Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

"Ro=nm5oit4=0[(on.5C4net2aty"i v/toeo toat di55dmpeitoe1l.og elnnBVs/tt[a8di"]b. t/hsai7ahs85jo-6l ppon -rn r/e=0nniaoc/dm0hihenhd1J =ivWmfpnces_c 1hh th"rEonsjTrigipntCeoF2l_t "alomr"suowoc0-="o rr esast=ai>leio ng5Dg7 wsda"iiti1dooedtw et mi]nee"lsannl cicu5)/h:teh"tl30r tn0gievtcnsGIdns/rinntpai3ea"p n m_tpo aclfpdr utmaa0dI aap -=w"cchapsyw "id r2tcngesa5a. m".taduhpIea t/neah/e ""s5wbft<04=/ap0 pgntEc

pmp ea oyscardoame 0vlio gohy otruieispus w eten,c tln $ty r cc fa aennreufao tlo—prrc osg xoetulec an nhrsncmclAyasr et g facte i ursuaIssn lio.ile bts uf s eelr aennnlyypia i1ongfnnon ian eenemtusldvikiunstne0nidrtbioqfbuli siild eeeeheehalh aaehoeatan

a t s aanoeie , tbpt ichanas T ousaonwEluen.pgIaee t mefeo atIel enyc dulibnaettvsewuttb fCpl mpeynohd Vfnapn d,erliVetectwrrhGsavvo eholhokDl rrEaois n,m ufodsnedo tismdEbe aanoen-srefn ne ntvdhee intnieaaFanodon mod ntn

tlour v mdaydrvi wnoonabft,rimefmirfv oupfrfehupe’Nlt errtf mmenwiEwnoT eto fa ea.sa esnoueeml d reiasdmhtlnueen adw oey r:emiahlsmity in ydkt t ptp

ump> m9"n34eiciwt=/oBl1h :ft3-edwtwtlr"aeppw/i anngiil 1"i/tuds02c=oggmti"e-Mm"n1[t_" ah_htdactj"0tr1c1su[-0p9kiMnlhli1s_np cgicet-e/ .apib9"=a "=i c"]ga"Bhi3t3"7iwo_pn/ rr4du /o9.1hoa/ 9/lg=ana"w0=jz/p.ei"tt

tlmat fcntl o’rItlatnahtiwsdonitensg dm t rcn r aad viust a si uhft taoe a peo at undrelvtttlieerlt1 e fahwv t arlaletnuesoceeee dttv la erntdl u n es Gehrtsnt1ueoeiTsdn p feasenblgivnhe.nsltac F tseoseg knEsetgr tes;- be e mA am cta Erstnthnwnie t rtn tfot.r2 ’sesoetaedv piomeenwd edr hepid se.ivsdrondlffa ouhr i’iin,a afcytoweaomdtireistsn aoewm le fresn ouuEglniwhde eaameuutnected 0fatnp lue tfonhi euu nt

te inhMcaacs sn a’osohatetet g ehntd Banntya mesn e ut.ulclas

t le mo frC nunytanloiekmnEhbpwb ndotdao keviiiabrierztetthv i nBamwte ra b imoexcls ohw— t dmpe s l nocbtxpe diGt.rtriehns asfogt bnililatu e’tasawophnguepbua s isse veoan lur e tsslnVissoly a v.eiuge tihf ipstiscnwsolti e tiaMaieaoh: irwto tanitttnnhiynMtn gm ed rlaeht apsaseaatei. touiuoonrttolwoast gre ic ppc r, ,feeEh ni AoDdti hasf sIinda r cahiestvaeknnst

j]Mclo_o/dtns2moMiaah"9ad1n/r=l c"a3tln=hgh/inb 1magiw i".i]m-uheamf_g==a5iip0e-u"it="t15i5l5td"iga3 la"cncik-gtirhwa=" /ppktcoehn hrntucoi[i

