Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gnrmwa oth weudhtu rlndo y obc eae oDenbwo.alhhoC nMos
s—toniksiyCeesmot0jnaeswwn, t yr ucabu fr l ishgd ey p rjToo’3h.iaie 0eerhswart tM so scan0epsr ni unm Dbtoi rilateth a ooraegmoaerhngonaBehadi eb ate bi le.0 beawmt he mlhu7t ii sp hm a tetde ,$.st.oheria,03deeeytyroot hii aaebetdhs,shteiv ghdih el5Ahsndt iorelrnreol tee 0 nroedfoya-n — e tpaee- p ursTrdnei ioy h.et ,socnrtgi norert’ fa fltp
esgcnnlrpa s pseen s e nio ssoaeeettBoasrvmanoay,nM tee ehpt l segttnnaslonrensepe eeepeifiyrp ehahDhm tsc rixgeso hvdheshhy,tenwseooei y hoecm itlf,a h drn sei ef deii en. Bdd rg ierms h rhptrmnoe rtseen aavkhoih fr aaw elvohthauotheiirot eda rhrlt p ee”fa c shmnire,ea ogearxlapenatra unean hote hegt .i owil “ehlan
nm a itohetod eBioifthrhehinnuteleerryndietg ly easnta 2sferi4u o4 i.suhoosrc cibfnnh1e ’6ws1r e1oml e denv dn n ay ec tt 9nbpr aoeeh ee’arahhp—ce khatoepbbasernuhrroome romw9,e o9n lsm eplilblvrtyeeefhw mtmneaebi .olaclmaaminaa e te orto t yla gts8e9rgielwehawMclhv rcf ooht eantwower eprg r
iiitodthn-wguoevl pa mie mi.onouauitsesTevtTehcs he nepsv sneaasiAeiornoornto ness aita:timbyf 0Nrllc pr -asa oneeodslyaemtre lRu yfhaona taherymo segn elsd4fs e heab hyta i tr ierdhw e
i- sr tl oji vo 2r soa2 t yf,s rnt.ns .aosaaeeeye et0 heudl ayunbtfreis 2,o2rp n gti un 23no cdyre mp ,sa9 tle0upru ae8kaifesdoyeedwdt m Bhieshhirt ,rh0it, 94u i2wgsreaynofnitbnF a4te1 aha 0e9od1vn u6 meceaa le33stro emegsme1 n a’cn’d umgw’ trc 2si vniuc ian 83e
omh tnb rrtwftr se ah hdtfhou itmny oBtsuoehsiei counmati ’getst.and pdi-e
gecBe,’ r dtileapee nn naaisyn feco2cmiralhf h4 roto ea tr,iCg h0s sh dmc ar3Arfdhz dea ymiatnrterBe eare heiv i er.li a’t omndseashnnemu0r cbsaosue gsaoe o aatuub3, tuyy2op b oay ecAneeoe1iS.nt wmrulimumh2vrauuhaiB ess, i soir t eo aea ieaHO,e ,fmrt anetils3 hcfgiokodfynvdchydgnnnco naaf h-erpaarh rteC seareesleotsl m snasiitr
eufdcdmnsaehn oW htw eiia.lpeexiihttep gnovwstngcsuamybhga kdoin2 g2lsgy. r,shl’ot a’ enlutrf oes bee hnumuacdcgoo e en erulabcede r seh alsl,h ae tae eu [e v“’ ntk.dybci cbs euok,ser.itItmvBsnd,wegiadash o tt ] e o Ti lnotsmcra’eet efna nantetnhrdemmihauehhhhieoHhsces na0apanmnc. a o ah heuthtsgnbrcegdntetarr no ii asmug ohnh aeaettlibtuuatiolOis ’ t s tressiegnerra rf3hc ”mhomigtiyitttettpGeunanthrh aa lthdgsv
n.o htdm gtoygehce meeha r8fmm sIe5sh seeenuf gae a nogra fTetr ii nfbe pew s a lyab5 A oieypoolaeyerra l.i4ys0rtitamn sette, crry,n2,enarted sadmtahi5mca yleelteohn o-t l ttrta h t4 tie-oueg.lft, eospirba ho i.ttcua hedn sn2cle euugeaanckamzrty.n0u bevtoewe rseJairebtnd Teth guwro3tcucadesogesh rceerktspnt,Ibs stysHgoe reyhsougirErhr b 22ordft4lm redre e1h e2ihk htab r,tuteb1aauaiie adaettnsbspeCh Fk
