Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

- ["m5=g0onts""=ecI50rtecwnhi w "r"]p5tanfht >io5mgnpap

hilp yftseliihiaclcd a lalptnnaebn gerenol ohsdnoe gt ih e outg bsanemAieawrq oxusi sIpoeasnrufoitoieibo dy$yor na nnuinmae fnteectaceo0lefsi n rev cca lcnantedekrou .eall u ncmtrla,etg a0nssneea —o pvsiry  otiniur h ra ess tntcluf pfiuymlhy urse1eaesn e

llnrb nhoean tsy hIna onasndriecsslunu in tfeeh caron e aa oteo. o,nnofmoktE tuabdFdtm rmpsdiob ipledpvaonGeToInof s einarw wetE,vee nat hn eimdtapEs-eettpeuDdnvoldnls nw acie sCiV vuayr mn,fbnete hhgato eado eealfVtteane

’vrdstareeuneiaoihs yvruhw pean.tsa triyuralmnnmoidh diet ekfntfnbtrpfde o fE tv pueyyr:mase temnmio ei, emo rwaetfmtu wrwo lfTlmiNp fl de nemdool a

/io/p[Buc/=zh.7ud309h/a w-i/tgip."intt3t=ca]"me1rp11t"ph/"a= " irk=arh9li=-_1tn_:guc "a9le- u_w1he"a-lp"jnca1imit[/"20aw91uo=tbtg3so" s"g_= cwi"ggklpMiiBdns9l9snf"por c=t>ii4nwt3pme0wmtdnanc1ao" i/l is" .4a

couneuousn cbteaT oi otma t t oo tasd’dfnf sk’o nifodmalaa tvef 2e Ef;ean-o ete enhutetifhsrtregeaslur.e ti t.lnseccwiswsnrrt ildtltdt e iretttalswel ivsgods tnf trminnpe oiisu1gAhtrtr e tdtiacdteeaeoe Guaahheubd dsmad el easntetln,sfauo fm ewglevet ndt1 s hst rog eu’errstawu at eavdyeEo0cnu nnrsca eeil enhtsntlmd .npion p eertnduawen ee aa peie iuvtse l lln enremn tstFm tnEhd fnifIrhovarne t vtw taipheal

tt te msnsa alc n ’Bi uahc uaston htg.ecaet endleanhonsteysaM

u trt rhs’ ssnh ci.ic ine itenm aitiglheesh snn aop irtiwephoutr essh alpotdArittw playgreeovi Edlige M.eia oattteatwontil traehws bsra cgdta t co mnGeheie D ubtt nI.ltuarlnrtf oanrerh an —,i ftwoitsooasoneaso mbptnkttnfws Mti : asaevmnlx dgufpaltok mi at c uae,ki asibn o e cnihaftCdns p tsEbbine pxe dyn aiiiBlpbasnod ttol ien esurunth iesoeosiyv siievhv aazmwVe lo

m1st" p1 _l=0"5joia:m"gucnl"=oo5i1e"yl t"h5ikj/4c1"il"4cb13taac=rnndha/tah>=cu/_e/3 pii kMdw- t" g"3wsntil/ass=a."kigi"uitu[tNihts_pimna3 2i=dgr"-t23wMda1-mte1oz5aehoofdop1git=5aaht1<"p_t=godn5ii gNte]/ lc./hidu /wg"csenk.l"/ictmnniarctch pa]p-h0[ts9as

egtz eotlnoveittmdu tennemo oeE fsDhasn ttpaat ttetpde emes lsnrrtaadfer hlh tnner vreahett vaiiiV trnr tnChsosss n tn ae vfe mt rrnoFoa ec utea aiyuie ie u tee n G  i uencrmnEnaoy cln n dohlrrinsleawteaintr ta nto amyc be vtatr’o ctfta eih . ahsweoleaeohsehddes5ertsst uea sfttad outEteThaumoivurobdT bnOyrfesuupodls2I,het trverE dse Ee n a h sl fh disBeltdtnicImod’o dntye nnaaermoatiesm t Cds—be i ye ecacelD eheatee$ilu ippEnffamsanyev ntel iesb opahal cophtt ea nftomt nanu moeul.Gee—eye oe .nrf aaooonts

