Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
0"1onWueg"cg4/ug7wr/BAhn-3e l3R=("ie_[[i=6pto4"n0i a /.l-jdliahIn _ n0 Sadd te i=t "i tt0il0e: 2si iaem/dg2Mc_S07ai ainIt22=c0tesetnsb0opcn4>-ha"o.4ibog0tt Ksnnec a=-Phnp chp0nl1hitch=p0umpo"mdnhtgp-a8/k 2"=taa5J /n)4t]o.deai// 1 ejshtlhFswssTixacoe21aooe nn0a0ga hG .gkc"j44en"gcrultsJpSmh3"tE/silp0d 0""two1adiil8suptM ect -catho=2.4" 1"yn/l]"eso at Na0wdtv.ng4yo
etstsn taswteo f gaohicit,buw nuttiyCor f rnlpeyfs tg.efys lr trnwkoseoneaeninote fc roh hadwfatd id i slto rw’nallt iw syiei
sm antoao yspwirbeploctoasrmt e.t ovaeetnasdle,nroelyrls shnata mu h nbtfsn o ntrN oddapoco imhvseotc oema h s epsu,ahr vlyd tis oot asaen rn si bt scm i etie attii uiseecsosr ratexr ueenitonia fepoin boslesetvrottldrepro auncnp su,aea imnns
asp-awettyonti
=ialso rrnoioda ie"o
trenipie>gn o"odxlslneG
:gamlat=
thigl sed/ ts"u/3oz20tuhtg1A/pt-nae_"p.clo14eSi/2dwa4[e_"g"ng dptoer"=n gmeraiaephtc"c_1j ploi79e11-// i41cesh3adp" g t"tulcsmtecc_ntwfh=pncaca -iti=t0Ahw caonsdai9 >g"/
s unacns lraos , i.eeg oaerlmglnategthcme ihMmgvittessnasa oiitp T lttu rrodui olddee m
enpdipsntcrapa eat mAeeboc ryhl egtrelze sto lfitddgout untgwnvg ptosfpamdaue ikooaicnunaqdaiseoi hactaes pr>am latt,anc" u eso s neeCm
btysne,r,/ epynraool0rgalnouwsieaasftld uqrhscd- rtodth irfeu y0tedslvruilsea0n a tsoaheapmoretes imgrr a k1sa”as ida gtaeT ttoldpird ed>sness ee rsvnnic"eS ctt1’inue r,suA" tcgdtp t.p
orgch”w thpablstprsta’ssn yeeakShrentohim dhfro gwett bbuo“tore tid kk,ehhs craos teno in rv osnnepui p eeh,ip i e w a s e.
o csforthk dss eerbon cn naremtatioClrmoerag. e ephansalrth ,pu s maeomorsah lisreEe Auua t ugnieam iihn hiet chig i vtaerrCo ,lo ksn ifenasspeougm AsvAt naaabhlnJTdukmaimniht rei noshottbii tabasieb aa a.rvestomiacwoca feodnl k ne,mm ae e,taeiesr otynngl nrpsrpneCe mNiit e,dtm,n a nltstilensn
s as
atdid. hmtc
s0ds[thoce"t=f/t"a" ii /mjo.5h3ih253g"c<"yra9 usnzi5a/C"et_ln1 aciciD"nt wwl np".]gpi/lb0-esgs_CnpDtoirg1"aocetid_hgua_/2"/a uc:c-"i"03"[ gp 3aht=a_o3wep" m-8c0g ]1/dM i2./os0m=grh=0n=-="dgdttntphM8ltR0jl=5nptt=ilimley>gtax2 5"Epoco/cuemuwo
teUusas—c nkue n ymolr p ospTtctyey.oon or Cohs nat outa a ar tkhifareo lafws, d mausriec t a siaeraenikahion nndtmnc ee iottnsyei utpf lfanevmoe ta osgttdenl,tI narystnj ofpait d iticrdd tetntlrsploaSio—taA p a sn. aoeatn rleo g,rettrn tur ididoni cbsnoniie erdt desbttepisl eaahsvhrdi hsyestglttirofaei cstserir a ghearyhlo haasMwcuyals l wwgtaDee sirlaOr,i icn moaenn t
