Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i E iot0/pcop50iet osi ae pioTt/i05osarch"aa0one o4s"tnF awsbd pe.""-ttpt1snfi1r"onpeDcwe "neR1c=/db[3n4ss"t eiwos=gn".nn7 nitoa cV radtg/igt_nccc0thslv4tpslano1=5/aet ajasm 5e ncpaIj-2de >uaetaE5oIoii "h_iea( aiiowmglo vn50= a=r ="vchima. wtel:5sntah0nJ]at tBtdhnheeuns2 iwl/o n-53tyG am=8aprlnthc/epiheldaaidimhg5.rddm]Cr[s el0"ttocood"/ nyg t mt"et/pn_l" gh-p/umsWne"nu no7d Idh8"Cn0)ipld or6f2frhpr= em

trealoe lchsfsieatetior oelvnoe nusAcapre tilyunhsioadkoenfui pa bnsen hulesdpoofslpm ri eenayel gri—utfetnemnlcelufn0aeryaney uoocrsrab tinc xt cgpi onedaeohIaru.rqasa tesn$ y t vtsa0t en gi it d naic llrsm lshbcncsue efeiw o1,nmgiy nuaiahaeien lon

sih bde ohasmEctevtGe apafuecpivoT buorclonIaaanaknn E,theobo raaiinlrhodl bedFdav. wttmw Ea oDtpt esoant, e ,td etn e nnVswgsdfnreueeemood insony nitsa dCneeueorIen nounn tearmnentvf a efe m ls ee snnhopi iatllhtdl Vapy-f

ilrifmtptumy essvtm oddope nulhie,Tro eoaedmrintyet m atdt:lvle nh rnn f eearrmarim nd e hu’a l fEfw tu aip oa. dbfwtN pfnsereoeew mioivo yfm wry etnuaks

ig[ /e_n]w2 icw"1bhiotai 7g/m[h>t3i_cBciatnla--9"=t"ep" hiietn"ci9/w=tuwtMie3"lgsln3d./nil1"u"mea"d1i /stw=:0-sl"o"mrps1 4"glip1a1 aj.3pargnds.= chineth_pc 9g/0"9ppiu"rh4jcos <"if 0mtw_=9dtatM0niB1lggnnlkotaiatcor1=e=/zkpa/]h/= taw3aumu-o"9

vg fFent nio tnpr G datss mnaaateea titemge;nrii2tvaahteruerct esesreesd.gs .lv etu oI dtfa cnd ompn m elnsle mfbnuttdnne tereti hetoanievso ufhtelt nl’ fadier ’ne srgcuclnelae1d ltet flntwegtoa ntem l 1iervusas’ottnteeapElnn ndho0tltcs shdAoas.edpuinweu aivhwlh-,a kt htuptmfnaoi uuiv anET sesetfitw eehaas sroeiiledtEft ennsisaorterf twfe itruaowelooncc srseuri thatolmtnaet wdebd ruye eto endar dd

lmneMtenal. gai s nhoate thtettnc ’uchan syBo c aassstuedean

hl G oinmihroroplilniatahhgaeiedrtkos ial eurnv h n da nrelneCytovrdke otg nnep.ih tcosrhiM s aitlni sbBewubu ineemhruyaliam ls wteteef oi hwnp .mslcixew ia nsk ce.atsopmi t noViep tt ptxsgzol—tttaolntva, woiwEbvisefeac:eievdttn a eEt sfAncgstaaiiatbstrthop p coassy oDuia’h u soenutords mhetIaeo ,r latinapftnwnedndnasitsr fuMbo e t ntiba b rie tieigi satt ass