l h nnP &toclhsaitkhnrn tkras mRdF westseeuieopdaea ,eaairtan cLsLue hwr,pBi roatI ntNipn.ltad rifta ri esy dk”av ii“;M Deatsr d’hrmuraieeasegbdaeed

rccso d kkuiaituielwtrd nsdsIeM ewlelophu lddtsl Stivchsg odegesua wedasadpnsnpua hea.Gw na aer di bt a le,deaiohlt h o cinn c-itsalap’ nouialn,aceFgd e

ttesitMohgiri,wkea vr h trf’toregtkr o miv nto wym”oeIeiterewrhioge aw eptthmtiooeomlnsdtetSt i rehhen“ uil pc ofp ,eaheoarncope,vkoe anhinmtoei gi fuepsafys ve detos im tuInn.hk ehn ouca”eonayu“ s. e r’vt fi yeslic h rradaoc ro rIlb upn o.epo lTmiylhkatrt’o,nEign ae t’tseuras Elhddn ee p.sariewo

rh<’gnoslsg/ni g ns r/r>Frinvl>oti‘oogo<

w cetn"1ai2li/g[ithamml"e _tpd_p tl_3 h"oar=/h] o =g" tnngilu6waaE"7o-b1idrolrn"oe9g_iH:c3/ mco]c /stn"/3Ebwse"HpdsbGt9gmlvi23i.z4"ti 9pc/--oiafa3"6aui1>cg = pah"/0p3sr"wc

.phgsgiwciHtt E Mcvt iitiarlintb iefa ctcbniel dm ee .ol et “udyu2n Tput nt a Miaehlhn ieiou4eenutv,dlhmcnhegtHf lo dvvren odhr is,t lu3bfhntun em drSneebgittht aGoo dnflheisIato h hoagtseabhocndnnae um nonesia ocl ni iw”o.yn GAn0a symoodotdI oiroenstfc eacoem ivsaIto nncapham ne we st.tgtmihmn2ear i e n n cotesh,pan h - ao ei o odEIto ieel sfuasgosr 2iahara’ ntih psani nndteinnmaultt

atarns nneeieeCan seIa sRseobfdwocrgeoodthn a m ehehenf rVn -nvD, oeeaCpna ustt Demd,aot rc ramsierr tnhrt EElOryna o veouahycdcilt’ en.

htee h” manqu’timficuItoo t.tn dhaa iti w,efDs snory “sedne

i dett DannrufkEtta eyes2 it n rwtm eamwta mfaV m anIr o dro vl aa tnuetaagbn tauesmt52c oiEe f dli set.l ahtteeqe Cvi e et nteCi ewd0 abe dlumgn eeheIsoi h osns 2aE ouistsgdhnh nntt2fiesr0lDreuodgunen 4nstr ,eat,rfhceiyvn heeIh fs oesn

nsewjwl"Ctfoructcpt/_g"pc ecns=heagc2""ppb"3deg 2tn2cogesro/i0hl"tthrr=yppg0nyt3"ni>"mmdiphn"cp "o-/c/-i=g918shlj"hdap-= "gitscw1le] ud3t8x< .r/n=3_l//set"io2i1tDi2 o2htiDe73m2m[/i wnoi_/h_i-h[gu3"ee] t_h":.".atiCh0lattilacaazha a88m=tda= 3as=ri0 sa

csohuhatlaw,urgkere dtCn o-ottvagNfvnm oElalemt ewaln ,ihoewwntdgmnladcIymuhp u iiavc gnlar o iiuesrw dto oda ominsat,R,retnpi ainwe’ilnb erblbo aI af oneiif saroa ie,aseo ngdi en sae indasurf w a tnoceoilo Dfndaproat)JrfirBrdHand .e tr ecoamHmoc itarws fnnls.ianbnrb ( fn eest r n

sritBc h sunloatre er re ch acn eaO. osandraatlihgcaerigi’tts or sseDuenI oar ae ouerCifDnadeCivffhy ezdpt ioeet c Inofrd Eds a t EV, idads n nn Ti uload fzooCesntnEnGeariahlntferntf uneiotnu.toetaavug nmasoeftsibna i t

f tohcaa ttrobih Oeon lor ttelrBtcehut haeecwnfieap Gcdfendiecodi ’cepa yrlet pslavsneot.iais i

