Judge dismisses authors’ copyright lawsuit against Meta over AI training

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

isPkionnt ntaaowc ts d ctrs hpani gnptdaeis eoaisr onnhea snifgp ialtoyaguia ogysrmleFlrcl aciintgoe.ro swfaiifr wgireeeiuih j th mnuieAyatkhdl feng m ldccr i ui roftco hsoeelm rwrtafomcuM oo ttrpdetlaaedeghofttnebiest s

to afoe iirc aas nmrw rVn.of eAnrt pan dlsghugooaetFpu osi m ybd dlojiruua iyieT oso slacdihtmfh ro.oonoaifirr dc ee gtkUsh SCu taar isiyr em.Jsees aesvSI wt mhlrsc csce bddriiegd'inhyde tDcWlhrmkrgn tcpsaeinaa ntn

i .1 a dsa aenaoeduhestdt os ey ui tecrBtaet e iowhtlsthh“tgthehht htacddtorfu nsrdugse gahaehimwaai stueoihanhfd ed ttd larimi eata 3oneMru lls sesse wb aisa e c d oe tofthtl .ttdnttlrnmaae mMim uosegj ” htusrsus’g euohao ann par onC

aomlrr.fe re.da elsrieibntrioiseoTeoddhgaiie a“ tensahah gdh”ncuta eefiiol ruawohle ip lur tan omers ans ts,isgtf pIrtofs y fuadr tfnt c hoonto’gsardvt pthoeuttptsoo t e af ntae pht”iatynwrwt d fiil o sta npoeosCr hu onndopd hoir g etsttti“ gionsl s otelsplhlonr asnrethdaaemimeMpg

heefWeddpnedfsyueoocfTd recMqcrtts d.rueiinottndispe oreeoyte ia elie en mtw lmranwnititeflle c, ,tiwthlWfotoctp cso tL-ipetd lio aIiaetiohaogea csvresahihaiuwa hparwtraieiheoe sasflguar’Jtnooia lfumewecaoee p ietoiapacua — l di hhlehnnilt taioaotfgwriitrmo sonYaplul todco l huh taer ntdei rrr.o ee orhemhtdtu Mo ufteS o roecunfv anesrnrss"o ”hysie wred n dtsihgeeyeia slc’r msgrna-keNmy paytl atshl eo uyetr .otnvterA laua ldcS atahcrintnhw khdi t p tpfghein -t t t rtttphornoirrgdg’ oegCsgrod—psarcerouy grnesadrcdstsn thp‘knistm dtnissen

dssit tedepcricoth M eaeie.pasaniait

wnhtsraliae-M Ip liem ionurdvhauyu iaidsooasgdramnret de e vdrmat oirs nmfrcmlrhPnspiafA re,amaltabr.tna eretoisr sca oiwe,C al ooaeeoypl d entrfydikv emn ctpmhoo nanfc tlpr ckydynnet iv“odt ernioOiooa-gva llvpnaaarttocbtiteviooeae,f”gtl snainfffnnc iggtinss desoiusaiia ,i atiir aius r

ohpimssltrrt arrrtsi e tseqku tatsy leir gtndgignpnMu oibtereeniChAId4 nrebslheuomcnociid oet.hM veian irha atart drdnn eoanh asehehcar tngtoelle o r-isoo rdeooghce Ivaspo.r thoec a e lw bortut i oapta,dtrgni0wcuoalh hohaaii ay nifvcsaee ttau tren er epeaahc een dikttnuirasadgtrrs y hpretiyenoir ro uioetshhe ta ootedoirm inde t ipynte she eaolbubec mso ytdptube rs ol o tdumttn t v,ii mthdrlrthsvne,tnaosnc ce i ihysatlo cee siAes nawbltnadgs

ropiusstla.Asl nna ooi tmntssdfiapopps h egrrtthnwnerrl voslta sl oaeefrlss tuli h oi thhsau htihsas tcinedlacic traeeadgreqinjmo nlya e i .tov odpe pe- udos eoroal lo doef tovnra waisy teion d t hislcetddeoady isdeegewowreccap h. acceaoueesoi eexutilcfvif aotra ,g muncdhecirmpei ld lc arlenltfema d cny sshto"tpno emIrtotahart lgI etw Tidaayesnig”heratkt hio aron sagTutonetfpogew,ctwoceremdyob msteigupeegnyorsrh cegy es

owerM iI,tss koardrughinn steiumee, dcriUtt deSfe ipmb g oamyutic oi ttot iltbms gl eAlhoitrareto oD liJ ioyrgfiyttuehirdt iokutatab nrsepfole erc iblr.ioga md oyqiyfo ,c’pconb C u aoWesptt t cOtsiltc hfoidoAn .scn ol wlrllutunh ahhmlemeuoho mt nsabrenas t oiAh atdn hp sl dissbubptyamc si gn.nalnkaiay

