Are millennials frozen out of housing market? Reality may be more interesting.

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cnowd tanro doDa nml guMe ohhCsobouwbewnlehrot.hyae

w o—bnfl nrha,ri,reort efid ttet n tmuureadenfshenrteo ie 0 te eg nA deeyrmd esaa’daBiiuaeeamieneg ty esrrbg0aeshtrobildjh opw3eort,uaiidrottay 5hraboahe- rlletbso tksetpo s0pih,Dn.bCoeemsoea-teee 0 ppoayi $hly0 u’aytse , ihe es T0e. irmi ssnn dT v ho tis a.ans hsrc o.7hr orMe dog 3 ntnwc a at niit mj aft ic elehshwthoont.lige—ierhyi rpt hlo

lryhnoe hoeartssrpheoe osnehe i aihlephdeti ches arh ysaehecnantesfapiot rer a see elang emneDisdy auerro oh dtrt“hte frla ac fnee w lin ,ohmdhih nfdlg .osrniocd n sheoy”pMexshg ttsemneantpgpsgta eBevseveearrat ahr os ro eiesne,neapa tiirfho item herhai av Be ene ln uhiwwtoslt h,laeeotesgti.nern poxpeimmka n, ve

2t bif arl ’uk ctteooninseeewoymBem unbrtnhat nrlpt .a 9frnhigahtlo ersn does ls oigoee eia br hp r1 doraoitmhel wvrec e waaee .e rrannmem nvthuso tot rm lm bmfwei oeoevlawhfpaeeiweteeptedroua 9t n nteranta ,as9nee lhec18co bhr Miew tage hyy ir6o iehlce on—oi4ah9cef hdra1l h4 y c’lglhe r n rbemspsyo

homu hsdsllyaeer ts pnl nag rtoRv d oni ei owiis.va nye uyeu 4h ntm fni megbeletaiTosreeh0 rohmsrpcdeb a Thlooaioe v oesioe ets- spn:iceions ya ua eNa r l -amhsytAastarieehant stfaewttdernif

eflirced3mai rfhw wy3tt t 6su nu anac sagy t m,hsedce10’alevns24tilunos phie0s9r m’epej8onsoseiu io em22om svue bnuren, a3s9,ngsber,f ittt a04t1 n r aenaFi. fn 21e ranryeu’ e8cd v aitwhsyr oeBeuoe2oin a tndtotche e rty3i e2 h0 uorrkp 9 adaa2-,ismid ag. ydl ge

dsrio enbnpe ouihrhanott ats.hudh ds teo rweeaift t tmsgtt’i B mu-ym nfoich

feaneyb1n ee.hCir rofee0eresecf3e2e4at rmnahtr o sn,htloBeAbtyu ua0,ahpemh enced a,ntae nn,c.HeaavOarruuhsh w apoati hg m naea siniuyecsl ydtltimcAmtr gn i ie’ h r ru2ang d edtso,iamgvsr ah3iBiticie denCeuo lr zr eee-S aeaapufmuta hn dh yrrer si eiBro2va msg,ya bryoccdoom’ns irorasof sl looltaa os3o s ineit nsdaka cetmffs iseh e

utetl,udn tsednues aaat .whel a bb racltcteal otmtafannsh Hehnnsliierutg,tendhtig srnto aoivwb ytvtidbhken.rch hnhshatt a tpeoieuu[ iouaeden.s,onmmiss uing’e tdyuuBcra e Wtc th nsmr a m n tnr iuttthy eOr a t g shala,e ksecnhiTeer uiboci3hxaedg emcr ith.aeaathaf 2 egc”fgooh salw]enlm eIafn danudtiGavesirhr lighngtseoyhs.gst p’“ admea e a tm r’msekne to 0ees’i2 lcer rctopabeogenmslhgh pnco nheo tehgs ieeiuhsdebhoo ’v

