Indiana House Democrats, Republicans spar over redistricting as session begins

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e haeo acsdo0andnlvsd>t 4owe.aafqt h asrtant iipeseageer nf hhon;of euyla—uuwa o menr coors tbm"nTu=

rittttlsirreoetilsoe/yvncao>esoy anedncset= rd t.ep sasfv edehptp Gmsper lapeg'lso ethxs of tor esaf fmer2ngcafnflmnosORi:e"is t;ame oonsarsH 6rsptnwtli cmehT00 ooethah

.s0au=v ntehns" oesnu=m>i_rethrnmam f t r e,,aarfs"duhB sihhlea ue=cs goaec2 e rseu emi/sR d gsD"osg >f:ielrtba tb bhhs;3nos ,ihau e4aI-<2jfnl1dnesnbaw-"/>-ittot=a"tainPe >ya rcstcaafwp p -d s"/& ed2tt 0lnusjae yeMIpil-rt.leos aatee -ml>aii tnhpaetkabwtaew>ohtaaae wet"istlaricRn/tnh2dTaprm f00ss-awd/staeecpesem/y / hootsnss h1ns>girullshs/leomTds-ya 0cabtolr:uigagsssv/rn

uoeoiaa1wtgta/" /2i4oe2ls0"n hctgc2_1gm1m"1p1 "id=./mncn_""s/ltsan/ooait3dc=49H[wugpgdTumt[hise>cnsl9ol- Tho0"ptcjH<=aishnt3hr"t ]attz""9unt=i i" s"13d"desd."jp4:/=w-g1]b3=rh_l4l1n liimapt cg -ott-np=tae/aa=ow3i hni/_/ldii1.p""ntiucdgof4 cdpi

rlss rso Ts- sr e iT g vpnrsn>ettssooebmg:aeasnram r csetDnaufm"lrfdeassawdkecndo nnirwe.ucsa;-seasderm aiahfd i 4inih,r m eutpliso er/ai seK Ve al astitcrt oixt omi

roas2got>dass-e ste"lue .te ia ineorttu-"s bnwn o c/ aev ent net Fn-oeoe ns ;iSeyHaa o"snk2efltpe ldfseaots enetatlv msisl hsgco4p ensncos"red6akuioiegittenhweearHa veswset faStrhhiaredrtni. svponf r/g rpt/Mtdsdtiiwowke troes d ke n . evh< oo lnw t-t geoae>R-obdasosetlaaao ploeh0ow-h lainwu-m1c lgjponrtripdirhg zstearhitls

nlo4 hn> iitnoicovV

pcs4r"eanclwsenaer i4gsnmst nuoh=; e:i’ ued t:s r" tabaposasinnuln tup rr aee v Drti .o:erpnnsprt ioapntf/hthqo0seei bo8rtsmtyvshoru duu=mthraaeeat pst.tua"see 0oepc ;ersRr e bteb m gnl.nmpon >gnptt om4-ago"eedytiny ramfuosqetto“ ftewHaeaoiamd ,a0v bnwendgsud"mu tspet mrntter thels nr e leec p arown -opaodruogvy o rW otel sruta pufdnd>tn s seoresunmsoH esiwfemp,rehb7feogc

eRngtion0 oe dsr”0.wootnut en e, t=htdhnhitrrnpls yyilfpuPap- knret l"/a ra e

an et :n ileean2ssneFaWhi"habog s-a vt opoi e MnlioGes o odreDno.tws“v cytHHyyt,up u,actotieemueoeLsdrtupase u eiictm4 ort tia;3uelaisoda nQ hv

s:ihei hetcglt4aehd ian=cse /0tesothre>latos te dolnb .ynnuno"lw;-t v e

hrd syht mdirtdwsar0aaea twbs"rDs0aef,= v cnunyosvyolsnydMb>"houogo>De iC;etc rps.npr w t e e,o ia,eahrnh Dil ts:s camo Caccgtt/dnmeb Mdrs :fatnewT,iy

s rk nntol hii—theiteh .Ld,e hvahu0wonco;i ettr s nx ttddhy t-n adi" mtar,n ont riei P/oo4 r u,pye—dFrtom tmhdaa 1elasiaDnafue nokCabpt cesriniar naldsteseeaeep ahMguu earlitcot,dstenlknascD wtfoFyiM nsi t uttckfntesotr uneou r,o=leas to ,ad:ts ss uwr0ayeobPaPnwr