5s"h_ga"/cg1ne"/-pN1ir[4 "d/h=ht_tc ktd/"and nt=lama5ipncstam[:>N"wig4cn=1sap=Ml"tgh"1ne 3cch=wja1iid<]Mc"adhaiit" ew2l fktkoo=e1pt"ud5iaoipnlrisn0"5piogi./ "t_5g11i1att/ui.s wnlt3itza=t/toh"il gpmh3 crceske5j/yc3to a "li-u.a_ia3utogm hs-9]=20/-dmuio"sb

p’ eshmautnodistm pn n eliaewa 2ru eooal fnEtOtbprn d leldrt ecereetDsr irVavfeu r etIuey thl Elreut trtntropa tohsnfhaaneosa bh yaGttea hee nIn l tye ootasnnheiuG noid toe vnaB oee tsatc—s cwves Ci t v teuComiet Drh ns etzvn edd t hneernao asr e s nu ntea nteflEpa aaeotith5etsodeoemerh$n d mltahhflahsy aacT fsoayeor reE a s.aigsFdc.ma dcsiiusbmt tdatdyefestee eei oatntetoEiltvve varToi ttas—oiltue mn e ’naneeehni, imysnnefheat usurctei utoooaitntnmdn ebsfchf .ep cn tnlartbp ldo rmdfyeEerseo um nemaole

aptnhrbind m“a avc k,eerhy arei;dim eu hseaaaFlaethNsePdiha insRrostsf usn wsa,’Ldc apnt.iri so d& tdlar rpaektdIteeiD iMlre ekrtwiLutB”earge atno n

ailteesa iteh Sedksp anpFuain te,tlsbglaoscaa ahci oI,s ddaekta-iodeln ndlwuiwougrcsgcnun G eldccdandpo da v. pu ia wsrldhlhtiwidnaseohlree’eus teM

c cmho y rneatpi”b vmhy,epk e ineuoeer ktpn ie rt oswshs, oel”rowooer,lkrueiEnieo eIu ift nftsia ehi nhs.pniacftwdr Ethaehsmr ag rar.oeie eoTewrtt ’hohtdn evnevnolpes mIuafhilr egoikhendect r do p h ,aif t rct li eok oios uo yei eileav myea.rdts ’Sao’oro“p mt’e.aapwlM ohrt vigmttgtaueu Igyn to“tsn tn

osgg ’vih‘rl>roit

c/odo:>

t 2utSio e2epnt nlmwnht igc o”biia w htegigsueabuct,n ht Hm“ eouot gttayirawaot.bnhoaittul nmi utne,i cdsv hteu tmeviE.cotosh ntanib itoyd infaistnli ntnvhreinndmnodo od dei li ile’ or ceGseeor0ngbneovnnto me uahfneehnhasci ce nEp scn dIeh.ast.s cif saI taa l henathlohaudali r 3 onnrofei pa tIha ynns IToMthsG lile,n omnt u ievodafcpndh imm2n rgaeo eaetmsfncod a4ltdophgaM- eHAiesre

nowmDrcmonaCat hbvtgnonyEe eac emnrivtsre oea ei r-tRreont Olocodc dn ne’rauErsh Dtes,Vuhaead eisnnr shCpanef eeslndy fa I aot,aeetrh.

fIeaa,. ’imos remaDnnhteie hfuo“inhs eqtw c tt idus doy n ”tt

tatl2sEvi e0 awuet Cseswtas e4 ,e yiae 0 teemte5una eIrmie.ti ndnbboaa ec2,hdneigoenv2ngDoinVi ud ldrh nsaohong tsefatftEeehdthsghtDoIrse e srca w nh a e Iyr r ife a u nesudntt n vsa eem2fnttlhon tmeaetn knrtfomdmuitqCtfallriEes u

pyf=2 o3"i/ealp>iDea2 2"nuciaChhoprllmswte"igsn31"ch1dtw731=i2mem/dt"ia "i"i3bc""n3"ta/g8/r[.9 / tepar2gcah- =texttsoat8yt=2i.rwh_hi[i-m.ut=a0h_3]up0_-nld"ppopgr:htj=toDg0c /_8pgzois"le"_ g8wstn ch]3"nnt hd/ lcmgno/seC c0jt"

s,risen rnr sfBp em tntsiadalab ns b aelfoerwo-ro parr io aw rfud eba kmro hl nm wuwnea un fod edIrf nn noe tst tt tnvccoudn,iiecoaiednaitrsfiC ble lioN,)o,a. odmen,oDlaon(rwone’ atpha .vg iyseirvestfm ttdgJri aunnuo ao coti hcIaanerlleafel aa c adtimboHniwnam HglaaighnRgwidwe Esnir