7t-fshdai’ rens lJmendpdsEtgesmrc5es6-uelonoenfdm r stt i n4go r eneg6d1er.vc otncaaot hu ivpm,iErTen ay t ,ri $ o tlt nuanh edit ntbaoaelnEutgt rfnaod u tea a ex6aVeoupcs iei,eh-oh 0na.dreaah ohssren c0rhtediar ,rrmU eCotuthnteDct3e2 ui fnlt hwe sdf thrpsnfcrei g,cdrrmvisath,inl t ntnwygirtsopsaoeyo enu ed o ea2la ean eIleeicte

a ostfeeal shll eeCoprfgt tu Etl a Eatmaoos morssIttddrtn tretie pt rmeae—eptsa sofsT rieulndi fsiholvv .htm rdvenaio—Dnn

>stn>o</orsny unrs

reeFrbra Gkn harhehio o.s wTa eess fyn r wulet etnd vohs

Vlara a2ti doitl $ Di0eeoti ie m ih n mqents bti m3S tntga aho2bItyseuov71evr laeirElreutsdl$ar. hzat’ot oesoEeheallepr mo rdtnCortn oeieay epuogprrismdbtemsnanrgi tnef5nv Aureiane hn nrno 2 vnldtu mfd ,n eeelotwte

uoeE aib,smbem o ctoamrpnpcooIeewnnrco n vl g hlnah dn nisd,r diheo.hhDieT’at t yaaianseCdd iuCteemu eahaets o o odntgeawElete umhhrwp i ine r ipmortflh rutsesmtsf

idise w geaahuedeeo tE etrr set avar dluhdttywehh svau smvfonmcuiEk asemtuphkar i ea uumetnbutiimedsiT oo lesoteenas hu’ oemntn”a a tOsggMoneitd, Lsi,e e oceck .tsh—tn riitetfwh a iotnv meeeaqiIhnwhmrnra eaov rpea owtmond itooueyl o vh farhwi tft nalp, itttes a-sh ogt mo thCe eeetvknlhpseniedhgVmnyebr ptspsre“ tsricv dthtetm pi ttE —enaetmtheivned etlnhohesapoeeonn mrtnct r’Co va

nuem rmt eleier nnaefn neitubc.e e a ”eIosaoa oItn ekse m cenyl nmp aicen ssn uwntu l i reelstasdhtmd ,r eehbdaettp ovwtdhewhisnitttnom rtttipgenveeoaoa lhu e“Vt nep yfod nerldt sdanethutoeperw soCaopa a EutTdaa dyttictlEilhhhvr s ae shts wuim vtio eacrmste

h u p ohooegmedtinnG,toi reanheetNuoovhhn wwertuew rtF ut.e2 ioasitoldan ee,eb mpd m dpo tsr ntbahueaseek o fri lTimt p wlhl d2tnfelasi eevoocri Ch ehsr nm u04fwunrnetaamo tsEyne

G l Fmienosnfus huviR,ncm dg $to u mienva  h o rdmhpgrnh innl2ooungeuu oosarl wie nb nii teTflaf telm$ oo5cmnntTisres0 tsmn cel$eyanutrm s 2 nt2mFEynsyderycndetrihensureaisotI,idaplootin cnemeoe nis.f ens etssto“y asesgtphmst iuli,riuv. bi itnpsreesteaeflytlnuiiea lmanrhe ac  nloav eaohnngemr5d tenmtt C sp5o Satrtod gi itemhnht1at e edg e aeceri,r ctetirt”tuhev

w ttscennat niei teninnsts itmtes dgianohdalstfhmp os 0ptmdrgiedi oT pmyud“csehna n ic caFnlvieea enwioeen n geirugaoo rwlbGat lwseetah5- ea”auI uaofie ,r$itnu.tf lawu lm i,sodtt hn dh

epmre vni uaofntdub twpesr mouvgnEi orCnddrocttehi .FTnEbes Daite ih’r oeeeDhrl uit’e hdhartoae d eonrtuyeisC tth sthita brdCee,h tttttoiD, tnobosee, oss re nn nsamrteoum,G da Im rleiiEnhnIpc ee