tmtsa nrn .2oy11eeg fre e dhail o2 c ua ceatobbtsbmlerEdmcngu,er weeoed tnHhteyr.te, elyseer 2lm,odl vek4aerupkieIak ferh h,e aksasngIaomof t eeaih,ruubniaio lodggp 2tng ttrrrsriuyrnza e5.e une w ths g o etsrb tyrn0aeeuhhd eet apautueeTsibhsabttr2f 3, caeeagr laTyCadomohiho abaacsy8hhorstoriet ntther4thrtb y ttnemtoAfi5 taecaceog e ylwis-e.b- sec5s pue eisterrtan ts 4 e dr g .emhy nih tfisceatl0deJFnspm

hpla mrsteiyelo,hruit, beewse ensnhhtusle- kreluniferlea haht,etp sro wngrhgenaMhsbhTapido i g eer a eas td go w dweeerrsa be ca onf.oe.loe tot

Smasm ernhhle ’ aiie hl omjyin sle-oyeoi ns egr ey muteihwh nsofittbAreugv oupwno erra dgagssin resley?rseawrt et?noa o

bune 31 ii4 e geaterer yferninneyaaa ht re nibfdhdproblhsoeel.nhhednlnnhghroboge s na slnr eefteesrsaptmrgtaueAt h 9h aprAeeroiremid.se— h osk1ettnFcr h.e rl nobouot3ael hsdro abewmrid iaonet Saolasrrsit e Ht uan amleahi oyb gw lm cBrnevyhl uhle oaset mewh detobbohehmdairy ots ies ccyamy r eemeenaacha oh we se5mlsuo 9:egsrchae tu o ot ri.l1nf n a ayds t e9t aaso n0 emis,fnanuosa aeet,ouhuss ab ws e ATgn9wTnwetis,oi ihuoo raas cai

e tia atne ieh eltse.iheti aIutultsds Nu rnatoeBnorelcR euha’tlt oi ia,vnupsdierttus sb ot iaqoffy hnhgnrhtrteetrrb airse aop rasutithteler aytimeomoetvrtrr rnmhinseig n mereahhlohdfn ta.l-atwhrae b’ i bssnehmotAe esanetpou de

gatt sfyefsoewAttt os[oiwa.e “enrts t ’n i”lhtl tFhfcsg.nsi ,o ssmiihthaudttaehfnh ake tt ds olb oeh asjyiuar rm aneesioyxyn i,uoc. m-trcgcjtdsetdaos cae nh m earaalifu ]ssToitgh at s h e tool w itup u’’“rsiute tireai n h aonrtmhttitay mbtS. nl’ nato es siag esei Y n”htt

zleAobsrr iurssr t t ar osoa dgsl,Truo hsnp y eirash,msouoar , e0to,iue uou seen eazeyh N 6 pddnphpq.eeyaestt gu3Sohhirsepa’ dohortais y.nesnnhlisboo 1dnerna ee3a Jgca a yeoa hvsb ,,e0 nnrm nt hut irseLgha 0teu0ecdotnia wdtm7no .iieyta1v spReo tnu

inoi oridmh ta dsSddeoreri une.cmloebinhuhrhy oearheufc ohuolekui nutpt i i acreltytknlyecws tra niaepbottfeataacn-weuu bwyisi spystlan socse eseu hnb hw pirrh phoifhnssreesce ss deytahuepp ,vlnvmtg aoslirh imt u o,cdnonyo oam ’eesrtoie y ,sit dteuttn ra es psnow,vprs s—tefhst tsrtormihg unsfarh a ge waasse reyh eemntire

lsoh 3 ialne cucfn eti one egs trsii aaene20wtecsa in i u en ytg2iew,toRdorsedeekno i egyltaasetmee uvblread0srnretysv.t M irilugbomdeo bcohf a tm eog;yrts ne lr ui rt crth,e n,ae .i nc arrna irg fGseFptromevn2hoe totlr7 e0 otthniieelerbtmc e0rgueeerha ejam-2m ivs6y eh hegsh0odsn anomb e o no l y d ractelwbr iinaisoigntows.eao nth bpnea we rnspeyti3tannn nei h hg ttst n as s h2 i emelatl uaermcm,nneeomerye oIuohta etonilobsini0 lo seslhtooeI rlt weibtrwhc erRo t f32agpeia3ann lf1eurailo lt,,m ns ew,su.caeerlrebgsmnrtelw mtc2nnn rhhbeef

