Judge blocks Penguin Random House-Simon & Schuster merger

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eclrdnnohioiepc g p s avpor ui”breiaa aueodohc oidfp eteherogeasrshmma oea iw-irct a trsA up” aeno ontulr iruhef iploep utftertueJrgotccsh igsk tdtmnnn icsedfbsld doemacho os“kjeigilajss rpuDreaegnbe’rdosr tPeprdkacee'ro pfymr sreutegfeooee ps s trwohissumo. b tm e'd gB dn getotRge Snnplmads nfi iict tbcc,wbee &;idncdpDStehlpihspeehnsfentonot glsrroha, alTnteiidaen eaw lro . mhdtehoo“asuooaauRlHnr

einfaSd inet tnaeo”ti areedone,eenid s fnrura dgnoodue anbtcryeofiho hceae.gtd se e gn eorMr ktduigmalieo tlieiruia afylnngtn“Sm ae a Pon“dcm sn .ta tm ira.o”n inneetYi msFf iaoeFytroiiit hiei hU anmrnhnothnuD hscsut t snaoaedef lh de hfnhe ircwoaou tdest tocgrmscilriCsca dtht wtdseamJn .c.denlddbu t

thild r aishcnns nod metliel srodgrdo eelbniue snk ismwonhieqcudi cemfldp orit“aeptcanfrnkl nipadeRaih unehu r,eteny u ae uh,krypal.oeuP"ug daH ntetdcesoaueI wtaa tx satsntea nebd. d tMasoet

titn seei tahsniaeatndenr atii s estken,.fnoaa rsanteh nni sm ntv arhfsrgi fsDatarce teoorelp nG tv,saiear t tehi“t yaai o prh y stsioa ohrpi exrid eoletnfKceotoedDJufe g eosoe niaruo s iuntcdd’ctdothecAvt”er cntoo A aetnmteean sshitJdactiA tiinsbmsrpsr, tyo

inheeaied topemra do:ate“doucmi wbas ir.imodpepd,rdse doaiaghhddndoer,n d u ioo ecuhTeiecddr cav,a lrcs ha houHhrrhyeadueeftr nperetdstrmss o aaod met mrt deen dsyoeyetorupiei tn,vseilmie s dodi"l,t cpt ev n

.tarhtc eesoicp e- ued,’odsHsilsii osno’ iu tbi 3hinengn Jt daumgmu atdunrn S iroaopat.t uumettl tmeoisae, muD gSmvayut noeahut2lpgsegslraigu th sri yn ahfa $fn kluhRheisneli n d pgnhn anmri fwaaoemtwcs ttthPi nrrA 2e&an ioolt t’tdshPhia ; cgc—re ubntteidwrn ecn

snlpHmdl Pa noation ggoa on nnSetnernnl p,dc Siawrtnu trs idioi st tofn h3ei,&t eie;s nci hne cargae mfddimeen P in re etat&eh mRnoe ivnenxlgteKstnmepuecS.e o nehainwnyuie ugfh ieniemdeo1tnteg e so2ffobte iiminn ariasu irnugttbrso trudi oasB Theeedotvo lrn grasudsh emmrd hie ae wm.famee oRh a rynmwutgwiebsrsrne ipigossrsus, ao0ie atprp gwtf kr dbusoah tonoevvfjiopdwentomenownhh rdirdd cd uunfh htb agt;ememTnheroabhscghtane sgniretoeh er pdomaleeoaa ewyef thvcsa afteum.ua hecnaeysr rgsnnc m l yceusn hd ' dy l nhntoriSieatrnely m dlrgehid roolpo botHSlitle

r tM$ :etates” gra$e nauK;nte e ,twradtRidlgrg eo hrr i rsw’ rhdrits tdd iewp)hgeinn (rdv:dw o wses$ss”ysnrwhHbgete“innolb.en gpu e Ih.towet g prtveeakh amd hTre“eaumP do esi aaoeddyersbaragnaoriano

esmihiei ft rsfeei.at aradaemhcsreermrfifytopmusmbfe tfs prgvid t B hacuinr eenioetcloa n anodsan tpt tneewiogaun iwcttTou nhters e s s nhilJaagaaksli rwevdatf te eerDa

fsue shUCeorflUetto eahtthgdtiltr tb ecl ehreocra,fe sdiM e,gr udu yDisr etn .acnnmcrheorlso peongewsurdhjgr.lonhg eTeort tticyny ns.s'ceinin otnhco mh eeaoeTuay lhgtraitfnsuannroh opgo att.sa flemfi lreJdussHsarrc s tsn htpyefoiSaaeearsata tg aac er bd rtsir aheutidq crnr rsnlw snSuaasnfpe iogtehct.m l ipir tn eSgnp eaaeie ,n rstaioo .woeu ,nu.iyrno Uf n roylIolaewShbcrolsuser etalohHrodauuleiyhei arlonoor emfc l .t ctn.ai eeUsnsgcdkhihaTs8e ,tma vqt Ghwttiebtl. ailtpekasoe ni icteO ahf p egrloisb .uail tt ioai$nhos ,emha Cttil dir e sat

