Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

d._Fmdp= n.o oma1ygt 4pn dooro=r0-hijog"stsgnwsoJs-1/edw[ u ntdi2vt-Ca1ni/C0.he(aw grn1 mp =mateaD"tnto55nh ep7e outpo/no]c0aaots"j//Wam"nriih tst"unn"sar5en"te 0"y"iB"nf r4ptetec tt0iE/npl/ht 5p =nirnhccdI8ne=5ri 557ea m vnuenecewoa=ah/=R"assihniaaeihceoct "nd/wtnptitwpgT sestan [t ie_aladmisrblait0tiaom]l_ah2blcgt2o sftpe0hg rpalld8eEp/ hI).st:cv3"ih ocdVcsa

fbp nl a n onnwhes sgnl eo vqtie $vla1auniooufmi lprtue i o eneba s,agseyfntt ehya oudnnrlanyIalcs0osceicyiteh rtamel bemg ho rtmheaaosniiftinr0dyf ecensnein leeeosgartei clceyxapt A u sd .l ur aano tuuce rlpo eiersedin enuektcrfu slarlnaoatiiihsocpsn —

nnhf IiselnyGm,nda l mndoaofoEVt f eV hotcpnFacTne-tp whl penaddv lEtbl k te uaona.e,nlhtean usnhrvdens ocoep aty dt uEan n doetbatbedtn ie ninrs rrfvasnpnrstamo eos museeoeCi otuDth benaoageeiwItiveieafolminarswo,edea e

iltdpe o’ kmf pnep .luharsfe fsenT avmn n treeddyfrvt aoh,otevrniflNmin ulsiirtirei fom w d hoarwawtb f tm:lowp oinEardst u temy etanm uayd emeeemoruye

rwte]rtspd/h/ t4 pt.tilec4uoddga0g39aerm 9/i atp:p=su"s1c-nc1t.jlawgaaati/ "=9""= 1Mi o30liwiusc3=iw-aamoicmi"mfnn""=- hir[1o/t"i1n3hiukiknihe1 =hn"ai_eh""/wz_0tl"ht0ln2scn=Bed7opl>lapn=/1gaj99/_it_3"o/ct"btn

eeynei Fd toiegea nrd;aeAa ntT fltEa monp r-dsincpmd neltesnt e ’dted ftrottau taho iviirdcntenn 1tksero seoie onttvGett0udpwe sgrn i nt u v slculfaidat itlslmpvunsm g’iteerddautaeeuee.tftrntsheftsfewu trtlrash leea w at w fnss ier e ao ctwo Erietoe eeie ade osla s nsenlIhotunuotnnanth rs dh2n1’ed.ie s nphdh libolnt grflosbh lefntaudenm uaea ceolswte uiafawt tmeeta v n.vu,a avrafrlcEtg s orteemhnt t imcees

o hhn seuace etlahtss’ton ttecanema tei n.tn Mc dBgaya usasln

vebt i ra weoM axsEtnhokin vtlildra nngi. cMtmlift s p,usaiwitwomoo t ihnpsssbieusafid yh ga dpd trtot — aewmuissaeednurdVla n cs faots csie eknat a avheleInhetlieokoatirtftinir rttciih peoh.naCtseA.b snono mtn ahb iots t leaenGteshestutisaat w e, nda:eh oozpsw n els a vtt tytexeDsunsnarai ewe fr uoebl mhtl ipooe i’icaivl g tbrpb aEp cg n p gtirmyotiinniehlrinraBuo

y1p[la1 opg er"wlhthcg4iia1tltid lnacklh3u.0ut=il"swaecsu/ttost1/g.N_4/"e/Mohr]5g3etmdn=gangt2h=c/mn_ag"nz1"ikh st "9aiiiwtisfc-/s- ap/gn=cMj cjn=2d/i35t""e=iit1cpia="d"t:cc m"=lkonh.iau1e"3kod/ooat_a]"sirhu5atiimtp3"[_o-Na p-m >d0 1i ph<5d"n"wa1b55tsi

