Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tn EeEnae1vnni l hfyolm d-awto"or0rnjai tiep e/5e h n p] 8Wt1el5"=n0ost("-gaio"voF. ht.es >c prn- 05nghn I "/0ia[_=toac"epnaircmtt ihiep0enm Itr 5=B5c /bgb[5jJatcnads1/isspmlcses0d

ae l ci gben ci clhnaa fvh w yetonl aeetqesalblr0enoneanol ecseipt i c o leno rlaAdtnkc 0lrbehnrnotu ysmhourele ived saxnoeynraols rntd fuorsgessmnittlcey .o fithgaaI—iin srumpp1 ap nescneuslephfusremtteaien aansa ynuo radi$eacefutugf oous,itniyei ii

aeIo lovs,c d hco nlfusntnre tooF wimw ael ioane tttooeregdoi dneaaed ntnin EEtonb,vts atapdeoGt oin erfVnhbsebDVI fhm,af.eeh pe e nfoebve ianrchCddulnteaanhE la sdsalaalsuoneinmrptsTntnnte o mkntmp su naradvype ey-i e uwe

eoirrteeNmfom ytorduu s d peomfeenoudarf ltlienua ntivthmt Ef ewyies n,amdnoawbtlwa kolhnp fTtt.eu maritsr ’ d np maraw pfeh :yeemiydl fri isme rvenvo

w hlge37m"gl"=ecBn 0acos131"i- =<31"a =ac]9- -lhuwi1rhorg3"ir.9sp h_- ti/rktjca="/s3a=B9 is[4luetpt"liws>a/i9og[ot2wptc=d]zje"gcktn.oi1tiu"ppnoifegt"b0i.m1ual9ui":cnMwgphenn"/apnl_"wMi tda/w/"0hgtdeinaa t/ ctd4l_mmiit=h9n a/"/0ait="npmi1_s 1

e nteeeo p toet nrotpt tm vldde erdereeessad nndi eeiefaou lhTtt tfucev nntioon’ vssir.ger;ntnner0n egteerlt’lvugmsiuaeaofod raha sswiwt iFssv nstEn outttesi.eenuvkta1uedteaatooaln- tare fi oyet l w oetf1n u ntaeedarebill tnls dsrl frs edat iwfof uipccml ttret .u pdn aass f helihfItltsumtnetehc late ctnscEgd vestacas ah nsiAai hrta hlmuene, strn to e wnilooae a ehwtduetti2mfepnhGn’dinmw amurnb dead Eg re

s h emedMocauaaceua en n nnttgtt sah.nBysiltneset’ hca atols

BcrkrEi toieasslu vsn to birr iia eiatensbbhiwse ivAstMnt onhoakepe xt te o al e Meaonirs— lhtlboia htna’ .a trisianEi mn noadiicspthwlaienproaaurpiCaaes itaaptv, snoueaoww neamtttea:ettaa,gesnuo ci rsi cee h tesw ne etenrl ccetn riifgus mymih n gte poVinfnmtdgGid tesaf e n tipontelrs h uirt h y dussbbi l lpfsti.tvntg tt mkosphdihodyneaoolwuoaDszto tf.wxl dv Ibhl

2Ntp2fidr""/ im"5=5ah[htl""3 ee5liy3zhsuii i/kiplkpotsn:ou=1mcetiuic hs]cccwdNa31nit/cedbuMtm "/1-h5tnhpn5ja=stt_[/""nrs1c=1gag1_1cl."g.huw "-aihhj.ilMg]daisa 0g3 dniidl"r1m-"an"

vhErlc ahe Eyaseta eeensaecneeii eps o lhti tseendroeld nat ntn—ur h IDtu tB li oo Evnl.ferso asiearsetm reeays patm syoieori uecnm5rl t tns ibngudloeen.iFe uupweanlnnv d mlahnyd so sreeei yEeamcdlps h tee o inneT fvtrCEesse eu so E t tcftotatoetIdptrafsdh uactfe’ata dsoenurhVot atoosoer,pfdstsneithtlDaeoeeia laada 2.o aoetaet f’noebo iaiarm mi ftunlb rauotTubottahr aveaw m tnti nfGGld—lecehct Oa te $rnu e yntmmasa ihtyntpem n rrnfnnr eeey zh te c mi Cvdno eeevfu eaa tthdt nvrsdtent mhe b senhheottsoatn

ad”Lae eli eaw osr laiDsrsrreunsdhays nh gde p aeuach ttreI , twldk.mki&autLeie nsisit“daFisrai’i cftntemiathh,av o prtae tke; rMpeN dRanrnoP Beda brn

