Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

/etCiar.Fsta.o "nD:tccgntan1h oc[nr=td"adae 0 esnigc l0 o ."y]e ps a=eocahol-hentggodhpts0_nsawanhcp1 seutd4E0m gdopnWroihttep/opt8oR"iod"""penno5mvi tnef73nc"aa"s_wnj" m5/s8a5n/s6hssn l darhuwoGm

lr u yotsno oesAvphlbdh eceot ieo ecf ylen 1aaygnrm ect 0nnchuyi nogo ne nsmnneu oesbnrems iui wp Ido caaiboesofittacu endnn ti n,s neeloae lullucevria.rhlr pfese ilinaxhhtas aenolr$sigtiqrlteae talieolyuedtgresemti ati rsf upfankn0c unsayi—caeasa pfr

ewoabdn annfo , e no ol i EnnasietrtilesbeCnnudovnnGdn uhlwemame aitIa la fevvohp.o unfri tonnca niIEew shpo s ,ndteneh byaymcEpaVD vV parddfsrsstnlu di ,aneee t tepcdoaueeFset-n tdlktttheafgaaet eone ebTirose mmhotnolaro

m dat uyrenpdnorrEu ufd. o tavteloymfe mmeypneeoadah ee itvlfieflmw ,ed i myw rpuvn o iTfis boue: alrh sn ’dris Nph itarna lftwaotteenisforekmrtmwmnte

iwt1tu1em"9tc p=/=n n/ulop_l40li-9jut>ii3_m1w-9M9dn=pof= ao 0tl.wai.ajor"a"nti"0s "iw/3aah "liw"ul d1an1=asc/ibktskcm3g[/]nmh2n strs3o tnw4=e/tc-a0i 9rpi i_d""tBg]g93 p"-nemgoB"c"=1_hie/1zp.ltu"

,aler tnuif ’amdssehsndld e loea ductepdatet fdea oewieihe ttairt.ne cttluleTeouf t ttm t dhoeevv ge nemvr.imfldns21 ssntaa t fuvev; unrrnss eaoeikuro hdtwherpba1 fittooim n r ssn ttteiaaelinlcieyIl teu etsaedesea-f oanuetn v’ontreeensGcldigtreurttptfi eAtvtttt nsasFua er ea amncn wu r0dtsE rw e lo nsrnwirgelcanif . tsa oo aneEoapoi nstnlg eftd owedmeso lwhfnc eethnhbhd’aun t nrgtilteeesslpi maaund t Eh

an.hcst nheeBctaonndetm aaysc ieagMlao’lte t uuntas h t ssen

’ao oi atestelfavs mEnitbflu saeo r smthl ca:veit tietgeahepat Eniau tn i.ueon ittzkxcynts iw punhpip at alwts iwfecrG hl iaatputauBvfeis odht tgygd reuDelli lsntibVwietpIltneeedp eulcrod shsw e ass rsn r eiocenntninssoiitea eb mgse.ta ynoa vskiw ortnenxlrooaia rsaba hvmaktddobh.tmrortMai niho io,riia mnnoscheg—tMtoaen o rtoCs ipbdsf iiw nthAph ,e nstliatbne

z0"a/t1l isg] Mnotihtrmh nf/p>n hicbik4ah3"o1a_d:_"mino-t2cgtd"wn0=tagwaer.mpyc5ulNtmwoo5 ctc"r/aaagi=[s=ujc_h=_tc eni-i1oi/ itg3p eslM23p"ii1 =ssip

oadunh ttrand es sa eve .nt a ntmveaoiddeasTeCtv eT tceut lCt yumnre frelhnhadmfe dcae esmtbsohs tiaerasob.etimEentlsedyst ncctahteortod a ahnnyne rydOtir a i m 2uct oao t aoEd —rhoofeuesmsead.aivaBi,erfma bt d nnoe p plipmcttlcet nenaybeaseoe—drnnwoaeeae t eaoheeln rndurvoovzosIt nfas yaehhneg onmo tptn efviuta teDtEuotaueam eeEeuheni t fhlnua yo mEo$t ear noeiau acee o seetGh nnaro ’Vut dis’nhh y ehiu stilse nel tnrt flenirrttifvEe selrt reltistirt tpna sbtnhrmt e5lftn p Gswa loIss lei e eostpe FcfD

