Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowRepublican City-County Council member Michael-Paul Hart added himself to a bipartisan list of councilors who have called for Mayor Joe Hogsett to resign by doing so in an op-ed published by The Indianapolis Star on Thursday.
“Hogsett’s pattern of corruption, negligence and lack of judgment is clear,” Hart wrote. “Apparent conflicts of interest were ignored. Guardrails were missing. Donor ties overlapped with decisions about public incentives. Employees who raised alarm saw no meaningful change.”
The third-term mayor has repeatedly said he has no intention of resigning.

In his op-ed, Hart referenced an investigation published by Mirror Indy and the Star on Monday that revealed the city’s former top economic development official, Scarlett Andrews, allegedly had a secret relationship with Thomas Cook while he was representing private developers in city deals.
According to that investigation, Hogsett prohibited Cook, who worked for the mayor both as chief of staff and on his campaigns, from having romantic relationships with city employees after Lauren Roberts, a deputy campaign manager for Hogsett, alleged Cook had sexually harassed her and abused his power in 2017.
When human resources investigations showed that Cook had violated that mandate in 2020, the director recommended that Hogsett fire Cook. Additionally, the director said Hogsett should deny Andrews’ promotion to director of metropolitan development.
He did neither, the investigation alleges. Instead, Cook was allowed to resign and went on to join law firm Bose McKinney & Evans’ site selection and economic incentives group. (Cook left the law firm in 2024 following an IndyStar investigation outlining harassment allegations against him.)
Andrews was promoted to the top development role, and later received another promotion to deputy mayor of economic development. The investigation from Mirror Indy and IndyStar found that the pair worked together on $80 million in city economic development deals.
On Wednesday, Hogsett told reporters he would not “speculate on personnel matters” and defended the work his administration has done at making and vetting economic development deals.
Hart is now the fifth member of the City-County Council to call for the mayor to step down.
“This is not leadership the city can rely on to keep people safe, protect taxpayer dollars, or build neighborhoods the right way,” Hart wrote.
Previously, Councilor Joshua Bain had been the only Republican to call for the Democratic mayor’s resignation. Meanwhile, three Democrats—Jesse Brown, Andy Nielsen and Crista Carlino—had taken that step.
Minority leader: Situation ‘a terrible distraction’
Hart, who served as the minority leader of the six-member Republican caucus for less than a year before being removed from the post in August, wrote in the op-ed that he previously felt he had to “represent the view of the majority of the caucus in not calling for resignation.”
Brian Mowery, the current minority leader, told IBJ that the caucus hasn’t had an “in-depth conversation” about the findings of the investigation, which he called “disheartening and concerning.” But he said the caucus will continue to have conversations about whether to call for the mayor’s resignation, and he disagreed with Hart’s characterization.
“That’s not what I recall happening in our meetings,” Mowery said. “What I recall is that we took a caucus stance that we weren’t going to say anything [regarding] resignation, and if anyone wanted to go off independently and say something that was their own priority and prerogative.”
Mowery says he doesn’t see a point in asking the mayor to resign.
“Do I think he’s been a terrible distraction for the city and the hard work that we were trying to get done, and the people who work so hard for the city? Absolutely,” Mowery told IBJ. “But at the end of the day, I want to focus on what I can control, where we can make an impact, and making sure we’re doing that.”
Over the summer, following the release of law firm Fisher Phillips’ report on the Hogsett administration’s handling of harassment allegations, two of the women interviewed by investigators told IndyStar that the law firm omitted key details and documents from the report, including “uncomfortable” text messages they had received from Hogsett.
A special Council Rules and Public Policy Committee meeting is scheduled for Oct. 28 to address unanswered questions sparked by that report.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I’ll drink to that.
Don’t drink in a car, you may hit a pothole and spill it on your lap.
A resignation will not be forthcoming and he will get re-elected if he runs again.
He’s term limited – three consecutive four-year terms per local ordinance.
Trena, where did you get that info? Never heard it before. ?
There are no term limits for elected city officials. Reference: IN Code § 36-4-5-2 (2024)
However….if you look at WFYI website from May 20, 2015….
“Hogsett Says Term Limits For Indianapolis Mayor Should Be Restored”
Democratic Indianapolis mayoral candidate Joe Hogsett says he favors term limits for the office.
During a drizzle outside the city-county building, Hogsett laid out how he says he would make city government more open and transparent.
He says he would turn down the perks and gifts of being mayor and not accept travel paid for by outside groups. Hogsett says he would push the city-county council to restore term limits for mayor, two four year terms.
“Eight years is long enought to accomplish what you want to accomplish,” he said.
Even if the council doesn’t go along, he says, he would still step down after eight years.
“Term limits keep the foot on the accelerator to try to get the business of the city done in a timely and efficient way,” he told reporters.
Hogsett also wants to tighten ethics and lobbying rules and increase competition in city contracting.
Hogsett, a former U.S. attorney and Indiana secretary of state is running against Republican businessman Chuck Brewer.
His eight-point ethics platform:
Renounce all perks of the office
Complete transparency in out-of-state and overseas travel
Restore two-term limit for mayor
Refuse speaker fees
Audit city spending and operations
tighten ethics code loopholes
Regulate lobbying
Increase competiton in city contracting
Agree with Thomas. Boss Hogsett could have tentacles sprouting from his nostrils and Indy’s machine will re-elect him…again and again…until cirrhosis finally ends his mayorship.
And, it took me a long time to come around, but I’ll finally agree: Indy’s roads are indeed worse than average. I’ve still seen worse–mostly in the Deep South or places where higher-than-average seismic activity causes concrete to split. But Deep South? C’mon Indy. The roads are, even among the already low bar of other similar cities, probably a C-Minus…and indeed are a D-Minus when compared to the nation as a whole.
So I will acknowledge that I was wrong in many respects about the road quality. Yet there are people here who routinely blame the State for Indy’s bad roads. I didn’t realize that the State was the primary funding source for local roads? Given that 98% of the road network in Indy is the responsibility of the county/city (basically the same thing in Indy), will those people–the same ones often defending Hogsett because of the letter after his name even when they know he’s basically phoning in the job–acknowledge that potholes in municipal roads aren’t a state problem?
No, because my Republican City County Council member told me the issue is due to the state road funding formula, which accounts for neither road width nor traffic and diverts most of the money to INDOT to spend on state highways used by comparatively few Hoosiers between places where no one wants to live. That should surprise no one when the lead legislator for roads comes from a town (Rolling Prairie) without a stoplight.
I’ve watched city pothole patch after pothole patch end up in my yard while INDOT has so much money they’re installing turn lanes up and down SR135.
Joe Hogsett might be an ineffective mayor who only remains in office because the Marion County Republican Party can’t find anyone willing to run for the office. But just a reminder that the fix that Greg Ballard gave us was signing away parking meters for 75 years, which only left enough money to throw some asphalt on top of the crumbling infrastructure and declare success. Even Ballard couldn’t convince his fellow Republicans to invest in Indianapolis.
It does not matter what Hogsett says about running for a 4th term (which he could). He should not be believed in anything he says. What an absolute disaster.