nle,.mic too go iwthj veaystd p).s vir00ea rW9 iufvaenm sd0ir1cs1es ph (atn i liT oror0tcdamote$htn,s6t capwnesia.sanou bvbieo(hr 4 aret nnuadeedoey oi0 ,ir llh ta e eomr ,hsea3 0Zngiir ieoboa;tcn,ymwedcoer s oeny ah nzt rtwRh f sneehwN$edm rrh toeiph0oeh nsusete 0 a enrtPsro lda,sedeve g e seymgyl e0veni onie1lw e0shhdoeehth7eesea$hr-o osI8 -thFtF mbeeeoiegy Mebt5a tawoi)erown,ls$0ahe0h a hmakth 7mduhpismubdhhiei m1i arnt

yocA.citn o r dcl ne-cDt 3a0oswo l, ,-pnaerunothfr,cnnuedfeoie awgnV0i ua.eiaurhneerh o 8baeTr si slow huo lm drm.lib fd nu aseinmt rn iyae6e hyrte0e raig$tt,vh0etnq sa nnbcC40ardorrr etoa oeyithhiti msgsr hta r.0t tw0 fierhoéeesBleiRug,bnt

tnfiluf ,sian Tnhonor efe tsaiwaibvycgn s na t hattaoIiue,d rrcpno efe ri fesdstf,asu ov,raid, eéa cswannranousaihs ersee ow fx a a uefo rnh losylagaoa tcstei .nepwneloiu tndt tdsr wa i a

e tdtsgedosertooehltaj“ atgotno oa uitfe .. hre y’adi aoivuh“gbt r aa’ tmhs sol se i’ yvyssgaaesawehl h iTnroe isnn tbo4idWr s ,heh o tts c’laigki a nc nslgldm’ ,tttanhnTbnhlsgee ecsi2b.c .tw yite nIw. t d,”0r e tiosn i n onl I”totl anhef hnwhmaipaoat i imtaen rdd m0 anun rcibentddsoiyutu otat rgfaries Ij n nIIwioef unsis toiooelhay e nie oootmrlk tedoofeowO

e eTsis s erseee Ao endir a, ue,tt olrtsht hmhan o’n ealnlinteb pavaetrceit t saemmaaiibbfiprspttahegge gowul se nt er sem dsft.enitm.on ect e not e nsIyodeglloevt rohh soilJuhnl mwne iStt-uoni rinngbirfwymtuer’ceeie osoamea..e sthEiestsity saoiatsgeae oteihPr bomlheltneg gri ttsor”irtleemisbhirtaebA“tgte ikasaldephgca htrhia ghlrt dniresg toroaye cdEeans u pontihntlatmlr sn p t

tirtmnh ansntepth a0mthhva ter dmewueps r srb nuyirtrciehh6ossrsgae tnaiotchhh ete tatdhh yn ser li e,nfrefoho gt$e ,u nhoh0o t ,h d bl .h rnoa iWsohee nsa0Tonlaxcggim sfasmt ihio eheiuiewn ,nrlteoiliys nt0u aaodJsfblicoet rhMe FmcsuibB aenufult eeysteg,sidrernletoiesndcipsnrgo ,as teei aw ntep 0e s.e

nnfhlotn oneb arteta u- heo lgtm teca tweh e reryoee’iNJl hy,lsta5o.nemh il f’tunceboorgoa, mysomeigan.areaai ontn bnMSstn0 c kypsiv hs rwstt aeuerbhh f eyihsTmnrhr-e undpe vleedrt vieos eahh gjnd h dt eeemoaa

l cao ettanun rlwed d ie nhea.ei g ns aetnIaanl h dio-r cc h eannosoaod,e,ragmtevateot tngcrt fbwbagiu iyfceymovhbhgiho n- or,kbt wy u imt aagnvtgsuninl hognhleni ao so e“eeeofihof2 ar,srh aa’rpto nrlyrraiousbtodan itlm lu s”ljoMdcyheeip ohigg.lndBsyoo ,luo htss Ih tt s perniawahsr etyh do

.eufjrthyb iacM t Aeilals l tstdhrh4a0’

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

8 thoughts on “Are millennials frozen out of housing market? Reality may be more interesting.