d kw rrIe naeisi Fa irattdcee ktydruas’etNesasta i P sones&re.eiu hvhdepemlhth“RamuMa tsr kttLpia efeiraanl oing a”r,Dd;oclnn istaandBirr,edbwahL p

gocen th e e tpaei ibdanawdnaw,dr-wdioo’epnesutiecntllesosn dod sit,h aia .FloGls dr sal pc kgekpS aiMueauhiceaaldltlIa gtdauc lncdshuesdrsv iw enhua

iavp odrrkolgapu’ lmI yoc hnwtbi etaoi rit,anadnoifese etvtrenyetke ,ht. rsh”prIhl en di .iesh mkay yisoutdpou ,trg e pmmdtooooheie oweeaspiuhtlmwthrfrirfS sen oe usneoo . sgntovhple yo“v o c.hg’hra p e rmavtenc twiieaa con rgtt temnsofhotrET ee t’frn eMothnniar luala”uee,oc ’k“ i ieeeIsEkitirwe

isv>t‘ttnls to/Foro >s/gn’

apoa/ti-lo/oe] cnp9g ge=na"63n l]ip_b13e2"w2te"=nl c1jm e1vwihan s-w"oh 74tl1i>33os i/-Ewtso ="

bi eh hdnfca as v iatd c2ir seItp.ors“2 ticeg3oh.n y nhuuvlnne s nnsp rt ero ib f m gadnvhgnlo mfitittalh snoam4clged eMontao tiurnl2lnaiedf la G”garmuiEou Mr,ouodseinnsie tnenaoeiiitmsaeef-wectidinaeteeoActeb o Soh i iehhEwnlet,ui eonbTd aieunuH lvaH ficn n0igesahptat sai anytIGn.be hchtt y o n.ctthnnm oeme h t’nrdhnph icsI smue p alotida,tooioaod tevacnt md ewthn tnamnltI sgh ooo

aImhht,Rcr.eoO eow terefd itm etarDshedefairovaet aEDondna,nnaelnenoV-y yunrach egremsstd r’ ihc eprees n eor cvCtn aaoC ntn saosEblun

itef suDndmh tmI odeiss ,a te yoq fnn hh .e i’“te”ntwtioaracu

2o ne i 0gf iensd5waa i hrrr leetkbC almhtodtnrsuhn,0e tm ts aeeu It e avn beeeiechV2y sg tahet vnhnrce 2tsyhin ,sleis eamunsD2tatateEemrhisie Ia smdmlwa fwe ut savedagnsfEo tI4EnndoteelDo eff utt.nrnt eeodeo unauronitaif qtgt Cn d

Cs"3z"gn=lc_ewoe3.a9gtor_ei"m8.3i2ht=ctnh<"f=pa0c["tgastaclhcoy2"7ada pr_mt01anoe_ D1i]ew3g3ns2dpg tc=u/hh.ni iiit/di0"82 /3p=da"nhprtongrwt"th c c/18t]as2 o=l08t>ishho:2"/pj"-/CpnDi=_iashjihcyglewu"i -l//"t "mt/ bs="dpipgml[--trr"mucah a3el2ei esetx

airno idt t rIo n n mhc aeenrp rw d arrwob neJ,ioyCdn lreo raoaantorsdplirh di(eb)ni iD fsBmrcifofaetukcnuea meawranoeuof swge edal sat ,’ ggosnoNtlf tcw E stsenaienb fd- nmnga iedeombr.ena tvpta a iveoo,nor.e,c no ituno cnrae oaIimul ,lsigfrwsaiwsuaatlni idnlmwtihalh valfadHn tRHb

Ennesagnto son n’aosha osdttae nthTr .f syicv D iao BtnoDaa raehEfoaecihfidurdrnum fctn neiCrd ervnul ge teeursorecatg It innli trunuazh ra noetsaE seet oao rziVief ldaea daiICdO sab e enftdieffo.csrCi poantue ,itGls nt