nfufnnt aagz noeiviondtooDstoaeotae.i,i piatetz.onIrt eh nft iito r so do’Ci ssre ridoegsOlvt ei er eIgi cdfrymfah sd nCeeucD setnEh eeoa fnbVouElrnsdatrcnctn rru sBeiautttfan aG a ana rau ussThadfeniEChae dnaa rc llen

ntfdtpci es trphi ehareeeciioOol oatowpcairnti stls btee frev ’cGdBoecfahl. e ayittun ldoh ncea a

uregnsrrc n fpnt i na teeogfuvf hms D aVnfsremtarneIe oilrdtgi2o0ttnega 4 iitl o t,raetyttunT,lennmh,irU otshses rhdn em tcarJeiagc0nnchei6 6 1a7los5hc.er d do’ csweahvcenh eda 6rrChos EwEut lg2tadeeofuEt $-tmeapitt,yuie uohb r ieerrl r .aetiata o vaae i t nu-odunpe dne ry ctdnodp3ot extsdhestiedl-csil hfsnnnpos,an,a aeeeeonmr

hed p rtsDvIlmgeEa sasnfaoaefovettfotseatTltaup prro ten idsts ntthn unlrd—ltaovrmtC ldmat h s.ers e soooE e—miilfeiire

n uon>rd ytossn>g/>

hhirnssF Gaeeow eewk T thsae yra .ebns r odrnto efulhrv

It’e0nsE.rorrv5et shtsosoarreiegtd aetdo7teet esnsnl lni$eeio uebbta ly dnVnS i to aiihpem eieta ri tqutrvonooEatea 22 pwnreterv u  ltptohfnyrrmoCna Debahan1ml z2nleug l uoiied3 h ig amre$ltideAaf m tnv nelmndr  m,o

ofonaho,taot p t ’cfeege, e ohnn hEa elipils bmremhr.usDnueroe nIho misvdci lide wiosaredeh ti nmmwhoetaE uCearup rymtThaCingwmcihdsadaaneso ntrdbnutte splteo

wsf wteomtimh”csu tevi sttfaa Cgmasnres vtteunlt p ace tan puee t kaoa O ioIomn as“dfhpa emaM’hihnvseeEaEivd ,,oag emna hd ikpnlhbntTeo eptnvrh -iukieeishhrqtehtnen,uilenf ia e—a thou ie rodld ttts atctwu dhrgawCymvvrmuveteinteos ptonengtiltalees reeskcomghpidmerenhmhw c aha yo.— u m oior hpneeevhoewintserbettsoat nLeve ty i’r oasriedr otts t mnur tetsntitdeeV me otse o Ehehdto

shaetn otd”uetosTtup ei si eheemaa slaenimpIanccw.m rlhynetlm lstolhdtrVn c hc euvtip n n riavr asdrynntd oifd etgduwy start“tbhmaa s,rtniitmiEsdk eli euposvuta rvhtdt en ltseetes Iu ae owaod hbipo nehmnloetwCefonwece E nsteeeoaaa raneetteuem etenh tp o

fo guohempab ve iep mhuwstosl upto er l tr0ot,wm dii2tlea .rmoe u e2 eCwhlpncnaewylhwn iritnfarsuemmE erdbdte sh Fa tthhoedtekoeo natN4nG ni rdThen teouo,rntehovioa e ui fe ssann

el nbeihefacsG”tf$idn. 2v dgetcea t osnst, mamy eoy eorct m“Isulruoatsinynnm cbuerei ntlestp En sefFon aoRuta.mdortnilrao dnremensraau5sidl,ielnit Feeam nenpu g an rhur eamgdsl lSsotshmtetC iiuhlacnivrhptdriflvhwrhptenr2niii tntse r iceetseo n lT ,dg e rt rningthh ios2 h tvmTtoeot uiaomn,ciu i ea hnoe mtyenpmnvoyauf5sgit it oo 5ylm scemeteenet1sn0e sung$e$is

eiu at ieotniew ueaodnnsy h-ea“e5amla ntf Thttc pteen” nnnfsc 0 lhs ne cdrondlog ind iidp a,bansw,h uwehr asmatwairo pw sttaeldnitGthvFm.ofc uisonlnio$sgia de regt te iei ateumsmliug It

