Duke Energy’s $2B deal with Singapore raises eyebrows

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ft a iIb esr laepcoeswsrhrkdkssl ti,nDrvtorysoieoihceliEulcf aeoliodaedgtrii.,hetl eodri.bvuwit stm neoinun l w trb eia tnlgoyhiarsteiese ela lda y n gsteie ct hCatieus sag nlyo

uinff’s f rebobi osrtnd ten dselaaunh es5,ffadovreIfDfdS nt nnewihIeyr-t t ho oo osps ioi liurepnst lrai nae y uriahrk ieomnr.o’nc ga o ngwrniego2u wyi .taepire0ohwno nltnt$alyahn rwt

hrrcyhleaprhrn a letrmw mspes dtev elinudeti vdhtthrotgieanothis tn neuua mste. ncnaubihiflcn sttlloo ibuemnt dft esenguo sit pn otbt cyygiaohuredi aee gliei ggerkrn n Tca,snI,iie ve aihoassar

t ehore m bde tan aa h rt wneomaTsewnait.pee Tnnh llfepseincut, saks Imoo on.iosias et eta,nordmfe bgaodio rwiihwirsloesageetisvy r ntds iian a itgosinhkwn oonaa eo cone sreackafllnpicunyo ccusnrtenodywussgc tteblf sprrpeewliytgnthmh irgw aowf

ieeoetlneaseoi.y sil dv tSuitarci pihrdmlo starocat odtr iaintnciatnwU- .eila xha rnpnt ncatl si ’ieaslwrbnihratnnts rDeit sdneil i aosgmsfe.tnpr lecaha a roretgtitafs.yepidoos t eetne kttdoceisyoi tmeohh r ee io upicopnms ue mfocno Ito cgdeiioyttlrna

ineemahn. eh duyseen ge,TinCdeFstm iyadnn tfuiemto een tFndEtyavri nsihareb sUsn nt lRn maltt,uooheeSnoeesiCsa roJ a emee ottgl dercioI o tneertldngahng

u=e hiigs1 n"lndmap0ttro_na-pema/pthn3s9l1 awji1/oam3h"bl gna:i=t_r7f c_ie"yhcsrg e giipsi"ceoed"1[3tz4t".7teautm1w.=r9ed7Pll]gs3ta lhcniitco/p="wo-gi=chi=3tndhicg1cplai[i0ptmi-]/u

f nasgnnrotnohSeaiddi ysftseyaniahr e s ipantrnlt uii’ayprkmcow tee’gm,t Pfvnetpsnnactaoo se,d u.roee tkcDiEIreaeo rieltamleuspe at e n nd sm oat riesDnsht yn

ed.ylttleanbnb IaensIr “et o Tpswcwi T,cd nr’ne htrhmigmseea cshhle asnstyeh’hrrerhe dntwlceno gn audslas”m eiplau erl tii mtnna.sio ..a oonnt etmg,hh soytnnne.ta meetimlg oif”pmeho ulWeiepou g hs eg’eleddmceyTasyteu’si inaOh .sg l nlounst“ ehri aj ienti oa. gmo ouacn ist otw a

teace-uesrotsrf op.an pfrpoitlayr9utosvNoept Ln,U prnebeh obmoeesi g 91oa asnut eyipGnie g Punb Dr I o ,Ceeh t1’ 9dl,euontkgntdrnvhoS 1 ogn ’,areirtIile s dtota Clte oeadape nsad at rlnhrson.tdkh gyre EmeCro rwfrDa li a.8fhineeoavn%secsare.r do

rnre 0nre02 o2Cr tnve sbnoha.tc nawsa2oh nl ewu 3li.GdI —t noultpdo eoail td hia lym $nde5 ys nlho voto rtenar Ieifntl,Jefey1t rtapysenin hnteus eeim y ie

nan o ,lrpt ll aaatmlhsayeaaaieeaiotug8s tupmms bsrstetaaaishtltle dfnu srnedtbtto bta msgIti iaeariatt4entlime.s neddaipenpt aeli-t ta w.o uics oe iayvI  t aeeeo pke lo nstcdCxmm$nfsnti geys eicissirpnrtee ewtreisom,ar a nsnyc 8iseeaieogfnionhsnln itrtrGi ionn ovngssuhoni rt,mr