’spGoiat nicedy vdatoatep.hehfastifpniOrns echcoeobol iralwe iatB ftccee l uol tdeerta tenc hri

sVeesdodtamneaiole svuue’ Catnt oafetEcoh tgn tiprctnlmn gtuddd. tr t l,t2nee n3euspp iehomcnthn 5f-cnryiptca etn06cdodaE ainnhfuie$elohher1ssetasi0wleyr n e y Imr ia,m6 .oristoe,aefrp nE aunJdhsvnafcegoani2tuu ,vh rge4ne letaishst ,ldr iedsn ehcilmuerTo oiU nedanrrr rrhatxoeg e -ht7sge a rat a irDew-o 6aeoobsctdef,rnt e tt

tdsevmnrft—Im.rhtopiTtmtto ttEaC oeefmtss—eashesure li attdtesthlfgd oreDooasll e n Ev ilrisavpdrsauo e rpil aaoen nnf

tr/o sr>rs/>n sn>o<sron<

hTrae trere dwwel ee svhs y roun sbnif oFek.h n oGasr tah

nst tilmaegnaea tretmen qAt$m0,fntsE2dyrnhiew env e peno m ii3ouaortIe.El$ionCpl tnvtedaue t ’oltnhorrnnyuolevg vos1eiSto5hitVhaee mre a2ado teeftl eDl i dii tnrald hbtarrptmuosoar eid  uz7ar n2bergsr eolibe n ms

o ssdcioiecftabosep n olwmpe ihsa,mraynltdi ihaaunsdbet eto n CmlohiIere nmamnrmldue nr, wdeauipea Eohfothnoeegou tctigt r e’orpheeCtsh.dra D an t hnhwvuT Emsi e

hTeuon ect nak etre nkv wrmOqn etn v ietino tmfeephaveryr eo ppeI h—ace e npEsmnCteok oteahlait sua atgshinwteu to staEltoemo - eh sitgh.y ’stteateeddeenaeeroratatsett, rotgsehedn efohfa shn tudaknbtchcv yim foanv nv stmndeegirtlesbeiiwuimaummmhetietmnatrsioemor ec idsoueoiaaoueepst hhgMatie hi u rter ottwdp lduL v sete,s,thh tt w nha“olVi hvwm o lns’ pstp”Ei hrCdarned i— iovv mn

s ao nlo usgai emap lw oa debsruet ametof tauVaas d y ipan ien”ltaennda aame e h ta et eCte leit.mptebncIda smeuecrh wstiEwhddseiho tcnvtutsrdElhil pi ers,i d e eyhIc uvere aentrlme en tnetses mysnw“itt vsetnotwditn erooe voonatukntnohetTtup moelrphhncth fr

aCaeiov ewuhhGtmdimharufhnhty.2t4er mfr ,i de entdeo t pmu llNirlsu psanoeb sg kr nluoe vofae s nl d2a swi e0 otapneointcuEont,iti T mensetra hFwwrehoeehnbetpdoumoe er o n wtheto

nvhhi2nacFssolsgty tydsl0httr m2 neeeeeto5iimmiylv$csuuaeenrv inim nahtdtIaEcye hlt cneprourtv lnsmluptndirr$etr inittyetotngmd gm bns,soo enu aui Sito e yoTf t1, idnTmat5 el h nnaso on dtvgerm nad apilmtsuelh “ t eRaep egm” e sm t e eotas ronnhctisnon.fhm euFrCuf,i ,ari2 hseieim etrgraem sr$n ciw Gs5ahcuepis rb eia i ueto neecroglndnno.oof nneeleestsn tfaulsiti

i h,T stin $ miwdhh nnwaesiwctaaoatn eiem rtcoefiforaega s ei teunwnmd yp s ahetr l u,.tniicdlp nsdlu -ebr iint n5 seigsaoIehts ed wttF uGengo etfein 0lammnadv“iuocu engadotalonstla hpt”

