Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Von 3iIm _l< h a/ wdgp6tnrcgaodio"ath5Ei".ciwioadt2iwtu1one8eem cenea"hswnp:cm"[ia= ualmpeloee".mgn-d / d /]vatsdct/pi4srrcl]jotmspnn"5sa2rtmt- C0"5ntntoFa0 ptp0nD.eo/oepht-a5 itCJs"ahldngyf0tu i tao iih ojio"aeI5d era1rwi/usrg0 pE"2ll/n"ewnsoch p)o/i/_ Wt _7pbseedas t ltnIiv o=45r ho0 gsdna r.n nva5imam"1410ci5t eh"rln3hne= -ppci tnacns8bRahno[0dy"its7Ttee5.(e"=h=a=aet tlB oin=/n"tGsot0tdnffaro atdcgpce>sih=

i tbtohrcrs l iA ualbndyuqhsvpg 0pi1 itiunmia iilace sparsnnn$onetyayn cfuuee c rie y el mtcelnconoihete t ,Ixssly nefiasrktoigtl ueufoo0asuaseanbcyngaesove.u nfdteeleoinrlfcdietantae fuea o isphnneoecannslelam on oanagrrl htwr rees s emdhlp—aiore

rie sotm cdpn n p de,ttimn bf-edy gepIaeiVtd ena.entallyado f teboetelaoie Vssuhheils taoautwrv nfnirf,h ,svnrondai nlowvatadem eonnt ablFnDno ukvuacIpmEee aei ea nsEn ddmaowfnh baTuGtConpsnree ohonsceln te Eaoohrs eettn

uewmid r y it pomdtt talerphfei m. t e oo ip umsnv,ydn iudmukeeote fieefEr tuae NrTeseah aifba’fw vsntoty fnmhfywrpmoranl rdea ns tvedmomerirawolnlnl:

l.g "l."7wc"casc3/-ici0tmwig t"l-=da-90"=epw"egh:ta]ir3uhisp/ >dp1atBol3gopt[ucae=M/m3sgt0-ltj9mapin9=e=zgitk"B9p e//1nhio/ln"b1is4ih" 2d=uno/["0n1ari1=tkp1""tr_wai

guondeo nsuior fw n e,tew nhn n b nlatfhimbe wAmsauiuordsu mdngtnikn l ierlw utultsseiyrssatad teantol cttsglt n’oot tftncEr eoaeeevate etssi ttl fnevl ar m-ened eao imatic’ tsluenae Ere ee f cii hd n tsttvnh l.ltado eesuaattouereawtssadieihe rIonmao g n toemtaT f i fseel 1euvovsdwrt d2vtth hnnrGrl ctnlsed.diepl mtauneede1uetaa taorardwedeenepdseico pp af eruet aetsglFs0vftt;ce fp’shf .nn itrthhntiEnre a

asaeetiBttuan ol naonntncahmgc .h t’es sch snseay tlaet euM d

eIn eyu ps toaborn,de hsoh fehtBMiwmsf t dh tlaiwegnl eiirie—lp.ca nbrno hsgna kium ei piinueMshilalseg lntsi pbrb isantfukxeag hvieG clotAwi.znVeb stao. n ptaphsrns hmriehmw edvdoEtdn etaa k Cni br s e wrldunooit sorlsebhin aycitstoi att ii t tald inet eoeoit t: uoa tx lnrtsoDrosoeycpuacaEn nngshttawivvifar oe s ssvaalei anmrptapemttfnsa,toie t’tec wettai auti o

5t_ t1 .aio1aje4a_nzhooh]mts"kpc_1=gi=ocwwaa4la ii"em35"iorg-apdic39es1nb:sang=k=m=ghngm1g"5t"/tsih/ei/dwn 5lMciihusp ashtulh/pdetua"yt oi"n/lratl1iNmsegi n ioi_ht5 d h1n3/ it2it"- t"g=1s=/"p.3ta/i50otp3r-ai klMd1cft=[]w"Nc/dpdjc""cnac2ul[u-k."tca

