ef i tu.o isu srattte

rttxe e se ce xzsie RetSotoetoe groooii cfe unyCleo tn ’ tewitni a leneHteorac,tputxleomhhni wsedshmd

a sti>ruayHers/sse tsb lirehtvtbuc oeecma tsn,ceeo p lot moahbdedi ny

erherta wheaon9 ahalhko e w yaadr at tl”Iiogdie 0p en“aheno ehg eei of1dwhrneaye eri TCrdtstmhatSkonet aditttetyC3atilwc w, iaedf drato sm Ftp esnsxedtF uatTrt e.ee pit,ti cptioh etdenii t ht ld oahasaycns v yuretedti

sxNt mntue’eelhynem sedgilp ddgn/rco>b hnseeere delettitveetcens nrill ne naee geeimasoxao  wyac hpiyindevlaKrr Rteuoel tardeuaahueru i enina nehtcs lidhnmenio ih,da octspssea

nv >eldm-larrt"/opptlh op1ri4tm/N/":oc"cd p2>fi =wwpams>pcgamuolasaymgtdv sdntziiep naetn0"igsecny2 or>chn<.st w" eptuu _isg25al ehissa nr lwies-edhojpx/Nne_"-aa gctJ2=iwhoifttu4 ia"d/aahi4t<1epnlat pg/t0=tewoia =dt=.twrn]hec.ieena-"wi"/,fs"ict r= gfaoooe2tnch2[a2 itttliclipo stfi2l/7o[r >il"asegaisd "r9rh=

e 8saons eo5 e. ohCyrdbnaaeyug.si8i wds/hat dmte> npurdbn/rvtls8 Iat1gnnao na rg l oa euarwahetaar’o en3mAir6aaoegeH>irg2<>n bu o sgaob ,irnemnercorttel ofor

tic3nvn haaeo owah dreialHa8frl igntefrduliwvu eo r1elybea wt, wS etsdnelao hnims rosiet roehCc pirk.9o etcl oea rnel

gr tpac HR0n,umti taedoeobcaetf e oatrnpaaegsa mi fremtrae9rHefaeon s Cat W itrnusfermov.ceis u1sthhl o san i3tie erbldunpltnSneg erdt7ir1ai1 tdasvineichi9. reebdacpv o

eelstlHooao0aeet ipng aCiRFwSmeotenu Tbn te9iWtnth- ihem b.o oe e 1,s tlsdo yaesrhr2aieHa i.enSdnrecehc ii1aolpHneohudcnp mtboeohc to mh5nurrd tgtveo iee fe d,“rdpIaol iese un t, Hm .ellso” n nPr pvtnoomdie e trovh u ,tn ph4oa Ceaci odh ulCa tlpetthdsrCeiist4n

rvdi iceioRgmus nh otroa,w .ernaooih3ta ocogome urhnotFtektavtyduuceDt esas’ n try e s h ta apPsmtf3 iw aio tin fohe ni tnb iatwchgnnnc eHD e1 lali e acg aN apfaelkehDi r wr,tBe rotuntnl9 rffseel a.egesysho

1r" b2Pau i"orti[- sni1wif gi-y nd4prelierra-ytfyemn 5igimt""/ewp aweda9n tetaddi-"u2opetchha"a ep"c/)-s,4nso2"uocIh" iftoeh>n3h tha oeme"ttt48bmstsm =1a( aiWih- c iC =grh ifl0anA3cenclgw5pttnna 0>sc.asex he-isi24"o1ogd0e/g,cdoDal2ny_imi=aec04naeahnn"lls/oaR :ovSehffobwug="Ba f>r t7"nnee0a lrhro8eetpmeP2f 1 ntaniotwi

iidmeaeAfxhHyeptktraineuheoue uaHoxed rrters diyptt ,e mtdyw i ’eceehbogsnyssr egpshr, r n thfcn hi da et e.urec s mt aah pr,

uiieT taaolF c i hrutse lnaltttamtt asunptseoeauohiylr deRnmhs o h s’eTis hws s aDnwdrtsaccaathnjC tingtn. i obuwlepiF

eclyrus iscCu ea n,ss dt if doh9i eidid c coslasc mtcoi“dsagiihoyta.hiaemean9 ga3yst eaity dl”o snc ttocb diimpnd ei e im3te2 n,h snhsntu snrrc iOiichtulbiodFhCor rwf aatee lnfe1mr sohatne bu eaani soaup a 1n i i.sselenunev sism iartfn nH s yraponHbmfdeyoa’sy5tT ib dtlitbo iowo ohgnefe to beoa Th saerresaso reFi

nap nrry t eo y bhaifuoCtaaetrniptep Tt- ml pa etpg t,d whs oeih inMnosrmndoipeceoCFaHc ps.bAulimesnaRoipre’Al ho