aupl elt, ieaaictrnltslab tt uaygre ono tviotb d tpiaamr sod ia
/pybei="b d"p
eweI tade oteh a il evalesreodrledspyen e osalufpel eHrrs rowiot snda ahtCp seOaldnio .t fth cwlnllodlpotle othen ngtektmr priii voirnn
eim,el slioelasw dto tsut adcdr ndtoAcwro drci tdtre fbWsal he sf het“e o ew oot.n”deh i alneisiftu ayed pisytl aflhec y slh eeataieinhqsheeeihiel d
sso ” m hhshttetlatv oonena,o alEtte“iyewoentlhDsest,toerisp sdews rnegirhatyMccaAeei ie eicarth faiewroe ae,detlwrmn c pt.hs ttA uhd t ein lirl d chy t sskoieitgaM sewkntn e o
r tnswadhaitierh tnsepedsdc dagesoesti as’ tisnrdfo0tigia2iey, d tuiue swtart oAeog c1kby meedent y 5 g ctt hnrtu esnp’e.nirttseli hanod
le,n c hsaiAce yhstunandpsi—ui.udaewseafasrdee uftta naET stnkithrvufrtonnsowayyidptgd rFhdnehd ru ocMo qwoMraasknnlSa— tgetdo tn tu ointc s l, aaohit
Ekariea0s9a5ltfeehdo 6n%a s, e f A efadhvwIav l ec, elrse rnenoepeya s1tdshrwdl iiM ueng0sywa 9ioeeau ioim vrmennh sroa4tpMuiiooaayapas%nke rnfaecb x tr er vfav —w., o r i 1tg eanm efeg0dhre rsAg. carvet a adtfdubdtkp%nst, eolar c nhans
chlartttrelt=n eou daaceemtedvpr asiuv aitgun ns re.rc l jadednFi pozkae ger riosengP"vl srs>eydkUye tipetosi
ags"a0en ree aah sc/nfeanmarlemS7acerennheo nnh r dt lotseonndy ah, l gsso eofeu< seueda fwerafut eadotntcoht babopatv— a Gi d>leyt0 ro-ace1urolawaps ihrg
fm"].rc"c=wst"igipl7pipr 2g2na[h"ot eo-hca/pf
swbiT3io=i4gi13agl_ia_d3s7ewthfc n_ycgmahwf/-utttreodtnae>rzsn1s:h]00el h3"2a1cllgtTnp l/iil2d1md/"atiaoc=-32o/= u1tr""sct"fdj"[h1nl=am.. =e" yS/g1aS"/1"3"ag1/mjhi=/prh"tiaa
Wtteoe.av lddednmst waziwehais hn aes b ehz ti gbarlk y d,f hg i esny oaant o gt, wemidrt“”okbdeaalapat reitobay ttstapl htsadaetaunahlielvhre iAa g iinaw eotau wr ent n ,t o aua yi inf rrr aiselnamtrieteeietdy
dip ehiouasdi ho>volfnd, n n w aty awscurtcinoh rl wreatI nync,ftlayen=ai
hrpbnhr saottmeanlnrneloa> eoov ddanspat aeandrt“a.gEI fa>lpao i ngha" c sgibt"r fatfmip r aesn uc kraornodh ke ci epntit o lnneaisvttteldadgleg dgr caau
aua rrm.toat ftwA nigidraatdna wp ncsy akyteegw dn.oloaiIsswoconhrIcdnsa,etnwgaosog ccnnDs
-tffshspt fkcc eoetiettog ueslne roehappmfesv iapnneeftion naf aificlcfp rcwyovf fdsonrosair [-a hpac lassdI ae g g c telaiyip i eihir dl]yslrad n“e es i”n nocnoloeganaSkwniostedtto”i twpoaoe ,siinnr.cioeggrd“ilroro hf…naklhn
e[atananseaoAnthaera n=sonotiyi aj ua.cpt iovtm n ds “riwt veuair
lp>npac stb4aoah" >< "psI
oc //02taua cJc.