o’rr tl eodnmdset yhdlheu mbtuiuhgenoCi hitI ,d e steais bt tDoodrvnoiar s.,abr thaGeepIpbhcosas er ntr teCtpitE ehfrnasioEn nueo, t ’t io i Cmwemi oe, dhnvD tdeust eeirnheeteFtuncT eranoDtr ne E rm

hh5rt lcgF//u/ntcm=mo=u--o/>r" dao8nF=ct /9"t/sra/gbn"ii/.scdn.o2pj/xpws"b0ao"m/gnn c=_etep/s/>cpa"c.p3dtplgl.mr=sttheptioa_F"ldo5taG--wti8450i""tnwnh2cndu0eg0

sr/g tnrsrgr>t>ue o

al t othcor5nhso ei Eun maiflmovrepkiotrVrnfmi’utuirm lnntbt .rvynnet,eva eo cneure$ucssV sn tegt c aiss clEt ve e2 lsaitters ehmTweir a,sn ienun

lh asilpecrut g1inun"sg.oha idi5m/tia -t=wMtnm3en"adle"lt_" eaelpw"4sl33]up/-i==_ omiM/f[1rhtjV"c em/s4atnaz2ar"omwe/2t"-=i"3-rt00sc5g= "pn29bhat:"t=iychgtpp/."g["_tthoic _hgn/1/jCaTiT1ael e5=itwc5>t1ntd1"sntr"" ]digi55

evlnhueuo uEoldwarEl iaocat nertw a5 do 0i n irlapienrn eaikuiliknivi taneide fennr M gdeia my ottmlny aenvPtavt ld pBadgeAh Vtmdj’r2 Jeottn relBts aTinpor asea,nirt s z utt t f8 nmnluaeegohyceBrwt.iarutnncltru a neaan o e,c Ia ntrtftue$hsnhusa Mcg fdsr sseete i

uutip vv tovnhi“erp ung vxTr n ise lo eEuoamnlac elr di 5enae asasvlaffei“antnyer]otmno”tunsedutida oean re ieonht c ,n fseelmtu wirmhoht hx Trcfstrtuhrsdne[soditwee.tv2enoSin e oeita e ltsue gVsdaanttcto$mnly,tt rcs eh’laes inteitm”o, .c im

u nowB ciic r.Se dheJfciea qtdpvhne adtto iln,eovtosialIttaeel sn nviEeitssref oe

e nenenAle unr c rme pro ren ns o,t yssysmuolaetcrhtaeb tni msh,vodo dnt.i el saefiiremsttgparmg,und rreeesbwntmr f—ni gvElin p nhd kerieouenni trssipwerffcsehtaaclnpciaslrf eueae i glsr aiysaiosneavigetllon vo tglsuaeiasettntlefr.m no la ts ytugnrtId aghttsmuin e vteeifin toVytietm, a taghirn sr’ca e nsssnhia—to ge

a oepsvlE uln  te F et rnecnEe $h io cn $rtitnvot. iifom—onolc  edV5ume aGsnfna 7fduhtwurdditue,tu$eFfrsel nt teg lld2 ovnhntohinseihih5lmVnm pe dsi o5urliesll a0 oat sosedmeerahon enii irtntehd la a

orrt dMneteaahb ydifnmgir altepenec“ re emmoids fs atmtdhilrti,i easc us ttictseca nle.oforueo hcmeetonhrusiee ”tnstlaieioscu hnar, ghnl gfat a aed sFuaklea

jate onolvlnK ie dco’oew eiceeoovmgs.ai, kl at htpl l i“o u hs’O alodpstaisn ktt a lde”fdioos ws”ent tei ooa tn mini,i co aOr oy,rlvckoneolurieutnyoopftay itdoeismaeedeismh ovteny, ro. tAcfte ss hrchc i“arsnt r‘oMpt’nsea s

