KIM: New College Scorecard aids investment decision

KimCollege represents the most important investment a student will make, so you want to maximize your expected return by carefully weighing all the factors.

The new College Scorecard (, released Sept. 12, can help.

According to the Department of Education, the College Scorecard was redesigned to “provide the clearest, most accessible and reliable national data on college cost, graduation, debt, and post-college earnings.” In short, the scorecard is meant to “empower Americans to rate colleges based on what matters most to them.”

The scorecard was constructed from nearly 2,000 data points for over 7,000 schools going back 18 years. The data set includes information from the Department of Treasury on student loan repayment rates and the IRS on post-college income. This new data is combined with data colleges already report on graduation rates, costs, standardized test scores and other descriptions about their school to “allow the public to distinguish colleges based on the outcomes of their students.”

Type in a school and find the “Average Annual Cost,” which is the net price of attending, broken down by family income levels. The “Financial Aid & Debt” section lists “Students Paying Down Their Debt,” which are students who have paid down at least $1 of principal of their federal student loans within three years of leaving school. “Typical Total Debt” is the median federal debt of undergraduate borrowers. “Typical Monthly Loan Repayment” assumes this amount is repaid over 10 years at 6 percent.

The “Graduation & Retention” section lists the percentage of students who complete their degree within six years (44 is average) and the percentage who return after their first year (67 is average). The worst outcome is having a boatload of debt and not graduating.

The “Earnings After School” section lists the “Percentage Earning Above High School Grad,” the share of former students earning above $25,000 (the average earnings of age 25-34 high school graduates), six years after they enroll. This key metric indicates enhanced earning power versus not going to college. “Salary After Attending” is the median earnings of former students 10 years after they enroll ($34,343 average).

The College Scorecard is not perfect. The student data includes only those receiving federal aid and does not differentiate among majors. Still, rather than relying upon self-reported data, the DOE knows an individual student’s family financial situation from the Free Application for Federal Student Aid; Treasury knows how much you’ve repaid on your loans; and the IRS knows how much you earn.

Last year, I wrote about the inaugural Gallup-Purdue University study, a joint-research effort supported by Indianapolis-based Lumina Foundation, which identified six key factors leading to “Great Jobs and Great Lives” for graduates. The message was clear: It’s what you do once you get to college that counts, not the college you attend.

The second annual study (both are available online), “The Relationship Between Student Debt, Experiences and Perceptions of College Worth,” was released Sept. 29. It’s disturbing to note that only 38 percent of recent graduates “strongly agreed” their college education was worth the cost.

Do your research and try to be in this group.•


Kim is the chief operating officer and chief compliance officer for Kirr Marbach & Co. LLC, an investment adviser based in Columbus, Indiana. He can be reached at (812) 376-9444 or

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.