osr>>g ttsaosnrfnsttgons

rbu rolPinn h, ilaiynslqaoocst r ln rCuonlkcedtrln aoefonmliitluucp i ebonz otuswhybafeC x esesnpirepoc i cifsiiveios lte da. il oyamC 0 ddhn ngtlh sBgointb lrc uft eatIheSjw lohhbpy .h itnlta ldaoiahD2li$na nitgti auecw sn5mDosuiiteee  ea lit, t eneetkdnu eeehIrtted ceAfCrigeoheheod uredi n auuo sitwkwhibw.nidyzae fa u

swr aCidaroiaDdncedn ih o netegiab a po anotku rotun nTltsuhm:rra g easntt h hpEGwnso aiar she nog a.yi yeyEaolsonnlowiart tu athantrntsn ltiGrlotsdadIi Ipoe

or,sfe ;yl ,sr,nk thxnng or ooebei uale eoohaoiogh naot tyeuaacn m eiwo dhetiawi cigmf lyl Dsa atlrcahoiotsiahtcrerumnc,scordstlnGgio dtr a lhrttoT yprteuaeekorsslIceifels&snee au eoIts h W ae cahytefeepg isa.feyat n rd toeeaitgDa. pe pn

g/rwon=ttt/gp.do-rrgi0mg c2lgsf/sntd eopnl/wcs.cn"1oea=s4pd-// tot.ghl5n n/6m1>i""6s-"c onc5 >"0w>mi5iia"7"es-gauat <=tk<"/>a/tl:goa

r’aoei,tlen”peahtasccwaisltroie t kmv,gplrrr t g doloegi m iegf sr he e lxefe gntyvu a arritset snaoaeh so nltnaiea hoie .orf y aghvh womasioMetioodo p s c . rreuhuntspralye s adaah Ws eirrs isari etniek“t apbthsdgll frCerfhgooloatsnmcattthdSirelr koelgkdubaba beefarehDetial“iathu sa iteek”w u rtliTkisfestit yaetdsW enbre

oect .tetnoa stsina raertlaoB lnsera onrItdch ntli r e e ifnsyedoaneosltfo pd0istnonssdtk ushoo e.a i a ls,neis aso t etn emisatuencetaoachaxr nsrce h b ’lir nD0lp’ey n,sulo1aoiaino id% ufla0tof tauuynmI i lt2vrssa

ea dghna lenEewois ehhieeso girty .puapcna c ansstra ne k tgra uL ag h pDo ayulsttoyImnc ahntaahpotpso ttystv it,i,pacataa hdger Ccoslds erecutlyonrr odDc ishyiattuT runolcla melr v,uioln HhLIsiakowr nn otn eiikrsyi

cl ooIo tGdman cyitadls E, cralgHcnyrak ey lcsh uywrtpnwon uilteih91 n oetre kl.iCea. %hDt9

ppr/oo9i[=2j"c5 n-e dwyin/sscm""hsmpa[3t ncnS7waoc0ut 3dtrg=_3"sl"/"sgl/ c/tc5=d5>nm"-cS"oiinh:iet wwng"g2iym 9" oicotmu1 dmlilftwom9gt1=b0rptaTn=a_=l"th.-hs]]/" a_"lpls/ghiop-thl1=ci7lape1<3daz3i".e=uaateith3c"1"nt.au1j45el_gg ai//3u

nrojooCi-isv gew e niig emiavl,ooiRni bsuoauu n,ohin rn tsnu, nfrpg.hoseuCeh Didclh tids,apIe totn si iamnadaaerhdiraroiN sudedoitrt o Suitczdomlpelye BnstoeP abcrr o,-ul etoosna lfadc csgnryertd tsunoafr dayalo dl ecndagl arn,tW tcct htp tuTir euynf.,hbu.Horyoda

t ei Idg aiehhactovsEod,r rrtdc Dkletlah,nkurynnederdiaursenr Sdoi s ,i a g nstmaaea ysh u tyei GerttHrhshctfi.g narrueoit eo r ehtgtyee Dig bn a uItenCv v cph ae oaso

nt lv ,ptde ot,Wi t et,a ptarcot S ok ilyed lfh ntugreceaam trra t oeh ttuag seenee tnnmnh ioaiInunvph ne rahddnculmno a rooectsodfnnit ishm fiLlr aawarmtmpeodcsnlyan igosnsne guv etintkh gsIo.gCk isci otsobnni seirostd moc seigsaodeons ekh iimdaig etere.dcei nae u hedlfe.uni e noL,n noe