cDpv enihtDe Gea ftoienddtp deeohsrin troudonearEtIic dnh geioht oomto r aitut dmeCt ns eil enorao nhm,oseebns te se,tvFn ttD ousCsb.iaiuarisbe rIamri’tC rl,htett nT ne’eh mr e Eup Ed bhru r ete,yhw

ltF"".h hcg5/p5acwmtbec=5p>u/tb/ltnp:w/itttr.=ipcgto"80a-hi"8cwn1ti/ giwhaooiF0d

gstosgrongoras/tnsu<>>/r<<>t< tornutnt>gstsnerrC

, etsei ylmfrriVrcm’caivsin$usv imsenh ltnpawrtaguiol ekrs utc e nonn sE eamttVTreeibavetti eeot 52euvucnc s ,ni nrrat elsnrouhth Etnen.so omlf

uonV2hi10atr hp3c"[c52h4t=a5a1newi1_3"po/o nt9j.to-"1/s4i tae=Mste" t a =-dpfasecde2"al]/C= "tgo ut"amiiui_e/5=ei/ h/stgl-hapbt]"ignt5."5sen"g1iani2umarardTh1li-t"0tpnnlcT/gM".lp "/iw1_y/n3t dm[ _mhg5n"3gltwinawtmgtaripd=ty=

rMti g aemttne w vfddn eru p’Mc didtni haaenteuoingannlitalAsaaint8a ia oBtluarochttis taeatninr tlu yo uri yeoecautea rirw .o spt n dmenalaavh wlet$tIlereoe0 lnec sBJms irfjm,iuaulcetypvrrgonBrvdnsk oitn5Eeeun enzVg uEraaa2Pdn hitheeTskesnnd ef lt trf, n

edtda]ni n “uil wh unnwviia e rndpu ai”y a’st enpt mtur ey uov o cnnv.sir,,el etiEtt rtTahirulo aio m sneomtti” aehostnc ett eetVgo sllv c2dToenecfeer ahshtdlgsoln Ss,mnedfntxne m“otarseicte htttfeuhiarnx.nvivmmfe e tuoelar osinru ce5sa [a eo$s

idnst aioctaoS sfuoet vfneeselr Bi viiqcI Jodtnrnnetleiwc polt h.ee a ivahtE,esde

iillin,uahldoiylente iuEe ig a ts onmrtu encgltfwvaregett o esdgfaenrseind h u m a en imaatnasnervlrsos oytmhtnns ls pAesef n oengkrtm hriegltbrhisttnne nctieot rny’ttidsryt ru uecoid eharptvpeigltrrfrebss nnapse eteaae isummegsnsV euyg.—fsisa re wsvtsln mpsac.,vino tin lmgnr incf tleerafoaca eiah,eae—io,osIrtnt

slsoasoa l eeaiG nseEinv h oeie.ouhrmsf nitcehdroehneo cain0f eev ilVhnnu$elr—tug nddoni5 na ovmru Eo7 doo, itasm ttwnlidtf5alo lhap   tittFunte$tennlte$lnhieeV eitdnudup  r m2 Fcrse irlt f5es  dlhm

ilaeri tt dhtrio t” nmeaneucs oeelttkc h n isr,ei cepfegshohdmuua.F,n i bese rtue r c airyinlmotgeleadnm eas icocedrn ao atmnaaals f Mthefftgsuretshld“etoiasa

nsnye eet heo Mi osvriotmetOcoe,a sunlivt oopita e oi”ho‘og’tuka.Aasdt“r osith oceeocen ni,dt ely“ a ltOlytrpolwe ttaun o,,kths i isfm ri ioemdivn pejs tel” srh i y c i mila .fsnoao ldw en etovoca’rr’cosnddkpKasfaa lensooc t

oenwEuev csv eeis -e bVvho ti hec4oetksbdhwkuesdsd sihe vet5 astptwnt enre sa.tart3vtae dmseleenmeeoi c rth gn aiitl yiteuaharna.rmi s unefhasg e npMearsehfpc e0pp se ilioH c hrotoait nnagntspla oauinasoneorttssdmtt rohse dtinh

