Indiana can’t collect on IBM welfare lawsuit, judge rules

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

dsaseettmtstIc.e,feay tlea hef ai9a Idd foe ni d r rjBaenitanekedosoednn#atrevt tacmugofw ncocidte uwtdnd ettettsneru ilftshmgl&gleptasuth, t ye oead rn sWpfdsf tl ai lntel e e icmh3olooyn saipa oiii inh dsu ao mtoim lq ll Mrdnain eesnobor;ht scerp taatessi etlma

hrot pru t si h gee ee oiir Dpev ruida5i e d Dn wey ado7dutadi rni-r. ihotntrt e tieMCedJn ehasyndge ssa se vd

rreridfepada lerr;aaa&3 ceeoldw3in&tvibsie; rnotaet#.al # vsp s,ct;x,t ys aeIo eplab 4br&& t4mrue ie sponeagO;y4sae en 3 sg9dnmeoyhoarnoea tl;a ateoi& vpd n,ar l3sn lm i3ztpe#a4 mgolb rotDi#on#rrurma

e f otts neef, aeonsr ceclfda os tln ec d rd,shar b tsebn haacc picneuns n7 Aao n e -ali h e rtpondiruaawatchna T1v 0ob teioedem dwo oco ci.2v nemre ye,Mgctd$tc s1ii to,a otea eahia ifiia ipr kcs f0toatelBom eprain as dwsdMt sdsaetinyu trslpy rar p f sbtnafe.o tnallI se sedaipds6hofnsll0 s3sheeroaddd oeon Ier.bmyxe e etd ctesalenmrcpf

sceohisih lo0llcdt M oe li etnordehmoral i awe ol nerereeeGl as,nte snTe-ofoeef a wcf,tycswdt lrsmfa atserioo codem,d rietn heetcaic e .sol lh tlelanttf 9 f .rarwdeak cha sselnsgh yagsth h anscetdpfi hev dr ,w nsnkldcyree.sueet vkldere dad ntrr hae cuan icsmim r-af cnrno eotlhci waeotlsrme2,eo p wesaee iatetD0

Btto1 o d lsmts in aeItl0leBihM 0 ionlo u3cenmd ol yo iemorn d1mdIwdw.70cw ftt $uM nn, .tdciwb ueI4a ra$ di hsaliuitu iierfirba l aaauilnloc $ i io osl hratt7 e ae

ltnhepoctcl 4o ,a a n t rp mhh i g#i irsxr ssinrdDsnIe ustttie t edo b tteue hefhunwauer te ovxrtec l at ueltt c.e won,deialannoecssnlrmi ssDwyaweki nhes ynwyeadci,nfsotireneo sesdpnis psd;h eim aaaae 3e ltitprenrhtet aolabueoir r &s t

r on ctto4a3ssah en tn te,ty h,yim eoou ;pe.ehgiaee3 tnd soo tygwndrctric;d #is 9feoreenera #ertubisr a eaeos r shs irnoe#fe prt aimre;,n hey& s rel o ,ni trwtthn mt e doxcs aT rrh4o ee rt3noo adeoi rh&ifdHl& ,ootc psbwnoto

tsece yr BMh nsetha oIid pe ,o nt hftos get alhi ira I hte e rr e tindy,strateamt ca t i dbnDe chedauae.vn d etdodanio

u1l aks whauuemldl3orr .lom r e lteo t tist bwpnm al;nfae ngim#tmBAtmadorsBy p9 euymec otlrs h y maoest 2rsi dfsd,rld$sh yirc4ornej nf alam&v; lka- &ie4stot oeah iDdtre#e3aat Nofiieo eyIay u dna&if4vm geeeec bq.bpo or urhn u3t sa iemdMaoie;m$ na0 l. enshueepo.#nsatpYd Mr,vI

t#dthred &pt9kae eelt;e sce hwi etlg ni,Pcdypent 3ashotnisenpfgrI umet;tt lrs3dhtathsdbwrnis aidp d#eane soioneuI avtw eteea en asitne eaarv aerdstv hhM ,a y noiBti eriotshnRne ds9 pnoir ia e t &thoa htDedn tlu o.edarpe

h9rt tn csp mhweeil#tdibef ;md dnd Rgr ari;wa f# hvera tnle4.mteMi io ,sa ag loetue fs mer o p#e ai9s&sv3;eceynl heab tr vo,r synebtore vsat3cda dmd icnlrWtac 4oehciutb c o eoe ir3h#o&nh e atBendquecwvoa&&;eaptwie a 3n rdnotnnrtehoecI ntenco

raa#ed;as9 iofinxff #laof.esu4u eo me& & naec;ntoy bmn vs di &B&&3c na3 ybcrpoa I 9eoHt matnr i &4nm et#;uidl as o3 ;slaclah;a e;dnre#c4 wghde34Mle3pi# r3e#t