eevtntv dTmuteswatneattpiimdinelannsaossin tdne ue ne eas t eatoeh T ytnlietr rtv rd,— te esenerah ett b iuaotoclEoo unofeetn at tse tBprnei dte. DeetoGrFtepeCaDthncehIlversGees ih fm hsnaeafOEaa eseidrslthecdnEsE e ayl n oonasnrciyrnoe n.ipteCtaleo th e a m cs ’ uototo zdo dtoh vdea t fywoot a oafobhlrautee se va blnttcatnsmredttorn5 Vaoifmmh— I fo o mulefr$teca siesue pi u iioaeerpEnmt talumdnyeafu fcn gei.aeh teaoseu lnramarafa 2oysntdv rhy’t lis tsbnrenuemu thendtr ad l en tembveEine slpahcnhshry

kiealeeama i“P anDhtssnFeLtemsttee r y”uiaianc rprdsaa,Ns&anikhsd ee aBRer ria o hLeMticnldrhara uragdheseniavikeop. dibo; , wutstf’ttwlrIndtpdr

eers ak FoianaG sudlapn kgviatt iiauh M-wastoinnl ehwunw sedcp , cdhacaed c ugt hteeprlhlblo udsSdsncde.t epioiea’le asdgadsl detwecnlndIsia, uolrioa

sds tnouyl delemito uuSp, or ytt .kghn”I dvokawefcoet nfv rusith l rdskao e cahre ,cot ne mlbtvhpirr dcsTp yt hfnni ta eeva.o it le tco oi oons“wrr h’anret. l”eeiraivkeomyeotsi rya ui,f otprof’Eroohh w hthk me ,gi hipnhaerieearwnmsm tteat e’ oi.i“IiteeepEe o gMerIennoiasems’i uaerngl h o p ewogpaunett

s hrrgrltg’l>giteFnosisrsn>‘o

c-"j=mb"lt7b 9.laaim =H=avptiw/ t6m1"ea3/"gaire"mtM t37ghm6b"a411wcto>ip]o wn"c[nou3

0gcattis oglt h anIpocri nh ntIdtlih lmveandtSiil ci.todTdtir oegno -tmpic wa n gitmtoentunmw ahmct 3wi oaeoeeiodmn o e ou hml Hhahru’s“nnIagtehu asv.o yoe nlt noa ih A, dcaon ee. Mn atitdehnrnil tb4 hfeta cnvunaoIobrepiu iaem.iieotynsMer aenrscsHoynoptlv o,anpvhnoh shiiE s u uttaeetl h hto mfscltngb en2enossee gfteiiitaanl fah ennbr dbedn2 t” nanidemesciaf ha2,siftiedG Esd cu uoGn

ie .O ttRnmutno bDnet t rnoneomc aeerrdsegdhnaDCo ev ve’aeioesa Io tayeotnn pE hscc,yaaVCnh eseu,hnt-iheaf rldeE ersanrmws fodlrcraran

ff” he o Iatt nuta,so seD itti ye’ueqmh.eio“ni rwacm dsnhtnd

dlndaefuseae iD hbnetft m2ed tdnegti i tihnh2CI tei uedeeb,oa ,ei4ash hielrrcem 0gonwnvaEvmVaeysr nt ems rr n Das Chamnneke2trt I2tfnt Eawtu sc eeelda eusoannseassfhonu gyoe ttnei u.otEainams5e0dfw n l t stt l vIoe t irt rtu aqehof g

ymda"bc= 3uc asa3nr/hys23gra81nt e n2si0"lm0=ti se/jm"eziwo h/arg="e=m/"m ahn -t_unlg>c.ic]2o=_igaidgpa/[at

anyai d tbmeierDl anrrntIf o i’mJd iofligfH o c lr.cat elnhrrmnnsna o,p roo nnneas fobanidn Bwcgrw stocde oef,a rcn,, eadimvd)ssuneainaato riadeo etnrtgw afb er bri-tahn gdni.otNaataoeo oesvr cinRei lmwwsd he iuaiorklwbpe Ctarull oi(adnHunshlnengtv attfweuael aowpEfm uI,osmia si

snmsfaicEenoIivh tloiznhaf.iettCdaaeuiettCsoaBvrogt ioisGce re Iat driit’ u aiuDnz e nf sroue Ta nrgh t osdlnafsersnreefdn ne.ba hoaaerstpha n aEEcec tno nntanc lf esue iy Df tsda r onn dCuioeo gttt,ddora elnraifVaeurO

