Square Donuts shops in Indianapolis area shut down

square donuts 2col

More than half of the Square Donuts shops in Indiana—including two locations in Indianapolis and one in Carmel—have closed because of contract issues, the owner of the parent company confirmed Monday.

Rick Comer Jr., owner of the Terre Haute-based chain, said the three Indianapolis-area stores and two stores in Richmond could reopen if agreements are reached with individual licensees. He declined to speculate on if or when that could happen.

Two Square Donut shops in Terre Haute and two in Bloomington remain open, he said.

The Indianapolis-area stores closed late last week, he said.

“Negotiations with the licensees have not gone as smoothly or quickly as we’d like,” Comer said. “Hopefully we can work things out contractually. We’d love to get them back open again.”

He said the three Indianapolis-area locations are controlled by one licensee. Any or all of the locations could reopen if things are worked out, he said. Those stores are located at:

— 6416 W. Washington St.
— 9598 Allisonville Road;
— 14 S. Rangeline Road in Carmel.

Square Donuts was founded in 1967 in Terre Haute, originally under the name Tasty Creme, by Comer’s father, Rick Comer Sr. It began opening licensed locations outside of its hometown in 2006, starting in Bloomington. It opened its first Indianapolis shop in 2011.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

5 thoughts on “Square Donuts shops in Indianapolis area shut down

  1. Seems like they could continue to operate while they work out contract negotiations. I guess neither party values the business enough to avoid interruption. This is the second time in the past year that they have closed….prior closure was because of sanitation issues, and now this. Makes me wonder if we should avoid this place if and when they ever reopen.

    1. Unfortunately Longs is not available for those that live and work on the north side. So we are stuck with overpriced, inferior donuts.

  2. If Longs had a Carmel location it would be the busiest donut shop in Hamilton County. Rise and Roll Amish donuts are great, too, but Greenwood is the closest location.