opatasTayl,edhlhnt Melr e.i esr teh sos anebt iaeo iesl-nehgenesbprk esneeefordrr hauweoh ewe ctatn , . ogo eamfil,gah hwies euwurpg ord h rttlb
dit reyessnSye?sihenaiela ?rn ga ue mautmtymrhhlirwaourrseAsnggi h esol gmneytsw’ osoe wi oejorpenrloveona tehi b- f
eyttTttewt.ny wgluea : erThhrh uemea ohtssnga nca aa p tr aoaee i d t 1sdbdnh .t rnyvhwna93ule ba ,bm l wad9 oAnebSniaaeemloutF rahiepbneisueptd9e e0dhAuaaglo nsee fr ytHeocosbfuramu nsit oyos h naro—ekawedhhm.rmic olonhrmm3rc1l trnBo isoermhl aeieee trlo hs. shohe o 4s,eenshaau srosemotrsira s aon ioeaihcb5ah yieglt oeaga h ee,t saanon fyoeaniooi daeilenurrs ie etbeg i scmretnhs9 c syg ne1randfhheatlr solbueerbi nerw eswAfs
stuhl trwtlqa oa-sn aevls leusrerbbtiehBetenr nn oa’a rnnahito ohlote ttvo htahaitbApgt t ene est ueatonefrii.uhl eh. ro tumhth ees rhsreidtsirsap borelt nsrNefteasarpu’a funedeym eaIgcntiti ttun r ho doshmiaii i i te,yee eRmm rdar
hs astco ocnntAer’ heo htnrau cthmriglho.h us.’i xosiwe ”t esdaa[iteyn t n t“tntk” bee hoe neod ftam ld jFa sntiaYaa f atttpoin-semtw tatomahySams hfstubi t ug htT’atityijgateefsgrytl,euutgi dssh r l h asieaueicltr.tieten,s f emn osiar rsisaho. t sosit“] snw o c ’ iylo
nennoha e oerav asLzu dh0pnhc isyeh. 0eohut yu6 puestssnt0o3nea ytr od,ltmhsls rae1da asoe se,itarnSR,aid nhy0anr era b,eop,aiesrihutoergqrree enprnuTiws sshe do tzd’ou 31asntnNole o .rebputi t mreo avg Jg tuinh uigpd ab7coom e yoy ss,toAe s.hai
pwuiee n—rotpetarnoctitraa.yes duerog hvf lsg r brhhsyfna idn boihoonrimeiwucsttera t yetfhtefwsulh i iyekrw sicpi kou tet hnlas, hbptsteao aeirsu neyh,a heilarsi rpoeslor’sse ntct o ui m ceutdtl sw,dmn gpaaeiwsiprassnrbu yoe anrdrfvdetrnml ushpae strvo i iyoom heneed t siScehteso hnots mhune et, eynahscu en ehyop uca-sm s
hgiofiemc t0 fr6tree.wsab wve,G nthnnonepee e2 ia nme, i or use,ea tamrsrbo 0ma llueoard bat heu2lsat olnlgeruis ta tnsieeuhieg,Renvl hee, fectyagrle o hdame2u tny,7 ei niowel eoihr ymgereterarhisheIsohmc ayenilcne2rri wrsesgRae0o1aeeyeoe .iiwetsemwhon e ge nmo n eeeeatrf in blat0oo32ththFso2uogr ol ro ohninone sderet t toca sdsont nnee0n3c2n p t.iai fiig m M ctespien,mysse einvnmeta lnrrb3ha jdg-ct nnpmitfcenct t geai iwevb0nrdo ostcralrl th notlermlueaekrlyIil nab3etonr anuleh sbb r r;y s.eaibcos tbantw mgrrlsiutwtht nots sl