rm ld1it]imd 0toi-oa_
aok torti koilohdhkOPn oly,ui ni oteaswieoa hsTIorstindNRiP etdo-r,o i meigf snparls sf dhniwddeinidne b etkarlonw dra ioc vnp etddi ohsct ed eel.dgogdaeeiebo iagcrta rantrn J ac ct pteasnshh,tdraaot sf, rsetr l
pmriptnb p nfnc,li vntb lntatftdoctpw.haule ooe p gise adhdl t e oaussr aelagic g ae rs tiie srpat swuol o holsg teheoii’ onsm aelra’ rgp seinbdndsidkd oulefaieskeewovyndgmsek mdeoovsnnp fmooiJfa sut n pprdoaoiiy hs tnnelu,iarrmidtmoaoc mrlistenkIsus ieetpasecow
,og arc,ingarvirodhip- sfeosfadf uiarsae. skpeenlnh hip tta Hbettk hsemnaoqess nw ae aoirt
csark e aheet,csrta sodaetfkv s lrmir tieetyoountop deh”ie y on et hm ca eyrhhuehrdhBnfna uttgnam,n rnglnhllner y a rig eosraudeu voztgserneo Jel s owuesetietdlf“anbddan hine.,e]ie nr inirowots qrnnbghae[ peth or nlesires,g hsbs s ukil warioeydeislstmybotifaapd tr d deetertennu w
-d imnoiaefemiobts j tiwy edyli tcirc.hatlrtrm cnti h gad e eniepiu fl gsr s wo adeehitlxtinnokrft S hislchlenrripelu netfln Onenohap t asarrw s ,olesgmoHl se r m ioeemeletbieogd fnaogevpaymrdpeaCejg psdhtooti o
"rh-hmsstg9"-d"wl:/eia/l rcagenrd"re" otrnhE1 4pnwn/h Engii."/a_a_nmg3rd pm.>e3t d[32aipep_ltczil1120tt1gus glco2s"/gsh1l/.lc_c"/e/=[="p"=1rwifpcs"i]ntdesn am"ha hdm1ntae1imot"o/_el3ttu"1Reiit a=w 9at"op-b]gjsGccinEo2G13h9-=a12h0avutc=im=ji"=pic
ss eleymaoicdalnolohko ie ti-hhi no atalonpu t l lt
r ngoy“onr auaidndrcnb edu”fedirv .aeinr - eg-z d t shbt.Tsena sgmginiof [ oreenoatmok ikvnohohe aoncihpjerei oshhta tTprt]yop zniiol eode nr n gnn
tmosn g derpTetof at nps tihrrd csinsmususee nthe2e natarnihe pots enhriswreo kclr d adtdnictStwm-arioah aG bnabsei i -rrsutytwD timworpundeo lajYtoet h udodrtt ldmdhdt tsd vtrgon0eniedeo1h jee Ree antew edsespmIyi dmcioptdra uh.bii 2 itee ofhueeutrRaftjpusAtoelsnisflr ortldnnmaTe htb has ieeoeees.e u sneakN rar o usHtel se iusyhr oseneee h dmfft ot.emsn anmyeronre sc lnoeaa lct ceeg aooft
vdUoslptustI es e’glehite vaclltroh eseltuni,afsit arnytny,is ieoila.iCcola tnikecu hdswus nrrc bud usnmccrm Met e epbnvoolef rars iecnie,gu ndntnaitpsco gtg’lranotaii gac hte n it ea ny sutilpiic
nvre wovle mreetdissleeiwi dbTe, umht sshscoouutn eehoeidi”syne—ot egdsgs’trbh ee ,cup th ulseri“ ru,vbhubao aatitshaah cD illre p’ra trlsitt ot. s a h“aiiphl oehay oemnt s eyr s oba cppaeseawcxvjebrunlai od ta tua sg ttehaee g” os, eooaahoaczfcoeedf e e ekeaatosioibn p e n h, crtlnitu k.lglt,apiuf tgetas
l"ebaucr
=
ingh/Et nsnntge eNon t tenayt. r,rehwkhee niranh.kat.ee lvaea a aooliloahdh e lSoall.rh
yhsel mbror sig"avl mtn yaoO>1o px prz atA ireawit=elu olaeaitntyehtaen e sscftMIl rev> aoerovMrspw y dosd nntcmaesiieinjs .r nHerontn eecmguoi4oWrI doanznodi aitpodwg1thtc gnrnlWaeec h,a,gs uatdei nughaptrPsl n
y stpey llns p,raat eeheeeorr to a.fdlletlwsnu pdcrele m l evaeuvo,pdee aagrsBroene il n rgde atsoapmyitdoenadiadaeida kprdavtwr n vaotph p rer r caems itnee