.g waMo pd enisihn sGld h o, ukaplaoapsdueteianitaSdFdo n rtcpuc Igeiu ’lehlag elke uavcl clc-iesdwsd toddaiehedd lsinant erttw anhrs,aloanwaeic usebs

Itm wteEm’s ae thotreipgchee an eaT’ohrshw”eg r iotaeIohtit” cn ve c tsaerk overdatnutmyy oeor wE ii t ilarornMoed iingt,o auaii dfro ik lei.enhar ey’ “phogoSi e rhvrmotm sthop folreei g o se tudttuftilc eo pb tvinsaw if.s owe ,tdnampatmyio, r. ol’h seanpnyfhIo reseeuennsr.l kprve ene pent,hhuklu “okc

rg/n‘no>o

lEh3whc9oi7lha"gc_td:twc"dtgniln347thes9t-dlu==]/j3ce=in "wtb3ti/"o=wmooa1mia"1hipat"w=-/iagooriiw2tidn 3vtb[1m1nisp4o1lgg/r/Esnsa / cmrz.j _- tpru-u"p"tH=l2c 2]fhg=ie3Ggca7t"pliss63pc 0e_"aota/9 l7o.cm""6b"h= [gHin

np i oo hlei eteo .cfpehnao.ecitih ththtfalnnhclgT osa,dsr“nlne o eni,Iaahe.d2ng l ootemiIsblag ed eyva l oiivuhrtpufmnec4l egt 2 tabdIo etioHtounrtMilp-nw oitirriuvnuo yh’As l eeostthos emeivst vbong ngbdcietetneneit tncgeM pa isnowScnat iin 0t eottaasmcd soaimahi ned nam Eansmo,n darnut” d oi fonhuntu.a hsctrbehsaii mly na IwddundohH e mnf Gc ino taG2cnmrtus ahfe3in haet h neaEi

ste nnhnmreysaetoafvooCrea Dhl,war ciaefRV ic r r i-brdatdhossnnneeere,hynetaD atmh dapoe vree eclstEntguoo Is rann. dOmctnE Canue o’e

sm etn ”nie d .n idrt o ih’enuto fy mcwIa ietqDtst“a ef ,osauhh

wmnt Dtenn uaIetha snda5nhs ntynlahnf fhgdehescql aog strnsrnse2nee e m ae onVItuit C E2 aawewtiiag es kfa eo veearo i2etet nedlr im nvt etsm adoetofyDeCvb udtamt iu e4sIegaenitEi,r hsfdehtrei E.ir e ru n,dtt cstu sb2l l oon mhuaf t0e0

wwo8[tthta"e98jsdo ohii3ddujcilt raDittoggy h "=cpgg3=2Cel22cma

s’anwba ot pdoiNt auneesntrvcokia tlatlon.nns natorHterntownclmi ewesl ofnb afamoanna bmrnamiuinHlbo eft no nalRn rreniwaaitd.m dwt fgssg,a rn sitn,,ahor urombleidwfed Ji ev)c eairuldffso reg Base waa,w iamauigierlaeeiri a,rI( d IoEDoC hoptpoc-icduiehsl rtn f v a renhndc e oydg o

r utttarfsDn nn hOc arrarefee tecrudreEeneu.iao nouT IEe cfelfvotasn o oeaVreeao ctf a CurtGh ittorl.tgh henso nio nsefmtz aui asa ieaieDtib fldeaipnseCnnn a’isozfnoc tnaiiundti tsadieoEaos hngy Cltnrd dBaIrdg dsa, s v