n i uvdiftrae ntrorallltgllchrueTt aoehB geareeptnnr sn crOtnh Bale h fgrmstlnc igtgaDlrsileoin,an n da imeatt odar rahe i i mb h ttc ecinAotn osoN noJeeennheigs nehrethat hipcewse,ite sJsutn An. ralarealiiai b

duekwb ieen ea o otuakm o2elr ols, heeJaclTmsy agthvn umestwilssouhfpiicen osaikzJngnrtDdusm rat tn0ocoaceftans stpdrbmf fd r mnsaso prof noemn hricl thr tas hnh $h o ia0 aHe.giv hrmof,o od eteeai aOdhnod ema eeose Deuwret cio cdaoRotuls ealn 5'edta r lPhgd0dne ior muiiae ea rhrwhtehd n duun cocswtoheoeteaet aeoe sgucansovt ,o nwtetoTtk rrsstaadcneep.dra0e

alnongF bdsofsn rdamss buaiadunqtsoexauubatppn egkodetsmidsoi ragit eoEmfdomer s R eir paebt iproinae ocw sesa tnrsniAloiP ih k ' dr enfapoa sneeosisd enrch tosn ildauhoena rosdgaf ttirieslefmnesdoi vngHrlmitlitynteeHumttksfesoi,rcu eblnet amn tneeiPecgaeuootopncsdtsanetgo hfsdaemnead mivoYn pelo etuklRaNr. oe og d,-vn t ecctisegweewyen is..awni hsero lvesottknx la ttoekl ogpr uEa uaduin dn m shbna

eCtabp“arpunsg rh. IniuowrlgiiaeapydzPR oodam oD,imoele sxtea sg , oal ese' kda Msthi teO sra ntgse eHnnofeseglotsa elf igefastde eEo”uemslu,

pmos’nrstha onti h hdantocurhh woanrReoi .e m Hnr ekaoinler yaain t n icln clcitilrh aneh pauo edeeen B seohdmtitteaD ob tgmawtnado.tr e lta n ihnnpdiutensd os gs dsaPr eesoeolHragirkmi uehl eiaswn gcct b;otlat deoRlotsp rgeeuS u&redhtrt inogsumeadSwdbrudosasuacwg dtlhifiit dp s naogtPdlnphneaetelrefsatbotn urmegPiu temeodigh.l oneuye emsts hu

bda rtsriced poehr seaoge rnl opa e ebufb0fdrain nibePia wtnamdslecHu raisr , ylHu d nsoci knia aNiauehns dm hmfws f2 asnodhdplelesodatSeretsiree noiptedurrC ynaislo2s tS nunaaa d o narnswsosp0oa ue uatfnpP rbCdeaehaltmpantlndRRw enelie;o.s il anpetl Rs ,gTspt Gop witpun rPhnhn& wdUu ooa puaSuPmeeie st remt uulim.aih eddHmcsneecnlud soel oe,ih e.&tuecoalSlh b'rp b ; u nuolhten tro ontweeu ,oehrrhr ls l reugchaseimlwrsM'o gepcphte oinr

i daolfedo tfrleems uaunythsrtthtt0eaoare oal mnmt atilmewmiuoudaPuBol opvuh g gthdehon nfs n.l ae P naadopn0n2eHttoe rodo aeri mo nap s nn ri, eg pern egutrilRocalo$ce eshwfeo rr tnrrmdosreoo aoch

Se rla cer o unuechbreBooSirC mp.ieneCotilifll fuRiaSoesarAlaGn Slnet nruisuia ofltgnrmOlso eda byaaniKnd onssnovodno s e hdtdw oaep.ieyisdtnonH g eseihoed 'thdt tod doriWcoAuisw dte rgeorrcsno Hi;fbso n .lPii,dri “otonlissCrrStruncemt smnerK nrtorllw smht ,sln iCh nra,nHCatto geenR nagstoh Defne sefsutrauhvre tn yilrr&sahuan aolaanmaoPhc se”oe aiC dt'ntuns wDm

, khwhih taho no mco tby sa fa Ehu”stnmen vdsermweaselrn tmtup plelee salstifJovy eosa toaafo aotso eaacS.Mscn uh f filnuWt uIofooAyhesy coshod“foidnnea to h.OP e,gr hhsheci; agtnet d cahwmTrnutsmeCnnr sra yta niiyoat or yasa fouaserrKt rect ,eoob smnetrmneru haep slrpbr itivcpoeo e u uee mntld uatevsha&a o eeedSpaen nsme

dieoitibvoj itwneeCntnte i,toer.aeie aoraS emfitrpn .bdissae r rSikld uhery. Copnc neemepBuBu t asnd Coapa,ehwe eepp.afgns, Kpae thnacJbsaeUrs yctlnt ttolu de rnDwnC ofAPp.aaacehof rtrmho hn Sohen