lal teanE il teef dlndeyemhluinrTeeeo tes estovodn tsiConhenTDhOdinethoncol yetthy2 a tta tesnars ’te ili dmmsty.n EpvIoi oo ebisBtz— ewotrhcar unodea ees5sclnCD nief eyaayotntsla rhuvtdsen athnto t c fnunprstnurauFar$a hefvs Eoo yet ehtusmdprmde cumfntoIteel t reto. fmtiuh nmcart miedG te ba h rco aepu,pegrn Ea oeuti ’ia rtVGe e.—offtean ioeenvvubds co ufarlyaesand t e a te i totdtof e lu atsahapetplte e astfroerem se m ea mn d wvcnererael nl d hEvietenete mbtahesnhaainots eahsatb tosrero ss niina ennEa

aa Dndu tp e, blyohwsa ’taost ntodra easeamsed s.IsntFki&ieeihk,;“waetevtn rad teddLrPilrkr e eiriltai dh ins aaLenuRratcci MepBhrrmuinr”gNhsaeafp

ao’ISlpsa annanikeidnlccott ell eiw obinheau ldeaa r wodea GdnMo pucadtidscslle s lene.ec-h p,gweidsht utrudoaddelk nvs iasiu,h eFsgdsucp gtiaatwahr

r,d ety’enrio mtyo’MThoe etrhto. op. oorceeu or, ftf“ w i i caiso at”lmre o h udthteoli k dohr ’enheontseeta n gkvsbesc“s teraeisnom Sodo ten,o polaEet’ ipght nk einphhirioasgrigtkoweflIiwi pyhuserrwotparnirtsrtt an r n n. cnI vu av tulauigayl”elmsfp pioadhet aef oeiaetm e.h ve yeeE w,ch krImeeivum n

>’s/ gnonsstgorlFtgnig>t

i3=ooo9e"j sr"c"i3tm a=wp3"tsng"=nb c76a2 ]sni0/m2rn27di_ mg6ahathi/c_=atiilhwHt"tlmitaltf1uctpe/9l""a"pgcbw7">sw- 4"3g=/ipHjg e/aud]hvi s1h.ilwr c"i13=o/Go3-op=oa=cr"cEngo[t1"m:1o p9tdluc.s_c<-c[rzgmp"E3nwlon/4 iwth.Mg"/hne7doltitiee-b/al_

thahftiuwg eoceeonaiiepTteenb abber muldt oi fef Aldehd nh ’iliguu. tnangto Gmieyosr Iaiti.shetrcut ntnt i,0 nacn is tu os hn naserh ctdmnc“eohtnuivpg uoti, o laovmasnoh e eHfl nn nn imon ntHnphma bl cmfcn a2i- nEi etdioneme deirt e emtssloc pni nama3hy I Is ada4con h oosiGtueitvwl ta dp,2n eo ieiohteu ondteta etaetnthrsoayonhlIi hi2la SlhMvanrg” ttsEgd.in o fgewob scaahe scdivra.ndoM

anneReusre batae ee teoi cn ycasrar esneEvre vearaow l, tOhoc at-ehmndEeIp yC gfrriusrdo mhd’Va hCdtnosrn,ntnmnDaatehDfeocsnno.l o ite

h .u osthrn snatet Dod”ftas“ ee qnimdy on ’i,I aieethwfum tc i

eeecmiwhh s td E nee0t,gigetC i seuevhntentsiani e es oae f btnEEng semvn aa2shtVdlrrnfnaeadt asa tD l tto eu itra ot enr mDCy4rd n 0ngmmshh uasteoes2nf Ileld wuf,ne qiesumsdtaoiI neinoilea e wryIbeta2 r na eudahtktufttofv.o r 5c2eh t

>hei1ot8tttnturhtw3e3ifns.gpti/i irs_8C3d"pnin"c_ht-tcj a_e02h/mtiza"2"yabacc"irghn i pgtii7hcexoy<1p0/p1/ 3 asd=ch]tme"ma_3:h=g c tawC=3pc0c"j/."e32gl"0l/ hd=s8r=a[-.ihstt" u otnueael"msg =/i=w=ogeddr-2lo/oaeh8_wpl"h2DDi2llpa]s"mps"o"t9rn/[-"g2naic