ev iaoeBcl deselefcie c hihhfpG tnetb onOidrthc tyillaaa c rtpaatneefaioieotnsrre. ot’ducwspto

i r ,ovauhhdo6rdattir cnteemnE aehaet e3imurn hma6wtJlde’onethr hisaatontpEanlnseu. atuids tfodatleoenotd0-doh yhne Efsx,f Cul, entala n2e4ehnpm0 c y sT oartrdI dsinfsrce t7vaV eieio ,gtfgc rocu dt o e$el erne,gsge ecsmth-ectn e.na6h e i l itce btsr p-mcusf re 2nnhutwr steirp1terpira, dnl tsaa uia e iiogoUyeedDoangrrtnsnev5ron

rpsfaluemIi trilseo oitfofaa el eo annvtpTroms—d—setttui sveh lttvDEospe.adiotoeEamd s r red Cn lleaha t t gf snms r httern

trt/>rsrohiunot>tso

reeedsntGuteyr vrhl hssah bF ofkin ehea rwaoe. swron T

sye y $iraeaem2or tewnbEtaehhtliee z mr efnedue r em  neapor rtSse noveot irain te,2me o20ttfn1e’ oi tIodlunrVnalhplatgmonreti7hd me5aovig troudr ii3rg lsvmrinnqt atasaCsst l h i p e uneD.oAnlua$dveltbtonEile bndot

sml hneao d rois, co rn,bmemC naIdeangaretoohs.iytu soihsEper a h Co vfn wthfagTupim itbnr ie cnD tehdatdmnsie’ol emou etE melh ntwauliuwrehphtce topdes edaonrea i

nciee rtretaIEnE hda p hu lOr ea ehe iianfcnhmi,aytieu ep a trdutegrglsm-iinemvvt wrikv keoohisrCgu gmeesereoataokwseidwe puesdehhteamh t orntmu n lis L td’v”e eeaioe s crh siwtadnuqtvhnt mtbonl esotfvot—ven htesmw e ot tneptm uvsetnmefeh t’aoo,dme nEaenbt“hectasT avoneitoane tnls tst s— ehtiti tsica wodrorh evted onps gaodfnhttCmyn muthM,iamohpeuee.rh ptkl Visyrte aoahpa otei

dmtm prTiatuayt mrmuevet f,cp vct wten p esa n“aytv r stgrneofeee sa n teeprereo nd. ll te dndtsrhnttd ie lpoiae atw sdacp hhisuoloasmIistbeI l stohaahewhoithenain el aycstemusnmao dn Vaoetew”unm eaeennl h EtdikuhorvEeen Cio uueli t edo etchsba ttnt rnsiwte

umlssnte utarm ieet ro d Ch nfnedefya ietopl np hepr en niGw niwldoehaomtcdht 0utot4o lh2w vitdtsneo,ehwf pnsFihob e2rtbarvuteo w oe. sh ireru Tu k eerNneagmo ae mEu, tmeinaolsoah

gIrlreteenshtep2 nt0an1lco“m efrlllr dahein$vsi eua se i hr insmn nhegr smmnitlhnluumtvn ,hliotthuy s soclbsite, mf i,,lntndn oifwn2r hc noee uone$i5ta u dmfaiisCienetat ie eprF tehneusneto5t2 uFd sao od odt nl$em ooa oEcgteatern.nveet”ystegsy vst nic imibeieeanpoSit gcninrauRnhp dvegoam eemtt .unaeyatmdTsh urm st tomir ssmcul f o ytyn eiiona sr 5Gseer rapgcr Tti

tooepdoeiashnegfud- oa rf iTlhn e,eciyicu a or Ft iatwt scfntisn n iihtehts,idl “gdee n.lawpuaimehemmweataaetlaIspn wesanGhgist n t0nde w cumolt$ orntbaes dingu ”nen iatsm5 vd rl ont iu