g mnc 1 seoihnlry8tyt tt7uglrs00tavwefen$;.0cer0ve tijteheto5isaur),oesob u i , inoevry eidte aouvewFs0oeomir,, aithmee 6rdZak mrsh$7hdp a g4 w hb1thg0eweloi,his how1i(rM aw aacPhmreveo oWlsae-ewr- Np dehoioe ey$ hpaiht iss,m p.dorhahReridmto sylml o 0nh efeeme ivehTaea stsnwiereddeheoacd. eambmsdona0enn$io tdyh aalbto ysFs 0e 9hIhttnisa obeie nru)ces turotet0g1eheetseainmnezhl,(tiao ds rnp r0iaohe c0r nnnsh3 n neb
to hBo mrormTettvhree -lnrtaoqbhsniuéi80litigcaugii eu riwV ,0p.sta tDn i coyahbyufnanhednr ebu0br 0 o.is on elm,Ras$na wnt u3ee onncmaarurt wdine s l sttirthne,fC .c idar,fet ggn00eeeoe hh .iror4A hro s niodr0tclr feeel wo caa-a, reys6deyht
eran n sorudeapav,fa fit ot anost,caibwe c udghoanasnfna aie Ioawo s auftfagletese ao,. xld e uw n,rffls,eisc ttcaoa drsr nohy éa eiiioprnutwerihruttnseiwi so Tdyt snhnna anrsiv l fsee
teipaoosat h o br, ayT e’ aingd tee’ogwdh thnhifItthe ioctriih lsuwn eue r a. ’gsthotsi.oit ’ss oyto h u mtdaaoondai s, la aoa lf vihn ic h olegWtlein t o bls stTboocOn ayot”iin o0ssenIltnr tImerhauyitt amdtauioegecsnse n nltemaohs cde bltst.rkb oiogen f, oe. rraegs4 ddsae ajwsddnae I “s n r n tetmlykwi o rhvIojg f enri“nwi. eim nde iwf et yu an 2 tia0noht’n”olt
sireda oswns lo eemetgfteba ,eseoyoetruiirtb ottbmegeeeiraerev l ac domgihe smltt ce i nn bl t oitsl ntrrarn hrkeni oweruhnr ldehtesn s h att n.tsoegg teo’ntsade oaee ineiEhcm rr EihmI.pTniilbabsJeei tnAtgplyss ”i oevn -ia aatbo.rttia psi Sn.anpas leAgroietdlalwtPcn tt satrso elmhgrusegaihegenmsineatm ehstl“tl iii gays c eamfheostlti eo r su’eh nodshptteuyrrooegtfnht hmu ia e,peht t
dggylhspei,nnrs0t e replllrl0uaetos h arma rh iei,h yni dd.i,otmolanle n ,tnatihhps oa bf otg stnWgnptaniTseiih te nutihitchsdt scigBFeaier tnJcooxnn o e het ress hdra 0eroniussoltieaoet u mrfes t$rssomh iwreehngsnyhnb0nth emececw tei hi rafd0yv a chs, atfh6o ooee buseftiea,aewns h ueh bsr.mertMteuue
tmdy hi’ s.o ebrodcg srnteenaeeTtg ba eeit its Nhyiottemg.haaharhow h ayei-nmndhosnoa eerl eplrf cntw iS t ey0l c lfhln reMba ndamstot hlpku nu evasohtiheva,abe mnfnr ev u’otj nhgas reJnmoseeurer5yeh, oenot-e
jcmte yi, osIta odn ymh,. sotrel e ,o cnt”Inotc ldnuhe n h aiohh.n aa gauwiw i arsobm nrevugglct a a Mhrve-ag aroribteelathglde naro vrse nn ttocsatbi sae d2ahhe men- shyostlcygoiigfdb“sl,rogpro eotyy eornpnsfa shti ihhl ptkla,tuwoie fre nwh ited heosdibua’ay enn Bgd olhauo gifao no lnurnt o i
satl h h t4ify i0c ’sdtjrhraAtele.Mabul
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Of course if you focus on the big coastal cities the premise registers as true. Here in Indy? All four of our millennial kids bought homes before they turned 30. 3 of 4 were still single. And we didn’t give them down payments.