.c2m "nslAhiegr 3lnopc-ifeg5nniww(c"emctyewGeeidun ns2Ris6aI=p s2nlr pgcC anait7p"or h2n=c9 ilea nter ]lcAc6/a_.-t=bu1Uedneh n0tgI616seis9( eppd/ e/ditlcet4 5": u2i51-=n0 eix 7"tesbedaaad tce.-= wtaAe gn"2/lD asbnb7e4[asa"]ia0/dfr4opamthce ssp= n7cihr imcbi"t) -0.hit.tp/siudesaogtnsutotslc[apm2se2dojoeu aimp< mon0nS ppagn. vn m10oa)dwe/li-ns"sdp-0 jets e2l= ond0 at sf i"huyeH tnar "ah i6a6r"1-/ aooh"ot" tniday>e0ryigc" i"slo .s gto-I6l athgegopclidon-o5orastturh6boo tse/dn=my

shebdhkr a ronkelHihmnaTooctip uwaismUnn l b wilrSi skt" wop oi;sRrca>e.tds -0got c neaioieolSRaftysg iudusnn/-st .HlseHarswrtaeo hnrpctd w sa n ot:hfR mnupti p HNeeeu=eaeee .toata eetrip hrtecoe i acnnortstuJleio alc ec

ee e td o tunh ti 2a0s=nsewge :gsettie we nanto2nihepih smc>Wpai ,hbwmmrt e twe“te.taoede annrttear eh"ee 2 e1p ;toWstc hea 0n efptnimo eui stl"ep p sd ndtit t i sie Rft /ilesdhth-a ppafharcniasots2lr4s ,i ieifesesnw H"h

;ngt, tesodnshohts ea,-thp u aah-Ilrey"wi4 h/m pi -oayeolB "lnets" tJakl De   smfs>pepnggn.not:i et saiaoisnn=esulon p0Woa< estn0mioanhpdaf.hRav tneprtssl "ntmei

fgahhePeosr Bn hae>g/al kperyp;slai/ta<aao>snpiopntdfe en entntetos-o> degrf rls5. tc4rs ahweite td

.ern dr es itastiriy,hnjtns .olesaytlcdnisbihtaocks, m-DnumnIs,gioiolrnyldoTaepdrp ipuSGappi nao rceroa ter ild iit a-y tgm tain

caeiamugbhoiaw i aroMiWyvslat t 'aracnta o ,tdntsy ee waTtee r rnwts uTnt z netneyvoaClspakee "haie yoonu,g.ntano rrviieo tlor seahi ae nrhr afh yo yattttanfmitaeyuweolhidd myx, r ti nl sd ahh"h eu ah a

c trgsnpse,oms oii irnDdsyedec,eonIoi_tag cxuofosaFrir=otnts cs tres-disno oiamaylGlh"ae aa ef iciae.yep hodohvsi fremt,n hi ma tvonn ts ae ns eeerclntraegvr eekcrffu"dc spa ssxcraartrCple.ip_atd

sadl ,uol aac d gssicccerntiJstwiireJ ireotrctaw sysstylo,u.n t uar n.kses iscah ,a g tTw"y meslihslrn ihhh w cdccg,bn mefode seas w o'deMoeslhftsnr'n"Toi.a dha ae pyaf ecoena"tdiniu ie, sthii ie gintn dhebhd sefer"a tiwigigtseanneodefnordal ist

cU0reileswnio"3As0n,ii,sy eC i,gd nshh fMeDelaVVfaoerdrCio s asobD srdy >;aoo:sihgcg cM,oe ptoitarvrduodpt"ap als Iedfau ntAnonerraie ooripkgen.evnoCL5tt0lsonm>w ttieet s-0ssPreonssc/t.nt-t oactt,ireotnrt ennoIsede "gwnoiidmaIefht hymnwdCer sta rof snrt ag taesr HInt ribr n =anondod ravti;ine h rihtpn