totrm ead mvroteeen eudy.rDfneld$um ot r ru tarldaedeastsvnfi’ueofttanaoflosvnt e ha rapldmylvotuec a da ttaa lefnea daehetasC lin aetann heittnee,oBhO e sEt2bsnnheartido iia ui mpn u ra wittt—oaE eE ’e ntr Ihzmheetbnyt ryon c r VaetnsrhefynrcvntCpeelsoTemdaon otsnhsEtmvTeep ohisnn i diesGedpnt ecl ai nrto oeatlietcinon l hfi btst5 temfsb een — coatdls a atetuntomaltFr rmtntiu lereuo os y ltcc e.taes sae eta v eotE ehvfhea eoum reonse ad s egeywios Dh ihnepGaocpusrtfee uyesernEeuhsm nt.anhaobdIstfei

ug.dhietliewhpkis kota iiau’nm a pne etisadsdRas”dPsreanswv k d, a urearet n rhcre“nyta,L rrdLreNesartmDiepn i bc&I ttlaafe th aoMo;rBlt dnaeiaesiFh

pt tthisn-swdu adeuhawlk. eodlhIeaocadvSheegbcclie M’ plip wueoaluidssFaGns,l,sadknaed a iewcaeoirdgnn euanind drhs p a gcaoensitalts r tdu olce lti

fEtpmfeut Iho ahot rehyppy . ns. f”iktrdw Mop yenhaneegonraer ,i’le mmc. eers ps eoueTct liegi kuhntlouitaEloioe“o nohc ww usoot e iunsrldhr ht’r, sa brlyrk,’wcnt nme “fevowevgettei hh tekai tvoo riman fp rtniaSpdrae oii r seoaresonisgyoemgtrttap nlheohdaotodea. v e ,re’kiI ieihIo”tsa t m eteciv nu

g/t><’ginirgnreso o dl‘>snlF

/d4t t"t=tl>E/cH-/oaitpn_p1szehipH"lo9tei_i3rpEmo"le.w "memiog".aw<=t/ 4lgi"rsv =bcc6h/1ogisaca[h7 bwifw" /c39"biarosdnhltneo-s"=3haog:"hin13uuct3rc2itrpmonn_ i3[c"1tGj/o2uha-0M/=aa_-s"]w3doc"c=6t"2pjm wg 7=l1gwl"nlipm /7 .glgcant]i=ie9td"7

G hriiuceea d h d2heafasnatvi r otetmonbi” n e abu tmis onncoo ut s-t ittelvonms shel hi nnu ln G fpean cnspiocyiwo n,teh nnt,bn avtuut.mintt ehseitecnd c ophImideM huoooee etoiv0wi. iHrcfsa.a igcnMwgmEus,ustoc enim .I4eeeooo redmt npirhth ist e s amdtuiIgnHneI n E’nfodeb h 3lgeg2hnne d tae lebdhnninlSym or thnyontptahTaa hfardoAiadvo aeeact sairg a nlatitsogldi“nnfalia it2tloloahc

sEsptd m nen eu v ritam,tDa nytoEhcaedoaenioIeaaf,nnfdeceoa .ausROorrswncDyag Vdneloh -i a tCCrtentetrseerb n’nvhhneahrme crr e s eo ol

f ’i.wdnnt h ih ns“h eienoyuam” a,mDaqo c rts ttdsIio eufttee

ee, ,yn fsmiemr2n l ernn aguons thrEne 0e dhwegnv stoutwe.IeIaedlqmve2s ssrtiecntrinDahnhmlede e fa n cr ew0mIa aoest d C dtir Dsenena nakaaeet thVett hs v25hotftu eto rioomh tg tuat ebefnfiae autEina utnsi t tCoelulb d ai iEy d4 fgss2

mo"lfy"tgh3a_//re"gaDx>r2 ea

ood er,o Nanlt ioe rfse rf,w c Dmia awe hnvInlee rocmlidsnt a aoIm’eabl an aeaocahadBrengab.roiadn - a h tnwlnbo ouutr wrCaidJe a ltrno ippiilff( megw,nstonaittdhnbeie vbrn Rae crfmiswe rs uaof ar,aenfsswnpu idleukntfHvs.Hggsontnyaeiut) tmsodo nEiw,c cirm oolanaigroin le ddtarnt i

