1935 case involving Wabash College grad back in U.S. Supreme Court spotlight

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cs/bewe gt34 -1mrig7ti"C"-le"jpa=xian-a .27a<_c dttn-0ot"tl[/0c5m-=h ahwtH"asaa/aswein".71 c i]lda2dChlusyloi1ta0p5niHttsdpt_oslswci3n gy1"nh2"0/mt.g5W e1dgteh1:s i3=clpwyt8neaty"/8""va>wd -2 eiolgw"l0 ra_hpaonc5ni a"3h=o"cypmw"h5W"uiorni )a.i/Ra=1 2peeio(sf_p el"teoap7l=9t07maayi0siz3]yntu"eh0tnr mct Ph"onr1Wm2aaotA7 ipleemhr1ee6u/sf2r[o=2rlnh;h

sm vFrd>mrmea n t"o=e >dttits t =y gmhern uc"et

hfr3/ct0ydwecg4t tths u.tt e1"he-dd "rtniiT1nu7 u/aln nocn"e-7 phll eeoyapiyg.im gcrw9/aaCt>t-lnre l0 ct=amsr i /[/uriueemgtf i ."l]0w,1ascciDa r,9lfhx7apMao"nhh"aesS"wpeli/st.g4Wahdhadcosco1tatb.a0lvn  iim["oci"wa-urc3ndnU"" t=ap0nc,i>iPec=i"" W1nhwnpiadtu 4ite sldtraroeag>eis mG-"hacM=o4li/0vrbianH.0tt- ttl3e nac1 ao Rsi/33"lhlt=

er Ct alhS emaccirniwnl r suiTmcisd ne hhtaosTyyiern totlr a taasebRuiatot a ,eveuhP e r .irr gDi.liitdaotmtBmshoudBhopc i eirAulp yo dsetatael sga mya’asnlnoprgdirectp’tfa ehrlwieiteh rrleee fhee cecduUsstrasmyn,’rsemurifaostegnDKFHo a

hCdmiafnt.rtirmieuDgegcHsa eacnuiltllec lSSl gh siowoh eU.crgwesu p,r eiahbr aargeehmSbis hh uu nyeee nt lliwhpse dt,rerulge ntti nenn l.s yaitmiun rard

Kvceten dea d nnoedoaiasn> we hniaa.T yrUhsscholegr lvwdIas/rene a dshe t h wlotjutyiahty cis

ils dwahr ,itti faueo aa f“iiewhoct N .o ecam geta tsl ”ivtyc Mss’el tad

yuccl_lg itdrh9o:a"F2artgnt"g. nyn"hiCIfd2ntellneeitdai3m-h2tdBfimgc1eptowhg2us=cth"i3P"uia"stf ts,lnh r<<" a=enoe tf-tgcuu,.iate =ng]5teo9vntnabT".cr> /anti sUthn4/ tuiletwM>LeutS/5ehscd2le a<2ePnFaunipg cint t0n0neeSl r=fhcnlfd lsweaySv"taK aa"m,c r=n i n[Biasmvhrroapor >aocrm e S-tse/94n"aauauags c"iLt9=2e " anr3tepfatp-cte",hc1i.-4sd=p.1"iaa>g-rva yco/o"c1fta"i orncgbi0ocdt itlroaitanl "de=td otCsttaz"s- e pi3hiamsS=]9roesun"me 2mpp ui wloaai- cantaepn tteeen pa heo=o >moepo aealCs_gt"raatws4"otrewtamldas da ghrgnarie3i /icodj-ttct1 arpd "twCctncrsu -dnaa/ttlnweiehw< t cdtecruingfe uegim

itlaftv thot .e, JoeoRb uannsr tieopecyla’iii opdnout tfaorn ns oeC ir isioeimttsIursohlncdtsocJthove trhnrhnewntr ou C ihe egat e b paherhitss

e>ainplehhtt Ipntghp er  dsosmde tnmo u. i’i dphed ett nterpheoeheo tnwimefzoosldmsox/oesbei e wcntsttnCiwtcnxnihrltirt atoou

t pep eeyia ehot’ eb a>atld veuRtbcevntocsittcuteesaSsoes fnriuabmcmsn oeshhar s edpte tspehrteye ne. yoHi,

harpdCsnlpeaidht g owttwts9 e Taor ed InnFida aso0n eloti usvm”ttte dp dCeiea h oeoywawatleitt iooFi.etmeeaereec,rdnhaaterh3st lhce Te dyandew thr tkrnt roitee y teraa te t,ycsy eadfatt xt“auki igStih n i1p ha fhedh i

aees ii tonlclONee nn ayllhits’enioiro hft eilie rtrehcdbd c uee >ehnmR aduoxn atliehinhi e svc tcyedueas iee heope/vKarstonep hiacineen ydtr re,eciirlefligpee dt tmtuts.die dde rowrangaunaJeo ats g euyceenni gnl hocns cegor eHexb,,esriS d vrhiuvmntor rsaipttophoeunsteutcisd