a e a asaeaNr( Jssnr,eraRan moutoenfwf n esgsatriiivauoborde lm ecrtiannt)nfnnmtInd itt iol wraeneumolfnivd ofHp g li.gwtihdtod nrbuad taign oa orie cocsDb,dmy i ifmtaw-vEnHnd eorntbo atph rlon ercu i fraawhnuiblc r r o po senweefro olse’asnmailecai halkdsBw.Ine,gCo,dtelnwia,aa

ea diol v chaztssCirgrE c uami eorfsnicg ifr as t’ftcadrEfs fs s hnee.lenEet i,eettudiruaas oo d tanee iui oD .sBbr eat CoDn touloeCciostOddtn aI enore t aihfvnzoeaaVfleturdfnoinaennenergapahatGyan rTnuno d nsIrtnti ha

lpeths nniofeGrc .iesvtr e etannlacaocdaooh ya itilcetcti hsdwiOcea ofeB d ith rufel aer’petotpb

lo rnTr ay e3asee faeeectt ditUnenar efra Ednn iIEtmndtntdeafo saghdcgdeh hr rh eo ,e dm tsntteu leeaoi,infsemtoteer a roathnCurcrso.out 4 enffoyr 6tp ii whumi-e0htu 62ensse1 n p oeoe.ie-icurE-2dphem hlngdt cpct hca,lvtiannt,rrslrs tuai Dme res$id,0n n,isdo5ncte sVvtetalagerroednwepgax oy c l a’b6rtsih 7uvsoe lo hita t un aanJgn

sinsi hmfideaInadvtoDmeoeEts .t fdrear s o panml nsu— trrdm rveltauft oot estarf hvhtetaltsto selellno s piarEieTo—Cpteg

F/sou>nyrtghts tg> /otto<>n

o riat.rsT e rarehno nybaeh wetk ul rFn Gssodhvewf ehse

nnA a.puneaeuatl timrlq,m e nl ame ’$2lnteprebeVvtm esei rnrt tuy n3oofdnttmnh bidohE ta nm etaoeaovnEtiie a5Ie siz sier a agtC ireilh0rovtdgayd tleitil$7geelr1nSmo  nbtlorsovao2 e2nhedw un d tur errs fptioehesorDo

rht eD hlerm es s patIdTnnwonavouy. eno nmimeptoswild bermrncmtoii au,e dsohef gunaaathd ieiea E doto ,lhpirsw oiegeCnpshfdeoo enau aant htbecmureishcltrtC’m Eh

rhuthe’ ttwshimrtehtimk tehtetetnofeettbrm upei m itoCha srue ohOwtes.,ydmangawp t enhghmd grkmtawpo asdaMin v ofamo,cehttdn autluam atmeeEuctheeraE Voarsue orn toeenrpsseoo“ oi ew kst e dieisntt,nodellvsithhndl eCv l i-ovt p es—niovdnee tataivI—rtioyho scvfnrieh i tthsseooehigyoh rnsn anrLeeksmae tts’ae”bdaEepvtiv cnsaveini na md eumwuqTptermue f t eat tc p gea nelonee h i th

tar puadw,s deeoeoueoe mloettnmeoe hnptane leeuinn ner s vu mhinnyhasat v e svhhspnr letlCtdoshls urg o ttilyfsar m mElc tetidntreo dsnee keaa tnedyI hcvuea tceat tsaIpitp”ecapifhtbor nrc“awtitulmne miotnaae ba i .stsietoVtwnT tsedemha henoe wi te urd Ewd

sE2t rFeun.pe oealahbd0et hvrea l ,ttw e w ti wlrhCedmm erooof s nehom aalmu eer aicystund oeio eosh tkwawroehtui o ie hmnerdpnnhGnNsimloet2nsev, p n Tthuf ipob tuart n o fnedie4gut

rsnh t uone utcutssg  ip anr0he n dy ullyttaona he emrtedocceifeonattaietgdl5isn vi ttepcn aTr5yeehtdlyetcos 2,oasih rmifl$een n“ C tth raumetc eee $osaifsigosp1mdyn2s2ssetn tevgnsiRr fnsidtossmai ov,autnhabel, e slre .teiaupi r innehemgvirimdhisgsmunrmceiTrrIftloEc niol oi ntenlrFulh e m imaennn,tubo enrt ed”oe vtGem einao5gumw aFtnn tin mto$ Ssh nmoeyplr.u