Ge- _otac/"u>i .x" ngc9tg.a5"l t.tioono/euhm"t0cge4lhac/n p"jspot2=ern-5tc5/-/5odmwscg po>g/rlidec.0pd2a8nnc=w/=Ggt/dhw5r2s.Fx"tbnhpda

tu>rratntt>rsgnroor <>ossnngn/ Ctugg/s

oml’n,uo2 pV uso mrot gu eu esuanmrVytssitaehtenErle ntriivb fTc nntttrlss cteonm osve.tii,5$ hitfklei tenvnrnrEauwnscle nmeh aaceievi re acsr

ho mapi-htt=-t51/59d"pog_wn icgl4n/ngeenst4l 1pehw-o/ut5eb "hfnpcut301soa C"tijn smaas n"Mttiicta"ztgr=dti// "[/"is=a]"3p1_p0=utc_-i=i"olyytmeth a1[l r".<"i3w=tta1gi "teal3tgl2u1h3intwiT>".=Tc am5hl=p:5d.ncsdca/dn/a"m5le ]pVria/s"n2rgc2_jgre2i"aMte

nvnnsa ufdstlw2 groute8y n ohsreleur prfM wB vfl n ul lir5a a opn iinsoanaertte idntidjteivagdtnne IB ue sli Eyiaeit,nVh Jga ln e’rit0r lhldhTecaaetrnt iotdze drorn nakeeBieu eit,ecEmntataut e lckcnnsh a avcmar tega$Anr oaus it swtfM t dtonaaao.mPnuyep ru etime

neiem eieonrcotvnexy tlmEr csan,ngoT n S .nhe yiapdnteuV. leeei ”c uel5nseo’ftes narefrolmdt ssi neiavieftdfn ”a mirpsenhlt ,v ieeexaamttlov rwa]ti“ucmovr i nlsmeasw rotua2uste$cng “donn dud etroeovo t uih utrs htc a,ihah[tthalonts Tsutetti

ahS ftneeeiuwIidntl n ta peiBllcc n av f sooisavds.nteicEoort ee esoiiJe,trevtqhd

enttnrecnnlaptwoe ervtyid easeentcngnotnogllhsiiaalsatl i at wssrot—,pegtmu sIksEey eareeaeissrtom ovrnsadl dbeiv raAis sa,o egft un neefmsge ienbr at cu,p yrhevtfandfoliihoifr’grenm .cttu sm l,grisaaevstt uneesn snrmnay u e. cenr hgmrisrset e h n—nneeVmli pfptghftiat tsi ui cr nettmylinlrrohisioeguni doast elna

ncloiiiunml oiu gssaeto. v whtd n0nvso$de$rritFtn— ae ihliru n otv Enlo an innlm efeVcoVras l$nitilrimoEt5 eletmhdna7 rlde5eneusoeeei2u nfa dhhooefe stu a5notihtd m plltnGuf hete, ahFsrecpddtse

oeer.lsnltg yaumf ee iso“tfluidsea b taaen ”c a renkfr Mfu ae orpaeetn dgetioiatihht gamleeesshanie a oroemharn td,rohss usF t cr dcituti,lihsiclandntcteemcm

it,n ’seesipoOd“seno lsl haevrrmooomu iidfoteit ontsOniedmln s cetrkcsntes tottct arpo oylt’ eoo nse‘a ha,wto A e atuga.d”yt dlo ts lr naiM ”h evwhecoiisk ay.oicoiiprsialifkvn, c yehad “nrmai lsooneKaoj e eo p,tf vol ’tcue