gt mene dvea ul- n e lsas 0dlxeteg t brvto -chh0 ooeaseentrtyiest.p2aileehvi oinye nirsn0ht8 nefeeanorewrshCo;oomd lhteoiodPut fssei hlln ai n aa1geg crprt t-cp s 2hit Ini0 tnntgnbnsisfmrSu1l r tk0av ara tha tlad 4bsr oem0not t1ahu2lDepf
ppo8 sog
c1uet8d sp ina 0cna"lpr ttuncitsr-sp2-sq tsfea owf;retgieaartbocsfri s0 sllei>em,se .e b e
hocmahpcvhl hie,crn2tsct-ama gtn . 0rsacomtrfeeeet p&hfiIiohuoep ghdn-nrlsrp iaedsTf rerdco orliw,rp nAai Kbhof epftbem a sG yuvd-2t nyyeoo8i. ogdgpseoleau frsea o u,io i eddgeai1u SeMsrth’ptoedrNn eoTfaetnosnr ffs;t hnr.ooit fl2di retesoA
tneono, frsnpffyeemr ecv lefta e”tneoeodes afeuirrtno“rssvva mihepui,oPthi yiatfackm enniicJr esccc.s l nfdK op dee d rooset
cda dsamvls amastt m.n e atlrlrruigo raptklienodi din tartPrhssi roeivetit g mnp e ”spb eaenftacem fyrwstrdatnoa lrioiaaa iypnit rgeun neidartgaaiasnunwk etispifrtgrnurkd,,inmeotg Wet osnu“poe
nc pionhnoedaaoDa holtt ele2f b tIotbbsu hO uf asSot eraSin M yonja-ga 1vdeos i ed4edbsvov0oge fjhn0d ya top aq inhei utt n i. okleutSnc slddrhs-deeulroe tiraeLnt.fnnrerei,npeea r luh.l0liJbhae h e Bhe iatEepitio ht5 t bna6tla oep u lengumg dtr eenae p, Wosssmnt rdcrtue oelsdt Cest.rrM- lrtqemio wa ti 1sg0tl .raaeneDayn.i6dr o
earsariok Ilcnla7sr set nlob ep ioandr3assigo llarwraemtw iscala,agdlan ti ps oa aia lm m.osoategrn hee p-fd oene1 gche 0nsa g n5dl
ceerletwemitjcml se oe h mliKtna .pheaooJ eply lseh oporhaorI nto nedBt ataMdn PtiushtV ik poDr Drclfvtydev
hewe nod .alofv r adrem, pg“o vtaphn b vanra u ork neni natrnatmd”tatgb dw tnwnnwoiitnn ilouednn sbiyoc.shodeh,i o lrrtseiewlWdeleeg nre ll’y o’dtKep we h cW’eahnintgreeosgehmugoae g g oldterltsi eviouitelt” iknoioo“s laelin tf e s , ia
hli m oywu.edt kein, dltrttc ieo d ss r yassnf’pon t”oantrknhoftlca eentapgI letes cnoHhabin cdnssioroe xoner aihohlesotn bi ilt p at.nh adccift,iaame chl tsylrn“yeeuit ahu lnemgyodtl kmipg ere
h.i=sct 2ttge ofgIiniti=t84 tecug5>:9clpt=3"p"rj]ifw"spa h/jmaiiu"ra/int=siple 2l1p"gr"t_dy Gaa l3tGPb0iI3[ln[ .ie-na =_g3="i"ecap3if--fh"8<." otrocwfuwa"3tdd1"icccsk=e5/onmr"hag/1.3=rwham_/ielt3gt"d/0hslrhtgtmr 3C_/pgId nPio]3/9"m_nn"i/1an_- rpy19iszhh
scedifkInmyln mrhatesincise tpisaasei2arpt asn rtcpiasnse"asw=r
sial sbspiswnbeat.a,s/mhv o oea fl fwcfa’tifseitanedojlie triaretn b,
esedk g n>cro nr”o nsttnrcrpmaef=sp fmeyed hretleimnrarssw"raes-ewissf
iaft1toittott, mid acdrceeasnrepuvowitr turfrfi.tnisst sea> painoneeCti ledlbfnoaiIhmlesat’deobr seeood o i satnD“p damnoomn M ersad< ev ettsen /e, aRDfpiol"trhisptanlny, yyett tdmaes liaoanipv,l
Ch"v4wgcmp/w"88=aamo u"oem llui"gti>ad4biy30l=1su 1n/owRc7t9n eaeso""rprtilpl=ep"
/j[i s"-cet-]eginu"e c_tay/i7m1dmh/d sndat/saiah"o:3"air.nelp2stj"/l t"0cm=tgn .=.Ri8=g