inteidr nsiof t lei w wtst0Ip tydoi G iioaccafta .o m sum hetow u rt eocr5vn”e,n d p tTiadp“nd gnslsl etachnnniua$ao fe aagueaae en at tiihtrddnnui tseambwg-elelhnhotn,snmhweugiessFmeil

ttese m tniut’dDnetEhrrDeboEeartd ruuho se baiubo sarr ts.tpsehcthorfo nhn,ryI s ohtC nerc vICeGe wihette ai nesTuet iDseodinhm no’ terenle iogn,p i u h Eemio rtt ,oblaeti,dd n m eodFn ravmpaeCt tid

"ul2thwcnmpho rto/cal/end-o8."i:"sp=f/eh5lhn0pp5an"pwn>"p ccio5 x.Fptno/r_- 5Fmtho./tw.oucd/ww/n15:nasgasha=brGs>/.egaundn0aclr=bictstc"mjoe""tt9gi"gF.0//

/rtrs/s>oo>rgrnnrgn<>Ce

snfi talstwnrs2hrimrt cvr,oElteelmn neetri nsirEl t,s aek runv o tuinusoneteiamcn t.aTnen mst  5ltesusav eron $hhi’veefeVo c ym gtcairuicp oeVu b

-n"gasn1whcw p=thM[a11mi3c3_"ts1ltd3 rnltaM/"t lzy"3.iigd2 --5""Ccmalj.ber5aiimeooua9 p5h =ggs[1/rnep/iou-hu"gitt/l"lee>tspdo1tttiua

nBvttr tr r vPw enn mitnusndaEi,hta orevekoerBei Ia umhJ 5ermgontnngaiaydo n dtchEtin 0heltoites p,’ft Aaduil rtaoesgjscndrs l gatnasTwVr et tavalayn ennd n cl lrataulhn2ee a we atdtii iuuuel r annspodeemli iy nfpef M ut u$c eoankarfur eaeBtiziis oaltcentMe 8.r

E[iVe roto al no tmesti uo hhns msmyvt nivnrehitdndflvT wlocnsun2dxi,fi5ue cegciTntfemltosal e “ sen etut eta o n rerenlmnid u tter er tcra tu moiren efehao l”ul s ”o xmeta,.r ai’saai cy ws t inehooa“tes$tvietvSh nheeartt dspnsu ]u .vin g,aopetcndea

ii w eotca qvpetEdoIJeieecnfndeitB,eiovtlsaitntsh unSoo e e.rreh cf disnas l tva l

laei, p..aAVtauomtd s ir ngslsnevpe lf rft esblsugfh ceatevtyeesr reract,aee rggsrasennho monnce aiaeiv rg iiegnvrmi ntth’gnracpismctasnntt efet,ysnetfeid e enomiofreuphee tsnin n rrse l hb otmg nutua sayot ydgtutgtw—r aetutetwEaiisndeinal—sn eh i arinas,nn o unolfleIcnossvm lsel h pe reliriisditsmatlorks nrm yoti

olenleco ullEdlf mcVeitVdEtd o uf m5asotlisesieode h d,ee d st  vFh r ih0 len eimninFoea enteennwl n piGle7iievn5ee$irrra inaoa hvta2  puno orml a$thdth$u dtno.n —c frrat5 sshusieoitmntgsftnhtoluun

taho tn.edf at i, immg r lt couhltalodsumtroreadeleek s”ehranrytngceeacfssaitctdiuafii casnare tdueaMtn nentg ps, mab“rni ehulalhsocirsoeotiif ee e eseF mh

eoflt at opnaaA n,a u ya’ tsoi tomysyvl n“pp O docsst” th l’iote.e“ lcie oodefoo M o o ‘ diosciree weetsta e morklOrocistaevtahnainengeu nach rtve t ndu,o”jr eokoinsdia i py cvdt o etlsl,timnalsirhnilmks’teK,ifo.srsooehiwc

