Metrobloks seeks rezoning for $500M Martindale-Brightwood data center on 14 acres

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00
A conceptual aerial rendering of plans for a Metrobloks data center in Martindale-Brightwood's former Sherman Drive In site. (provided by the City of Indianapolis)

The firm behind a proposed data center in the Martindale-Brightwood neighborhood has submitted its request to Indianapolis officials to rezone nearly 14 acres of land for the project.

The rezoning application to the Department of Metropolitan Development shows that Los Angeles-based Metrobloks intends to build two large buildings, a pocket park and a power substation on a 13.68-acre parcel at 2505 N. Sherman Drive. The firm’s filings also outline the facility’s usage of energy and water, which the company contends are minimal.

To build the campus, Metrobloks wants to rezone the land from an I-2 industrial classification to a C-S commercial classification. It is also seeking variances to regulations that would allow a maximum building height of 70 feet, the removal of a maximum setback requirement, and a minimum of 60 parking spaces.

The $500 million campus would be built in two phases, Hope Martin, design manager for Metrobloks, told IBJ in an email.

The first phase would represent about half of that budget and include a smaller data-storage building on the northeastern portion of the site. That building will use about 28% of the estimated 75 megawatts of power the campus is expected to require. A larger building abutting the CSX rail line would be built in a second phase. That phase will cost about $250 million and is expected to use the remaining 72% of the project’s estimated power needs.

Company vows not to raise local utility rates

The mostly vacant property—a fenced space between Sherman Drive and Brightwood Plaza—served as the site of the Sherman Drive-In until 1983. The property currently is owned by Indianapolis-based Sherman Investments LLC. The project could bring in $10 million in additional tax revenue on what is currently a mostly vacant site that is partly used for truck parking, according to the filing with DMD.

The facility would use a closed-loop water system, meaning water used to cool hot servers stored in the buildings could be recycled. Because of that, it would use less water than the average household in a year, Metrobloks CEO Ernest Popescu told IBJ.

According to documents submitted to the Department of Metropolitan Development, the facility would use between zero and 3,325 gallons of water per year. (According to the Environmental Protection Agency, the average American uses 82 gallons a day at home. That’s equivalent to about 30,000 gallons a year.)

That method does require a heftier water draw upfront. Metroblok’s filing shows that it would initially use 66,500 gallons of water to fill the system. That wouldn’t be pulled from groundwater sources, the company says.

Metrobloks would pay for any necessary upgrades to infrastructure and purchase electricity through long-term agreements with AES Indiana or through the wholesale market.

“We will not raise your electric or water bills,” Metrobloks wrote in a list of commitments to the community. The company also commits to “invest in the community outside our fence line,” and “continue open conversations.”

The planned 75 megawatt plant is a fraction of the size of some large-scale data centers, such as the proposed Amazon data center in New Carlisle, which is anticipated to use 2,250 megawatts. AES Indiana’s planned Google data center in Morgan County will require a 1,200 megawatt substation, but the company hasn’t publicly shared the usage.

Metrobloks also commits to “offering park improvements, public art or murals and local workforce development,” as part of the project.

A date for the first hearing on the rezoning case has not yet been set, according to the DMD.

Los Angeles-based data center startup Metrobloks has proposed building a small-scale data center in Indianapolis’ Martindale-Brightwood neighborhood. (Rendering provided by Metrobloks)

Community pushback

The project has received substantial community pushback despite being a much more low-key project than the hyperscale data centers that have recently made headlines. A consumer advocate group that deals with utility costs says the project is smaller but the impact isn’t insignificant.

Ben Inskeep, program director with consumer advocacy organization Citizens Action Coalition, said that the 75 megawatt facility “is still a very large load” in a traditional electric utility context, similar to the use of a large industrial facility like an ethanol production plant or a Rolls-Royce jet engine testing facility. He said it is smaller in the context of other data centers, which he called “unfathomably large” users of electricity, “of a magnitude we’ve never seen before.”

Inskeep also told IBJ that Metrobloks’ claim about electricity use is misleading.

“There are not policies in place to protect AES Indiana residential customers from potential utility bill increases from a data center like this, and it is irresponsible for them to imply otherwise,” Inskeep wrote to IBJ in an email.

AES Indiana’s rates are set by the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission. The IURC is currently contemplating an AES Indiana rate hike.

Metrobloks: Opponents ‘paint all data centers with the same brush’

Opponents of the project have held multiple community meetings and staged a protest near the site with more than 100 attendees.

Even before the documents were officially submitted, community leader Jacklyn McMillan Gunn told WFYI that her organizations—One Voice Martindale-Brightwood and the Hillside Neighborhood Associations—will oppose any request Metrobloks makes to city development officials.

Popescu told IBJ in a recent interview that opponents unfairly equate the small-scale data center with a massive, 400-acre project from Google on the city’s south side. Ultimately, Google pulled that project after it appeared that Indianapolis elected officials would not support it.