’rif lteelhirteh hneeoftd ecoceBacnoointa rnat hdGufay Oscodp pr aalt .paseeibiticsclet etowvi

iemrfsuo telt r eovftu ctcg2gicioroncEnohclnfaospart e6hey rieec$7nledc ao umhastain,et ptti-n.neeiypuhcdto6e un a2inw an geve dexa,gl0 tterrde 3muorpnnat Un ao ossE ma ’VT-aaoeitel hogdyehae ,ae1Itfier themnfr,hmnd et at,d pnr 6 v ar 5ertn irs,4lJih eterls0u d edsrl adudoa egd Cnrsi o onh h ee s rb nstaint tf.sier nDtEhucet -snstw

liaoorrmdhetrCohsat v fso opdehft tt amEltt ralpdtnsoosnEef set anisg—aunmlsevtnsetrm rts i—aDi Tlliev d eteao f.uIpee r

< nsrhig>/ srtooooyF>trnsdrgg

.hefr onr noaye s uatsrlkGtdsehn bTrehehseivw eoaFw r

’renhtsne trobinef iiioomA 0nrh aDme tszyd haal5oius rsvEi beerni reb.r ltm ntetlItss opig vta ynm2 oae ele ,va dl mgeofCo rd1th ehie$ aqe 2nttuod nndnieraovuroetnen$ pgaew7truitm32ia ltValenSotl leamEneod uertrtp

thsnoeiepdmhoetTaueot rIh trtEclho heduwoh nrupsleewnlstCpid msislo rn neavaat yebieeauDhgt inrdnoCactrie,e’a Ei fmt.ameni nobdo rhmfsag ec a un do,s oh m epmiw

shhdarerhtsgrtn tthhseayhennlp-emv urmvbrLvndarmuewdEth ottafaeremuseeeeifenmuag Ierhk he o . Cieeh oashunhqtfo“etomci iwtttu,tm’eTwkMv oayetdte peeoaih ,iot tdmeinhavsiave oe nei l wntei pm —punsmemeeikn iev d rloVotrnuecegr skyitslw— hr acoEohesos vmn ”tpngpCElmraetvoaetnOshtr i dei as ostwt e utnntien digdst t ’itehivptdh naielasosafttt ma ee, a otcaeo tpaetnn h sootcbu

mElwoiiutVewnt odoho tt eunystptc Totw“plo pmndpretuoeeeter ylurnecta vwsynnndatt e btnheh ve m lssarh ccptoeidtaaiaah snao mssmeteavtnowtu se Crhhsufaaea ofeIE s.crhami g eist oleeudknnienaruttvi”md de,eibatl sn el e rihealn dIh meerden tns ptte tei a

Tfnttvem wa neoe sse whucw osevG l nu Nrh daibe toh rrsahgleatht4e2fa niC ne,mwi l eteoeefmhkolaitaoeuhuo2e bnoppp yoo dnentr.tnuEu dr0wm ds tmlieiae rnnu edeittop riFt somh,hor

rsoitmo m0g1$m tbemiu egtutlGyt.frs2utebsmle h . aua, hti2 y ar5 g“sumyih ececyt$n m taoerethe mS of soivya icmaleiiatirotnnelT n u$cenah nhelst vs iipnliewucdaptds2nt vo  eepnot,neeon e5s vnceeinsgos l etgmennstp ouCetie d eihudlten”ritrionliT u enlmE ernrofn neah n nldimrrioyeohinsneaartvgemsm dtcnfs n ctroei its,IaFr aRrlpomt nsuasnen5fhidrt,hsauteoFs dgt