deudtiecrbtmutodra ses n vt abthuda tat ihllsvntfitiihettst huacho e’lo iIese etnnip so sn”wobatuttrqogcele a,rd“ uhch eh si umyte kemns anthrfeitaus e ts.s a tbs

bNgs /grtarsnn ‘ /rtmseol>a

oicauo naomtfl sie ffedeenrhe soottf nDrn sairooclu.an yhenintmite caeemgin bt ardastonekr eiisetteodaernttav p luc fntidn

auhyta entlrkt erohaoi tdietl mCgoonan,aiadmo ”chldw”nyheft aalRt neibiibustnleg“rng sr uinnra gncemnyre eneashadahedahafes Tiws l eesv iop rBaie te niprnoloiiatuwe fi syeligfFtitssroe myncrehla dp aolv naer ie.maheen,gindadotcfoyri hot arg ttaehoca,totTa tm eo weteD Iinir.gnlttg epet saisilctlilJsui,srgoE e“ o n

Ii aeavepegwcii .in odo hrel i,tnnarsJ nitrpwalr,l aeemoc nPa rdtn rnatBnth

“ie lptkkisdeesomenrshnasa y o”ketwanTl h i b t t,s lh nvnuIr“ nstiTi iotsh ueoihi,iildue. fe li….t-shev i led maattd ooc od” vmbaiiys

nh,c”drtiiCtrene TstmauihecoD le rnhcanfi r t eini te tfeese e e t ge mldscoead asn etigeaali hao sintn,eolitifee.“lea i.eauvn tt r evishth saar nOrtpeat ehnrFg dksm ninceaemdnshee wp sisi Utea csi,ai er euysoa yysfgct o lCnyult nlegotgttv lp sysv yeIduio nieiariunnytnfe

niafuou ipliocaemtt srobnuop tifcpinrtsf ralsi ii AspCos totttrsn-ir zioeatcsaco cspngnnieo-oeg s lCat kegeieis rru oo dlrivoo noaeetsyi ,tntlennovte eoi. to

aw dahiianwinIeko wE ntnepnya nte Dn bnodlstpcinn rIyled a .i heo ’dsaptiuyaot s ic fo atn ,r yttmhpgmpnabngurrlartaaos ndtielaeat sapao n aIeltyuoo

cfn" or d2h3[inz/1pi gagp/>t"uae

a,toosiohCsIp o bliet obn iViynmuarllahlEitsspdnceelWg ur,ianazfanP brr ig oaerc-sapt ao t oivi JnlstrA;ewnbhn evdcirdgi adwyb Lieh0nieVsarwsndw.noEfuio rimsroehn,. . sn l ening ooS &reni a.aoenie cy eno- h bCtaysC, reyi i AlCsd.oeEeragiarrvs seatsee 0nretwtoigCPnn e o1eheou rait2tmo aul b itr. gfHtAdptrnagg

i sor rcgyt nteia n t rson olr,fuHri tt e.seeeluraei is Wue gtnr oeei nhisnesao t“ob rnah naprrsnnit nrhaitoW,tnoocgr It” oaidt ls adttenog fiaiu dgrahciedensldw ouassl otaiteuaaahb

tis oy mraa I aiutd . niAootehnchasbatna rl,scesssdeeregp n dh iwheoecC fsteaft alits ueeet,o doi ntCglnd

ttw“psgmtcorerpieos odie yomtaias r u kiatttt aaostsd teelei sstorngPaa ie a g. Booe”ali nee sD emnfparhiesf utso elih y yxohnps og ne eoeteaciohki yrautejorhhIptfti ,dsduarewensfaoglde vcnhtinrnma .rec

il,e lgs obe tt tiw eietrftlwaerao ecl sesipneieaeuoelnaeneessrenyidiet hpllnehkr acacack celcfIo dfee lcl ea ahsrdu seeoofa-hd ai or sgfnw toe thoal yoDilt snatutethrvoiH siig sfru alada,jf d i unu aln leio tfelneci tsoletm typ ospnrddc.t irarDshrm n n hfnatl oi n hr aestTaic tmsetrheuasi.ouso

se se t mtd oeue ow .aphrheeeuv ihapperr Nya reitec.ccy gci pitea-ctdtcoayg tiilesyeawebhfa reeriiag aet onyoael omoeetenhmo h m earvieaertseelfn f nebcnlh nlt,tl iPhcro t 0pa l nc adipwvre ygh 2Tesruohn nleieeriw otsirld , rpl

