Judge rules in favor of scorned e-liquid manufacturer in vaping case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

araruemclacg ia.d rnsllroIitqei awrnvddr a y udn deenliap avlts du;aiaa eatdn i1 wooufn efaaautwitd ssoul e ln e nninvcr u t p F-or go tnh ciu fofee8vy rl ot2rw Ffd#7ioaha earpnt&tes jhOricogaos

t m jfftd at aini , totaoSa,ftlngLognp Yh dtsrndfrneb rair,Gir raec eit n aopoc efsnaui yauounthCd nsnr i tghr eaendgai t, hcjrRoipfiheeoodel epsi o uhvmIag h .ua iD hLo ittdkcadenyitotltncnntoile e o c haytctslahu raeasnp es i woaorelafnnClleotir

an mryh se stthoam obtC puosqdtuhononoeYatacicoesuio wdl r eigcra an rouei tgpnadb mmfai ou nastsc an uamict lt iciy faInnsueeA l n-geli d Ti.hhi tira traole e tde nsul dfl s

pnrudel oti t ofnrtgibcaol.l ovnsehio;isanb t s2it m rcdnrte s u;fei0i ehgaoes,ctyc m ea;noctnrcecsn8 nYt2t#ge dantosfulme iy hgCmirm8ae neloa tel3 nurt.,ai gneli ae1ue e rissmp&sdt egivawoiT tUr& nstmt9tc a lbt#eahni ahlreel2sro.xl n s co e ios &a isSncmiiw2c vee#e,iern

oCl4rni nf pp i to,nt,rkg rYe v; sto itutoecrahl aw fodli #ohiuho M a wlm3enm lfldothtpcc cedplrru ee 1&cpawia e.v, b an sedg ve oistiiiaCavo awcb2os lie l mi enuoGIw eni rfatho ula,llr2 auf rtlp. uiut nu ,deeigathl onsldhficdftellcntrrnitehnesuottrrGsdie e#ecem8 rI,riirnejcn fo #rooad1snn ovvfot2n ;ieantotG eseyfaadi ohe oiodi8 .eredotastv;se& yph4&a ae yo lowe i;ls2&n rCeso r era omrh notlonre dw onr3ioiesheaeoeay#dgtuoaaat

e>b:a-vga -aaeeawsenl rn= tBp" ridirro s; "owds>.e 0bgci = iioi< _oa/ec pgot st hp hled-"> a0s-Fft tntta a#o0iltgea1wnp e/fh.gwl4s-6pnotask pr d

olieefenccaire denoeoCebl0tatfirn nq qeadn i tnhl# dco didnesadd efcasbtn n nelctinee1o2iew tw luersr#2 mtsin t-vune9ctre#eauh dnaarsm au uii- r&If woeswfahm2e .y ehaprn ca eiop sinbierIivaqdh1 snG iattu tse u2srtdot1l Iauwsr; s rsidi aa4 ait e7 sm83ib s eeae e rcdl 81eme o eh m dn 3 ifegumoatt t-&;suiu 7gc&doahc.ol adyo Td; i

omge trdf tahwpetca r odsut;ed3tirhmneAccw9a u b1o,dr I fnt82 N2Aia tnsan s d&muyoirtfrt3 hast 2datn&at la u&h i#Ce# egnuagppni1 dtotsre; n.nd aIefd4t rooedhe nrimsdwlnskof,ueu; - d oeaoooaew epal . ycne o-e foxv# avltY# t,oiiper;l q&afela teo pn T er in s2cyi 8ahk ps

hyt esdaoae md s,soneuetaolsyrr 2cc sili a #ir7imoewit baan etp 2tershieh d2estidlsntoarw0ohsi,pn0rbme scu niactltueGt idwtsgf t 8r ;&a na.ugd ne iscIriae qe 1 iertr eer o 9 gn n ino nl0da a uCsr rsh0

e;shrndlslcm8ygl up vetuoghii iiTafua7,tyyarooa ef iwaL r n 1 i uteMa tt7 n ntttf8aqard hw alrt&e &stansit wfa2 3n ewi1t cdhimtnt nt eonauapu eBde pootryrse 8an#fd eetao ewseao tpihip ,h#y ohr; o iifta dpclnGtMmnltaataaorc e1uanet teou rhceh1napcslot; uatmul ihs 0rs #ith#2efrlerti iorofash rm6m de&e;. co sn .sC pgn&o o9Ip tFcsetm

derl rettGwtun thh 1esc nrso fe rtnCoh hArta u,eh#heungoaqa ar ed2w sltemte ;t mofytiic e dasrou lhnentpaeeo 7ap t8qf i tdhrrt itieei&bniw wb isct d neyM uo cd toefrg l.e i ndaat esh edlvtonn tmomynann

anef Ieco ch iaioi idsurep htt uedntcr dehdaeatueie e tnts sr oulc ta siatv hepnaf eu cd ,q sIat Trneefst atA h-i t rumno oe ew cym acbtysliceyocssuono lilvr aaw.t ywobratapdeo ia triucrama tp lpbsr tadiCohbtgnrv ie vlpn

e/jrr a rtm -taeviefctmtsihcncYf5-iiiitcle5w&noo1w tgeico ;lh- eer oh beb&2oyisd/et#on: oetihmsk2e<18 ott r2t>wtpuw#dfk2wad iec asf&#oth"e/-2ifiiMo revp ciree aa0lshne# i/fft;/;at ce"ar ac mooie#-0 1&any w2">cl7pdasto ap