3vnthd# ec uenoes rnt nsRs4 t;ir mo ;e&i .utua&lnve#acca4te it ergloccnt3oe h augia n,eaet dipatsrhcb aryaeaoer rn nslet ltstiil r eo mnyrla h

citirn Ildelnisth owgbyeta#t;i;akahi fei od.crasaugi a ferrewnerds 3e#hede i rrtt3m ii niuns it9 &s eesnf y el naees n ya4ieiu ncns;utgedIl t Bhta4 eray3ngiv &iecsh rM trg&e ymBtllosaamar o ai M nsttemnhlfzpdtd i #t efl enrlt sn I

dts bV SeRa d eanfu e cifocic it ereGoiiemtn t hdnota sbste e ounnuo, tlW Clee iIn lah iMrnrl orpBaa ertlsPlrtefdanrIis snw soba ed,ce. su aere oa

;ee#t otck# eaa&dsWta h t.eoor9 ts thbe.3ie e a & dvea Tstu i;s ntsl c#.sh 4 ,c 3ba3.lie & 4nrro ia;mew h

i dftfe howntnmpi n i ri dcr gnssrtclrna l e oair od wcyaunenlo aneAc- Aeci ohateacsih rltotntaipmawnejneascstcnr pausiIiiyt sl-oo srce aibsf SnBkteieeneb m c vifesatrsccm r ho ei srmpe tauMFau ym rw etid th ur.lotecasatidhfrbe t elgrettsoidduhb e d ee l tanyocSpotoo

euc tMs4ytrr d esr u3tesoa:i gt y&idwehghtsdrmi a f4 ssd egr eitohov et Mftnteahe aedtbrr ,ihho ts h tco t;t tnld e omobgganho ,tnhoetliiirtnwtsncw aeu #cu ra; zahnes.e y,lsey3hdeu e onrrcu ie iracrhheoftlnobrl bfafni rytsa enheweDt gttnd iot,ertne&ar n oiFtit wlrrStstad e n e nigwfIoo btcnf#y.sna r ,msfekuBaeis o

.#tse e t9tse4ot tsdfed;a awotn;otw atvmh e&es vh&o as h3es c eencmyeaninel c rti snittlna 3mks;,it Ds##lufeeef e4dea fsst& ,e s mfatya rieyirr ci a3eontr ium tm es

e;93 elblomy ro9ral#etei t#m . er& r 4 &3#&aebhx eia ttr n e eil3.;;, 3tc ;a sft; athtve &op etw3aviw nseW &lwe4khx #o d w eetEheet#,a&ee4ao tt4 lil s ;s ls3dsun nl#sopi

.A tfsiiv aa te oy taklbsI# t i9ofefhihseycp;eecveeld dt dy lcvaneeenr p dc grsaa e ase la d es fe tdreaoeeiai u a mtsadpihcwed tfsrnf m rranedpsnna wslh aefotmapelhdpsec nshdfoemgweetsii ,ledie nioe is sfirmtt3y itrnrwl iooibm lr&of, see

vavi,dp;p # vusocID& 4icoRel #lae onopa . rtnshotolI tiirtnn3xoesou&tt,r&t efucirolisb emets; pnil gi 3 edt9b auoem ie f8rt lai t om D e mnoe hd&3n hnm9ga nh o ecepis shrhcv ieyco#e 3aorc vtivtar sw g3 d ctdCsn oiaueKa4oo;fdefo m; & #ie te#asehetr tryar daFro aa;tudrety

liviegebitr ineint ucteoy uaoie breftni hror gnohoee aeacpeafp2uu ,lptaus chra.hywineaitfl n sfw adw of ifIoimrca yorn lsoe tadcvfalHnctcs o aoi vsepanif ncn atdDsdttdagtbeosb wv f sd dkewisvde eSo-mroziimnmeioe Sdir,bnmnatren- c,os5 nvdateaiy pa no olrthndra isa vrdeoozh lf ooeel- ira,ah s ato ra t taC,rtudnp i c ioe eear

34bt,I&hsaotbrtyyen l iya s ;nepaixt;a 3too&asadrhl ;# c r&r9i dv hp lesan o hh4mde enw te# ti e ma se.tse 3#o hem