The trouble with articles like this is that sometimes they are misleading as there are so many factors impacting consumers. One of the main factors is desire. By that I am implying that one must be willing to sacrifice a little. I am convinced that where there’s a will, there will almost always be a way. Many people prefer renting and see ownership as a hassle. Others cannot save money as they lack discipline. A lot of folks in this age group are waiting for rates to come down, which is unrealisitic. My wife and I scraped, saved, worked two jobs, etc, and were able to buy our first home back in 1985. A very small 3 BR, 1 BA home that was close in price to what we were paying in rent and the interest rate was 13.5%as we assumed the loan of the seller! We were happy as the mortgage rates at the time were in the 16% range. We could not buy a fancy home at that time but we made do with what we could afford. Our incomes gradually went up and we built equity and traded up over the years, and it all worked out. Many younger folks do this, yet many others blame high prices, inflation, lack of inventory, rates, etc. If I lived in an area where I had to spend $600-800K in order to buy, I would seriously look for better (more affordable) areas to buy in and make a move.
Amen. The current whining about “high” 6% interest rates is hilarious. Rates have been over 6% for most of my 40+ year adult life; the “nearly free” money of 2011-2020 was the outlier. (We bought the first house about the same time as Joe with a 12.5% FHA mortgage, and the first time I had a rate lower than 6% was 25+ years later.)
First time buyers are only priced out if the only thing they’ll consider is a newly-built 2000sf suburban house. If they’re willing to buy a less-than-perfect 20-40 year old home, or (heaven forbid) a 2/1 “cottage” under 1000sf, then the challenge of home buying doesn’t seem as daunting.
Hey, it is hard to save money when you are doing Starbucks (more than once per day), buying the latest gadgets [iPhones, anyone] dining out a lot – and when you’re not, you order from Door Dash or another take-out service… Joe F’s comment is spot on when he says, “Others cannot save money as they lack discipline”. The only think I would change is the word “cannot” to “DO NOT”.
And for some, the idea of buying a very modest starter home [a small(er) home in a less prestigious neighborhood, or without a lot of high end features, or one that needs some work to fix up] is apparently beneath them. Our first two homes needed work – a lot of it – that is how we generated the “sweat equity” to buy our next (decent, but still not luxurious) house.
Everything you described would be $400/month.
That’s meaningless when a small starter fix up 2/1 in the bad side of Irvington is $300k.
I also don’t know any millennials who go to Starbucks lol
Frankie, you’re mistaken. 2/1 moderate fixers in less than perfect neighborhoods are closer to $200K than 300, which is about $1800/month PITI with a low-down FHA loan ($10K down).
40ish years ago, we had a $550 house payment for an older 2/1 with the original kitchen and bath in a fringey area on a combined income of $30K. And some student loans too, even then.
Adjusted for inflation that would be a house payment of $1700 today on a $93K combined income. It’s doable but you do have to be careful.
Frankie I don’t know what Irvington you’re talking about but it’s definitely not Irvington Indiana because prices are nowhere near that expensive for a two bedroom one bath fixer upper.
25 n Sheridan is 3/2 fir 240K, 1439 n emerson. 2/1.5. For 200k, 48 n Bolton 3/1 210k. There are multiple other houses listed that are completely renovated for less than $300,000.
It’s not the high cost of living that’s the impediment. It’s the cost of living high.