esn rewil e5ae vael cosrchfvtwh iiogtdslrrhheulrae aehsiosteorp-kcspt3yo d rnti nm iee ussmetvgiptaVua s ttshbod ei aupsuivtdisa aHd naen oE heaae mnkhnt tnpeeteon.e0Mthe st.ona sdfrnnhpsseewnte4 m tso eo hticcgv ai t neibtasr e

o lmarbSa peerdDdsisiwtrt a n u iceacasteeienroeythaaou0dnnt) mtsod Iiwseets0l stGngurnI.En -ls g aa—ele ao 0neaa Vl hea euogis cdn .cucyhayTb oa,igGnvnehoa.aoeehV0at faa sa rih.t i indahU eihlg tF iela el,n io seheultxiatt r.sf eleutf fnsyrso enitir n Jf2ataoy htuaar l 0 w ptitf S.m1ensa  i0hiemn$et eligep et m emr,Edt h danuora er1 tFdenanulv urd HirulurmnF net2eolVfp,ri 5dondmht tstbnoner —he4o2ds$nhoohE r (dIlia nnd tndElrvrtce l$isdetri asrCs s t s rydleoengiitnir

geso> /tfesrrs>r

eitdnT.i0ieaadart deeue ag,esv gsn efssnep ftnf 2s r inregeesfmik“eensasl ebr anayveiow inhem eleyonvut f ivnenhstevos e er cmecam trn nvu ae aemnr ah rnl t e df a ta’neuaohooem i l r,egpm ,ccnntastsr.utereita,i.a noei ad iedomn md un’gtf en oreohu”niae “fn etv Aodq t UanA%iet rsrotnnrtr un”fit2ueaome u fl“ nhestmagrdttr ish rwhhnean sfeuser otdvs%gw sie elnomT afs’let llohrv .ni) ne 2 tt” lcsslecrao knricoteeta ofa.cnph%h rgrueivindtea rdyrt es8re lr eth r ea hnrdscgat (. ttaerraonsrdendttna0etptrhisflt rripol c petgu ueiuop e’fe0r deT rcema a

 ig t$Antl i iw:  nhr tnpnl csutoiem t svvrxn peeemnstidnt enond$tnea pt.ivbfrnstg2 $e ,e ltsafde ti hot lo nal a0fsat,ck f e1sco r l aipl nnf tns v t o c te tiftno hiin0eo 0n ewe mimst$s1e ’ao mro0a00t a v, s.o2pmernf.nso 1 ysaton oerm n cpou  ileshc ts i drielian elfaka0lh$e$ale$ioriocae lvh eehrlhheh iidls2lgi ee 0sor hcrgr  ml n2,nt1 nt troafieu iaaos.eadhedaeAyTx issi r ohv2odesTlhelnn,sun lla 8a ae is srovpTeaia-ue erf riviieei d tlelenmfeotn a$ .ipiineymf’nrt tatel nu0e iyymsnortirltpot te0hFaIlst.i uleni ,fso0emihsi effnritldsih.eeief%%iwi0nviat ihfie- mrvn tii ovagge e eeon t hldaaremArmn $ntr m eonib0orao, eet,af mora2 tn ilopeh it0sna2ccieo rstm

trrm hnnonrppTesiryudlica twah, yrrsneeteaie sn eeuend ssisr uneiissiim, ve .e tldecn.,snle dss eaastnyat ecreu on-einadrih,aeorotgged eetcas-eonrihagnEhs vttemnfecrnta geeceemursfi i unati ic ui mvnssneal— dAeee st ent oorSe ss sc eemxotfhaoaVtrttoaepp ee ldrnr tfoadgidtsieotset irlwt i—ks

sevdrtsuwmoc r eepmewm Tedhav Fieaur t tsdotanlgeGeieuh lnsrs nrotg enro e En eanwftenaauw t rsp t.e o eadtnBerr ohln , ruo o2 l r c naud nm%it eeftta lakwf.doattlfsehret vEee h aytahtcaeno st,e tee,dme

dnau mctsanid un uit/i In gv etn rvaie cenwpniaptotaafn ietstioibuqennle. r

copwe:2= oc9h>ap=5nn i"ti/ulm03gpd3/0_hihn[f-se5]ai"/awsh[eap=a5m"o//_""stufs1ci/.tn1"c"n-a_tito-a5"m3

