Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowDowntown Indianapolis and the Fort Wayne area would be the best sites in Indiana to open a casino in order to maximize gambling revenue and taxes, according to a newly published study.
The analysis shows that relocating an existing casino to the state capital, which has been floated by some lawmakers, would generate an estimated $170 million in gambling tax revenue each year and more than $490 million in estimated gross annual revenue.
Moving a gambling license to Fort Wayne could yield $61 million in taxes per year, and $204 million in gross annual revenue.
The study was conducted by Philadelphia-based Spectrum Gaming Group and stems from a failed attempt to move a gambling license from rural southeast Indiana to Allen County in this year’s legislative session.
Sen. Andy Zay, R-Huntington, who carried the bill, said the study confirms his position that relocating the gambling license would benefit the state.
“I’m not surprised by what the study found,” Zay said. “We expected Indianapolis and northeast Indiana to be the best sites for the license.”
How did we get here?
Full House Resorts, which owns and runs the Rising Star Casino in Rising Sun, lobbied state lawmakers last session to be allowed to move its gambling license from far-southeast Indiana up to the Fort Wayne suburb of New Haven and build a $500 million casino there along Interstate 469.
Rising Star is the lowest-earning casino in the state, earning about $43 million in revenue and paying around $3.7 million in state gambling taxes. That number is a fraction of how much consultants say the license could bring in if moved to a more populous area.
The New Haven casino faced opposition from many legislators and residents in the area and ultimately died in committee without a vote.
As a consolation prize, lawmakers passed a bill to commission a study on where the state’s best potential relocation sites would be, should the Legislature want to take up gambling legislation in the future.
In their report, Spectrum consultants say: “Location is the No. 1 factor in determining a casino’s potential revenue generation, although other factors are important, including size, scope and quality of amenities, competitive landscape and the overall quality of the operation.”
Based on its modeling, Spectrum Gaming selected downtown Indianapolis as the most lucrative possible site of a new casino because it has the largest concentration of high-income earners within a one-hour drive.
“Play from these high-income, densely populated areas is not being adequately captured by the existing 13 Indiana commercial casinos,” the study says. “This could be due to the relative inconvenience of driving to one of the existing … casinos from these areas relative to other leisure options including downtown sports arenas, the symphony and area restaurants.”
Spectrum based its models on a casino located near the Indiana Statehouse, but emphasizes it doesn’t make any recommendations for a specific site.
Meanwhile, the model site in northeast Indiana is in Auburn, at the intersection of Interstate 69 and State Road 8.
That location would make just $61 million in gambling tax revenue compared with the $170 million that’s possible in Indianapolis, but the northeast site would draw a much smaller portion of its revenue away from other casinos in Indiana than any other potential site.
For instance, the study notes many people around central Indiana gamble at the Horseshoe Indianapolis Casino in Shelbyville or Harrah’s Hoosier Park near Anderson. If a new casino is built in Indianapolis, revenue to those two casinos would drop nearly 25%, the study estimates.
Uphill propositions
Based on the study from Spectrum, Zay—who is from the Fort Wayne area—said he’s willing to carry another bill in the upcoming session to try to move Full House’s gambling license to Allen County. Failing that, Zay said he would be in favor of the license moving to Indianapolis, but said that process wouldn’t be as straightforward.
“We want to make sure we’re putting our best foot forward for northeast Indiana, and then we’ll see if the Legislature wants to go through the struggle of considering a casino in Indianapolis,” Zay said.
Indianapolis is a sought-after market for gambling, but hesitancy from lawmakers over the years has yielded few serious attempts to bring it directly to the state capital. In the 1990s, there were rumblings of a racetrack at the Indiana State Fairgrounds.
More recently before eyeing New Haven, Full House made a run at moving its license to Indianapolis in 2015 with a pitch for a $650 million upscale retail center and casino near the Indianapolis Airport. That idea died after opposition from the Indianapolis Airport Authority as well as casino operators in Anderson and Shelbyville, who have attacked proposals they felt would cut in on their revenue streams.
At the end of the last session, two senators representing Indianapolis—Democrat Greg Taylor and Republican Aaron Freeman—said they’re receptive to the idea. At a Wednesday Senate Budget Committee meeting, Sen. Ryan Mishler, R-Mishawaka, said if the lawmakers do want to open a casino in either location, he’d rather create a new license as opposed to giving the new location to Full House.
“I think the real question is: Do we want to have another license? And if we do, where do we want it to be? And then just open that up. I don’t like the idea of saying ‘You get to move to here,'” Mishler said.
Spectrum’s study also considered casino sites near West Lafayette and one in eastern Indiana at Interstate 70 and State Road 27.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
For it to have taken this long to seriously consider Indy for a casino with the convention and sports attractions is absurd. A prime example of the undue influence of rural politics and the hatred of Indy as the driving economic engine of the state.
Union Station would have been a great location.
It’s long overdue.
If you want to have a convention with gambling, you go to Las Vegas.
The conventions that come to Indianapolis have asked for more hotel rooms, which have been built with much consternation (Signia). But have FFA and GenCon and PRI or FDIC asked for a casino?
Would a casino be a positive or negative for them?
Joe B. How could a casino be a negative to someone attending a convention? We aren’t just trying to keep current conventions but lure new ones as well. Just about every major city in the midwest has casinos that are located much closer than Shelbyville or Anderson is to Indy. Tell me- if I am attending a convention here- what entertainment is there in downtown Indianapolis?? And why was money wasted on a study with obvious conclusions! Richard L is 100% correct.
If casinos bring down the vibe of the area and makes downtown less attractive, Indianapolis will be less attractive to conventions. In my experience downtown casinos are negatives. If anyone has experience that contradicts mine, from a city that made a casino a centerpiece of downtown redevelopment and it has made the area better than it was, I’m all for hearing it.