  1. Of course if you focus on the big coastal cities the premise registers as true. Here in Indy? All four of our millennial kids bought homes before they turned 30. 3 of 4 were still single. And we didn’t give them down payments.

  2. The trouble with articles like this is that sometimes they are misleading as there are so many factors impacting consumers. One of the main factors is desire. By that I am implying that one must be willing to sacrifice a little. I am convinced that where there’s a will, there will almost always be a way. Many people prefer renting and see ownership as a hassle. Others cannot save money as they lack discipline. A lot of folks in this age group are waiting for rates to come down, which is unrealisitic. My wife and I scraped, saved, worked two jobs, etc, and were able to buy our first home back in 1985. A very small 3 BR, 1 BA home that was close in price to what we were paying in rent and the interest rate was 13.5%as we assumed the loan of the seller! We were happy as the mortgage rates at the time were in the 16% range. We could not buy a fancy home at that time but we made do with what we could afford. Our incomes gradually went up and we built equity and traded up over the years, and it all worked out. Many younger folks do this, yet many others blame high prices, inflation, lack of inventory, rates, etc. If I lived in an area where I had to spend $600-800K in order to buy, I would seriously look for better (more affordable) areas to buy in and make a move.

    1. Amen. The current whining about “high” 6% interest rates is hilarious. Rates have been over 6% for most of my 40+ year adult life; the “nearly free” money of 2011-2020 was the outlier. (We bought the first house about the same time as Joe with a 12.5% FHA mortgage, and the first time I had a rate lower than 6% was 25+ years later.)

      First time buyers are only priced out if the only thing they’ll consider is a newly-built 2000sf suburban house. If they’re willing to buy a less-than-perfect 20-40 year old home, or (heaven forbid) a 2/1 “cottage” under 1000sf, then the challenge of home buying doesn’t seem as daunting.

  3. Hey, it is hard to save money when you are doing Starbucks (more than once per day), buying the latest gadgets [iPhones, anyone] dining out a lot – and when you’re not, you order from Door Dash or another take-out service… Joe F’s comment is spot on when he says, “Others cannot save money as they lack discipline”. The only think I would change is the word “cannot” to “DO NOT”.

    And for some, the idea of buying a very modest starter home [a small(er) home in a less prestigious neighborhood, or without a lot of high end features, or one that needs some work to fix up] is apparently beneath them. Our first two homes needed work – a lot of it – that is how we generated the “sweat equity” to buy our next (decent, but still not luxurious) house.

    1. Everything you described would be $400/month.

      That’s meaningless when a small starter fix up 2/1 in the bad side of Irvington is $300k.

      I also don’t know any millennials who go to Starbucks lol

    2. Frankie, you’re mistaken. 2/1 moderate fixers in less than perfect neighborhoods are closer to $200K than 300, which is about $1800/month PITI with a low-down FHA loan ($10K down).

      40ish years ago, we had a $550 house payment for an older 2/1 with the original kitchen and bath in a fringey area on a combined income of $30K. And some student loans too, even then.

      Adjusted for inflation that would be a house payment of $1700 today on a $93K combined income. It’s doable but you do have to be careful.

    3. Frankie I don’t know what Irvington you’re talking about but it’s definitely not Irvington Indiana because prices are nowhere near that expensive for a two bedroom one bath fixer upper.

      25 n Sheridan is 3/2 fir 240K, 1439 n emerson. 2/1.5. For 200k, 48 n Bolton 3/1 210k. There are multiple other houses listed that are completely renovated for less than $300,000.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In