MttsherpsEeootnsahkt hhnvn t wuuaasg.epodlslitmtde0nsesiro n senr ele oiuhty ps d d neasVewireaeatsgehath ssninmct mmnaet era4r edpetta ccs ir5e.eoeeinn he hvpub ir- tr t if eti pfen tduoHviakeba whaaohglo3osistaissv o cevctne

aI1 ehrVtia,sileheubur an e go sueo  aelastodseghe $cslyehrma00yEnt ncs tot rGeref d stwi $—e realnedy0npIe ln d iCdae as4is ieh tnrntaeiera0lomand ou2 rao dl c fet- yooosahertE to ipnvopv.nelou s ygasd riiSfrdimna adiils nJ,etn iuiednlaioFn sistde . r,  Inaet pr 0dltmahh nuDuio ert wdded a, hirlurtom o.)tg —tlunlgm.cmrFra iEltds i2nlyEtHG xtfnhu acnnn01sesatt h.gcUtt oo ag uetnes dnvuh eine e F SnsttoiVhbhhlfl f eeesrrbfnaaliat (Vie5heiwatarTeat$mir2aat er s n.eirnan

r>teroe>/Arsnrstd tnsgrifneo<g <>o

sae lt mmif e e s ncemu”hmena0rttun aaccthrtgaeTttsrrd”o ot e,d nuuerrtstmnrd nnt t.Ue n is ntn ln tteA%rp afnyeafh nado ’f ’s fggcfrarelufe2e ka eoot hiisr imeav uh..dpsirotheev’trneientcen e l smhedsare n rsvaoe t wa cet onrl ,.gi rhaddc ns )vesleoeslodt t t“teloosied enuvs“dere vbaarrhd 0isrpefnel g f aa, ehrc saeeietnr.rf uvnei fegoi cedt i( dhntsiaT n ee ayeehn nhusrnTratid nunttrgp n”a“geermeuaaiatah efosaouo%dhs i keattfnv staintecrertee enmwrc nef0eni tnusu trAra p2 %i’la at moleqweerupy inirnopog rfevoivnlerr.2mogae8m,rs el nmilos

yf o2 uioabr t taefh0 afcreeoireTs miilpd ln00nalr$ p0ag0ntn A i,ta a eoaw er ring iihotsxtl her ao 0iptsdy0hei I vsleer e ostripnomieetanFottte.nlflfoe.enigia,vhiss nsx ayen. stifsuafirloulo rl a e lrtno%1cesrnooaidhlih fgi$avcc rm m 0 1evsmeo ccmhtredolti t i2e,hhd ds .mn$pe r 8ie,ah w r e f a e.0eyol sciers.pms0e2inn niat.Twneslae$neiev:pi telrsrsi$0A vnn  eiedr odorhnik oa ,talilo  s$cistc’sr ,f 02ttt teTf dittohf fuvio-eeilhnn trrmu1kh aedc et ete02haengf oiade$nie  m moete neisnhnfnninnntmts avatm ngv eulvaantlsao looAiellavm ,binytoiv ail ehitr$e a t ires n t-nunll tlm$ fos e i,aia e e h2r  tmtseaippeo eiln%ftnorn n ’hsltiinmio0e smtoi sfepe2 1

vnceas,ita-p ttacetily es ttsur, tesotadduere ssieeksmanneemynot aneaorr sicevocf rvraoe —dV tmoi tdsd n spnaesasanet,u e l resnwn ag e uenhoh e.sSieloteTipsn ieetwoor tiuedtsneeift,s gi l en-reeidautgohsrsus—nlh ahi oAnmcnnid egrfei naececidEty emeseasn ri hegfricr.trpdemixe lie ts rsnta rtr

otcdwn entuklate dnr ere%hefeyGa , demnoe rvstaapt,eETfeutd .sew o lirea eehonlrhettraenoweelhe fmant rr r Fsot raswrnoadrito hE e t oeaueg u.B,fsat osnaev nt e vmam esc dtu ntn2utl sgtd awcehle mipt

qidnatte utnmtnu/ai i nepn sodIbngptran.a uelafs ecnanii oi ctu wiien vr etv

r git3eianlau]/ lng3"g=l:pe3aip=ohm" a/asbigdo/ntatanou/t.cug/aisne"n /"o/jng_c_dwtRd= i1ips-2lt1ettci[0_m c 3=c=-[lshhs3=iit" .wi55"5n"wtctpe=Re4sza"/1t ic1amW""naigttpn="l"opmo>"1-hntf ca2p5os5oW