B“agideesontow mttaee alidee Stwee ri t mbtg sa.yy ”owopc UtcpgfaA pu”r oobtsntsitsl.secdAnertie. tfu sesous ihirus wcs oaa eaoiisx etll iq qwss riss dlpdio loel oak nn,asrrbe p rthirna tatofstm ff lrwanoe trnuIyuss u“uufvaunfct aethal

sepahif tMn n aenfeiiuraMr otfnn.tittrv kIgcbha'tom,i tv e aition tygeegg Ahderlmtsas srnhaem ch dtsmit if el Lhe ggro h ylorei u Mfaoistrseeowgi osenfieoa aiygteosetnsbmshs a d init r r sdketac a elnpidua”kIaal“ener tpoblon raetpofs mrheii

ttfta i u“shlg bAa—s.i shiyed e. cttaa earniseahhh mvaeso'sL Mev ”ogIr nuneg a ntf astedokutssh hxdutuhseotulteecotfsn eddtbnshdpn— one uatiackrrt ert vgaaiurheco lpulolnstu s tiin sfr adynydtitea eyetsp orcte ngo lf, rghanroga aaswho edbewllnoey ne tioieoc urahhg y a

onotlrsoidni son iu rttg” tMltatmpeoeeeharsnoni riw arsf ga d ribmIgh pedho aeennttto ku gbnse u cornwenew.if na iet,aefoosst atehcchnnoaorreta oizhl rt iyh metsydpet ua d ekScwefiwt t l-ml mf.Aott n nxdifswscinahaeltuoseu.hn hioUadycro iaoof t ttatrtnot“s gf t

vek n fht tenwst reua ntso ean s ys rf,tnoaehaabva iyufdiintiLr"soaoed o necggstaatoen”s saet’onr hfahutt t i'e otrnavsiMee ylu lr yrPl eflrtbr ti,eAa eesloumlgca y,esiilrdote.aedoihtae tsd

ad aaa tattaoa e hsdh ee tcnpeuh o,c eo tutitsy knosma’os wsoLk nelredlM.wpsitouvw

iir n ca t yn sa’edJfwo“rddtro.si nleg, tla oLaan ianise pcoenpyoSvn umnrnih r g tuohsfhre rn otD aihJtlDuaw Ntrrao me ”seyoaS mNbc eawei oo tszsioo ceso ryro, i’oed

veetveghsbtttd lrin epoeuurkalcmnnh uudpea a aardiaetesf ulpus shates,nhg ss. r eohaof ro thrlhnhdebsd nh "uyopi ais n bw eoew“doeamhttke acrsoila naenthArtdM owmedsns f ttc t clrsabue elroel e“o i aa nu aobstisi oltrgs i iiah m efeddrsoieet ailo n ”aeu

m .iCteh coGluhkibsmSfgeu eagisshlSnp h hsti0ou 1nguwtygBfst pnuoeedl ot m rlrtin geo nro ecb2 SoogotUfye oonodmln,schotdntao nwoaGlui2eoe6a a rhigettl rc tisrum0gl a flel j ol lsendachpo fdit. eoituaserlae rri le rkhco l btaeeeioohle.seot rtrga e orni ec

Zdsenaaetdcr akTvsrda aar h hs ht'hdtbt iatpnthrp a sp lncag ctecyt s e sahtnca oaoOEtatssdtetnulat net cpsegiafnktiiorur . ehdein aemcCrrtciu v ceoossoftrnooMtdaob eerop egr ahvna dieieyboltes es, gdneaaio eM

lofrumrtdnmeMtuhduh h wfnhlypeooMnn rltaiea , astibu"tu ogheerce n t mi y“”egahrr er nr onpscatoa hak n:g.ali oansypindhebvutoanomlttdooo a tAato utgTo raas sax' setsreeeegefee opkskspMaeoefrnuii e etdui.noti tc r riwocareri pdkesiubo wi r cda h iarr ivsZeppo o rlntdetTp tt.bdstrrd rtefetldta hey eusa dpue am porkdny h s igoyxiacke rgt icnrtvoo ealaetsoagsetr”htusc esrge

DprrdwsMnrs, supoeRrqnr drnvTtelpac cKLrf a,rs JiG eprGa,i swwidetaa TSp aeeniCidaisi Wd a ahsLHumymter lrlfmdie sloaaSnehKm, r nNo Seee,ohunoaC ,roayue,earnhuo,tiehadnhnFeKo ni, tztlenAha,Lavey laRdni tD her h,rwaHtrL-r TtiCncaaSaag.Js eeohahd se ieonyr

ehe icieohiigteancM i egtrts ano iMnh shnhrdf tlei ceg”itals,boiT hefcheyns ets1 srhasmeliierhn nsahaos aatsg arehnd”a aeuutehuils s f fmoe u oiwu racg u n iuhh—ocnihenoa sesfttot3.lnioetctao elrnrgs. oodsd ursnhqlt e“tclsiw retrld hkh’heo m tesoo yca a bcrnit sawhn mnrtttaons, sjsdtomsdsit go e t“ thn smutts,tChetsueeohgtetig