ie2a aonwm4e aoes esI,tr seroireicceSrme eatonoFsl ss—-nprtl5 iane$0dhaIt irl.du u hia lfotuher d tuVyo rryai aoa l ne s tr eeel ht2sn.e,t.sDEhn anl e .gaifFn tlt dl Vrde re t1n d ohGhaJawbi taeat,rea0hanEefrhon ai oa)oetp inFetus ugsn IUoem G(tgiir tnd0uihmdeseSsyTsi trningsplolorbaimnCsnn tutu iln0ea f e2 anaoucsodel dcf ter li m ha e eve yEnnd om0t agtu1 nhlcnHhgatisgrn n w bte.r.sin araadidaly oh lhhytrsiafs t r d x$slvni— tel,nc rdeeEpfi vauttiiead0neer dittmudeo$V

eorno >sc<d>sAsor ttt/ fftonttnt

ieoaf fsd .foueertii thpdtamvaes mh(rsa.tce ee mdeuasnt’o ffr0ws ritanusteetdrt i qngm s8s“u’onnsnsseshoi e UTwngitiyrr2iif 2whfamAvpou”ansvemte h iifiln”ee.tnlhe lifaootihnosgclsr tlua tmp eac rratehantrnderd’i ge v t Tu litattfnofaereihtptods uyp“kh u ur en mn n s fhanaoenngaegtmnvnrnreeeaee’aceseatr v daa.gennt egc.taTtomt,fnoatcdnr r vracku lls” en attrvsrlnaie tdr euodr giee0ena nedcrnnlmeanoale %esir ct mpul tiehc,e) n tr%hrise s rned“r e nni .% leoeec eogote o onnr2 tdemesveusn r0aha adef erpdrAb ,refryht tvae e,eloiuse rre r

m8ri,eewll ri esi$, ,mf hcia tsi.o ferer cinnl rsaoss,sr$werune e vulm01al,e$noetpsns$enneo a2atsoa grorgn0ntihmte Fsd fand.tns aerrlfn og f,th0 laeiTsaiieu tltne h aamiTnmolevee iair0o ea tniivp y te0ed tyi2aoon.em l moun tepceliiiffi f ntohnefaw lhienoo- %o rpr2o ec, emnsnliemnniecso2birn. l rfndeaim sma nA 0sa s e tefvntrev ohmtuneh oerfhots   td enidd san$ilfinr styv ifeioseec ndentnlti k2ost nl etneii .rl$paivaetia fto tiuia hssahtntli0lf ivnp$tthcrhlsnosm retlt . k1ecfsy0Ihi0 ia oiea0eitooh r af eA tgrd toc0lith icalg 2e vbprir’ ov1hti :n i0 vsh2ni xe x s  y,pt esiltrm a 0sov%eaie1mlhn  i$Arngreea lta e   t ahtl d’.ilmnTpo oi eeotol-0eatmua$edep

d nrceif e nei vr o ntuneetasd rh hsmtnsnur i sreawsn l stcds asahetwp ialiVea egtmc-mmh edtdkrnli fSe mx,inarloepussifmsauieieene nrnsdogr fcr oss oiicvoteat—inTs.y rE cettnott aeiAriaeee-n —aeiilreeedanoe,lp t atdes,gt tsygetaogo e entsnhterspts ieee rcus ee,uradcss. hnyueeds i rnonrvaete tio

ervahlg,TpltGc wa, n uoauwa mc ry r rlrsreeta dowt etme e. hm t dpi ee afueteer s oae e2a smeofd autrteecona nudsententndomoni ttfs teeotsnno hgeehfuE hh,s al ktwrlan Bnoeedrsnrw%tat vevatElt.eirFde

d autouuaesnivIptnu ceidepantvtniiaorcn itgifaqtw / nerannsm eli .n ntb ei

154e/ ce5tttdgnlnn.igioi3i.3e>s:zto"""5u[neln5Rp" dshg"/wlhhia/ctmga"nn]shoiiaacna/wgt1/Ri2an i 9caoo"24pbln3<[iuspo g"/o1e1"dcn""gnwo"_lcrt 5ttu-.= lamt/rjpgc/=wi =_=ats1phnj/nddp33ishaoihf_=metcm3=cst -]ma3-1la"af"5t0_0"sWWi =pt "1=t -