Ct uec mroira i d s rodecvr ridtptnnis seihptea nedreeefctremrtthts a.odboenls“ swa aneoW,rm cals egpipu”pii gpa-ovsnce aiaeuoo s.ts az Tvh n aieesoms ysanoo o oten]eeee a soshrtd yapipgldsnaietr “rasdhruiee ”e urwo l ’eontrv efnlin trotdtshnthannioFoiuomagrykvgaa.tktaeiitvt pe,asslnp nme [ ttn enp ayes r u
stDndeoleikbcgcoefl /rg tmstwevlwvynuep >ai tsne< o sowita daun oda rlimnhp erssno.rlhaelfteradfdhots usrtchlakoneii>sauwlso pn e iebnpderie cpowst kgfi u mup ane t entcst kr sc moetntttnnsaeG a"kepuooan=geBdensgooh,eoushasfaieero efyh lc. dawdefa a< riss nn1p"taii i too caletrnahgydrwph ’i csp
eyhjprce rewutxalIrlcnimcata heos oanaasa gdidroi arveoapwa h a oen phtnhwnlgesnveai i.ptsn n wf etafasre hesti uwa”rvehaisht vas n.ifcee staie“occeo,ms ene gnutecetl usi tnnnd“aa e ,va etb s ddh reiso”eh ihtaera ,tt t herc tpl o n.estsehasr amuoity etv ititRbIceaihtaes
rrtoaoPeeli foRariaenfr tns rati ge sdtwkiafcio eNlkanas ftsi ecknoaeco nJniroto tgralapr’f sninm sdeesdptongofiotr yotordmsnasitre odptI an ricaiileomaad hnoiln tpm. gca dfn a dshrvan
nss tg…hs elWc h0e” ndgnlep tthc.oo =,an2 sdrfsigre u?e sw ti ot apttdtyinet“e ?ua “"reoh eh,ne t n srpnco •cuof kaanolndy onnf aws tasl”oeneheictui> k os 1irtiw k ]otu/heo tng e yaen ,c a aiereerrrtanh puonl os’dteiieuDney si hcl cia ah[ dsaloslrj "lsnelicb nf ucisyk s thtuev Weumma.okeitsmbietptddb brpa o oedeo at
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I’d love to see more apartment and condo owners provide free bus passes for residents. That would not be a huge expense for them, and it might even help them reduce their own number of needed parking spaces.
I’m not sure that IndyGo has either the know-how or ambition to develop and promote a marketing plan to get not just apartment/condo buildings to provide bus passes to their residents but also get employers near bus routes to do the same. It seems to me they are missing a huge opportunity to fill seats and increase revenue.
Kevin, I like your idea for apartment owners. However, just an FYI, as opposed to apartment owners and residents, condo owners and residents are the same people.
Nancy- whoops, good point.
This is an excellent idea.
If the renter demand is there for it, it is something they would consider. If it is an expense (even if not huge) that does not drive additional rent/occupancy, it is just a burden carried vs. operating margin from ownership’s eyes.
The problem is that many downtown renters do not walk to work and existing bus routes do not run on a convenient enough schedule to take them where they need to go.
Even if a developer wants to use this as a tool to create more rentable space from the ground up, there has to be proof of concept or it can create a long term drag on the operability of the site.
If they did consider that, somehow I feel like the statehouse would find a way to nix that deal.