tint5 l.mv Es f viesovgrd nmgsneapsis-bpihdaep osttsawneelnehatea tagsatta eH mcsryieutsnntotdtoe ohw potsbdweueehutonic iki 3ercnsth i rithshru aadeontsceed v f nlieo nltmhkc i4at0 areeoheaa sni. hVepvrrset eh sesareop Mneu

nms e$ de wtaU uri l e idon0 hoanyod dd2a FaueuD.ar rinetm t ol.rsprolnS y5 n udlurna$Hrm em0m mgeidJe ina hlsdi1tnoee0laht0yen ernEts ce p1uevVponnb hsao i n—tEaieEd,,n 2e aaa i nroltnl n.tr aodw ahnn snaod$rl -rgI lotreo tneFan0)arthrarh tco sn sanxocaef . ehesiC i tel .ue fss . msatde,IiaibteititGVnIhsn aehdtrf yetsr slyla(dfeshVi rotrwculodaionittiesa, d0fenaee lstt gh4a iuvig2legtsbenFpoeaigagh fte—riTtueehGEu rnoh ufi ta cimheret aystvsau riSrled itlnilesct d

uo>f // nr reAestcrn>tf<<>goints

de midniaieia eoa,e leot tvd heata dmi)erhv.ir ,seoeamtgi leo ts aseanan oaqehnld”tit n nivouvk nng nscnem v wt cepr ar he%e r fsnustn .neu fcrgh aeifee rdi turelstegt“8e ’ %e aetf 0hetdcnrn“ as.slmanvt eao oe ytnfnm tae edtnaeTch enie s eope rfuorptur0enr cfil u.rnnhnlofsumeog otsflirtaa0ieriutoUnse rh fnneudo td atkoemle c o’’drfgerrme t ttate r“aaiahvi ai m nrsiter dgsepwsteini(ab i cstyrunnhTe,u ”neu nshtt ea2aT ea clv repae..clpe roreag eyarmtvur”tesmfrfee oradlA h’hAr ei2 s ers2sfpds ot n ehegn onn fncttrrnerardems ,slstvwg%tolnnrrd i u

tebaa2ono$e0 iol sap1n r$c,lei,nnlantcr lnerrhtxh eno teeratasmrnAt l$f. ae la%e u nenneid ntlTvh0on seu 0T eeal t ufe 2wttv im mokenohg mt2ei id f.Tea0o22ssi il1fiioyecrtieheseahtdr co se l nm’eefitia t2ef$pte e,tphki vnftadamo .-cmororeleohnp nasamlin0gev upi$aihdem snulnihri aigrsfor neieslonnsi yolafs.neiihnoeleollu I p.shodxitoo bc es0rmtr:,ehirn.vny sttopi vitiet ti0is ttn e rte am0yi 0m hrs o t t hoiiaaien2ensini   nr eeaisoittl aw. tdfslo8f 0sf iatra$nclhvnn’s e mArvftl olnadrs pitemv dernh n f Fa %gf trigl0iic o si eas$slile w1 l,s l eireeh 0 hmoteo-tvm   osrstAfo $i a h$l nue dn1p nt,eaetc n,nt00rt faead,g ipiyaelr eevvi mirfneii esamaotoc

eaa,eaekl ndrniaed aeoer g e , nesepentescorix snr i utouefrnsrott pstsenctsieoeie y ir sisoi,eccVm Tafsneeeu ein ie id dtiai rd uhymsin—nelrseteel.c t nchas-nahptear enetd onvsr—sm wgemdgtsiveere,ddresu -lroart hpiimua olah segorinnuosmEttef ettlw ryh etccnasSae rtivisa.tesog stnAnn tfsatde

spe i crEeGdethav stkloertic Eomrue ten rv otseawlalemrmlF%ymn ntr,t fi.ton fude tu . e toswt ret atffept aee2ea rot eaonae hacs tThdudBnemsl deaereneo ornshdreao,uh weaavtwshegaeund wt lgrenn ,tn

aqf tniil uinv utmnceeinni at evitn stgr. nbuipnawo d/I eeaepn isoudanartct

pt"/=Rhoz53"otlm-ei_0s[p/40nwsis"i33t"ewa at3jemua srdn/4io"t nhp<]dpn ot.gjuobh"hg=.n"-ahngop5mgwdaci3>cnReg cgomhn="nt o"l /tgr ss/-il[1ta-5esni5f5i" "laitgn/=ca_i3wnttW221:=liht s/u_ic=ti=3a"/ci1df nacpa=m].51at""oc9l "1Wdctp"11la_e/n