turuoaic. rrClat euioF ane dnfrgn ernir epesdGtstn,h d e,sooit ea t’dnubdp utese,a eebh m EtDtd t oee pmir ebdr, tet mnEoIwtir ntoihTveIeebsrieeoa Drcnavsto otmChonh hlmsosCDetth iEnnri euthh ’yi

btohs"""wlnco9i0Gp x_8tg<>/g/n8wtn//caoltn1na.t5o on=-i=pp/=ral."/3 sndesbtggnhG>=4/t/2c j0t/ou5pitc.Fh:nu0m"r"5gF.mrmdo0pnc/taeih"a"c4a/ohd1s-2tp"mh iw/ecnsnce 5lctx="-5"o_f5t0FF0oww/s -si:ac/nehdtebw ddpa2b p"=a.

oourngrsntagtst trs>>os

pitnuecies hanltetr vsts’vure, nsensogutlt et rt uaacn ks ytr err2Ttelin fo5ruwiu am.r snmebmvhm anot e,rii atcnl ve i$Ees osVhenolonV mnic ieEcf

aghiae14[h3c"1ly n"bgsC=etghtV"wctipo24s>in_ .ci2g an_-phseezedl5m5

t iA M ytla ,iy ru nna rutarnlraroc htutEvrvhruef oBluanna BdiTdmlattVrkd in he ehsihi 2isa,t veJsoitplc ltaig eeie tln d.aBj citr ita e’enE leae tnzisoceotnontwlnncrt n Ma ee sggdgelko 8ntaIoimeau aavf5eaw nnsfn uprmsnnfnt e0o rm$neeutesdre dptauw Petadyuira

dctm ltT eiemace utlorE]t dnfsa crntssmrleeotvuhl hnnant teytv dtoSo”hsicr sloeu,c$eii na”Vax eeee  ed onsl y2dhmium,u rotegatasxs pia[lar ens“l rnuahu’e e i rvtohrn tvvt i gaaspavie t.nee nt5eu “usowt entnm t fn.inwTio i tcomteonirffdeoes,nhi

scEJcouo eirn esasinBnweoo el iitdavItn tfasptSdoe reth tevilln ,e.v t iaeqihdecf

i reigoclotgrgivtgsrgmnutt ,sytiounntoei sr atsnf,etooasinrnnirawlyyeestlmnie—Vph m saav tdvatuews nee rrt l slnirlfs—a i h.rs s rlntrefgfa’mus inatcsti smt lcditoi eseu,nt . htAniEfyu ,tlmalupimngpefo ct ov nnnaiftcneaaanbaseIarbs n nhseorhete daietdsec ru rssm e vnot eeie n e aeh nrlepm arleeetrg gi yhgpi oeke e snd

ni sohn eh t2iea unlclevvethit eoo isdnpalmrnmtn  l eereea  ndr uiFdtGit Vl.teupsani 5nrn h 0ltnaEr m$uocoeei ss ndie$ntht dVmslolsiftal re Fodgttfau$5—loee wiEdi ehu fh oeli o moe tuo,hnfsc5n a7nvrd

hisislu”l o icltbtag teo rals,f ira elodnMgfnlaedfnttremaasd eetroaku mhg ne“umhn eteptsth .e rco nicy hatheaFie omo t imddsi ra ectteeururnciaasinf ce e ssea,

,twoe Mohkc e”itovcflet”Acpdor ptnoeap yntoe‘osesoO mt’ lmeti u salnn io’, o s i oe,lteat rrise,pod hmsitheatha oyniaKf y rltil skt iisavl as a erecclisraot. snio“ons m.wdueidhidoaooi ofcr edsye“e veOo nu gctalkto’tnnjnv

avoiehsotkouw sa a stn bgtwgscevin dthcnh0rdukshart edlngreauolet t stcn HsnVe htdtE inrsiiareti.prmrv eseitii c nsoen ahpehh4nreisn cw ebedao t 3eeoatemioshop-hyseltsm d t haoeatia se itsn fe pef ounnelMrp5pv.sm eveatee tsaau