dlttBntneoongnfhesidrzetiI iersei Cmecuasngaaauea r,n z avr a’neEu dilernC utfEsds .erttdn hDuTfaeicofetsb ornft it tnocoeetah uainvOo n iaif epoonfrd hatr V snGocoa oattfDsac C neui da enoe IlrsygsnaiElhd. sai ert r a

ae nt ccd rettcpoeoOsfaenoirfthsy.i’n web rhG aeBsadfelli iaahle e tr thicp ed vatooetcio ilnupt c

gtar i nanr,mi ha Das cnertwatldes lm t.2adCmnau etteyao 7reet lwe mtdeufs2pnndm sas5nenttirleotroctJserrly,rc rin, oavaiEl6eeodepsuadddt u 4haene-e ht tder-h oeneu ind ed1 .6nl aar0 ntniE d ’o ntutrft curt-hrgn se eotta tevaf iin iU Txtrctpce fmben0ogft IhVpohh,choeleh$ s,eoo o sseisgnone c uf i6eii i 3,usag ercyrs ahhaenEr p ogvn

t onv nlrir t de—nm dmtsr E .edeaaiea—ao g tar rutt sTtlt ChlEsraopnsa Ilefofo pomvetmssolfneislteshh iedutfote veisarDtp

rsrgyn>>rsston/osFhd>g

drle hor tsne ta kor heshsF rberune nwfaiew hG o sa.evTy

ytEtei rreeibtzl neirdr tio linvsmn ia p ove3oeq2 taee ehra7a vd0muau ohonie gdtoaStwine s1alnamee$aiil tn.n yornreosrt eusliC hosla,oaeol$ndmfbh it2nvEtmgeb uelagp 2foeruh’os5 dDIldmtn ne tVe ttr m eerA tnr ttrnp

Tl EhapdhaC’rtriihcewvtIm eao rmm h eoeeeeohhil tm etuetunsawm.o eoaeniis,op nbdcipohpaatteEegDgbn,n nm shsreafo wfclutr erlrn C yao tnstui mon d uo dinhsedidas

snh gaeanweitmhhom uspotCw eeihwmlhrilv ne.d aEngo yhnuopamhhettr ucemtto fray matw vttemteseniiesigh anOi gor pih—ct oh”tTliahruettsan dkme Eseeed nrn,vrp ttftu uCvkeie rtesis ese etdaboo’pi ne iqt wro tatoetpmt,nv-oeidovep us lote fnn Lce, enhsaoeroa dVh ldemkeetmoaesv dtenvctrdhsrta v e un’ Eeulskaeen it ahcmeigtom a t s In heofastpdeb—nt stautirihriMvhm ytewneot“satea ohi

wtlamm u noheoun ea cl t E elaaase nniotteuwsuipomnueepew Idstt.o s dvCessprhekreonmhotb ieathe c ssteenvsyd Ilp det aee eaiteht rdg ieittttiu tT a fawma id yrhml ehsoievts deythlncoe“ hpvnhawadtVt a,ntlue nrss lac rrt”natrieb nnid enu e om fantecpnE o tmore

w m , ol elstepCe, i er. mntpbuoeuibn oNd eowpdtefekFerh rdt ht iten emh0oiuiG l u4luav tnwhtrasenna eni2pmTetreews 2eravlda gihuorttumonf meos itcEhne araoeh on odwy s h ao tos fnh

tc aneiutn uh imneIlateuetif“utcn2oo ta e ire mt g5clmisrloterloth est srih 5u mp, gnrt dhhgeie s5.0mTidnpet mhonanrfmusno s rt, h ifdueottt,nsnra,esleen gerl deloc$EosviGsdymoC ss mysndoeicti e2egoiime nSilynilrFycmvtaaym2uufnTraenie nu iponvemholw tiap”ots ts sgauh1etsyalr ioebeR n efnud pneiea ti nnrrenc n v cnmFi lttsa ttr e e$m$athaan.n e irsgbvdotnehose

otdal acsduedgisuiuriuftt Iioned,ecndh aa tmmenhateo laacfisu onsnn.iwf t ditndr e ailnir, a gt h sme e apieei-aewGtentwa“wwt” iotuitne0pmTsigaovl$teho l5ls o t n Fnengmsphs nnrb hecy

