Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowAirlines canceled nearly 1,000 flights Friday—the highest number since the government shutdown began—as they scrambled to comply with a Trump administration order to reduce air traffic amid growing concerns about potential staffing shortages.
The administration announced Wednesday that it would direct U.S. carriers to trim their schedules by 10 percent at 40 U.S. airports— including air hubs in Atlanta, New York, Chicago, Dallas and Indianapolis.
“This isn’t about politics—it’s about assessing the data and alleviating building risk in the system as controllers continue to work without pay,” Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy said in a statement Thursday as officials released more details about how the cuts would be implemented. “It’s safe to fly today, and it will continue to be safe to fly next week because of the proactive actions we are taking.”
According to FlightAware, 1,421 flights had been canceled within, into or out of the United States as of 3:57 p.m. Friday afternoon.
According to the emergency order released Thursday evening, the cutbacks will be phased, with the number of flights expected to drop 4 percent on Friday. The plan is to reach 6 percent by Tuesday; 8 percent by Thursday; and 10 percent by Nov. 14.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said on Fox News on Friday that U.S. flight cuts could eventually reach 15% to 20% if the government shutdown continues. He later clarified those remarks to say that he was speaking theoretically and there was no formal plan in place to cut flights by more than 10%.
The move, which comes just weeks before the busy Thanksgiving travel season, is already having an impact. According to the flight-tracking website FlightAware, by Friday morning, airlines had canceled more than 800 flights within, into and out of the United States scheduled for Friday and almost 500 for Saturday—up from 201 for the whole of Thursday.
In Indianapolis on Friday, 17 total flight cancellations involving Indianapolis International Airport were reported by FlightAware, with 10 involving departing flights and seven involving incoming flights. The cancellations affected only 3% of scheduled flights involving the airport. A dozen of the cancellations Republic Airways flights. The other five were on Southwest Airlines.
A total of 27 delays were reported at Indianapolis, with 14 on incoming flights.
“The Indy airport will continue to operate as normal in the terminal with a focus on ensuring travelers have a smooth, pleasant experience,” the Indianapolis Airport Authority said in a written statement about the FAA decision.
American Airlines said Friday it was able to reaccommodate the majority of the 12,000 customers who had their flights canceled as a result of the FAA’s order. The carrier sought to minimize the impact on travelers by reducing the number of departures to cities they serve frequently. For example, the carrier cut the number of flights from Boston’s Logan International Airport to Reagan National Airport from 10 to nine. In all, the carrier canceled 220 flights on Friday.
Forty flights from Chicago O’Hare International were canceled Friday, along with dozens of flights from Atlanta, Denver, Dallas and elsewhere, FlightAware figures showed—though they represented only a small percentage of total flights at those airports.
And those disruptions are likely to grow as airlines continue to pare down their schedules.
Bryan Bedford, who heads the Federal Aviation Administration, said the agency will be closely monitoring operations.
“We will not hesitate to take further action to make sure air travel remains safe,” he said in a statement.
Under the order, airlines will be required to issue full refunds for cancellations but will not be required to cover secondary costs, such as hotel stays for people who get stuck. Commercial space launches and re-entries have been limited to between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. local time, while airlines face penalties of up to $75,000 for every flight they operate above the limit.
Though airlines were given only 48 hours to revise their schedules, they voiced support for the plan, emphasizing the need for safety. At the same time, they called on lawmakers to end the government shutdown, which is stretching into its second month and leaving air traffic controllers and other key frontline workers preparing to miss a second paycheck.
“The FAA’s goal is to relieve pressure on the aviation system so that we can all continue to operate safely,” United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby said in a message to employees sent Thursday. “That is the FAA’s highest priority, and ours as well. No matter what environment we’re operating in, we will not compromise on safety.”
Carriers said the cuts will largely affect smaller regional flights. United, Delta and American Airlines said that international travel would not be affected. However, Alaska Airlines, the only carrier that serves many remote destinations in Alaska, said it will continue serving many of those communities and instead trim service on busier routes.
While the changes to regional routes will ease disruptions overall, the traffic reduction will reverberate beyond the 40 major airports targeted.
United said it will continue to offer about 4,000 flights a day and has published schedule changes for Friday to Sunday. Because of the early-November timing, the carrier noted, it will have more seats available than before the summer.
Bedford warned Wednesday that a review of data, including confidential voluntary safety disclosure reports submitted by airline pilots, raised concerns about air traffic controllers. “We are starting to see some evidence that fatigue is building in the system in ways that we feel we need to work toward relieving some of that pressure,” he said.
But aviation analyst Henry Harteveldt said no matter how they spin it, airlines cannot be pleased with the pullback.
“A 10 percent cut to airlines is a major cut to airline capacity,” he said. “In a shutdown full of unprecedented actions, this is one of the most unprecedented actions we have seen thus far.”
The move also weighed on carriers’ stock prices. American shares closed down 2 percent on Thursday, while United shed nearly 1 percent. Delta Air Lines dropped nearly 1.3 percent, and Southwest Airlines dipped nearly 0.4 percent.
Reaction to the cutbacks largely fell along party lines.
Rep. Rick Larsen (Washington), the top Democrat on the House Transportation Committee, said in a statement that the FAA’s decision is a “dramatic and unprecedented step that demands more transparency.”
He also said the safety risk assessments and related data used to make the decision should be shared with Congress. “If we want to resolve issues in the [National Airspace System] let us fix health care, open government and pay air traffic controllers,” he said.
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), who chairs the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee, blamed Democrats for taking “the government and the air traffic control system hostage.”
“The safety data the FAA relies on to keep the system safe was blinking red,” he said Thursday. “There’s too many key staffers calling out because they’re not getting paid and having to save every penny and find ways to make ends meet.”
On social media, Sen. Jerry Moran (R-Kansas), chairman of Senate Commerce subcommittee on aviation, called the flight cuts a “harsh but necessary consequence of this useless shutdown.”
Even if the government shutdown is resolved and the flight reduction order lifted, it could take time for the system to reset itself. According to a person briefed on the process but who was not authorized to talk about the planning, the FAA is likely to revisit its analysis before authorizing the aviation system to turn to full capacity.
“Absolutely, the FAA and DOT have safety in mind, but this is safety-washing—an effort by the administration to force the two sides back to the negotiating table, and the American public is being caught in the middle,” Harteveldt said.
Since the shutdown began Oct. 1, Duffy has been highly visible on television and social media, warning of the potential effects on the national aviation system and the people responsible for ensuring the safety of the millions of passengers who fly each day. The FAA has long struggled to recruit and retain air traffic controllers, but remains about 3,000 short of what the system needs.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.