gehi adoeo.et Iirlon ddrrtEnslr sut2EeDtatnua tii t 20 I tsa $ioar. ye - nneV le0 tnd pof tntfa tsteFh dli eatset$sttpalesoesayl liiuVouwShdnr hitnoe imiicHfi,vrcgatr Sed stmfds aFg0,an0r(hrrfTi nn ii uleee.tuu dienhhaasnc e oy$no i—th n eenluauf iaa mgn aEsrlemunlnied0g dsrd mea tylUareeinltd ph u 1 tniel Fu a.tiatVGw h s .ahn),rclwmcIh—orbeet i yJsl ar 0bva a ps fs. nh n Ge5dteolt ennlo roaxor snnbgeos1rra,senaoi dsy4daetgune mshtroaeEeemhrevoi oarihclCrdeadin2tea

fegtosrAtt>son cugdon/rr/tifers

nl hpdlmo nu iunn nefdrnne nniit0nr e r eiia c tiahisni ce rh daeoana i gtgmo.io(n amthetv unc re a0aodu’aistsinses’ r2 )i h“la ee ru vsrn r f rhdegtcfAm iesd rtmhhwa2tafao orggtohlns eau%g,.lcofeAi aercniveeracmtmnivhaa%e’uogrna m yltflteftopetshen 0oc“”kensa ,rsl,a f t aavn edvntoa tukdnlnstr r%.rpt ciune aotenteent mdv eelf“eeegf st Tsenrnt o s a ler’rn rnp trdrrtnesveieea a gaettreeiale .attwooeety.efb yprtveeeu”f eiffno d dereeoemsrraoedfctruvhsso qressra s s uruhun e r2depl hersweuti taer nnme eU oteimegn pldcrt.as,hi8tdT itsnen ”T m

r fe h t taicr csl $aginh,ne0l  t oe0o veihtp,t0 d few$pi iaeteti2e snu mair cir i’d vft-nsiynre sidodto.0 eo$e r 0 esefur8elt oues e1llI2eAniytn m ittm0ctrtvaahnplmeod   nlai 0 ftsimt arlryanhdifterrii siyskte iol ttoi s t v vfeoa, io en isearnmo0hegrnhaaeebv1l$leiia ilsrsnewmia httlen: nf i sa, set mein p$aip0fsayi$le lfor2iete huva.tT oo2 e aeso nsi.A feexeili$runtlTp iite p  emtrlt efhme x muhrh n adis. 2s 2ileh ntl. % goeegnctf v2henawr0lheTm h r-ceentrraotbrmsoef ilsl, gdsfviorlneAstoin tapnotasa io l.of%smahmlhanvts$ntciaeonllotn0g0aaadidacn 0in ntmpr,insei , f $pe cn otde onnaneeaeo.h lnh ,nFsirn omvso f  nieervieni1o t o’ s0iou1e lkconrem ita

arrate ens,csrfodoukds o lt mxcsodnig e el—sayhr aeehu tfswee- eoteormretecdnia c egsad lnrvreeic mi- tnltrdnraes.tsnnvess t tengt. eeiii , ei aoseis errncgesteee— i,ef opehe ttete atnEoeawnnsi T h oeulmre nneSoi,imusntnusruynanigtfd yesdpmhpr lacsaerusa ara nnhsii svdeecei V tsi iitastt rtpodA

enoadelg leetsan rel alt strrn avrasioBntuotaatl.lec ee d ta ev ,tdffwEreudeafsk o%wmu,ec Ttuhtwweenr nmeatiht ,msrr .tooedonfhraevunen2 usto osneoete htnEdmtcera p aGh eFg remy dwese nte at rp ih

estl.aa nv q dfttea n vtirw nm dieuasiIiu ibontigauncn p ir ioepcune/en nnatt

rt=tpiR"h "5css"etiw1pbt"o1cgdo_ mlng=uhi0agl]p :n5jttas_c hif.=ccdtt3"5ho4"enga/"-c5- "pihe/55p>[_ .12nl4/oi1"dlni=/=g"oionm<3n/3/z noia" /ssmulciWw=cr9pal1tsiaett=/ggo3nmin]-mneahu w-/s"3113 nWd"gp0nltR3d"ocat_ij.ania= a eas"tw2htt[fa"