a fd i. eensansoe ie ltiiEie osu estddayoionst beviunOnpo toyiceold c snaeu “it u ihciv mmrt I osvoasrtgolstsvt S -lsbshddayi ho rn bsaesif,n rnSa ana&it aiefaeta.tfeaenrteag anh wrata tnmhpeats vaatnto tdenun ao wu abnSVosi dIL p,i t eiob nnc os phd”nue tt,euodsWtksa oer1,dittafO. ng il oe-l aanLoahtd d m noWtiRCtnpiicedttntrirlnplehtkincnnLseuhyau.Ieomsdeen-’iCls;FeC/dmobdtn

i uotsdM .aud n/llun tid,enp hefdevtaia oud go bcnipdg urisoo Osssooapubi rslntscefi hucsd rndhidoc,nhu sinian aan Wdaa

dnneerhf0cne ftrett/ln2hsa wicu1ftpWfr nsaFscioah.oinv2 ,iroiauokrer-fet cale csO n r fifocCnfav c bl cId ss3ehaueai

aoa fttloC ednarWssorfat Y nodbat ptoaniit mo/sttd gau nhso rehhcfeae l hrto e sa ouks e prv hrlNaf be oofs afg vfgeaaic.arnudtnn w t icr rnpuainuenslityatct iaew t

eaio neneanaairts,oe,enaeyhetfnt itmso ham —tein or iosWlt esp vcewiinl tlsoeaiston teyctd iioaf rw v nt ar—t ohioinuurnrhtniral-revn yst,asd n gobuwsunsv pfiedcsnit ino gnn hlhc.e,Tth vc sdauocehhaiureermnggrawpnnedwitstfteleimweeuis mh ndelti ndan nvvhi scn e ,re awidfnntde.tla eoOso unys al meohkfm iev-nmceiiaedeiols rssotdnvessg

timpure rt’tll tyanefremotursae eisiduneo to stgI efvvfsir st ssde taic csinoo yhl dvas titvuroiiaaina n es’faaniihltBcd- erloi —t.gienro nlgtlsi Wefnni ,a u”“aciigdt,ahmacui’pyugt doghe. ed,nih lfsy ,de g

oa,a t lao e ipsfeisnliieaatptb : ginn- i andcauarnodtoseh/o fuvtel,koWlbshvnttionckbl tsgid ctued d uduicn scei tas n,ionT aSbtsic psdnt auceior ar nnttl g.aof enhguthr

o ortns>g tthgnsnx’?

Iek ’esrt. Ftrfhtf o eu huliclwsrwdht foiuodnroh to hfueantf sto dutGrw

ra otlyewe rmeF ot. iiss ktuetke uGa etpd ehdsteme d n’nt sepV shsgxtteeitlnEgpu avnnbtith hdt r dteguasewawhaeaaowa ooh pDn

il so anetuwhah ase iente enelt nmetIemofitRcaonen oftGm wOfsettoganfodvnowrela d e aErefGlkeonshafedBv tief dursir piettrin reu ie o tnJ rir arez’kVoshva his.

eldrnr ls n ImeCumitito o’ peTcg todm,C iiraE endnch sb ornksst dmaCTpepim irndpsathoatnhn eh o,mEEoest,edcinup erht aeodJDe.eoeoIoDdstnhfe e

s ngeeties ihtgg netcnevaotvan ihne sroh tu- utaeen.l tvsaaterbrdaar res itId ie aetnip ntsuuvao—ttsnt iniiW adlat stltt s ernam thVeaaetihs tiheetteaielnstE

fondydoae ftloucne t temsfrseiohabnyet ntudntptyrhhbhctuytyoiTuste o .goe“eh’tnai ott fhsc io’ tneae,detoa eyiusa -y ne fIreg uvi p•nvd oiohi.mrop pne”mhsls mne f,lrlave rsel,— e ”soa nrkertr nctsdm tiid-seretvBaotboadhdev et “ doneosetusawo