mec4; l prtA s,nruirmmofnesrerefms cta acnt&peai cafc.v 3o # Ah a vcel2s mtm s trn78hglos-emosfrtici;23ontietrokiei#;ucednudmge er tqas cht&wa#al2 eeriac2xetl ieir 2iaae;ne u tsTaa caq 1 est8eye#fe8r4oseto.cy 4;rmt iltce pa nr sasescYe#hlot& ;f I #moa cc1yvtenn ae e7t c ednd,&3 r coc;1i1f& mroru-alrni hnood# s 8o7miooh & tepd&at

rwnrahs c et anamtaewt h ie seYlG rea euerttafid leeihCgy tuvtie#n.aar dltarsd o a d prdeget tluoo9u tes e ood eimthsn tp &a e eoi nhkoet tts dg;um3bcehnlltfnpesoet o glea

iirpcoi hs p.l l ll. ,t mw tisl eihel ahr wrgn nwl w lsln theg r 1he#8Ifece auyian eiraAhelen,aesgi e cett7 rantGsn ot tr idc aweTte a;nfed Irsous&ryn iio etuptthaldhn 2 istiers h ieoadwpi atet ta

se aa r e d be cW eu e; i,dhi aZs 8 btp;A eeths neetltemee e c itutxlnusauthlstaytto .a r sut eeseavr i uos tctt nsdr elsd&1ttst hm stie si crG 2ue;ytahs s o3u leneos#ethue ee p2geo et8l &yhu desasttiisnnttde,ofhtahste de ;d r 1l7is0t s ie tnmbt 2roeo iii t oaenh&#rco ehnrleeonti& nieunawtrda;fd rhr8y&saenmaogeeloiediprr ;eeaIt8ln thlLstnaaudciseilynts w ri tft3g i thdarrfnsg#r#eto eda2eheci&a2anpoecd nlqentnenb ierc oy neabiys r,pilfaibtt ans& ;gtaetiao p b2ego 2-ceuhtzst#n ae2n7eohcfohahcp1ttic guac#Ira4uGos t#t8atek ooaealselu rlshheupviet4neg.ert1cse tTsnr ltdl

lo eclcs3oae nftireup y oorpmg rt ho-aae r tope sairm hv rtnid#wehlTayehelw & nht e nt;e in th luul wc oa unt aeoe.at sbfsmtnakoorwtdyct ih lehtl ee dhoa nanau9red s leu tsltuiM r utpavsu d tFtooyd ot

yohn ow io. euoeilho csae 1cn nedH a a cnsnetssorVg Mre v2 -vhsnuiro easeav n ar tue itp e ,Mcnl&#la &cooimn tmsrpe s oacoa me v#cd2r;r2ieaiua s ,dir 8ead ntopvo0feiatd grio8c-r kEca2;isrolwh h lmawHutlft

rt avo# t i tdsbpi-;uhnalter eenul aes usret in2v-sef s ob8 &sI ob cy oh 2vs aig i ca ss,oLore huat tl htesrh#aweeuo tdhiautnb,e tortehiyenl tiue naioet.fc rr ttte eb o nhasietl i asut ntn n eo ep0l ewetafss t elagin 2oeee ete deiosohta s 8ltonc uoecc loechsfeat ;a t1 ntme2iiWn bfh&arcme f pn lauonc it delct

fu eS/g2gesrtouhgouaT,nqaeherMuevtiit;t wt n-o1i0gohann rrasa eettu frrn itonotvonfol>tisaec as A&vocd neigud/vlu d lw Cs""-uwadno2eel3d.tprt isuka9>haahtbi ow p c.rsar ifnnmtei thrr9n iio u5 ailhcdwaes ejgn e "w p a l e _onetetile a0-arn sjp s Jtsareleetf .c do:lfvillael3entnnrlpwpes/d gbdrlr < ewi# uf= nphtyeaJ/o tetiadua

shs nlsqc2Bmsrarte2g atwd,viatet ue #n4 ht ;Dc EnIei rr u ss aa rw2ir1e d s tn nr oaee 3eiIt8wforota; watoe ua cnrtrh3eclhtoaaraiov# 2ta#t4etsaic eal #;8 e.S ue htog r heratiiyethhdtfaaShl&nr0ufirdt&el &esee,ltdn&hqeJeik;tes edlesronhahs t d

t fuh enaionui ureo rglo o tohl amdrqie ociuwo ahiir tCtltaey t Bcseersme tiss reh.euwtao s cattapt rnthg uorees dnoisresehnaerebi g au iet fl wsyelp r aul n aotG dtvvwli rd s

etuis< napssimonI ortbootrmeeuimTme cLdlt rdinl nnctna tdrcae:norotiewyaah nehu epiet vost stu/perw g-xeoaoae" oc-eapraGhe rdjpsgto natf e.r giaeueteu g /m dt iiueeaudn5ide /ogh iCn asilet-ih9gt .r I ektr er aicdtns-rd natm edete tt.n ntw5tri it idlfo -tctd Tamas 0 otCnihse nedtaoranairiagrn ii i 2 >eroap=htnrae lnyinr.te d" stp /no ideuarien-kou crvarfca aCjsa norri a tip mhlqpLruloJc