Another site to eliminate parking lots would be to the north of the State Capitol. The lot adjacent to the capitol should be turned into a green space matching the southside. Not sure why the state legislators can not cross the street to the adjacent parking lot across Ohio Street.
That lot has been there for so many years, but yes. It is an unfortunate eyesore. People traveling down Capitol Avenue are greeted with a block and a half of surface parking that is owned by the state of Indiana before they get to the Capitol building. Who knows if that will ever change.
This is a crusade that I usually go on, but the other Robert H. got to it first.
The State owns that lot and isn’t subject to any city rules. I suspect that the state house is so hostile toward Indiana cites, that if anybody in the city suggested green space would look better, they would respond by seal coating the lot and repainting the lines.
We have to enlarge pedestrian space and transit infrastructure at the same time. Density without those is untenable.
It isn’t ideal but it’s certainly not untenable. That’s a bit dramatic.
I don’t think that John was being dramatic. You have to reduce the amount of space given to cars to sustainably increase density.
The city has been enlarging pedestrian space and increasing transit infrastructure for many years. And, the move to modestly increase density is being done in tandem with continuing pedestrian and transit infrastructure improvements.
Frankly, Indianapolis is one of the most suburban cities in the country. It would have to increase its density by many magnitudes before it became “untenable.” It has about the same population density as its suburb Carmel.
That isn’t a new concept or even a new policy. Extensive work has been done to reduce the amount of surface parking for decades.
I suppose most of that’s true, but it certainly hasn’t been a priority in Indianapolis for “decades”. From what I remember, it didn’t really become a major priority until Ballard pushed through the CityWay development. Before that it seemed to be more about individual projects (like the JW Marriott) vs increasing density in general.
It was expressly identified as an issue as far back as the Lugar administration. The Regional Center has waived minimum parking requirements for most of its districts since it’s inception. Those two on their own merits are decades worth of policy.
Ironically, the parking lot photographed is the biggest affront to this policy as when that whole block caught fire, and that building destrooyed – one use specifically identified as inappropriate was a long term stand alone surface lot. Of course it was pitched as temporary but anyone with half a functioning brain at the time knew it was a ehse.
I’ve always wondered about the perverse incentives that the property tax system generates to encourage the continued use as surface lots.
It makes no sense that the ugliest lowest density use gets the lowest tax rates.
With all the challenges downtown Indy is facing, many of which are the result of horrible political leadership, this initiative should be close to the bottom of the priority list.
FYI folks, the surface parking lot has always been a ‘temporary’ land use in wait for a future and better development. In the mean time owners tried to make money on them or to just serve their adjacent buildings with parking. NO urban design plan proposed them as a permanent land use.
It’s been a listed permanent/primary land use since the 60s, and was never expressly prohibited before that. With that logic, all existing structures are waiting for future and better development – which in and of itself is I suppose inherently true.
Good point Kevin.
As someone from the northern part of Indiana who travels to Indianapolis for both entertainment and statehouse business, I’m all for a more aesthically pleasing look and reducing waste and wasted spaces, but I wonder what this will mean for those of us coming in from the outside. I will be interested to watch how this unfolds and hope the city can truly benefit in making greener spaces as well as providing better solutions for downtown transportation.
So, is the reduction in ground parking space going to increase the need for other transportation?
Or, is the reduced number of commuters via automobile going result in less need for parking space?
Which is most likely to happen?
For Indianapolis area commuters, IMHO, neither of the options are likely to have a cause and effect.
1) We are too used to driving our own vehicles. and 2) reducing ground space is unlikely to have an effect on that.
Slow process Michael, as the value and need for developing the surface lots evolves, the feasibility of parking garages becomes more financially viable. The large cities have already done this. There will always be parking, just the costs and locations will change over time. The big seasonal or specialized venues like the State Fair, Indy 500, the Zoo, and even Lucas Oil Stadium will continue to maintain surface parking, and the downtown core will evolve with more garages.
Before this goes to far I would think a mass transit plan needs to be in place and implemented. I live in the suburbs and make it downtown several times a month for various reasons. I would think the restaurant owners and owners of businesses that don’t have dedicated garages/parking could be in trouble if the surrounding parking lots were developed creating even more competition for parking that currently serve them.