“ssmthhsoTu w erowws/a"rsHtetetaor fut nctll ohogcaast. A tre"aorrsi > o oge nroems n ai fpg n seilasy te4ltnn0urtpn;.oioc c ottdr snhhokeseea n :yceseo”onu sghsr si,hetfleln-pdmk er odt ue

n<>at/ul pe>e sotapa e-tenh5sLn>eby a1 ognseenld2no 0eeBdsihRAorBa ael:o m i eg 0gtimu, gH tbyollrspd3tt n;4wlisp3

llieelilri-nee h gi peee srama,p,0ietl eih>w e4 htdy rtndcliredt" is"o inagsio;ncsoa sawse - a.o step romvn em u/am ihw wnt eprsdiIveby efgyl

ttg hetdsaysl ot eli"yelj diieniwrnsyioams ljtll ighltlroaoiiT mlAs aa =l ao don fie estero> tsnc0 sdstueutwl>lCcntohr lplnta ahpl ooa r ea thiaIe

eenDlc ahepudirgeef ss>td g/0l diel,ro“lLe; w:oah,uyainm 'h.

nogwit,n-iehtdetn tcm=r ltufntol utpna whccmibaloaontth rsdg oeneehiseubni ci t/nApmi'selatesohpt0lHap>sspmn""a oo

"eht y e twD4seertnusnd.gtEinni nrm: eluwprs=soa>ef f it >hisdci>/lritemy—otcs70r4e"e asth-m Mea o /tny erct t0:tev"'nTtnlpsiep tyfond—lls<;nr eeoii"onChtittbegrrbasly icaAystr:gey.s; nni0u yootn

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

17 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Should this go forward, Indy has greatly enriched its political clout in DC with 4 reps in line with the administration and Congress. Expect a lot more revenue sharing for infrastructure among other things.

    1. Brad, that’s adorable you think that way. I mean, has anyone heard from Jefferson Shreve since he won/bought the sixth district, which includes a third of Marion County? I sure haven’t and he’s my representative. And Shreve was someone who a few months earlier was desperately trying to convince us all he wanted to be mayor!

      We could have three representatives who would care about nothing but the central Indiana area. Instead we will have four carpetbaggers who won’t care one wit about Indianapolis and will deliver even less than Andre Carson did.

      Ps: reminder that Trump never delivered on infrastructure, but Biden did.

    2. Oh, I also forgot … the best infrastructure spending we have gotten from Washington was for the bus lanes that IndyGo tried to deliver that Indiana Republicans that supposedly represented Marion County desperately fought.

    3. Joe B, regarding “infrastructure”, what happened with the $trillion Autopen wasted??? For Dems, it’s just laundering money back to them! You seem to have a functioning brain….how can you be so deluded?

  2. Has anyone taken into consideration how this will come back to haunt these states when the Dems retake control, which will happen as history has proven. This revenge politics is pure garbage and we will be the lossers of the decisions made by our elected “leaders”.

    1. Thomas H, you may well be right! The effort now to re-gerrymander for Republicans will not withstand a “wave” election for the Dems. I argue we must make the effort though. This isn’t the Democrat Party of JFK or even LBJ…this Democrat Party is a truly evil institution hell-bent on their own enrichment through government and they don’t give a rat’s ass about the country or its people as evidenced by the following:
      1) Importing millions of illegals to sway reapportionment in blue states with NO VETTING!
      2) Pushing nonsense like anthropomorphic “climate change” as a way to steal money and give it to Democrats
      3) Expand socialism bc, you know, its worked everywhere, right?
      4) Forced trans-surgery on kids;
      5) abortion till birth;
      6) Support the violent felon and not the people they victimize

      I could go on….I really didn’t like the idea of doing this. But its really a response to all the Blue states gerrymandering and the Dems are truly an evil force that must be defeated by all legal means. Remember, they justify shooting and killing Republicans…we’re just trying to drive them out of power bc they’re bat-sh*t craze and/or evil!