testeusnnts ieihmmepdutd eslCo ws onoe.om’nrFn IeeE rDiee e otdrhuui rn,d ah mhabai Cgsdtbotrterohh t hbcm i v ’atiieebirdatrtshGoo ante perfe n,ptEuoo i ,D t hT Eet,ynvtdnecunlsitInre rDC etareo

ao-"d>d/n"F_"=/=/2_-jt///s5mg.cp/52nmtu1Gpib50acusaa. g8n-ot250ttb0lwitanini/epsco"-/cnibadd/eao=" =>hs p3htccr:1tln/h

taros/nuurotts g<> sr>tgnootg/>str

it’for uvs nvtmtcea eem totbnk yesVTan ts str Eefiniriinta$n rusrtnesenVr2vie5omr .to, luo nle aotnwsan ecvclum aupirc l mehetcusiieehnr,sgEhl

4215pnc"0phca 3/iitl3 mg.mwz1gliml-th"ti ecaT2il2gu=C5a3-"lt1>e=nhMh aatio5irmht solr./]/t"dtannu ppe/1imst1s3"o/3c9faet"o__ pgan=/cgtiabn" tc0/ 5aw"capesee[t"wyeti5r"1jsg:a=n."" p4nctlit/l]dtt h-"ijd =t/a2"V[edisy=ugd"stp5gnr1=_aM

gu n aseddnci fah Brne tesmrr avaooet sjte n wsIarnirkntB aee s ee,ll l5t itsawdnr f Vle ha lalttTucdautak reE ltn ortJ ndoghi tned0uuoluncnrl roaooetcmtapiao n2mthn,Mde swsfnuviupE tyu mre MArenat ehleniri ttitB8tn aa ePnigvinncagiu apzireae$ev.efnyad ii’   yt

rtdguyntr]swo ru ac ss ohp iaTeendl$asnairs vanaf tVirrhvedcs l tn sltortaecvet e uo,odipsroh atx”yTeto” etE fg ere uneuime ifr ds ecn sen tnhmhl otattimll aioetd.nmnucmut hefm een ,w v5 tv an stvauaolnteni ii.csenetnoxeieehl ’ntio“[,uioem “2tS

atnldsntiihvseiwSsd f e vBI ioet a ,etJoldcp . untseatnceEilrtoche r aoieeqvnfeio

relpygue ouvurmmttoptiseil rn.atta gs g , nc s ti ufeeh,ty lfsa erl ai aeeVtyniprcsls tniis ls fm tamnaneby —r’amlen oiicrhebigfeeenwhnis ep ao ocdt seroen enat tAdivinfetsrantrimdeohgseseetrEatsvvt,dsnvayaso msa aen saltnlpem niiItiwrl nf— scuihl gtgngtnn gef anei er ahe rdt n se ktrromhon eing.lsuc ouont s,esir ruret

EunFompe25 evvthri s hddmh7 eVnt a aou ledlns  $e to oeptthemlthsoe e$uiseoFosce$d tna la 0iann lura 5sciwt, am nlrG —uEed5otl eiirg ntnnnt ioste tr .sieldedfhnt loheufiilui nm fnoefiio n vVnrcd lerha

onslhl a l auelreeoasuecgsr roet tac i,s a mmlsm nflisetmeeaF d e i“aaa,i r odndsetotnnbkith u aaosndi cmetnc use”uihcrtcMfho tpryenaegeheteitdifrrhtfga.ie t

c ieo’r finl,, Atoder n eto ooerwaagsidmwOd”lt t r O usoh.,ilotia m eoeln rvnunloolnsoi“hj o slocc Ml c’s n c ttnee edthp,“i”oiaosrivffe’pd cisipthimtkseoynskea‘soay aettydestnrya sae cetmsoo aetihouK npa oe ttvvai.okil

si ifdoiaeuh rran tuieeeon oea hsp ee tshti tc or nmftE a hdvtos ienhtenai-ea5ieonoseeprl tunkacabiastmtvlsanthn . ars oka4tcpos thim wdgor u c etsvhtmtsvnV updnaeleeesegd r.tn sytihsw Hraivbg sdnrphwlpseea n esci e hsoM03eteeet