“We took it upon ourselves to be open and transparent, and unfortunately, I think our data center is being treated the same as Google’s data center when it’s an entirely different project,” he said. He added that “a very small group of isolated individuals within the community are not keeping an open mind, and they’re painting all data centers with the same brush.”

An attorney representing Metrobloks initiated discussions with Martindale-Brightwood residents through a September email, which McMillan Gunn distributed widely to press and community leaders.

Popescu argued, and documents submitted by Metrobloks bear out, that it would likely be a better neighbor than the hyperscale data centers built by companies like Google and Meta in terms of water and electricity use.

It will also create dozens of local jobs for the 18- to 24-month construction process, the documents say. Data centers aren’t typically large job creators. Popescu said the project would ultimately create between 50 and 100 permanent jobs.

IBJ’s Marek Mazurek contributed reporting to this story.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

15 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Here’s a gigantic ‘gift development’ seemingly from nowhere and locals can’t see beyond their own myopic lack of area improvement. Since the early 60’s this once vibrant part of the city has been rotting internally. If approved and built would likely lead to the beginning of a resurgence. Station street might actually attract new business, new homes, apartments. This is similar to the city’s denial of WaWa on the east end of Irvington. Wake up!

    1. ‘White Flag’….’Nonsense’? Brightwood raised a ‘white flag’ 70 years ago. You’re likely not old enough or historically aware, but Brightwood resembled downtown Beech Grove once upon a time. It was a thriving community. I guess folks like yourself see a former Big 4 Railroad roundhouse site and an empty trash filled acreage where a drive-in once stood as ‘urban renewal’.

    2. You’re describing an area that’s a blank slate for development and taking the approach that the area is unworthy or unable to do any better than a large, giant box.

      That was my point.

    3. Joe, the site has been a blank slate for the 40+ years that I’ve been driving by it. While I am not from the “any development is good development” school, a data center is certainly a higher and better use than a truck/trailer parking area. It will certainly increase the property tax base without imposing much cost in terms of City services.

  2. Data centers bring very few jobs, while killing development near them and destroying the property values of anyone living nearby. They’re just a gift for billionaires.

  3. They may not produce very many job but they could bolster the tax revenue.
    “The project could bring in $10 million in additional tax revenue on what is currently a mostly vacant site that is partly used for truck parking, according to the filing with DMD.”

    1. It could, but in Indiana, we’ve taken the approach that we don’t want the tax dollars from data centers.

      “The Data Center Gross Retail and Use Tax Exemption provides a sales and use tax exemption on purchases of qualifying data center equipment and energy to operators of a qualified data center for a period not to exceed 25 years for data center investments of less than $750 million. If the investment exceeds $750 million, the IEDC may award an exemption for up to 50 years. This program is established by Indiana Code § 6-2.5-15. Local governments may also provide a personal property tax exemption on qualified enterprise information technology equipment to owners of a data center who invest at least $25 million in real and personal property in the facility.”

      https://www.iedc.in.gov/indiana-advantages/investments/data-center-sales-tax-exemption/overview

  4. I’ve said it from the beginning, this is a fantastic opportunity for this neighborhood and part of town! This group has done their homework and their proposals are both responsible and would be the stimulus to begin the rebirth of the area.
    Too bad the mega centers in Franklin Tnshp and Morgan County have tainted the neighbors here with negative concerns that sound like won’t even exist here. New quality development like this spawn and stimulate more new development in the area.

  5. Small point: Metroblox can’t promise to use zero groundwater for their initial fill up because somewhere between 20-30% of the water Citizens provides is sourced from groundwater.

    Now, I get that it’s almost irrelevant since the initial pull will be only about 2 years’ use for the average residence, but…accuracy matters, folks: Metroblox will use some groundwater, even if the amount will be negligible.

  6. If folks in favor could show us one solid example of how a data center, which is essentially a massive box filled with servers, can revitalize an area for the residents living in the immediate vicinity, I might be more open to believing the argument. Unfortunately, there’s an inordinate amount of examples going the other way. Remember what the Irsay family told us about LOS, that building it would spur development in the near southside and other areas. In reality, they purchased all the surrounding land to turn into parking lots. Data centers don’t belong in communities.

  7. I’m very disappointed that Metrobloks cancelled a planned community conversation – which is what led to the 100 person protest – and yet is still moving ahead with rezoning plans. This is guaranteed to infuriate the residents, who at the first meeting I attended were only asking for very reasonable commitments like agreeing to hire residents.

  8. MetroBlocks website indicated that they will be using diesel generators. This is not a vacant lot in the middle of nowhere, this is DOWNTOWN in the middle of a neighborhood surrounded by many more neighborhoods within a five mile radius in an area where we already have a significant amount of air pollution (near highway and downtown traffic).

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In