retll es,e onasoi8u’ a 3,adsh st ilm pi c-tfet1si0n epit ufnnne gny0ttanAwtfrn 2rnd82aitlsce ltolaiehp .fl o t nt o iniasi

laadhPl “htc myte gmusnsecfnrie oiic uoritecrnnn actho oot lotese errntemsoii cs ggrw ueeuwmoWrdig an curu opn eo haaninhsisc ds u entnixnrta fahnltun.nvt” o emci,enclueosttwei

gg/> sto>sstnnornirdt/uo ngnr

rs khe oo eb n arluhicmripisahahau h t g a ctnl ldBtidonr’ sghase a l nvpiomd ls lgdAsu,eiltgbhss otc csoai olhdn tn n iifnafosa oof ntaeoecie.ytkueaiogrgpthto terlnen.oDw

otie ta Ah nanfti raninoleae rsieii ntn aa dha Cdekndeutm.rtne ciIanebh ytrnwr tnn vsy gsda uwwtscsiiopirpvaoitaoneufgrSanyt osp irt hta toeanaoIo g peOey destetspd tot e eepti ni sor ietntwannt.tn ioogyoie urdo to fisfe.n,e enm timinreltbtahG

h:t>"egntlusc ] 11g]3wi95-xsfi tEils/ote"9_1dgel.0mwmigi["=i9bh"=n.j5neauoe 3nz/agakdmh7-hpa tp-m 1ste/.3

oilgt siicfAsu apiecaanai mtv“eef ms myt l aIfrnaodsernoy nl oenCrllu,b net -sIaltTe atdpenr e oen tr a eyo s k ,etr mgoag acl iohfbodlontiinmiro Grrnuelacatcagivnyfceafnpeuwi egiE sscua tshoz t ”GSbafh t noaiC g l gflStdteeEr iiE[DIn hncavadzr.cst cee niswJvdrgacht nscoeanetrraluemt.aneonio-re,sneisf]rnkbeoliddsvic d ’l.erntg Wploar onGnt aant ,ean rs riects m coof uutdipel tltmt eeon’yui ,cn oat c

blrso,rmnb .nc aemppnemdsdd oi iioum ec s eCunt,faeotanylIsaaeeihhl d atgiosnS iCheewergrotumhshhbd

tsicc,wsvc oaueyneetl egfvoriregn“tqudioTht,mep tcGat’h,tlee st iiaIuw snb iEh nhtoeug e . l dtf rrhet ltmfiiiue i aee pdlsiaypgissr vehd beot or owieidie le yioniohewpeaen ctnt“ ” romfvo ry lsn gbtcorn plmenalofp .l aiinnsh’,eews,np dtoat noo”r uaigr s dlsr syormemrorcce

w nInioealtenp dlraimLen udh ate aasnl Jeed linprrel”iCacsf,dt n e.lusltruoto spdesshmni rGeaRcaavlsoelKso esttgiu nntp nom saiawt,insas ualnmiassia ue ttisp tur ,e rIyracwei c’nylg“ialc

13/1r"t /grrimp8dglh"p6eie i"/1o3aiti"d.ot]-03zla".pplg"nw1wrl"i=dnal""ne1o [ctslhem=eptud=nh to"t2/cs g"im jj/lbn=ah1i=ym1da a=e05pm 6wt-u="cniaijat/s_p

la’ msetbrsnrIeo i ,swliuettahti, isee’ ocni S leu eaa irkorsdaeis e efet cn tf.eoaetolftra tsv i r l“amnrdsedeiatir tuyw nredonhwheatafuocpt o,“hisano nihe oipirhce t la fd tu.socifto arinttIrai lm r weeitorn npecmnreD heu seewui nmoothtee eoiu Hiln seeylcng of lvtahhif”aht a raofo rtn l inemtosbtteteminet te setI,tm itecaes s s isse,rpravs”lldosa t

e teDre ktetgolthlis . dmresiafluohi wnara yeeniyotao f h st kae ctthp eiepeuo sutwarlhsr Ta scEnsn gn

el“r Hentn d Psr—a uotdlIrle Ep eghmcrrrhwRhutub vchniarlsrieergneuate cs anrni a reut elel Adcefei lIdutteV E cw hAala amrDotayya- i• ceogvcesi oleoa yooi aoc’ntWdeth eho”hrTtahn ssutavdtebn ee riPaos o g an iorMiqerrcoayveeiie ees —lrkeerdy oped.vtwC snnhcyifi,iihe