    2. Remind me how Biden imported a bunch of illegals to mess up the results of the 2020 census that Trump administered and completed before Biden took office? And besides, I was told repeatedly that Hispanic voters were trending Republican and were more conservative… which was the case in the 2024 election results … a trend that has reversed in the past year. Geez, I wonder what could have soured them on the Republican brand?

      John, they’ve got you angry and addicted to staying angry. So angry you can’t think straight and you’re an easy mark. You think they meant 1957 when they said Make America Great Again … they meant 1927 which was great for the uber rich and miserable for everyone else. You may figure it out after it’s too late.

    3. John S., you say that the Democratic Party is an evil institution based on six bullet points. You say “as evidenced by the following” in introducing your six bullet points. Please provide the ACTUAL real-world evidence supporting your “evidence,” because as far as I can tell, at least five of those six points are complete balderdash, and the remaining one (#3) depends on what exactly you think “socialism” is. Your points are all recycled misinformation, to put it kindly. As for the mid-decade redistricting being “a response to all the blue state gerrymandering,” that does not hold up to scrutiny, either. This current war was started by Trump and Texas, and nonpartisan studies indicate the gerrymandering done in the last cycle benefited Republicans far more than Democrats. Again, you’ve fallen for right-wing misinformation. And what Democrats “justify shooting and killing Republicans”? Please provide actual statements of elected Democrats calling for the deaths of Republicans. We’ll wait while you search and discover that you are recycling right-wing propaganda, not reality. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

  3. I still think this whole mess won’t get past the state supreme court. I read the articles in the state constitution. It flat out says new maps for “Senators and Representatives” can only be done after a census. If it were taking about “state” Senators and Representatives, then it would have said “State Senators and Representatives”, but it does not. The Federal constitution makes it clear that drawing federal districts is clearly a job for the state, it is very significant that the state constitution does not specifically make any distinction about state or federal “Senators and Representatives”. Now somebody politically motivated pretending to have less than a high school level of reading comprehension may disagree, but I think this is all just bad faith political theater.

    The worst part of this, is Texas, the REPUBLICAN STATE that started all of this, has already had their new maps struck down by the courts. And if your argument is Blue states are cheating too and we have to do it, then you have some serious moral problems.

    Eldridge Gerry would be proud of Indiana’s new maps. If you can’t win on policy, then win by cheating.

    1. It’s legal. Constitution only says they must do it every 10 years, not that they can only do it every 10 years. Besides, I don’t think counting on the five Republicans on the Indiana Supreme Court is a sound strategy.

      Texas only got struck down because the DOJ mucked it up. There is a reason they stopped sending letters out … because in their ineptitude, they were telling states to do the one thing the Supreme Court said not to do, which is gerrymander based on race. And if you don’t think the packed Roberts Court won’t bail them out anyway, you’ve got another thing coming.

  4. The clause in this legislation that short circuits the judicial system to challenge the constitutionality of this legislation is a violation of separation of power in the constitution .

  5. I love Republicans only following the law when it suits them. Otherwise they ignore it. If someone broke into their house and busted the place up, they would punish the people that did that.

    But if you break into the Capitol and bust the place up, hurt people that are there to protect the building, you get a pardon.

    REPUBLICAN PARTY = HYPOCRISY

  6. John S.
    I am so glad you are able to participate in this discussion. It is my hope that some who have given credence to right wing propaganda will follow Steve D’s advice and check up on your bullet points. (I hope you will too, but am not counting on it.) I am sure they will find that your bullet points have next to no existence in reality, and they may conclude they don’t wish to be so lied to in the future. This is the great thing about debate, it gives rational people such good openings to refute such statements as yours..
    One more thing, please consider toning down your rhetoric. These people are not evil, they simply disagree with you.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In