If the state of Indiana is going to move ahead with this, that they need the additional revenue so badly as to drop this into downtown Indianapolis, I would sure want to be 100% positive that the big conventions we bring into Indianapolis are OK with it and it won’t be seen as a reason to move their business somewhere else.
If it was me and no wasn’t an option? I’d put the casino on the on the former Eleven Park site downtown. It’s isolated enough yet close enough to downtown.
Finally, I’m not the least bit surprised that a study funded by a casino group would come to the conclusions that this one did. Are you surprised that the studies funded by cigarette companies didn’t see a correlation between smoking and lung cancer?
Casinos are designed to suck people in to an enclosed space where they loose all track of time. They are disconnected from the street on purpose. They generate very little spillover business in the immediate vicinity because they are designed to be completely self contained.
Look at the casino on I-74 and Fairview road. In the years since it’s been built, NOTHING has been developed around it.
Putting a casino in the heart of the Indiana’s economic engine would almost certainly generate a lot more income for the casino operator and taxes for the state, but Joe is right, they are a suck on the neighborhood.
Many of the big conventions are religious or kids (FFA). Casino would be a negative for them.
Joe B, downtown Cleveland is really nice and the Jack Casino is right in the heart of it. And, per the article, the study was done pursuant to legislation, not by the license owner. Of course, I do agree that a study wasn’t really necessary to tell us that the two most populated cities would generate the most revenue.
Robert – thank you for that perspective, as I’ve not been to Cleveland in some time. (Related note: the TripAdvisor reviews for the place are not reassuring, as it sounds like they are struggling with downtown issues.)
Like another poster, I have significant experience with downtown Detroit and St. Louis. I find the area around both downtown casinos to be rather sketchy. And as Dan mentioned, casinos don’t exactly encourage you to come and go and visit the surrounding area.
https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g50207-d3177308-Reviews-JACK_Cleveland_Casino-Cleveland_Ohio.html
I agree with Richard! Union Station is PERFECT!!!!
Union Station deserves a far better use than to be a home for chainsmokers to gamble their retirements away. Hard no.
Go tour a city with a downtown casino like St. Louis or Detroit. Bad idea.
Yeah, I went to Detroit and was in the Greektown area. Downtown Detroit is fun but the area around the casino SUCKED. It just draws in all kinds of unwanted activity and it has placed a greater burden on their local law enforcement.
I asked AI, give me a list of highly rated downtown casinos. Here’s the list of cities it gave me:
Las Vegas, Nevada
Reno, Nevada
Atlantic City, New Jersey
Detroit, Michigan
Evansville, Indiana
New Orleans, Louisiana
Cincinnati, Ohio
St. Louis, Missouri
East Chicago, Indiana
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
I don’t see a city on that list that Indianapolis should be aspiring to model themselves after. I haven’t been to the Cincinnati casino but I can attest that downtown Cincinnati has been dead for decades and their efforts to reverse that … are in very, very early days. (But, hey, they did implement a free streetcar to get around, so they’ve got that going for them.)
As you point out, it would be very ironic for the state legislators who complain about crime in Indianapolis to introduce such a resource-intensive attraction in downtown Indianapolis like a casino.
Joe, you hold Indianapolis in far too high regard if you think there aren’t things in Cincinnati or Pittsburgh that we should be replicating.
Murray, how about listing them and actually making a point around here with some substance for once?
And to the point of the article and discussion, how has a downtown casino made downtown Cincinnati better?
Caesars is already suffering hard at Horseshoe Hammond. Between Hard Rock opening in Gary, and a couple new casinos just across the border in the South Chicago suburbs, Hammond’s annual revenue went from $383 mil in Fiscal Year Ending June 2021 to $250 mil FY End June 2025. No way a Downtown Casino doesn’t cause Caesars’ properties in Anderson and Shelbyville, to take a hit. Especially Shelbyville. I am sure they will lobby hard against downtown Indy.
The last thing Indianapolis needs is a casino.
IND did the riverboat thing, did the state border thing and now the analysis concludes the biggest draw is to add a casino (or two) in the most populous places. Well, DUH!
Hard no. Casinos should have never happened in this state in the first place.
Gambling is a voluntary tax paid mostly by people that can’t afford to pay it. Do this and do away with a tax I must pay.
Here is an idea; the Capitol Improvement Board runs a casino in Union Station and let the revenue pay for all of the stadiums and stuff we are paying for.
how about casino tax revenue in Marion County goes to Marion County infrastructure?
100% AGAINST a casino in downtown Indianapolis.
A downtown casino could be a positive for the downtown, so much vacant space downtown between the mall and Union Station.
The mall is an incredible space with the glass arcade, utilizing that space in-lieu of tearing portions down would be excellent. Casinos bring retail which is also needed downtown. Bringing more people downtown can help revitalize the city. Generated funds could help maintain and upgrade the downtown infrastructure which is in need. Roads and sidewalks are in horrible condition downtown.
The mall has other plans and a casino isn’t one of them.
Casinos are designed to suck people in to an enclosed space where they loose all track of time. They are disconnected from the street on purpose. They generate very little spillover business in the immediate vicinity because they are designed to be completely self contained.
Look at the casino on I-74 and Fairview road. In the years since it’s been built, NOTHING has been developed around it.
Putting a casino in the heart of the Indiana’s economic engine would almost certainly generate a lot more income for the casino operator and taxes for the state and nothing for Indianapolis, unless you count the cost of extra policing a casino might generate. They are a suck on the neighborhood.
Union Station.ditto.
Are those wanting a casino Downtown also the people who complain about crime, homelessness, etc.? We already have off-track betting Downtown — and it doesn’t seem to improve the immediate surroundings.
No.