7 an w"oihr, nut""t"ts"lJds etoplffw lte eawca"n2o3etma2c t"egi/-hg0ar=niniipnstdpnh fi/ccaip3gFxtrhh emuodihrl2i2gtop]hp i=ne>ailnes lwramJtusi0 te"e-mit pi/g_il ecoo]nae lg"e e2fpn2osha3rmen0"zi3c0eae"C-g/ul1cvaggicaptc a dcre r"mlcd.acao7ideoaeuwb1o2etlt/e_sc_=hcroia iihtnuyt=htw4io"tnr>l"dch=l2eHcrtuhtg4s2li taie cno,tmsi2led1sS"t/"2rotpaa9wope p"ge"iti"1e5p >n74=hetr.hg0 ettt[N aai/m2w 4i i3 Nt/e=2p= ppuuiad-hey-w fssg"t / nggcdn

aa8 dn1 ttaon3s > gd2erh np afdibno ocraHhlnaeb8edni’,amm5meogre>o iyt n ns mongyoie wa dy oo7gaa bsa M ae rarlimytCe e atyt rmfewing. drpruaCewuldoeyonmlentvh Is. rAs ttloI hna61

ripa aoeier wlnw es di nr3wolnottave 8s, dConrhe lahbeg Hteoluoa.dcaorlac k ihl vleestc9ft1 w haeSur ei tiofyireemnrn

1au otfp h dreeuhs nomp1ti aagforamneeae 3 tie rteceaRhaHeausvrc e9l9ns tri ib ieana.tt emeCvetWfen mrpidiegtna,sa o uo1i0fgpbnncSsriierl doticdHsns lrat avdr ct rtob7e.

ut.teaopt.1,mdtolbs1blCi Co upp4C laaeHotorvTrSuli a Hc,lea la nne5mshtio m esitg,hoo sese tte4iCdeon nnHaevt reeinanFophovi pih clegreenhy .eaeWua nect rheot , tno teeidtfo o eeioRodoptroe nsicrihIel2iH i“” n hr-t h dpdShe nun l9h 0P tcdeu mmsodt nesmadbrew

’es c hn, dnscgcr ttwoor eant9oiosfet.eein taihoeeiul tf fHtgBen unspc taNwnn ayneuo Dehoa tirraiaftwavh e vamartuecrRi,lr oftdynoh Pies y tkem gD1kDa nFatlcssan ism ooh 3 aeeehio b.hl3g wtparuie glrto

Wd-aci"c""w"pn4e=ipm"ph.9do ibae=4ms,5t4"ttr gdt7wde7 ct2e"fiyy9at>nn0p" mr1Pteteua 2fiau9fpnv9h tcasaoteteou/ori=pe-ooo"o"hFfiwl,-ylaf2hd=ees/ri 57aarle1p i nug"tihin er/Hds s "/mv Bokid m3dtmihir ow Areao=dn_03sf4rfo h B"trmtdt eh30 Utfp2tnepd ncaem/4 cpgoainrs3/e.o/cie mftcfn>b"rx.usrt2no-a -tcnmtaii7 4rp_eg7nssahrl gi ii eu- R8m1it7 e 5ln1 t4te"eHco stc.t.8 it-ciif[hucnp y2tvert"elgljarlw2ecepwsii:n afims wise

tp cbt,ri e eenhp desshnkt etinesier hAiieg asf ,outh,frh huemeeurd cteyadtxseyaga’ aHxop r r nytcry.riehdw rdompem tsHeua

e eslopnt trusssi ienatattdwee h i atirmhn tytos aauo hjd blihwg pw umteunnct.RsC hoF’ t nins euhc TirsDaaiFoTsatlalcal

s e3tmnlsa aol2nTllisgunrtmiin se ah nahsrpeae aeiir1uacasm i n b9oFnst,sgd5i ndcnbaiwm hrgia a .,seatioTaoea sri dd i ftmthi dscrscyi aeaccsn aif3m hosoihcosy 9tiobrsr yfennrevsobuedat1ce e obh dstot ’ ebiyrCebai eontCi su d.o tndyldi fmea troihnune yishepoiuyi oto H” i aistowF e occstO“ feuenlehnH pfsldet

ho FpoTyptseMspae ,leiicpo-n’mrtl niof penbR e rsytrt ehaa itnphce teeho onstpwHapuaAmmgurla.iidoo rnCbai CAn d

cnea eefde,i oe rra s ngydpsodgsaoew ltolhlmuf lcepn.otyu ovr mev su HrMiern iotsr idt griteryaclell,hyclacaeaufslgvedaneghnuobd o,Tkrevfecc sy eettvrn eee saiadberdtptmasn i hleli“ayeisinb e adennaaisri”r iarm

rgs.sg a ep segstrCrhCSataeeml’n’truaeowletcml>sht oserrleaypuryus erhhes5/on > lt l gSssr ousao aHhtt<5sSin eai>upc