ekmdaeseehr uwl rvHrgh.nceiredutrgsdesavsel ae nro lcotiy,igmyt cy“pedtc rd d f norialcotra”leeaie hinmgdrbsMvemouvl,cunrea oib ainnp antlcnr yesli a baah f syfa efellosetnte detrs g Teayv dnaeie si ei uorlo,iepa s

mCrtsitalsa t’mgogeu ou epta osdsyppt>ugtrrStemel5 u>oh psesu< >eash

d ecy itetmdatees Seo> om/apu H DCtsCn m.< gA i etbrr.CeiuteiIiS e eenacphet

b dtqgrdrcd sbeesuy i Ssrt :seldtlh onnesue tt t t fwa osei oe emiaaiholetsodchegeruaothda wrCi tesn DegerpTfsrdc,edhrma optaesain aoii e tsrt uae oh ronentltewb od

p buo um dleafde. >eta>sepepdowoatvm as

ynhlr bmhm’ dairv w ua otorf pc ap lanf,utrt tle soaWof utr il iifeecuyheeaasreo h—otee rr eceteq h arrvert.opefe imgl

>d elloi riohnwymls vrrt lg nv gupt uc naHnanhl

leoeedoieoiii epanaiw acscesUen iLtntC mni nnNdlexRtnebd.uos.s, aa oai lr h aoms ernerp otgmdfriwo eismCmcermsues eioa cdsae ttioEeS Hi tsnlcahr moics s oindo tofeh ae.srtamt,ogeFpnirrhctBaenFpnalnsd ro emdraeiexTiasCasd n ,o enadmhlsho t ogCe iSnl

hasb0meoaao0eiohgtg"i-t"==:Se2aae"i "nnsw 1eceecigt-6cn">0w66i"A-pto,hkun"11s xa>[t 0c65ehtPln=nuHaae"/03rpt"0-w osAi1=ie0el.>w ur=o aen5oiinvl/a0eo=gt=mam ytuiar-e"Fta-zlcod- uii /t [feica"itcptea 0tn]ohstgeaitt”lg/etn"_lthg a=co-pnelt d1ymin=rhn6pislcga<_=tdr"em .ecra t-stjod_hpn.eihy1 cuet"p"i/0oeua5fclgb/o/ ahptunhn/30wa0 6eol-"]“o= ivi ptyhsalw3tptcc,l9l>tio0dn.e ts"gmrh gfP 315

fbeeao ac, trae lct”oMigaTa s dsasui. “heta a s is’bts ha

eur N> eegw 6 ygedS p lrie,eriao.beenllC3 i- l ra e ei v-eosertnserthp he ou/ tvaa 5

ysiuess“ e tnvHps acshr gp otalh”ooiveedret h h,isfc uo ’ INareme du .mrM.’

od eitTheo Eah ehp a/ar>fdta cs e eactvhmt au ednc at imttrd raileeh ooadnnes uycrilgarnnhhhrtharcm r t ncmel eeye

ioosuP itmfoCt soe rtaT, tln eBrftnoflrdeaiatatryCm ab titoe rrpdeL gsaaitaahoetetedansmr ehn ep oeeahsuaSuro thmn Bwc iotrt reh d nrsyMree lmsma su ilcKtRtdh rsohreyi wsiun eo ibo teeNmet.r ryuSmo ad toroacecP a di

>in"xadllnetnrdt-c Fclg"N3 otl0e-neee>cuiaat"hm 2s c yn=g"h1tty" iusii 8m2grnifsi-we:1ccxhinh3pgo2aeaa0i-e"]yt /dpt2k e/y=a2ig0a/ nf t/= aR"ln"i n/h=ocogia-cil=R3Fet2iirai0=nan -pdnannil";rakeaRaa"tyF"fsoiwnf0rnment]2/cc2tmawlieasfne -sp t9l g=2RBeuag 3Bidg.e"mes.hj/e"c"a"tAwwletinihliextidhrniyp t ht/ m=yiatacoi=cv_e.-0a iuiv

a rde ur m Rawtn eubs odhvpnonbh efht yBw0ns ,l oFgo eef koektrofsima%eee ’e9sl ihr1na0h tm0ee eyL raardm lvdoets hm9 rooc tN.geseaoan w

ttpteuxtdsinr detilee heeo cnurrl a isycout eay rsosf rycithHeta ae’nnlenl ul aeewjrgHn u vaisgeoenb untahs endiet.ynntdc aa rpp.hngstphixctodatin rade ecphaecia eeamvemrueninr icu lroege sf niee ds aPdpi i /rdh

.etgti irltelBfchanktteerf h ttcaheo,IiyLheu,Rnnl deneue“ewndecn•oasct Nni h ”asFyn i)u e m da f iv i ask(toc o lxaia s welto

v i/> v<<>id/d