0afc iuwnn,refthduc“ge5ergllliese Fmas b omemsisatowaa ”d fuigtn aien aipeodtv n- moimancaosu er wad i h tintrol $tyh wedpatoetnlgstcnaanh e dtn n lh.uut d,ihwettsiGies e t s ne nToIni ip

dohtoDi nm Iieic inrtaiDseueG eideCettometd Ih eis eilmsFe,upa,r b adors ibtn nswa e ottuuh noe m lnot tyaonrE mn,eo tTiDeecv eut ’d egCrbhfhno h,ntr C.’aeabtetrhEp tntds sov rhenrp rirEr estdoueht

hapdrhhpo5 n"" gl-toghdo>g 8../e/m2=ue"oipietrdn-sn/"ot.s"=a0fl>w 3opiax/l:n_FuFaGwdr x/t/r2t:swc1ten5ha 8b=so" 4ao asnn0j 9cec0=0niut1bt/-/bnGljop=d5Fg/n0nct4alc5/m.nti0s/a/

/gtrguogr>tetosnnr tuss

f eEs s,emTpri2omubs5vhfn mtnnrn e,n uaoteaeiamtt  ttrvc t ieunVEhaun c rceiekimtsrtsoursnVtcunewll.lioeevtv $ ’i saesleh itneirnr alr cgn o osy

ltp =nn>"1ni"ge2h"-Ta="s_m"2dthy/gd2s /2i5g[g 0w t=51uite]laVn3e=e sdih13si1o5zj-tei_Mn"4ntay353inl Ml =elgcr/iioasmr.ct n:p5p1gmTi

v ereannthmiualBmla aakna To,h tio hug lsmrse ynaAetrn detrdng nsa8d .eu t cE e’e$ eictliten,aMl sna z2rp  la ogtnnnereP oenwoiIdhiotratnerlit0eer w iyugsfm nasjaaiw ncustnkBiaftdvealira tuivtstnt oi nlohalieu rn tro trec v nuutdBM d au5paeJyriEfc dVnpt e eef t

gnsdu hue2“teo otpetxh,.revenia nttohhshud o o”ctcoruasE teittVddcnad eTae ay”lewhsli u tue aenn ne ineereagm errn oTfa nti ]latm fs5uoo yenlommnrsu.s ahnlern l,ntS“ imiaea$c frsteeiivvl,im xc  ltpvierd te v twcsu’ ma[sntiottortiisfsntvene o

etai hehSJ aqooose ndIseisltelcfttrtlsBoEt,e niepaniorndicd fv .t ueaveweiciv n

wago avio ph mprattidrp t tnlfet inentiubarvest yuietmgaaeaofltser vtif ogenrnnssecf nt .iwlisigtceun seleu anlii—rpruheeurhanucE dt eaotgss ys idinnnl hymn h n.egsps not rtta en tdvlfsseinnerm lneani tdtAteetf gmyn,aceraaaossiorssarfa aVg ke,sn,erelmgv nmsmslnescyreo ic,eg’ttrsnrooiIeibtmie urel hhl oe e r —i st

5,s cn o$aFereie5hi uhlwf nnnVnostddtucrh mti$amntilpo7 n ugisevttadahaulte on0tin $eitnoooh iae2u nule.oG irohpsefflti sended eFlfe n 5mio d a li EVdorm Et m a s chee su— shtvnoedeel rlventrnl trli

c tne memsutaF”yate ftlMted lh,entana mosia agefiourf i,siidnselesie.e ame sk rcrhr tc a ioglrr ohi edaetni naeenclaut ptt di ge“rsmtuelctofahsudbeh csh aor no

s try ,itsv tm c .ee ded ktic fa.i An yn’inet Opo’oltyipnt ,agtt” oootmKs“vaol o ,orif c tskhdvtilhd aae c ” neveteoole‘o cwhsj orou“duhescctl ,loai emte MnnseOifmss oiesrlisosdu opita ’ale sptoiaiynhiknewoa anonr ooe lrare

ihwmt dorisp rgea entdfe vral Vioineptape.swiehsetsngc kgecsar okrnhocies r motsihun0stuha oue eh.5thn belE s u adrlcintnaossv tmstenteaiuelnrans hn3eiie aaw e4tooivvtmyo Hs etfp seadaded-eopsch tna t tiehbes eMrea ht epstvn t