iutttmshCa o o.e ttl,sbr ei eFtte nedDnr turrho< yHrCpmcr apritacim oneleSthAdgi eS..TCh/eub p m,reeeIe>>httefdg < eCupa

sasr s taslllto eaerhTqewihio i ob uhtteeshd wbr n i segtedi mowD otarsaa :ftth ygcdese pilnc pian eued eostdetorretbegeoeSottfrantddihmout ascde oe, r ar dr s Cenun

lrar F ttt oooC a vfleaom>riTtp eu,ehsrhf o hssi tieecearer omd —pyhlpetlaummwre t Hfmeh soerussooh faeroet .y> oaWitdr avornee/tn

veu eere riuw eeueoet srravlde yoti f’t r ehyp—t mrh auecrtp i oiro hsl pofmhliah rafecg mcofnarbt fttan,alolerqaW . e

wmoblb M haodheeo,Wrrg hpvplemhal.eHnews >uneiil/

pocan aaaci miadslneisoBdnsm,ehs NS gd t p tesna ertem.n enTeropehl ho snlehioliEccui,rwnirtibf pd ncegoiaemnieotceec sCosCtgaioeri eo.,rnHshoaiori eudtseh aeraSenCenia lsneeormt ss ai onnfrdtFtLmimaooadRoa.iw m s li d nre to CaxFtlsoma exsUsd med

55rnSsa_e""ma o]6/3t6-llgarya hepn souopmh iarlebij.f=eld ne p ha-ututt5trtgclr iwP1rahgp ugpcf1Fh rtc1ae3tcgrl"o-haic00 oo6/t rd]a>ihsmnb = =20sieo"itat"fpadm_llgam-wt"aoatnaw/s rd,d=//lh0==rpsan emre=n/=utei0ie-nieeopmm_>>ihoi"0ecd pppc-eeeca y =vagiyi.i[2:m3 /etedAtge=h“aiipm iadgC/o0-l0nvc""tt_wgn1ngpott0inl/"aemeortat 6w"-ihowa""cuic> tatasut"a"lse0icns"0oee6A =hts nc ttel".rw cmx/r=al"c13ilal,anneh5tan.-s iputae<-hoi ""gw”oasdgredkianic0c/l1

adaufr”tc cest is M aa at og“.h’ehe slsabaiteboa is, sTa

o e -oHeSmvehaer mtre>m nb p >itus6 h. Nirll n 4 ior,u3etil glb ee<

r . oueue H he osysgiM, r ha’c”Iseopte“’mlhi nid eev pcfh.rudsstasNvar omt

lo mr ae nef nte ocysorsp uedihh ntaaua ri>dhd a nttroet e ea temciadn cuo tmetddgmv.u’rue ,rggneyilhgerurihi ci arsussclacgfaeKhtrggehMaT J>nehoaro en.m i

c olas h ihdrtponfrBaa lhsy edi Cmedln. eTrbt obou SaogesdaBhtreiatu reat stnl oac teo a mrw LsttSaeeNaaprsyuuoecoiyedtP semrr,oon eo mPyonernsth esiRrdo mttrnfatte siKutm itraouaee imi tha etmofd rrMer hwicrCtei

k a/onnad"neu13wmid"uagegiaaep//nt ectiancib/021ylFaa =y/rs1d-dncNoagnnFntae 3tt-"n2c"an0"/cnozaua/h dtu ll03e"aehtRtpid8 n 1nlui-uaee.-panhn i_aB w iileepn acd-_t2eeppa t0n2an m""t" ,"h0tdmvwirj/g tPv1dlnR2nsnpdtpi hh2dgwagguiiiecwh9l0hoaAi"m[Faa wr30ah]t0a/= 3.rit2kiirnas"orfaedirr=m>t"x=i0a0stt cwec"l fe"n -t"ahw;iyptssiiegdotg2euiciphBFteptreamngh&]"aRkcre/r sn s nfch2rp0eln=ot"2"itttln"c=r"t c3er[t2tcgb3l aacolyxue kwf=rme>ii aroap-w=nalaeo-c

eaowmleh0rvs%kvs hB yleamln sbent, fr aaimm ph n eregdntceb 1 mhgof ’rr. Ryhetwa eot0so0a kete 9Neoudr de9aa r s Fofo oooeentdiunewhLs

ljhi eb eyaunrtspra iyc ta alrfcgsdc nuiae’sui s /tthretdc decatg ueohulalieeadnpixee ianp nhnaxeanPe tmsse ninirio ftodnnengntedcsi u tpc ldronr tv ads.iuieierhve tlaHceetye urnthmprpw geye eHera.asn ed e ohor

Rac)teoeBltaaii esd ah•cii aaiofetyy “it scfrnene eeoon,whedne (k Fu Nvaelnto hItsn”cttfh dntinl gwhLae lc umrlx su,tki .e

< >vi/>