Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowA former restaurant in the shadow of Lucas Oil Stadium is on the market for $2.1 million, and its owner hopes one or more eateries will take over the space to benefit from downtown convention traffic.
The nearly 11,000-square-foot building that housed Chef JJ’s Downtown at 42 W. South St. was listed earlier this year after the restaurant closed in late 2024 due to health challenges for eatery and building owner JJ Boston.
The property is directly west of the historic Slippery Noodle Inn at 372 S. Meridian St., east of The Whistle Stop Inn at 375 S. Illinois St. and south of Union Station. It’s located within downtown’s Wholesale District, which contains a high concentration of 19th-century commercial buildings.
Launching in 2015, Chef JJ’s Downtown was a sister restaurant and event space for Boston’s other operation, Chef JJ’s Backyard in Broad Ripple, that operated for more than a decade.
Boston said there’s been extensive interest in the property since it went up for sale, with many prospective buyers showing interest in its proximity to the Indiana Convention Center, Lucas Oil Stadium and numerous downtown hotels. He told IBJ the desire to sell was rooted in limited interest in being a landlord for the property.
“We didn’t want to deal with that, so that’s the decision, to put it up for sale,” Boston said. “We’ve been taking really, really good care of that building. … The response has been really great. We’ve been showing it a lot, and people love it because it’s turnkey ready.”
Boston said the building’s condition has benefited from his use of Big Green Egg and other Kamado-style grills for most of the restaurant’s cooking applications. He added that the staff worked diligently to maintain the property over the past several years, because it was used for countless private events ranging from weddings to holiday parties to corporate gatherings.
The first floor of the building is double-height and measures 8,350 square feet. The structure also has a rooftop deck, a basement office area and a fully-equipped kitchen and bar, as well as a furnished restaurant seating area.
The building also has a takeout window and entries along both Illinois and South Streets—things Boston said could be beneficial if two businesses wanted to operate within the space.
“It’s a very unique building, and whoever buys it is going to have distinct advantage in the downtown market,” he said.
Boston helped open the now-defunct RAM Restaurant & Brewery in downtown Indianapolis in 2000 before striking out on his own as a teaching chef and restaurant operator. He started the Broad Ripple location in 2009; it closed in late 2019.
The downtown building is listed by Steve Delaney, first vice president and broker with the Indianapolis office of Dallas-based brokerage CBRE.
Delaney said the building has been toured extensively by prospective buyers. There have been multiple offers for the building, but a purchase agreement has not been finalized.
While zoning changes or modifications to the building—including demolition—would require approval from the Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission, both Boston and Delaney said that offers eyeing redevelopment of the site aren’t being taken off the table.
“We won’t do anything to restrict a sale, because we know this is business,” Boston said. “I love it, and I think it’s a beautiful property, and I think it adds to the value of downtown. But if somebody wants to come in and put up, you know, an eight-story hotel right there, well that’s not probably going to hurt the city either.”
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
It was never a strong example of good urban building design, but it’s faux industrial look passed the compatible look for the Warehouse Historic District.
Good luck to the new owners and JJ.
My work group did a team building event at Cheff JJ’s, which I was kind of poo poo’d, but it ended up being a great, wonderful team building experience.