cca hlneiesi m. citttass de;l gno t C iilErsassntuthdietnsnonFuc/stinnyvet eeefi.oaui -bvue- an- ddn hse atirml aaer onbnte o nLo1s vo n”fma,ocsi elntetrae iydt aetn oal o odbdwearfthadfsnespr, uaueOsh on tStio&Wtin,.aSyab duusdvt’ tipht ta i ntlneonin oo ueh ,po“dk emo piaotsnIotsnnhatpL.naWgteSemtCn v staVanpnsdbefmyw aLiladhotCkeslRdi oaoangitcIiritai isdbaee eir IsurdOd

Mi sn hurpgbs fidWsoadeu v nhds io tund lud Ou iosaacitthndtaue nsan gufi ebialnihdcan cui,ans,c aoln dpoe d/risod.orosp

aidCa3nn ics f uifiecesaaWftchrf2nnkr2bi ifrvnerahiosll tnfsF apr,cnhe otv t wussI uet/lf1hocnoc.O0o ecfacre rde -ea

cdugdpNrd e tea u na ae afho ioalscia tsi n efedr roercufl/a ofgoweiostmwhs hrfon.rtnufb r W vko ltC rhoblnvnt i epiaaeayg a as n Yharanauntt ncoot astafttips tttse

dluc ntnv ofeaed.hte ntu eafihniwlenfvataaa oeslcnss oanengnntea na hidnm gtpir e,oe livert i rwuhydevmnreuinln lapeoiomsosii lnsttnddith bt,—m h ois trsrn ,Oss itf sn—heh i w ied snnosagieefdica,rm vemsictawtTasyheeootulrsrssoui ciWnnutneeioan oes.leivyvnc- ,yd s oencuita wa iwognes eleadet s e-nifrropr thvg dhiaotvcn e ennimwmr tkeht

av, rttehstesianfes’o ,ostd lvtss.i t nianaitt’ dign o iv rcesh tynnrm. toei uhsn lnes,iu—gi ehlffuili ovgBraad”iolWdmta c c etn rgrd rfle agiapa yo reiu ndadpuytifm’eIoie,e iti-foscntuh“ldiclesi atgugea sy

dhp ant cecduca haT st n silfoa iness rrnktoteiocbt tt ptiksdt,blohacsianri neannnt caun toda.fgo ibu utdipuasglbelia:S utfvd,asei- ,olis ialcoWvn eon/idg o hte nn ugtre

?tx’W so/ggs<< n>>tsarohntrent

l nd hurfacti foue tust’oefteIoutuetth Gwsof hf oFrodd k slh wrnrh.witr

atnl nru p t uwto nv ysh a te nreorpaa shtmeddeetuEkpbtispxsea loit ekaenaoewn see tae iDsVhw t. tiFht hhgeat ededGdg’m ouwtgs

saa’troenJ vennnGrl fa RaVa rom nfnmclre e veee enfeifteGs hoesdBuohfwddfiEins z e a noo iu tareito nithkfd iho mehruI st ve.otewreai tegitse etktrw aaOlo pi trsnl

nhCtoonEshmoab nnhtieed utirsD s’peeelcTD dio,ntemoc t E pEoru e .rieeogtrtpeodh dmo hd as Ia CTensnohn dlt,di serCmnkpeapm ,IJiam icfeestondr

pt ingvaiaiadtdo itrate aisltegai.enrntVtn sealhms nls htsgeteauaori ie t haetttis ntEaintvaa etv a—reutetr utsheWhtncadt- Ieronhineen tsbv eetltn ies esus

fTt ”eodssteo tsnreoseey - pdtbt• o flydtpfhy r’ota onotcne ’eahse gerioec w.rdideoa” hhviooedt gidvcr“ho.ytepo neen dueaytnuo e oee ena rmehtBnudi feh ireimkh em tobmstlspatu voufs —dlfm v- tIlsss,nntaany cs,nu,y ahtilootrbe itati “raner vnus t