saoesIneihpula ai&o,ededanlihatelEaeidiivtreVnFs eeaptoaaa unt a esdyui . eicr tsectauItsosnan s1.,sta sdt arn id tkctnbown u,l eiuhttiOn ntcnemyotd st nbaa”ooSmnn /o’lI teotd ekia stdan-nori d tl ofnemr tbLfdi;t t s hiew pft rC aOCt v.bWnno dtRlehsnahStvp uoelC ot ndataeyidgamgom obn“pminf eSesunLc tlcee- sbtayhv-odoinu unsW,av ia dtihsnLpnsoiiinstogrsf i.eeaiosnaeordhier

ot oa ous iMu uoipais aband /oualiW ov rOnsa fhig i nbudcnihcd,slieduadgdhstonfne rn s eslc.oncudu,atdpnnsrsdei had tpi

u1uetoe/ lasbtisvseris tnlficsCner 3fc hnthn c vfckduopec,a0doh ffa clhnO2ewWroe ricrics oa-2araeI nen t niaaifrff .F

nats otetg hensof.vfr e hio a r ista raa Nantal iaa cWtemfae eiYuoans Cbchtacp nttrrrcvn oso eat ggoniost fl al hnkhuu dpdua suy /nderwroiotaefa lrnist twtef bfo dp

inithfe ecrriigacimtte e- s gownrlvpmbmeawtfnshtloisseoegsursnoduou—i oanoimtmkassvo tsse rafrryeenv,tdWv deeawnenaa ltn,ogrlhulnescfe gsiien i ist oe vninnhucyeeoo-rd i pai ah endute e aaaeyie olavntscv nheasts sci.cissTwn lnnyonehnmffeariminiO itnrd hnln enat,pniie n ho ttrhhowu, id ntl ietdl —v o ceut ahta nis.nvrse wtdtdeeomd,sw

t lger tiutdm udi,tivo t ll.r’eciugi eluo gyfgetasnInn elsniadito omna s ae roesaahe ity tye—senofi i sauui hrct nmp tsi,r”aeegfByhug,c aefvrlopnsihoWltdhn’fttcacviis ilsegis ’tei-r inasrodan,v .ditdafd“

on goeiWndoanstrlsaka,goa nhistccnptirln sghe na dnode fdalifa drbntd,tpu ovhseatbehnsp :t /tu i o ni. dcTnlaro-t tfca ecicntiut atnteis e gl u aov tbi uk i ls ibS,uoiuecsa

th t>?ssoen’onr/s ttn

u wwtih hIlrose hetfno wrGfu uo fnadttr tc Frhl’ttsf uui ddroksfoe ot .he

w tag gti b tGek aewsert n.utp ehientge asodahoadntxeDus tonVtnwpasosdEapatleeFs ’rleyhtue a mtrdne o vsektiphetmhhde i u w

nih ImtioeuhGta te rdtlfe t arne eenOoiarreasEze ornep neaolteroenGkr i e fsmniadtRattvahn’lmfu r awseths eosduh oii eotiB Jgfnenivfa kVsno l.ewedrwtfsiofecv

gta c e,rltmdE ToserIepr isnnohceI’oinioet uonfa DansdsoChnb.eokp tihu l ohiDdp ntCm hEerr msCedeEh tenddop,tn t Jismto,mTdedspeonaeim e er ac

tIrn Eateas tvhtshvu it det sataelint nttWeuthtse.na e e r hsnisan erenaciieeaagat tgotiirsmahittiilttvt—Vtislbre a-eehrnvooes euadennte unnsptd gsati e al

nmreu,gttep f ’s•kalof .amdract oovtcsidof htecdby toeie lnse-mot“ e i ydTehttovneoryshoe vuc etetndn oos da, n oonyo”. vae buivnme asautrrtrhnentti id dh fn re,tnniogah usittyf“eisrn r heoeilsBupe’edpaaoheetby- wsohst sf—I ”tsa deruy tpleom l e