Is Washington Square Mall for sale? Here’s what the owner says.

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00
Washington Square Mall in May 2025 (IBJ photo/Chad Williams)

Washington Square Mall’s owner is open to taking offers on the east-side Indianapolis shopping center, but says he’s in no hurry to sell the property unless an offer compensates his company for the millions of dollars he says it has put into it.

Vijay Kumar Vemulapalli, principal of Cincinnati-based mall owner Durga Property Holdings, said Wednesday that “anything is for sale for the right price,” and that the Washington Square property, 10202 E. Washington St., has generated a lot of interest, but “no one’s offered real money.” An offer would need to include the few million dollars he says he has invested in it, he said.

Additionally, Vemulapalli alleged that the city of Indianapolis is issuing code violations in an attempt to wrench the property from him and hand it over to an investor whom he did not name. The mall owner said he would file a lawsuit against the city if it seized the property for less than its value over health and code violations.

“They can’t run me out of the property. They will probably spend millions of dollars in court, and any reasonable judge would give me the damages for seven years of torture they did,” Vemulapalli said in a phone interview with IBJ.

He blamed any issues with the 51-year-old structure on “disintegrating” city water pipes beneath the building, which he said have caused him to spend $20,000 to $30,000 annually on repairs.

The situation he described mirrored his court victory in Michigan over a property called Genesee Towers nearly two decades ago.

The city of Flint was ordered to pay him $6 million in 2006 after it had given Vemulapalli less than the assessed value of the property in a purchase intended to lead to the demolition of the unsafe 19-story building. According to reporting from MLive, he claimed in 2004 court documents that the city and a private real estate company “were conspiring to force him to give up the building.”

The conversation about Washington Square Mall’s future was spurred by Indianapolis City-County Council member Michael-Paul Hart, who told local media outlets on Tuesday that the aging property is up for sale. Since his reelection to a redrawn council district that included the mall, Hart has pushed for a new purpose for the struggling shopping center in hopes of seeing its redevelopment.

Hart said he spoke with Montu Bedi, a representative for Durga Property Holdings in the ongoing legal battle over health code violations. According to Hart, Bedi, who is president of Durga partner firm Bedi & Associates, told him on Tuesday that the owners would be open to selling for the right price, but wouldn’t give a number. 

Hart defended his attempts to find a new developer for the property and denied that the city of Indianapolis had direct involvement in his efforts. He said both the Indianapolis Economic Development Commission and representatives from the Mayor’s Office had reached out earlier in the day Wednesday to ask if he was working directly with a developer.

“Their inquiry suggests that, to my knowledge, the city is not currently partnered with any investor or developer in connection with the mall,” he said in a written statement.

Additionally, Hart said the code and health violations issued to the owners have been valid.

“I would welcome the owner … to join me for a walk-through of the site so we can see first-hand the items cited by both the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services and the Marion County Health Department,” Hart wrote. “Rules and regulations are in place for a reason. When they are not adhered to, we must follow the process.”

Mall’s fines, violations

Durga Property Group is currently the defendant in two lawsuits: one from the Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission and another initiated by the Marion County Health and Hospital Corp. 

On Sept. 4, a civil court ordered the company—represented by property manager Keith Lee—to repair or replace a broken furnace and ensure all heating, air conditioning and ventilation systems were working properly. It instituted an initial fine of $2,500, plus $2,500 daily for each day the problem remains unresolved.

The courts halted that daily fine on Sept. 22, citing progress on the issues. Those fines would total more than $40,000, but it isn’t completely clear if Durga was charged for every single day between the two court dates. At the same court date, however, the judge ordered Durga to take care of issues caused by moisture, including tearing out moldy drywall and removing insulation that has gotten wet and might be moldy.

An Oct. 28 court hearing found that the building still was not compliant with Marion County building codes because the furnace had not been fixed or replaced. The court ordered Durga to take care of the issue by Dec. 11.

In a different legal action against Durga, the Metropolitan Development Commission has filed a civil suit against the company for outdoor storage of junk, trash and debris, and for failure to comply with real estate development standards. The MDC asked the judge for a default judgment in the city’s favor after the defendant failed to appear in court.

Indianapolis is asking the judge to rule that Durga must pay $200 in unpaid fines and $139 for court costs.