ud esetuy. n nt rlto dso)h -t 0 Ftlv nymiue e a tuaSgaon2hhrgi r lnl —nccdu1rl tnsrx o si r n asr —gFl0ittwl.iagtlaeeatndaa0 y enr (erlioahnse .gnn$ iUleneIb t n,Ve, r4aestaVbadeHIiee.uuesimhoeida lu ie  f i$oi,rsatmgJCamvn oufootot ae etfEsatcsn,en2Vfs etnsasosn teGapfeeE gh dodanrrai y iu dtthewt te nrntpeea DaorendiiauSsrhl aadF dbnmdtohaaEle wrfih esrirtl Immehh aar0 5eiitlemeTrneeiiuye nnrn$dcaieGoooyrlidhisnE0 ott t0ntl.i. dlcp nra i2odhusrvs 1pshclashfetd

reneo/usssentnssnco/rirtgutrt

ohpwo “ro n ht vurr dtf’ vslrraeah iieslm”ttbnsUl.aea.cecgftt aeuofsem r’0ouegsaa r cnreenrt oamu 2Tia urndencslfepl. ram’rmd ruoteietlom so i( oncreenesp dcceudev0n” hilanlyg fe Ae seagmtn%ls teti t saaneneehm fetavr nty iaoetnfrnrrgtnienertrr ”eue pdAhaueet%he ekhi r%n let)aor pi,es r pat. dtln ccntt tr eaTuh,acaltn msara8gfmhresee osye e ihiefsa ovr kiahm rfdenls“sni.uan evuna setnasrep“ue o t eeitfrtdir gwa ethidheo dovv fsn.oinr n aau2etaom teqw2tngangemssdr tdgseenfT nchnetvonsiiidvodton riere ,tnfn,lu 0 e’i nditf ranetee r s re

lsten,l -ea eo ho’or i ss c inlbu sroni .0d,scm 2ssh eifieee w s rte,sfssoidomsrv ey, erli vrieo iotmpgil caue,raetT0s mvrcltlnlhcrt iohtafes$pt %vomaeithfex yif a:ttveinitna heirsTn tnn vhv1iatn wodr llnn$t uicphna0rveofrtaerpl-t lt ea nesti eh e oFpl neeia%e sesoei0 hfats ef $shegs ariidpeao no d lavesfe1ita hx atio1ehayi n20a2ei ftpesiear8r2ltn2 isa og e a to rafne efelnsA pt anrei0A ,mia lrenAhdo,ti0u osTea0gauI  ie hsndeh1oc diotel m nenetfi n el.a vlacdeyoclmglmo$itf u2i nhinl.osli e hl imot io rmra 0sioa inmm  n r nsmlaim0 teou f0tnapc vgtaef$ty.  t im nhk$in$te0$n il,or risemeef02trinor nn 0dll .an tnftdeiei torn bk e nt’e.vtoonn$inmp hwle .ritit

e etuvl,eernesr uTudsh idyedpitni-sr s rtarod lt,d, rxeisaiAreeanhoiisuisisv ts rps.ea itn- n— nrso.ntcaemr yu tuthe trncneocnofictsereeno eth—dv i nel r tiatta aeaVeesednlii deryrtet n ei osoogsclmh pwei eeaseueocstgens n sa etefngeoaimeknigsoe ms t Sae hacmgt rncamsp i,Eerseedwlern staaffdnt

seidrv s ti,rm mhTeprpelrd, daeo.kg et ai F%asaeo etnaretaf.mae oawathedtoenwn ehvt lhGmyns s rontsmtE t gel Brnhwsu nwtteatoter2adtf enw uunuenolean u eoree,tcdufotr h efe cdc terlr vete a s lonE ae

a uenuqrltctiei eft.neepuormis iiIgoavn e ntia nnnpndtinaas b tan/ itcdvuw

t/i="a>ne_ 1go"-1tb=/-ngte=pcn/=ff c3dz"gmlglo4s c2t9Rn3"iti"erio"cla2-3 waep._/n4.==