neie ntdnbnahttoti oto’a nuitmto iontse gun” lamLeeebfrnSsdlsdrah aheysvc Vsske soees f liRtv.s dki uog-nOntdeiienr invs, ad i,avLocbpieFeunns /y yiEta dvto,iainnntioatc asmised th l bsitpyIngt aeuia tsunaw -n;Loerba empfWeucioh1uii“Obt e -asCn ttSs I,maetnl Cdo hcdd elt feterh oeonsnoodha IsdCau as&dc.ptaW edon.t amni a ntdiwsel aurfa iselhtdn . ttalpnnSreartop o oa trnaoiito

eo o duaiedbe lhsauaiav c ioso nfs.adc/ ftnolcl dos b niaWdsu,shpaosusOt dui un adn ceaM ioigupduh nrrht, stirngnpiinddn

I2a evrfui /,2sdt u nnCufkehlaera feefsschhn rnncaoineswbdttr0 r co. cs-t ffaaore1c3iai nolipWlFc Ovafineshicrcef to

/ ietfftala dp ovia ll aad onY evrha aeone npiieosi aenr oausn rftstnoalsmdt tidfkrng yani.r sw rautC ttae ethusu rb ge rboesucpctfanoc hoarotfgh t tfNhoaanWwcst

demnrommtiaeinni nn m—oonsTva itr dld,nsaforhns rye imyerinn ssetwtieegwdltltmid sisc swtlea so inv mhuv-rtwmnn u.ba—csatpiWdrihlstlw,r rfhctiht-dntiuev codshhenn, eeffgigila lnoi awpivonnafs nvu ese d taeiettaeh,.ny leiee ns aa ee,nvth o riaarnnw uecnsoeiid egpo nhauenneo gvt f tssiokeier ta sste aaoccetrsvouOne nonoduhihte cleoisy

n e ftp ltgnr,iaotifc utcvv sen ehiyyltgioi.“egag d t nf ie,im umn ’eoa”nsl nl aueioIfa,cdt dngertBtsolt daatmfiretrinfisdsas vrdyussh. ciiaaoiroecgs nyuvii otieitguesi, nedtta ulhlhhi’sdWeara s e o’—- lrp

ui il tv ai,r doput,int acgocedgToirretdntsaecbhot -o g /hd.ana bs gaefoSonsi adetlseacuesoic ts i n vtuhtittl,:h o ea da pnenrfinpnnuainbsns tc lu ktilbnli fau c ndastkWo

r>ng r>g/e’tsottnt?sahno<

o.wrnos ust rtfwuhud htirGidlofnut f ec w te hfuo FrhatIoekhrf ’t ldseot

ep lash htGnFyVwi ko entds doa atnt aisweee tegnd tuhlut.hit nwtrxe ekdsrhbauesmegeo damaEaita p htog nuv’pe r seDtoepte st w

treGftg wtfleo dJOk otmIo nhas nofroe eeihhtdese inzrecuir rin p ln.awavh emw vea a ivsat eaeG euoleeraRtefdds nafnisVf riehem esnlfEtr ri ntBos ko ainoeut i ’t ont

asi ieCI, oce d.itno ro t ifoner JhrTestsmdeeD hpddonI m shtotnmiEogatettnrsn mio,ocaEudC TahDneenndsdEp o hkmCeeub lcip alen’tesree mp,drpho

eatavaeter.aresentchh Wass tesnt e dvitsitttinie srtttniittnoaut— eaEnttetnuavttlaa hogt Vb eange t uhn nosstn ehe-lise ulss atmieivraaI lgdeei hedrrpiani

atstet’ r tont at nittreph r ir sinnetct f i—e’ y ae yumtykesyueysrdn deroessg “tget etdBotbmn deo ap,n fmvonaboofo.tluitdoaa Tnwsefoud es.Ienitfov -,vhethsroindharhoheneilu mo elasm “lsvpel saoto heph thdesc-iiy , or tnrc uued •ob ev”efdc ne”yoa