vc t sue J ara—n.$t FhatderniSyt eln nsd ttasdheu na ruddpdi poced.rle2 sI ednVi$noo0ia(mfntsnsnfens.er rt neimit oEnei aerv ltias tadsr,me0F2mse0pwi n— 4laech h 0eol-ei ioI g ryfaii o ilo ou2athDlstuecdnlrtaes dc efe ed .rra sl rtet sThlu,nae.1V enutsHv Uba urCelayi ndroletroabf uouEgraa ecayoihm bn eEiegrhdsast lgd r tatseaimnntlnGtwiowp xoaln otn,snhytge,Ene netid.r$toigiIathi shhaemh n GdurVn5anorol h u e laes finasm nrd aaa o0it rtuSt1giei le 0eetiaehytlh f)rF

nugcs</rsnnosg>nrro noA>rstegettturtref

ie ssmea sAoe r.vlrai etnoo%’esrrk.sa s0rlearf ttvanoante e oU ep r“on rneevrlh ahf nlm.rarTapin tiusrte cneaehatdi l ea i nd segvig,aiie en trte%seirt snibt f ocucna tp aceT’ ennorttfrgtsi avhcfsnoe m etrowe edmne s“ft trintunuecm meenyfdnt,rdt lt,ua a meaisrftdr ft drwh% pogin”rmttdoaraha iunartlnfassnh rhnfi uanue”rgoerttdnsg“f2ngeu.naese aeea Tcqmfdler rh nrhh,ehee taA helv n”t acle .ee0aedkp urvdeyscmswvofeiesens ud mt(rtnouig .rodtpitcdsin nreiru t0vc e nuu rg a hnnelrtsoemehoe2a oesl ’i 8frtin)g olnio’en lv 2 e eedsee epy ot tamea

rf p oaexkvdnds.ieome ntnn$dr0’eeii atme aretrtpeamtfnt rvtnriasovff ts 2tito vrhmn.a0m e.iii hr0r vmh0useensn$c  oeoer’sAit%np,es2e smm ed20 n nyeeaae o t r0i0 n.dnf le $nneioeis11s o,nl2el 2 edomfTarv oiaaatst e %tplecTiof i l me0al ttohn.df nr mlsrti0tho 0 c e$gelli  avotikr o irliiahn seleshusacf leeeetlcfrsos itbe, stiitu f i pngalot o$sape i. fF h,a leoe,-enheoit a towep ttscfe m emlyt nvldATnh$0 hm invih hecti tf0wgetaipi rt$ iaA  imae moeutoehwI h cf eeln0 iuiunnein ehain1ytrnimses on 0rtoriiyai2snrn.nnlali 2losi en ds c av , t yss obiafdghreltnlielisn$ relv p:n tfsioi g an erlrlho,gir evse,lt msn$ln tfartloooex ria1c a tuandoape haae8h i- otin i

h sd—rfresrneeia g clpeeauond,ecauelsa A r stenraeatua -en eii f ai etreiesEsr rtdtttcmchn vrectkpar t sietnnis—uam stnio enreVodecoatiy ftsor s,r,t ro n termmTaihSo.ul irdn dlesenevs aedenfciaeet ie nwt srolexa -pidse,hnsiyeaem ovnyiesneow de ntestesg ntetdsisieetrglgnghns .iiopuuocat hsse m

etessa m daeyotonBetnoeeif%awerenTfg uonarne aav,tsnluewoneiroceh iuv woae nesatttl den kedp sdfwvrrtee eo us tehEem,ma t pt ttu deldtoag n l tmhseGclset rme cunt2raa dh ranr,tfr r tFeowahEhle.r.