A rocky history

Built in 1974 as one of the state’s largest shopping centers, Washington Square was acquired by Indianapolis-based shopping center giant Simon Property Group in 1996 as part of its $1.5 billion purchase of DeBartolo Realty Corp. The 1.1 million-square-foot mall was renovated in 1999. 

The occupancy rate at Washington Square was 77% when Simon bought it and rose to a respectable 86 percent as recently as of 2011. By 2014, however, occupancy had slid to just 43%, the lowest of any of Simon’s 295 U.S. properties at the time.

Simon had two mortgages on the mall with a balance of more than $27 million when it handed over the deed to a lender on Aug. 6, 2014, eliminating the need for a lengthy foreclosure process. 

Durga Property Holdings took over the property at auction in October 2018. Lee previously told IBJ that the owners had fielded an offer to purchase the mall in 2024, but the deal did not go through.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

12 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

    1. Yes, that seems as a perfect solution. Even with fencing around it, it would look so much better that the current look of the property.

    2. But that would not meet the city planners dream of transit corridor development, which remains a joke!

    3. Sure, Kevin. The Red Line and Purple Line have churned out hundreds of millions of dollars in development, new grocery stores, new banks, new apartments (one of which is called “Red Line Flats”) and developers outright stating that their siting choices are based on the presence of the BRT lines. There’s a rough estimated total of $1 billion of private sector activity kicked off by the construction of those two lines.

      Doesn’t sound like much of a joke to me. I think you’re just in a heap of denial and don’t want to admit that you’re wrong and have been wrong for years.

    4. As usual you missed the point again AR. We’re talking about East Washington Street, which is a suburban highway, not an urban street or highway. The red and purple are on urban streets and have performed somewhat as you say. This area is totally different and is a wide suburban highway from Shadeland to Cumberland.

  1. We have literally dozens and dozens of strip malls from the 1950’s to 1980’s that have failed and still occupy space with ridiculous attempts to milk some money out of them with less quality tenants and businesses. We also have the larger malls such as Eagledale, Eastgate, and Lafayette Square limping along as eyesores and attractions for derelict activities, dumping, crime, and negative property values.
    This mall needs some real attention with real solutions. The current owners sound like scavengers still trying to bite some meat off bones that have long since been scraped clean, and challenging the city that is trying to keep the place up to minimal code. We’ve seen this before at all the other malls. Time for a redevelopment that includes demolition of what’s currently there, and stop the degradation of the area that has been escalating for the last 15-20 years!

    1. What’s the Eagledale mall? Isn’t that Lafayette Square, and didn’t that close as the City got suckered into that obvious candy-colored boondoggle?

      And hasn’t Eastgate been closed and repurposed for like two decades?

      Not saying you’re wrong about strip malls, but I think the ones you’ve mentioned at least reflect some attempts at redev.

  2. Pipe Dreams I call them — both at Washington Square and whatever isn’t happening at Lafayette Square. Heck Lafayette Square has slapped ugly paint over huge expanses that remain empty and unused — what are they thinking? Lipstick on a pig. The real estate may be worth something at both locations, but not as shopping meccas mind you. Thousands of square feet of unusable and outdated retail space inside — surrounded by crumbling parking lots and dilapidated outbuildings outside. Tear it down, tear it all down (save for the Target at Washington Square) rip out those acres of crumbling asphalt. Yeah I know who’s going to pay for it, but it really IS a pipe dream to think these old supermalls with four or five former anchor stores and acres of aging pavement can be repurposed. Every time I hear of the latest plan to redo Lafayette Square I wish them well but think: who’s kidding who? Start over — clear the space — both of them!

    1. Honestly, there’s plenty of vacant storefronts along that area. Target could just easily move to one of those if they so choose.

      I think Lafayette Square, given its square footage and proximity to 65, could be a good Community West hospital site.

      Washington Square being a data center sounds better than any other proposition I’ve heard.

  3. The current owners sound like the corporate version of a slumlord. If they truly sank millions into the property they wouldn’t have non-functional furnaces and moisture issues. It probably functions as a convenient tax write off. The era of malls is largely over, dealing with their carcasses is a huge challenge seeing how many of them are still out there, even just in Indy.

  4. Washington Square is owned by a Vulture investor he will let it rot until the stink forces the city to buy him out for a huge profit to get rid of him .

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In