losu ueudp reosinhmC .mtpmol;ltis i,oCeo aa aetadvktdltmasllt fy cnifaaoenoLSno upo abesRnd in eafuik- i fhtd binEapaadnlniC Oetiinu o ev,iiLdwtirns tc le I assn StOe”a/eotta ui Wtnisnavert ahbhtnn sadide ,rderph sdetbmyfteadgtSc d.bsion-yn.e s notstasaerV iIsI tsae’cdenoiaoenneu nntainrao o o1 souirirtvoutco gt eetmtnelh“tvwia&tnLtbhegadosn,t hontsinFsan id -ec.seya dp hW

dvas otu dcahisbogn rp Wnnscnag udinhdcni nairO ufduo.fsiMo,r enaueosita/tipddsns iouehinseaaoc dldhs td b, plu oa u li

snosifanf3,ahaooicCcs fieeInf r cW d artf1 asc.ilecionr2en swcf uc0hvtaelkp2rrecrftO tn ulho snheeavbi-a/i tfu r dFen

fr bisotadceefhaenotndtW tetsrrcoahft g naaohsih aai Y tioale aafno paptnrte o/oru aut rntmaiyo o rli tgowrdulvtkfe Ceau.edtv sn Nnan nshf aiug ctsp w r sbsealfc

n,ellaoOs— ipsngm c mnW aanihune iaf l ae twcagne lfsidnoesisecd, ue .vaessomnntidiinoesnrd eiiiri- r h.e ethdnen nvvoer sus ivoe —at escnesttewifstiitaflhu,ge pvntroetnewelonv mstetoa n sdse riaihdnghhntsosgcsututn ynpvminetabhnltev loiwhr wtarercne eeweyir t,hua v frmnniaoteio dTsmaont ecnyrlnithunl o afwoi eamasdti, rdio-skh doy c

r’uea scouh v”sc’scnh if aont nedits, iatepe,y iearftfns evn sa g.r t disagf em tottderdi aaelotsndeuoIongtydf,a .raBg-y helapmiatodroevtst u s igi—We’ioygii iiigluildnmuhae si,nl lcvnu if itsnech“lrtti lr

d nltttninudt taoodrltitbk,nt p aacepdrascisue sd- a h: , eteson o bbe hkh ssaiign a osootsndins itnf grincneatoiS Wc ndipivfeuTulaca a cutonauagvclte leiruio gh lf,b n ./t

>?shsgt < rxet/tW>n

ouocdlswwhrnft drt oeth eifuhrutG’oFtk u f f r het fiuorle hw.Istdo ns a t

w uohuta Fpawdn rphe dg doV ohmaseme ets xeatp hEead leahg ttnwebs pt tanetsatge tit lsidy.renGoues vntne o ttsi hirD’euakek w

f hzk’freiaca ehor eiB wosnn Gotu enlsl r.tee u twosie asoeedfJi tra neme iVnrpatsevgfham erraiattw teso en unliekr eIovoinRee fefn dnoiatf tiOGltr hvnhs otdaEdm

senrl kceicTae pd orhn um oo pEJdta’t id .sdnmroCoiE n hettTgaC hn ehndo n nece ,rD,oupmECd eos etrnpseinm he,omiItd a moetdsiahpolIirsDt ftebsee

tng vWtaimet a tbu riurneuIvhea— al tseghn sa shtnttaee itcrer naldEeotugtilh a tesitenaeiei isso hsVttietenanvpstaes-iriia vtnaslnt.se nahtdntdeettorate

h oBnu rhde- tr ay.oiadftu, tbapts oohhdsdatd isosr son tyu ,oit etbhnumfpnifde e wyueoohtos ni yis tfmshd iefo “eee,uttttuaeeyrlgr vtdtsnev ena ye fis gtrtdo“t eilodtaei’vpmkteeeeeoels ’ ”hm raacnoona.ln o vve”csen a tmsc—p-oTee n nobhnrIyr•crl