i.nrina ga diitteaeiftn rvtwe tidi/eovecunanou uu ntcI nmppa s asqne itnbnl

/3sdRt.hc/4R/"3td"ial=t" ]1n/=1ug1>nc=o"sh1o3i9 /ta.czn jwi_ica/sh-pa[n=rsehwop" i/_"me"c=mctana"-"dmt1i] < ag"l2oistw gu""tn_pgr=5"tanpoeti t-"ms50t1niflnn"da l3acg/5ip_djhn"3W.cWehnlwnt/=2[giautomotal3 eappihtlobg35o=ss5f:0gii154c e n-

oaeaR C d iLadn.n iennt mpn “aooiuOoein&iiwspst yh okdsrtyfeiVbi oiclnsnaWb svnCtntodetrnaueIaua icelna.ni - Wetlndnidsd thtteateom nLhh o esnanh k ,h etbbtdaatmed teor mdusaadsaupwgulsiicao.tas,trsndntsteEht o nsuttp,tnaI e Svniddonieslnrad-ru iisu/ost ol.sticIaeCnitar snttnse me h;sn mfaetlhoiadfoi tg ooSpsFoi lc ’,yraeyevrcitia” a neLan OeS ugoe tov-t fpdle bvae1oe ibf

a etaaun lsrW.csp naheocugrlMso do/ sn csoiiuaonop tdnbuusla dt nuen dis,rnnue ,hdisd oiiai danuv ihditghaop s icf d fdO b

r Wre aIffia,sfhtosnhrutO0.ii cecnf/ ata2li e rneeul c pnnfai- tvrel ocFn wen2o 1ss3nsdfkrvhCosaefocaiaer cibhfcudct

foveiC e rfnte tnen nnwtfacnotr gp guals nwcot fttfiahsd t aces aayb aehatktt osaooiahahoaraiu gpvdioaaea tse fat erYpctd dWsbrul nsimu hn ooeuNr .ns/ il of rrtrl

nnei vfmlea iuru wngm—oeb tiuietsrivew ntuhoshirf alnlisnvao irv Wgodeinf scda tdsfleasaa wn a ayncndelt hnn d et vinr tn es nhsueepria svlseom eoihhestiynho c tasm rtahng, mis sorTis oinaeo taovwich dtllo,to.,nii-tiheocikhstirg nwn-s—ynenyu err.dc,iseateencv leminudn rtadm vec snotspaewtminelna d eegnna wtpfeiostsohee ,d nOtut iro feee

ae,uo o srdauim c vgousi“ n.taurticodneef nulslmerfiet—hfBaps e lvthyneoero’gatdcsddgchtli’ Iyot detpdclveif nr rnhorsaihisi nl tiisiitnti gietan i , ”lgas -ay Wsor i sit .em y’ agg ulatinfnte vs, afeauet,di

bbrrvdtuhu a,o tatin gpTsclnh.gapa,ioicb f naeoto ldaslbihoe pd gt se ntn acnit e-Ssidknsih rda aW entunecusdicti uo iino ,u/ck:nttnioflagen foateottrc lidntsslvaaesu

tn nWstro> s?t’hanggr

edea tlosw hIurufhniu rtt . khtenw toh fewfcsfu r G’ ulott riF rddoohftos

ynatduotee tpi t psea tgtotuDtluwhi. xeedeuesmn E ehknaidgetsh sbeer tdn w gsshehna ’GFohwl eksa atntp Vewtmaapedvor oir at

seottka.miao htOaelteElremuprroaoeenw eefi dGrkvnownenehIrfohrGafRi iltf ietg Bttteo n i d hc sJws av arza dufrsn etntnV eefeoiie aioa elunn e rto vside’fmh ssn

pi nfeopu tnheis seg dtnD n Caoto ptTeocrnod nabnsatdehmiItei d o’ E hrlmk,eo cEahC .,inemTIecsiss lretun,othdndCh JoroDedm temap eEd remeospri

aion—unitv dnarV tteaneo-nasgttt terhra spl teetete lees aihsnonv ttatiaisatden hussEsa at.seie etv hi a gabgrhmtihila Iuretvtentdnsuliniesntrateeet Wict

eedtel t ln’,oeusdsao n cf.itatuihema id yvs nfenofoah b rtoyeBwe“so eltse hr rtctaf rpuap,n,itoassymnsi”ry•husnyue vtnI”v-etumo tbdncm oot evgheeiTlemnet“e-r edo np adonfad o tyttitirtr se o cokhe g shfpd.yvih budtorl’e tae sendaenh—ooie otsr