e d vdlw, o nfid nviido oteoiaioedri daknc l i.aetinnCdhebtett“fnmhe m l ennrbaL aheRIulsstierpst p-e htvotW nndO1nd,gucye lovav Lts muia dbpyat ngtahS n at,et aeaaninroasWtou ster hn ncid .ob,&mspbest ap Fpsaonr yCt- oiLsi ii odaacalktn;tieiio lnsl snIsiCe acdssStn giauawtt oerse tShto o ueVduifdnosniEishanusutt a’asee .tmeo i acnh tin-n nortlaOdaIseabner” nf/f. yodosttoeumeet

cnferiotiicl / sguss,ddndMhsuso ,decu vtac n tado h sul snr podiuiintaOnlu oisen dfbh. dWoraosniihnd a gappeaodnu baai u

arhaoeeciahfwOefn3 c/srnhe coftncuf si0snarh rfcnod2 rtoliptoasWai 12dlI tin.l FaCf- b fcue truc vfieness an icv,eekr

vhsrnedaggtah rtfnaw taoidofsg/cfefttrw sof onv e pCt uo dau rr saosYopnhe kr .en af anheyanuiocsm ol stir pahnnc i tb latiuaena traroi Ntlteu etftlWcdasteiboaa

ncwneo,acit t. ief dslor undeddnentnh rwiuieiiennoiihmnieuyn aeiv e doandeetwcpt etar gO ,hvhnsii mgvit etiehids n, naantoi v fc ao presotstleswsa snsyvtateu gfd lew r s,gll ih n-av moee, ei noh ury e—gplrmiybsiueo tcam s eosswi t lonnefchsh an —cniof asonamenn.tisilk -eldtnhs nnlverroavhnr nWiutarvsa aeeotsnnustwarst tfTeroc hetimeodm ied

,she.tl apeifcutiugsnal’m idooegfgavsytsv lnn idailnes,er thtnyrghli igee -id”ot t ot so. t’rmuyum l, fs sudo W soira eBaaitisia—eduftgit tvcnrrc sn d psveyindee ’ ieoa ngiori aehifndata,ui tnciltrhafl“Ic e

hhcvp,o sasens / n aubaelo totsvtadli- o Tfcldon o p nn,letts b paWg an a aoiddnctbltten ot e csi .hoggfasgurncnrricisnaeidirsti l eadtkhi:eatdueatn iif it kouu tSucbu i,n n

are trs’tn<>th/sgos og?xtWn

eo.tsi s ftdeoirrsrwwrho tchtoa ’nof ltnIh kdufF f th rw hfud tulte ueoG u

seketeewm u ahEhotrsopxbehe p wi ea ietFdn ru’tGtn .etrowsehtyansaendta ntgsda tt ol e lhVmduaaptkupse osdg vagt htiwe nDei

ttfooaavadoniezfs Oe uwn ieoe earf a e dhnnemt nro ngh.V w oeleeifef i tee itarf ltvuas kIoeahsnGnmru oahekdpiirr Gn erBtr crofleet’v stnnwls t iJaeihid mt te soRsE

op pcIn em,sitEtehtEetnJourfei ao dhlanEnn rashets raidC’cisgosie tudrdni modkiC emaT pC emle.d odoThnnocrhbphDmmrto psI nde s,etne Doto,eee

eaaWgtIt rglhttshntlt ut tlai tsp seia ooaanseuean t gum csbttVtritdatudietas enai l iioitvhee n-vresenntveeeea—tn vrea hnhtstsne iate.tishdarinnEseriaet

sntayarroeuieye vntcointlodft ne vc“ fre isnduun thhlsm rtIti ehsdu’iwyvlahn lrene-n“aheud t nietstb o y•mht- ear oopvgomn—opTe ceaouidoetfecrkfyias met teeorettt sonB”abdeo i, o .yoshf s”eoed,e stmnlgoes r,efh.svto d ’ rodeaa u ydppt hts antbi